Received June 8 , 1769 .
XXX .
A Letter from Mr. Lane , Apothecary , in Aldersgate-street , to the Honourable Henry Cavendish , F. R. S. on the Solubility of Iron in simple Water , by the Intervention of fixed Air .
Aldersgate-street , June 5 , 1769 .
SIR , THE various impregnations of mineral waters have always been very difficult to explain : and whoever has read the divers , and often contradictory reasonings upon the subject , must clearly perceive , that there is still room for discoveries in this part of natural history .
Read Nov. 23 , 1769 .
You , Sir , by your accounts of fixed air , and of Rathbone-place water , related in the last volume of Philosophical Transactions , have obliged the public with many additional lights on this branch of knowledge ; and , from your known accuracy , and diligent pursuits in most philosophical inquiries , the learned world has great reason to hope for many other new and useful improvements .
To your judgment therefore , I submit the following experiments ; which are intended to show , that iron is soluble in simple water , by the intervention of fixed air ; and thence , that it is very probable , many different chalybeate springs sustain their metallic charge by this means only .
The solution of iron in mineral waters , especially in such as , by exposure , readily lose the property of striking a purple colour with astringent vegetables , has usually been attributed to some subtle gas , or volatile acid .
Chemistry , however , does not discover any acid solvent for iron , but what has greater affinity with alcalies ; and by means of which , therefore , this metal will be precipitated .
Hence if any water appears , with a predominant alcali , which has also the power of tinging with galls , and , on being exposed to the open air , lets fall the iron , and loses that property ; may we not conclude the metal to have been suspended by some other medium ?
This , for example , is plainly the case in German Spa water , which Dr. Brownrigg has proved to abound with fixed air .
Your own very curious experiments , before cited , have clearly shown , that calcarious earths may be suspended in water by this principle of fixed air .
And these have led me to examine , whether iron might not be dissolved by the same natural means .
I would not , however , be supposed to deny , that iron is frequently found united with an acid .
The fact is sufficiently evinced in the pyrites and vitriolic earths .
Nor can I doubt , but that these substances do largely contribute to the primary impregnation of waters , they being so readily soluble in them .
But as an alcali , or absorbent earth , is often found more than sufficient to saturate the acid in mineral waters ; this would effectually disengage every particle of iron dissolved by an acid , unless the metal was supported by some other menstruum .
My endeavours , therefore , to detect this solvent , by experiments , are what I now beg leave to lay before you , in the order I made them .
EXPERIMENT I. A wide-mouthed bottle , containing half a pint of distilled water and sixty grains of steel-filings , was suspended forty-eight hours over some distillers molasses , in brisk fermentation ; so as to receive the fixed air escaping from the fermenting liquor ; the surface of which was ten inches below the mouth of the bottle .
Immediately after its removal , the clear water was decanted from the filings and ochrous sediment .
This liquor had a brisk and ferruginous taste , with a flavour of the molasses .
An infusion of galls , or green tea , soon changed part of it to a colour like ink .
The remainder , being exposed to the open air , presently became turbid , threw up a party-coloured pellicle , and deposited a yellowish sediment .
The water now retained but very little power of tinging with galls ; and in a few days lost this property entirely .
EXPERIMENT II .
Fourteen ounces of coarse sugar , dissolved in seven pints of water , were mixed with half a pint of yeast , in a bottle capable of holding more than twice the above quantity .
One end of a bent tube was luted into this vessel , so that no air might escape but through the tube ; the other end was loosely inserted two inches within the mouth of another large bottle , charged with four hundred grains of iron filings , and sixty ounces of distilled water .
After remaining twelve hours in this situation , the sugar working briskly , an ounce phial was let down gently into the bottle , and filled .
The water from the phial , with one drop of tincture of galls * , changed in a few minutes to a light rosy purple .
The liquor being shaken , and another phial-full taken up soon after , one drop of the tincture gave a deeper colour than before .
In an hour and half more , after being shaken again , the phial-full received a still deeper purple , from the like quantity of tincture .
The bottle continuing as before near five hours longer ; when the quantity of fixed air from the fermenting liquor was supposed sufficient to have saturated the water ; the liquor appeared very turbid on being shaken ; and , after standing another hour , under the tube , to settle , the whole was filtered .
Thirty ounces of the clear liquor was poured into two Florence flasks , and the remainder into phials , which were afterwards well corked .
Two of these phials had their corks dipped into melted resin , so as to cover the mouths of the bottles .
Two others were enclosed with a paste or lute .
Notwithstanding the above precautions to prevent the escape of air , the liquors in each soon grew turbid , and by the next morning deposited yellow sediments .
* This tincture was made by infusing half an ounce of powdered galls in eight ounces of proof spirit , for four days , without heat .
This water had a smart chalybeate taste , somewhat resembling Spa water ; with a slight flavour of the fermenting liquor .
One drop of tincture of galls gave a rosy purple colour to a wine-pint of this water .
Syrup of violets turned it green* .
Soap leys , or even alcaline salts , either fixed or volatile in their natural states , soon changed this liquor green , and rendered it turbid , whence a yellow sediment ensued .
But neither of the alcaline salts , when previously saturated with fixed air , produced any perceptible alteration .
Nor did any visible change happen on the addition of acids .
The thirty ounces of water , in the flasks before mentioned , after being boiled twenty minutes , to expel the air , became very turbid , and let fall sediments .
The clear liquor being decanted , the remainder was passed through a filter , and , after drying , the paper appeared to have gained two grains and a quarter .
This ochrous residuum could not be again dissolved in water , by means of fixed air ; but was soluble in the vitriolic acid .
The solution , diluted and filtered , received no colour from galls , until alcali was added to saturate the redundant acid ; after which it struck a purple , as in common solutions of iron .
* Simple distilled water , saturated with fixed air , by any means I have tried , makes no change in syrup of violets : and , when mixed with soap , does not curdle .
The liquor , decanted after boiling , neither changed colour with galls , nor showed any precipitation with lime-water .
EXPERIMENT III .
A common quart-bottle was half filled with distilled water , to which were added an hundred grains of steel-filings .
To these was introduced , by means of the bent tube , as much fixed air , obtained from a solution of alcaline salt in the vitriolic acid , as was judged sufficient to fill the bottle .
The whole being then shaken , with my hand over its mouth , the bottle stuck like a cupping-glass .
About the same quantity of air being again added , the bottle , after shaking , had less adhesion than before .
On repeating this experiment , a third time , with fresh air , the adhesion was scarcely perceptible .
And after the fourth trial , a small portion of air was observed to issue from the bottle .
The water now gave a deep colour with tincture of galls .
This experiment was repeated with fixed air from different combinations .
As also by passing this air through a vessel of pearl-ash , to arrest any acid which might escape from the effervescing mixtures .
But the solutions of iron , in all the trials , appeared to be exactly similar , except some trifling difference in taste and smell .
EXPERIMENT IV .
A bottle , with the like quantity of steel-filings and distilled water as in Experiment the First , remained in a room many weeks ; yet although it was frequently shaken , and had an ochrous sediment , it gave no colour with tincture of galls , EXPERIMENT V. A single grain of iron in solution* , diluted with a pint of distilled water , changed to a deep blue purple , with the tincture of galls .
Half a pint of the like mixture , exposed many days in a wide-mouthed glass covered loosely with paper , let fall a slight precipitation ; but its property of tinging with galls was not sensibly diminished .
The same quantity being boiled four or five minutes , in a Florence flask , became turbid , and deposited a small portion of an ochrous sediment .
The tincture of galls , nevertheless , gave as deep a colour to the clear liquor , as it would have done before boiling .
The foregoing experiments seem to prove , that iron remains quite unaffected by pure water , but may easily be dissolved in it on the addition of fixed air ; and that in whatsoever manner this air is generated , the event will appear the same .
The last experiment shows , that where iron is suspended in water , by an acid , neither exposure nor boiling will destroy its property of tinging with galls ; which is the reverse of what we find to be the case with many ferruginous waters .
Experiment the Second more particularly * Iron-filings were dissolved in diluted oil of vitriol to saturation ; and , by experiment , one grain of the metal , with about two grains and a quarter of the acid , were found to be contained in sixty-eight grains of the solution .
teaches , that the iron , dissolved in water by fixed air , is at least equal in quantity to what is commonly ascribed to most chalybeate springs : that this air , by which the metal is held in solution , is similar to that elastic vapour , so often mentioned by writers on these subjects ; which cannot be wholly retained by the closest corking , but , gradually escaping , suffers the ochrous matter to subside .
And that fixed air has greater affinity with alcalies than with iron , because addition of alcaline substances , not saturated with fixed air , will disengage the metal , while such as are charged with this principle produce no alteration .
These conclusions seemed to account for many particulars relating to medicated springs ; but as all my trials had been made with iron in its metallic state , which is rarely found in nature , it was necessary to repeat them upon this mineral in the state of ore .
I proceeded , therefore , to different experiments upon various ores ; but did not find any of them to answer my expectation , except what is called iron sand ore , which seems to contain a perfect iron .
This , at first , offered a material objection to my former inference .
But , upon a little consideration , it occurred , that waters , being first charged with pyritical matter , might afterwards have their acid neutralized with alcaline or calcarious substances , and the iron yet remain suspended by air generated in the saturation .
And I was the more ready to adopt this opinion , as it would explain , very naturally , the application of fixed air to this business of solution ; which , I confess , had hitherto been to me somewhat difficult to account for .
It was necessary , however , to examine the truth of this theory , by the test of experiment , which I did in the following manner .
EXPERIMENT VI .
To a pint of distilled water , mixed with one grain of iron dissolved ( as in Experiment the Fifth ) , were added forty grains of soap leys .
And to two ounces of lime-water , diluted with fourteen ounces of distilled water , was added a grain of iron in solution .
In both cases the point of saturation was intended .
The two mixtures instantly turned green , grew turbid , and let fall sediments of the same colour .
The liquors , being filtered , gave no tinge with tincture of galls .
EXPERIMENT VII .
A quart of water was mixed with two grains of iron , as before .
To one moiety , three grains of salt of tartar in solution was instilled .
It first appeared green , soon changed yellow , and gave an orange-coloured precipitate .
To another portion two grains of powdered chalk being added , it presently became straw-coloured , and after continuing nine hours in a well-corked phial , was yet turbid , with a yellow sediment .
The waters being both filtered , part of each changed to a purple , with tincture of galls .
The remainder being boiled , a farther precipitation ensued , and the clear liquor no longer produced any alteration with galls .
This experiment being repeated with magnesia , and with the earth of alum , showed no sensible difference .
The quantity of iron , left dissolved in the liquor , was found in proportion to the volume of air generated during the saturation .
If the quantity of alcali or absorbent earth was insufficient to saturate the acid , part of the iron would remain in the water after boiling .
All which were discoverable by the tincture of galls .
EXPERIMENT VIII .
To a pint of distilled water , being saturated with sixed air , and containing four grains of chalk , was added a grain of iron in solution ; the mixture continued pellucid .
Another grain of dissolved iron was diluted with a like quantity of water , previously saturated with air from a solution of pearl-ash in vitriolic acid : eight grains of salt of tartar , crystallized with fixed air , and dissolved , were added to this mixture : a slight degree of cloudiness ensued , but disappeared on shaking ; after which the liquor much resembled Spawater ; only it tasted stronger of the iron .
The quantity of chalk , and alcaline salt , in this experiment , was more than sufficient to neutralize the acid .
Both the above mixtures , on exposure , became turbid , threw up pellicles , deposited ferruginous sediments , and lost their power of striking a purple with galls .
Solutions of iron , and of its ores , in the marine and nitrous acids , as also pyrites dissolved in rain-water , were substituted , by turns , instead of the original iron in vitriolic acid ; and they all gave a purple colour with tincture of galls .
The trials were repeated with lime-stone , marble , island crystal , osteocolla , and magnesia , in lieu of chalk ; and with volatile and mineral alcali , replete with air , in the room of salt of tartar ; but no material difference was observed .
The success of these experiments compleatly answered my expectations .
They satisfied me , that any acid holding iron dissolved , and diluted with water , might not only be neutralized , but the water charged with an excess of alcaline or earthy matter , without precipitating the metal ; and that the solvent , in these cases , could be no other than Fixed Air .
Since the iron remained in solution , only where this principle originally abounded in the water , or was afterwards generated in the saturation .
Thus much being determined , it seemed easy to apply the discovery to the more perfect analyzation of some waters ; and to the re-production of others , by art , which should exactly resemble those of natural medicated springs .
This is a task I should probably have undertaken at leisure ; had I not been informed , that Dr. Watson , junior , by whose conversation my thoughts were first led to the subject , is already engaged in something of this sort .
This gentleman saw many of the foregoing experiments repeated ; and , as he is since gone to the German Spa , I dare say , his abilities and application will sufficiently improvo the opportunity : I shall gladly , therefore , wait the result of his enquiries .
To conclude then : It appears to me highly probable , that fixed air is generally necessary to the impregnation of mineral springs .
That by the right knowledge of this principle , we may now solve most difficulties that have arisen on this subject ; and very possibly be able , hereafter , to imitate nature , in the formation of medicated waters .
Whether my conclusions are well founded , I with pleasure refer to your candid decision .
And am , SIR , with great respect , Your much obliged , humble servant , T. Lane .
~g2 XXXI .
Account

