XII .
A Letter from Mr. John Robertson , Lib. R. S. to James West , Esq ; President of the Royal Society ; containing the Demonstration of a Law of Motion , in the Case of a Body deflected by two Forces tending constantly to two fixed Points .
SIR , THE late Mr. Machine ( who was , for many years , secretary to the Royal Society , and Gresham professor of astronomy ) gave to the editor of the English edition of Sir Isaac Newton 's Principia , published in the year 1729 , a tract entitled , ` ` The Laws of the Moon 's Motion according to Gravity , ' ' which was annexed to that impression : Mr. Machine , in the Postscript to that tract , after apologizing for not mentioning the fundamental principles of the demonstration of the propositions relating to the Moon 's motions , says , ` ` Some of which , I am apt to think , cannot easily be proved to be either true or false , by any methods which are now in common use .
' ' Read April 6 , 1769 .
One of these principles he gives in the following words : There is a law of motion which holds in the case where a body is deflected by two forces , tending constantly to two fixed points .
Which is , That the body , in such a case , will describe , by lines drawn from the two fixed points , equal solids in equal times , about the line joining the said fixed points .
And ( after observing that Sir Isaac Newton has proved , that Kepler 's law of bodies describing equal areas in equal times about the centers of their revolution , cannot hold , whenever the body has a gravity or force to any other than one and the same point ) further says , ` ` there seems to be wanting some such law as I have here laid down , that may serve to explain the motions of the Moon and Satellites , which have a gravity towards two different centers .
' ' About the year 1742 , discoursing with that eminent mathematician , the late William Jones , Esq ; F. R. S. on the above-mentioned law , he showed me its demonstration , and permitted me to take a copy thereof ; and as I conceive it to be highly worth preserving , I now offer it to your consideration , about giving it a place in the Philosophical Transactions .
I am , SIR , Your most humble servant , February 27 , 1769 .
J. Robertson .
TA B. IV .
FI G. I. PROPOSITIO N. IF a body ( P ) , projected in a given direction , be constantly drawn towards two fixed points ( S and T ) , which are not both in the same plane with the direction , the triangle ( S P T ) , formed by right lines drawn from the body ( P ) to those fixed points ( S and T ) , shall describe equal solids ( STPP ` , STP`P ` ` ) , in equal times , about the right line ( S T ) joining the said points .
FI G. 2 .
For , suppose a body projected in the direction P P ` , and acted upon by two centripetal forces towards the fixed points S and T ; the angles P`P S , P`P T lying in different planes .
Let the time be divided into equal moments .
In the first moment , suppose the body , by its given force , should move along the line P P ` ; and in the second moment , if no new force was added , it should continue to move in the same right line along P`p=P P ` ; but when the body has come to P ` , suppose it acted upon by the two centripetal forces , in the directions P`T , P`S ; and let those forces be in proportion to that in the direction P P ` , as the lines P`t , P`s to the line P`p ( =P`P ) .
With these three right lines P`p , P`t , P`s , complete the parallelopipid P`P ` ; and the body in P ` , being acted upon by these three forces , in the directions Philos. Trans. Vol. LIX .
TAB. IV .
p. 76 .
p PIV p PIII PII PII Fig. f. PI PIII ~t~ PI Pt TP S Fig. 2 .
P~p , P~t , P~s , which forces being as these three lines , shall move along the diagonal of the parallelopipid made by these three lines ; so that , in the second moment of time , the body , instead of moving from P~ to p~ shall move from P~ to P~ .
Draw the lines S P~ S P~ and T P~ , T P~ , as also S p , T p. Now , the solid STP P~=solid ST P~p ; for they stand upon equal bases T P~P , T P~p , and have one common vertex S , or their common altitude is the perpendicular drawn from S to the plane PT p. And the solid ST P~P~ = solid ST P~p ; for they stand upon the same base ST P~ , and lie between the same parallel planes p P~ , st. Therefore the solid STP P~=solid ST P~P~ .
In like manner , in the third moment of time , the body at P~ being acted upon by three forces , in the directions P~P~ , P~S , P~T , shall move along the line P~P~ , so as to make the solid ST P~P~=solid ST P~P~ ; and so in all succeeding equal moments of time , the triangle formed by right lines drawn from the body to the two fixed points S , T , shall constantly describe little solids , each equal to the solid STP P~ .
Therefore , the moments of the solids being proportional to the moments of the time in which they are described ; the solid itself is proportional to the time in which it is described .
Q. E. D. Some difficulties may , perhaps , seem to arise upon a slight view of only particular cases of this proposition ; but , it is conceived , all such must vanish , when the same is thoroughly considered .
For , as in two bodies T and S ; if T is acted upon by S , so as to describe a right line , that is , if T falls directly upon S , no area can then be described by the right line connecting T and S ; but yet , this is certainly one of the cases whereby S and T may possibly act upon each other .
So in three bodies , S , T , and P ; if P moves in the same plane with S and T , no solid can then be described by the plane whose right lined sides are the lines connecting P to T and S ; but yet , this must be one of the cases whereby S , T , and P , may possibly act upon each other .

