Received December 8 , 1768 .
III .
An extraordinary Case of three Pins swallowed by a Girl , and discharged at her Shoulder .
In a Letter to Frank Nicholls , M. D. F. R. S. from Dr. Lysons , of Gloucester .
To Charles Morton , M. D. Sec. R. S. Epsom , Nov. 25 , 1768 .
DEARSI R , INCLOSEDI send you a most extraordinary case , which is transmitted to me by Dr. Lysons , a gentleman of great learning and credit , and physician to the Gloucester hospital .
It seems to be exactly drawn , and the Doctor 's veracity may be depended on .
I think it well worth preserving in the Memoirs of the Society ; and believe that the Council will have the same opinion of it as , SIR , Your very humble servant , Fran .
Nicholls .
VO L. LIX .
CSI R , Read January 26 , SIR , UPON my mentioning the case of a girl who swallowed three pins , which were afterwards discharged at her shoulder , you thought it might be proper for the Philosophical Transactions , and desired me to send it you .
I have drawn it from notes taken during my attendance upon her , with as much accuracy as possible , and it is as follows .
Eleanor Kaylock , a robust , strong girl , aged twentytwo , was admitted a patient in the Gloucester infirmary , May 29 , 1766 , for a pain in her side proceeding from pins swallowed three quarters of a year before .
The occasion of the accident was thus .
Being employed in the business of a kitchen , as she was scumming the pot ( her mouth being open , and three pins in it ) , she received a quantityi of the vapour , which obliged her to swallow , and the pins at the same time passed into the oesophagus , where they remained for eight weeks , notwithstanding various methods were used for their removal ; but they were at last forced down by the whalebone instrument used by surgeons for that purpose .
Whilst the pins were in her throat , the parts became inflamed , and swoln , which occasioned an hoarseness , attended with great pain , and difficulty of breathing : being also capable of receiving but very little nourishment , and that liquids , she was reduced to so weak a state as not to be able to get out of her bed .
After the pins were removed she could swallow solids , and recovered strength sufficient to go out again to service in her former employment .
She was hired as an under-servant in a gentleman 's kitchen , chen , but was soon obliged to quit her place , and apply for relief , any extraordinary motion aggravating her complaints , and occasioning violent convulsions , from which she did not recover for eight or nine hours .
When she came to the infirmary , she appeared full of flesh , of a ruddy complexion , and in perfect health , excepting the following complaints .
She had a pain in her right side , below the false ribs , which she first felt immediately upon the removal of the pins from the oesophagus , and it continued to the time of her admission at the hospital , but was most violent when she moved the trunk of her body forwards round towards the left , or lifted up her right arm .
At her admission , and from the time of the removal of the pins , the hoarseness she was troubled with soon after the pins first stuck in her throat , continued ; she often spit up blood , and had a violent cough , by which , as well as by labour , or any excess of motion , the pain in her side being greatly aggravated , she was obliged to sit or fall down immediately , and could not recover herself , so as to be able to stand , in less than an hour .
In these paroxysms she had always a pain in her head , was sick at stomach , and frequently brought up blood .
Whilst she was in the infirmary , the violence of the pain three times occasioned convulsion-fits , by which the musculus rectus superior of the right eye was so violently affected , that , notwithstanding the eye was open , yet the pupil was entirely covered by the eye-lid ; and , after one of these fits , continued so for a fortnight .
The left eye was also inverted in the same manner , but the constriction was removed in a week .
When these spasmodic affections left her , she did not recover her eye-sight for some days , the optic nerve being probably oppressed ; but the left eye always recovered sooner than the right , being never so strongly convulsed .
None of the other muscles appeared to be affected , except in the paroxysms .
While the pins were in the oesophagus , the surgeon was utterly at a loss where to direct his instruments , as there was no certain indication where the pins were lodged .
And the physician 's practice could be only palliative , using bleeding , with anodyne and lubricating medicines , according as the various symptoms occasionally required .
In this manner things went on to the beginning of August , when a small painful tumour , the size of a man 's thumb , appeared upon the right shoulder , which disappeared in the compass of a week without coming to suppuration .
Afterwards such another small tumour appeared upon the left shoulder , which increased , and , by the care of Mr. Crump , the attending surgeon , was brought to suppuration , and opened by him , August 20 , when a large table spoonful of matter was discharged .
Upon removing the dressings , the next day , a larger quantity of matter flowed out , and with it issued one of the pins .
Mr. Crump then examined with his probe if he could find either of the others , but could not : however , the day following , the other two pins were also discharged at the same wound .
These pins were all of the same length , each measuring five quarters of an inch .
The wound at which these pins were discharged was upon the superior part of the scapula .
After the girl had received her cure , and was discharged from the infirmary ( which happened September the fourth ) , I compared her shoulder with Cowper 's Anatomical Tables on the Muscles ; and , as near as I can guess , the wound was upon the fleshy belly of the trapesius .
And yet the pain in the patient 's side attended her as long as the pins remained in the wound , but left her soon after they were discharged , as did also her cough , and spitting of blood .
Being obliged to lead a sedentary life in the infirmary , and to keep herself as quiet as possible , her catamenia left her ; but her spitting of blood could not be attributed to that defect , because she was very regular before her admission , and yet she had spit blood from the time the pins were removed from the oesophagus , which was some months before she came to the infirmary .
It would be matter of considerable satisfaction , could the exact course be ascertained which was taken by these pins , in their passage from the oesophagus to their exit at the left shoulder .
From the cough and spitting of blood one should suppose that the lungs were injured by them .
From the pain under the false ribs , it may be imagined that the diaphragm was affected .
And yet from their being discharged at the shoulder it may be presumed , that neither of these parts were ever wounded ; but that the pins , being forced through the substance of the oesophagus into the muscles of the neck and shoulder , passed thence to the part whence they were discharged .
The first symptom observable upon the removal of these pins from the passage of the oesophagus was , that the patient immediately felt a pain in her right side , below the false ribs , which was most violent when she turned the trunk of her body forwards round towards the left , or lifted up her right arm .
Now if the pins , being forced out of the oesophagus , penetrated the serrati , rhomboids , and trapesius muscles on the right side , this symptom must necessarily happen .
For the serrati being muscles of respiration , and the serratus superor posticus attached to the second , third , fourth , fifth , and sixth ribs ; and the serratus inferior posticus being attached to the tenth , eleventh , and the extremity of the twelfth ribs , a pain in the side will be produced by the constant efforts of respiration .
And the office of these muscles being to elevate the ribs , and draw down the arm , the pain in the side will be most sensibly felt whenever the right arm is lifted up ; because then the extremities of these muscles , attached to the ribs , will be most tense .
For although a wound may be given to a muscle in its most fleshy part , yet the irritation occasioned by it will exert itself most forcibly in that part where there is the greatest tension .
The rhomboids muscle lying upon the serratus superior , and the trapesius being incumbent upon it , and all closely connected by the cellular membrane , they must all be in some degree affected by respiration .
But the office of the rhomboids and trapesius muscles being to draw the arm downwards , and backwards , the pain in the side would be increased whenever the right arm and trunk of the body were turned forwards towards the left side .
Being thus , as we may suppose , arrived at the true cause of the pain in the side , the cough comes next under consideration .
And this will be found to pro2 ceed ceed from the same cause that the cough of a pleuritic person does , only with this difference , that in one the pleura and intercostal muscles are affected by an internal inflammation , by which respiration is disturbed ; in the other , the malady arises from irritation caused by an extraneous body .
The effects are the same in both ; respiration being impeded , nature endeavours to relieve herself by a cough , which increases the irritation and inflammation of the parts obstructed ; these again increase the violence of the cough : and thus , each being aggravated by the other , the lungs are often so violently agitated , that a bloodvessel bursts , and thence blood is thrown up from the lungs , as was the case in the present instance .
Whoever considers the communication between the third pair of nerves , the intercostal , the cardiac , and the recurrents , together with the other nerves dependent upon them , will easily perceive the cause of the violent spasm upon the eyes , the sickness at stomach , and the general convulsion , as being all primarily dependant upon the irritation given to the intercostal nerve on the right side .
And it may be observed , that , although both the motores oculorum were affected , yet the right eye was convulsed most violently .
From the symptoms attending this uncommon case , it is reasonable to conclude , that the three pins were all of them at the same time forced from the oesophagus into the serrati muscles on the right side , which immediately communicated an irritation , or impulse , to the intercostal nerve , from whence arose the pain in the side , and thence the sickness at stomach , and convulsions of the eyes and other parts .
But whatever caused the pain in the right side , upon the removal of the pins from the oesophagus , that cause continued to act until all the three pins were discharged at the left shoulder , for so long did the pain in the right side continue .
The thickness of the two serrati , the rhomboids , and trapesius muscles may be thought too great for pins five quarters of an inch long to penetrate all of them at the same time .
But if it be observed , that one of the pins was discharged at a time when neither of the two others could be felt with the probe , it may be supposed , that one of the three passed into the rhomboids , and trapesius , whilst the two others remained in the serrati , and there continued until the first was discharged at the trapesius ; after which they took the same course , and were discharged at the same outlet .
Thus might we give a very probable account of this extraordinary case , had the pins been discharged at the right shoulder , but they were discharged at the left .
By those who think that , the nerves communicating with one another , the cause and effect produced may be on opposite sides of the body , it may be said , that the pins might be forced from the oesophagus into the muscles of the left side , notwithstanding the pain was felt in the right .
This will not be generally allowed .
Neither can I perceive any reason why a tumor exactly resembling that from whence the pins were afterwards discharged at the left shoulder , should arise upon the right , and disperse without coming to suppuration .
Since I drew out the above account , I have seen a case nearly similar to it , recorded in the Philosophical Transactions , No 461 .
A small needle being lodged in a woman 's left arm , about six inches below the shoulder , passed thence to her right breast , whence it was extracted many months after it first entered the body .
About a month after the accident , she felt a pain above the place where the needle run in , which extended up her shoulder .
It lasted there three or four days , and then returned by fits .
About 17 weeks before the needle was extracted , she felt a pain at her stomach , was sick , and had reachings to vomit .
These symptoms continued to afflict her ( especially in the morning ) , until within two days of the needle being extracted , at which time she thought a pin had got into her right breast .
This directed the surgeon to make an opening there , and he extracted the same needle that had entered at her arm from the part where the pricking pain was ; after which she had never any return of pain in her breast , stomach , shoulder , or arm .
If , upon perusal of this case , you think it merits the attention of the curious , as corroborating the other , your recommendation of it to the Royal Society will be esteemed an honour to , SIR , Your much obliged , humble servant Gloucester , Sept. 1 , 1768 .
Dan .
Lysons .

