XXIV .
A Discourse concerning the Menstrual Parallax , arising from the mutual Gravitation of the Earth and Moon ; it 's Influence on the Observations of the Sun and Planets ; with a Method of observing it : By J. Smeaton , F. R. S. IT is demonstrated by Sir Isaac Newton in the Principia , that it is not the Earth 's center , but the common center of gravity of the Earth and Moon , that describes the ecliptic ; and that the Earth and Moon revolve in similar ellipses , about their common center of gravity .
The same great author has also investigated , from the different rise of the tides , when the Moon is in conjunction or opposition to the Sun , to those which happen when the Moon is in her quadratures ; that the quantity of matter in the Earth is to that in the Moon , as 39 .
78 to 1 ; from whence , and the known distance of the Earth and Moon , it would follow , that the common center of gravity of the two bodies falls without the surface of the Earth , by one half of its semidiameter : that is , that the center of the Earth describes an epicycle round the common center of gravity once a month , whose diameter is three semidiameters of the Earth .
Read May 12 , 1768 .
Dr. Gregory , in his astronomy , has laid hold of this circumstance , in order to prove the relative gravity of the Earth and Moon , by observation ; which is the subject of his 60th proposition of the fourth book ; in which he has demonstrated , that if an observer on the Earth makes a correct observation on the Sun 's place , when the Moon is in one quadrature , it will differ from a like observation , taken in the opposite quadrature ( according to a mean elliptic motion ) by an angle which the diameter of this epicycle will subtend at the Sun .
The same learned author has also shown , in the scholium to the same proposition , that this quantity , or parallax , will be twice greater to Mars in opposition , and three times greater to Venus , in her inferior conjunction with the Sun .
The difference thus produced in the apparent place of the Sun , and of all the primary planets being governed by the Moon , and having it 's period the same , may perhaps be not unaptly called the menstrual parallax .
Now if , with Sir Isaac Newton , the relative gravities of the Earth and Moon are taken between the proportion of 39 and 40 to one ; the menstrual parallax of the sun will come out 13~ upon the radius of the Earth 's epicycle , and will affect the solar observations at the opposite quadratures , by double that quantity , viz. 26~ : in like manner , the mean distance from the Earth of Mars in opposition , being to the Sun 's mean distance , as 1 to 2 .
1 ; and the least distance of Mars from the Earth , to the Sun 's mean distance , as 1 to 2 3/ 4 , the menstrual parallax of Mars will affect the observation upon him in that situation , by 56~ and 73~ 1/ 2 , respectively .
The mean distance of Venus from the Earth , in her inferior conjunction , being to that of the Sun as 3 1/ 2 to 1 nearly , and not very variable , on account of the orbit of Venus being almost circular ; the menstrual parallax would affect the place of Venus , in that situation , by a quantity not less than 92~ ; and in all other situations in proportion to her distance ; which also holds with respect to all the rest of the planets .
These disturbing quantities are by no means to be dispensed with , in the nice and critical state that astronomical observations and calculations have arrived at , in consequence of the discoveries of Dr. Bradley , who may be said to have given a basis to astronomy ; however , could we rely upon the data , on which Sir Isaac 's investigation of the relative gravity of the Earth and Moon is founded , we should have nothing to do but to apply an equation to the particular cases , according to the diameter of the epicycle , as deduced from the relative gravity ; but whoever considers the great obstructions that the water of the sea meets with in its motion to obey the influence of the Moon ; the great difficulty in ascertaining the true height of the tides , from the many disturbing causes intervening ; and the many uncertainties , and want of coincidence , that have attended , and must attend , such observations ; must confess , that this matter does not seem capable of such a determination from that quarter , as the present state of astronomy requires .
Accordingly , since the time of Dr. Gregory , those great astronomers Dr. Bradley , De la Caille , and others , have applied themselves to determine the quantity of the menstrual parallax from solar observations : but though these have given cause to suppose that the relative gravity of the Earth and Moon are not above 2/ 3 of the quantity deduced from the tides ; yet , as the observation of these small angles principally depends upon the observation of the Sun 's right ascension ( which , depending on the measure of time , is less capable of exact observation , than if depending on divided instruments ) ; the deductions thence drawn seem still wanting of that certainty which the subject demands ; and if to this we add , from a deduction of Mr. Maskelyne , that the relative gravity of the Earth and Moon is as 76 to 1 , derived from the effect that the Moon produces in the nutation of the Earth 's axis ; the relative gravity , and consequently the parallaxes thereon depending , will be reduced to almost one half of those resulting from Sir Isaac 's determination .
It is true , that the quantity of effect of the menstrual parallaxes will not be great , if computed upon Mr. Maskelyne 's induction , for as much as that the common center of gravity will be considerably within the Earth 's surface ; yet , even in that case , the Sun 's transit over the meridian , when the Moon is in one quadrature , will differ nearly one second of time from that observed in the opposite quadrature ; and though De la Caille and Mayer have formed equations depending on the Moon , to be applied to the equation of time ; yet , if we are at an uncertainty , whether the maximum of this equation is one second , two thirds of a second , or half a second of time , each way , we are still under a material difficulty ; for though these differences are so small , that it is not easy to determine them exactly from solar observations ; yet , as they are capable of creating a sensible difference in these observations , they will , so long as they remain undetermined , prevent that solidity and firmness ness to the solar observations , which is the more necessary as they are the foundation of all the rest : but with respect to those planets , that in their periods come nearer to us than we to the Sun , the observations upon them will be affected by a greater uncertainty .
The determination of the menstrual parallax is of still more importance , as it is a necessary consideration in the determination of the Sun 's parallax ; and this , whether deduced from Mars or Venus , as I shall presently show more particularly ; but first I must state the quantity of the menstrual parallax , according to the best data yet known , by a contrary process ; and , taking the mean quantity of the Sun 's parallax , according to the determination of Mr. Short , at 8~ 8 , and the relative gravities of the Earth and Moon , according to Mr. Maskelyne , as 76 to 1 , and the mean distance of their centers equal to 60 1/ 2 semidiameters ; we shall then have the distance of the Earth 's center from the center of gravity , at 8/ 10 of the Earth 's semidiameter ( that is , 1/ 5 of that semidiameter within the Earth 's surface ) and the menstrual parallax equal to 8/ 10 of the Sun 's parallax ; consequently about 7~ ; and the double menstrual parallax , or vacillation , arising from the whole diameter of the epicycle , 14~ ; the mean menstrual parallax of Mars in opposition , 29~ 1/ 2 ; the greatest , 38~ 1/ 2 ; and that of Venus 49~ ; from hence it follows , that , was a person to attempt the Sun 's parallax , by the diurnal motion of the Earth , applied as a basis to Mars in opposition , as has formerly been tried ; and should the Moon be at new or full at the same time , the change of place of the Earth 's center , in its own epicycle , would amount to an angle seen from Mars of 1~.3 nearly ; that is , in case the interval between the observations was eight hours , and Mars at his mean distance ; but if Mars was not at his nearest distance , this change would in the same time amount to 1~.7 nearly .
In like manner , if a transit of Venus happens near the new or full Moon ( as will be the case next year ) , the time of the transit will be affected by a change of place , such as the Earth 's center will describe in its epicycle , during the time of the whole transit , if the beginning and end are observed in the same place ; or during the difference of absolute time , at which the transit appears to begin or end to different observers in distant meridians .
Thus , when the same observer sees the beginning and end in the same place , the base described by that observer , from the Earth 's diurnal motion , must be corrected by the space described by the Earth 's center , in the circumference of it 's epicycle , during that time ; which , if it be supposed of seven hours , will amount to an angle of 1~.9 , seen from Venus : but , where the beginning or end is seen by different observers in distant meridians , as the difference of absolute time can hardly amount to above 1~5 minutes , the change of place of the Earth 's center will ~ that time be but small ; however , at the rate beforementioned , it will for 15 minutes affect the parallactic angle seen from Venus , by about 7/ 100 , of a second ; and the parallax of the Sun , by about 1/ 400 part of the whole : but this proportional part will remain the same , whether the distance of meridians be such as produce a greater or less difference of absolute time than 15 minutes * .
* If an error of 1/ 400 part of the whole may be supposed in the observation for determining the Sun 's parallax by the transit From what has been said , I suppose it will appear , that the effects of the menstrual parallax are worthy of consideration ; and that nothing has been yet executed , whereby it has received a determination sufficiently accurate ; for , in regard to observations upon the Sun , the whole quantity is too small to be minutely observed in right ascension : and with respect to the application to Mars and Venus , as suggested by Dr. Gregory , I do not know that any thing has been done ; and indeed no wonder , as the theory of the motion of Mars and Venus has not been as yet so critically reduced to computation , as to render their parallaxes ( though in themselves much greater ) deducible with equal certainty as that of the Sun .
What I therefore have now to propose , is a method of observing the menstrual parallaxes of Mars and Venus , without laying any undue stress upon the theory of their motions .
The first opportunity of making an observation for this purpose , will be at the next opposition of Mars ; which , according to the Nautical Almanac , will happen the 26th of October next , in the morning ; I will therefore endeavour to illustrate this matter by taking that as an example .
The distance of Mars from the Earth will then be somewhat less than the mean distance , that is , as 1 to 2.2 ; and consequently his double menstrual parallax , according to Mr. Maskelyne , will be near 31~ in the point of opposition .
Now , as the Moon of Venus , a neglect of the menstrual parallax may make it 1/ 2 00 part of the whole .
will be at full , not above 12 hours preceding that opposition , the Moon will be nearly in the most favourable situation for the purpose .
For this end , let an accurate observation be made upon the place of Mars at the following times , viz. first , near the time of the new Moon , preceding Mars 's opposition ; or more properly at the nearest opportunity , to the time of the Moon 's opposition to Mars ; which will happen in the night , between the 12th and 13th of October : secondly , let the place of Mars be observed when the Moon is nearest her quartile with Mars ; that is , between the 19th and 20th of the same month : thirdly , let an observation on Mars be made when the Moon is in conjunction with Mars , the nearest to his opposition with the Sun ; that is , between the 25th and 26th of ditto : fourthly , let Mars again be observed when the Moon has moved on to her quartile with Mars , viz. between the 31st of October , and 1st of November : and fifthly and lastly , let the place of Mars be observed , when the Moon has again got to her opposition with Mars , which happens between the 7th and 8th of November .
Now it is manifest , that , when the Moon is in conjunction or opposition to Mars , the center of the Earth , the center of Mars , and the common center of gravity of the Earth and Mars , will be nearly in a right line , and consequently , that an observer will then see Mars , in the same place in the heavens , as if the common center of gravity was the same as the center of the Earth ; therefore , then the place of Mars will be unaffected by a menstrual parallax ; and such will be the first , third , and fifth of the observations above propounded .
It is equally evident , that when the Moon is in quartile with Mars , and moving towards a conjunction , an observer , at the Earth 's center , will see Mars more backward in the ecliptic , than if seen from the common center of gravity , by 1 5~ 1/ 2 ; and that , when the Moon is in her opposite quartile with Mars , and moving from her conjunction , that then an observer at the Earth 's center , will see Mars advanced in his orbit more forward by 1 5~ 1/ 2 , than if seen from the common center of gravity ; and the one observation checqued with the other , will , according to a mean elliptic motion , differ by the quantity of 31~ ; and such will be the second and fourth observations above propounded .
Now , from the first , third , and fifth , observations , three points of Mars 's orbit will be given ; which , by the help of the theory of Mar 's motion in an elliptic orbit , whose aphelion , eccentricity , and nodes , are known sufficiently near for this purpose ; the intermediate places of Mars may be inferred with the requisite degree of accuracy : and particularly , as the two intermediate observations , viz. the second and fourth , will be nearly at equal intervals of time between the three others : from hence it follows , that the difference between the inferred , or computed places , at the quartiles , and the observed places at those times , will be the menstrual parallax required .
It is to be noted , that the times above specified are the most favourable for the observation ; and could those be made uninterruptedly from weather , there would be the less occasion for any other : but , as much as possible to prevent disappointments of this kind , it will be right to begin the observations , a month preceding ing making the proper observations , at the conjunctions , quartiles , and oppositions , of the Moon with Mars , which will be the means of supplying such observations , as may happen to prove abortive before the opposition of Mars , and also , in case any of the observations to be made after that opposition shall prove deficient , the observations may be carried on for a month or competent time afterwards .
As a further security against disappointments , as well as cheque , it will also be advisable to make the proper observations , the night preceeding and subsequent to those in which the quartiles , conjunctions , &amp;c. happen ; for , as the quantities will not differ considerably from those obtained on the days specified , with proper allowances they may be brought in support and confirmation of the former .
In like manner , when Venus is moving towards her inferior conjunction with the Sun , as will happen next year , the same observations may be made with respect to her ; and continued for a necessary time , to get observations of the place of Venus ; viz. the first , when the Moon is in conjunction or opposition with Venus : a second , when the moon is in her quartile with Venus : a third , in conjunction or opposition : a fourth , when the moon is in her opposite quartile to the former : and a fifth , again in conjunction or opposition : the same opportunity will also offer when Venus is moving from her inferior conjunction with the Sun , and becomes a morning star .
In regard to the observation of Venus , it is remarked by astronomers , that she is to be seen with a good transit telescope , when she is within a sew degrees of the Sun ; but , as she is three times nearer the Earth , than the Sun 's mean distance , when her elongation is 25~ in the inferior part of her orbit , it is plain , that the necessary observations may easily be made , when her menstrual parallax will be at a medium , three times greater than the Sun 's ; and consequently amounting for the whole difference to 42~ .
To avoid embarrassment in description , I have hitherto supposed , that all the observations are made in the meridian ; in which case the right ascensions will be the same as they would appear from the center of the Earth ; and consequently , the planet 's longitudes thence deduced , nearly the same : but it is easy to see , that if the quartile observations are made when the planets are considerably to the east or west of the meridian , and so chosen , that the place of the observer be further distant from the common center of gravity , than the center of the Earth is from that center , that the base of the observations will be considerably enlarged .
Thus , in our latitude , supposing that the quartile observations are made four hours before and four hours after the planet passes the meridian , this will produce an enlargement of the basis by one of the Earth 's semidiameters : and as the whole base or diameter of the epicycle comes out , according to Mr. Maskelyne , no more than 1.6 of the Earth 's semidiamers ; the base will , according to this method , come out 2.6 ; and consequently , at the next opposition , the menstrual parallax of Mars will be thereby enlarged to 50~ , the greatest to 62~ 1/ 2 , and that of Venus at a mean , to 74~ 1/ 2 .
It must however be acknowledged , that no kind of observations of the places of the planets are of equal validity with those taken with the best instruments in the meridian ; those taken with micrometers perhaps not excepted : for however accurately small distances can be measured by the micrometer of Mr. Dollond , yet , as these measures can hardly be reduced to the ecliptic , without having the difference of declination or right ascension from other means ( except two stars making somewhat near a right angle with the planet should appear within the field of view at once ) ; and as in all these cases the rectification of the places of the stars themselves ultimately depends on meridian observations we may perhaps be allowed to say , that in the most favourable cases of the micrometer , the determinations thence to be drawn , are not superior to meridian observations , and in less favourable cases , must be inferior : however , as the micrometer observations out of the meridian give an opportunity of repetition as often as we please ; and the observations for rectification of the stars concerned , can be repeated in the meridian , as often as we please also ; it must be equally allowed , that when these kind of observations are taken , not too near the horizon , when proper stars offer for this purpose , and the whole skilfully managed ; these kind of observations fall but little short of those taken immediately in the meridian .
I cannot therefore hesitate to recommend , that the quartile observations be taken out of the meridian , as well as in it : in the first place , by Dollond 's micrometer , if stars offer in proper positions ; and if not , secondly , by taking differences of right ascension and declination between the planet and the stars , by the common micrometer , in case proper stars offer themselves for this pupose : but as it frequently happens , that no proper stars offer themselves to micrometers of either kind ; and this is still more likely to happen in the observations of Venus , which will be chiefly in the day light ; I beg leave to offer ( what to me is ) a new method of observation out of the meridian ; and which , though I esteem it not equal to micrometer observations of either kind , I apprehend will fall so little short thereof , and prove so much superior to any other method now in practice in these cases , that I hope I shall on this occasion be excused , in giving a particular description thereof : but , as it is a general method of observing out of the meridian , I shall reserve it by way of appendix .
In the next observation of Mars , it has been stated , that , in the meridian observations alone , the menstrual parallax , according to the smallest estimation , may be expected to amount to 31~ in longitude ; which ; turned into right ascension , will make about 2~ of time : now , if it may be allowed , that a well-practised observer can take the time of a transit to 1/ 4 part of a second , over a single wire , if he has three wires , or more , as usual , the mean of the three should be within 1/ 1 2 part of a second ; or within 1/ 2 4 part of the whole quantity in question : it is however a matter of chance , whether the mean of three may or may not be within 1/ 3 part of the whole ; and as equal errors may be committed in the observations of the transits of the stars , wherewith the right ascensions of the planets in question are compared ; which it is an equal chance , whether they tend to correct or increase the errors committed in the former ; yet if , as has already been proposed , the observations are continued for two or three months , instead of one ; and observations , taken the day preceding and subsequent to the days of conjunction , quartile , and opposition ; and this as well out of the meridian as in it ; we can hardly doubt but that , if the weather should favour , so many cheques would be formed , that , from the next opposition of Mars alone , the affair may be brought within a 24th part of the whole ; and , if to this be added the force of such determinations , as may be drawn from observations on Venus , before and after her transit over the Sun next year , it can hardly be doubted , but that those three will bring us within a single second of a degree , subtended from the nearest planet ; and these conclusions will be further strengthened by future observations ; as two years will scarcely pass without affording one or more opportunities of this kind .
As I meant not to embarrass myself with exact computations , I have constantly supposed the distance of the common center of gravity from the center of the Earth , to be a fixed quantity ; whereas it will vary in the same proportion as the Moon 's distance varies ; but , as this and many other minutiae will properly enter the computation , when the observations are made , I must beg leave to refer them to the learned in this science .
Austhorpe , April 17 , 1768 .
J. Smeaton .

