Received April 20 , 1768 .
XX .
An Account of Inoculation in Arabia , in a Letter from Dr. Patrick Russell , Physician , at Aleppo , to Alexander Russell , M. D. F. R. S. preceded by a Letter from Dr. Al .
Russell , to the Earl of Morton .
P. R. S. My Lord , THE enclosed account of inoculation in the East , I have just received from my brother at Aleppo , and though nothing farther seems wanting in this country to remove prejudices against that practice , yet I thought its being made public might be of some use to other European nations , where such prejudices still prevail ; and as a matter of curiosity , would not be unacceptable to the Royal Society .
I have therefore taken the liberty to trouble your Lordship with it for that purpose .
Read May 5 1768 .
Just before my leaving Aleppo , I did hear that it was practised amongst some of the Bedouins there , and went by the name of buying the small pox ; but being then much engaged with other business , it quite escaped my memory , and indeed my information was so slight , that I did not think it right to mention it in my Natural History of Aleppo .
I shall only add , that my brother has been more prolix in the narrative than perhaps was necessary , had the facts come within his own knowledge ; but so far as depended upon the intelligence of others , he thought it best to explain the foundation of his own belief .
I have the honour to be , My Lord , Your Lordship 's most obedient servant , Walbrook , April 18 , Alexander Russell .
1768 .
Dear Brother , FROM the manner in which inoculation is mentioned in the Natural History of Aleppo , I suspect the circumstance of it 's being a common practice among the Arabs must have escaped you .
I myself was ignorant of it for several years after you left this country , and a mere accident brought it at last to my knowledge .
About nine or ten years ago , while on a visit at a Turkish Harem , a lady happened to express much anxiety for an only child , who had not yet had the small pox ; the distemper at that time being frequent in the city .
None of the ladies in the company had ever heard of inoculation ; so that , having once mentioned it , I found myself obliged to enter into a detail of the operation , and of the peculiar advantages attending it .
Among the female servants in the chamber was an old Bedouin , who having heard me with great attention , assured the ladies , that my account was upon the whole a just one , only that I did not seem so well to understand the way of performing the operation , which she asserted should be done not with a lancet , but with a needle ; she herself had received the disease in that manner , when a child ; had in her time inoculated many ; adding moreover , that the practice was well known to the Arabs , and that they termed it buying the small pox .
In consequence of this hint , I set about the procuring more particular information from the Arabs of this place ; and the result of my enquiry was , that the practice of inoculation had been of long standing among them .
They indeed did not pretend to assign any period to its origin ; but those of seventy years old and upwards remembered to have heard it spoken of as a common custom of their ancestors , and made little doubt of its being of as ancient a date as the disease itself .
Their manner of operating is , to make several punctures in some fleshy part , with a needle imbued in variolous matter , taken from a favourable kind of pock .
They use no preparation of the body ; and the disease communicated in this way being , as they aver , always slight , they give themselves little or no trouble about the child in the subsequent stages of the distemper .
This method of procuring the disease is termed , buying the small pox , on the following account .
The child to be inoculated carries a few raisins , dates , sugar plumbs , or such like , and showing them to the child from whom the matter is to be taken , asks how many pocks he will give in exchange .
The bargain being made , they proceed to the operation .
When the parties are too young to speak for themselves , the bargain is made by the mothers .
This ceremony , which is still practised , points out a reason for the name given to inoculation by the Arabs ; but , by what I could learn among the women , it is not regarded as indispensably necessary to the success of the operation , and is in fact often omitted .
The Bedouins at this place , who are employed in the service of the Harems , more rarely have recourse to inoculation , their children being often brought up in company with those of the Turks , by whom , as you justly observe , the practice is not admitted .
But the Bedouins , less connected with the Turks , who dwell within the city ; those who live in tents without the city walls , and the Arabs of the adjacent desert under the Emir , do commonly inoculate their children .
It being highly probable that a practice , which was so common in these parts , might be known also to the more Eastern Arabs , I applied for information to several Turkish merchants of Bagdat and Mousul , who occasionally reside a few months in the year at Aleppo .
By those I was assured , that inoculation was not only common in both the cities first mentioned , but also at Bassora ; and that at Mousul particularly , when the small pox first appeared in any district of the city , it was a custom sometimes to give notice by a public crier , in order that such as were inclined might take the opportunity to have their children inoculated .
I enquired at the same time of the Bagdat merchants , whether the Arabs , who dwell on the banks of the river between that city and Bassora , used the same method of propagating the small pox .
They told me , they believed it to be common also among those Arabs ; though ( with an ingenuity not usual in this country ) they owned they had never thought of enquiring about the matter , and might therefore perhaps be mistaken .
But I afterwards had an opportunity of being better informed by the Arabs , who come hither with the Eastern caravans ; from whose accounts it would appear , that inoculation has from time immemorial been a practice among the different Arab tribes with which they were conversant ; comprehending , besides those in the numerous encampments on the banks of the Euphrates , and the Tigris below Bagdat , other tribes in the vicinity of Bassora , and in the desert .
For these several years past , very few slaves have been brought from Georgia .
From what I could collect among those already here , who remember anything of their own country , inoculation was well known there : I have seen several old Georgian women , who had been inoculated , when children , in their fathers houses .
In Armenia , the Turkoman tribes , as well as the Armenian Christians , have practised inoculation since the memory of man ; but , like the Arabs , are able to give no account of its first introduction among them .
To what extent inoculation reaches in the Gourdeen mountains , I do not know with any certainty : it is practised by the Gourdeens in the Mountains of Bylan , and Kittis ; and , I have reason to think , extends much further .
At Damascus , and all along the coast of Syria and Palestine , inoculation has been long known .
In the Castravan mountains it is adopted by the Drusi , as well as the Christians .
Whether the Arabs of the desert , to the South of Damascus , are acquainted with this manner of comV O L. LVIII .
U muni municating the small pox , I have not hitherto been able to learn ; but a native of Mecca , whom I had occasion to converse with this summer , assured me , that he himself had been inoculated in that city .
It has already been mentioned , that the Turks at Bagdat and Mousul make no scruple to inoculate their children .
I have seen also some Turkish strangers here , who had been inoculated at Erzeroon .
Hence it is probable that the Turks , in other parts of the Ottoman empire , do not merely , as fatalists , reject inoculation ; but that other considerations , which have influence in countries where fatalists are ridiculed or anathematized , concur likewise in Turky , to oppose the reception of a practice so beneficial to mankind .
The child of a Bashaw here , was by my advice inoculated about eight years ago ; but that is the only instance I have known among the Turks at Aleppo .
The Jews at this place absolutely reject inoculation ; partly from scruples of a religious kind , and partly from the distrust of its success .
At Bagdat , Bassora , and in Palestine , having acquired a more favourable opinion of an operation which they see so often performed with success , they have got the better of other scruples , and join in the practice with their neighbours .
I have several times conversed on this subject with the Mufti here , as also with some of the Rabbis ; but the theology of both was too abstruse for me : their arguments , so far as I was able to comprehend them , seemed to be no less cogent against all chirurgical operations , which were attended with any degree of danger to life , than against inoculation .
In the different countries above-mentioned , inoculation is performed nearly in the same manner .
The Arabs affirmed , that the punctures might be made indifferently in any fleshy part : those I have had occasion to examine , have all ( a very few excepted ) had the mark between the thumb and the forefinger .
Some of the Georgians had been inoculated in the same part , but most of them on the fore-arm .
Of the Armenians some had been inoculated in both thighs ; but the greatest part ( like the Arabs ) bore the marks upon the hand .
Some of the Georgian women remembered , that rags of a red colour were chosen in preference for the binding up the arm , a circumstance of which I have been able to discover no trace among the Arabs .
Buying the small pox , is likewise the name universally applied to the method of procuring the disease .
There are , it is true , other terms made use of both in the Arabic and Turkish Languages ; and at this place , it is principally known to the Christians by the name of inoculation .
From the sameness of the name , as well as from the little diversity observable in the manner of performing the operation , it is probable the practice of inoculation in these countries was originally derived from the same source : and that it is of considerable antiquity , can hardly be doubted , if we consider the large extent of country over which it is found to have spread , and the obstacles it must have met with in a progress through various nations , of which some are separated by polity as well as religion , while others , peculiarly tenacious of their own customs , are little disposed to admit those of strangers .
That no mention is made of inoculation by Rhazes , Avicenna , or any other of the ancient Arabian medical writers known in Europe , is , I believe , in general supposed ; and I am assured by the native physicians here , that nothing is to be found regarding it , in any of a more modern date .
Some learned Turkish friends here , some time ago were prevailed on at my request to make enquiry , but have not hitherto been able to discover any thing concerning inoculation ; although they searched not only the medical writers , but also the historians , and some of the poets .
It appears from accounts communicated to the Royal Society , in the year 1723 , by Doctor Williams and Mr. Wright , that inoculation had been known in certain parts of Wales so far back as the last century ; and it is remarkable , that it there bore the same name , by which it is most generally known to the Arabs .
I think it has also been discovered to be an ancient practice among the vulgar in different parts of the continent .
If inoculation was really known so long ago in Europe , and the accounts of it till within these fifty or sixty years are found to be merely traditional , the silence of the Arabian writers , on a practice which probably was never adopted by their physicians , is the less to be wondered at .
What may perhaps appear more strange , is , that after the year 1720 , though the curiosity of the public has , at different times , been excited by the controversies relating to inoculation , the state of that practice in Syria , where there were so many European settlements , should have remained unknown both in England and in France , which probably was the case , as the advocates for inoculation have made no reference to it .
Whether before the account transmitted by Pylarini to the Royal Society , inoculation had not been mentioned by any of the travellers who had visited these countries , I do not presume to determine .
In the books I have had occasion to peruse , there is nothing to be found on the subject .
Among the travellers the most likely to have mentioned it was Rauwolf : yet , however rational it may be to think that a practice of such a kind , had it then prevailed , could hardly have escaped the notice of so diligent an observer , it would be rash to infer from his silence that it was not known to the Arabs in the sixteenth century .
The justly celebrated French botanist is equally silent , though in the beginning of the present century he visited several places where inoculation was undoubtedly at that time both known and practised .
Having related in what manner I came to learn inoculation was known to the Arabs , I can arrogate no merit in the discovery ; nor would I be thought to insinuate any reflection on the accuracy of the indefatigable M. Tournefort , to whose labours the curious stand so much indebted .
Customs the most common , in distant countries , are often of all others the least apt to attract the observation of travellers , who , engaged in other pursuit , must be indebted to accident for the knowledge of such things , as the natives seldom talk of , from the belief that they are known to all the world .
This consideration may , in some measure , account for inoculation having been over-looked by those who have transiently passed through these countries ; and is all we can offer as an apology , for the having remained so long unacquainted with a fact in medical history , in a situation where we both had so many opportunities of information .
I am , Dear brother , Most affectionately yours , Aleppo , Nov. 26 , P. Russel .
1767 .

