Received January 18 , 1768 .
IX .
An Investigation of the Difference between the present Temperature of the Air in Italy and some other Countries , and what it was Seventeen Centuries ago : In a Letter to William Watson M. D. F. R. S. by the Honourable Daines Barrington F. R. S. Dear Sir , I Troubled you lately to procure from your Son Mr. Watson , who is now in Italy , some answers to certain queries with regard to the temperature of the season which commonly prevails there at present , and particularly whether the rivers of that country have been remembered to have had their surface frozen over .
Read March 3 , 1768 .
I have often put the same question to many of those who have made the tour of Europe , and have always been answered in the negative : as most Englishmen however travel before they pay attention to facts of this sort , I was desirous of procuring information from those whose observations might be more depended upon .
I have long entertained a notion that the seasons are become infinitely more mild in the Northern latitudes than they were 16 or 17 centuries ago ; and from this it hath happened that many passages in the classical writers descriptive of the Severity of the climates , have struck me more than they would perhaps a common reader .
It will be immediately seen that the proofs of this assertion must depend upon accounts of the weather , and it 's effects in places , the situation of which we know with some precision , and which may be compared with the common meteorological observations in the same latitudes and spots at present .
If this same question should be agitated two thousand years hence , it might receive an absolute demonstration ; as a journal of the changes in a well-constructed thermometer would show the temperature which prevailed in any particular place , during the present century .
No such accuracy can be expected from any passages in the classical writers ; but in order to state the alteration which may have happened in so long a course of years , the most proper method seems to be to compare their accounts with those of more modern travellers , who have equally wanted the assistance of a thermometer for their observations .
I shall for several reasons chiefly rely upon many of Ovid 's letters from Pontus ( though he was not only a poet , but a writer of most glowing fancy , and imagination ) , in which he describes the effects of cold at Thomos * during his seven years residence there , and afterwards contrast this description with that of later travellers .
* It is so called by Ovid , who resided there so long and understood the language of that country .
It was however likewise styled Tomis and Tomi , the latter of which seems to have been the more general appellation , as the adjective formed from it is Tomitanus .
Besides this , Ferrarius supposes it to be the same with the modern Temisware , most evidently taken from the ancient name in the time of Ovid .
Ovid was born at Sulmo in Italy , about ninety Roman miles S. W. from the capital : Millia qui decies distat ab urbe novem .
' ' He afterwards resided chiefly at Rome , and was there at the time he received the Emperor 's orders for his immediate banishment : I shall therefore consider him as then leaving the 42d degree of Northern latitude , the climate in which he was born , and continued to live .
He was thence removed to Tomos , which Dr. Wells , in his maps of ancient geography , places only in the 44th degree of Northern latitude : the change was therefore only of two degrees , and yet Ovid immediately describes the winter of Hudson 's bay .
But , before I particularise any of the passages which prove the intenseness of the cold , which he there experienced , it may be objected that no credit is to be given to a melancholy poet , of a warm imagination and too exquisite feelings .
This argument , I admit , would have great weight , if he only complained of the excessive and intolerable cold which prevailed .
The maxim of law , however , holds equally in natural philosophy * ` ` that he who means to impose or misrepresent never deals in particular facts , ' ' especially such as admit of an immediate contradiction , and in which he could not himself be deceived .
He saw with his own eyes the Euxine sea covered with ice : Vix equidem credar , sed cum sint praemia falsi Nulla , ratam testis debet habere fidem : Vidimus ingentem glacie consistere Pontum .
' ' Lib. III .
El .
10 .
* ` ` Fraus versatur in generalibus .
' ' But if you will not credit what he saw , he asterwards mentions walking upon this ice : Nec vidisse sat est , udum calcavimus aequor ; Undaque , non udo sub pede , summa fuit .
' ' The sea thus frozen , not only bore Ovid who hath described himself to be very light and agile , but oxen and carriages passed over it : Perque novos pontes , subter labentibus undis , Ducunt Sarmatici barbara plaustra boves .
' Lib. III .
El .
10 .
When the poor banished poet , during this rigorous weather , wanted some generous wine to warm himself , it was presented to him in a state of congelation : Udaque consistunt formam servantia testae Vina , nec hausta meri , sed data frusta , bibunt .
' ' This effect of cold was not experienced in London , situated in the 52d degree of Northern latitude , during the great frost in 1740 .
Add to these proofs , that what he here mentions is not the effect of one particular hard and severe winter ; he complains from year to year of nearly the same circumstances : Ut sumus in Ponto ter frigore constitit Ister , Facta est Euxini dura ter unda maris .
' ' Lib. I. El .
10 .
The snow likewise in many places never dissolved during the summer : Quaeque nec host fero , nec nive terra cares .
' ' Frigore perpetuo Sarmatis ora riget .
' ' Et solet in multis bima manner locis .
' ' I think therefore that what I have presumed to conjecture , may be rested upon the single testimony of Ovid ; but , as there is with some so strong prejudice against facts from such a quarter , I shall endeavour to corroborate this authority , by descriptions of the same country , which we find in other writers of those centuries .
His contemporary Virgil speaks thus of the effects of cold in the same latitude : Caeduntque securibus humida vina , Stiriaque impexis induruit horrida barbis .
' ' Georg .
Lib. III .
l. 349 .
&amp; seq. He likewise asserts that the snow .
-Septem assurgit in ulnas .
' ' Virgil indeed is also unfortunately a poet ; but his Georgics are perpetually relied upon as authority , not only by Pliny , but the later writers on husbandry .
Such credit is given to our own great descriptive poet Thomson , that the compilers of the Encyclopedie have almost entirely translated his Seasons , under the article Zone : nor is there perhaps a circumstance mentioned throughout those poems , which the most scrupulous , and minute naturalist may not rely upon .
I shall just mention the authority of one more poet , as he is scarcely more than a metrical geographer : Dionysius , in describing the same country , speaks thus of the snow 's never melting : ~ ~ ~ , 1 .
668 .
I shall close these corroborating proofs of the cold which was experienced at Tomos , by a passage from another geographer , who is sufficiently prosaic not to admit of any objection , to his testimony , on account of a too lively imagination : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ .
Strabo , L. 7 .
Thus is Ovid supported in that very material and striking fact of the ice being commonly strong enough to bear carriages .
It now remains to compare this account of the severity of the cold at Tomos , with that of more modern travellers , who have either been at the same place during the winter , or passed not very far distant .
Rubruquis , Marco Polo , Jean du Plan , Carpin , and Mandeville , were all of them on the borders of the Euxine Sea , and proceeded many degrees Northward ; and yet we do not hear of any complaint with regard to the cold .
Busbequius travelled from Buda to Constantinople , in the midst of winter ; nor does he mention any inconvenience , or interruption , from frost or snow .
If it be said that his way did not lye through Tomos ( or Temesware ) , to this it may be answered , that he crossed the same latitudes ; to which it may be added , that there was no Euxine Sea to mitigate the severity of the cold .
I must likewise here make another observation , that it does not appear either from Ovid , who is so very minute in every particular relative to this country , or from any other traveller , that there are high mountains in the neighbourhood of Tomos .
Tournefort was on the Black Sea , in the beginning of April , and dwells much upon the very fine weather during the time he continued upon it .
He observes , however , that , in the time of Constantine , the straight opposite to Byzantium was frozen over ; and that in the year 401 the Euxine Sea was covered with ice , for twenty days together .
These facts , therefore , struck him , as extraordinary .
Mottraye was in Crim Tartary , in the year 1711 , during the months of November and December ; who is also entirely silent , with regard to any uncommon effects of cold .
These are all the travellers , whose works I have looked into , or could procure on this occasion .
I do not take upon myself to say , that there may not be others , which have escaped me ; but I should not suppose the number to be great , as the Euxine Sea , and its neighbourhood , neither answers to the European traveller , in point of curiosity or commerce .
I have said in the outset , that I have some particular reasons , for fixing chiefly on Tomos , to make this comparison ; which arises from the country being precisely in the same state that it was in the time of Ovid ; this entirely excludes the common observation , that the cultivation of a country will render the climate more temperate .
We will now leave Tomos , and compare the accounts of the weather in Italy , with those of the present times : it being first premised , that the country was better cultivated , in the Augustan age , than it is now , which should consequently have made the temperature of the air more warm than it is now experienced to be .
The queries proposed to your son Mr. Watson relate to this comparison , and have occasioned my troubling you with this length of letter , since I have within these few days been fortunate enough to procure , through other hands , the information I could have wished on this head .
I shall begin with some passages from Virgil 's Georgics , having already attempted to show that no authority can be more relied upon .
This most excellent husbandman is constantly advising precautions against snow and ice in the management of cattle ; and he may be generally supposed to give these directions for the neighbourhood of Naples * , or Mantua his native country , where he does not evidently from the context mean some other parts of Italy : Et multa duram stipula , filicumque maniplis Sternere subter humum , glacies no frigida laedat Molle pecus .
' ' Lib. III .
l. 297 .
This relates to sheep ; but that hardy animal the goat wanted the same attention during the winter : Ergo omno studio , glaciem , ventosque nivales Avertes .
' ' Lib. III .
l. 317 .
Speaking afterwards of Calabria , the most Southern part of Italy , he expresses himself , with regard to the rivers being frozen , as what was commonly to be expected : Et cum tristis hyems etiamnum frigore saxa Solveret , &amp; glacie cursus fraenaret aquarum + .
' ' * ` ` Illo Virgilium me tempore dulcis alebat Parthenope , studiis florentem ignobilis oti .
' ' + It appears also by the sixth Satire of Juvenal , that the Tiber 's being commonly frozen in winter supplied the ladies of Rome with a very extraordinary instance of implicit deference to the commands of the Egyptian priests : Hybernum fracta glacie descendet in amnem , Ter matutino Tiberi mergetur- ' ' Pliny 's favourite villa of Laurentinum was situated near the mouth of the same river ; and , in the very minute description of its beauties and conveniences , he dwells much more upon the exposition of different parts of it to the warmth of the sun , I am ashamed to be obliged to state so many authorities ; but , as the proof entirely arises from many such concurrent passages , I shall now support the testimony of Virgil by that of two naturalists , who were either Italians , or resided in Italy .
Pliny , in a chapter , De natura caeli and arbores , and speaking of Italian trees , says , ` ` Alioqui arborum frugumque communia sunt , nives diutinas sedered .
' ' Lib. XVII .
cap. 2 .
But perhaps the strongest proof of that very remarkable fact , the Italian rivers being constantly frozen over , is to be collected from a chapter in AElian , which consists entirely of instructions how to catch eels , whilst the water is covered with ice : to this , without troubling you with a long citation , I shall barely refer .
( See Lib. XIV .
de Animal .
cap. 29 .
) Now , if we may believe the concurrent accounts of modern travellers , it would be almost as ridiculous to advise a method of catching fish in the rivers of Italy , which depended entirely upon their commonly being frozen over , as it would be to give such directions to an inhabitant of Jamaica .
I likewise cannot find that the precautions , which Virgil gives in his Georgics , against the damage which sheep and goats might receive from the snow and frost , are now necessary ; and both these animals are known to stand the severest winters of the Highthan its coolness , which is the circumstance most attended to , even in our northern climate .
He also mentions , that the situation was not warm enough either for olives or mirtle ; and that the laurus ( which , whether it be the bay or laurel , bears our climate , except in seasons of extraordinary severity ) would not then frequently stand the whole winter , neither at Laurentinum , nor near the town of Rome .
lands of Scotland , conceived to be in Virgil 's time almost the ultima Thule .
I do not pretend however to assert from this , that snow does not lye upon the Alps and Apennines , which arises from their very considerable height , nor that some waters on the tops of such mountains , or perhaps nearly under them , may not be frozen , especially when they are at a great distance from the sea .
We shall find however that the climate hath likewise , upon these very summits , become proportionably mild with that of the more level countries .
This receives a very clear and satisfactory proof , from the difficulties which those formerly encountered who passed the Alps .
Every line , almost , of both Livy 's and Polybius 's description of Annibal 's passage , makes mention of frost and ice ; we know that these mountains have been easily crossed since by armies , from the time of Francis the first , to the war of 1743 .
They are likewise passed sometimes even by consumptive travellers during the winter .
It is now time , perhaps , to release you from this very long dissertation ; on a point , however , which seems to be of some curiosity and importance .
I am , Dear Sir , Your most faithful , humble servant , Daines Barrington .

