Received December 20 , 1767 .
V. Observations on the Bones , commonly supposed to be Elephants Bones , which have been found near the River Ohio in America : By William Hunter , M. D. F. R. S. NATURALIST S , even those of our own times , have entertained very different opinions concerning fossil ivory , and the large teeth and bones , which have been dug up in great numbers in various parts of the world .
Read February 25 , 1768 .
At first , some thought them animal substances , and others mineral .
When only a certain number of observations had been collected , these substances were determined to be mineral : but , the subject having been more carefully examined , they were found certainly to be parts of animals .
After this point was settled , a dispute arose , to what animal they belonged .
The more general opinion was , that they were bones of the elephant ; and the great similitude of the fossil tusks to the real elephants teeth gave this opinion considerable credit .
It was liable however to great objections : the bones were observed to be larger than those of the elephant ; and it was thought strange that elephants should have been formerly so numerous in western countries , where they are no longer natives , and in cold countries , Siberia particularly , where they cannot now live .
We had information from Muscovy , that the inhabitants of Siberia believed them to be the bones of the mammouth , an animal of which they told and believed strange stories .
But modern philosophers have held the mammouth to be as fabulous as the centaur .
Of late years the same sort of tusks and teeth , with some other large bones , have been found , in considerable numbers , near the banks of the Ohio , in North America .
The French Academicians became possessed of some specimens of them ; and having compared them with the bones of real elephants , and with those which had been brought to France from Siberia , and with similar bones found in various other parts , determined , with an appearance of probability on their side , that they were elephants bones .
Monsieur Buffon gives us the following account of this decision a : ` ` All this put together , leaves us no longer any room to doubt , that those tusks ( defenses ) , and those large bones ( ossemens ) , are truly the tusks and bones of the elephant .
M. Sloane had said this , but had not proved it .
M. Gmelin has likewise said so , and more positively ; a ` ` Tous cela reuni , fait que nous no doutons plus que ces defenses &amp; ces ossemens no soient en effet des defenses &amp; des ossemens d'elephant .
M. Sloane l'avoit dit , mais no l'avoit pas prouve .
M. Gmelin l'a dit encore plus affirmativement , &amp; il nous a donne sir cela des faits curieux ; mais M. Daubenton nous paroit etre le premier , qui ait mis la chose horse de doute , par des mesures precises , des comparaisons exactes , &amp; des raisons fondees sir les grandes connoissances qu'il s'est acquises dans la science de l'anatomie comparee .
' ' Hist. Naturelle , Tom. XI .
p. 87 .
and he has given us some curious facts concerning this question ; but M. Daubenton appears to us to be the first who has put the matter beyond doubt , by accurate measures , by exact comparisons , and by reasons founded upon the great knowledge which he has acquired in the science of comparative anatomy .
' ' From the first time that I learned this part of natural knowledge , it appeared to me to be very curious and interesting ; inasmuch as it seemed to concur with many other phenomenon , in proving , that in former times some astonishing change must have happened to this terraqueous globe ; that the highest mountains , in most countries now known , must have lain for many ages in the bottom of the sea ; and that this earth must have been so changed with respect to climates , that countries , which are now intensely cold , must have been formerly inhabited by animals which are now confined to the warm climates .
Some time in the last spring , having been informed that a considerable quantity of elephants teeth had been brought to the Tower , from America ; and being desirous of procuring some information concerning them , I waited upon Mr. Bodington , to know the particulars , and to beg leave to examine them .
He obligingly gave me a verbal account of their having been brought from the banks of the Ohio ; and on the following day sent me one tusk , and one grinder , as specimens for my examination .
The tusk , indeed , seemed so like that of an elephant , that there appeared no room for doubt .
I showed it to my brother , and he thought so too : but , being particularly conversant with comparative anatomy , at the first sight he told me that the grinder was certainly not an elephant 's .
From the form of the knobs on the body of the grinder , and from the disposition of the enamel , which makes a crust on the outside only of the tooth , as in a human grinder , he was convinced that the animal was either carnivorous , or of a mixed kind .
This made me think that the tusk itself was not a real elephant 's tooth : for Mr. Bodington had told me , that there were many grinders , as well as tusks , and that they were all similar to those specimens which he had sent to me .
And some time after , when I went to the Tower , and examined the whole collection which had been sent over from the Ohio , I saw that the grinders were all of the same kind .
I examined two elephants jaws in my brother 's collection : I examined the tusks and grinders of the Queen 's two elephants : and I examined a great number of African elephants teeth at a warehouse .
From all these observations I was convinced that the grinder tooth , brought from the Ohio , was not that of an elephant ; but of some carnivorous animal , larger than an ordinary elephant : and I could not doubt that the tusk belonged to the same animal .
The only difference that I could observe between it and a real elephant 's tusk was , that it was more twisted , or had more of the spiral curve , than any of the elephants teeth which I had seen .
Some time after this , Dr. Franklin received a large box of the same sort of bones from the Ohio , by the way of Philadelphia .
He informed me of this , and told me likewise that another large box of those bones was sent to the Earl of Shelburne , one of his Majesty 's secretaries of state .
I waited upon Dr. Franklin , with some other friends , and found the bones to be exactly such as I had seen ; and was , therefore , confirmed in my former opinion .
Then I waited upon Lord Shelburne , and was permitted to examine the bones which he had received .
Besides the tusks and grinders , which were all such as I had seen , and still served to confirm me in my opinion , there was the half of the lower jaw of the animal , with one large grinder still fixed in it .
This jawbone was so different from that of an elephant , both in form and in size , and corresponded so exactly with the other bones , and with my supposition , that I was now fully convinced , that the supposed American elephant was an animal of another species , a pseudelephant , or animal incognitum , which naturalists were unacquainted with .
I imagined farther , that this animal incognitum would prove to be the supposed elephant of Siberia , and other parts of Europe ; and that the real elephant would be found to have been in all ages a native of Asia and Africa only .
The Earl of Shelburne , from his love of natural knowledge , showed a desire that the enquiry might be carried on ; and did me the honour to offer his assistance in transmitting orders to America , for procuring farther information about this matter .
In consequence of this generous offer , I proposed that his lordship should send the following questions and orders , to any person in America , whom his lordship might think the best qualified for conducting such business .
Queries and orders concerning the bones , called elephants bones , found in the marsh , called the Salt-Lick , near the River Ohio .
I. Do those bones appear to have lain upon the surface of the earth from the first ?
Or , II .
Do they seem to have been originally at some depth in the earth , and to have been afterwards exposed by the earth 's falling away , or by its being washed away by floods , &amp;c. ?
III .
How far is that part of the marsh from the river ?
How high above the common surface of the water of the river ?
And does it appear probable , from the level and face of that marsh , that in former times the river may have run where the bones are ?
IV .
How many elephants skeletons have been found , as far as may be collected from the number of tusks , or other marks ?
and at what distance from one another ?
V. To send over , if possible , a whole head , or the most entire parts of a head , especially of the upper jaw ; and a foot , or the small bones of it , if they can be distinguished ; and any bones which have those parts pretty entire which once made a joint .
VI .
To make correct drawings of any of the bones which are pretty entire , if , on account of their size , or tenderness , they cannot be sent over to England .
VII .
If the bones do not lie in blended heaps , but those of one single animal all together , and at some little distance from others , it might be of service towards ascertaining the species of this animal , to expose or uncover one complete set of bones , without moving any one of them from its place ; and to make a general drawing of the whole , as they appear in that situation ; and to send as many of them as are tolerably perfect over to England , with that drawing .
Lord Shelburne was pleased to take the care of this proposal upon himself ; and in proper time will probably receive such information as may be satisfactory .
I thought it would be adviseable , in the mean time , to collect all the information I could upon this subject ; and to lay the result of such enquiries before this Society : that those who may have better opportunities might be invited to the subject , and no longer leave so capital an article of natural history uncertain .
I examined all the fossil teeth , as they are called , in the Musaeum of this Society , and the head and teeth of an hippopotamus .
Then , with Dr. Knight first , and a second time with Dr. Solander , I examined all the fossil teeth , and all the jaw-bones , and teeth of elephants , and hippopotami , and other large animals , in the British Musaeum ; and some likewise in private collections .
In making this search , I met with grinders of the incognitum that were found in the Brazils and Lima , as well as in different parts of Europe .
At this time Lord Shelburne presented the largest of the American tusks , and the jaw-bone , and some grinders , to the British Musaeum ; and his Lordship did me the honour to send me the smaller tusk , and two grinders .
I went to four of the principal workers and dealers in ivory , with whom I saw and examined many hundreds of elephants teeth .
Though they all assured me , that the real elephants teeth have often a spiral twist , like a cow 's horn ; they could not show me one tooth so twisted , in all their collections , at the time when I visited them .
Three of them did me the favour to come to my house ; and they gave it as their opinion , that my two American tusks were genuine elephants teeth .
One of them was even positive that they were African teeth .
Another worker in ivory cut through that tusk which Lord Shelburne gave me .
It proved to be sound on the inside .
He assured me , that it was true elephantine ivory ; and that workers in ivory could readily distinguish the genuine , by its grain and texture , from all other bony substances whatever .
He polished it : we compared it with other pieces of genuine ivory ; and indeed they appeared to be perfectly similar .
His opinion was afterwards confirmed by another experienced worker in ivory .
Yet their opinion , and what I saw with my own eyes , convinced me of this fact only , viz. that true or genuine ivory is the production of two different animals ; and not of the elephant alone .
Having thus collected all the materials to which I could have access , I carefully read what the French Academicians Messrs. Buffon and Daubenton have written on this question , in the Histoire Naturelle , Tom. XI .
p. 86 .
&amp;c. and p. 147 .
&amp;c. Tom. XII .
p. 63 .
; and Memoires de l'Acad .
Roy .
des Sc. Ann. 1762 .
p. 206 .
&amp;c. But , instead of meeting with facts which could disprove my opinion , I found observations and arguments which confirm it .
One very material fact , which Mr. Daubenton furnishes in support of my hypothesis , is the comparison of the American thigh-bone , with that of a real elephant ; both of which he has represented in figures , which appear to be done with accuracy .
To me it seems most evident , that they are bones of two distinct species .
The vast disproportional thickness of the American bone , compared with that of the elephant , is surely more than we can attribute to the different proportions of bones , in the same species , which arise from age , sex , or climate .
But Mr. Daubenton , to support his hypothesis , that the American femur is elephantine , is obliged to refer the great disproportion in thickness to the causes above-mentioned ; and he affirms that in all other circumstances they are exactly alike .
Now , to my eye , there is nothing more evident , than that the two femora differ widely in the shape and proportion of the head ; in the length and direction of the neck ; and in the figure and direction of the great trochanter : so that they have many characters , which prove their belonging to animals of different species .
In order to prove to the satisfaction of the society , that the incognitum of America is of a very different species from the elephant , I have added three drawings of the jaw-bone of that animal ; which the curators of the British Musaeum were pleased to give me leave to take , and which Mr. Rymsdyk executed with a most scrupulous exactness : and that the comparison Philos. Trans. Vol. LVIII .
TAB. IV .
p.43 .
II .
Fig. I. IV .
III .
VI .
V. parison might be made with ease , I have added three similar drawings , taken from the largest of the two full-grown Elephants jaws which were in my brother 's collection ; executed with the same care , by the same artist ; and drawn to the same scale , nine inches in the real object making one in the figure .
TAB. IV .
Fig. I. An outside view of the half of the lower jaw of the American incognitum , which the Earl of Shelburne deposited in the British Musaeum .
From the top of the condyle to the anterior extremity , the bone measured , in a straight line , thirty five inches : the basis alone , in a straight line , two feet and four inches .
Fig. II .
The same view of the same bone in a full-grown Elephant , drawn to the same scale .
Whoever will take the pains to compare these two figures , with a critical eye , will see that they differ so very much , not only in size , but in their general character , and in the particular parts and features , that he cannot entertain a doubt of their being the jaws of two very different animals .
Fig. III .
A view of the inside of the same jaw-bone of the incognitum .
Fig. IV .
A view of the inside of the same jaw-bone of the Elephant .
In comparing these two views , the difference if possible is still more manifest .
Fig. V. A view from above of the jaw of the incognitum .
Fig. VI .
The same view of the Elephant 's jawbone .
It may now be fairly presumed that the American bones are proved to be certainly not elephantine : and whoever is of that opinion , will naturally suspect that the Siberian bones are of the same kind .
I imagine that it will be found , upon strict enquiry , to be so .
But , as I have not the necessary materials for discussing this question at present , I shall only state a few facts , to show that there is some ground for the opinion .
1 .
All accounts , and particularly those of Mess .
Gmelin , Buffon , and Daubenton , say that the bones found in Siberia are larger than the bones of common Elephants .
This would make us inclined to suspect that they were not Elephants bones , but that they were of the Incognitum .
2 .
The Siberian femur , as represented by Monsieur Daubenton , is very much like the American femur in size , shape , and proportions .
This circumstance appears to be almost a demonstration , as we have before proved , that the American femur is not that of an Elephant .
And in this argument , we have even the weight of Monsieur Daubenton 's opinion in our favour .
For he ( page 211 .
) taking it for granted that the Siberian femur was undoubtedly elephantine , reasons from the likeness in size , shape and proportions , that the American femur is so .
Now , as we have shown that the American femur is not elephantine , his proof taken from the size , shape , and proportions of the two bones , must serve to convince us that the Siberian thigh-bone is not of the Elephant , but of the incognitum .
3 .
Monsieur Daubenton found a difference between the temporal bone brought from Siberia , and that of an Elephant .
This likewise is an argument in favour of our supposition .
4 .
The supposed Elephant 's tusk , which was brought from Siberia by Mr. Bell , and presented to Sir Hans Sloane , and of which we have a description and figure in the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences at Paris ( An. 1727 .
page 309 ) , is evidently twisted like the tusk of the incognitum , and not at all like any Elephant 's tusk which I have ever seen .
This proof will have ~considerable weight with those who will take the trouble to examine that tusk in the British Musaeum .
In the last place , it may be observed , that as the incognitum of America has been proved to have been an animal different from the Elephant , and probably the same as the Mammouth of Siberia ; and as grinder teeth like those of America have been dug up in various other parts of the world ; it should seem to follow , that the incognitum in former times has been a very general inhabitant of the globe .
And if this animal was indeed carnivorous , which I believe cannot be doubted , though we may as philosophers regret it , as men we cannot but thank Heaven that its whole generation is probably extinct .

