ERRAT A. P. 7 .
l. 10 .
for confusion read concussion .
P. 28 .
l. 8 for Q3 X Q2 read q3 X Q2 .
P. 29 .
in the note , for 00379755 read 90379755 .
P. 30 .
l. 2 .
for hypothesis read hypotheses .
Ibid. throughout the table , for ~ read ~ .
P. 32 .
l. 16 .
for 1759 read 1761 .
P. 175 .
l. 15 .
for being any number read z being any number .
P. 176 .
l. 4 .
for that read to that .
P. 179 .
l. 18 .
for B/ 1/ 3 read B/ 2/ ~ P. 203 .
l. 24 .
for thing thing read thing .
Received November 26 , 1767 .
IV .
An Essay on the Connexion between the Parallaxes of the Sun and Moon ; their Densities ; and their disturbing Forces on the Ocean .
By Patrick Murdoch , D. D. F. R. S. INa letter to Mr. Reid , formerly presented to the Hon. Society , and printed in Vol. LIV .
Part II .
of the Transactions , mention was made of a rule which I had used for computing the sun 's parallax ; but as that rule , though it gave a solution near the truth , was in part founded on authority ( which , however respectable , ought to be cautiously admitted in such enquiries ) , I have considered the subject anew , upon such principles alone , as the established theory and the best observations furnished me .
And the result is now humbly submitted to the Society .
Read Feb. 18 , 1768 .
1 .
The length of a second-pendulum at the equator , and on a level with the sea , being 36 inches 7 1/ 10 lines , Paris measure , according to the accurate observations of M. de la Condamine * , that length * Journal du Voyage , &amp;c. p. 163 .
In the copy of this paper , which was read in the Society , the length of a second-pendulum , at the equator , had been computed from its length at London : but here it is taken from the immediate observations of a very able astronomer .
Some other small alterations have been made ; and the examples placed in a better order .
( properly corrected ) will , by the reasoning in the abovementioned letter , give the distance of a moon circulating round an unmovable earth , equal to 59.95792 semidiameters of the equator .
For the logarithm of this number , which is 1.7778438 , write l. Let L be the logarithm of some greater mean distance , inferred from observations of the moon 's parallax ; and if r be the natural number to the logarithm 3xL l , and M be taken equal to 1/ r 1 , the mass of the earth will be to that of the moon , as M to 1 .
Conversely , If M be any how determined , its equal 1/ r 1 , and r , with its logarithm 3xLl are known ; 1/ 3 of which is Ll to be added to l. For instance , if , with Sir Isaac Newton , we put M= 39.788 , the distance will be 60.4557 , the logarithm L being 1.7814372 .
II .
If , for each of these three , the moon 's mass , her accelerative force on the earth , and her distance from the earth 's centre , we write ( ~ = ) 1 : the accelerative force of the earth on the moon will be represented by M , the mass just now computed .
And if F is the sun 's accelerative force on the earth , x his distance in semidiameters of the lunar orbit , Q the ratio of a sidereal year to a periodic month ; we have ( by Cor. 2 .
Prop. 4 .
Princip .
I. ) F/ x = M/ Q2 ; a given ratio in given terms .
III .
The terms F , x , therefore , must involve a common factor ; by which being divided , the quote may be M/ Q2 .
And this might be obtained innumerable ways , were we to consider the ratio F/ x merely as an abstract quantity , altogether unrestricted : it were only putting Mn x Qp = F. And Q2 + p/ M 1n= x , or M1 n Qp = F , and Q2+ p/ M n= x : so as the sum of the indices of M should be unity , and the difference of those of Q should be 2 .
But though the quantities F , x , are as yet unknown , they are not for that indeterminate and variable , as such a liberty of substitution would import : and all substitutions which imply the contrary , all indices which the theory disowns , or which are inconsistent with observation , are to be rejected .
In a word , the indices , n , p , ought each of them to be unique , and determinate ( fine compare ) , * as the quantities F and x are in nature .
I take , therefore , p= 1 , and n= 1/ 2 ; that is , F=M 1/ 2 x Q , x= Q3/ M 1/ 2 .
See the examples in the table subjoined , upon different suppositions of the moon 's distance .
* See Neut .
Arith .
Universal .
in the Schol .
to Prob. xxiv .
The maxima and minima of variable quantities ; the coordinates belonging to a double point , or to a point of reflexion , or contrary flexure , rays of curvature , limits of ratios , &amp;c. All these are examples of the unique ; that is , of quantities in a state that is distinguished from and exclusive of all others .
IV .
The accelerative forces of two spherical bodies , A , B , upon a third C , are directly as their masses , and inversely as the squares of their central distances ST , LT , ( or of x and d ) : which may be thus expressed , F/ ~ = A/ B x d2/ x2 .
But the masses , A , B , being as their respective densities ( which call s , m ) , and the cubes of ( R , r ) , the semidiameters of the spheres conjunctly ; if we write for A/ B its equal , we have F/ ~ = s/ m xR 3/ r 3 x d2/ x2 .
Let the mass C be to B , as M to 1 ; and ( f ) its force on B , will be ~ M , or ~= f/ M , which gives M F/ f = s/ m x x/ d , and F/ f = s x/ M m d : supposing the apparent semidiameters of A and B to subtend the same angle at the centre of C , and thence R to be to r , as x to d. V. But if S G , the semidiameter of A , be to the supposed semidiameter S V , as q to 1 , then , E2 the SG V A L-N B C v T .
the density s remaining , the accelerative force of A ( proportional to its magnitude ) will be increased in the triplicate of that ratio , that is , we now have F/ f = q3 s/ M mX x , putting d= 1 .
And the three bodies , A , B , C , representing the sun , moon , and earth ; likewise Q being the ratio of the periods of the earth and moon , it is F/ f = x/ Q2 ( by the corollary quoted in Art .
II .
) .
Whence s/ m = M/ Q3 x Q2 .
VI .
This accelerative force of A remaining , imagine the semidiameter SG to be reduced to its former magnitude S V ; and the density of A will , at the same time , be increased to s1 = q3 X s , and s1/ m = M/ Q2 .
In which case , namely , when the apparent semidiameters of A and B ( the sun and moon ) are equal , their powers to raise a tide at v , a vertex of C , will be as the densities s1 , m * : that is , as M the ratio of the earth 's mass to the moon 's , and Q2 the duplicate ratio of the year and month .
Or thus : The distances of the bodies , A , B , from the third C , being very great , their powers to raise a tide at v , or their disturbing forces on the ocean , will be directly as their accelerative forces at the centre of C , and inversely as their distances from it : that is , writing a , b , for the disturbing forces respectively ; and for the sun 's distance in semidiameters of C , the Letter z , it will be a : b : : F/ z : ~/ d. * See the last page of Dr. Sanderson 's Fluxions : or the late ingenious T. Simpson 's Miscellaneous Tracts , p. 13 .
For , by the general law , a is to F , as the difference of the squares of z and z1 is to the square of z 1 ; that is , as 2z1 to z2 2z+ 1 .
And the same way b is to ~ , as 2d1 to d2 2d+ 1 ; whence , halving the antecedents , and retaining only z2 , d2 , in the consequents , we have the ratio of a to b , as above .
If the disturbing force of B is exerted at v1 , the opposite vertex of C , b will now be to ~ , as 2d+1 to d2 +2d+ 1 ; and , in strictness , we ought to take a mean value of b : but this may be neglected as inconsiderable .
Lastly , let the sun 's distance be again expressed in semidiameters of the lunar orbit ; that is , if for z we write d x , and unity for ~ , we have a : b : : F/ d x : 1/ d , or as M to Q2 , as before .
VII .
In Art .
V. it was found that m denoting the density of the moon , and s that of the sun , q3 being triple the ratio of the sun 's mean semidiameter to the moon 's * , then will m/ s = Q2 q3/ M. Whence it will easily follow , that the density of the earth is to that of the sun , as Q2 X S3 to P3 ; P being the moon 's horizontal parallax , and S the sun 's apparent semidiameter .
* In the Principia , the semidiameters are 16~ .
6~ , and 15~ .
381/ 4~ ; giving 0 0379755 for the logarithm of q3 .
Others take a few seconds from each ; which does not much alter the value of q2 .
VIII .
I have applied these rules ( as in the following Table ) to the principal hypothesis of the moon 's mean distance .
10 .
Supposing it of 60.24 ( from Dr. M. Stewart .
) 20 .
60.4 ( Cor. 7 .
Prop. 37 .
Princip .
III .
) 30 .
60.455 ( Neut .
M being 39.788 .
) ( As by Mr. Short 's calculations 40 .
60.493 from the transit of ~ .
) The Moon 's Mean Distance , being in Semidiameters of the Equator .
60.24 60.4 60.455 60.493 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' I Parall .
~ 57.4,17 56.551/ 15 56.52 56.49,88 ~ II .
Mass ~ 70.4225 44.823 39.788 36.9908 III .
~ dist. to ~ 284.723 356.885 378.293 392.854 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' IV .
Parall .
~ 12 1/ 37 9,58 9 .
1/ 2 8.69 ~ V. Dens .
~ 2,77 : 1 4,35 : 1 4,9 : 1 5,273 : 1 ~ VI .
Dens .
~ 1,449 : 1 0.9295 : 1 0.827 : 1 0.7707 : 1 ~ VII .
Dens .
~ 4.0128 : 1 4.045 : 1 4.0559 : 1 4.06375:1 ~ VIII .
Tides ~ 2.5379 : 1 3.9873 : 1 4.5544 : 1 4.8316 : 1 F. ~ on ~ IX .
F. ~ on ~ 1.593 : 1 1.9968 : 1 2.1194 : 1 2.1981 : 1 REMARK S. 1 .
If it should be thought that the reasoning in Art .
III .
rests too much upon a metaphysical principle of Leibnitz , and requires , if not an apology , at least a more formal proof : the ground of such reasoning , and its extensive use , may be more particularly explained on some other occasion .
Suffice it at present to add to the note on that article , That as the given factors ( Q and Q3 ) in F and x , may be joined with Mn , or with M1 n indifferently , the case is similar to that of an equal chance at play , for the stakes n and 1 n , where the just expectation of each gamester is 1/ 2 , whatever be the value of n. The fifth and sixth Propositions of Element I. scarce needed any other demonstration than , that it is manifestly impossible to assign any reason of inequality , of the angles in one of these theorems , and of the sides in the other .
In the following Proposition , where it is proved , that two lines being extended from the extremities of a right line , A B , to a point C , there is no other point on the same side of A B , to which lines from A and B equal to the former can be drawn : he who holds the contrary is supposed to fix upon that other point D ; but why D ?
rather than d , d ' , d ' ' , &amp;c. he is silent : and , therefore , I conclude , there is no such point different from C. And the like may be said of some other simple theorems , that are commonly demonstrated by showing the absurdity of asserting their contraries .
2 .
The title of this paper renders it almost needless to remind the reader , that the moon 's parallax is not here proposed as the properest medium for determining that of the sun .
Our data are still too uncertain for that purpose , scarce one of them having been determined to an unexceptionable precision ; and the numbers in the table show how much a small difference in the moon 's distance must affect the several conclusions .
It may be of use , however , to know in what manner those conclusions , as well as the quantities from which they derive * , stand related to one another .
For if , hereafter , the necessary data should be more exactly known , the calculus may be repeated ; and if the transit of Venus , which is to happen in 1769 , should confirm Mr. Short 's calculations from that of 1759 , we may thence conclude the true mean distance of the moon , better than in any other way .
3 .
In the mean time , if any person should have the curiosity to examine the numbers of the table , he will please to take notice : That , as no two measurements , nor any two lengths of a second-pendulum hitherto observed , make the earth of the same spheroid figure , I have retained for the ratio of its greatest and least diameters , that of 231 to 230 ; answering to the hypothesis of its uniform density : and have thence made a degree of the equator equal to 57200 French toises ~ .
* The connexions of F , x , Q , are manifest ; and the relation of M to Q2 is easily deduced from Prop. 59 .
Princip .
Book I. ~ This was computed upon the supposition , that a degree of the meridian at lat. 49~ 1/ 3 is 57183 toises : but if that degree is , by The measure of a second-pendulum , at the equator , I had from M. de la Condamine , as was said before : it was corrected for the centrifugal force , and the resistance of the air ; and the moon 's distance , as revolving round the earth at rest , was corrected for the sun 's disturbing force : which is done either by diminishing that distance in the subtriplicate ratio of 178725 to 177725 ; or by diminishing the length of the pendulum in the simple ratio of these numbers .
In this last correction I was favoured with the advice and assistance of the Rev. Mr. Price , and of the Astronomer Royal , FF .
R. S. a correction of M. Picart 's operations , found to be only 57075 toises ; the diameter of the equator here used ought to be diminished by about 18 10000th parts .

