Received November 16 , 1767 .
III .
An Essay on the Force of Percussion , by William Richardson , M. D. communicated by William Heberden , M. D. F. R. S. WHEN we consider the extraordinary advancement in natural philosophy , from the surprising discoveries of the great Sir Isaac Newton , and other ingenious men , who have followed his example ; it may afford matter of the greatest wonder , to find the most acute philosophers still contending , whether the force of percussion be in proportion to the velocity of bodies in motion , or the squares of those velocities .
Read Feb. 18 , 1768 .
Sentiments so opposite in their nature , and so strongly supported by their respective advocates , may well make a cautious person suspect , that nothing is to be discovered with certainty in the operations of nature .
In which opinion he may be the more confirmed from this consideration , that the present dispute is not about objects far removed from our observation , but such actions of bodies as do constantly occur to our senses , and which without difficulty may be reduced to experiment .
What then can be the reason , after such variety of experiments have been made , why this matter is not , before this time , brought to a decision ?
The fault cannot be in the experiments themselves , the chief of which have been often repeated , and that in the most accurate manner : it must , therefore , be in the use which has been made of them , in the groundless inferences which have been drawn from them .
Those who have wrote best on this subject ( whether in support of the velocities , or the squares of velocities ) seem to me to have inferred more from the principle they maintain than what they bring sufficient arguments to justify ; by which means they blend truth with error , and the more they endeavour to illustrate their respective doctrines , the more they render them perplexed and confused .
For the truth of what I have advanced , I appeal to the two following instances .
Those who maintain that the force of percussion is as the velocity of the striking bodies , when they account for the impressions made in soft bodies ( which are found , by experiment , to be as the squares of the velocities ) , inform us , that the time ought to be taken into the account ; which being as the velocity of the impinging body , the impression will of course be as the time into the velocity , or ( which is the same thing ) as the square of the velocity .
But this , in my mind , is to assert more than what can be clearly demonstrated : for as action and reaction are equal , the more forcibly one body acts upon another , the greater must be the resistance it meets with ; and whatever be the time of its acting , supposing its force to be given , the effect produced must still remain the same .
To which I must further add , that some of the most learned and zealous advocates for time being taken into the account , have not agreed among themselves whether it be in a direct or reciprocal proportion of the velocity a. Those who , on the contrary , insist that the force of percussion is in proportion to the squares of the velocity , finding from experiment that in soft bodies the velocity after percussion falls short of this estimate , would make us believe , that in compressing the parts of those bodies , a certain degree of force must necessarily be lost , which , being added to what remains after percussion , will sufficiently confirm the truth of their doctrine .
To this I reply , that the parts of soft bodies are , indeed , removed out of their places by the stroke , and that some motion is lost in the impinging body , being communicated to the parts of the soft body it strikes upon ; but these parts cannot lose their motion any other way , than by communicating it to other parts , or by the force accruing to the whole body .
How then are these different effects to be accounted for , and in what manner are they to be deduced from the same cause ?
This diversity of appearances , I have for some time suspected , might proceed from the nature of cohesion : that while the force of percussion produced an effect on the whole mass of matter which receives the stroke , in proportion to the velocity of the impinging body ; it might , at the a Dr. Pemberton , Philosophical Transactions , No 371 .
p. 57 .
Dr. Clarke , Philosophical Transactions , No 401 .
p. 382 .
same time , in separating the cohering parts from each other , produce an effect in proportion to the square of the velocity .
Into which way of thinking I was first led from the following observations ; that a chord , which would bear a very strong pull , might easily be broken by giving it a sudden jerk ; as also that the weight of a hammer did not contribute so much in driving a nail , as the quickness of the motion given it by the driver .
In order to make a further discovery , whether or no this my supposition was really founded in nature ; I determined first to make experiments on such soft bodies as have a considerable degree of cohesion ; and then to try those bodies , when dried and reduced to powder , and by that means deprived of their cohesion ; which experiments , when compared with each other , would , I flattered myself , give me an insight into this intricate affair , and at the same time disclose that beautiful simplicity , which nature observes in all her operations .
My apparatus for making the experiments consists of four balls exactly spherical , two iron branches , and a small lead cistern .
The balls are each of them two inches in diameter ; two are of brass , and two of box-wood ; one of each sort is solid , and the other hollow ; that which is hollow is only half the weight of the solid one , and may be opened by means of a screw in the middle .
The iron branches are to give the balls their proper directions ; they have each of them a small brass pulley in the fore part , and in the hind part a kind of hook , which fastens them to staples at different heights ; one of the branches is two inches long , and the other four inches , exclusive of pullies ; by which means the balls when let fall are directed to different parts of the surface they strike upon .
The lead cistern is of an oblong form , that the matter therein contained may , at the same time , receive two distinct impressions ; either when balls of different weight are let fall , or the same ball is let fall from different heights ; its length is six inches , its breadth four inches , and its depth two inches .
The matter I have found best suited to the purpose is stiff clay , tempered in such a manner as to be smooth and uniform , with the same reduced to powder , after having been baked in an oven , as also after having ( by a still stronger heat ) been converted into brick .
The cistern is by turns filled with these different materials , which are to be closely and uniformly pressed down , so as to leave the surface quite level : in effecting which , great caution is required , more particularly in regard to the powders ; as they will not distinctly retain the impressions , unless they have some small degree of moisture , or be very closely pressed down ; in both which cases they acquire such a degree of cohesion , as of course must render the experiments more or less imperfect .
Things being thus prepared , in order to try the necessary experiments , I fixed the staples , and by their means the branches , at the following heights , viz two feet , four feet , and eight feet ; the result of which experiments was as follows .
When the brass balls , in weight to each other as two to one , were let fall on tempered clay , from four feet and eight feet respectively , the impressions made were on various trials found to be equal .
When the wood balls , being to each other as two to one , were let fall from the same heights , on dried clay pulverised , that from four feet generally made the deeper impression .
When the wood balls were let fall from the same heights on brick-dust , that from four feet constantly made the deeper impression .
When the lighter brass ball was let fall on tempered clay , from two feet and eight feet , the impressions were to each other as one to four .
When the lighter wood ball was let fall on dried clay pulverised , from the same heights , the impressions were ( so far as the eye could judge ) nearly in the proportion of one to three .
When the same ball was let fall on brick-dust , from the like heights , the impressions were not much short of the proportion of one to two .
From these experiments it plainly appears : First , That the impressions made in soft clay are in proportion to the heights , from whence the balls are let fall , consequently as the squares of their respective velocities .
Secondly , That the impressions , in pulverised clay , recede considerably from that proportion , being as it were in the medium between the squares of the velocities and the velocities themselves .
Thirdly , That the impressions in brick-dust are nearly in a subduplicate proportion of the heights from whence the balls are let fall , consequently vary but little from the proportion of the velocities acquired .
Whence I should apprehend it clearly follows ; that the impressions made in soft bodies , by hard ones striking upon them , do vary from each other , according to the degree of cohesion in the respective soft bodies ; and that the impressions would be in exact proportion of the velocities , could their form be perfectly retained by bodies quite void of cohesion .
Nothing , however , being more evident to me than that actions ought to be measured by their effects , and at the same time fully depending on the accuracy of the experiments , I am determined to rest this important point entirely upon them .
Shall not , therefore , attempt any illustration in the mathematical way , lest , by too far indulging a favourite opinion , I should bewilder myself in intricate calculations .
Much less shall I endeavour to establish my doctrine on metaphysical principles , which seem to me in themselves too obscure , to throw any clear light on subjects of this nature .

