LIV .
A Letter from Mr. B. Wilson , F. R. S. and Member of the Royal Academy at Upsal , to Mr. AEpinus , Professor of Natural Philosophy in the Imperial Academy of Sciences at St. Petersburg , and Member of the Academies of Berlin , Stockholm , and Erfurth .
I Have not had the favour of hearing from you since I sent you some experiments upon Gems similar to those produced by the Tourmalin , which induced me to conclude , that the electric current moves always along the grain thereof .
It was the more agreeable to communicate these new experiments to you , because from the least hints the greatest discoveries have been made ; and what may we not expect from that curious observer of nature , who first discovered these extraordinary qualities in the Tourmalin , which have since excited the attention of so many Philosophers .
Read Dec. 23 , 1763 , and March 1764 .
Your treatise upon this stone , published in 1762 , seems to be the same you formerly mentioned in a letter to me .
The remarks at the end of that work interest me in a particular manner , as they contain objections to several parts of the letter to Dr. Heherden .
I am obliged therefore to say something in the defence of my own experiments and deductions , which I hope will merit your attention , and remove your difficulties .
In In repeating such of the experiments with the Tourmalin as were most proper to answer your objections , I accidentally observed an appearance which has given rise to some new experiments , very simple , and of great consequence in electric researches .
These discoveries you shall be acquainted with , before I conclude this letter , that I may have the pleasure of hearing your sentiments concerning them , the sooner .
I am glad to find we * agree in admitting what are called the two species of electricity , one whereof consists in the augmentation of the electric fluid , and the other in it 's diminution .
But still , notwithstanding the experiment made with the bent tube in order to determine that interesting question , you seem to doubt which of these is the plus , and which the minus electricity .
You say ~I have proved the opposition of the two species , by the knobs of light appearing at the upper * Mr. Wilson reconnoit de meme que moi , l'existence de deux especes d'electricite , dont l'une consiste dans l'augmentation , et l'autre dans la diminution , de la quantite naturelle du fluide electrique .
C'est un question qui doit interesser chaque physicien , de demeler , quelle de deux electricites , ou la vitree , ou la resineuse de Mr. du Fay , est la positive , et quelle en est la negative ?
Quant a moi j'ai declare , il ya long tems , dans mon Sermo de similitudine electricitatis et magnetismi , que je no connois aucune experience , propre a decider cette question .
Je suis maintenant encore du meme sentiment , car la belle experience de mylord Charles Cavendish , rapportee ici et perfectionee par Mr. Wilson , me semble laisser pareillement la chose indecise .
~ Quant a l'opposition des deux especes d'electricite , je conviens qu'elle est fort clairement prouvee par l'experience de Mr. Wilson , et par ce phenomene , que la lumiere electrique est beaucoup plus vive qu'ailleurs dans le vuide , aux surfaces superieures des colomnes du mercure , ( jusqu'a y former comme des boutons per surface of the quicksilver , when one electrifies with glass ; and at the under surface , when one electrifies with wax , or sulphur ; but that , in your opinion , is all which can be concluded from it .
You then declare , that was you disposed to argue against me , it would be in this manner .
` ` It is easy to de lumiere ) quand on electrise avec un tuyeau de verre ; et que ces boutons se trouvent au contraire aux surfaces inferieures du vif argent quand on se sert d'un baton de cire d'Espagne ou de souffre .
Mais selon moi c'est tout ce qu'on en peut conclure .
Voila comme je raisonnerois , si j'avois envy de disputer contre Mr. Wilson .
Il est facile de concevoir , que , quand un fluide ( et sir tout un fluide elastique , ou dont les parties se repoussent mutuellement ) sort d'un corps , le fluide , dis-je , doit etre plus dense proche de la surface d'ou il sort , que la , ou il trouve plus de liberte de se repandre .
La surface donc , proche de la quelle la lumiere electrique est la plus vive , doit etre celle , de la quelle sort le fluide , qui cause ces apparences lumineuses .
Ces raisonnemens , n'ont ils pas autant de probabilite , que ceux de Mr. Wilson ?
Mais no prouvent-ils pas directement le contraire de ce que Mr. Wilson a advance ?
No prouvent-ils pas , dis-je , que l'electricite resineuse est la meme que la positive , et la vitree la meme que la negative ?
Pour dire le vrai , le raisonnement dont je me suis servi , me semble presque avoir plus de vraisemblance , que celui de Mr. Wilson .
Il est incontestable , que la matiere electrique entre tres librement , et sans eprouver un resistance considerable dans les metaux et autres corps non electriques , comme je le prouverai clairement tout a l'heure .
Le raisonnement de Mr. Wilson semble , par consequent , etre fond sir un hypothese gratuitement admise , savoir , que la matiere electrique s'accumule a la surface du vif argent , parce qu'elle n'y peut entrer librement .
Je no pretends pourtant pas prouver par tout cela , qu'effectivement l'electricite resineuse soit la meme que la positive , et la vitree au contraire la meme que la negative .
Mon unique but estde fair comprendre , que cette hypothese est au moins aussi pro , bable , que celle , pour laquelle Mr. Wilson s'est declare .
conceive conceive that when an elastic fluid issues from a body ( as from the quicksilver in the bent tube ) it will be denser at the surface from whence it issues , than it is where it finds more liberty to expand itself .
And therefore the surface near which the electric light is the brightest , should be that from whence the fluid issues , which causes those luminous appearances .
' ' This reasoning appears entirely new to me , and I am at a loss to comprehend why an elastic fluid confined within a tube , whose sides are supposed parallel , will be denser at the surface of a body from whence it issues , than in any other part ; since its expansive force must in that case be limited by the sides thereof .
As you have not given any particular experiment to prove what you assert in this case , you will therefore give me leave to differ from you in opinion .
If , as you say , there is really more liberty for an elastic fluid to expand in any other part of the exhausted tube , than at the surface itself , you must produce some evidence in favour of that opinion , before it can be admitted .
On the other hand , I should have thought , if all resistance is supposed to be removed from within the tube , the liberty , for the fluid to expand itself , will be equal in every part ; reckoning from the surface of one column of quicksilver through the whole void , to the surface of the other column of quicksilver .
As I am for supporting this opinion , let us examine it more particularly , and attend only to the appearances which glass affords in certain circumstances : because when the direction of the fluid , Lll2 caused caused by glass , is once traced , that which is caused by wax , amber , or resin , follows of course .
The electric fluid , when it is emitted from any smooth surface of metal without edges , or angles , appears , in certain circumstances , to issue from all parts of that surface equally .
This fact , I apprehend , is so well established that it needs no further proof .
Now the column of quicksilver being confined by the sides of the glass , which are supposed parallel , the top of the quicksilver will answer to the smooth surface described .
The electric fluid therefore that is to pass from it , into the void space , which is of the same diameter with the column of quicksilver , will move forward within the hollow of the tube to the next column of quicksilver .
And since no resistance is supposed to be within any part of the vacuum , there can be no cause for any accumulation : consequently when the fluid is suffered to pass along the tube , the appearance ought to be the same at the surfaces , that it is in every part of the void space .
But by my experiment there is a greater quantity of light seen at the second surface of the quicksilver , than in any other part , ( when polished glass electrifies the first column ) and that this light which appears so dense , extends itself about one tenth of an inch from the surface .
Whereas the light extending all along the intermediate hollow of the tube , appears to be much thinner , and rarer , and of an uniform density .
I conclude therefore that this luminous accumulation at the second surface is caused by a resistance exerted at , or near , the surface of the quicksilver : when the electric fluid , issuing from the glass that electrifies it , is pushing forward to enter the second column of quicksilver .
At the time I related this experiment with the bent tube in the letter to Dr. Heberden , I omitted certain phenomenon , which attended the experiment , greatly favouring the doctrine here advanced .
If when glass is electrified , and applied to the first column , we suffer the electric fluid to pass along the tube in small quantities only , and at short intervals , little luminous streams will be seen to move from the first to the 2d column of quicksilver , and consequently from the glass .
The like appearances happen , but in a contrary direction , when resin or amber is made use of , and applied to the same column .
Glass therefore electrifies plus ; or fills bodies with more of this fluid than belongs to them naturally : and resin , &amp;c. vice versa .
When you say , your reasoning appears to have as much probability as mine , I believe you do not include your observation , that the electric fluid enters with great freedom , and without any considerable resistance , into metals and other non-electric bodies .
Because the words any considerable resistance , imply some resistance , which is all that is contended for : and a very small resistance will occasion very extraordinary appearances , as I shall be able to show by and by .
There is no occasion to trouble you with any further arguments to prove this resistance ; of which yourself seem to entertain no doubt ; and the accumulation caused by the resistance is evident .
In your second remark , respecting the impermeability of glass , you say you agree with Mr. Franklin * as to the * Je me tourne verse un autre objet , sir lequel , il me semble , que Mr. Wilson a eu envy de savoir mon sentiment .
C'est la question de l'impermeabilite du verre .
On peut bien savoir par mon livre : Tentamen Theoriae Electricitatis et Magnetismi , ce que j'en pens , et que bien que je tomb d'accord avec Mr. Francklin , de l'existence de cette impermeabilite , je differe pourtant beaucoup de lui , par rapport a plusieurs autres points .
Il no seroit donc pas a la verite necessaire , d'exposer ici de nouveau mon sentiment , neanmoins je me charge de ce travail , pour no laisser rien a desirer a ceux qui liront ce recueil .
Qu'on suspend un fil de fer ou d'archal , quelque long qu'il soit , a des fils de soye , et qu'on en electrise un bout par le moy en d'un tuyeau de verre , ou d'un baton de cire d'espagne .
Dans moins d'un clein d'oeil non seulement le bout qu'on electrise , devient electrique , mais aussi le fil entier le sera d'un bout a l'autre , et le sera partout egalement .
Qu'on touche apres l'un des bouts , et l'electricite fera detruite dans tout le fil , d'un bout a l'autre , avec la meme vitesse , qu'elle avoit ete produite .
Qu'on suspend au contraire de la meme facon un tube de verre bien sec , ou un cilindre de cire d'espagne ou de souffre , et qu'on le traite de la meme maniere .
Le success en sera tout a fait different .
Ce n'est pas le cilindre entier , qui devient alors electrique dans un instant , mais seulement un party de la longueur de quelques pouces , ou d'un pied tout au plus , acquiert cette force , et il faut travailler fort long tems , si on veut amener les choses , au point d'en rendre electrique un party d'une longueur un peu considerable .
Qu'on touche apres la party electrisee du tuyeau , et l'electricite no sera detruite , ni dans un instant , ni dans le tuyeau entier , comme dans l'experience precedente .
Au contraire , encore que l'endroit touche perde son electricite , il n'en sera de meme , des parties tout proches , qui conserveront plutot leur electricite pendant fort long tems .
J'en tire la conclusion : que la matiere electrique , traverse les metaux ou d'autres corps non electriques et se distribue en eux fort facilement et fort rapidiment , mais qu'au contraire elle pass par le verre , la cire d'espagne , et d'autres corps electriques par eux memes beaucoup plus difficilement et plus lentement .
Cette regle no doit the existence of this impermeability , though you differ from him in many other points : and refer to your Essay upon the Theory of magnetism and electricity .
You then relate two experiments , one with a wire , and the other with a glass tube , or cylinder of wax : and observe that the first may be easily electrified , and the latter also , though with great difficulty , to any considerable length .
You then draw this conclusion from the two experiments , that the electric matter pervades metals and other non-electric bodies , and expands itself in them with the greatest ease and rapidity .
But that on the contrary it passes through glass , wax , and other electric bodies , more slowly and with much greater difficulty .
This conclusion , instead of establishing the impermeability of glass , most evidently affirms the contrary : for though , according to your observation , the fluid passes more slowly and with much greater difficulty through glass than iron ; your admitting that it does pass at all through the glass , ends the dispute , as to the point of permeability : and at the same time establishes my doctrine of resistance ; at least in glass , and resinous substances .
In regard to my experiments upon the Tourmalin , you say * that the first and second correspond with your discoveries .
pas etre prite pour un hypothese .
C'est un loi , prise immediatement et d'und maniere incontestable , de l'experience .
Cette propriete des corps electriques par eux memes , est selon moi la meme que celle , que Francklin a appellee d'un autre nom , impermeabilite .
Au moins , je no fais consister l'impermeabilite en rien autre chose , qu'en cela .
* Je viens aux experiences de Mr. Wilson .
La premiere et la second s'accordent tout a fait avec mes decouvertes .
Il n'en discoveries ; but that those from the 3d to the 8th do not agree with your notions and experience : and then est pas de meme , de celles qui suivent , depuis la troisieme jusqu'a la huitieme , qui demandent d'etre discutees avec plus de soin .
J'ai etabli comme un loi constant , de l'electricite de la Tourmaline : Que cette pierre est toujours dans l'etat contraire ( c'est a dire , que son cote positif , est negativement electrique , et le cote negatif l'est positivement ) quand un de ses cotes , quel qu'il soi , , est plus chaud que l'autre ; et qu'elle no return dans son etat naturel , qu'apres que la chaleur s'est distribuee uniformement en elle .
Par les experiences de Mr. Wilson au contraire , il faut etablir un regle tout a fait different , savoir : Que la Toarmaline , quand elle chauffee inegalement , des deux cotes , a l'espece d'electricite , qui est naturelle au cote le plus chaud ( c'est a dire , que la Tourmaline est positivement electrique des deux cotes , quand c'est le cote positif , qui est le plus chaud ; et qu'elle l'est negativement .
quand c'est le cote negatif , qui est le plus chaud ) mais qu'elle return dans son etat naturel , quand la chaleur s'est repandue uniformement .
Cette regle no s'accorde en aucune facon avec celle que j'avois avancee .
Encore que je fusse tout a fait convaincu de la justesse de mes assertions , et de leur parfaite conformite avec l'experience , je no pouvois pourtant que fort difficilement me resoudre , a douter de l'exactitude des experiences faites par un aussi habile Observateur , que Mr. Wilson .
J'ai donc mieux aim supposer , qu'l y avoit , dans la maniere , dont Mr. Wilson et moi avions procede dans ces experiences , quelque difference , qui put etre la cause de la difference qui se trouve dans nos resultats .
Je croyois a la verite de trouver facilement un circonstance sir la quelle on put fonder quelque soupcon .
C'est que moi j'avois toujours pose la Tourmaline , ou sir un charbon ardent , ou sir un plaque de metal ou de verre echaussee , de facon , que l'un des cotes de la pierre , avoit toujours touche a quelque corps .
Mr. Wilson au contraire , en echaussant la Tourmaline , ya procede tellement que la pierre n'a jamais touche a quelque corps .
Voila un circonstance , qui semble assez importance , pour avoir pu causer un difference , sensible .
C'etoit a l'experience d'en decider .
then declare that you have established this , as a constant law , namely , that the Tourmalin is always in an inverted state ; that is , its plus side is electrified minus and the minus side plus , whenever either of the sides is hotter than the other : and that it does not return to its natural state , until the heat is distributed uniformly therein .
My experiments on the contrary , you observe , lead one to lay down a rule entirely different .
viz. That the Tourmalin , when its sides are unequally heated , exhibits the species of electricity which is natural to the hotter side , that is , the Tourmalin is plus on both sides , when the plus side is the hotter ; and minus on both sides , when the minus side is so : but that it returns to its natural state also , when the heat is uniformly distributed .
To account for these different opinions , you think it more agreeable to suppose some difference in our methods of making the experiments , than to question the facts I have declared .
Accordingly you observe one circumstance which would naturally give rise to such a suspicion .
And then tell us , that you always placed the Tourmalin upon burning coals , or upon a plate of metal , or heated glass : so that one side of the stone was always in contact with some ( non electric ) body .
That I , on the contrary , in heating C'est elle qui me force et m'autorise a declarer , que la regle , que j'ai avancee , est la seule , qui lui soit conforme .
J'ai echauffe la Tourmaline de la meme maniere que Mr. Wilson , et j'ai pris grade , qu'elle no touchat a rien , mais pour le resultat , je l'ai , non obstant cela , toujours trouve conforme a ma regle , et pas un seule fois a celle de Mr. Wilson .
Je le repeat encore ; il m'est extremement difficile , de supposer , que Mr. Wilson soit tomb ici dans un meprise , neanmoins je suis convaincu , que de ma part , il n'y a assurement , aucune faute .
Ainsi je no sais qu'en juger .
the Tourmalin , never suffered it to be in contact with any ( non electric ) body .
Here , say you , is a circumstance that seems of consequence enough to cause a sensible difference ; and then you appeal to the experiment which is to decide it : adding at the same time , it is experiment that obliges and authorizes you to declare , that the rule advanced by you , is the only one that agrees therewith .
Now your experiment tells us no more , than that you heated the Tourmalin in my manner , taking care ( as you express it ) that it was in contact with nothing .
But notwithstanding this , that you have always found the event agreeable to your rule , and not one single time to mine .
From your description of this experiment , your exact method of making it does not appear .
I am inclined to believe some material circumstance has been omitted in the method ; o~that our apparatus 's are essentially different ; ( though you seem to have had a regard to some of the necessary requisites for making the experiment properly : ) otherwise , I cannot apprehend why you were not able to succeed : because the experiment always answers with me .
Perhaps the difference in the size of our Tourmalins may have contributed towards causing the different effects .
The Tourmalins I employed in the experiments with the flame , are above five times larger than yours : and must therefore require a longer time in heating .
Now the degree of heat given to my large Tourmalins , was much below that of boiling water ; and therefore I supect , that the small Tourmalins , you employed , were made hotter ; whereas they ought to have been at the most , but about blood warm .
For since a difference of heat , between the two sides , is absolutely necessary , it is of importance that this difference be increased as much , and as suddenly , as the nature of the circumstances will admit .
If you follow this rule , I apprehend you will be more likely to succeed : but that you may be the better enabled to make my experiments answer , it may not be amiss to relate them again in the manner they were lately repeated , and frequently , with two different Tourmalins , before several members of the RoyalSociety of London , who are well acquainted with enquiries of this kind .
EXPERIMEN T. After the convex side of the Tourmalin ( b , fig. I. Tab. XXII .
) has been held for a short time , about one tenth of an inch , from the flame of a candle , both sides thereof are electrified plus : and continue so for half a minute or more .
And in a short time after , the same Tourmalin , without being heated a fresh , or disturbed by any other cause than that of the air surrounding , returns to its natural state ; as you have called it ; that is , the plain side changes to minus , and the convex side remains plus .
These appearances continue whilst the Tourmalin is cooling .
Upon heating the Tourmalin again , as before , excepting that the plain side was now next the flame , both sides thereof were electrified minus : and continued so , for half a minute or more ; and in a short time after , the same Tourmalin , without being heated afresh , or disturbed by any other cause but that of the air surrounding , returned to its natural state again ; that is , the convex side changed to plus , and the plain side remained minus .
One of the Tourmalins that were employed in these experiments , ( marked b ) belongs to Dr. Heberden , and is the samel formerly made use of : but the largest of them was put into my possession by the favour of Dr. Morton Secretary to the Royal-Society , of London , who received it , with several others , from Mr. Loton F. R. S. late governor of the Island of Cylon .
This stone weighed about one hundred and eighty grains : but the form thereof not being the most favourable for experiments , I had permission to fashion it into such shape as would answer the purpose best .
For this end , alterations were made therein ; and at , one time , the electric poles ( if they may be so called ) were pretty near in the longest direction of the stone , and at another time , in the shortest .
These trials terminated in the form and size , nearly , as represented by the letter a , fig. 2 : and the direction of the poles is now in the shortest line that can be drawn between any of the opposite sides .
I have to observe , that when this Tourmalin is held between the eye and the light , and viewed in the direction though which the electric fluid is found to pass , it appears of a darker colour considerably , than when it is viewed at right angles to the former direction .
This appearance obtains in many other Tourmalins , especially if they happen to be as conveniently shaped .
a bc bb oo cca~ Fig.1 .
dd Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. XXII.p .
448 .
def bg o a Fig.2 .
h k ii Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. XXIII.p .
448 .
D G F H BC I QR Fig.5 P Fig.4 B CO A AMN In regard to the other experiments with the heated iron , and Tourmalin , which you have only hinted at , it is enough to recommend the utmost care , to avoid the least degree of friction ; and the iron itself must be so managed , that there may be as easy an electric communication with the air , from it , as the flame of a candle is found to have .
Give me leave , in this place , to make some observations on the apparatus you have made use of in these experiments , as it does not in my opinion , seem the best calculated for such nice purposes ; at least in our climate , which is certainly more moist than yours .
The instrument first described , * consists of a balance 12 inches long , fixed upon a small stand ; from one arm of which , that moves upon a hinge , is suspended , by a silk string , a small cork ball : but there is * Le premier de ces instruments est represent par la Fig. I. Sir un pied quarre A B. je fis dresser un baton C D. environ d'un pied de hauteur .
Ce baton avoit au haut un charniere pres de D. au moien de laquelle le levier a bras egaux F G. etoit un peu mobile .
Chaque bras de ce levier F D. et D G. avoit la longueur de 7 .
pouces a peu pres .
J'employ cet instrument pour pouvoir suspendre commodement le pendule H I. Le levier F G. etoit un peu mobile , afin de pouvoir au besoin hausser , ou baisser un peu le pendule .
Pour fair le pendule H I. je pris un fil de soie crue , j'y attachai par le bas un petit morceau de liege arrondi de la grosseur a peu pres d'une lintille .
La longueur du fil H I. etoit de 5a 6 .
pouces environ , et j'attachai le pendule avec de de la cire a un des bras du levier F G. Sir un autre petit pied quarre M N , qui est represent dans la Fig. II .
je mis dans le milieu un tube mince de verre O P , a peu pres de 6 .
pouces de longueur , dont le haut se terminoit dans un hemisphere O R , de deuxlignes environ .
II est tres-facile de fair ce tube en soufflant un petite boule de verre , comme on fait en faisant un Thermometre , et en brisant ensuite cette boule jusque'a la moitie .
Je me sers dans les experiences de cet instrument pour y poser la Tourmaline , afin qu'elle puisse agir librement .
no mention of what the stand or balance is made ; though a difference in the materials will , I apprehend , make some difference in the experiment .
And if the cork is , as you say , the size of a pea , it will be a considerable objection with me : and the more so , if it is to be moistened with water .
For the force employed to move it , in some of my experiments , is too inconsiderable .
And I should imagine the balance itself could not be very nicely adjusted ; because such an increase in the weight of the cork , by moistening it ( as you say ) from time to time , ought to make it not only preponderate , but unsteady ; as an evaporation of the moisture is constantly making some alteration in the weight .
My apparatus contrived for the same purposes , hath already been described , except that part of it which respects the size of the pith balls , and each of these are about the thirtieth part of a pea .
This smallness , nevertheless , does not require any moisture to retain the electric fluid , as the balls communicate with the finest flaxen threads , and the threads with a slender piece of wood , about one inch long , and the greater part one tenth of an inch thick ; with the angles rounded off , and polished .
This is fixed upon the end of a cylinder of amber , properly supported .
But that there may be no mistake in the construction thereof , I have given a drawing and description of the one I use at present , see fig. 2 .
When I at any time want to examine the state of the Tourmalin , it is brought slowly towards the electrified balls in an horizontal direction .
Your glass stand seems liable to an objection , unless the air be extremely dry : because the mere breathing , if not properly guarded against , in very delicate experiments , is sufficient to cause an unfavourable alteration ; by the moisture condensing upon it .
We are not told of what materials your pincers * were made , but I suppose of some electric substance ; otherwise in removing the Tourmalin from time to time , they may interrupt the experiment , by conducting away the fluid .
And even supposing them made of an electric substance , the unavoidable friction may possibly disturb the experiment .
I have therefore always preferred a different method , which will appear presently .
I shall now comply with the promise I made in the beginning of this letter , to acquaint you with some simple and interesting experiments upon the Tourmalin : most of them were made during the frost in Nov. last , in consequence of an appearance which I then observed accidentally .
With me it has been always found most convenient to fix the Tourmalin at the end of a long stick of the hardest kind of Sealing-Wax , and when I am not using it , to put the other end into the top of a candlestick , or other suitable stand ; that the stone may be the less exposed to any kind of friction ( See fig. I. ) And it is a rule with me never to take hold of the Sealing-wax , or even to touch it , but by that end ( d ) the farthest from the Tourmalin .
One day on * J'emploie encore de petites pincettes AB C , pour no pas toucher la Tourmaline avec les doigts , et je la prens toujours par les cotes , comme il est indique dans la Fig. III .
afinque la pierre soit touchee le moins qu'il est possible par des corps non electriques .
Il faut encore avoir un Tube de verre et un baton de cire d'Espagne tout prets , pour qu'on puisse examiner de la maniere que nous decrivons plus bas l'espece d'Electricite produite par la Tourmaline .
removing the Tourmalin into another room , to repeat the experiments we have here been treating of , I observed it was.electrified ; though no cause for its being so then appeared : the friction arising from the air , in such circumstances , being not sufficient to produce that effect .
And I must here take notice , that many months before this fact was ascertained , I frequently suspected the like appearance : but it happened at those times that the effects were so uncertain , and appeared so accidental , that I did not think they deserved attention ~ .
In tracing out the cause of this appearance , it seemed most necessary to observe the changes in the air with respect to warmth : for , it is well known , those changes cause manifest alterations in the expansion and contraction of bodies .
EXPERIMENT I. In a room with a south aspect , and where no fire had been for sometime , Farh .
Therm. stood at 42 .
The Tourmalin was in the same room , and had continued there some hours , undisturbed , without showing any signs of electricity .
On removing the Tourmalin into a warm room carefully , and the Therm. along with it , in less than 3 minutes ( the Therm. having risen to 47 ) the convex side of the stone showed ~ N. B. The experiments upon the Tourmalin , by Mr. Epinus , which respect the heating and cooling of its sides equally , when occasioned by violent and artificial means , are , it is apprehended , very different from the ten following experiments ; tho ' they also respect an equal heating and cooling of the stone ; because the degree of heat employed , is not only extremely different , but the means of obtaining it , is so likewise .
The one being natural and the other artificial .
a minus , and the plain side a plus , electricity .
These signs increased for a time , and then decreased , till they entirely disappeared .
When this happened , the Tourmalin appeared to be of the same temper , in respect to warmth , with the room ; and the Therm. was raised to 58 .
The same degree of warmth , or nearly so , was continued in the room for thirty minutes and more , without causing any alteration ; for the Tourmalin afforded no electric appearance whatsoever .
EXPERIMENT II .
I then removed the Tourmalin with the Therm. into the cold room and with equal care * .
The stone , some little time after , showed signs of electricity again : but then , those signs were contrary to what had been observed before .
For , in this case , the convex side was plus , and the plain side minus , in nearly the same time ; and these signs increased also for a time , and then decreased , till they entirely vanished .
When that happened , the stone appeared also of the same temper , in respect to coldness , with the room .
And the Therm. was fallen to about 42~ .
During half an hour , or more , after that time , the Tourmalin showed no electric signs whatsoever , nor did the Therm. fall any lower .
* It is indifferent which side of the Tourmalin is moved foremost , provided it be done slowly .
EXPERIMENT III .
Not content with this last discovery , I removed the Tourmalin and Therm. into the open air .
In about three minutes , the Therm. having fallen from 42 to 39 , the Tourmalin was electrified again , in the same manner as in the last experiment .
But when the electric signs disappeared , the Tourmalin and the air were in this case also of an equal temper : at which time the Therm. had fallen to 34 .
The stone was continued in the open air for half an hour or more , but no further electric signs appeared .
EXPERIMENT IV .
On returning into the room where the first experiment was made , the electric signs were stronger than in any of the preceding trials , and contrary to the two last ; for the convex side was minus , and the plain side plus , which agrees with the appearances in the first experiment .
EXPERIMENT V. When the Therm. showed the state of the outward air to be considerably less warm , than what answers to the degree at which water is fixed , the same changes happened , by carrying the Tourmalin from it , into a room , where the Quicksilver stood at 34 : and afterwards , from thence , back again into the open air .
Sir Isaac Newton carried two Thermometers , properly prepared , out of a cold place into a warm one , in order to show that the warmth was conveyed through the vacuum , by the vibrations of a much subtiler medium than the air : and had these last experiments upon the Tourmalin at that time been known to him , he must have been agreeably surprised to find them tending so strongly to establish the existance of that subtle medium * .
This doctrine receives a further confirmation from the experiments that follow .
EXPERIMENT VI .
About the middle of this month , December , the wind being full south , and the air loaded with a thick fogg , which you know is the worst of weather for electric experiments , the Tourmalin afforded the same appearances as before , by removing it from one room to another ; and even into the open vaporous air ; notwithstanding the unfavourable season : but then , the appearances were weaker .
EXPERIMENT VII .
In the most wet season , and during frequent heavy showers of rain , I repeated the first , second , third , and fourth experiments .
And though the electric power was not very strong , yet they always succeeded so well as to ascertain the facts .
* See Newton , Opt .
page , 323 .
EXPERIMENT VIII .
After being acquainted with the preceding experiments , you will not wonder that the Tourmalin afforded the same appearances on removing it , in the open dry air , from the sun-shine into the shade ; and again , from the shade into the sun-shine .
If these small differences , in the degrees of warmth , are capable of causing such appearances ; well may the greater differences ; and such more particularly as Mr. Brawn and yourself have experienced in freezing of Quick-silver : and therefore I cannot now agree with you in calling that the natural state of the Tourmalin , which arises from the heat given it by boiling water .
EXPERIMENT IX .
It appears by the preceding experiments , that when the Tourmalin was of the same temper with the air in the different rooms , there were no electric signs to be observed .
From which we may understand , if the heat of the air should be increased , even beyond that of boiling water , a Tourmalin exposed therein for a time , would afford no electric signs ; that is , whilst the stone continues of the same temper with the air .
I have lately caused the heat of the air to be increased , in a convenient room , beyond the degree of vital heat , even to 108 : and then placed two Tourmalins , in the same room , very near the Thermometer , without being able to observe any electric effects ; that is , after they had remained therein a short time .
EXPERIMENT X. Upon a very nice examination , and during some favourable opportunities , I have observed the Tourmalin to be feebly electrified , when the Therm. varied , up or down only one degree .
The smallness of the force here required to cause those manifest effects , and even them by natural means only , is a new discovery , and , perhaps , deserves the attention of philosophers .
In my first and second letters upon the Tourmalin , there are experiments that give us assurances of a flux and reflux of the electric fluid , or aether , at different times , even without artificial means to occasion it .
And I did not scruple to advance that doctrine , as appears from a passage in the opticks which I quoted in the second letter , somewhat favouring the same opinion .
This you see has happened to be a right conjecture ; for these last experiments , are I apprehend , so clear and satisfactory , that there is no room left for a doubt about it .
And I do hope they will lead to some useful discoveries .
For these forces , however small they may appear , are probably sufficient to answer very great purposes in nature .
Upon considering the effects which heat and cold occasion in the Tourmalin , it may not be improper here to observe , that all bodies we are acquainted with , are dilated by heat , and contracted by cold : and when they acquire the same temper with the air , whether it be hot or cold , the same state of dilatation , or contraction , continues unaltered .
The Tourmalin we find , when uniformly disturbed on all sides , by changing the temperature of the air ; is not only electrified , but shows two opposite and contrary effects .
That is , in passing from a great , to a less , degree of warmth , it is electrified in one manner ; and in passing from a less to a greater degree of warmth , it is electrified in another manner ; which evidently shows , that there is some power , belonging to the stone , which is differently affected by such contraction and dilatation .
The same thing appears from other different effects it affords , when its two sides are equally warm .
But the Tourmalin , affording no electric appearance whatever , when the whole mass is of the same temper with the air , agrees with the observation that all bodies cease in that state , to contract or dilate : and is a manifest indication , that the fluid , which causes these electric appearances , is in such circumstances , in equilibrio ; and must ever remain so , unless disturbed by violence .
The importance of this last observation bespeaks your attention , as it greatly tends to throw more light upon this curious subject .
From the experiment with the bent tube , mentioned in the former part of this letter , it was proved , that there is a resistance exerted at , or near , the surface of the Quicksilver where the light is accumulated .
This resistance , which I apprehend is essential to all bodies , merits a further illustration ; because the electric phenomenon in general greatly depend upon it .
When a bladder is well blown up , and secured properly , it will yield or give way , and change its form , in that part against which any given pressure is exerted .
And upon removing the pressure , the bladder will immediately recover its first form .
This yielding or giving way of the form , and then afterwards recovering it , proves an elastic substance existing within the bladder , and between the two sides where the pressure is employed .
In like manner when two glass prisms , or the object glasses of two long Telescopes press upon each other with their own weight only , philosophers know , by the phenomenon of light , that they do not touch : and that there must be something between the glasses to keep them at a distance .
They also know , by the like phenomenon , that more pressing is required to bring them nearer to a contact ; and that when the pressure is removed , they immediately recover their first distance .
Now this yielding or giving way , and the recovery of the distance between the glasses , proves the existence of some elastic substance between them respectively .
Since we find the effects of applying , and removing , the pressure , exactly similar to the case with the bladder .
Hence it is evident that the same elastic substance or medium causes prisms , and convex glasses , when pressed against each other , to exhibit several rings of different colours ; by having its density varied : and that it occasions all bodies to act upon light at a distance , by reflecting , refracting , and inflecting it ; and light to act upon bodies , at a distance , by causing a motion of their parts , and heating them .
This is the medium then which gives rise to the resistance found in electric experiments .
For when a quantity of the electric fluid is forced into the apparatus , which supports the two balls , we should from its elastic principle , expect it to pass out again immediately : whereas the fact is , that it passes out by slow degrees ; and takes a considerable time in evacuating the apparatus effectually .
Some power therefore must hinder the fluid , at least , in some measure , from escaping : and that power must be exerted at , or near , the surface of the body .
To say it is detained by an attraction of the body , will not answer the purpose : for the power which is supposed to draw the fluid into it , must certainly be sufficient to hinder it from passing out .
Now by the experiment , the fluid does pass out , though slowly : this power therefore , which resists its passing out , can be no other than what arises from the medium we have proved to be spread upon the surfaces of bodies .
The evidence in favour of this doctrine is greatly strengthened by the following experiments , the three first of which , are well known to electric enquirers .
When glass is properly electrified , and held over the wooden part of the apparatus ( c ) at the distance of six or eight inches , and there continued for a time , the balls are separated to a considerable distance .
But upon taking away the glass , the separation is at an end , and there are no electric signs remaining in the balls .
These appearances therefore argue , that no part of the electric fluid , appertaining to the excited glass , passed from it into the wood .
And that the cause , which obstructed its passage , is a resistance , exerted at or near , the surface of the wood : because we know , from a variety of experiments , that the repulsive power of this fluid acts at great distances , and in gross bodies particularly ; without the fluid being able to enter them .
There can then be no doubt that the separation of the balls , in the present circumstances , entirely depends upon this repulsive power ; which drives the natural quantity of the fluid belonging to the wood , or part of it at least , towards the balls .
And though the repulsive power is sufficient to force the fluid from the wood into the balls , and there occasion the effects of a plus electricity , ( as is found upon trial ; ) * yet the experiment shows , it is not sufficient , in the same circumstances , to force it out of them , as they cease to be electrified on removing the power .
If this is not the case , and the fluid from the glass is supposed to enter to the wood ; I would ask , why the balls do not retain the fluid , or at least some part of it , and continue separated when the glass is taken away ?
It would be unphilosophical to say , the glass actually suffered a quantity of the electric fluid to pass from it , into the wood and balls ; and then , on removing the glass , that it took it away again ; or attracted it back : because when the same glass is brought near enough to the wood , the balls will be electrified , and separated so effectually , as to continue in that state of separation , after the glass is removed : which proves clearly , that the repulsive power is not only great enough to overcome the resistance of the balls ; but even to force out some part of the fluid contained therein : therefore in this case the balls are electrified minus .
And this minus may be increased , * For the proof of this , see the Essay by Dr. Hoadly and myself , page 13 .
by bringing the power gradually nearer , and then removing it quickly .
We may then very justly conclude , that this separation of the balls , is occasioned by the expansive power of the electric fluid , or aether , crowding from without , and through the air , to enter the balls , and restore the equilibrium .
And in like manner that the plus electricity causes a separation of the balls in consequence of the same electric fluid , or aether , crowding from within to get out of the balls , and passing through a like quantity of air , in order to restore the equilibrium ; for the same medium which appertains to the surfaces of bodies , must resist the exit and entrance equally : and therefore the one case will be always the converse of the other .
We have seen that on bringing the electrified glass near enough to the wood , the balls are electrified minus .
If now the circumstances are changed , by bringing the same glass considerably nearer to the wood , and much quicker , the balls are electrified plus ; and continue so for a considerable time after the glass is removed * : which is the strongest confirmation that this effect entirely depends upon the resistance of the wood being overcome , and the electric fluid entering the apparatus , by the nearer approach of the glass .
There are then two different methods of causing a plus appearance in the balls .
The one , we find , depends upon an actual enterance of the fluid , from the glass , into the wood , &amp;c. And the other upon a quantity of the fluid , originally in the wood , being forced * The glass in this experiment must not only be brought quickly towards the wood , but it must likewise be removed from it as suddenly .
from it into the balls , by the repulsive power of the fluid appertaining to the excited glass .
In these experiments we also learn , that when the glass is held nearer to the wood , than in the minus , and farther from it than in the plus appearance of the first experiment , it does not produce any electric signs whatever in the balls .
Which shows a kind of balance subsisting between the power of the glass , and the resistance of the wood , &amp;c. For , if we deviate the least on either side from this intermediate distance , electric effects , of the one kind or other , immediately take place .
I shall produce another experiment in favour of these forces , and of the balance obtaining between them , in certain circumstances .
In the experiment I am about to mention , it is necessary , first to electrify the wood and balls ; by properly rubbing that end of the sealing-wax , amber , or glass , to which they are affixed .
You know then , that , if we touch the balls with the hand , we immediately unelectrify them , and the wood ; but not the amber : and that these balls with the wood , will continue unelectrified .
But if I blow ever so gently against that part of the amber which is electrified , the balls will be separated to a considerable distance , and continue in that state .
On the other hand , if the amber has not been rubbed , no electricity can be produced by the same force of blowing , or even by a blast six or eight times greater : but if the blast is considerably increased , the amber will be electrified * .
By which it appears that in the first case , the electric power in the amber receives such an additional force from * See the letter to Dr. Heberden , page 332 .
the slight friction of the breath , as enables it to destroy the balance and overcome the resistance at the surface of the wood , in that part , where it is joined to the amber .
The Leyden experiment depends also upon a certain balance , which obtains between the mediums at the opposite surfaces of the glass , by the power of repulsion * : but this enquiry , being of a very extensive nature , would lead me too far for the business of a letter ; I must therefore refer you to the works quoted last .
In selecting the experiments above related to prove the resistance , I have purposely confined myself to a few , and those such as appeared to be the most simple and most worthy of attention .
You will therefore do me the honor to examine , and consider carefully these experiments and observations , as I think they have sufficiently established a resistance appertaining to bodies , independent of the gross matter they contain : and that it arises from the same elastic medium which we before proved to exist between the convex glasses .
I am , &amp;c. London Dec. 20 , 1763 .
B. Wilson .
* The consideration of this experiment was particularly attended to , in a former work , by Dr. Hoadly and myself .
See also the Phil. Trans. Vol. LI .
Part II .
and Pages 898 , 899 .
Explanation of Fig. 1 .
TAB. XXII .
a , b , Two Tourmalins fixed upon c. c. Sticks of the hardest kind of sealing-wax .
d , d , Two handles of wood , in which the other ends of the sealing-wax are secured .
f , f , A stand of wood , with holes to rest the handles therein , when the Tourmalins are unemployed .
Explanation of Fig. 2 .
TAB. XXIII .
a , a , Two very small balls of the pith of Elder , suspended by b , b , The finest flaxen threads about six inches long .
The balls and threads together weigh about the fiftieth part of a grain .
These threads are neatly fastened in a small hole on the under side of the thin end , and so as to touch the wood c , Which is mahogany .
Every part of this small piece of wood is well polished , and neatly joined to d , the cylinder of amber ; which is about four inches long , and near half an inch thick .
It is finely polished also , and the other end slides into e , which is part of the arm : e is joined to f by a screw ; and the other end of f , slides into the upper part of the stand g. One end of the upright h screws on to g , and the other end , into the cross pieces i , i , and k k ; which are let into each other by a mortass , and thus secured .
The whole apparatus takes to pieces easily , for the convenience of packing up in a case six inches and half long .
The stand is made of Cocoa-tree , without angles , or edges , and well polished .
The size of my apparatus is about twice as large as the drawing before you .

