LIII .
An Account of the Sea Pen , or Pennatula Phosphorea of Linnaeus ; likewise a Description of a new Species of Sea Pen , found on the Coast of South-Carolina , with Observations on Sea-Pens in general .
In a Letter to the Honourable Coote Molesworth , Esq ; M. D. and F. R. S. from John Ellis , Esq ; F. R. S. and Member of the Royal Academy at Upsal .
Dear Sir , I Should make some apology for deferring so long the account I promised you of the Animal you were so kind to send me in February 1762 , which was taken in a trawl in 72 fathoms water near the harbour of Breast in France ; but a new species coming to my hand occasioned this delay .
This curious sea-production , I find , by your letter , you took for a new kind of coralline , and not without reason , when upon examining it ( as it was not long taken out of the sea ) there were still remaining several of the suckers like heads of Polypes disposed along its sickle-shaped Pinnulae .
But when you hear of more of its properties , you will agree with me , that it belongs to another class of Animals ; I shall mention only one at present , till I come to describe it more particularly , and that is , that it floats or swims about freely in the sea ; whereas Corals , Corallines , Alcyonia , and 2 all Read Dec. 22 , all that order of beings , adhere firmly by their bases to submarine substances .
This Animal was well known to the ancients by the name of the Sea-Pen ; many of the old authors took it for a Fucus or Sea-Plant .
This species of yours has been found in the Ocean from the coast of Norway to the most remote parts of the Mediterranean Sea , and not only dragged up in trawls from great depths of the sea , but often found floating near the surface .
Dr. Shaw , in his History of Algiers , remarks that they afford so great a light in the night to the fishermen , that they can plainly discover the fish swimming about in various depths of the sea .
From this extraordinary property Doctor Linnaeus calls this species of Sea-Pen , Pennatula Phosphorea , and remarks , after giving the synonyms of other authors , Habitat in Oceano fundum illuminans .
In order to attempt a description of it ; the outward appearance of this Animal is not unlike one of the quill feathers of a bird 's wing , but they are found of different sizes from 4 to 8 inches in length ; this of yours is about 4 inches long ; the lower half of it , is naked round and white , not unlike the quill part of a writing pen ; the upper part represents that of the feathered part of the pen , and is of a reddish colour , but faded by soaking it often in water in order to examine it more minutely .
This upper half ( which arises from the quill and is feathered on both sides ) is a little compressed and becomes smaller and smaller till it ends in a point at the top ; along the back of this , in the same manner as in the inner side of a common writing pen , there is a groove in the middle from the quill to the extremity : from each side of this upper part of the stem proceed little parallel feather-like fins ; these begin at the top of the quill part , very small on each side at first , but lengthen as they advance towards the middle ; from hence they shorten gradually on each side , till they end at a point at the top ; their terminations preserving on each side the figure of the segment of a circle .
I come now to consider more minutely those Pinnulae , or feather-like fins , that project on each side and form the upper part of this animal .
These are evidently designed by nature to move the animal backward or forward in the sea , consequently to do the office of fins , while at the same time , by the appearance of the suckers or mouths furnished with filaments or claws , they were certainly intended to provide food for its support ; for notwithstanding what Dr. Linnaeus has said in regard to its mouth in his system of nature , viz. Os baseos commune rotundum , I could not , with the help of the best glasses , discover that the point of the base was penetrated in the least , so that I am clearly of opinion , that this animal , like the Hydra Arctica or Greenland Polype , which I have described in my Essay on Corallines , nourishes and supports itself by these suckers or Polype-like figures ; that by these , both kinds take in their food , and have no other visible means of discharging the exuviae of the animals they feed upon , than by the same way which they take them in ; and that , from attentively considering the structure and manner of living of both these animals , I shall make no doubt in classing them in the same genus of Pennatula , though they vary very much in their exterior form and size , and consequently are of very different species .
The stem of the suckers of this animal is of a cylindrical form ; from the upper part proceed 8 fine white filaments or claws to catch their food : when they retreat on the alarm of danger they draw themselves into their cases , which are formed like the denticles of the Corallines ; but here each denticle is furnished with spiculae , which close together round the entrance of the denticle , and protect this tender part from external injuries .
Some time after I had made my remarks on this very extraordinary animal , the Royal Society did me the honour to recommend to me , for my opinion , some very curious observations lately published by Dr. Bohadsch of Prague , a book of great merit , which shows that the author has taken a good deal of pains , in examining very minutely into those animals called by the old authors Zoophytes : but as many of them have not the least resemblance to vegetables , I shall beg leave to pass over such , and only confine myself to this class of the Penna marina , which he seems to have been happy in observing ; and therefore shall take the liberty to add such of his observations , as the opportunity of his seeing this animal alive in sea-water afforded him , without which it would have been impossible for me to have had the pleasure of gratifying you , and the rest of the Royal Society , so fully on the subject .
Some of the most curious remarks of Doctor Bohadsch on the anatomy of this animal , as also on the appearance of it while alive in sea-water , are as follows .
When the trunk is opened lengthways , a saltish liquor flows out of it , so viscid as to hang down an inch ; the whole trunk of the stem is hollow , its outward coriaceous membrane is more than a line thick , and forms a strong covering to it : between this and another thinner membrane of the pinnated part of the trunk are innumerable little yellowish eggs , floating in a whitish liquor , about the size of a white poppy seed ; these are best seen , when the trunk is cut across : This thin membrane lines the whole inside of the trunk , in which we observe nothing but a kind of yellowish bone , which takes up three parts of the cavity .
This bone in some of these animals is above 2 1/ 2 inches long and about half a line thick ; in the middle part of it , it is four square or quadrangular ; towards each end of it , it grows round and very taper : that end is smallest , which is nearest the top of the pinnated trunk .
The whole bone is covered with a yellowish clear skin , which at each end changes into a ligament ; one of which is inserted in the top of the pinnated trunk , the other in the top of the naked trunk ; by the help of this upper ligament , the end of this little bone is either contracted into a very narrow arch , or disposed into a straight line , according to the motion of the trunk .
The fins likewise are composed of two skins ; the outward one strong and leathery and covered over with an infinite number of crimson streaks , the inner skin is thin and clear : The cylindrical part of the suckers are in the same manner , only with this difference , their outward skins may be softer .
Both the fins and suckers are hollow , so that the cavity of the suckers may communicate with the fins , as their cavity does with the trunk .
We now come to the appearance which this animal makes when alive in sea-water .
The trunk then was contracted circularly at the bottom of the naked part of the stem , and by this contraction formed a zone of the most intense purple , which moved upwards and downwards successively : When it moved upwards through the length of the pinnated trunk , it there became paler , and at length terminated at the top : the motion being scarce finished , a like zone appeared at the end of the naked trunk , which finished its motion in the same manner as the former .
When this zone becomes very much constricted on every side , the trunk above it swells and acquires the form of an onion ; and then it appears , as if a compressed globe moved along through the whole space of the trunk ; this constriction of the trunk gives that fine red colour to the zone ; for when the skin of the trunk is outwardly full of purple papillae , the intermediate spaces are of a whitish colour .
In this constriction then of the skin the intermediate spaces are obliterated and the papillae are brought nearer together ; consequently only the purple colour presents itself to the eyes and appears more bright .
Moreover the end or apex of the naked trunk is sometimes curved like a hook , and sometimes extended in a right line ; both these motions then must be directed by the little bone in the inside , and from this motion of this little internal bone , that sinus or cavity at the lower end of the trunk ( thought by authors heretofore to be the mouth ) seems plainly to be formed ; for sometimes it is deeper , sometimes shallower ; it is deeper while the moveable globe appears in the middle of the pinnated part of the trunk , and shallower when it is in the bottom of the naked trunk , at which time the bone is most extended .
The fins or pinnulae have four different motions ; they are moved both towards the naked stem , and towards the pinnated stem ; sometimes they are drawn in very much to the belly , a little after they are inclined to the back ; further , the fleshy filaments or claws move in all directions , and the cylindrical part with the filaments is either extended out or drawn in and hid in the fins .
' ' Doctor Bohadsch concludes this chapter by observing , that there are some varieties to be met with in these red Sea-Pens : some , he says , are paler and inclining to a rose colour , others of an intense deep red : in the first kind he remarks that there are fewer denticles or tentacula ( from whence the suckers proceed ) in the fins , and that these are placed in one row within half a line of one another ; but in the latter , he says , the tentacula are placed in a double row and as near as they can be together : this is the Pennatula of which I have just now given you his account , and which he saw alive in seawater .
water .
The other seems to be the same with yours , and is , no doubt on it , Linnaeus 's Pennatula Phosphorea , so that heconcludes them to be two distinct species , and calls them by the following names , viz. Penna ( Rubra ) pinnis falciformibus , tentaculis in pinnarum facie concava densissime dispositis .
Penna ( Rosea ) pinnis falciformibus , tentaculis in pinnarum facie concava laxe dispositis .
In the three following chapters Dr. Bohadsch describes three other kinds of Sea-Pens .
One he calls Penna Grisea or the Grey Sea-Pen with crenated fins ; this is figured and described from a dry specimen in Seba 's Museum , Tom. III .
The next is a very singular one without fins , having a square bony stem 2 feet 10 inches long , covered with a skin , and furnished on 3 sides with tentacula or suckers : but this was unfortunately broken off at the bottom before he received it : he says , the fishermen call it Penna del Pesche de Pavone , or the Feather of the Peacock-fish .
To these he has added the Alcyonium called , Manus marina ; he calls it Penna ramosa pinnis carens , tentaculis in ramis positis , and in another place , Penna Exos .
In order to give you and the rest of the Royal Society some idea of these extraordinary Animals , I have copied his figures , and also the figures of the three last species of Linnaeus 's Pennatula , viz. his Pennatula ( Filosa ) Pennatula ( Sagitta ) and Pennatula ( Mirabilis ) from the authors which he refers us to , and have added an exact delineation of our Alcyonium ( Manus marina ) or Dead mans hand , with some microscopial drawings of different sections of it , to show that although the substance of it is fleshy , yet that it approaches much nearer to the Madrepora Corals , than to any known species of the genus of Animals called Pennatula .
At the same time I allow his remark to be very just , where he observes that the Hydra Arctica or Great Greenland Polype , which I have described in the Philosophical Transactions , and in my Essay on Corallines , is certainly a species of Pennatula ; but he will find , from both the drawing and description , which I have given of it , that it is not fixed by its base , but floats freely about in the sea ; whereas this Alcyonium as well as his ( which differs in colour from ours ) are always found fixed by their base to some solid submarine body , and consequently cannot be admitted among the Pennatulae .
I must now conclude this letter with a short account of a new discovered species of Pennatula , which my ingenious friend John Greg Esq ; of Charles Town in South-Carolina , discovered on that coast and presented to me some time ago .
This beautiful purple animal is of a compressed kidney shape .
The body is about an inch long , and half an inch across the narrowest part , it has a small roundish tail of an inch long proceeding from the middle of the body , its tail is full of rings from one end to the other like an Earth-Worm , and along the middle of the upper and under part of it there is a small groove which runs from one end to the other .
I examined carefully the point of the tail and could find no perforation in it , which is agreeable to what I have observed in the rest of this genus .
The upper part of the body is convex and near a quarter of an inch thick ; the whole surface of it is covered over with minute yellow starry openings , through which are protruded little suckers like polypes each furnished with 6 tentacles or filaments , like what we observe on some of the Corals , and seem to be the proper mouths of the animal .
The under part of the body is quite flat , this surface is full of the ramifications of fleshy fibres , which , proceeding from the insertion of the tail , as their common center , branch themselves out , so as to communicate with the starry openings on the exterior edge and upper surface of this uncommon animal : for a clearer idea I must refer you to the figure of this , as well as that of your own Pennatula , and am , Dear Sir , Your much obliged London , Dec. 15 , 1763 .
Humble Servant , John Ellis .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
Tab. XXI .
p. 429 .
3 12 ~ a4 FIG.1 .
The front of the red Sea Pen .
3 .
The Finger shaped Sea ~ ~ .
4 .
The Papilla or ~ 2 .
The ~ of the same .
~ .
The ~ show that the Animal can Polype like Sucker a. One of the ~~ the Order in which extend~ or contract this Part .
5 .
The Sucker ~ 9 8 7 6 5 10 ~ or ~ from whence the~ 6 .
The front of the ~ Sea Pen .
8 .
The front of one of the Suckers .
~ proceeds .
7 .
The back of the same .
9 .
The back of the same .
~ 10 .
One of the ~ Fins magnified .
~ .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
Tab. XX .
p. 429 .
7 5 3 21 8 6 9 4 a FIG. 1 and 2 The front &amp; back of Dr~ Bohadsch 's red Sea Pen .
aa The hollow ~~ at the bottom of it .
10 .
~ 3~ One of the ~ magnified .
4 .
One of the ~ separated .
5 .
The bone taken out of the middle part of the ~ ~ .
~ ~~ gray Sea Pen .
7 .
One of its ~ ~ .
8 .
His Sea ~ called the Pen of the Peacock Fish .
13 .
~ ~~ ~~~ ~ , or ~ man 's hand called by ~ Bohadsch ~ ~ .
14 .
~ 17 15 16 14 13 c 12 b l 11 10 a ~ ~ ~ 3 89 761 10 ~ ~ ~ Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII TabXIXp .
429 .
4 5 2 ~ , with theStarry 8 and 9 .
Both sides of the Kidney ~ Sea Pen magnified .
10 A part of the edge of the upper Surface highly magnified to show the ~ &amp; ~ coming out like openings of the Cells .
P. S. Just when the two plates XIX and XX of the Pennatula were finished , and sent to the Printer , I received three kinds of Sea-Pens , finely preserved in spirits , from my learned friend Thomas Pennant Esq ; of Bychton in Flintshire , which he informs me were sent him from the Mediterranean-Sea .
One of them is entirely new to me , and , I believe , not yet described ; the other two , which are the Red and the Gray Sea-Pens of Dr. Bohadsch , are so very indifferently designed by the Doctor 's painter , and which I have copied in Plate XX , that I thought a better drawing would give you a clearer idea of these strange animals , and be more agreeable to the Royal Society in general .
An Explanation of the Plates .
Plate XIX .
FI G. 1 .
The back part of the Red-Sea-Pen , or Pennatula Phosphorea of Linnaeus .
This was found on the coast of France , they are frequently met with on the coasts of Norway and Sweden .
2 .
The front of the same .
3 .
and 4 .
Both sides of the same magnified .
5 .
One of the fins more highly magnified , to show the Polype-like suckers by which it takes in its nourishment .
6 .
The kidney-shap 'd purple Sea-Pen from SouthCarolina in its natural size ; this upper part is full of starry openings , which send out small suckers like polypes by which it feeds .
7 .
The under part of the same , with its ramifying fibres , that lead from the insertion of the stem as from a center to the circumference , and correspond with all the starry openings on the edge and back of it .
8 and 9 .
Both sides of this animal magnified .
10 .
A part of the exterior edge higher magnified , to show the form of the starry openings and suckers , which consist of 6 rays and claws .
Plate XX .
The four following Sea-Pens were found by Dr. Bohadsch , in the Sea , near Naples .
Fig. 1 .
Represents the forepart of the Red-SeaPen with many rows of suckers on its fins .
2 .
The back part , the middle of which is covered with the appearance of small papillae .
3 .
One of the fins magnified .
4 .
One of the suckers separated .
5 .
The bone taken from the internal part of the pinnated trunk ; this is fastened to ligaments at both ends which are likewise inserted in both ends of the animal .
When the ligament at the base is contracted , it forms that sinus at a a , that has been taken for a mouth by most authors .
The Grey-Sea-Pen .
One of its crenated fins .
N. B. There is a figure of this Sea-Pen taken from a dried specimen in the third tome of Seba 's Museum .
8 .
The Sea-Pen called by the Italian Fishermen Penna del pesche Pavone , or the Pen of Peacock Fish ; this appears to be broken off , and is described to be yet 2 feet ten inches long , the square bony part of this is not so hard as that in the Red-Sea-Pen .
9 .
This last of Dr. Bohadsch 's four Sea-Pens is the Alcyonium called by authors Manus marina , or vulgarly Dead-man 's Hand : he calls it Penna Exos and the branched Sea-Pen without fins having suckers placed on its branches : but it by no means belongs to this class of animals , which float freely about in the sea ; whereas this adheres to Rocks , Shells , or other marine substances .
I have introduced our Alcyonium Manus marina or Dead-man 's Hand , which is found in great plenty all round the coasts of the British Islands , to show its internal structure , and how near it comes to the Madrepora Coral , which appears by it growth and form to be produced by animals of the same shape .
10 .
A piece of the Alcyonium Manus marina , cut perpendiculary through the middle , to show that it is formed of tubes , which branch out into others , each ending on the surface in a starry opening of 8 rays ; in each of these openings is a polype-like figure or sucker with eight claws , fastened to the inside of the tube at it 's lower part by 8 fine tender filaments , by which it can raise or sink itself at pleasure in its tube : all these tubes that compose this Alcyonium are connected together by minute reticulated fibres ; these enclose a kind of stiff gelatinous substance , which seems to be the flesh of this compound animal , and these fibres with their enclosed contents to be the muscles ; for by the exertion of these it assists in opening or closing the stars on the surface , while the suckers or polype-like figures are pushing themselves out in search of food , or when they are retreating to secure themselves from danger .
11 .
Is the magnified part of an upright section of this Alcyonium represented in its natural size at .
b. Here the polype like suckers appear in different attitudes ; one has extended itself through the starry opening , and is sending forth it 's spawn or eggs ; at the base of the next sucker you may observe some of the tender filaments by which it is fixed to the bottom of the tube ; the sucker next to this is contracted and its starry opening is closed over it ; the cell or star next to this is cut in half to show the manner that the sucker is placed in it .
12 .
Represents one of these suckers taken out of its cell .
13 .
Is a cross or horizontal section of a piece of this Alcyonium , the natural size is expressed at c* .
14 .
The Madrepora coral is introduced here to show how near it approaches to this Alcyonium in its external appearance and in the ramification of its tubes .
The * The reticulated fleshy part of this Alcyonium approaches very near to the nature of sponges ; for sponges , when first taken out of the sea , are filled with a gelatinous or mucous matter of a The other 3 figures in this plate are introduced to show the form of the Pennatula referred to by Dr. Linnaeus , in his Syst. Not .
10 Ed. p. 819 .
15 .
Is the Pennatula Filosa , and is figured in Boccone 's Recherches , pl. 287 , page .
287 .
This animal infests the Xiphias or Sword-fish in the Mediterranean-Sea by sucking their blood , and is called by Boccone , Hirudo cauda utrinque pennata .
16 .
Is the Pennatula Sagitta ; it is described in Linnaei Amaenit 's Vol. v. Chin .
Lagerstr~ p. 14 .
f. 3 .
and said to infest the Lophius Histrio or Sea-Bat , in the Chinese Sea .
17 .
Is the Pennatula Mirabilis .
This is called the Polypus Mirabilis , and is described in the Museum of Adolphus Frederick King of Sweden , p. 96 .
t 19 .
f. 4 .
strong fishy smell : Yet I much doubt whether Sponges have such polype-like suckers as the Corals , Alcyonia , and Pennatulae , or are even produced by Worms , as the late ingenious Dr. Peysonel informs us ; for in the title to the second part of his manuscript on this subject , which he dedicates to the Royal Society , he says , that Sponges , as well as Corals , Madreporas , &amp;c. are produced by animals that are of a particular species of Urtica marina or Purpura ; but I am inclined to believe he took this for granted from the similitude they bear to Corals , Alcyonia , &amp;c. rather than from actual experiment .
I rather take those holes , which I have observed in them , to be so many mouths upon the surface of the animal ; and I am the more inclined to believe it , from a remark I made with Dr. Solander at the Sea-Coast of Sussex in the summer 1762 ; on the Spongia Medullam Panis referens , while it was in a glass vessel of Sea-Water ; where we observed , that the Mamillae that were on the surface opened and shut , but that no sucker or animal-like figure appeared to come out .
Explanation of Plate XXI .
Fig. 1 .
Represents the front of the Red-Sea-Pen a little larger than life , as are the figures of the two following Sea-Pens .
a. One of the fins showing , the alternate order in which the denticles incline like the teeth in a saw .
2 .
The back of the Red-Sea-Pen , with the rachis or middle part between the fins covered over with a rough skin like shaggreen .
3 .
The finger-shaped Sea-Pen , or Cynomorion , called so from its likeness to the shape of the Fungus Melitensis .
The upper part of this animal is covered over with circular cells , one of which is represented at Fig. 4 , from whence proceed Polype-like suckers , having eight pennated arms or claws , one of which suckers is figured at 5 .
The Rugae or Furrows in the swelling part at b , show that this animal can extend and contract this part , perhaps to raise or fall itself in the sea .
6 .
The front of the thorny Sea-Pen , called by Dr. Bohadsch Penna grisea .
7 .
The back part of it .
8 .
Shows the front of one of the suckers magnified .
9 .
the back view of the same .
10 .
One of the lower fins a little magnified , which shows the position of the suckers , and the insertion of the spines ; These spines are combined of many fine spiculae , which unite and form one spine .
When these spines open at top , each forms a star of small spiculae , which nature seems to have pointed out as a protection for the mouths or suckers underneath , which have no other covering to defend them , whereas in the Red-Sea-Pen there is a circle of spiculae to each sucker .

