XLVII .
Second Paper concerning the Parallax of the Sun determined from the Observations of the late Transit of Venus , in which this Subject is treated of more at length , and the Quantity of the Parallax more fully ascertained .
By James Short , M. A. and F. R. S. IN the last volume of the Memoirs of the Royal Academy at Paris for the year 1761 , there is a Memoir by M. Pingre , who went to the island of Rodrigues , and observed the transit of Venus there ; in this memoir M. Pingre endeavours to determine the parallax of the Sun , by the observation of the late transit of Venus , to be = 10~ .
both by the observed durations , the least distance of the centers , and by the internal contact at the egress ; and seeems to think that there must be some mistake in the observation of Mr. Mason at the Cape of Good Hope , particularly with regard to the difference of longitude between Mr. Mason 's observatory and Paris , because by comparing the observation of Mr. Mason at the Cape with the European observations , he finds the parallax of the Sun , from thence resulting , to be between 8~ and 9~ , consequently differing from the determination by the observation at Rodrigues when compared with the same places .
I shall therefore , in this paper , endeavour to prove , beyond all doubt , by a comparison of the observations Read Dec. 8 , Fig. 1 .
LSP L OK O MA NR b AF c BD E Philos Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. XVIII p. 300 .
Fig. 2 .
LSP A M a observations on this side of the Equinoctial Line alone , that the Sun 's parallax is between 8~ and 9~ , and that this determination is the same or very nearly the same , as when the observation at the Cape is compared with the same places .
I shall also endeavour to prove , that there is a mistake of one minute in time in writing down the time of the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues , and that this being corrected , the results of the Sun 's parallax , by a comparison of the observation at Rodrigues with the observations at the several places on this side of the Line , is the same with that which results from all the rest ; and this agreement is also an argument that there must have been such a mistake in setting down the time of the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues .
I shall also show that the parallax of the Sun , determined from the observed durations , and from the least distance of the centers is very nearly the same as that which is determined from the internal contact at the egress , though these last determinations cannot be so much depended on because of the minute elements from which they are drawn .
I shall therefore proceed to compare the observations of the internal contact made on this side of the Line only , and from thence determine the Sun 's parallax .
In order to do this it is necessary that the differences of longitude between the places of observation , compared together , be well ascertained : and in the doing of this , in all places where the ingress was observed , I have been much obliged to a very ingenious method , proposed by M. Pingre in his aforesaid Memoir , to which I refer ; and for the longitudes of other places I have consulted the Philosophical TransV O L. LIII .
Rr actions actions and the Connoissance des Temps .
These differences of longitude are as follow .
h~~ Tobolsk and Abo =34 37 West .
Bologna =3 47 46 W. Calcutta =1 20 38 East .
Cajaneburg =2 42 12 W. Calmar =3 27 32 W. Cape of G. Hope =3 19 32 W. Florence =3 49 3 W. Gottingen =3 53 35 W. Grand Mount =0 46 26 E. Greenwich =4 33 7 W. Hernosand =3 21 55 W. Leskeard =4 51 39 W. Madrass =0 47 11 E. Paris =4 23 51 W. Rodrigues =0 20 25 W. Rome =3 43 14 W. * Savile-house , Lond. =4 33 37 W. Stokolm =3 20 41 W. Tornea =2 56 7 W. Tranquebar =0 46 9 E. Upsal =3 22 40 W. I have deviated from the above mentioned method of M. Pingre in settling the longitude of Stokolm , by * The latitude of Savile-house , London , is = 51~ 30~ 50~ N. The latitude of Florence is = 43~ 46~ 30~ N. and that of Gottingen = 51~ 31~ 54~ N. The latitudes of the rest of the places are set down in my former paper on this subject , only that of Tranquebar should be = 11~ 30~ 0~ .
the ingress , because it appears clear to me that there must have been a mistake in the observation of the internal contact at the ingress at Stokolm , owing , as I mentioned in my former paper , to the small altitude of the Sun at the time of the ingress : for by comparing the times of ingress and egress observed at Stokolm and Upsal , we find that the difference of longitude between these two places is 1~ 39~ , and 1~ 59~ , and as we are sure that the observation at the egress , gives the difference of longitude the most certain in this case , therefore it follows that the error was at the ingress , and it is easy to prove that the error is in the observation at Stokolm .
To avoid all uncertainty , and to be as clear and distinct as possible , I shall set down , in the following table , the observation at the egress at each place compared , the difference of longitude between each place compared , the effect of the parallaxes resulting from the comparison , and also the effect of the parallaxes computed on a supposition that the Sun 's parallax is = 8~ 5 , in order , that if there is any mistake , it may , the more easily , be discovered .
I compare Cajaneburg with 18 places , Bologna with 17 places , and Tobolsk with 18 places , and they are as follow .
h~~h 10 7 59 Cajan .
2~ 59~ C. 10h 7~ 59~ Cajan .
2~ 59~ C. 0 38 29 = D. M. 2 18 S. 0 40 28 = D. M. 2 21 U. 9 29 30 41 9 27 31 38 9 30 11 Stokolm .
9 28 9 Upsal .
41 38 Par. = 8~ .
50 Par. = 8~ .
50 hh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 0 22 25 = D. M. 2 30 A. 0 45 20 = D. M. 1 59 C. 9 45 34 29 9 22 39 10 9 45 59 Abo .
9 23 40 Calmar .
25 011 ~~ Par. = 7 .
33 Par. =8 64 hh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 0 39 43 = D. M. 2 26 H. 2 42 12 = D. M. 3 44 T. 9 28 16 33 12 50 11 45 9 28 52 Hernosand .
12 49 23 Tobolsk .
00 36 00 48 ~~ Par. =9 27 Par. = 9 .
06 hh~~ ~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 1 11 23 = D. M. 1 18 G. 1 50 55 = D. M. 1 12 G. 8 56 36 1 41 8 17 41 47 8 58 26 Gottingen .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
01 50 01 56 ~~ Par. = 9 .
25 Par. = 9 .
09 ho ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 1 51 25 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 29 27 = D. M. 14 L. 8 16 34 1 48 7 58 32 1 55 8 18 22 Savile-house .
80 21 Leskeard .
01 48 01 49 ~~ Par. = 8 .
50 Par. = 8 .
06 oh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 1 41 39 = D. M. 0 53 P. 15 34 = D. M. 0 29 B. 9 26 20 2692 25 2 30 9 28 25 Paris .
94 54 Bologna .
02502 29 ~~ Par. = 8 .
43 Par. = 8 .
44 hh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 112= D. M. 0 13 R. 16 51 = D. M. 0 24 F. 96 57 2 46 9182 35 99 36 Rome .
93 28 Florence .
02 39 02 20 ~~ Par. = 8 .
14 Par. = 7 .
68 hh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 42 50 = D. M. 2 22 C. 3 28 38 = D. M. 10 G.M. 14 10 49 0 37 13 36 37 1 59 14 11 34 Calcutta .
13 38 30 G. Mount .
00 45 01 53 ~~ Par. = 10 .
34 Par. = 8 .
07 hh ~~~~~~~~ 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 10 7 59 Cajan .
2 59 C. 3 28 21 = D. M. 0 52 T. 3 29 23 = D. M. 10 M. 13 36 20 27 13 37 22 1 59 13 38 25 Tranquebar .
13 39 38 Madrass .
02502 16 ~~ Par. = 8 .
36 Par. = 9 .
71 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 0 27 5= D. M. 2 18 S. 0 25 5= D. M. 2 21 Up .
9 31 59 1 49 9 29 59 1 52 9 30 8 Stokolm .
9 28 9 Upsal .
01 51 01 50 ~~ Par. = 8 .
65 Par. = 8 .
35 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 0 43 9= D. M. 2 30 A. 0 20 14 = D. M. 1 59 C. 9 48 3219 25 81 30 9 45 59 Abo .
9 23 40 Calmar .
02401 28 ~~ Par = 8 .
71 Par. = 8 .
31 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 56 Bologna 0 29 B. 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 0 25 51 = D. M. 2 26 H. 3 47 46 = D. M. 3 44 T. 2 30 47 1 57 12 52 40 3 15 9 28 52 Hernosand .
12 49 23 Tobolsk .
01 55 03 17 ~~ Par. = 8 .
36 Par. = 8 .
58 hh ~~~~~~~~ 950 Bologna 0 29 B. 950 Bologna 0 29 B. 05 49 = D. M. 1 18 G. 0 45 21 = D. M. 1 12 G. 8 59 11 0 49 8 19 39 0 43 8 58 26 Gottingen .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
00 45 00 39 ~~ Par. = 7 .
80 Par. = 7 .
71 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 0 45 51 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 13 53 = D. M. 14 L. 8 19 30 42 8110 35 8 18 22 Savile-House .
80 21 Leaskeard .
00 41 00 40 ~~ Par. = 8 .
30 Par. = 9 .
71 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 950 Bologna 0 29 B. 0 36 5= D. M. 0 53 P. 58 24 = D. M. 2 22 C. 8 28 49 0 24 14 13 24 1 53 8 28 25 Paris .
14 11 34 Calcutta .
00 24 01 50 ~~ Par. = 8 .
50 Par. = 8 .
28 hh ~~~~~~~~ 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 94 54 Bologna 0 29 B. 4 34 12=D .
M. 10 G.M. 4 33 55 = D. M. 0 52 T. 13 39 60 31 13 38 49 0 23 13 38 30 G. Mount .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
00 36 00 24 ~~ Par. = 9 .
87 Par. = 8 .
86 hh ~~~~~~~~ 950 Bologna 0 29 B. 950 Bologna 0 29 B. 4 34 59 = D. M. 10 M. 0 51 39 = D. M. 35 T. 13 39 59 0 31 9 56 39 2 36 13 39 38 Madrass .
9 54 8 Tornea .
00 21 02 31 ~~ Par. = 5 .
76 Par. = 8 .
23 12 49 hh ~~~~~~~~ 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 3 20 41 = D. M. 2 18 S. 3 22 40 = D. M. 2 21 U. 9 28 42 1 26 9 26 43 1 23 9 30 8 Stokolm .
9 28 9 Upsal .
01 26 01 26 ~~ Par. = 8 .
50 Par. = 8 .
80 hh ~~~~~~~~ 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 34 37 = D. M. 2 30 A. 3 27 32 = D. M. 1 59 C. 9 44 46 1 14 9 21 51 1 45 9 45 59 Abo .
9 23 40 Calmar .
01 13 01 49 ~~ Par. = 8 .
40 Par. = 8 .
82 hh ~~~~~~~~ 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 3 21 55 = D. M. 2 26 H. 3 53 35 = D. M. 1 18 G. 9 27 28 1 18 8 55 48 2 26 9 28 52 Hernosand .
8 58 26 Gottingen .
01 24 02 38 ~~ Par. = 9 .
02 Par. = 10 .
57 ~h ~~~~~~~~ 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 4 33 7= D. M. 1 12 G. 4 33 37 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 8 16 16 2 32 8 15 46 2 33 8 19 0 Greenwich .
8 18 22 Savile-House .
02 44 02 36 ~~ Par. = 9 .
11 Par. = 8 .
66 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T~ 4 51 39 = D. M. 14 L. 4 23 51 = D. M. 0 53 P. 7 57 44 2 40 8 25 32 2 51 80 21 Leskeard .
8 28 25 Paris .
02 37 02 53 ' ' ' ' Par. = 8 .
34 Par. = 8 .
60 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 3 49 3= D. M. 0 24 F. 3 4314 = D. M. 0 13 R. 90 20 3 20 9693 31 93 28 Florence .
99 36 Rome .
03803 27 ' ' ' ' Par. = 7 .
99 Par. = 8 .
34 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 1 20 38 = D. M. 2 22 C. 0 46 26 = D. M. 10 G. M. 14 10 11 22 13 35 49 2 44 14 11 34 Calcutta .
13 38 30 G. Mount .
01 33 02 41 ' ' ' ' Par. = 9 .
64 Par. = 8 .
34 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 12 49 23 Tobolsk 3 44 T. 0 46 9= D. M. 0 52 Tr. 0 47 11 = D. M. 10 M. 13 35 32 2 52 13 36 34 2 44 13 38 25 Tranquebar 12 39 38 Madrass .
02 53 034 ' ' ' ' Par. = 8 .
55 Par = 9 .
54 I have explained the manner of this table in a former paper on this subject to which I refer .
I shall now set down the result from each comparison in the following order , that they may be the more easily seen .
Sun 's Parallax .
Sun 's Parallax .
Sun 's Parallax .
' ' ' ' ' ' Cajan~ and Stokolm = 8 .
50 Bolog~ and Stokolm = 8 .
65 Tobolsk and Stokolm = 8 .
50 Upsal = 8 .
50 Upsal -= 8 .
35 Upsal = 8 .
80 Abo = 7 .
33 Abo = 8 .
71 Abo = 8 .
40 Calmar = 8 .
64 Calmar = 8 .
31 Calmar = 8 .
82 Hernosand = 9 .
27 Hernosand = 8 .
36 Hernosand = 9 .
02 Tobolsk = 9 .
06 Tobolsk = 8 .
58 Gottingen = 10 .
57 Gottingen = 9 .
25 Gottingen = 7 .
80 Greenwich = 9 .
11 Greenwich = 9 .
09 Greenwich = 7 .
71 Savile-House = 8 .
66 Savile-House = 8 .
50 Savile-House=8 .
30 Leskeard = 8 .
34 Leskeard = 8 .
06 Leskeard = 9 .
71 Paris = 8 .
60 Paris = 8 .
43 Paris = 8 .
50 Florence = 7 .
99 Bologna = 8 .
44 Calcutta = 8 .
28 Bologna = 8 .
58 Rome = 8 .
14 G. Mount = 9 .
87 Rome = 8 .
34 Florence = 7 .
68 Tranquebar = 8 .
~ Calcutta = 9 .
64 Calcutta = 10 .
34 Madrass = 5 .
76 G. Mount = 8 .
34 G. Mount = 8 .
07 Cajaneburg = 8 .
44 Tranquebar = 8 .
55 Tranquebar = 8 .
36 Tornea = 8 .
23 Madrass = 9 .
54 Madrass = 9 .
71 Cajaneburg = 9 .
07 The mean of these 53 comparisons gives the Sun 's Parallax = 8~ , 61 .
Rejecting all those results which differ more than one second from the mean of the whole , the mean of the remaining 45 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 55 .
Rejecting all those results which differ more than half a second from the mean of the whole , the mean of the remaining 37 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 57 .
The mean of these three means gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 58 .
I shall next compare the observations of the internal contact at the egress made at Paris , Greenwich , Savile-House , Bologna , Madrass , Grand Mount , and Tranquebar , with those made at Stokolm , Upsal , Tornea , Cajaneburg , Tobolsk , Abo , Calmar , Hernosand and Calcutta .
They are as in the following table .
hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 9 28 52 Hernosand 2 26 H. 14 11 34 Calcutta 2 22 C. 484= D. M. 0 51 T. 0 34 29 = D. M. 0 51 T. 13 36 56 1 35 13 37 51 31 13 38 25 Tranquebar .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
01 29 01 20 ' ' ' ' Par. = 7 .
96 Par. = 7 .
47 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 13 10 = D. M. 2 18 S. 11 11 = D. M. 2 21 U. 9 31 37 1 25 9 29 38 1 28 9 30 10 Stokolm .
9 28 9 Upsal .
01 27 01 29 ' ' ' ' Par. = 8 .
70 Par. = 8 .
60 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 1 27 44 = D. M. 35 T. 1 19 14 = D. M. 2 29 A. 9 56 11 2 12 9 47 41 1 36 9 54 8 Tornea .
9 45 59 Abo .
02301 42 ' ' ' ' Par. = 7 .
92 Par. = 9 .
03 hh ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 0 56 19 = D. M. 1 58 C. 11 56 = D. M. 2 26 H. 9 24 46 159 30 23 1 33 9 23 40 Calmar .
9 28 52 Hernosand .
01601 31 ' ' ' ' Par. = 8 .
63 Par. = 8 .
42 ~h ~~~~~~~~ 8 28 27 Paris 0 53 P. 9 30 11 Stokolm 2 18 S. 5 44 29 = D. M. 2 22 C. 1 12 26 = D. M. 1 12 G. 14 12 56 1 29 8 17 45 16 14 11 34 Calcutta .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
01 22 01 15 ~~ Par. = 7 .
83 Par. = 9 .
66 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 28 9 Upsal 2 21 U. 9 54 8 Tornea 35 T. 1 10 27 = D. M. 1 12 G. 1 37 0= D. M. 1 12 G. 8 17 42 198 17 81 53 8 19 0 Greenwich .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
01 18 01 52 ~~ Par. = 9 .
61 Par. = 8 .
42 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 45 59 Abo 2 29 A. 9 23 40 Calmar 1 58 C. 1 28 30 = D. M. 1 12 G. 15 35 = D.M. 1 12 G. 8 17 29 1 17 8 18 50 46 8 19 0 Greenwich .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
01 31 00 55 ~~ Par. = 10 .
04 Par. = 10 .
16 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 28 52 Hernosand 2 26 H. 14 11 34 Calcutta 2 22 C. 1 11 12 = D. M. 1 12 G. 5 53 45 = D. M. 1 12 G. 8 17 40 1 14 8 17 49 1 10 8 19 0 Greenwich .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
01 20 01 11 ~~ Par. = 9 .
20 Par. = 8 .
62 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 30 11 Stokolm 2 18 S. 9 28 9 Upsal 2 21 U. 1 12 56 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 1 10 57 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 8 17 15 178 17 12 1 10 8 18 22 Savile-House .
8 18 22 Savile-House .
01701 10 ~~ Par. = 8 .
50 Par. = 8 .
50 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 54 8 Tornea 35 T. 9 45 59 Abo 2 29 A. 1 37 30 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 1 29 0= D. M. 1 11 S. H. 8 16 38 1 54 8 16 59 1 18 8 18 22 Savile-House .
8 18 22 Savile-House .
01 44 01 23 ~~ Par. = 7 .
75 Par. = 9 .
04 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 23 40 Calmar 1 58 C. 9 28 52 Hernosand 2 26 H. 165= D. M. 1 11 S. H. 1 11 42 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 8 17 35 0 47 8 17 10 1 15 8 18 22 Savile-House .
8 18 22 Savile-House .
00 47 01 12 ~~ Par. = 8 .
50 Par. = 8 .
16 hh ~~~~~~~~ 14 11 34 Calcutta 2 22 C. 9 30 10 Stokolm 2 18 S. 5 54 15 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 47 52 = D. M. 0 59 M. 8 17 19 1 11 13 38 21 19 8 18 22 Savile-house .
13 39 38 Madrass .
01301 36 ~~ Par. = 7 .
54 Par. = 10 .
33 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 28 9 Upsal 2 21 U. 9 54 8 Tornea 35 T. 49 51 = D. M. 0 50 M. 3 43 18 = D. M. 0 59 M. 13 38 01 22 13 37 26 26 13 39 38 Madrass .
13 39 38 Madrass .
01 38 02 12 ~~ Par. = 10 .
15 Par. = 8 .
90 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 45 59 Abo 2 29 A. 9 23 40 Calmar 1 58 C. 3 51 48 = D. M. 0 59 M. 4 14 43 = D. M. 0 59 M. 13 37 47 1 30 13 38 23 0 59 13 39 38 Madrass .
13 39 38 Madrass .
01 51 01 15 ~~ Par. = 10 .
48 Par. = 10 .
80 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 28 52 Hernosand 2 26 H. 14 11 34 Calcutta 2 22 C. 496= D. M. 0 59 M. 0 33 27 = D. M. 0 59 M. 13 37 58 1 27 13 38 71 23 13 39 38 Madrass .
13 39 38 Madrass .
01 40 01 31 ~~ Par. = 9 .
77 Par. = 9 .
32 hh ~~~~~~~~ 9 30 8 Stokolm 2 18 S. 9 28 9 Upsal 2 21 U. 477= D. M. 0 59 G. M. 49 6=D.M .
0 59 G.M. 13 37 15 1 19 13 37 15 1 22 13 38 30 G. Mount .
13 38 30 G. Mount .
01 15 01 15 ~~ Par. = 8 .
07 Par. = 7 .
77 h 9 54~ 8~ Tornea 3~ 5~ T. 9 45~ 59~ Abo 2~ 29~ A. 3 42 33 = D.M. 0 59 G.M. 3 51 3= D.M.0 59 G.M. 13 36 41 26 13 37 21 30 13 38 30 G. Mount .
13 38 30 G. Mount .
01 49 01 28 Par. = 7~ .
35 Par. = 8~ 31 hh 9 23~ 40~ Calmar 1~ 58~ C. 9 28~ 52~ Hernos .
2~ 26~ H. 4 13 58 = D.M. 0 59 G.M. 48 21 = D.M. 0 59 G.M. 13 37 38 0 59 13 37 13 1 27 13 38 30 G. Mount .
13 38 30 G. Mount .
00 52 01 17 Par. = 7~ .
50 Par. = 7~ .
52 hh 14 11~ 34~ Calcutta 2~ 22~ C. 9 30~ 8~ Stokolm 2~ 18~ S. 0 34 12 = D.M. 0 59 G.M. 46 50 = D. M. 0 51 T. 13 37 22 1 23 13 36 58 1 27 13 38 30 G. Mount .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
01801 27 Par. = 6~ .
96 Par. = 8~ .
50 hh 9 28~ 9~ Upsal 2~ 21~ U. 9 54~ 8~ Tornea 3~ 5~ T. 48 49 =D .
M. 0 51 T. 3 42 16 = D. M. 0 51 T. 12 36 58 1 30 13 36 24 2 14 13 38 25 Tranquebar .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
01 27 021 Par. = 8~ .
23 Par. = 7~ .
68 hh 9 45~ 59~ Abo 2~ 29~ A. 9 23~ 40~ Calmar 1~ 58~ C. 3 50 46 = D. M. 0 51 T. 4 13 41 = D. M. 0 51 T. 13 36 45 1 38 13 37 21 17 13 38 25 Tranquebar .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
01 40 014 Par. = 8~ .
67 Par. = 8~ .
12 The results are set down in the following table .
~ 's Par. Stok .
Upsal .
Torn .
Cajan .
Tobo .
Abo .
Calm .
Hern Calcu .
Mean .
Paris .
8~.70 8~.60 7~.92 8~.43 8~.60 9~.03 8~.63 8~.42 7~.83 8~.46 Greenwich .
9.66 9.61 8.42 9.09 9.11 10.04 10.16 9.20 8.62 9.32 Savile-House .
8.50 8.50 7.75 8.50 8.66 9.04 8.50 8.16 7.54 8.36 Bologna .
8 65 8.35 8.23 8.44 8.58 8.71 8.31 8.36 8.28 8.43 Madrass .
10.33 10.15 8.90 9.71 9.54 10.48 10.80 9.77 9.32 9.89 Grand Mount .
8.07 7.77 7.35 8.07 8.34 8.31 7.50 7.52 6.96 7.76 Tranquebar .
8.50 8.23 7.68 8.36 8.55 8.67 8.12 7.96 7.47 8.17 Sun'sPar , mean .
8.91 8.75 8.03 8.66 8.77 9.18 8.86 8.48 8.00 8.63 The mean of these 63 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 63 ; and if we reject all those which differ more than one second from the mean of the whole the mean of the remaining 49 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 50 .
And if we reject all those which differ more than half a second from the mean of the whole , the mean of the remaining 37 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 535 ; the mean therefore of these three means gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 55 .
Thus by the mean of 53 comparisons the Sun 's parallax is determined to be = 8~ , 58 , and by the mean of 63 comparisons the Sun 's parallax is determined to be = 8~ , 55 .
The mean of these two means gives 8~ , 565 for the parallax of the Sun on the day of the transit .
It may be objected , that this determination cannot be depended on to a very great precision , because the greatest difference of the effect of the parallaxes in any of these comparisons does not exceed 3~ 31~ : consequently that this is too small a base , from which we can expect any great exactness in the determination of the Sun 's parallax : But if we consider the great number of comparisons ( no less than 116 ) , the certainty of the differences of longitude of most of the places of observation , and the small differences in the results themselves , I cannot help thinking that the force of this objection is in some measure removed ; and that this determination of the Sun 's parallax , by the observations at places on this side of the Line only , must be very near the truth .
In order , therefore , to remove the force of this objection entirely , let us next consider the observation at the Cape of Good Hope , by which we shall have a base very near three times greater than the former , and also the observation at Rodrigues , by which the base is nearly double of the former .
But before I proceed I must take notice , that , in the Memoir , by M. Pingre , before mentioned , the time of the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues is set down at oh 36~ 49~ .
But in the same volume there is an account of M. Pingre 's observation sent to the R. Academy before his arrival in Europe , and the time of the internal contact is therein set down at 0h 34~ 47~ .
Also in a letter from him to the R. Society , on his arrival in Europe at Lisbon , and dated the 6th of March 1762 , and which letter is printed in the Phil. Transactions , vol. LII .
part I. the time of the internal contact is therein set down at 0h 34~ 47~ true time .
In another letter from him at Lisbon to the Royal Society , dated the 14th of March 1762 , the time of the internal contact is again set down at 0h 34~ 47~ true time , and he ends this letter in these words , ` ` Notez que l'attouchement intern des Bords s'est faite a 0h 34~ 47~ .
Je fais cette remarque , parceque , vu la proximite de prononciation , qui dans notre langue est entre 30 and 40 , celle attouchement se trouvoit marque 10~ plutot qu'il no devoit l'etre , dans un copy que j'ai faite pour mon usage ; cette erreur aura peut etre pass dans quelque autre copy .
Mais , selon l'original , il faut absolument lire 0h 34~ 47~ .
M. Pingre has no where , that I can find , in the said memoir given any reason for this alteration of the time of the contact .
If the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues happend at 0h 34~ 47~ , and if this is compared with the same observation at Tobolsk the parallax of the Sun comes out = 7~ , 36 .
If the time of the contact at Rodrigues was at 0h 35~ 47~ , and if this is compared with the same observation at Tobolsk , then the parallax of the Sun is found = 8~ , 62 .
Again if the time of the contact at Rodrigues was at 0h 36~ 49~ , and if this is compared with the observation at Tobolsk , the parallax of the Sun will be found = 9~ , 93 .
But to return .
M. Pingre , in his letter to the Royal Society dated at Lisbon the 14th of March 1762 , sets down the time of the internal contact at the egress at 0h 34~ 47~ true time , and with regard to the time of the external contact expresses himself thus ` ` a 0h 53~ 18~ le soleil a paru pendant 3 ou 4 secondes .
Je n'ai pas vu le disque du soleil bien ferme , il me paroissoit un peu altere au lieu de la sortie de Venus .
M. Thuillier no voyoit rien avec la Lunette de 9 peids .
J'ai de la peine a me persuader que Venus soit sortie plutot .
' ' It is plain from these words that M. Pingre believed that the external contact did not happen before 0h 53~ 18~ .
This being allowed , let us compute the duration of the egress at Rodrigues , which we shall find = 17~ 55~ .
It follows , therefore , that the internal contact happened at 0h 35~ 23~ .
But this supposes that the observer could see the very last contact of Venus with the Sun 's limb , the contrary of which I have shown in a former paper on this subject We are therefore certain that the external contact happened later than 0h 53~ 18~ , by several seconds , consequently the internal contact happened later than 0h 35~ 23~ by several seconds .
Upon the whole , therefore , we may safely conclude that there is a mistake of one minute in setting down the time of the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues , and that , instead of 0h 34~ 47~ , it should be 0h 35~ 47~ .
This sort of mistake has happened several times in the observations of this transit , but they are easily discovered .
I shall now proceed to compare the observation of the internal contact at the Cape , with the observation of the same contact at Rodrigues and at 20 places to the north of the Line , and also the observation at Rodrigues with the same 20 places , and they are as follow .
~h ~~~~~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 2 59 7= D. M. 2 59 R. 14 19 = D. M. 0 53 P. 12 38 57 398 35 31 71 12 35 47 Rodrigues .
8 28 27 Paris .
03 10 074 ~~ Par. = 8 .
54 Par. = 8 .
56 hh ~~~~~~~~ 6 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 0 28 14 = D. M. 0 29 B. 0 23 42 = D. M. 0 13 R. 9 11 36 6 37 9 16 86 21 94 57 Bologna .
99 36 Rome .
06 39 06 32 ~~ Par. = 8 .
54 Par. = 8 .
74 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 0 29 31 = D. M. 0 24 F. 0 34 3= D. M. 1 18 G. 9 10 19 6 32 95 47 7 26 93 28 Florence .
8 58 26 Gottingen .
06 51 07 21 ~~ Par. = 8 .
91 Par. = 8 .
40 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 1 13 35 = D. M. 1 12 G. 1 14 5= D. M. 1 11 S.H. 8 26 15 7 20 8 25 45 7 19 8 19 0 Greenwich .
8 18 22 Savile-House .
07 15 07 23 ~~ Par. = 8 .
40 Par. = 8 .
57 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 1 32 7= D. M. 14 L. 080= D. M. 1 59 C. 87 43 7 12 9 31 50 87 80 21 Leskeard .
9 23 40 Calmar .
07 22 08 10 Par. = 8~ .
69 Par. = 8~ 55 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 02 23 = D. M. 2 26 H. 038= D. M. 2 21 U. 9 37 27 8 34 9 36 42 8 29 0 28 52 Hernosand .
9 28 9 Upsal .
08 35 08 33 Par. = 8~ .
51 Par. = 8~ .
57 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 019= D. M. 2 18 S. 0 14 55 = D. M. 2 30 A. 9 38 41 8 26 9 54 45 8 38 9 30 10 Stokolm .
9 45 59 Abo .
08 31 08 46 Par. = 8~ .
58 Par. = 8~ .
63 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 0 37 20 = D. M. 2 59 C. 0 23 25 = D. M. 35 T. 10 17 10 97 10 3 15 9 13 10 7 59 Cajaneburg .
9 54 8 Tornea .
09 11 097 Par. = 8~ .
56 Par. = 8~ .
41 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 3 19 32 = D. M. 3 44 T. 4 40 10 = D. M. 2 22 C. 12 59 22 9 52 14 20 08 30 12 49 23 Tobolsk .
14 11 34 Calcutta .
09 59 08 26 Par. = 8~ .
64 Par. = 8~ .
43 h~~~~h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 46 43 = D. M. 0 59 M. 45 58 = D. M. 0 59 G. M. 13 46 33 77 13 45 48 77 13 39 38 Madrass .
13 38 30 Grand Mount .
06 55 07 18 Par. = 8~ .
28 Par. = 8~ .
70 h~~~~ 9 39 50 Cape 68 C. 45 41 = D. M. 0 51 M. Rodrigues and the following places compared together .
13 45 31 6 59 13 38 25 Tranquebar .
076 Par. = 8~ .
60 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 43 26 = D. M. 0 53 P. 3 27 21 = D. M. 0 29 B. 8 32 21 3 52 98 26 3 28 8 28 27 Paris .
94 57 Bologna .
03 54 03 29 Par. = 8~ .
58 Par. = 8~ .
54 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 3 22 49 = D. M. 0 13 R. 3 28 38 = D. M. 0 24 F. 9 12 58 3 12 9793 23 99 36 Rome .
93 28 Florence .
03 22 03 41 Par. = 8~ .
94 Par. = 9~ .
24 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 3 33 10 = D. M. 1 18 G. 4 12 42 = D. M. 1 12 G. 92 37 4 17 8 23 54 11 8 58 26 Gottingen .
8 19 0 Greenwich .
04 11 045 Par. = 8~ .
30 Par. = 8~ .
33 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 4 13 12 = D. M. 1 11 S. H. 4 31 14 = D. M. 14 L. 8 22 35 4 10 84 33 43 8 18 22 Savile-House .
80 21 Leskeard .
04 13 04 12 Par. = 8~ .
59 Par. = 8~ .
81 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 377= D. M. 1 59 C. 31 30 = D. M. 2 26 H. 9 28 40 4 58 9 34 17 5 25 9 23 40 Calmar .
9 28 52 Hernosand .
05005 25 Par. = 8~ .
56 Par. = 8~ .
50 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 32 15 = D. M. 2 21 U. 30 16 = D. M. 2 18 S. 9 33 32 5 20 9 35 31 5 17 9 28 9 Upsal .
9 30 11 Stokolm .
05 23 05 20 Par. = 8~ .
58 Par. = 8~ .
58 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 2 44 12 = D. M. 2 30 A. 2 21 47 = D. M. 2 59 C. 9 51 35 5 29 10 14 05 58 9 45 59 Abo .
10 7 59 Cajaneburg .
05 36 061 Par. = 8~ .
68 Par. = 8~ .
57 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 2 35 42 = D. M. 35 T. 0 20 25 = D. M. 3 44 T. 10 0564 12 56 12 6 43 9 54 8 Tornea .
12 49 23 Tobolsk .
05 57 06 49 Par. = 8~ .
33 Par. = 8~ .
62 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 1 41 3= D. M. 2 22 C. 17 36 = D. M. 0 59 M. 14 16 50 5 21 13 43 23 3 58 14 11 34 Calcutta .
13 39 38 Madrass .
05 16 03 45 Par. = 8~ .
37 Par. = 8~ .
03 h~~~~h~~~~ 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 12 35 47 Rodr .
2 59 R. 16 51 = D. M. 0 59 G. M. 16 34 = D. M. 0 51 T. 13 42 38 3 58 13 42 21 3 50 13 38 30 Grand Mount .
13 38 25 Tranquebar .
04803 56 Par. = 8~ .
85 Par. = 8~ .
74 The results of the Sun 's parallax from these several comparisons are as follow .
Sun 's Parallax , Sun 's Parallax .
Cape of G. Hope and Rodrigues = 8~ .
54 Rodrigues and Cape of G. Hope = 8~ .
54 Paris = 8 .
56 Paris = 8 .
58 Bologna = 8 .
54 Bolonga = 8 .
54 Rome = 8 .
74 Rome = 8 .
94 r. Florence = 8 .
91 r. Florence = 9 .
24 r. Gottingen = 8 .
40 .
Gottingen = 8 .
30 r. Greenwich = 8 .
40 Greenwich = 8 .
33 r. Savile-House = 8 .
57 Savile-House = 8 .
59 Leskeard = 8 .
69 Leskeard = 8 .
81 r. Calmar = 8 .
55 Calmar = 8 .
56 Hernosand = 8 .
51 Hernosand = 8 .
50 Upsal = 8 .
57 Upsal = 8 .
58 Stokolm = 8 .
58 Stokolm = 8 .
58 Abo = 8 .
63 Abo = 8 .
68 Cajaneburg = 8 .
~ Cajaneburg = 8 .
57 Tornea = 8 .
41 Tornea = 8 .
33 r. Tobolsk = 8 .
64 Tobolsk = 8 .
62 Calcutta = 8 .
43 Calcutta = 8 .
37 Madrass = 8 .
28 r. Madrass = 8 .
03 r. G. Mount = 8 .
70 G. Mount = 8 .
85 r. Tranquebar = 8 .
60 Tranquebar = 8 .
74 The mean of the 21 comparison with the observation at the Cape , gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 56 .
There are only two of these 21 comparisons , marked with the letter r , which differ more than 2/ 10 of a second from the mean of the whole ; let these be rejected , and the mean of the remaining 19 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 56 .
If we select out of these 21 comparisons those places whose difference of longitude may be supposed to be the best determined , the mean of these may be regarded as the most exact determination , viz. Paris , Bologna , Greenwich , Savile-House , Upsal , Stokolm , Cajaneburg and Tobolsk ; the mean of these gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 55 , and if we leave out the results of Greenwich and Tobolsk , which differ the most from the rest , the mean of the remaining 6 results gives it = 8~ , 56 the same as before .
The mean of the 21 comparisons with the observation at Rodrigues gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 57 , and if we reject 8 of them , which are marked with the letter r , and which differ more than 2/ 16 of a second from the mean of the whole , the mean of the remaining 13 results gives the Sun 's parallax 8~ , 57 , differing only one hundredth part of a second from that which was determined from the observation at the Cape , and agreeing in a most surprising manner with what was formerly determined by the comparisons of the the observations at places on this side of the Line only , where the base was so small , as I said before ; a most convincing proof of the great precision with which the parallax of the Sun is determined by the late transit of Venus .
We shall now enquire into the limits of the error that may attend the determination of the parallax by the observation of the internal contact .
An error of 1~ 10~ of time in the observation at Tobolsk when compared with the observation at the Cape , will produce an error of 1~ in the Sun 's parallax : and if we suppose an error of 35~ of time in the observation vation at Tobolsk , and an error of the same quantity in the observation at the Cape , and both in contrary directions , this also will produce an error of only 1~ in the Sun 's parallax .
If therefore no greater error could be committed in the observations at Tobolsk and the Cape , we are certain that the comparison of Tobolsk and the Cape gives the Sun 's parallax so exact , that the error does not exceed one second from the true parallax .
But this is too great an error to be supposed in the observations , because I have shown , in my former paper , that an error of only 6~ in time was committed in the observation of the contact by persons observing even in the same place ; therefore , if we suppose an error of 6~ of time in the observation at Tobolsk , and an error of the same quantity in the observation at the Cape , and both in contrary directions , the error produced in the parallax by those 12~ , will amount only to 1/ 6 of a second , even though we had only these two observations to determine the Sun 's parallax : But since we have a great number of very good observations , made at other places , it follows that the mean of all these , must give the Sun 's parallax to a less error than 1/ 6 of a second , and consequently very near the truth .
In all places where the internal contact at the egress was observed , and where there were more observers than one , we find a difference in the time of each observer ; the observation at Greenwich is an exception to this , as the three observers all agree to the same second , in the observation of the contact of tions and of different magnifying powers .
This coincidence not only surprised me , but also the reverend Mr. Hornsby , now Savilian professor of Astronomy at Oxford .
Mr. Hornsby went to Greenwich in the beginning of the year 1762 , and on his return told me , that his surprise was at an end , for he had been informed at Greenwich , that Mr. Green , the assistant observer there , as soon as he judged that the internal contact was formed , called out now .
This must certainly have caused some disturbance to the other observers , and might possibly influence their judgment : and the fact ( as I am informed ) was that each observer had a second watch in his hand , and they instantly stopped their watches , each having his hand at his watch ready to stop .
This problem , therefore , is easily solved , and the surprise at the coincidence entirely vanishes ; so that this observation can be looked on as no more than the observation of one person , and he too not much practised in observing .
Moreover it is proper I should observe that another person was present at this observation , who confirmed the above account .
The very near coincidence of the three observers at Greenwich , in the time of the external contact remains now to be accounted for .
Mr. Green did not call out at this time , because he was forbid by Dr. Bradley , who was present , though not in a condition to observe because of his bad state of health .
This problem therefore may be solved in the following manner .
The observation of the external contact was undoubtedly more uncertain than the former , and yet we find two of the observers agreeing to the same second , and the third differing only one second from them .
If we attend to the following circum5 stances , stances , we shall be immediately satisfied by them .
Each observer had a second-watch in his hand ; the three observers were at the same window of the same room , one of them on the leads immediately without the window , and the other two within the window ; therefore each observer was within hearing and seeing of each other ; consequently the instant one of the observers stopped his watch , may it not be presumed that the noise of the nicking of it might be heard by the rest ?
especially as there was a profound silence during the time of the observation .
I have thought proper to take notice of these facts , because several persons both at home and abroad have expressed their surprise at this coincidence , and that such an exactness may not be established as a precedent in these sort of observations ; and because I think it essentially necessary , in all sorts of observations , especially in one of so much importance in astronomy as this , that every the minutest circumstance should be particularly related .
We are now to find the limits of the error arising from the difference of longitude between Tobolsk and the Cape .
I find that an error of 1~10~ in time in the difference of longitude between these two places will cause an error of 1~ in the Sun 's parallax .
But as we are certain that this error in longitude does not take place ; therefore we are certain that the error in the parallax is within one second of the truth .
The difference of longitude between the Cape of Good Hope and Paris is determined , both by the observations of M. de la Caille and Mr. Mason ; the difference of longitude between Paris and Upsal in Sweden is settled by the observations of Jupiter 's piter 's first satellite , and the difference of longitude between Upsal and Tobolsk is settled , by the observations of the contact at the ingress at both places , by the method of M. Pingre above mentioned .
Therefore the difference of longitude between the Cape and Tobolsk is very exactly settled , so exactly , that I am persuaded that the error does not amount to 5 or 6 seconds .
Therefore the error in the parallax arising from the error of the difference of longitude is extremely small , scarcely amounting to 1/ 12 part of a second .
Therefore we are certain that the error in the sun 's parallax arising both from the error of observation and the error of longitude does not exceed 1/ 4 of a second in the comparison of the observations of the internal contact at Tobolsk and at the Cape , even though we had no more observations to determine the Sun 's parallax ; but the mean of a great many more must bring it very near the truth .
I now proceed to determine the parallax of the Sun from the total durations observed at different places .
If therefore we compare the durations observed at Tobolsk , Cajaneburg , Abo , and Tornea , with the durations observed at Madrass , Grand Mount and Tranquebar , which give the greatest differences , the results of the Sun 's parallax will be as follow .
Sun 's Par. Difference of duration .
' ' ' ' ' Tobolsk and Madrass = 9 .
61 2 50 G. Mount = 8 .
33 2 27 Tranquebar = 8 .
52 2 40 Cajaneburg and Madrass = 10 .
09 r. 1 49 G. Mount = 8 .
00 1 26 Tranquebar = 8 .
33 1 39 Abo and Madrass = 10 .
66 r. 1 34 G. Mount = 8 .
33 1 11 Tranquebar = 8 .
60 1 24 Tornea and Madrass = 9 .
20 1 34 G. Mount = 7 .
00 r. 1 11 Tranquebar = 7 .
50 r. 1 24 The mean of these 12 results gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 68 , and if we reject four of them , which are marked with the letter r , and which differ the most from the rest , the mean of the remaining 8 gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 61 .
This determination of the Sun 's parallax cannot be depended on to any great precision , because of the small differences between the durations compared , the greatest of which amounts only to 2~50~ , and also because of the small number of comparisons .
It serves only to show nearly what is the quantity of the Sun 's parallax .
We are now to determine the limits of the error in the determination of the Sun 's parallax by the durations observed at two different places .
The greatest difference of duration is between Tobolsk and Madrass , which amounts only to 2~ 50~ .
If therefore an error of 20~ in time is committed in the observations of the ingress and egress at both the places compared , this error of 20~ in time will cause an error of 1~ in the result of the Sun 's parallax , and in the comparisons of those places where the difference of duration is less , will occasion a greater error , and therefore the determination of the parallax , by this method , cannot be depended on to any great exactness , because of the small differences of the durations compared .
In this method , however , we are free from the uncertainty arising from the difference of longitude not being exactly known .
I now proceed to the determination of the Sun 's parallax by the least distance of the centers .
There are come to my hands only two measurements of the greatest distance of the limbs of the Sun and Venus , one at Tobolsk and the other at Rodrigues .
I shall only consider the measurement at Rodrigues , because there seems to me to be some mistake in the measurement at Tobolsk .
If we suppose the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 5 , then the apparent middle of the transit happened at Rodrigues at 9h 37~ 30~ .
There is a measurement by M. Pingre of the greatest distance of the limbs at 9h 38~ 13~ , which is so near the middle of the transit that we may safely take this quantity , viz. 5~ 54~ , 6 * , for the greatest distance of the limbs of the Sun and Venus , and especially as it is marked an exact observation .
This measurement , therefore , gives the apparent least distance of the centers of the *I all along consider the observation of M. Pingre at Rodrigues as it is printed , from his own letter , in the Philosophical Transactions .
Sun and Venus at Rodrigues = 9~ 21~ , 4 .
Supposing then this measurement to be exact , here follows an irrefragable argument , independent of all other methods , to prove that the parallax of the Sun is very nearly = 8~ , 5 .
Let us suppose the Sun 's parallax = 10~ , and let us compute , by the following method , the apparent least distance of the centers at Tobolsk ; from thence we shall find that the geocentric least distance of the centers at Tobolsk is 567~ , 416 , and by the observation at Rodrigues the geocentric least distance of the centers is = 572~ , 612 , so that , on this supposition , we have two different geocentric least distances of the centers , which being absurd , it follows that the Sun 's parallax is not 10~ .
Again let us suppose that the Sun 's parallax is = 7~ , we shall find that the geocentric least distance of the centers by the observation at Tobolsk is = 575~ , 356 , and by the observation at Rodrigues it is = 569~ , 248 .
Thus then , again , we have two different geocentric least distances of the centers , which being absurd , it follows that the parallax of the Sun is not 7~ .
Again if we suppose the Sun 's parallax = 8~ or 9~ , we shall find that the same absurdity will follow , but in these two last suppositions we shall find that the differences of the geocentric least distances of the centers are not so great as on the suppositions of 10~ and 7~ , it therefore follows that the parallax of the Sun is less than 9~ and more than 8 , and if we continue to reason in the same manner we shall find , that on the supposition that the Sun 's parallax is = 8~ , 5 , the geocentric least distances of the centers severally found by the observe O L. LIII .
Xx vation vation at Tobolsk and at Rodrigues is very nearly the same , consequently that the Sun 's parallax is very nearly = 8~ , 5 .
If we pursue this subject to a greater precision , and suppose that the measurement of the greatest distance of the limbs of the Sun and Venus , taken by M. Pingre , to be perfectly exact , and compute on true * principles the apparent least distances of the centers from the durations observed at the different places in the north ( the method of which I shall afterwards give ) the parallax of the Sun will come out as follows , when they are compared with that measured at Rodrigues : Cajan .
Calm .
Tobol .
Torn .
Upsal .
Stoko .
Abo .
~ .
Rodrigues 8~ , 60 8~ , 58 8~ , 65 8~ , 48 8~ , 60 8~ , 40 8~ , 63 8~ , 55 The mean of these eight comparisons gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 56 being the very same , as that which we found before by the comparisons of the internal contacts .
Again let us reduce the observed durations , at the following several places , to the center , on the supposition that the Sun 's parallax is = 8~ , 56 as in the following table , Tobolsk .
Cajaneburg .
Tornea .
hhh ~~~~~~ 5 48 53 = Obs. Du .
5 49 54 = Obs. Du .
5 50 9= Obs. Du .
096= Parallax .
088= Parallax .
083= Parallax .
5 58 59 = Cent. D. 5 58 2= Cent. D. 5 58 12 = Cent. D. *I say on true principles , because I have reason to think that there is a mistake in the method given by M. Pingre in the aforesaid Memoir .
Upsal .
Stokolm .
Abo .
hhh ~~~~~~ 5 50 26 = Obs. Du .
5 50 42 = Obs. Du .
5 50 9= Obs. Du .
07 36 = Parallax .
07 37 = Parallax .
07 49 = Parallax .
5 58 2= Cent. D. 5 58 19 = Cent. D. 5 57 58 = Cent. D. Hernosand .
Calmar .
Calcutta .
hhh ~~~~~~ 5 50 26 = Obs. Du .
5 50 39 = Obs. Du .
5 50 36 = Obs. Du .
07 39 = Parallax .
07 24 = Parallax .
07 35 = Parallax .
5 58 5= Cent. D. 5 58 3= Cent. D. 5 58 11 = Cent. D. Madrass .
Grand Mount .
Abo .
hhh ~~~~~~ 5 51 43 = Obs. Du .
5 51 20 = Obs. Du .
5 51 33 = Obs. Du .
06 35 = Parallax .
06 35 = Parallax .
06 26 = Parallax .
5 58 18 = Cent. D. 5 57 55 = Cent. D. 5 57 59 = Cent. D. The mean of these 12 central durations gives the mean central duration = 5h 58~ 5~ ; from this central duration , we shall find that the geocentric least distance of the centers is = 571~ , or 9~ 31~ .
Let us compare the above apparent least distance of the centers measured at Rodrigues with this geocentric least distance of the centers , and we shall find that the parallax of the Sun from thence resulting is = 8~ , 56 the same as before .
These results of the parallax , arising from the comparisons of the apparent least distances of the centers , agreeing with the former determinations of the parallax by the internal contacts , are a proof of the accuracy of this measurement of the greatest distance of the limbs made by M. Pingre at Rodrigues .
There are 12 places at which the total duration was observed , three of these had a northern parallax of latitude at the middle of the transit , the other nine had a southern parallax of latitude ; let the apparent least distance of the centers at each place of observation be sound , by the following method , let these be compared together , and we shall have the parallax of the Sun resulting from them .
For this purpose I have computed the apparent least distance of the centers at the 8 following places , and have compared them with the apparent least distance of the centers at the four following places , and from each comparison I have computed the parallax of the Sun , and they are as in the following table .
~ Par. Cajan .
Calm .
Tobol .
Tornea Upsal .
Stoko .
Abo .
Herno .
mean .
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' Tranquebar 8 .
48 8 .
45 8 .
54 8 .
31 8 .
48 8 .
20 8 .
52 8 .
42 8 .
42 Madrass 8 .
79 8 .
76 8 .
93 8 .
61 8 .
79 8 .
50 8 .
82 8 .
73 8 .
74 G. Mount 8 .
42 8 .
38 8 .
45 8 .
24 8 .
42 8 .
12 8 .
45 8 .
35 8 .
35 Calcutta 8 .
69 8 .
65 8 .
81 8 .
43 8 .
68 8 .
35 8 .
73 8 .
61 8 .
62 O 'sP.mean .
8 .
59 8 .
56 8 .
68 8 .
40 8 .
59 8 .
29 8 .
63 8 .
53 8 .
53 The mean of these 32 comparisons gives the Sun 's parallax = 8~ , 53 .
This very near agreement with the former determinations is somewhat surprising , when we consider the smallness of the base from which they are computed , the greatest scarcely exceeding 20~ of an angle ; but we are also to consider , that the apparent least distance of the centers may be found , from the duration observed , to a very great exactness , and nothing affects the accuracy of it , but the errors in the observation .
Let us suppose then that an error , of 6~ in time , happened in each of the observations of the ingress and egress , both in contrary directions ; the sum of the errors , therefore , in each comparison , will amount to 24~ of time ; this will produce an error of 1~ of space in the apparent least distance of the centers by computation , but this error of 1~ cannot produce an error of so much as half a second in the determination of the Sun 's parallax .
It therefore follows , on the above supposition of an error of 24~ of time in the observation , that though we had no other observations of the transit of Venus than two of the above total durations , ( suppose that of Cajaneburg and Madrass ) yet we should have been absolutely certain of the parallax of the Sun within less than an error of half a second , and therefore of course it follows , that the mean of so great a number of results must be very near the truth .
This determination of the Sun 's parallax , by the least distance of the centers , is also a convincing proof that there is no mistake in the observation of Mr. Mason at the Cape , as alleged by M. Pingre , and that there must be a mistake of 1~in setting down the time of the internal contact at the egress at Rodrigues , notwithstanding M. Pingre , in the aforesaid memoir , prefers his observation to that of Mr. Mason , because , as he says , that after a strict examination of all the circumstances attending his observation , he could not find any mistake in it , but also because he has proved that no mistake could possibly be committed .
In this determination of the parallax by the apparent least distance of the centers , we are not embarrassed with an exact knowledge of the difference of longitude between the places compared , which therefore in some measure compensates for the smallness of the base .
The same irrefragable argument , made use of in the apparent least distance of the centers , measured at Rodrigues , to prove that the parallax of the Sun is very nearly = 8~ 5 , may likewise be deduced from the apparent least distance of the centers , computed from the total durations observed at these 12 places , but with more certainty ; because the determination of the apparent least distances of the centers from the observed total durations may be depended on to a very great precision , but the same cannot be said with regard to the apparent least distance of the centers measured at Rodrigues : For M. Pingre tells us that he used a very good micrometer fitted to a refracting telescope of nine feet focus , the object-glass of which was but an indifferent one ; and we are very certain , that in measuring , with a micrometer of this sort , dark objects on a white field or ground , if the image is any way indistinct , the angle measured will be less than the true angle , and vice versa when a bright object is measured on a dark ground ; as a proof of this remark , we find that M. Pingre measured and found the diameter of Venus , when on the Sun , = 54~ , 7 , whereas we are certain that it was above 58~ , and therefore we may presume that the measurements of the greatest distance of the limbs might be greater than the true distance , and as a further proof of the uncertainty of the measurements made with this instrument we find that M. Pingre makes the distance of the limbs greatest , several minutes after it was past the greatest .
I shall now produce , at one view , the means of the several determinations of the Sun 's parallax , by the before-mentioned three several methods , which will contain the substance of this whole paper .
1mo .
The mean of 116 comparisons of the internal contacts observed at places to = 8 .
565 the north of the Line only , gives the Sun 's parallax 2do .
The mean of 21 comparisons of the internal contacts , with that at the = 8 .
56 Cape , gives the Sun 's parallax 3tio .
The mean of 21 comparisons of the internal contacts with that at Rod= 8 .
57 rigues , gives the Sun 's parallax 4to .
The mean of the comparisons of = 8 .
61 the total durations gives the Sun 's parallax 5to .
The mean of the apparent least distances of the centers compared with that = 8 .
56 measured at Rodrigues , gives the Sun 's parallax 6to .
The mean of the apparent least distances of the centers by computation from = 8 .
53 the total durations compared together , gives the Sun 's parallax The mean of these 6 means gives the = 8 .
566 Sun 's parallax And if we reject the mean arising from the comparisons of the total durations , = 8 .
557 which is the least certain , the mean of the other 5 means gives the Sun 's parallax Thus is the Sun 's parallax , on the day of the transit , concluded to be = 8~ , 56 , and that from three different modes of comparing together a great number of observations variously combined ; the several results so nearly coinciding that to me it seems impossible , that the mean of them all can err 1/ 10 of a second , and that probably the error does not exceed 1/ 500 part of the whole quantity , as the great Dr. Halley had , many years since , confidently presaged * , and thereupon I cannot but congratulate our age and nation , particularly this society on being enabled , through the royal munificence , to send fit observers to the Cape of Good Hope , whose position affords the largest base , and consequently the safest foundation for the truth .
P. S. M. Pingre , in his aforesaid memoir , seems to think that there must be some mistake in Mr. Mason 's observation at the Cape , because by comparing the observations of Jupiter 's satellites made by Mr. Mason at the Cape , with those made by M. Messier at Paris , he finds the difference of longitude between these two places less by 1~ of time , than between Paris and the observatory of M. de la Caille at the Cape , and therefore imagines that Mr. Mason 's observatory was to the west of M. de la Caille 's .
If M. Pingre had looked into the map of the Cape by M de la Caille , he would have seen , that , if Mr. Mason 's observatory had been 1~ of time to the west * Ut juniorbus nostris astronomis , quibus forsan haec observare , ob minorem aetatem , obtingere potest , viam praemonstrem , qua immensam solis distantiam , intra quingentesimam sui partem , rite dimetiri poterint .
Ph. Tr. N. cccxlviii .
p. 454 .
of M. de la Caille 's , it must have been in the ocean .
I am not at all surprised to see a difference or error of 1~ of time in deducing the difference of longitude between Paris and the cape , by comparing Mr. Mason 's observations with those of M. Messier ; for I find , in the last volume of the Memoirs for 1761 , a difference of 1~ 5~ between M. de la Land and M. Messier in an immersion of the first satellite of Jupiter , both of these gentlemen observing at Paris , owing I suppose to the different goodness of the telescopes used on this occasion , for M. de la Land says that he used an 18 foot refracter , the object-glass of which was tolerably good , and that M. Messier made use of a very good reflecter of 30 inches .
If M. Pingre will take the trouble of looking into the Philosophical Transactions , vol. LII .
part I. he will there find observations made at the Cape , and in Surrey-street , London , of the immersions of the first and second satellites of Jupiter with reflecting telescopes , of equal goodness , of two feet focal length , where the difference of determination of the longitude of these two places , does not exceed one second in those of the first satellite , and not above 16~ in those of the second satellite .
Mr. Mason 's observatory at the Cape was about half a mile to the south of M. de la Caille 's , and about 10 or 12 yards to the west of the meridian of the same .
M. Pingre also seems to think that the time shown by Mr. Mason 's clock was taken from a false meridian .
When M. Pingre shall read the account given by Mr. Mason of his observations at the Cape , which he says in his Memoir he has not seen , I am persuaded he will be fully satisfied , from the many eV O L. LIII .
Yy qual qual-altitudes taken by Mr. Mason , that there can be no doubt of the times of his observations being found from a true meridian .
I cannot leave this subject without taking notice of a remarkable expression in the history of the Memoirs of the R. Academy at Paris page 96 , for the year 1757 .
It is there said that the English intended to send an astronomer to North America to observe the transit of Venus ( according to the plan laid down by Dr. Halley ) before they saw the map of the transit by M. de L'isle , and the authority produced for this assertion , are the English news papers , which , if they had understood the nature of these papers , can be no authority at all .
I must therefore , on the best authority , inform the gentlemen , who are the compilers of the history of these memoirs , that the R. Society never once thought of sending an observer to North America , even before they saw the map of the transit by M. de L'isle .
N. B. In this paper I have employed the same elements as in my former paper on this subject , except that in reducing time to space I have made use of 4~ 0~ , 03 for the horary motion of Venus in her path .
A method of determining the apparent least distance of the centers of the Sun and Venus from the observation of the total duration of the transit observed any one place , and also the geocentric least distance of the centers .
LETBCPL [ Tab. XVII .
Fig. 1 .
] represent the disk of the Sun , LSP the ecliptic , OR the geocentric path of Venus over the Sun , AD the apparent path at any place , to the north of the plane of Venus 's orbit , SM the geocentric least distance of the centers , AK the parallax of latitude at the internal contact at the ingress , ND the parallax of latitude at the internal contact at the egress , Ab the parallax of longitude at the ingress , and cD the parallax of longitude at the egress .
It is required to find S F , which is a perpendicular let fall from the center of the Sun on the apparent path , and from thence to find SM the geocentric least distance of the centers of the Sun and Venus .
If the parallax of longitude at the ingress retards , and the parallax of longitude at the egress accelerates , the total duration will be shortned by the sum of these two parallaxes of longitude , viz. by Ab and c D , and if we make no allowance for these parallaxes , the apparent path will appear to have been B C , consequently a perpendicular from the center of the Sun on BC will be S E , longer than the perpendicular on the true apparent path by F E. But since it is certain that the parallaxes of longitude do not depress or elevate the planet , and only alter the poY y2 sition sition of the planet in a direction perpendicular to the axis of the orbit of the planet , therefore the parallaxes of longitude , in time , are , in this case , to be added to the observed time of the total duration ; in consequence of which the observed time of total duration , bc+Ab+cD are = to the chord described by the planet in its passage over the Sun ; and if the semidiameters of the Sun and Venus are known , their difference is known , which is = to the line A S ; A F , from what has been said is also known , therefore SF may be found .
But this SF is not the apparent least distance of the centers , for if we compute the parallax of latitude for the apparent middle of the transit , we shall find it greater than M F , which MF is only a mean between the parallaxes of latitude at the ingress and egress .
Let therefore the difference between MF and the parallax of latitude computed for the middle of the transit be added to S F , and the sum will be = to the apparent least distance of the centers nearly ; and if from this sum we subtract the parallax of latitude , computed for the middle of the transit , the remainder will be the geocentric least distance of the centers nearly .
A true and more ready method to find the geocentric least distance of the centers , consequently the apparent least distance of the centers at any place , where the total duration has been observed .
Reduce the total duration observed to the center , reduce the central semi-duration , in time , into space ; then in the right-angled triangle SMA [ Fig. 2 .
] or SM a , we have the two sides SA or S a , and AM or aM given , therefore the third side SM may be found , therefore SM the geocentric least distance of the centers is found ; and if to S M , we add or subtract the parallax of latitude for the apparent middle of the transit , the sum or difference will be the apparent least distance of the centers .
EXAMPL E. To find the apparent least distance of the centers at Tobolsk .
The total duration observed at Tobolsk was 5h 48~ 53~ add 9~ 3~ ( = to the effect of the parallaxes of longitude and latitude both for the ingress and egress , on the supposition that the Sun 's parallax is = 8~ , 5 ) to this total duration , the sum 5h 57~ 56~ is = to the central duration , consequently 2h 58~ 58~ is = the central semi-duration : reduce this time into space , and it will be found = to 715~ , 956 = AM or a M , and SA or Sa ( = difference of the semi-diameters of the Sun and Venus ) = 916~ , therefore SM will be found = 571~ , 37 = the geocentric least distance of the centers of the Sun and Venus .
The parallax of latitude , computed on the above supposition of the Sun 's parallax , for the apparent middle of the transit at Tobolsk , will be found = 14~ , 13 , which being added to the geocentric least distance of the centers above found , the Sum 585~ , 50 will be the apparent least distance of the centers at Tobolsk .

