Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. XVI.a p.173 .
Note The Figures Serving only for a general Illustration are not Geometrically Exact .
aA Fig. 1 .
O SS o beB ~q ~ dDR pr w ED M B G FC c Fig. 2 .
LS CIHALL S tO fOT Fig. 3 .
P T Water VR RV Fig. 4 .
Z pH air PF v rPX SK Glass G ABN DO Lie rMAPB Fig. 5 .
Fig. 6 .
ow SrR CsS poGO nnN Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. XIV .
b p. 173 .
AS P Fig. 7 BOC W V MRT v m r M T S F pP p wD dCcKF o Fig. 8 .
LN ~t TM SpPF Dd~CKF Fig. 9 .
LN XXXI .
Rules and Examples for limiting the Cases in which the Rays of refracted Light may be reunited into a colourless Pencil : In a Letter from P. Murdoch , M. A. and F. R. S. to Robert Symmer , Esq ; F. R. S. Jan. 3 , 1763 .
LET SO , a small pencil of the solar light , pass through the refracting medium ABCD [ TAB. XIV .
Fig. 1 .
] whose opposite surfaces , represented by AB , CD , are parallel planes : then the violet rays OV , will , in the second refraction into the air , emerge parallel to the red ; for both will be parallel to the incident ray S O , and consequently to each other : that is , W will be parallel to R r , as is plain from the common principles of Optics .
2 .
If the light after its emergence is received on a screen placed any where beyond R V , it will be tinged with violet on the side V v , and with red towards Rr : and if the incident pencil SO is exceeding small , all the intermediate colours will be seen in the same order as when light is refracted by a prism .
But if the incident pencil is not very small ; or if the luminous body from which the rays are transmitted through a small opening at O , has a considerable breadth , like that of the Sun 's disk ; then so many rays of every kind will mix towards the middle of the spectrum as to produce a pure white ; but at the extremities W and R r , it will still be ting ed Read June 2 , I. ed with violet and red : for a violet ray from the uppermost point of the Sun 's disk will be more refracted than the other can be ; and a red ray from the lowest part of his disk , will be less refracted than any other .
3 If B C , the distance of the refracting surfaces , is increased or diminished ; R V , the distance of the extreme rays , will be increased or diminished in the same proportion : and if RV approaches very near to the aperture O , the colours will become imperceptible .
4 .
To reunite these rays , we may place another medium of the same refractive power , and of the same thickness ( bc = BC ) as in the figure ; so as the rays V v , Rr , &amp;c. may enter its surface cd at the same angle as they emerged at from C D , or as SO entered A B ; and after refraction at the point o of the surface a b , to which they converge , they will be reunited into os the continuation of S O , in a pencil every way like the incident pencil S O , excepting that the light will have been somewhat weakened in its passage through the media .
5 .
Other things remaining , let the thickness of the second medium be c p , less than cb or C B , the surface parallel to cd being p e ; and the emergent rays ~ will be indeed parallel to the incident as formerly , but the spectrum will fall below the place of the screen where SO or os would fall .
It will likewise be coloured , as the rays were not yet united at the point o. If the thickness be greater than c b , the spectrum will fall above the line SOo s , and the violet and red , after their intersection in o , will have changed sides .
6 .
Other things remaining , suppose the refractive power of the medium ac to be increased , making the extreme rays to intersect before they reach the surface a b ; in that case , let the medium be turned round upon an axis perpendicular to the plane of refraction ( represented by the plane of the figure ) in the order of the letters a , b , c , so that the angle of incidence of the rays V v , R r , the line v r , and the angle for may be continually decreasing till the intersection o falls into the side a b ; and the rays will emerge colourless and parallel to the incident pencil S O ; above , or below , or in the line SOo s , according to the assumed place of the axis of revolution .
If , on the contrary , the refractive power of the medium ac be diminished , and , with it , the angle of convergence of the extreme rays ; the point where they would intersect falling beyond the surface a b ; the medium must then revolve the contrary way , in the order c , b , a ; to bring the point of intersection to the surface a b. But if the refractive power be so small that even when cd becomes almost coincident with V v , the point of intersection falls still beyond b a , in that case the rays cannot be made to emerge colourless , otherwise than by increasing the depth of the medium till its surface passes through the point of intersection .
And in like manner , when the refractive power of the second medium ac is greater than that of A C , making the rays to meet within the medium , as at qa point in the line p e ; we may , instead of turning the medium round on an axis , cut off the part p a , leaving the surface pe parallel to c d ; and the emergent light will be colourless .
From these few principles we may determine the phenomenon of light transmitted through parallelepipids that are contiguous to the air , their position~and refractive powers being given .
Or we may dispose them so that the emergent light shall , or shall not , be tinged with colours .
And we already see ( what shall be more distinctly explained below ) that if light be transmitted through whatever number of media ( A , B , C , &amp;c. ) all the refractions may be corrected by the equal and contrary refractions of the same number of the same media ( c , b , a , ) similar and similarly situated to the former ; provided there is a medium Z interposed between the two series , thus ; A , B , C , Z , c , h , a ; and that the rays in their passage through Z , are parallel to one another .
7 .
But to give the rays this parallelism in their passage through Z , and to explain the several phenomenon of refracted light , we shall need the following LEMM A , a PROBLEM .
Given ( in Fig. 2 .
) DCB the difference of two angles AC D , AC B , and the ratio of DI the sine of the greater to BH the sine of the lesser being likewise given , to find the angles .
For D F , the sine of the given difference , write s , and for its cosine CF write c ; for the lesser sine B H , the letter z , and let the given ratio of DI to B H , be that of m to n , the radius CB being unity .
Then , having drawn FG perpendicular to D I ; from the similar triangles in this figure , we shall have CB C B : C H : : D F : D G , or 1 : ~ 1-zz : : s : DG= s~ 1-zz ; and C B : B H : : C F : G I , or 1 : z : : c : GI = cz .
But ( by Hypoth .
) D I : B H : : m : n ; that is DG+G I , or s~ 1-zz +c z : z : : m : n ; which gives ~ 1-z2 : z , or C H : B H , or 1 : tang .
AC B : : m-n c : n s ; that is , tang .
ACB=n s/ m-n c. In words-multiply the sine of the given difference by the least term of the given ratio for a dividend : from the greater term subtract the product of the cosine of the difference and the lesser term for a divisor ; and the quotient shall be the tangent of the lesser angle AC B. Or , if you prefer a geometrical construction ; In the semidiameter CB produced take CM to CB as DI to B H ; and in the tangent to the circle at B , make BL to B C , as DF to F M , and BCL shall be the lesser angle sought .
Or you need only join DM and draw the semidiameter CA parallel to it .
8 .
But before we apply this solution , it may be proper to give a table of the refractive powers of glass , water and spirit of wine , whether contiguous to the air , or perhaps the fluids contiguous to glass : these being the substances in which experiments may be most conveniently made : and it is also necessary to know the limitations that arise from those several powers .
I. When light passes from air into glass , and the angle of incidence is next to 90~ , whose sine is unity ; The sine of the refraction of the red ~~~ 40 29 33 , 6 rays = 50/ 77 is.6493508 = sin. And of the violet 50/ 78 =.6410256 = sin. 39 52 6 Whose difference 0 37 27 , 6 is the greatest angle at which the violet and red rays can diverge in the refraction from air into glass , wanting very little of 37~ 1/ 2 .
And when an unrefracted pencil passes from glass into air , as soon as the angle of incidence exceeds 39~ 52~ 6~ , the violet rays will begin to be reflected ; and when the incidence exceeds 40~ 29~ 33~ , 6 the rays will be totally reflected .
II .
From Air into Water .
The sine of refraction of the red is ~~~ 48 44 44 .7517905 = s. Of the violet.7454080 = s. 48 11 39 And the greatest divergence 0 33 5 the angle of beginning reflection from water into air being 48~ 11~ 39~ .
III .
From Water into Glass .
Sin. incid .
: s. refr .
of the red : : 1 : ~~~ 59 44 201/ 2 0,863739 = s. Of the violet : : 1 : 0,859966 = s. 59 18 45 The difference of which 0 25 351/ 2 is the greatest divergence .
IV .
From Air into Spirit of Wine .
Sin. incid .
: s. refr .
of the red : : 1 : ~~~ 47 10 20 , 2 0,7334001 = s. Of the violet : : 1 : 0,7266366 = s. 46 36 18 , 6 The difference of which 0 34 1 , 6 is the greatest divergence .
V. From Spirit of Wine into Glass .
Sin. incid .
: s. refr .
of the red : : 1 : ~~~ 62 18 0 , 1 0,8853964 = s. Of the violet : : 1 : 0,8821802 = s. 61 54 24 And their difference 0 23 36 is the greatest divergence .
These numbers are partly transcribed from Sir Isaac Newton , and partly computed by a rule of Mr. Euler in the Philasophical Transactions .
They are indeed carried on to more decimal places than the experiments hitherto made can well bear : but it is hoped that hereafter methods may be devised to measure the refractions of light to a very great degree of precision .
9 .
When a slender pencil S O , is refracted by the surface of a denser medium OT ( Fig. 3 .
) the extreme rays being O V , the violet , and OR the red ; we have seen that the surface RV T , at which the rays pass again into the rarer medium , being parallel to the first surface O T , the extreme , and all the intermediate , rays will emerge parallel to each other , and to the pencil S O. But if the last surface RVT cuts the former in a line perpendicular to the plane of refraction at the point T , on the side of the radiant point S , then the extreme rays being refracted at the points V , R , will converge to some point F in the rarer medium : and if the light be received on a screen at F , it will be colourless ; if nearer to the refracting medium , or farther from it , it will be tinged , but on different sides .
Thus if the denser medium is water , and the surrounding medium is air ; the angle of incidence LOS being 20~ , the angle of divergence FOR will be 7~ 46~ .
And OVP the angle of incidence at the second refraction for the violet rays being taken of 30~ , the angle of convergence RFY will be 14~ 26~ .
On the contrary , if the plane VRt , ( Fig. 4 .
) which terminates the denser medium cuts the first refracting plane on the other side of the perpendicular O L , the rays will diverge from some point f on the other side of the second surface : the violet ray OV being more refracted from the perpendicular V P , than the red is from the perpendicular R p. And it is evident , that if the distance ( O T or Ot ) of the point of incidence from the edge of a prism , the angle of incidence LO S , and the angle of the prism ( OTV or OtV ) are given , together with the refractive powers of the media , the lines OV , OR , will be given in magnitude and position .
And thence the distance VR being given , with the angles of refraction at the second surface , the points , F or f , to which the rays converge , or from which they diverge , will be given .
And their locus , or the Curve in which all these points are found , may be assigned ; whether the angle of the prism is constant , and the angle of incidence is variable , or the contrary ; and whether the rays are refracted , or , at a certain obliquity , come to be reflected by the second plane .
10 .
If it is further required that the extreme , and all the intermediate , rays which meet at F ( in Fig. 3 .
) should thenceforth remain united in a colourless pencil : through the point of convergence F draw ( by the lemma ) the line Z X , making the angles ZF R , ZF V , such that their difference RFV being the given angle of convergence , their sines may be as the sines of refraction of the red and violet rays , when they pass from a given denser medium GKH into the air , at a common angle of incidence : and HFG perpendicular to ZX will be the line in which the surface of that medium must cut the plane of refraction , when the rays R F , V F , are refracted into the same line F N. And if the medium be terminated on the other side by any plane KN to which FN is perpendicular , the pencil N Y , continued in the air , will remain colourless .
For instance , if the medium GK is glass , and the angle RFV is 14~ 26~ , ZFR the angle of incidence of the red rays will be found of 17~ 54~ 14~ ; and the angle of refraction XF N , common to all the rays , will be 12~ 6~ 34~ 1/ 2 .
But if the plane H G , to which ZX is perpendicular , passes not thro ' the point of reunion F , but on this or the other side of it ; the rays in their passage thro ' the medium , though parallel to each other , will be laterally separated .
11 .
Let a ray SOL ( Fig. 5 .
) of a mean degree of refrangibility be refracted by AB the side of a glass prism AB C , so that the refracted ray OM may be perpendicular to the side of the prism A C ; it is required to apply to this another prism of a differently refracting substance , as of water , so that the ray Mo being refracted at o , by the side D C , the refracted ray so may be parallel to O S. The angle of incidence SO P , and the refractive power of the glass being given , the angle SO M , and its supplement LO M , are given produce Mo to n ; and because os is to be parallel to LO take for the difference of the angles in the lemma , the given angle nos ( =L O M ) , and through the point o draw ro p , so that the sine of pon may be the sine of po s , as the sine of incidence to that of refraction , when a meanly-refrangible ray passes from water into air ; and Do C , perpendicular to r p , will be the position of the side required .
We have here supposed the ray SO to be homogeneous , of a mean refrangibility ; but if it is a ray from the Sun the image at s will be very much tinged .
The colours will have been separated at O ; a small matter more at M , but they will diverge very considerably at o ; for setting aside the refractions at O and M ; that is , supposing a pencil Mo to pass unrefracted in water till it falls upon a surface of air at an angle of incidence of about 47~ 32~ 1/ 2 , the divergence of the extreme rays will be about 2~ 51~ 1/ 2 : a small difference of sines answering to a considerable difference of the angles when they approach to 90~ : the ultimate difference to which they converge , being ( from water into air ) 7~ 26~ 1/ 4 .
12 .
Let a pencil of the solar light SO ( Fig. 6 .
) fall upon the surface of water B C , the extreme rays being refracted into O V , O R ; it is required to assign the glass prism PNn ( whose section PNn is an isosceles triangle ) such , that the base Nn being parallel to S O , and the surface of the water AC being inclined to the base Nn in the same angle as the surface B C ; the extreme rays , in their passage through the glass prism , shall be parallel ; and all the rays shall emerge colourless in the line SOo s ; that is , in the incident ray produced thro ' both the media .
The angle SO B , and the refractions from air into water , being given , the angles VO N , RO N , and their difference VO R , are given .
Draw therefore , by the lemma , the line OG , making the sine of ROG to that of VOG , as the sine of refraction of a red ray , in passing from glass into water , is to the sine of refraction of a violet ray , their angles of incidence being equal , and PN perpendicular to OG will be the intersection of the plane of refraction with the side of the prism that is required .
Thus the angle SOB being 30~ , FOR will be 18~ 12~ 1/ 2 , VO G=50~ 38~ 4~ 1/ 2 , RO G=50~ 19~ 52~ 1/ 2 .
whose sines are as the sines of refraction of the violet and the red , in passing from glass into water at a common angle of incidence .
And therefore , the angles of the emergence of the rays OV , OR , in passing from water into glass will be equal , that is W will in its passage through the glass prism , be parallel to R r , and the rays meeting with equal and contrary refractions at the points v , r , o , as they suffered at V , R , O , will emerge colourless at o. Yet we must not be surprised if the pencil os is not absolutely pure light ( even supposing , the matter , the figure , and the disposition , of the media to be faultless ) because ( 1~ ) perhaps the refractive powers have not been determined with sufficient exactness ( 2~ ) .
If the glass plate which contains the water be not very thin , the light will have received a slight tincture in passing through it at O : This however may be remedied by confining the water between two glass prisms .
And ( 3~ ) it its scarce possible to make experiments of this kind with a pencil of light so slender as the theory prescribes ( see ~ 2 .
) But proper allowances being made on these accounts , and the refracting planes adjusted as the lemma directs , the light will emerge sufficiently pure to justify the theory .
And the refractions of either medium being given , it will appear from the experiments whether those of the other medium have been determined with sufficient accuracy .
Observe likewise , that as , in practice , we must fit the water to the glass , not the glass to the water , we are to begin by assuming VR of a convenient magnitude ; and supposing the rays V v , R r , &amp;c. to be parallel within the glass , find the point O to which they converge in the water , through which a plane may be drawn which shall send them out into the air , in a colourless pencil O S. REMARK S. I. The 8th experiment in Sir Isaac Newton 's optics ( Book I. Part 2 .
) seems to have been made under the conditions which are limited by the foregoing problem ; though he does not specify these conditions .
For , it is to be presumed , he did not combine his prism and water at random , but adjusted them so as to produce the expected effect .
It is observed likewise , that he does not give us a description of his experiment so particular as , in most instances , he was wont to do .
He thought perhaps that the consequences he deduces from it might sufficiently explain his meaning ; especially as he had , in the foregoing propositions , fully established the principles of his theory .
However this be , several persons of skill and address in optical matters , have produced experiments in contradiction to that of Sir Isaac , and have affixed meanings to his conclusions which he never could intend , without being grossly inconsistent with himself : an imputation from which common candor and decency ought to have protected so great a name * .
For instance , when he says that ` ` light as often as by contrary refractions it is so corrected that it emergeth in line parallel to those in which it was incident , continues ever after to be white ' ' ; can this assertion possibly bear the meaning they would obtrude upon us ?
Had Sir Isaac so entirely forgot his own doctrine as not to know , That if the glass prism PN n , in the last scheme , is , any where above V v , terminated by a plane to which the pencil SO is perpendicular , the rays V v , R r , &amp;c. though emerging parallel to S O , will exhibit their several colours ?
The sense therefore which the experiments affix to Sir Isaac Newton 's words being so absurd , had not they done better to look out for one that was consistent with his theory ?
and such a one they would have found by only drawing a figure like the foregoing ; where the rays of the pencil , reunited in o s , as well as when separated within the glass prism , are parallel to each other and to the incident pencil .
But , if the water is terminated by a plane different from A C , passing through the point o , and making the rays ( no longer parallel to S O ) to diverge , then the light will , by degrees , in passing on from o , become coloured : which is Sir Isaac 's other position .
To this meaning his own words ought to have led the objectors .
It was light , not separate rays , which * The reader ought to be told , that it is not here intended to detract from the merit of the late Mr. Dollond 's improvement of refracting telescopes ; but only to correct a mistake of his concerning that difference of dispersion of rays , which he has so happily applied to use .
emerged in his experiment ; and which ( being parallel to the incident light ) continued to be colourless .
He adds farther , ` ` the permanent whiteness argues , that in like incidence of the rays , there is no separation of the emerging rays ' ' : as much as to say , that in his experiment ( as in our 6th Figure ) the pencil , in passing or repassing , is supposed to meet with surfaces of equal refractive powers , similarly situated .
The other cases in which refracted light may recover its whiteness , although it emerges not parallel to the incident , or may be tinged though parallel to it , Sir Isaac does not treat of : the experiment he had made , being sufficient for the purposes to which he applies it .
But he assures his readers , that if they will argue truly upon his theory , trying all things with good instruments , and sufficient circumspection , the expected event will not be wanting .
And the fact is , that in all the experiments which have been made , if none of the necessary data are wanting , the appearance of the emerging light may be certainly prodicted .
II .
When a slender pencil of light is refracted at the surface of any medium , the extreme rays , the violet and red , and the several intermediate rays , each of its particular degree of refrangibility , will all diverge from , or converge to , the same physical point : or when that point , by altering the position of the plane , is thrown to an infinite distance , will all of them become parallel .
And it appears from the foregoing solution , that such parallelism may always be effected , whatever be the refracting power of the medium PN n , provided that , in a given medium , the quantities m , n , &amp;c. of the lemma , which represent the sines of refraction of the several sorts of rays , to a common sine of incidence , continue to be in constant ratios to one another .
Conversely , if , from experiments such as that which Sir Isaac Newton made , it follows that , whatever be the refractive powers of the media , and the angle of incidence of the light , the pencils SO , so , may be made to reciprocate with each other , while all the sorts of rays , in passing or repassing through the prism PN n , become parallel ; if , I say , this is confirmed by experiments , it is a proof that , for any given medium , the ratios of those quantities m , n , &amp;c. are invariable .
III .
And hence Sir Isaac deduces the two theorems subjoined to his 8th experiment ; by the first of which he contrives to make the ratios of the sines of refraction belonging to the several sorts of rays , to a common sine of incidence , when they pass from glass into air , to serve for finding the like ratios for the rays passing from water into air , without the trouble of new experiments .
His first theorem may be deduced in this manner : Let all the sorts of rays , whether united in a pencil of light , or separated parallelwise by refraction , have the same angle of incidence whose sine is I , when they pass from a denser into a rarer medium ; and let V and R stand for the sines of refraction of the extreme ( or any two sorts of ) rays .
Then seeing by the experiments , the ratio of V to I is given , as also that of R to I ; the ratio of V-I to I , as also ( invert .
) that of I to R-I , and ( exaequo ) that of V-I to R-I , are given : for this last write the ratio of 1 to p. In like manner , let the refractive power of the medium from which the rays emerge into the same medium as before , be increased or diminished , as also the common angle of incidence ; and we need only write other marks v and r for the sines , and i for the common sine of incidence ; for we shall have as before v-i to r-i in a given ratio ; which call that of 1 to q. And , from these two , we have V-I/ v-i = R-I/ r-i ~ q/ p. But p is always nearly equal to q ; in the refractions from glass , and from water into air , their difference is less than 1/ 400 part of either ; we may therefore put the ratio V-I/ v-i equal to R-I/ r-i ; which is the first theorem .
And thence , if one difference R-I becomes equal to r-i , the other differences V-I , &amp;c. will be respectively equal to v-i , &amp;c. and the same set of differences may be made to serve for several media , provided the sines of incidence are taken in their due proportion .
Thus when red rays pass from glass into the air , we have I : R : : 50 : 77 and R-I : I : : 27 : 50 , and when they pass from water into air i : r-i : : 3 : 1 , and therefore , as we are to make R-I every where equal to r-i , we get , ex aequo , i : I : : 81 : 50 , as Sir Isaac Newton finds it .
VI .
But to explain this matter a little farther , and obviate some difficulties concerning it , I shall add the following EXAMPLE S. The refractive powers being as marked above , let red rays fall from glass into air at the angle of incidence 20~ , the angle of refraction will be 31~ 47~ .
Again , let them fall from water into air at an angle of 34~ 1~ , making their angle of refraction 48~ 5~ .
And the difference of the sines of 31~ 47~ , and 20~ will be precisely equal to the difference of the sines of 48~ 5~ , and 34~ 1~ .
At the same angles of incidence 20~ and 34~ 1~ , let the violet rays fall from glass and water into air ; and the angle of refraction from the glass , will be 32~ 14~1/ 2 nearly , and that from the water will be 48~ 38~ nearly , And the difference of the sines of 32~ 14~1/ 2 and 20~ will equal the difference of the sines of 48~ 38~ and 34~ 1~ , within.000488 , or less than 1/ 2 000 th part .
We see likewise that the red and violet rays diverged from the glass medium at an angle of 27~1/ 2 ; but from the water at an angle of 33~ ; making the difference of divergence in this example 5~1/ 2 ; that is 1/ 5 of the whole divergence of the red and violet rays when refracted from glass into air , at incid .
20~ .
Whence it appears , that although the differences of sines above specified , or the excesses in Sir Isaac 's theorem , may , in refractions from different media into the same rarer medium , be made equal , it does by no means follow , that the divergences of the several sorts of rays ( or if you chuse to call it their dispersion ) will be the same in the two refractions ; for Sir Isaac 's excesses 27 , 271/ 9 , &amp;c. are the excesses of sines ; not of angles , as some opticians seem to have misapprehended .
Again , let an unrefracted pencil of light fall from common glass into the air ( Fig. 7 .
) at the incidence 39~ , and the angles of refraction will be , ~~~ Of the violet 79 22 Of the red 75 43 55 And their difference 3 18 7 is the divergence of the extreme rays .
And the angle of refraction of the mean ray is 77~ 16~ 19~ .
By mean ray is understood the ray whose sine of refraction is a geometrical mean between the sines of refraction of the extreme rays , the common radius being unity .
Let now the same rays be refracted the contrary way by a surface of water WT , then , to make the mean emergent ray parallel to the incident pencil , its angle of incidence must be 86~ 37~2/ 3 : and the extreme rays will now converge at an angle of 201/ 8 minutes , nearly .
Through the point of convergence o , draw ( by the Lemma ) a plane w t , to terminate the water , and unite all the rays into a colourless pencil o s : and this emergent pencil will be found to make with a perpendicular to the terminating surface an angle of 49~ 6~1/ 2 , and will be inclined to the first incident pencil in an angle of 14 degrees , 28 minutes , 20 seconds .
Nor is there any other plane besides this which will thus unite the rays .
If planes parallel to it cut the rays any where but in their point of convergence , they will be parallel to each other , but exhibiting their several colours .
And planes not parallel to it , will every where give a coloured image , excepting only when they pass through the point of convergence ; but then the rays having crossed at at that point , will thenceforth diverge from one another , and give a coloured spectrum .
From all which it appears that light refracted thro ' different media may emerge colourless , although its first direction be considerably altered .
And that its mean direction may remain the same , though its extremities be sensibly tinged with colours .
Positions which , I know not by what mishap , have been deemed paradoxes in Sir Isaac Newton 's theory of light , but which are really the necessary consequences of it .
Of Telescopical Object-Glasses giving an Image free from Colours .
Fig. 8 and 9 .
If the extreme rays , the red and violet , after one or more refractions , diverge from points D and d , the distance of the point of divergence of the least refrangible from the lens , being greater than that of the most refrangible , such a semidiameter of the last spherical surface , from which they are to pass into the air , may be assigned , as shall unite the extreme , and all the intermediate , rays in the same focus F ; neglecting the aberration from the figure .
The RULE is this ; For the distances of the points of divergence from the lens , write D the greater , and d the least ; the semidiameter of any of the given surfaces being assumed for unity : And M/ r , m/ r expressing the ratios of the sines of incidence and refraction of the violet and red rays out of air into the last medium whose surface is required : the semidiameter of that surface will be M-m ~D d/ M D-m d ; as may be easily demonstrated from a theorem of Dr. Smith , in the remarks subjoined to his Optics .
Thus if the last medium is glass , the semidiameter of the surface from which the rays pass into the air , must be D d/ 78 D-77 d , it being , in this case , M/ r=7 8/ 5 0 , m/ r=7 7/ 5 0 .
EXAMPLE I. Let Mp CN cM ( Fig. 8 .
) be a double convex lens of water confined between the plano-concave MTLN , and the meniscus MKN cM , both of glass , and having the radii of their surfaces contiguous to the water , equal to each other , or to unity : and if a ray S p , parallel to the common axis of the lenses , after being refracted by the aqueous lens , have its extreme rays , the red and violet , divergent from the points D and d ; the distance of F , the focus where all the rays can meet , will be 8.898 : and when this happens , the exterior surface of the meniscus , that is , the surface represented by MPKN , will have its radius to that of the inner surface McN , as 139 to 154 .
EXAMPLE II .
When a double concave of glass ( the radii of whose surfaces are unity ) is enclosed in water , as in Fig. 9 , the water being confined on one side by a thin glass plate TL , and on the other by a concentrick spherical shell MPKN ; the semidiameter of this shell must be to unity as 471 to 547 : and the focal distance CF , at which the colourless image is formed , will be 4.772/ 3 .
In these examples the thickness of the lenses is neglected ; but it may easily be taken into the account , if it is thought necessary .
The same thing may be effected by means of any media of different refractive powers : for the semidiameter of the last refracting surface being determined according to the foregoing rule , the nearer distance of the points of divergence ( d ) of the more refrangible rays will be so compensated by their greater refrangibility , that all the rays will converge to the same focus F. And this without introducing any new principle into the science of optics , or any dispersion of light different from the refractions discovered by Sir Isaac Newton near a hundred years ago .

