XXII .
New Experiments in Electricity : In a Letter from Mr. Ebenezer Kinnersley , to Benjamin Franklin , LL. D. F. R. S. Read Nov. 18 , 1762 , March 24 , and April 14 , 1763 .
SIR , Philadelphia , Mar. 12 , 1761 .
HAVING lately made the following experiments , I very cheerfully communicate them , in hopes of giving you some degree of pleasure , and exciting you to further explore your favourite , but not quite exhausted , subject , ELECTRICITY .
EX P. I. I placed myself on an electric stand , and , being well electrised , threw my hat to an unelectrised person , at a considerable distance , on another stand , and found , that the hat carried some of the electricity with it ; for , upon going immediately to the person , who received it , and holding a flaxen thread near him , I perceived he was electrised sufficiently to attract the thread .
EX P. II .
I then suspended , by silk , a broad plate of metal , and electrised some boiling water under it , at about four feet distance , expecting that the vapour , which ascended plentifully to the plate , would , upon the principle of the foregoing experiment , carry up some of the electricity with it ; but was at length fully convinced , by several repeated trials , that it left all its share thereof behind .
This I know not how to account for ; but does it not seem to corroborate your hypothesis , that the vapors , of which the clouds are formed , leave their share of electricity behind in the common stock , and ascend in a negative state ?
EX P. III .
I put boiling water into a coated Florence flask , and found that the heat so enlarged the pores of the glass , that it could not be charged .
The electricity passed thro ' as readily , to all appearance , as thro ' metal ; the charge of a three-pint bottle went freely thro ' without injuring the flask in the least .
When it became almost cold , I could charge it as usual .
Would not this experiment convince the Abbe Nollet of his egregious mistake ?
For , while the electricity went fairly thro ' the glass , as he contends it always does , the glass could not be charged at all .
EX P. IV .
I took a slender piece of cedar , about eighteen inches long , fixed a brass cap in the middle , thrust a pin , horizontally and at right angles , thro ' each end , ( the points in contrary directions ) and hung it , nicely balanced like the needle of a compass , on a pin , about six inches long , fixed in the center of an electric stand .
Then electrising the stand , I had the pleasure of seeing what I expected ; the wooden needle turned round , carrying the pins with their heads foremost .
I then electrised the stand negatively , expecting the needle to turn the contrary way ; but was extremely disappointed , for it went still the same way as before .
When the stand was electrised positively , I suppose , that the natural quantity of electricity in the air being increased on one side , by what issued from the points , the needle was attracted by the lesser quantity on the other side .
When electrised negatively , I suppose , that the natural quantity of electricity in the air was diminished near the points ; in consequence whereof , the equilibrium being destroyed , the needle was attracted by the greater quantity on the opposite side .
The doctrine of repulsion in electrised bodies , I begin to be somewhat doubtful of .
I think all the phenomenon , on which it is founded , may be well enough accounted for without it .
Will not cork balls , electrised negatively , separate as far as when electrised positively ?
And may not their separation , in both cases , be accounted for upon the same principle ; namely , the mutual attraction of the natural quantity in the air , and that which is denser , or rarer in the cork ball ?
It being one of the established laws of this fluid , that quantities of different densities shall mutually attract each other , in order to restore the equilibrium .
I can see no reason to conclude , that the air has not its share of the common stock of electricity as well as glass , and , perhaps , all other electrics per se .
For tho ' the air will admit bodies to be electrised in it either positively or negatively , and will not readily carry off the redundancy in the one case , or supply the deficiency in the other ; EX P. V. Yet let a person in the negative state , out of doors in the dark , when the air is dry , hold , with his arm extended , a long sharp needle , pointing upwards ; and he will soon be convinced , that electricity may be drawn out of the air ; not very plentifully , for , being a bad conductor , it seems loth to part with it ; but yet some will evidently be collected .
The air near the person 's body , having less than its natural quantity , will have none to spare ; but , his arm being extended as above , some will be collected from the remoter air , and will appear luminous as it converges to the point of the needle .
Let a person electrised negatively present the point of a needle , horizontally , to a cork ball suspended by silk , and the ball will be attracted towards the point , till it has parted with so much of its natural quantity of electricity as to be in the negative state , in the same degree with the person who holds the needle : then it will recede from the point ; being , as I suppose , attracted the contrary way by the electricity of greater density in the air behind it .
But , as this opinion seems to deviate from electrical orthodoxy , I should be glad to see these phenomenon better accounted for by your superior and more penetrating genius .
Whether the electricity in the air , in clear dry weather , be of the same density at the height of two or three hundred yards , as near the surface of the earth , may be satisfactorily determined by your old experiment of the kite .
EX P. VI .
The twine should have , through-out , a very small wire in it ; and the ends of the wire , where the several lengths are united , ought to be tied down with a waxed thread to prevent their acting in the manner of points .
I have tried the experiment twice , when the air was as dry as we ever have it , and so clear that not a cloud could be seen ; and found the twine each time , in a small degree electrised positively .
The kite had three metalline points fixed to it ; one on the top , and one on each side .
That the twine was electrised , appeared by the separating of two small cork balls suspended on the twine by fine flaxen threads , just above where the silk was tied to it , and sheltered from the wind .
That the twine was electrised positively , was proved by applying to it the wire of a charged bottle ; which caused the balls to separate further , without first coming nearer together .
This experiment showed , that the electricity in the air , at those times , was denser above than below .
But that cannot be always the case ; for you know we have frequently found the thunder clouds in the negative state , attracting electricity from the earth .
Which state it is probable they are always in when first formed , and till they have received a sufficient supply .
How they come afterwards , towards the latter end of the gust , to be in the positive state , which is sometimes the case , is a subject for further enquiry .
After the above experiments with the wooden needle , I formed a cross of two pieces of wood , of Philos. Trans. Vol. LIII .
TAB. V. p. 89 .
a K d I b c N L C A M F G B D E H equal length , intersecting each other at right angles in the middle ; hung it , horizontally , on a central pin , and set a light horse , with his rider , upon each extremity ; whereupon , the whole being nicely balanced , and each courser urged on by an electrised point , instead of a pair of spurs , I was entertained with an electrical horse-race .
I have contrived an electrical air thermometer , and made several experiments with it , that have afforded me much satisfaction and pleasure .
It is extremely sensible of any alteration in the state of the included air , and fully determines that controverted point , whether there be any heat in the electric fire .
By the Plate [ T A B. IV .
] and the following description , you will readily apprehend the construction of it .
A. B. is a glass tube about eleven inches long , and one inch diameter in the bore .
It has a brass feril cemented on each end , with a top and bottom part , C and D to be screwed on , air-tight , and taken off at pleasure .
In the center of the bottom part D , is a male screw , which goes into a brass nut in the mahogany pedestal E. The wires F and G are for the electric fire to pass through , darting from one to the other .
The wire G extends through the pedestal to H ; and may be raised or lowered by means of a male screw on it .
The wire F may be taken out , and the hook I be screwed into the place of it .
K is a glass tube with a small bore , open at both ends , cemented in the brass tube L , which serews into the top part C. The lower end of the tube K is immersed in water , coloured with cocheneal , at the bottom of the tube A B. ( I used at first coloured spirits of wine ; but , in one of the experiments I made , it took fire .
) On the top of the tube K is cemented , for ornament , a brass feril , with a head screwed on it , which has a small air hole thro ' its side at a. The wire b is a small round spring , that embraces the tube K so as to stay wherever it is placed .
The weight M is to keep strait whatever may be suspended in the tube A B. on the hook I. Air must be blown thro ' the tube K into the tube A B , 'till enough is intruded to raise , by its elastic force , a column of the coloured water , in the tube K up to c , or thereabouts ; and then , the gage wire b being slipped down to the top of the column , the thermometer is ready for use .
EX P. VII .
I set the thermometer on an electric stand , with the chain N fixed to the prime conductor , and kept it well electrised a considerable time ; but this produced no sensible effect .
Which shows , that the electric fire , when in a state of rest , has no more heat than the air and other matter wherein it resides .
EX P. VIII .
When the wires F and G are in contact , a large charge of electricity sent thro ' them , even that of my case of five and thirty bottles , containing above thirty square feet of coated glass , will produce no rarefaction of the air included in the tube A B. Which shows , that the wires are not heated by the fires passing thro ' them .
EX P. IX .
When the wires are about two inches apart , the charge of a three pint bottle , darting from one to the other , rarefies the air very evidently .
Which shows , I think , that the electric fire must produce heat in itself , as well as in the air , by its rapid motion .
The charge of one of my glass jars , which will contain about five gallons and a half , wine measure , darting from wire to wire , will , by the disturbance it gives the air in the explosion repelling it in all directions , raise the column in the tube K up to d , or thereabouts ; and the charge of the above-mentioned case of bottles will raise it to the top of the tube .
Upon the air 's coalescing , the column , by its gravity , instantly subsides till it is in equilibrio with the rarefied air ; it then gradually descends , as the air cools , and settles where it stood before .
By carefully observing at what height above the gage-wire b the descending column first stops , the degree of rarefaction is discovered ; which , in great explosions , is very considerable .
EX P. X. I hung in the thermometer , upon the hook I , successively , a strip of wet writing paper , a wet flaxen and woolen thread , a blade of green grass , a filament of green wood , a fine silver thread , a very small brass wire , and a strip of gilt paper ; and found that the charge of the glass jar , passing thro ' each of these , especially the last , produced heat enough to rarify the air very perceptibly .
The charge of the case of bottles sent thro ' the brass wire consumed great part of it into smoke .
The thermometer appeared quite opaque with it .
EX P. XI .
I then suspended , out of the thermometer , a piece of brass wire , not quite so small as the former , about twenty four inches long , with a pound weight at the lower end ; and , by sending the charge of the case of bottles thro ' it , discovered a new method of wiredrawing .
The wire was red hot , the whole length well anealed , and above an inch longer than before .
A second charge melted it ; it parted near the middle , and measured , when the ends were put together , four inches longer than at first .
This experiment I remember you proposed to me , as worth trying , before you left Philadelphia ; in order to find , whether the electricity , in passing thro ' the wire , would so relax the cohesion of its constituent particles , as that the weight might produce a separation ; but neither of us had the least suspicion , that any heat would be produced .
EX P. XII .
That I might have no doubt of the wire 's being hot as well as red , I repeated the experiment on another piece of the same wire , encompassed with a goosequill filled with loose grains of gun-powder ; which took fire as readily , as if it had been touched with a read hot poker .
Also tinder , tied to another piece of the wire , kindled by it .
I tried a wire about twice as big , but could produce no such effects with that .
Hence it appears , that the electric fire , tho ' it has no sensible heat when in a state of rest , will , by its violent motion , and the resistance it meets with , produce heat in other bodies , when passing thro ' them , provided they be small enough .
A large quantity will pass thro ' a large wire without producing any sensible heat ; when the same quantity passing thro ' a very small one , being there confined to a narrower passage , the particles crowding closer together , and meeting with greater resistance , will make it red hot , and even melt it .
Hence lightning does not melt metal by a cold fusion , as we formerly supposed .
But when it passes thro ' the blade of a sword , if the quantity be not very great , it may heat the point so as to melt it , while the broadest and thickest part may not be sensibly warmer than before .
And when trees or houses are set on fire by the dreadful quantity , which a cloud , or the earth sometimes discharges , must not the heat , by which the wood is first kindled , be generated by the lightning 's violent motion thro ' the resisting combustible matter ?
If lightning , by its rapid motion , produces heat in itself as well as in other bodies , ( and that it does , I think , is evident from some of the foregoing experiments made with the thermometer ) then its sometimes singeing the hair of animals killed by it may easily be accounted for .
And the reason of its not always doing so may , perhaps , be this : the quantity , tho ' sufficient to kill a large animal , may , sometimes , not be great enough , or not have met with resistance enough , to become by its motion burning hot .
We find , that dwelling houses , struck with lightning , are seldom set on fire by it ; but when it passes thro ' thro ' barns with hay or straw in them , or store-houses containing large quantities of hemp , or such like matter , they seldom , if ever , escape a conflagration .
Which may , perhaps , be owing to such combustibles being apt to kindle with less degree of heat than is necessary to kindle wood .
We had four houses in this city , and a vessel at one of the wharfs , struck , and damaged , by lightning last summer .
One of the houses was struck twice in the same strom .
But I have the pleasure to inform you , that your method of preventing such terrible disasters , has , by a fact , which had like to have escaped our knowledge , given a very convincing proof of its great utility , and is now in higher repute with us than ever .
Hearing , a few days ago , that Mr. William West , merchant in this city , suspected , that the lightning , in one of the thunder-storms last summer , had passed through the iron conductor , which he had provided for the security of his house , I waited on him , to enquire what ground he might have for such suspicion .
Mr. West informed me , that his family and neighbours were all stunned with a very terrible explosion , and that the flash and crack were seen and heard at the same instant .
Whence he concluded , that the lightning must have been very near ; and , as no house in the neighbourhood had suffered by it , that it must have passed through his conductor .
Mr. White , his clerk , told me , that he was sitting at the time by a window , about two feet from the conductor , leaning against the brick wall , with which it was in contact ; and that he felt a smart sensation , like an electric shock , in that part of his body , which touched the wall .
Mr. West further informed me , that a person of undoubted veracity assured him , that , being in the door of an opposite house on the other side of Water-Street ( which you know is but narrow ) he saw the lightning diffused over the pavement , which was then very wet with rain , to the distance of two or three yards from the foot of the conductor .
And that another person of very good credit told him , that he , being a few doors off , on the other side of the street , saw the lightning above , darting in such direction , that it appeared to him to be directly over that pointed rod .
Upon receiving this information , and being desirous of further satisfaction , there being no traces of the lightning to be discovered in the conductor , as far as we could examine it below , I proposed to Mr. West our going to the top of the house to examine the pointed rod ; assuring him , that , if the lightning had passed thro ' it , the point must have been melted ; and , to our great satisfaction , we found it so .
This iron rod extended in height about nine feet and a half above a stack of chimnies , to which it was fixed ; ( but I suppose , three or four feet would have been sufficient ) .
It was somewhat more than half an inch diameter , in the thickest part , and tapering to the upper end .
The conductor , from the lower end of it to the earth , consisted of square iron nail rods , not much above a quarter of an inch thick , connected together by interlinking joints .
It extended down the cedar roof to the eaves , and from thence down the wall of the house , four story and a half , to the pavement in Water-Street ; being fastened to the wall , in several places , by small iron hooks .
The lower end was fixed to a ring in the top of an iron stake , that was driven about four or five feet into the ground .
The above mentioned iron rod had a hole in the top of it , about two inches deep , wherein was inserted a brass wire , about two lines thick , and , when first put there , about ten inches long , terminating in a very acute point ; but now its whole length was no more than seven inches and a half , and the top very blunt .
Some of the metal appears to be missing ; the slenderest part of the wire being , as I suspect , consumed into smoke .
But some of it , where the wire was a little thicker , being only melted by the lightning , sunk down , while in a fluid state , and formed a rough irregular cap , lower on one side than the other , round the upper end of what remained , and became intimately united therewith .
This was all the damage , that Mr. West sustained by a terrible stroke of lightning .
A most convincing proof of the great utility of this method of preventing its dreadful effects .
Surely it will now be thought as expedient to provide conductors for the lightning as for the rain .
Mr. West was so good as to make me a present of the melted wire ; which I keep as a great curiosity , and long for the pleasure of showing it to you .
In the mean time , I beg your acceptance of the best representation I can give of it ; which you will find by the side of the thermometer , drawn in its full dimensions as it now appears .
The dotted lines above are intended to show the form of the wire before the lightning melted it .
And now , Sir , I most heartily congratulate you on the pleasure you must have in finding your great and well-grounded expectations so far fulfilled .
May this method of security from the destructive violence of one of the most awful powers of nature meet with such further success , as to induce every good and grateful heart to bless God for the important discovery .
May the benefit thereof be diffused over the whole globe .
May it extend to the latest posterity of mankind ; and make the name of FRANKLI N , like that of NEWTO N , immortal .
I am , Sir , with sincere respect , your most obedient , and most humble servant , Ebenezer Kinnersley .

