XIX .
A Defence of Mercator 's Chart against the Censure of the late Mr. West of Exeter : In a Letter to Charles Morton , M. D. Secret .
R. S. from Mr. William Mountain , F. R. S. To Doctor Morton , Secretary to the Royal Society .
Dear Sir , I Received your favour with Mr. Samuel Dunn 's letter , touching Mr. West 's method of constructing a nautical planisphere , referred to me by the Royal Society , which I now beg leave to return with the following account .
Read March 17 , 1763 .
As this island is situate by nature , not only for coasting trade , but foreign commerce , so every real improvement in the art of navigation has always met with the approbation and encouragement of the ingenious and sensible part of these kingdoms .
The greatest single advantage that this important business ever received , was from the invention of the mariner 's compass ; and next to this , the projection of a true nautic practical chart claims place ; this last was performed by that great improver of navigation , Mr. Edward Wright , as appears by his book entitled certain errors in navigation detected and corrected ' ' , published about the year 1599 .
In chapter 2d , of said book , he tells us , ` ` that the errors in the plain chart had been complained of by divers , as namely by Martin Cortese , Petrus Nonius , and even Gerardus Mercator seems to have corrected them , in his Universal Map of the World ; yet none of them had taught any certain way how to amend such gross faults : ' ' And , in his Preface , he declares , ` ` that , by occasion of Mercator 's map , he first thought of correcting so many and great absurdities in the common Sea Chart , but the way how this was by him done , he neither learnt of Mercator , nor of any man else .
' ' Wright 's method ( erroneously called Mercator 's ) was at this time then adopted , has continued ever since in use , and has been improved by some of the greatest mathematicians who have flourished since that time , and although sometimes attacked , yet it has been found impregnable .
The first person ( that I am aware of ) who charged Mr. Wright with errors in his tables of rhumbs , is Simon Stevins , in his large volume of mathematical remembrances , which Wright himself plainly confutes in a subsequent edition of his book : now , Stevins does not condemn the principles , but only asserts that his tables have some faults in them , and endeavours to prove that the fourth rhumb at 78 deg. of longitude ought to have 61d .
26m .
of latitude , whereas Wright makes it only 61d .
14m .
Hence , the great difference is no more than 12 minutes ; and what inconvenience can arise hereby to the mariner in such a run , was this the fact ?
But it turns out otherwise , for this difference is reduced to less than one minute ( even according to Stevins own way ) as evidently appears from Wright 's answer in page 214 .
If every rhumb is then found to possess its true latitude in this chart at every degree and minute of longitude , without any sensible or explicable error ( to make use of our author 's own words ) it follows , that the degrees of latitude are duly increased , or that the table of meridional parts are true .
The great Doctor Halley has given us a curious method of dividing the nautical meridian , and of performing the problems in sailing according to the true chart , in Philosophical Transactions , No. 219 .
by a method different from Mr. Wright 's , but so nearly corresponding in practice , that this alone is a sufficient testimony in favour of my author .
Our worthy brother Mr. John Robertson , in his excellent Elements of navigation , vol. II .
page 358 , expresses himself thus : ` ` Now although a table thus made ( Wright 's table of meridional parts constructed to minutes ) be abundantly sufficient for all nautical purposes , yet had the secants of smaller parts than minutes been taken , the table would have been more correct ; and therefore Mr. Oughtred , Sir Jonas Moore , Doctor Wallis , Doctor Halley , and others , have been induced to find methods of constructing those tables with more accuracy than by the addition of secants to every minute .
But a table of meridional parts , constructed by the most accurate method , only shows that Mr. Wright 's tables do no where exceed the true meridional parts by half a minute , and this only near the pole ; for in latitudes as far as navigation is practicable the difference is scarce sensible''.About About the year 1720 , a curvilinear sea chart made its appearance , said to be done by Henry Wilson , the publishers whereof represented Wright 's chart as puzzling , difficult , and false .
But these groundless assertions were rationally answered by Mr. Thomas Haselden , afterwards master of the Royal Academy at Portsmouth , in a letter and pamphlet addressed to Dr. Halley about the year 1722 .
In the year 1755 was published a book entitled , The art of sailing upon the Sea ' ' , by W. E. which initial letters are sufficient to point out the ingenious author .
In page 74 he says , ` ` It is demonstrable ( by the method of fluxions ) that the length of the part of the meridian line in Mercator 's chart , which represents the difference of latitude of two places upon the globe , is equal to the difference of the log .
tangents of half the compliments of the two latitudes , multiplied into the number 2,30258509 , and that product into the radius of the sphere ' ' .
And in Scholium to his Fundamental principles , page 75 .
` ` In the few foregoing propositions , I have demonstrated the truth of the chief methods of sailing now is use ; and deduced them from their genuine principles , and fixed them upon their proper foundations : By which the reader will be enabled to see that this theory is not founded upon false principles ; but upon such as are solid and true ; and consequently that all calculations built hereon may be depended on as exact ' ' .
Notwithstanding these , Wright 's method is charged with great imperfection by the late Mr. West of Exeter , in his posthumous work , referred unto by Mr. Dunn .
Mr. West therein declares that ` ` the errors of the plain chart are corrected , in a great measure , by Mercator 's or Wright 's chart ; tho ' the latter is not a true projection of the sphere in any shape ; nor indeed is it pretended to be such by Mr. Wright , one of its inventors ' ' .
The first part of this paragraph surely contains a contradiction ; for how can the errors in the plain chart be in a great measure corrected by a projection that is not true in any shape ?
And in answer to the latter part , Mr. Wright has no where made such concessions that I know of ; -and further Mr. West blends Wright and Mercator together , when at the same time it does not appear that the latter ever published any principles of this kind of projection to the world .
In the 20th article of the beforementioned book , Mr. West has laid down a method of constructing a nautical chart , which he asserts to be ` ` the first representation of the terraqueous globe ever yet invented , in which the meridians , parallels and rhumbs , are justly and truly projected in right lines , for the latter cannot be so projected in Mercator .
' ' If they cannot be so projected in Wright 's , they cannot in his ; for in both , the meridians are said to be right lines and parallel , and therefore the rhumbs must be right lines also , or how can they intersect the meridians so situate at equal angles ?
He also says in his scholium , that ` ` It does not appear that Mercator or Wright ever thought of this projection ; for the meridian line here is manifestly a line of tangents ; whereas in their projection , it is a collection of secants .
' ' What Mercator 's thoughts were upon this matter when he formed his universal map , I know not , as he has left us no account thereof ; but what Wright 's were , he has very plainly told us in his aforesaid book ; and whether his primary conceptions , and preparative modulus , do not only take in the whole , but also the very manner , of Mr. West 's construction , will better appear upon a due comparison of their respective methods , which I shall beg leave here to introduce in their own words .
Mr. WAS T'S PROPOSITIO N. If a rectangular piece of paper be turned into the form of a right cylindrical tube , and a sphere be inscribed therein , so as that the axes of the sphere and cylinder do coincide , or that the equator be the line of contact between the said tube and sphere , and all the points of the spheric surface be projected or transferred to the concave surface of the tube , by right lines proceeding from the center of the sphere , and terminating in the said concave surface of the tube : And then , if the paper be opened , and stretched upon a plane , it will present a chart , in which the meridians , parallels of latitude , and rhumbs are all truly and geometrically projected in right lines ' ' .
In Wright 's Correction of errors , reprinted by Moxon in 1657 , not having the original edition by me , in Chap. 2 .
we have the following account ` ` Whereas the spaces betwixt the parallels should increase crease more and more as you go from the equinoctial toward either of the poles , which Martin Cortese also notes in his third book and second chapter of the art of navigation ; But he omitted that wherein all the difficulty lies ; that is , how much , or in what proportion those spaces should increase : Which that it may the better be perceived , I think it not unmeet first to show by what kind of projection ( or extension rather ) the nautical planisphere may not unfitly be conceived to be geometrically made , after this manner .
Mr. WRIGH T'S METHO D. Suppose a spherical superficies , with meridians , parallels , rhumbs , and the whole hydrographical description drawn thereupon , to be inscribed into a concave cylinder , their axes agreeing in one .
' ' Let this spherical superficies swell like a bladder ( whiles it is in blowing ) equally always in every part thereof ( that is , as much in longitude as in latitude ) till it apply , and join itself ( round about , and all along also towards either pole ) unto the concave superficies of the cylinder : each parallel upon this spherical superficies , increasing successively from the equinoctial towards either pole , until it come to be of equal diameter with the cylinder , and consequently the meridians still widening themselves , till they come to be so far distant every where each from the other , as they are at the equinoctial .
Thus it may most easily be understood , how a spherical superficies may ( by extension ) be made a cylindrical , and consequently a plane parallelogram superM 2 ficies ; ficies ; because the superficies of a cylinder is nothing else but a plain parallelogram wound about two equal equidistant circles that have one common axtree perpendicular upon the centers of them both ' ' &amp; c ` ` So as the nautical planisphere may be defined to be nothing else but a parallelogram made of the spherical superficies of an hydrographical globe inscribed into a concave cylinder , both their axes concurring in one ; and the spherical superficies swelling in every part equally in longitude and latitude , till every one of the parallels thereupon be inscribed into the cylinder ( each parallel growing as great as the equinoctial ) or till the whole spherical superficies touch and apply itself every where to the concavity of the cylinder ' ' .
` ` In this nautical planisphere thus conceived to be made , all places must needs be situate in the same longitudes , latitudes , and directions or courses , and upon the same meridians , parallels , and rhumbs , that they were in the globe ; because , that at every point between the equinoctial and the pole , we understand the spherical superficies whereof this planisphere is conceived to be made , to swell equally as much in longitude as in latitude ( till it join itself unto the concavity of the cylinder ) so as hereby no part thereof is any way distorted or displaced out of his true and natural situation upon his meridian , parallel or rhumb , but only dilated and enlarged : the meridians also , parallels and rhumbs dilating ` and enlarging themselves likewise , at every point ` of latitude in the same proportion ' ' .
By comparing these two modes of construction together I think it is not very difficult to discover that Mr. West 's derives its original from Wright 's ; for right lines drawn from the center thro ' all the points in the spheric surface , and terminating in the concave surface of the tube , are secants , and the tube becomes a tangent line to all those respective secants : And , does not Wright 's uniform dilatation , by the second law of motion , produce the same ?
West stops here , and gives us a chart at once ; Wright calls these his geometrical lineaments only , by which he obtains a rectilinear planisphere , and from whence he demonstrates the principles upon which his table of meridional parts are founded .
And that he does not esteem this as a chart completed , but only his apparatus , and preparative work , which requires yet to be applied and moulded into a true nautical chart , is evident from the next paragraph , Now then ( says he ) let us diligently consider of the geometrical lineaments , that is , the meridians , rhumbs , and parallels of this imaginary nautical planisphere , that we may in like manner express the same in the mariner 's chart : For so undoubtedly we shall have therein a true hydrographical description of all places in their longitudes , latitudes , and directions , or respective situations each from other according to the points of the compass in all things correspondent to the globe , without either sensible , or explicable error ' ' .
And hence he proceeds to the proof and application of these his lineaments , to the construction of his table of latitudes , as he calls it ; which is , in this edition , computed to minutes of parallel-distance , but with a little contrivance in the calculus to educe the same yet somewhat nearer the truth .
Notwithstanding this care and nicety in computaion , he is duly sensible that his increments of latitude calculated to minutes , altho ' without any sensible error , are yet not absolutely true , because they ought to flow with an uniform , and uninterrupted motion ; He therefore cautiously guards against critical remarks hereupon , in the following paragraph : In this table it was thought sufficient to use such exactness , as that thereby ( in drawing the lineaments of the nautical planisphere ) sensible error might be avoided .
He that lists to be more precise may make the like table to decades , or tens of seconds , out of Joachimus Rheticus his Canon Magnus Triangulorum : notwithstanding the geometrician that desires exact truth , cannot be so satisfied neither ; for whose sake and further satisfaction , I thought good to adjoin also this geometrical conceit of dividing a meridian of the nautical planisphere .
' ' Let the equinoctial and a meridian be drawn upon a globe : Let the meridian , divided into degrees , minutes , seconds , &amp;c. roll upon a straight line , beginning at the equinoctial , the globe swelling in the mean time in such sort , that the semidiameter thereof may be always equal to the secant of the angle , or arch contained between the equinoctial and semidiameter insisting at right angles upon the foresaid straight line : The degrees , minutes , seconds , &amp;c. of the meridian , noted in the straight line , as they come to touch the same , are the divisions of the meridian in the nautical planisphere : And this conceit of dividing the meridian of the nautical planisphere may satisfy the curious exactness of the geometrician ; but for mechanical use , the table before mentioned may suffice .
' ' More might be said in favour of Wright 's chart , but I think it is altogether unnecessary ; if his own principles and documents be duly considered ; if almost general practice and experience for a century and an half past can have any weight ; and , if the concurrent testimony and authority of so many eminent mathematicians who have handled this subject since his time , and some of them in a quite different method , can have any poise in the scale of reason .
I have carefully endeavoured not to mistake the true sense and meaning of Mr. West 's proposition in any part thereof ; if I have not , I cannot pronounce what kind of chart may be formed from his tangent line being made the line of latitudes , or that meridian line whereupon the tangents are to determine the sections of their respective parallels : I shall only observe , that , if the meridians be right lines , and parallel to each other , the rhumbs must be right lines also ; but by this tangential projection , these will be deflected from their true bearings , or make the angles of the courses too great , unless some expedient be devised to accommodate this error ; and if the rhumbs be not right lines , such chart will then be embarrassed with more difficulties in practice than Mr. Wright 's .
Upon the whole , it seems as if the editor , confiding in Mr. West 's abilities , hath , without examination , published this proposition ( found amongst many other loose papers , none of which were , perhaps , ever intended for public inspection , as himself says in his apology ) just as he found it ; and that the Reviewers in good opinion of both , and out of tenderness to the widow and family , the book being published for their benefit , have not so critically examined and compared it with what has been already done .
But , notwithstanding what is spoken in favour thereof , I suspect it will have little weight with the mariners , who very well know the value of the Mercator 's chart ( as they call it ) nor are they ever very easily induced to adopt new notions or inventions , and those contrary to what they are familiarised unto by constant practice .
The Critical Reviewers do indeed hint as if this paper had been heretofore communicated by Mr. West to the Royal Society , and that in the following terms : Mr. West lays down the following very ingenious proposition , which , if we do not greatly mistake , we have seen , with little variation , in the Philosophical Transactions , communicated possibly by the same hand ' ' .
In this , I believe , they are mistaken , for I cannot find any thing like it in the transactions since the date 1746 , the year in which it is said to be wrote .
I am duly sensible of the frequent monitions , and sincere desire of the Royal Society , that its members may avoid all possible occasions of controversy ; and whether this account has not a tendency thereunto , if it should , in other respects , be thought worthy of a place in the public Transactions , is submitted , with all due respect , to the determination of the Committee of papers .
I have the honour to be , Sir , With the greatest esteem , The Royal Society 's , and also Gainsford Street , Southwark ; Jan. 26th , 1763 .
your most obedient , and faithful humble servant , William Mountain .

