masterly performance , and a thing of the greatest merit and importance in navigation .
That there is a respect due to Edward Wright for his invention , that his principles are true , that Mr. West or his editor , and both ( if both of the same opinion ) are false , is most certain .
That the characters and abilities of Dr. Halley , Sir Jonas Moore , Mr. William Jones , Mr. James Hodgson , Mr. Haselden , and many others , for they are almost numberless , both of higher and lower mathematicians , who have wrote on the certainty and utility of Wright 's chart , I say , that the characters and abilities of these able geometricians are attacked by Mr. West and his editor , and by the Critical Reviewers , is plain , and that this will have great weight with many not over well acquainted with geometry is no less plain .
And what will an honest seaman say , who knows but just to make his calculations , when he reads the account given in this book , of Mercator 's chart ?
And what must those gentlemen among the subscribers to Mr. West 's book say or think , who , not being quite masters of geometry , are at liberty to believe or disbelieve Dr. Halley and many others , or Mr. West and his editor ?
Those who are masters of geometry must see the error .
But there are other circumstances ; Edward Wright himself gives the very same construction by his words , as Mr. West doth , although his tables make out quite another thing , that is , both Wright and West say expressly , the sphere being inscribed in the hollow cylinder , and the equinoctial remaining fixed without swelling whilst the other parts swell towards the poles , the chart will be formed .
But in this , Wright has badly expressed his own thoughts , for his tables make it that the equinoctial must either swell or contract itself .
And this is very excusable in Edward Wright , for at that time geometricians had no notion of Fluxions , or the increase of magnitude by local motion .
Mr. West and his editor have therefore fallen into this error ; they have taken the words but not the sense of Edward Wright , and the Critical Reviewers vindicate them , and make it as though this property had been communicated to the Royal Society by Mr. West , the particulars of which may be seen in the Review just now mentioned .
The proposed demonstration of this tangential property at page 58 of Mr. West 's book , is no demonstration at all , there is nothing more plain , than that , in order to have the meridians at equal distances , the degrees of latitude must be enlarged to the same proportion in every part , as the circular meridians are nearer towards the poles , which proportion is as the cosine of the latitude to the radius .
I am , Rev. Sir , Your most obedient servant , Chelsea , Sept. 4 , 1762 .
Samuel Dunn .
XVIII .
Remarks on the Censure of Mercator 's Chart , in a posthumous Work of Mr. West , of Exeter : In a Letter to Thomas Birch .
D. D. Secretary to the Royal Society , from Mr. Samuel Dunn .
Rev. Sir , I Should not be so ready to trouble you with the contents of this letter , had I not the highest opinion of your readiness to assist the scientific , in all matters wherein you are able .
Read Nov. 11 , 1762 .
I request therefore your consideration , between this time and the next when I have the pleasure to see you , if any paper has been printed in the Philosophical Transactions , concerning a sphere being inscribed in a hollow cylinder , and swelling its surface to the sides of the cylinder , to construct thereby a more true and accurate chart for the purposes of navigation , than that which was invented by Edward Wright , and hath long gone under the name of Mercator .
The reason why I ask this is , because there is lately published , a posthumous work of one Mr. West of Exeter , revised by J. Row , in which it is strongly insisted on , that the graduation of Mercator 's chart is erroneous , and that the same , if rightly correspondent with the loxodromiques or rhumbs , should be graduated as a line of natural tangents , from the equinoctial to the poles .
Now this error might have past the less observed , but the Critical Review of last month sets it forth as a

