XIII .
Observations on Sand Iron : In a Letter from Mr. Henry Horne , to Mr. John Ellicot , F. R. S. SIR , AS the affair of the rich American Iron Ore , commonly known by the name of the Virginia black sand , has of late not only engaged the conversation of many of the Virtuosi , but has been taken very particular notice of by the Society for the encouragement of arts and manufactures ; I thought myself obliged , for many reasons , to lay before you whatever has come to my knowledge relating to this discovery , either from my own experiments , or from the information of others .
And I engage in this service with the greater pleasure , as I look upon it to be one of the most interesting discoveries , with regard to this useful metal , that has come to our knowledge for some ages , and , if rightly conducted , may prove of infinite service to us in this part of the world , as well as to the inhabitants of our colonies , where ( as it has been supposed , though without sufficient foundation ) this discovery was first made .
Read March 3 , 1763 .
Without any farther preface or apology , permit me to remind you , that , in a conversation which formerly passed between us upon this subject , I acquainted you , that , about twenty years since , I was engaged in making a variety of experiments upon the nature of Iron Ores , and Steel ; and that I then made a very particular enquiry into the nature of this black sand , and , in the course of these experiments , several very interesting phenomena discovered themselves , which , as they might be of great service to the world in general , and more especially to such as are concerned in smelting of the iron from the ore , I had thoughts of communicating to the public ; but , as my business will not permit me to go through the whole at present , I shall confine myself to what relates to the black sand .
I procured , from Mr. Adams the Virginia merchant , a sufficient quantity of the sand , and , in order to estimate its comparative weight with that of iron ore , I procured some of the richest ore I could get , which having reduced to powder , I filled an ordinary teacup with it .
I afterwards filled the same cup with some of the sand , and upon comparing the weights with each other , I found that the weight of the sand was to that of the ore as 3 to 2 ; and having taken notice how readily the sand was attracted by the magnet , I was convinced that the sand must certainly contain a very considerable quantity of Iron , and therefore determined to make trial of it .
I was however , for some time , interrupted in my design , by information I received from a friend , that such an enquiry had been made many years before , by a member of the Royal Society , and a gentleman of esteem as a chemist , but without success ; and that the experiments were published in the 2d vol. of Lowthorp 's Abridgment of the Philosophical Transactions .
As this account is very short as well as curious , I shall take the liberty to give it you entire , with some few remarks upon it .
' ' A black shining sand from Virginia examined by Dr. All .
Moulen .
A small vial filled with ordinary white sand , and containing only ~ i. gr. xi .
being filled with the Virginia sand , was found to contain ~ , ~ .
gr. i. This sand did apply to the magnet both before and after calcination ; but the latter did apply better to it than the former .
A parcel of this sand , mixed and calcined with powdered charcoal , and kept in a melting furnace for about an hour , yielded no regulus : but applied more vigorously to the Loadstone than either of the former .
I fluxed a parcel of this sand with fixed nitre , in a melting furnace , for above an hour , but could obtain no regulus ; nor any substance that would apply to the magnet , except a thin crust that stuck firmly to a piece of charcoal that dropped into the crucible when the matter was in fusion .
I fluxed it also with salt-petre and powdered charcoal , dropping pieces of charcoal afterwards into the crucible .
It continued about half an hour in the melting furnace in fusion , and that without producing a regulus , or a substance that would apply to the magnet , excepting only what stuck to the charcoal as in the former experiment .
I fluxed another parcel of it with salt-petre and flower of brimstone , without being able to procure any regulus .
I poured good spirit of salt on a parcel of this sand , but could observe no luctation thereby produced .
I poured spirit of nitre , both strong and weakened with water , on parcels of the same sand , without being able to discover any conflict .
I poured single aqua fortis upon another parcel of it , without being able to perceive any ebullition worth noting .
I used also double aqua fortis upon another parcel of it , which , for ought I could discover , had no more effect on it than the former .
I poured some aqua regia on a parcel of it , without discovering any sensible effect .
I poured good oil of vitriol upon another parcel of this sand ; but seeing no bubbles thereby produced , I weakened the oil with water , but without any visible effect .
I repeated all the former experiments with the menstruums upon this sand after calcination per se in a crucible , but could scarce observe a bubble produced by any of them .
I poured some of each of the liquors upon parcels of the powder of this sand calcined , without any success .
Note , that I made these experiments both in the cold , and upon a sand furnace .
So that to me there seems to be but little wanting to discover any metal known to us , if it contained any such : for there is no metal nor ore that some of these menstruums will not work on .
I powdered a fragment of a loadstone , and poured some of these menstruums upon it , without being able to find that they in the least preyed upon it , any more than they did upon the sand .
I poured some of the aforementioned menstruums upon ordinary sand taken out of a sand furnace , where it must have suffered some calcination ; but could find no more bubbles produced thereby , than what might rationally be supposed to be produced from lime , and other dirt mixed with the sand .
' ' Having thoroughly considered these experiments , they appeared to me far from being decisive , and that if the Doctor had placed more confidence in the power of the magnet , and less in his menstruums , he would rather have concluded that there might be some sorts of iron ore which his menstruums would not touch in the moist way , nor any regulus be produced from them in the dry , as he made use of them , which yet might , under some other hands , be subdued , by more apt and powerful methods than any which at that time he was acquainted with .
However I apprehended I might fairly draw this conclusion from his experiments , viz. that the sand was not altogether and simply iron , but that it was strongly united with a very stubborn , fixed , and permanent earth , which could not be separated from it without some extraordinary , as well as powerful means ; but I could not think this a sufficient objection to the prosecution of an experiment , which , if it succeeded , might be attended with very happy consequences .
Proceeding therefore upon this supposition , I mixed up about 8 or 9 ounces of the sand ; with a proportional quantity of a strong corrosive flux , which I put together into a crucible , and committed it to a very strong fire in an excellent wind-furnace , where I kept it for between two and three hours , hoping by this means to have answered the intended purpose ; but I confess I was not a little surprised , that , after the crucible was taken from the fire , I could not find one single grain of metal in the remaining contents .
This disappointment greatly puzzled me , till having thoroughly examined into the unexpected event , without being able to discover any reason sufficient to incline me to recede from my former opinion , as to the component parts of the sand , I concluded that the flux might possibly be a very improper one ; for though it might have effected the intended separation , yet it might at the same time be sufficiently powerful to divide the particles of the metal , when separated , so very minutely , as to be capable of subliming and carrying them off imperceptibly : And finding the contents greatly diminished , so that the quantity remaining bore but a small proportion to that which was first put into the crucible , I concluded that this must really have been the case , and that some very different method must be pursued in order to produce the desired effects .
I immediately determined to make a second trial , in which I proceeded in the following manner .
I took the same quantity of sand made use of in the former experiment ; and first I spread it , without any addition to it , upon an iron plate over a strong fire , where I gave it a very powerful torrification ( or roasting ) to try if , by that means , I could not relax , and loosen the component parts to such a degree , as to make the separation and reduction of the metal more easy , when I should bring it into the furnace .
When I had so done , I mixed it up with a flux of a very peculiar , but gentle nature , which I had before made use of for other purposes with great success , and committed it ( as in the former experiment ) to the furnace , where I urged it by a very strong fire for about three hours , and upon taking it out , I found the event answerable to my most sanguine expectations : for in the bottom of the crucible I found , as near as I can remember , rather more than half of the sand I put into the crucible reduced to a very fine malleable metal .
In this very agreeable experiment I met with a very surprising phenomenon , which , as I am not at present able to determine whether it was only casual , or what would always happen in the like experiments , you will excuse my divulging at present , especially as you , Sir , by furnishing me with a fresh parcel of the sand , have enabled me to make some farther trials ; which I shall embrace the first opportunity of doing ; and should I be so happy as to confirm what I then observed , or to make any farther discoveries deserving your notice , I shall not fail communicating them to you .
Being fully convinced , by the experiment , that the sand was a very rich iron ore , I acquainted some of my friends with it , who being largely engaged in trade to those parts of our American colonies , where I was informed this sand was to be easily procured , and in very large quantities , I was in great hopes an account of this nature would have inclined some of the gentlemen in that part of the world , to have prosecuted so useful a discovery in a larger way ; and I own I have often wondered , that an affair of such consequence should have lain dormant for so many years .
However I was a few months since pleasingly surprised , to find in the hands of my very ingenious friend Mr. Peter Collinson , not only a pamphlet , but likewise a letter upon the subject addressed to the Society for encouraging of arts and manufactures , by one Mr. G. Elliott , who relates , that , though previous to his attempt of making iron from this sand , he met with nothing but what was discouraging from the most skillful persons to whom he proposed his design , yet that he had such a persuasion in his own mind of the practicability of the thing , that he could not rest till he had made a trial , and the event proved encouraging much beyond his expectations , insomuch that he could scarcely believe the trial had been fairly made , till a second trial evinced with certainty , that eighty three pounds of the sand would produce a barr of excellent iron weighing fifty pounds : a prodigious yield indeed , and far beyond what I have ever heard of from the richest common ores that are any where to be found ; most of the ores I have ever met with or heard of , yield little more than half in pig metal , and which will suffer a waste of near 1/ 6 part to make tolerable good barr iron , and much more if I am rightly informed , when the iron is intended for more valuable purposes , such as being drawn into wire , &amp;c. After I had seen his address in his letter to the Society , and his pamphlet ; by the assistance of my friend Mr. Collinson , I sent him over two or three hints , which I judged might be of some service to him ; this produced the favour of a letter from him , of which the following is an exact copy .
Mr. HENRYHOR N , Sir , Killingworth , Oct. 4 .
1762 .
I Understand by Mr. Collinson , that you have seen , and greatly approve of , the sample of sand iron which was sent ; that you are desirous to know how it was made , and whether it can be made in large bars .
The little barr you saw , was cut off from a barr of 52 pounds and a half , the first that was made at my son 's work , the first that was ever made in America , and probably the first that was ever made in the world , in that manner , and so large a barr .
I never heard of any attempt made upon the iron sand , till that of yours 20 years ago , of which Mr. Collinson gave me an account in his letter .
As to the manner of making the iron , it is wrought or smelted in a common bloomary , in the same manner as other iron ore is smelted ; excepting this difference , this iron sand is so pure , so clean washed , that there is not a sufficient quantity of cinder or slagg to promote and perform the smelting , therefore we add either the slagg which issues from other iron , or else add some bog mine ore , which abounds with cinder ; in this way it is as capable of being wrought as rock ore or bog mine .
I was in hopes that if this iron sand could be wrought at all , the particles being so very fine , it would smelt very quick ; but herein I found myself mistaken , every particle has a will of its own , and must have its own particular smelting , for instead of its being performed in less time , it took more than common iron ore , but , upon farther experience , and more acquaintance with this sand , the workman has shortened the operation from five hours down to three : if by any means it might be reduced to the same time with pig iron , it would be a most useful improvement .
If you can afford any directions to hasten the operation ; I should be greatly obliged for any instructions .
There is so much of this sand in America , that I am apt to think , that there is more iron ore in this form of sand than in mines .
I have written an essay upon the subject , which I hope Mr. Collinson will let you see , as I hope to see what you are about to publish .
My son has a steel furnace , which was erected several years before the act of parliament prohibiting them in the plantations : he has converted some of the sand iron into steel , of which I send you a sample ; as also a sample of the iron .
As my son had no instructions for making steel , we were forced to hammer out the skill by various trials as we could ; so conclude that he is still imperfect , and wants your help and direction to bring it to perfection , in which art I understand that you are a perfect master , and withal kind enough to offer your assistance ; for which I am very thankful , and look upon it as an aditional favour , if you will be pleased to indulge me with the benefit of your correspondence , for I live in a corner of the world where such information as , I trust , you are able to furnish , will be highly beneficial .
Previous to my attempt of making iron from sand , I proposed my project to those who were the most skillful in those affairs , but met with nothing but what was discouraging ; yet after all , had a persuasion of the practicability of the thing to a degree next to enthusiasm , so that I could not rest till I had made trial .
I am glad that the iron has such qualities as to meet with your approbation ; I knew that the iron was good , but did not know that it was so good as your superior knowledge has found it .
I want to know what such iron will sell for in England , whether it will be worth while to send it .
This black sand is a treasure that has long lain hidden from the world , and is what may render the colonies more valuable to Great Britain .
I am , Sir , Your most obliged humble servant , Jared Eliot .
P. S. The bars of iron which have hitherto been made of sand , are from fifty to fifty gross , hope in time to have them reach to seventy pounds weight each ; experience must determine that matter , we can do better than at the time the essay was written .
We have been visited with a long and sore drought , have done nothing for a long time for want of water .
The samples which accompanied this letter , were two small bars , weighing only a few ounces , one of the iron made from the sand , the other of steel made from the same iron .
These bars I have tried , and found that the barr of steel worked extremely well under the hammer , was very pure and clean , and free from flaws .
On the contrary the barr of iron turned out much otherwise , for , though it appeared to bear the force of the hammer , as well as the steel , yet it was not near so pure , but broke out in flaws and hollows , almost through the whole of the barr , and which a welding heat would by no means bring into proper union ; this however engaged us to try a different method , which was , when the barr was reduced into a proper size for the purpose , to double it up three times , one part of the barr upon the other , and to try if it would then bear welding and become more consistent , and by this means we found the end perfectly well answered ; for it bore the force of the fire and the hammer , and became in a manner perfectly sound .
This severe trial proved , to a demonstration , that the iron possessed all that agreeable toughness and ductility , for which the Spanish iron is so deservedly famous , without partaking of that vile redshire quality , for which the latter is very remarkable , and manifestly tends to prove the excellency of this sand iron , when reduced into barr iron under proper care and circumspection .
You will observe , Sir , from the letter , that this sand is so pure , and so clean washed , that their first method of reducing the sand to barr iron proved too tedious , for want of some of those adventitious materials , to promote and perform the smelting , and which always accompanies the common ore , whether it be of the rock or bog kind ; which materials , mixing with the matter , made use of by way of flux , and uniting with the ashes of the fuel employed in melting down the ore , is usually run into a thick opake glassy substance , forming , as it were , a covering over the metal , which , by its gravity , naturally sinks to the bottom ; this the workmen call cinder .
Now the want of this matter rendering the operation too tedious , I find they had recourse either to this cinder brought from other iron works , or to a quantity of the bogmine , which , I doubt not , would abundantly furnish matter for cinder .
If they had used only the first , and that properly chosen , it might very probably have been of some service , without doing any material injury to the metal ; but if the bog mine is used , though the service might be apparently more , yet in all likelihood the injury would be infinitely great , and I am inclined to believe that something of this kind occasioned the difference observed between the two bars above mentiond , viz. that the one might have been reduced by the help of more pure materials , and the other by the assistance of their bogmine , whose constituent parts abounding with many impurities , some of which , by mixing with the metal , may have occasioned the defects above complained of , and which required so severe an operation both of the fire and hammer to separate from it .
I am therefore of opinion , that as the prosecution of this useful discovery deserves the greatest encouragement , if the Society of arts and manufactures should take it under their patronage , the premium they may think proper to propose should rather be given to the person who shall produce the purest metal , than to him who shall produce the greatest quantity , for otherwise , I am afraid , we shall be deprived of what I should esteem the most valuable part of this discovery , I mean the obtaining a more pure , and better kind kind of iron , than any we have hitherto been possessed of , and which I am certain this sand , under proper management , is capable of producing .
I am , Sir , with the greatest respect , Your most obedient Feb. 5 , 1763 .
humble servant , Henry Horne .

