XCIII .
A Letter from the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , M. A. F. R. S. to the Rev. Thomas Birch , D. D. Secretary to the Royal Society : containing the Results of Observations of the Distance of the Moon from the Sun and fixed Stars , made in a Voyage from England to the Island of St. Helena , in order to determine the Longitude of the Ship , from Time to Time ; together with the whole Process of Computation used on this Occasion .
SIR , St. Helena , Sept. 9 , 1761 .
DUring the course of my voyage from England to this place , I made frequent observations of the distance of the Moon from the Sun and fixed stars , in order to determine our longitude : and , as from their agreement with each other , I humbly conceive it will be allowed , that the longitude may in general be ascertained by this method to sufficient exactness for nautical purposes , I flatter myself it may not be disagreeable to the Royal Society , if I communicate to them , through your hands , the results of my observations .
I shall likewise deliver the whole process of computation , which I use in deducing the longitude from an observation , wherein I include several useful rules of my own investigation , which , I apprehend , render the calculation not only much shorter , but also much less intricate than it was before .
Read June 24 , and July 1 , 1762 .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient , humble servant , MY Hadley 's quadrant , which was made by Mr. Bird , the radius of which is 20 inches , appears , from all the trials I have made with it , to be very exact ; this , indeed , the observations of the Moon alone sufficiently prove , since I have often taken the distance of the Moon from two stars , on different sides , on the same night , and found the same longitude to result from these separate observations , with as little difference as from two observations of the same star ; whereas , if there was the least error in the division of the quadrant , or the least refraction in the glasses of it , the error arising from hence affecting the computation of the longitude from the two separate observations contrary ways , must be sensible in the result .
I was secured from any errors in the construction of the quadrant , by the known skill of the artist ; and the speculums , as well as dark glasses , were ground by Mr. Dollond , by a particular method of his own , by which he is certain of making the two surfaces of a glass truly parallel to each other .
The arch and the index were both of brass , and the frame of well seasoned mahogany ; the Vernier 's scale on the index carried the subdivisions to single minutes ; and the eye might subdivide still nearer to the fraction of a minute .
When the index was brought near the proper distance for observation , in order to give it a more steady motion than the hand alone could , a plate was screwed down to the arch , containing the head of a screw , by turning of which , the index was carried backwards or forwards at pleasure .
This contrivance was extremely necessary for taking the distance of a star from the Moon 's limb in an exact manner ; for the quadrant being often to be held in a very inclined plane , it was impossible , on account of the motion of the ship , to make the observation at once ; therefore , by means of the screw , the index was moved by gentle degrees , and each time after altering the screw , the quadrant was turned by the hand round the visual ray , going to the star as an axis , so as to make the star seem to pass by the Moon 's limb , and the index was gradually moved , till at last the star , in passing by , exactly swept the Moon 's limb .
Besides the screw moving the index , there was another addition no less necessary , which was a dark glass , much brighter than any of those commonly used , to take off the excessive brightness of the Moon , and that glare upon the horizon-glass , which always attends it .
Without the use of this glass , it was not easy to observe accurately the distance of a star from the Moon 's limb , except when the Moon 's light was weakened by a thin cloud .
In order to render the contact of a star with the Moon 's limb more discernible , I always used a small telescope , magnifying about four times , except when the motion of the ship was very troublesome , though I reckoned the observations were not quite so exact as those made with the telescope .
The telescope , by means of two swivels adapted to it , had a motion parallel to itself , by which it was carried nearer to or further from the plane of the quadrant ; by means of which , the Moon , which was seen always by reflexion , was rendered more or less bright , according as more or less of her light was received by the telescope , from the quicksilvered part of the object speculum ; or by raising the telescope still higher from the plane of the quadrant , the Moon was seen entirely by reflexion from the unsoiled part of the speculum , which I generally found to be the most convenient : for my part , I should always recommend the using of a small telescope , magnifying about three times , as it would make the objects appear more distinct , and render the contact of the star with the Moon 's limb more evident .
My telescope , which was about 6 inches long , consisted of two convex glasses , so that it inverted objects ; which is of no sort of inconvenience to people , who have been used to inverting telescopes , the practise of which is soon acquired .
But if any one would rather chuse to have a telescope that shows objects in their natural position , he may use one consisting of a convex object-glass and a concave eye-glass ; which kind of telescope answers better in short lengths than the other .
Before I deliver the process of the computation of the longitude , I shall first say something with respect to the observations themselves , and mention some cautions concerning them .
A most particular attention must be paid to the exact adjustment of the quadrant , as a thing of equal consequence with the observation of the distance of the star from the Moon .
This is so much the more necessary , as the adjustment is subject to alter sensibly , even from one day to another .
The best object of all for this purpose is the horizon of the sea , when clear ; and I found it most convenient , in this case , not to use the telescope , but applied a concave glass to my eye , which was fitted for giving me the most distinct view of distant objects , which also I always used in all observations where the telescope was not applied .
The observer should always be careful to examine the adjustment of his quadrant in the day-time , when the horizon is to be seen clearly , and particularly in the afternoon , when he expects to make an observation the ensuing night .
Should he have failed of making this examination the afternoon before an observation , he may examine what the error was , if any , the next morning ; or he may make this examination by means of the Moon itself , in which case , it will be best to use the telescope ; though the horizon of the sea is , in general , by far the best object for this purpose .
As I found my quadrant would seldom continue exactly adjusted for twenty-four hours together , instead of fresh adjusting it every day , I chose rather to examine what the error of the adjustment itself was .
This is done by turning the index of the quadrant , till the horizon of the sea , or the Moon , or any other proper object , appears as one , and then the number of minutes , by which o on the index differs from o on the arch , is the error of the adjustment .
If o on the index stands advanced upon the quadrant , before or to the left hand of o on the arch , that number of minutes is to be subtracted from all observations ; but if it stands off the arch behind , or to the right hand of o on the arch , it must be added to the observations .
By examining the error of the adjustment in this manner , by at least three trials , and taking a medium of the results , one can scarce err above half a minute in determining the exact error of the quadrant ; whereas one may be mistaken a minute , or more , by a single trial .
The observer would do well to write down in a book the error of adjustment thus found , and which way it is to be applied , whether it is additive or subtractive .
As it is necessary to know the exact time of the day , when the distance of the star from the Moon is taken , which can only be found at sea , by an altitude of the Sun , or a star ; and as the altitude of a proper star cannot always be taken with sufficient exactness in the night for this purpose , I would recommend it to the observer , when he expects to observe the Moon at night , to take an altitude of the Sun in the afternoon , two or three hours from noon , the more the better , provided the Sun be not too near the horizon ; noting the exact time shown by his watch , at the instant of observation ; which will show him , by computation , how much his watch is too fast or slow for the meridian of the place ; whence the time shown by the watch being also noted , when the distance of the star from the Moon was taken , he will know what the exact time of the day then was .
Or if an altitude of the Sun was not taken the evening before , an altitude might be taken the next morning , after the observation of the Moon , provided the interval of time between the observation of the Moon , and the Sun 's altitude did not exceed twelve hours ; for a good common watch would hardly vary above a minute during that space of time , which only makes an error of a quarter of a degree of longitude .
The time being determined by an altitude of the Sun or a star , and the distance of a proper star from the Moon 's limb , or the distance of the Sun and Moon 's nearest limbs in the first and last quarter , being carefully observed , the longitude may be found from thence , without any other observations : and this is the method proposed by the late Dr. Halley , which certainly deserves to be highly esteemed for its great simplicity , and the small number of observations which it requires .
Nevertheless , I must own myself of opinion with the learned Abbe De la Caille , that it will be more convenient at sea to require the aid of more observations , which is the method I constantly practised myself , during my voyage , having always two observers , who were ready , one to take the altitude of the star , and the other of the Moon 's upper or lower limb , at the instant I spoke when I had made the observaton of the distance of the star from the Moon .
I can therefore answer , from my own experience , both that the method is practicable at sea , and also , that so far from being less simple , it is more so than the other method ; for the additional observations that it requires are very easily made , and even the error of a degree in the altitudes would seldom be of more consequence than an error of a minute , in taking the distance of the star from the Moon ; so that an error of 10~ or 15~ in the altitudes would be of no great prejudice : but with respect to the facility of the calculations , there is no comparison between the methods , the latter being much less intricate , and much more concise .
The Abbe De la Caille requires the altitude of that part of the Moon 's limb from which the distance of the star is taken ; but as at sea we can only take the altitude of the Moon 's upper or lower limb , an allowance might be made near enough , by estimation of the eye , for the difference of altitude between the Moon 's upper or lower limb , and that part of the limb from which the distance of the star is taken , I generally added the semidiameter of the Moon to , or subtracted it from , the observed altitude of the lower or upper limb , in order to have the apparent altitude of the center , and I found the apparent distance of the star from the Moon 's center , by adding or subtracting the Moon 's horizontal semidiameter , augmented according to her height , to or from the observed distance of the star from the Moon 's nearest or remotest limb .
This method will be exact enough , if the altitude of the Moon or star be not less than 5~ .
Having thus got three sides of the spherical triangle formed by the Moon , the star , and the zenith ; namely , the apparent zenith distance of the Moon , the apparent zenith distance of the star , and the distance of the star from the Moon , I find the effect of refraction and parallax , in altering the apparent distance of the star from the Moon , by the two following rules : RULE I. To find the effect of refraction in contracting the apparent distance of two stars , or of the Moon and a star .
Add together the logarithm-tangents of half the sum , and half the difference of the two zenith distances , the sum abating 10 from the index is the tangent of arc the first .
To the logarithm-tangent just found , add the logarithm-cotangent of half the distance of the two stars , the sum abating 10 from the index is the tangent of arc the second .
Then add together into one sum the logarithm-tangent of double the first arc , the co-secant of double the second arc , and the constant logarithm 2.0569 ; the sum abating 20 from the index is the logarithm of the number of seconds required ; by which the distance of the stars , or of the Moon and stars , is contracted by refraction : which therefore , added to the observed distance , gives the true distance , cleared from refraction .
N. B. This rule may be made universal , so as to serve with equal exactness almost down to the horizon , if the apparent zenith distances be diminished by three times the refraction belonging to them , found from any common table of refraction , and the computation be made with the zenith distances thus corrected .
But if the altitudes of the Moon and star be not less than 10~ , this correction will not be necessary .
It will not be proper to make the observations , if the altitudes of the star and Moon are either of of them less than 4~ or 5~ , on account of the variableness of refraction near the horizon .
RULE II .
To find how much the distance of the Moon and a star is increased or diminished , on account of the Moon 's parallax .
Add together into one sum the logarithm-tangents of half the sum , and half the difference of the zenith distances , and the cotangent of half the distance of the Moon and star , all corrected for refraction ; the sum , abating 20 from the index , is the tangent of arc the third , for which arc the second , found by the first rule , may be taken , without any sensible error .
Then , if the zenith distance of the Moon is greater than that of the star , take the sum of this arc , and half the distance of the Moon and star ; but if the zenith distance of the Moon is less than that of the star , take the difference of the said arcs ; the tangent of the sum or difference , which may be called the parallactic arch , added to the cosine of the Moon 's zenith distance , and the logarithm of the Moon 's horizontal parallax in minutes , abating 20 from the index , is the logarithm of the number of minutes required , by which the apparent distance of the Moon from the star is always augmented by parallax , unless the zenith distance of the star be greater than that of the Moon , and , at the same time , arc the third be greater than half the distance of the Moon and star ; in which case , the apparent distance of the Moon and star is diminished by the parallax : Therefore , the number of minutes found by this rule is always to be subtracted from the observed distance of the Moon and star , first corrected for refraction , in order to find the true distance , cleared from the effect of parallax likewise ; except in the case specified , when the zenith distance of the star is greater than that of the Moon , and arc the third is at the same time greater than half the distance of the Moon and star , when the correction is to be added .
In computing these corrections , four places of figures , besides the index , will be sufficient .
It remains to be found , by calculation , at what hour under a known meridian , the distance of the Moon from the star will be the same as results from the observation , cleared of refraction and parallax .
For this purpose , it is necessary to compute the Moon 's longitude and latitude , and horary motion both in longitude and latitude , from the most exact tables for the time under the known meridian , which is judged to correspond nearly to the given time of observation under the unknown meridian .
The mean motions of the Sun and Moon I took from very exact tables , which I received as a present from the ingenious Mr. Gael Morris , composed by himself , from the comparison of a great number of Dr. Bradley 's observations ; to which I applied the lunar equations , as they stand in the learned Mr. Mayer 's printed tables .
After finding the mean longitude of the star at the present time , I always allowed for its aberration in longitude , which will sometimes amount to 20~ , without considering the aberration in latitude , which can be of no consequence in a zodiacal star , such as those are which are always to be used in these observations .
The distance of the star from the Moon I computed from their longitudes and latitude , by the two following rules : RULE I. Add together the logarithmic cosine of the difference of the computed longitudes of the Moon and star , and logarithmic cosine of the difference of their latitudes , if they are of the same denomination ; or sum , if they are of different denominations ; the sum , abating 10 from the index , is the cosine of the approximate distance .
N. B. This gives the absolute distance of the Moon from the Sun , without any further calculation .
But in case of a star , it is necessary to apply another rule also .
Seven places of logarithms , besides the index , must be used , in computing from this rule , and the calculation must be carried to seconds .
RULE II .
To the constant logarithm 3.5363 , add the sines of the Moon 's and star 's latitudes , the versed-sine of the difference of longitude , and the co-secant of the approximate distance just found ; the sum , abating 40 from the index , is the logarithm of a number of minutes , to be subtracted from the approximate distance , to find the true distance , if the latitudes of the Moon and star are of the same denomination ; but to be added , if they are of contrary denominations .
The second of these two rules , though only an approximation , is so exact , that if the latitude of the Moon was 5~ , and that of the star 15~ , the error resulting would be only 10~ in the distance .
Four places of figures will be sufficient in computing from this rule .
If the distance of the Moon from the star thus computed , at the assumed time under a known meridian , suppose Greenwich , agrees with the distance observed , corrected for refraction and parallax , the time at Greenwich was assumed right , and the difference between this time and the time of the observation under the unknown meridian , is the difference of longitude in time between the said meridian and Greenwich ; which is turned into degrees and minutes of the equator , by allowing 15~ for every hour , and 1~ for every four minutes of time .
But if the distance computed differs from the distance inferred from the observation , it must be found by proportion from the Moon 's horary motion to or from the star , how long time she will take to run over that difference ; whence the time will be found at Greenwich , when the true distance of the Moon from the star was the same with that resulting from the observation ; which , compared with the time of the observation by the meridian of the ship , gives the difference of longitude from Greenwich , as before .
If the distance of the Moon from the star computed agrees with that resulting from observation within 10~ or 12~ , and the distance of the Moon from the star be not less than 20~ or 30~ , the horary motion of the Moon in the ecliptic may be taken for the horary motion of the Moon to or from the star ; but otherwise , the Moon 's longitude and latitude must be found at an hour 's interval after the time assumed at Greenwich , by adding the horary motions to the longitude and latitude computed ; and by the application of the rules , the distance of the star from the Moon must be found again at the end of that hour ; which gives the horary motion to or from the star , as required .
It is to be observed , that the longitude thus found , is that of the ship , at the instant when the altitude of the Sun or star was taken , by which the watch was regulated , and not at the time of the observation of the distance of the star from the Moon ; for the watch being supposed not to vary considerably during that interval of time , must continue , to indicate the time according to the meridian , by which it was corrected ; and the observation of the distance of the Moon from the star showing the time at Greenwich , the difference must show the difference of longitude between that meridian and Greenwich .
Perhaps the following method of deducing the longitude from the observations may be least liable to mistake : Find what the longitude by account was , at the instant of taking the Sun 's or star 's altitude , for the regulation of the watch ; which being turned into time , at the rate of one hour for every 15~ , and four minutes for every degree , add to the correct time from noon , when the distance of the star from the Moon was taken , if the ship is to the west of Greenwich , or subtract from it , if it be to the east : this gives the apparent time at Greenwich by account ; and the mean time is found , by applying the equation of time ; to which time , compute the Moon 's longitude and latitude from the tables , and the distance of the star from the Moon , by the rules , and find , by proportion , as before , what time the Moon will take to run over the difference between the distance computed , and that resulting from the observation ; this turned into degrees and minutes of the equator , will show the error of the ship 's account ; and the following rules will show , whether the ship is to the east or west of its account : If the distance of the Moon observed east of a star ( or the Sun in the first quarter ) is greater than that computed , the ship is west of the longitude by account ; but if the distance observed is less than that computed , it is east of account .
If the distance of the Moon observed west of a star ( or the Sun in the last quarter ) is greater than computed , the ship is east of account ; but if the distance observed is less than computed , it is west of account .
The horary motion of the Moon in the ecliptic may be thus made out very expeditiously from Mayer 's equations , by the help of the principal arguments used in the computation of the Moon 's place .
Call A , B , C , and D , the differences of the equations of the center , evection , and variation , and reduction to the ecliptic , for 1~ addition to their arguments ; where it must be noted , that they must have the same sign as the equation , if it is increasing ; but a contrary sign , if it is decreasing .
Compute the value of 32~ 56~ +Ax1 1/ 2 0x9 9/ 1 00+Bx 1/ 2 x1 6/ 1 7 , which put = H ; and the true horary motion of the Moon in her orbit =H +CxH 2~ 28~/ 60~ , which put = K ' ; and the horary motion of the Moon in the ecliptic is K+Dx K'/ 60~ .
The horary motion of the Moon in latitude , calling the difference , answering to 1~ increase of the argument of latitude E , is Ex K'/ 60~ .
The most difficult part in the above computations , and in which a person is most liable to make mistakes , is the computation of the Moon 's place ; but if this be done at land for every twelve hours at least , and the distance of a proper star , or of two stars , one to the east , and the other to the west , from the Moon 's enlightened limb , be computed for every six hours at least , according to Mons. De la Caille 's proposal , the rest of the computation , which will remain to be done at sea , will be very plain and concise .
Here follows the series of my determinations of the longitude , during my voyage , delivered in an extract of my sea journal .
The first column contains the day of the month ; the second , the latitude ; the third , the longitude , which I deduced from my observations of the Moon , reduced to the nearest noon ; the fourth shows the longitude per account , kept in the usual manner ; the fifth gives the difference between the third and fourth columns , and expresses how much the longitude deduced from the observation of the Moon is west of the longitude per account ; the last column shows , whether the distance of the Sun from the Moon , or distance of what star from the Moon , was observed .
1761 .
~ Jan. 20 .
At noon , took our departure from the ~ , which bore full north , distance 21 miles , allowing its longitude from London to be 5~ 34~ west , and latitude 49~ 57~ north .
Longitude W. by obser Longitude Longitude by The Sun or stars whose distance from Latitude .
vation of per reckonMoon W. of the Moon 's enlightened limb was Moon .
ing .
account .
taken .
o'o'o'o ' ~ Feb. 10 .
16 49 N. 30 22 W. 27 33 W. 2 49 W. Sun 's E. limb from Moon 's W. limb .
11 .
14 3 N. 29 22 W. 26 47 2 35 W. Sun 's E. limb from Moon 's W. limb .
15 .
5 10 N. 23 39 W. 22 44 0 55 W. Cor Leonis from Moon 's W. limb .
19 .
1 42 N. 23 35 22 44 0 51 W. Pollux from Moon 's E. limb .
28 .
96 S. 29 44 26 23 42 W. Sun 's W. limb from Moon 's E. limb .
March 9 .
24 9 S. 30 7 25 55 4 12 Aldebaran from Moon 's W. limb .
10 .
25 51 S. 29 32 24 32 50 Aldebaran from Moon 's W. limb .
13 .
29 49 27 55 22 19 5 36 Sun 's E. limb from Moon 's W. limb .
27 44 5 25 Cor Leonis from Moon 's W. limb .
15 .
30 8 26 52 22 84 44 Cor Leonis from ~ W. limb .
17 .
30 39 24 50 18 58 5 52 Pollux from Moon 's W. limb .
25 567 Spica Virginis from Moon 's W. limb .
18 .
31 1 24 0 18 47 5 13 Pollux from Moon 's W. limb .
24 33 5 46 Spica Virginis from Moon 's W. limb .
19 .
31 37 21 41 17 74 34 Pollux from Moon 's W. limb .
20 .
32 4 20 19 15 27 4 52 Pollux from Moon 's E. limb .
22 46 37 Antares from Moon 's E. limb .
25 .
31 23 12 45 57 67 Spica Virginis from Moon 's E. limb .
26 .
30 51 9 55 4 17 5 38 Spica Virginis from Moon 's E. limb .
29 .
30 32 S. 6 49 W. 1 13 W. 5 36 Sun 's W. limb from Moon 's E. limb .
April 6 .
71/ 2 A. M. came to an ~ in the harbour before James 's fort at St. Helena ; making the latitude per account 15~ 55~ S. longitude per common reckoning 1~ 28~ E. longitude corrected by observations of the Moon 4~ 16~ W. By the comparison of the longitude determined by the Moon , with the longitude by the common reckoning , we seem to have been set by a current to the eastward about 20 miles per day , between February 10th and 15th , while we were passing from 17~ to 5~ north latitude , at the distance of about 11~ westward of the coast of Guinea ; and I am told that ships passing near the coast of Guinea always meet currents , which set them in upon the land , which are so much the stronger the nearer they approach the coast ; as on the contrary , if they approach the opposite coast of the Brasils , they will be set by a current to the westward , which appears to have been our case ; for between February 19th and 28th , during which time we passed by the most eastern part of the coast of Brasils , leaving cape St. Augustin only 6~ to the west of us , we appear to have been set by a current at the rate of 20 miles per day to the westward , and from this time to our arrival at St. Helena , we seem to have been continually set to the westward , though slower than before ; which must have been owing to our approaching so much nearer , and continuing so much longer near the eastern coast of South America , than the western coast of Africa .
Though I had no observation of the Moon within less than eight days of my arrival at St. Helena , I make the longitude of the island , by my account , to be only 1 1~/ 2 east of its true situation , which is 53~/ 4 west of London ; whereas the account kept in the common manner made the island 11~/ 2 east of London , or 7 1~/ 4 east of its true situation , and most of the accounts on board the ship made it 10~ east of the true longitude .
Having got twelve observations in the compass of eleven days , between March 9th and 20th , I had the curiosity to compare them together .
Setting aside any errors in the common method of keeping a ship 's reckoning , and supposing us not to be affected by currents during this time , the same difference ought to have been found between all the longitudes by account , and the longitudes deduced from the Moon , or the same error of the common account ought to have resulted from all the observations .
The mean error of account from all the twelve observations is 5~ 20~ , by which we were really more to the west than our account made us .
And comparing each particular error of account with this quantity , the difference between them , in any of the twelve observations , scarce exceeds a degree ; whence we may suppose , that the longitude was deduced truly from every one of these twelve observations , within the compass of less than 11~/ 2 .
I have set them down in the following table , the error of the common account , and the difference between 5~ 2~ , the mean quantity of it , and each particular error of account , which , except in the first and last observations , does not exceed 3~/ 4 .
The last observation , which differs most from the medium , was taken in some haste , on account of the position of the sails of the ship , which did not allow a mean uninterrupted view of the star ; nevertheless , as I was tolerably satisfied with the observation at the time , and as it does not materially differ from the others , I did not think proper to reject it .
Difference between Error of 5~ 20~ , and each account .
particular error of account .
o'o ' 1761 .
March 9 .
4 12 18 10 .
500 20 13 .
5 36 +0 16 5 25 +05 15 .
4 44 0 36 17 .
5 52 +0 32 67+0 47 18 .
5 13 07 5 46 +0 26 19 .
4 34 0 46 20 .
4 52 0 28 6 37 +1 17 Mean error of account 5 20 After finding so great an agreement in the result of all my different observations , whether made on the same or different stars , or on the same or different nights , I must own I find myself at a loss to account for the great difference found by the Abbe De la Caille , in the result of several observations taken by himself , and a friend of his , at land , which ought to agree still nearer with one another than those made at sea .
I cannot conceive that such able observers could be liable to an error of 5~ in measuring the distance of a star from the Moon 's limb , if their instruments were not faulty .
The most likely and the most common cause of error lies in the speculums and dark glasses ; for if these are not ground truly parallel , which I am afraid they very often are not , by the common methods , they may easily produce a refraction of some minutes .
As a proof how near different observations made in compass of an hour or two will agree in giving the same longitude , February 11th , by ten different observations of the distance of the Moon from the Sun , I made the longitude , reduced to noon as usual , 28~ 57~ , 29~ 50~ , 29~ 16~ , 29~ 22~ , 29~ 53~ , 28~ 59~ , 29~ 30~ , 29~ 48~ , 29~ 30~ , 29~ 30~ : none of which differ above half a degree from 29~ 22~ , which is the medium of them all .
March 18th , by four different observations of the distance of Pollux from the Moon , I found the longitude 23~ 52~ twice , and 24~ 8~ twice .
I never found that a single observation would give the longitude above a degree different from the medium resulting from three or four observations , and seldom above half a degree ; which argues , that the error of any single observation never exceeded two minutes , and seldom one minute .
From the whole , I congratulate the curious astronomer and ingenious mariner , that the method of finding the longitude , proposed by Sir Isaac Newton , is by the improvement of the theory , of which he laid the foundation , and , by the great perfection to which our artists have carried the construction of instruments , rendered practicable in our times , at sea as well as at land , to a degree of exactness sufficient to make it of great and valuable utility to the extensive navigation and commerce of our native country .

