LXXIX .
An Account of a Work , entitled , Jacobi Christiani Schaeffer icones et descriptio Fungorum quorundam singularium et memorabilium ; simul Fungorum Bavariae icones nativis coloribus expressae editioni , jam paratae , propediem evulgandae , denunciantur ; by Mr. William Hudson , F. R. S. THIS treatise consists of sixteen pages , and is divided into two parts ; the first contains the figures and descriptions of some singular and remarkable Fungi ; the second contains proposals for publishing the figures of all the Fungi growing in Bavaria , coloured after nature .
The title page farther sets forth , that the materials for this work are already provided , and that it is carried on under the direction , and at the expense , of the Electoral Academy at Munich in Bavaria .
Read March 25 , 1762 .
The author begins , by saying , that as it fell to his lot , to inform the public , that the edition of this most useful work , which was promised last year , was actually begun ; but he could not prevail on himself to conform to the plain method commonly used on these occasions ; thinking it would be more acceptable to the public , if he prefixed something of a new and singular nature to the proposals ; to which purpose , nothing could be better adapted , as it seemed to him , than coloured figures , and descriptions of some remarkable Fungi , which had lately fallen in his way .
These were selected from a number of others , and , according to him , serve to illustrate and confirm an hypothesis he had adopted , and by which the existence of seeds , and consequently the propagation of the Fungi , are rendered doubtful .
The Fungi , which he has given figures of , and which he uses to confirm his opinion , are certainly very irregular , and perhaps not easy to be accounted for .
In the three first of them , more than one Fungus grows from one common base , or stem ; and what seems extraordinary to the author is , that part of the base of one of the Fungi does not touch the ground , but rests on the pileus , or cap of the other , and consequently cannot receive from the ground what is necessary for its rise , evolution , and nourishment .
I must own , I do not see the force of this argument ; for why may not one common stem , the bottom of which is fixed in the ground , give nourishment to each of the Fungi , though part of the stem of one rests upon the pileus of the other ?
Does not common experience prove , that nourishment can be conveyed through imperfect branches , even when such parts as would be judged , at first sight , to be necessary to convey the nutritive pieces are wanting ?
This is the case of trees , when all the bark is stripped off quite round a branch , and yet that branch shall bear flowers and fruit , in great quantity .
The fourth figure exhibits two Fungi , out of the pileus of which grows another complete Fungus , with stem , pileus , and lamellae , of the same kind with the lower one , in every respect .
However extraordinary this may be , yet it seems by no means to prove prove his hypothesis , or even suggest any reason for a new one , about the propagation of the Fungi ; for why may not the cap of the Fungus afford as proper a bed for a seed , that happens to be lodged there , as the earth itself ?
We know that a birch tree has often been found growing out of the head of an oak , yet no one suspects from thence , that the birch is propagated without seed .
Our author , indeed , seems to be sensible himself of the insufficiency of his arguments , hitherto made use of , to prove his new hypothesis , and suspects , he says , had he nothing more to produce in its favour , people might be apt to make objections ; but luckily he has two other Fungi , that will serve his purpose better , which are represented by figure the fifth and last .
In these the edges of the pileus of one Fungus adheres only to the upper surface of the pileus of another , and receives thence all its nourishment .
Now , though it may be difficult to account for this strange position , yet , I think , the consequence our author draws from it does not follow , viz. that Fungi differ from other plants , as to propagation , and in some other respects .
As to propagation , the same answer will serve , that was made use of above ; and what farther particulars , in this instance , deserve notice , will be considered , when I come to my observations on the corollaries he draws from all the Fungi represented in his book .
The corollaries are as follow : Corol .
1st , That the mode of rise , evolution , increment , and propagation , of Fungi , must be of a peculiar kind , and totally different from that which prevails in other kinds of plants .
Corol .
2d , That what from the analogy of the other plants is called the seed , of the Fungi cannot properly be called seed .
Corol .
3d , That there must be such a similarity in all the parts of the Fungi , that it is indifferent whether any part be placed above or below , whether it communicates or receives nourishment .
Lastly , That every Fungus , according to his hypothesis , is contained in an entire and perfect state from the beginning , in every egg , or , as it is called , its seed , and wants nothing but evolution , to imbibe the necessary juices .
These are the corollaries our author draws ; and , for a farther confirmation of his doctrine , refers to a treatise expressly written on this subject , in which , he says , he has made use of such strong arguments , that it would be quite needless to add any thing more in this place .
Had I an opportunity of perusing this treatise , it is possible I might find reason to agree with him ; but his arguments must be quite of another nature , than what appears here , to make me think these plants exempt from the common laws of vegetables .
For , as to the supposed difference in regard to rise , evolution , increment , and propagation , which is his first corollary , it has been considered already in part , and will be more fully considered , when I come to his third corollary .
As to the second , viz. That what , from analogy , is called the seed , of the Fungi cannot properly be called seed .
I must own , I cannot see the least foundation for any distinction between the seeds and eggs of plants , the latter of which terms , he thinks , ought to be used , when we speak of the Fungi : for those terms are perfectly analogous , by the confession of all the nicest observers of nature ; and what is called the egg in animals , goes under the name of seed in vegetables .
Thus Linnaeus says , Philosophia Botanica , p. 88 .
every living thing comes from an egg ; consequently , all vegetables , whose seeds appear to be eggs from their final cause , which is to produce an offspring .
He then cites a passage from our Harvey , to the same purpose .
Our author seems to have been led into this confusion of ideas , by the improper use of the word semen , or seed , which is applied to the impregnating juice in animals , and to the parts which contain the embryo in vegetables , which are by no means analogous : for the impregnating dust in vegetables , answers to the impregnating juice in animals , as it has a similar use ; and the eggs in animals answer to what we call seeds in plants .
When our author asserts , in the third corollary , that there must be such a similarity in all the parts of the Fungi , that it is indifferent whether any part be placed above or below , whether it communicates or receives nourishment , I suppose he draws this corollary from the fifth and sixth Fungus ; for in those , the upper Fungus adheres only to the edge of the cap , or pileus , of the upper surface of the cap of the lower Fungus .
The answer to this case , which was before omitted , shall now be made ; nor is it at all difficult , for it appears , by Dr. Hales 's vegetable Statics , experiment the 41 , fig. 24 .
that a tree inarched between two other trees , though its root be cut off , or dug out of the ground , will continue to grow ; and that many trees will grow in an inverted state .
In what respect , then , do Fungi differ from all other plants , as to the similarity in all the parts , &amp;c. ?
Lastly , when our author asserts , That every Fungus is contained in an entire and perfect state from the beginning , in the egg , or , as it is called , the seed , and wants nothing but evolution , in order to imbibe the necessary juices ; when our author asserts this , he asserts nothing but what will be readily granted by every one , who has read the observations made by modern philosophers , on this part of nature , and the only difference between him and others is , that he confines himself to one order of plants , what they imagine , from good reason , to be the case of all ; and this seems likewise to be the case throughout the animal creation , with this difference only , that , in some animals , some parts fall off entirely , after a certain time , and a new form ensues ; yet even here , all the forms preceding the last may , and perhaps ought , as has been observed by Linnaeus , to be looked upon as embryo states .
Upon the whole , I think our author seems inclined to invent a new hypothesis , from a few insufficient data , rather than to be forced into it by any leading phenomenon , which ought to be very strong and convincing , to make us give up an analogy , that is confined within such moderate bounds .
However , this ought not to prejudice us in relation to the latter part of this work ; on the contrary , it ought to give us a favourable opinion of him , as it shows his zeal and application to this part of natural history .
A man may be an excellent and useful observer , and yet be a very indifferent natural philosopher .
I come now to the second part , which contains the proposals , and with the greater pleasure , as , at the same time that it affords no opportunity for criticism , it gives us hopes of seeing a very useful work , on one of the most obscure parts of botany .
The author observes , that the Electoral Academy at Munich , from its first institution , determined to turn their thoughts particularly to this part of natural history , which , hitherto , has been but indifferently cultivated ; and , in consequence of this determination , the present method proposed to them was approved of .
He adds , that the year before last , viz. 1760 , though the drought was very great , they not only had an accession of above an hundred Fungi , but that plates of them were entirely finished , both as to engraving and colouring , and fit to be published .
The circumstances and method of proceeding in this work , are as follow , and will , as the author assures the public , be strictly and religiously observed .
~ 1 .
They will begin by publishing the different species of Fungi , engraved and coloured according to the specimen in these proposals ; with which the public will have reason to be satisfied .
While these are publishing , they will be looking out after other Fungi , that may grow in Bavaria .
~ 2 .
These plates , when completed , will make a separate volume , entitled , Jacobi Christiani Schaeffer Fungorum Bavariae , potissimum qui circa Ratisbonam nascuntur , icones , auspiciis et impensis Academiae Electoralis Bavariae Monacensis accurate delineatae , et publici juris factae .
This volume may be useful , without the other volumes , of which hereafter .
~ 3 .
There will be no plates of the Fungi , but such as have been examined from the first growth , and , if possible , from the egg , or seed , as it is called .
~ 4 .
There will be at least the following primary figures of every kind of Fungi ; viz. The Fungus before it is unfolded .
2 .
When it is half perfect , or half grown .
3 .
Its characteristic appearance .
4 .
its dissection .
Lastly , whenever it may be necessary , In its decaying state .
~ 5 .
Besides these primary figures , there will be added as many secondary ones , as there are changes , which may render a Fungus dubious ; and the author foresees , that sometimes one species may require two , three , or four plates .
~ 6 .
The plates will be all engraved by able artists , and well coloured .
~ 7 .
All the parts serving for propagation will be represented , both according to their natural appearances , and also magnified .
~ 8 .
Whenever it may be necessary , figures representing particular parts dissected will be made use of , both of the natural bigness , and as seen through the glass .
~ 9 .
In all the names and division of the genera , Linnaeus alone will be followed .
~ 10 .
To give a greater variety to the work , in its progress , sometimes the species of one genus will be published , sometimes of another ; but yet in such a manner , that order will not be totally neglected .
~ 11 .
No order will be observed , either in the species or in the individuals .
No specific names , or synonyms , will be given ; instead of which , they will be numbered according to each genus , and a short explanation be put at the bottom of each plate , as in those annexed to this treatise .
~ 12 .
To the end that beginners in botany , the illiterate , and even the country people , may be able to know the genera of the Fungi , as far as is necessary for them , the author hopes , that , before next Easter , or certainly not long after , copper-plates , engraved and coloured , will be published , representing all the genera , in such a manner , that they may be easily known .
These plates , along with descriptions , will make another separate volume , which will be entitled , Isagoge in Fungorum Bavariae historiam , &amp;c. ~ 13 .
When all the Fungi of Bavaria are finished , it is proposed to go on with such foreign ones as can be procured .
~ 14 .
As soon as the collection of the Fungi of Bavaria shall be completed , a new and last volume will follow , containing accurate descriptions , explications , synonyms , of authors , and whatever else may be thought necessary .
This volume will be entitled , Fungorum Bavariae historia .
~ 15 .
No payment is expected beforehand ; but yet such as are willing to encourage this work , are desired to send their names to Ildephonsus Kennedy , secretary to the academy at Munich , or to the author , at Ratisbon , in letters post-paid , that the expenses of this work , sufficiently great of themselves , may not be increased .
~ 16 .
This kind of subscription is judged necessary ; because copies in Latin and German will be printed separately , and no more of either sort , than the number of purchasers .
~ 17 .
A certain number of plates will be published every month , not fewer than six , nor more than twelve .
~ 18 .
For each parcel of plates , a certain price will be fixed , according to the number , each plate at the rate of ten creutzers ; so that six plates will sell for a florin of the Rhine , according to the value it shall go at , when the plates are published ; which price , though by no mean great , yet , it is to be hoped , that , after the sale of some parcels , the rest may be sold still cheaper .
N. B. The florin , here mentioned , is worth about two shillings English ; and therefore , each plate will sell for about four pence .
There is no room for suspicion , that this work will not be completed , as too often happens in this way of publishing by parts : for , as far as human foresight can go , every thing is so prepared and ordered , that there can be no reasonable doubt that the work will be continued , and finished .
Lastly , As the intention of this work , says the author , is to facilitate the knowledge of the genera and species of Fungi , as much as possible ; that we may be better instructed by persons skilful in this affair ; by what name they judge it is called by authors not now living ; by what name it is vulgarly known in their own country ; and what use is made of it amongst their countrymen , and in what manner .
For these ends , says our author , the Electoral Academy enjoined me to apply to academies , literary societies , and men of learning , either skilful in natural history , or promoters of it , in other countries , desiring , that they will be pleased to communicate any obser4 vations vations relating to these questions to the said academy ; which , as it will be highly acceptable to it , will be gratefully acknowledged , whenever occasion offers .
Thus far the author , in relation to his proposals , which , as far as can be judged by the plan and specimen , seem to deserve the encouragement of the curious .
Every one , who is conversant in botany , knows how obscure and imperfect this part of it still remains , after all that has been done upon the subject .
Micheli and Dillenius were the first botanists that examined this order of plants , with any degree of accuracy ; and though their observations are very considerable , and have been of great service to preceding botanists , yet Linnaeus , who mentions them with applause , says , Philosophia Botanica , p. 241 .
that the order of Fungi , to the reproach of botany , still remains a chaos , as we are ignorant what is a species , and what a variety .
Since the aforementioned authors , Gleditschius , who wrote a tract on the same subject , which is commended , expresses himself also to the same purpose : for , speaking of Dillenius , in the preface , p. 5 .
he says , that his genera are not only not well determined , but are even constructed in such a manner , as to contradict the natural characters ; and as to Micheli , that though he first determined the seeds of the Fungi , yet his genera are too artificial ; and therefore , he himself follows the method of Linnaeus .
Gleditschius seems to have taken great pains about this subject ; but candidly owns , that , after all he had been able to do , in order to distinguish species from varieties , by collecting all the Fungi he could find , disposing and describing them according to the Ttt2 degree degree of similitude , yet he found himself osten at a loss , and unable absolutely to determine which side to take .
The book of Gleditschius was published in the year 1753 , and is , I believe , the latest writer who has done much on this subject , except , perhaps , Scopoli , in his Flora Carneolica , published anno 1760 , who differs from all the preceding botanists , in relation to species and varieties ; and though his work has great merit , both in relation to this and other orders of plants , especially the Cryptogamiae , yet there still remains much to be done , as , I believe , every skilful reader will easily allow .
From all that has been observed , I would draw a few conclusions in favour of the proposals in question .
First , then , The uncertainty of authors on this branch of botany , shows , that it requires a still farther examination , than has hitherto been made .
2dly , That though , in general , since the writings of Linnaeus , figures have been , in a great measure , laid aside , yet in this , and some other obscure parts of botany , they may be employed to good purpose .
3dly , That the curious in botany ought to look on themselves as particularly obliged to those , who are inclined to labour and make researches in the obscure , and , according to the vulgar opinion , contemptible parts of nature , especially this order of plants , some of which are used for the table , and not a few of them are of a poisonous nature , so that a mistake may , and has , perhaps , sometimes proved of fatal consequence .

