LXXII .
An Attempt to assign the Cause , why the Sun and Moon appear to the naked Eye larger when they are near the Horizon .
With an Account of several natural Phenomenon , relative to this Subject .
By Mr. Samuel Dunn .
Chelsea , January 27 , 1762 .
1 .
THE Sun and Moon , when they are in or near the horizon , appear to the naked eye of the generality of persons , so very large in comparison with their apparent magnitudes , when they are in the zenith , or somewhat elevated , that several learned men have been led to enquire into the cause of this phenomenon , and , after endeavouring to find certain reasons , founded on the principles of physics , they have at last pronounced this phenomenon as a mere optical illusion .
Read Feb. 11 , 1762 .
2 .
The principal dissertations , which I have hitherto seen , conducing to give any information on this subject , or helping to throw any light on the same , have been those printed in the Transactions of the Royal Society , the Academy of Sciences at Paris , the German Acts , and Dr. Smith 's Optics ; but as all the accounts , which I have met with in these writings , any way relative to this subject , have not given me that satisfaction which I have desired , curiosity has induced me to enquire after the cause of this singular phenomenon , in a manner somewhat different from that which others have done before me , and by such experiments and observations as have appeared to me pertinent ; some of which have been as follows ; viz. 3 .
I have observed the rising and setting Sun , near the visible horizon , and near rising grounds elevated above the visible horizon about half a degree , and found him to appear largest when nearest to the visible horizon ; and particularly a considerable alteration of his appearance in magnitude and light has always appeared to me , from the time of his being in the horizon at rising , to the time of his being a degree or two above the horizon , and the contrary at his setting ; which property I have endeavoured to receive as a prejudice , and an imposition on my sight and judgment , the usual reasons for this appearance .
4 .
I have also observed , that the Sun near the horizon appears to put on the figure of a spheroid , having its vertical diameter appearing to the naked eye shorter than the horizontal diameter , and , by measuring those diameters in a telescope , have found the vertical one shorter than the other .
5 .
I have made frequent observations and comparisons of the apparent magnitude of the Sun 's disk , with objects directly under him , when he has been near the horizon , and with such objects as I have found , by measurement , to be of equal breadth with the Sun 's diameter ; but , in the sudden transition of the eye from the Sun to the object , and from the object to the Sun , have always found the Sun to appear least ; and that when two right lines have been imaginarily produced , by the sides of those equal magnitudes , they have not appeared to keep parallel , but to meet beyond the Sun .
6 .
From these , and other like circumstances , I first began to suspect , that a sudden dip of the Sun into the horizontal vapours , might , some how or other , be the cause of a sudden apparent change of magnitude , although the horizontal vapours had been disallowed to be able to produce any other than a refraction in a vertical direction ; and reducing things to calculation , found , that , from the time when the Sun is within a diameter or two of the horizon , to the time when he is a semi-diameter below the horizon , the Sun 's rays become passable through such a length of medium , reckoning in the direction of the rays , that the total quantity of medium , ( reckoning both depth and density ) through which the rays pass , being compared with the like total depth and density through which they pass , at several elevations , it was proportionable to the difference of apparent magnitude , as appearing to the naked eye .
7 .
This circumstance of sudden increase and decrease of apparent magnitude , and as sudden decrease and increase of light , ( for they both go together ) seemed to me no improbable cause of the phenomenon , although I could not then perceive how such vapours might contribute toward enlarging the diameter of the Sun apparently in a horizontal direction .
8 .
I therefore examined the Sun 's disk again and again , by the naked eye , and by telescopes , at different altitudes , and , among several circumstances , found the solar maculae appear larger and plainer to the naked eye , and through a telescope , the Sun being near the horizon , than they had appeared the same days , when the Sun was on the meridian , and to appearance more strongly defined , yet obscured .
9 .
A little before sun-setting , I have often seen the edge of the Sun with such protuberances and indentures , as have rendered him , in appearance , a very odd figure ; the protuberances shooting out far beyond , and the indentures pressing into , the disk of the Sun , and always through a telescope magnifying fifty-five times , the lower limb has appeared with a red glowing arch beneath it , and close to the edge of the Sun , whilst the other parts have been clear .
10 .
At sun-setting , such protuberances and indentures have appeared to slide or move along the vertical limbs , from the lower limb to the higher , and there vanishing , so as often to form a segment of the Sun 's upper limb apparently separated from the disk , for a small space of time .
11 .
At sun-rising , I have often seen the like protuberances , indentures , and slices , above described ; but with this difference of motion , that at sun-rising they first appear to rise in the Sun 's upper limb , and slide or move downward to the lower limb ; or , which is the same thing , they always appear at the rising and setting of the Sun , to keep in the same parallels of altitude , by the telescope .
This property has been many times so easily discernible , even by the naked eye , that I have observed the Sun 's upper limb to shoot out towards right and left , and move downward , forming the upper part of the disk an apparent portion of a lesser spheroid than the lower part at rising , and the contrary at setting .
Through the telescope , this has appeared more plain , in proportion to the power of magnifying .
12 .
These protuberances and indentures , so easily measurable by the micrometer , whilst the telescopic wires appeared strait , enabled me to conclude , that certain strata of the atmosphere , having different refractive powers , and lying horizontally across the conical or cycloidal space traced out by the rays , between the eye and that part of the atmosphere first touched by the rays , must have been the cause of such apparent protuberances and indentures , in an horizontal direction , across the Sun 's vertical limbs ; and also , that the bottoms of those protuberances and indentures must be considerably enlarged , and removed , to appearance , farther from the center of the disk , than they would have been , had there been no such strata to refract .
13 .
Before sun-rising , when the Sun has been near the tropic , and the sky , at the utmost extent of the horizon , hath appeared very clear , and when certain fogs have appeared in strata placed alternately between the hills , and over intervening rivers , vallies , &amp;c. so as to admit a sight of the rising Sun over those fogs , I have often observed , with admiration , the most distant trees and bushments , which at other times have appeared small to the naked eye , but whilst the Sun has been passing along a little beneath the horizon , obliquely under them , just before sun-rising , when the Sun has been thus approaching towards and beneath any trees and bushments , they have grown apparently very large to the naked eye , and also through the telescope ; and they have lost that apparent largeness , as the Sun has been past by them .
Thus , a few trees standing together on rising ground , at the distance of a few miles , have appeared to grow up into an apparent mountain .
Such apparent mountains formed from trees , put on all forms and shapes , as sloping , perpendicular , overleaning ; but soon recover their natural appearance , when the Sun is past by them , or got above the horizon .
14 .
Mountains themselves , at a distance , sometimes appear larger than at other times .
Beasts and cattle in the midst of , and being surrounded with , water , appear nearer to us , than when no water surrounds them .
Cattle , houses , trees , all objects on the summit of a hill , when seen through a fog , and at a proper distance , appear enlarged .
All bodies admit of larger apparent magnitudes , when seen through some mediums , than others .
But more particularly , 15 .
I took a cylindrical glass vessel , about two feet high , and having graduated its sides to inches , I placed it upright on a table , with a piece of paper under the bottom of the glass , on which paper were drawn parallel right lines , at a proper distance from each other ; and having placed a shilling at the bottom of the vessel , it was nearly as low as the paper .
Pouring water into the vessel , and viewing the shilling through the medium of water , with one eye , whilst I beheld with the other eye , where the edges of the shilling were projected on the paper , and its parallels , I found the shilling appear larger , at every additional inch depth of the water ; and this was the case , if either eye was used ; and the same , when the eye was removed far from the surface , or near to it , or in any position thereto .
16 .
I took large vessels , filled them with water , placed different bodies at the bottoms of those vessels .
It always followed , that the greater depth of the water I looked through , in the direction from my eye , to the objects in the water , the nearer those objects appeared to me .
Thus light bodies appeared more mellow and faint , and dark bodies rather better defined , than out of the water , when they were not deeply immersed .
And thus they appeared under whatever directions or positions I viewed the bodies .
17 .
I placed different bodies in proper vessels of fair water , and immersed my face in the water ; viewing the bodies in and through the water , they all appeared to me plain , when not too far from the eye , and although a little hazy at the edges , they appeared much enlarged , and always larger through a greater depth of water .
Thus , a shilling appeared nearly as large as half a crown , with a red glowing arch on that side opposite to the Sun , when the Sun shined on the water .
From this experiment , I concluded , that divers see light objects not only larger , but very distinctly in the water .
18 .
These , and several other circumstances , being considered , they left me with but little doubt , whether the atmosphere refracts horizontally or not , as the aforementioned protuberances in the Sun 's limb must have been wholly owing to such a cause , and the nearly allied strata in the atmosphere .
That the apparently formed mountains of trees and bushments at sunrising , so easily comparable with other trees and bushments of equal magnitude at other times , but in their affected state as much larger , must also be owing to the same cause .
That seeing the nature and properties of those strata of horizontal vapours cannot differ from each other , as much as the whole quantity of medium , through which a ray of light passes in coming from the horizontal Sun , differs from the whole quantity of medium , through which another ray of light passes in coming from the vertical Sun ; and the latter experiment being so consonant to the manner in which the rays of light pass , through the medium of the atmosphere , into the eye ; I therefore concluded , that these were proofs , that objects seen through a medium of greater depth , or density , do appear more large ; and that therefore , not only the Sun and Moon , but that all other objects , seen at great distances , under an horizontal direction , do appear larger to the naked eye , than objects of equal magnitude and distance do appear , when seen under a vertical direction .
19 .
Although the quantity of medium , with its density , be here mentioned , as though it was the efficient cause of this effect , possibly it may be some other cause in the horizontal vapours , water , and other mediums , which produces effects nearly proportionate to the difference arising from a comparison of the quantity of medium , or density .
Whether this effect arises from density or rarity , reflection , refraction , or inflection , acceleration , retardation , or absorbency of the rays , seems to me to deserve a proper enquiry .
What others may find to be the cause of these phenomenon , I cannot determine ; to me it has seemed most natural , that the rays , under the aforegoing circumstances , first become obstructed , and many of them wholly absorbed , the rest proceeding with a retarded motion , are thereby first more reflected , and then less refracted through the humours of the eye ; and lastly , the image on the retina becomes hereby enlarged .
enlarged .
In other words , certain accidents making the rays more divergent than they otherwise would be , at their entrance into the eye , seem to me to be the cause of these and other like appearances .
20 .
On any evening , when the sky is very clear and serene , and the Moon high , if the sky near the horizon , all around , be observed , it will appear , to the naked eye , more white and light than any other part , except that part of the sky which is near to the Moon .
The like is observable , when the Moon doth not shine .
This seems to prove , that when the Moon 's light has fallen promiscuously on the vapours of the atmosphere , it is more copiously reflected from the vapours near the horizon , than from those in a direction toward the zenith .
And thus , it seems , they must , in proportion to the depth and density of the one , compared with the depth and density of the other .
The same seems to be confirmed , by the burning of a candle , or other light , in a fog ; for , then , it appears to give a stronger blaze of vaporous light , within that certain sphere it illuminates , than it doth in true permanent air , and yet the rays extend farther in the latter case , than in the former .
21 .
When a number of candles , lamps , torches , or other lights , are placed at equal distances from each other , in a row a mile or two in length , and a spectator stands at one end of the row , viewing those lights , the nucleus of the nearest light will appear whitest and brightest , and best defined ; but looking onward to the rest , they will appear more and more red , dull , and faint , the farthest will not appear largest , nor the nearest , but some intermediate one , at a certain distance from the nearest .
Hence there is a maximum of the apparent magnitude of the nucleus , as seen by the naked eye .
22 .
Among the fixed stars , may be observed a diversity of colour and splendour , somewhat like that diversity , which is observable among those terrestrial lights .
Some fixed stars are more sharply defined than others , such are generally white , and their vibratory scintillations more quick and smart .
Others , which twinkle more slowly , are generally more red and large .
In the zenith , they appear almost all of them entirely free from twinkling ; and in the horizon , they are so invelloped in vapours , as to be undiscernible ; at their first appearance after rising , or last appearance before setting , they twinkle more slow .
It seems , therefore , not only probable , that the atmosphere is the cause of their apparent scintillations ; but that , could the distance of one fixed star be obtained , the distances of some others might be essayed at , by analogy of their colours , and vibratory scintillations .
Possibly also , we may acquire some knowledge of the nebulous stars , from like considerations .
23 .
For the reasons which have been communicated , it has appeared to me , that the Sun and Moon , and distances of stars near the horizon , do appear enlarged to the naked eye ; because they then appear nearer to us .
That they then appear nearer to us , and more faint ; because then their rays pass through a greater length of the atmosphere and horizontal vapours .
That in so passing through a greater length of the atmosphere and horizontal vapours , those rays are so reflected , refracted , inflected , attracted , resisted , accelerated , or retarded , so as to become more divergent than they otherwise would , at their entrance into the eye .
That as a consequence hereof , that part of the sky which is near the horizon , appears nearer to us than that part near the zenith .
That the apparent nearness of the sky near the horizon , is always in a certain , though variable proportion , to the state and properties of the horizontal vapours .
That as objects appear larger and nearer , when they are near the horizon , than when they are near the zenith , so they appear larger through the medium of the atmosphere , than they would through a space devoid of air .
That the alteration of the foci of optic glasses , in order to adapt them for remote or near distances , is chiefly dependant on the same cause , as that which produces the foregoing effects .
That this cause may be investigated by proper experiments and considerations .
That herefrom , possibly , the resistance of the aether beyond the regions of our atmosphere , and the proportional distances of the fixed stars , may be essayed at , with other matters of curiosity , import , and utility .
24 .
The phenomenon of nebulous and new stars , have engaged the attention of curious astronomers ; but none , that I know of , have given any reasons for the appearance of nebulous stars .
Possibly , what has been before advanced , may also be applicable , for investigating reasons for those strange appearances in the remote parts of the universe .
From many instances , which might be produced , concerning the nature and properties of lights and illuminations on the Earth 's surface , concerning the nature and properties of the Earth 's atmosphere , and concerning the atmospheres and illuminations of comets , we may safely conclude , that the atmospheres of comets , and of our Earth , are more gross in their nature , than the ethereal medium , which is generally diffused throughout our solar system .
Possibly a more aqueous vapour in the one than in the other , makes the difference .
Now , as the atmospheres of comets and planets , in our solar system , are more gross than the aether , which is generally diffused throughout our solar system , why may not the ethereal medium diffused throughout those other solar systems , ( whose centers are their respective fixed stars ) be more gross than the ethereal medium diffused throughout our solar system ?
This is , indeed , an hypothesis , but such an one as agrees exactly with nature .
For those nebulous stars appear so much like comets , both to the naked eye and through telescopes , that the one cannot always , by any difference of their extraneous light , be known from the other .
Such orbs of gross aether , reflecting light more copiously , or like the atmospheres of comets , may help us to judge of the magnitudes of the orbs illuminated by those remote suns , when all other means seem to fail .
The appearance of new stars , and disappearance of others , possibly , may be occasioned by the interposition of such an ethereal medium , within their respective orbs , as either admits light to pass freely , or wholly absorbs it at certain times , whilst light is constantly pursuing its journey , through the vast regions of space .
Ppp2 LXXIII .
Ex-

