LVII .
Remarks on a Passage of the Editor of the Connoissance des Mouvements Celestes pour l'Annee 1762 : In a Letter to the Right Hon. George Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society .
By Matthew Raper , Esq ; F. R. S. My Lord , SIR Isaac Newton , in the second and third editions of his Principia , ( lib. iii .
prop. 19 .
) has mentioned Norwood 's measure of a degree on the meridian , as taken about the year 1635 .
The editor of the Connoissance des Mouvements Celestes pour l'Annee 1762 , p. 196 , has the following passage : On pretend aussi en Angleterre , que des l'annee 1636 , Norwood avoit trouve le degre par des mesures prises entre Londres et Yorck de 57300 , ou de 57400 toises ; resultat , qui se trouveroit d'une exactitude bien singuliere pour ce tems la : mais un fait plus authentique c'est que Newton en 1666 jettant les premiers fondemens de son admirable systeme de la gravitation , n'avoit jamais oui parler des mesures de Norwood , et supposoit , avec tous les pilotes de son tems , le degre de 60 milles Anglois , qui font 49200 toises .
' ' Read Dec. 17 , 1761 .
Here this writer asserts , that Sir Isaac Newton had never heard of Norwood 's measure in 1666 , ( of which he can bring no proof ) and would thence insinuate , that , probably , there never was such a one , or at least not so early as is pretended .
In either case , Sir Isaac , in the proposition above-mentioned , must have positively asserted what he did not know to be true , or knowingly have published a falsehood .
Norwood 's book is entitled , The Seaman 's Practice , containing a fundamental Problem in Navigation , experimentally verified , namely , touching the Compass of the Earth and Sea , and the Quantity of a Degree , in our English Measures , &amp;c. By Richard Norwood , Redder in the Mathematics .
He tells us , that having observed the latitude of London in the year 1633 , and that of York in 1635 , he measured the distance of the two cities , in his return from York to London ; and the account he gives of his measurement is so clear and ingenuous , that the reader will find no cause to doubt either his abilities or his fidelity .
The book was first published in the year 1636 , and hath since gone through many editions , the eighth being printed in 1668 .
The title above-mentioned is likewise found verbatim in London 's catalogue of the most vendible books in England , published in the year 1658 , twelve years before Picard measured a degree in France ; so that the authenticity of the fact , that Norwood 's measure preceded Picard 's , cannot be doubted .
The editor of the Connoissance , p. 195 , 196 , has given a list of different measures of a degree , according to different authors , who had either actually attempted to measure one themselves , or had adopted the measure in this list for a true one .
Among these , he has most disingenuously put Sir Isaac Newton 's name to a measure of sixty English statute-miles ; which must imply , that Sir Isaac believed this to be nearest the truth , till he knew of Picard 's measure in 1670 .
Whereas it does not appear , nor is it at all probable , that he ever preferred that rude conjectural measure to the measures of Snellius , and others well known to the learned world before the year 1666 ; but being at that time retired from Cambridge , on account of the plague , and absent from his books , having occasion to use the diameter of the earth in a calculation , he took the common account in use among seamen , as Dr. Pemberton has related , in the preface to his View of Sir Isaac Newton 's Philosophy .
And this anecdote seems to be all the authority the French writer had , for ascribing that measure to Sir Isaac Newton , and for asserting , that he had never heard of Norwood 's measure in the year 1666 .
If his view was to do honour to his own country , by depriving others of their due praise , the wiser part of his countrymen will not think themselves much obliged to him , well knowing , that the reputation of a great kingdom , which has so long distinguished itself in Europe by men eminent in arts and arms , does not stand in need of the varnish of such ungenerous practices .
I am , My Lord , With great respect , Your Lordship 's most obedient servant , Matt .
Raper .
Nov. 19 , 1761 .

