LIII .
An Account of a Treatise in French , presented to the Royal Society , entitled , Lettres sir l'Electricite , by the Abbe Nollet , Member of the Royal Academy of Sciences , &amp;c. &amp;c. ' ' By William Watson , M. D. R. S. S. Gentlemen , ABOUT eight years since , the learned and ingenious author of the work before us published a treatise , of which the present work may be considered as a continuation .
That consisted of nine letters upon the subject of electricity , which were addressed to persons , who had distinguished themselves by their endeavours to illustrate this part of natural philosophy .
In like manner , the present performance consists of eight letters , and is addressed , as the former , to his friends and correspondents .
Read Dec. 17 , 1761 .
As an account of the former treatise was communicated by myself to the Royal Society , and printed , by direction of the council , in the Philosophical Transactions * , the author requests , at the end of the sixteenth letter , which is addressed to me , that I would give myself the additional trouble to lay before you an account of the present work .
This request I most readily comply with , not only in obedience to the order of the Society , but likewise as a testimony of * Vide Vol. XLVIII .
p. 201 .
the esteem and regard , which I have long entertained , and shall continue to do , for the excellent author of it .
The principal design of the work before us , is to support , and further confirm , the hypothesis of the author , and of several other persons , who have considered these matters , that the effects of electricity depend upon the simultaneous affluence and effluence of the electric matter .
This treatise , like the former , is printed in 12mo .
and contains 284 pages , exclusive of the preface , and four tables , exhibiting fourteen figures .
In defending his opinions , in relation to the effects of electricity , the Abbe Nollet has given a variety of new experiments , which cannot but be agreeable to those , who are conversant in these matters .
He has also occasionally mentioned those of other persons , which are come to his knowledge , and which he apprehends not to be sufficiently known .
He has traced the origin of several happy inventions , and has exhibited to us the real authors of them .
He has given , as he imagines , additional value to several experiments , which appear to him to have been too much neglected ; and brought others , which have been over-rated , to their proper standard .
As this work is of a controversial kind , the author has had particular attention to such points , as have been the occasion of contest ; to weigh the reasons of his opponents , and to add new explanations to such of his opinions , as seemed to want them ; more particularly , to such as have appeared to him to have been misunderstood .
The first of these letters is addressed to M. Necker , professor of experimental philosophy at Geneva .
In this letter , our author endeavours to establish his opinion , published long since , in regard to the existence of the simultaneous affluence and effluence , and consequently the double current , of the electric matter , in opposite directions .
And herein our author , by a series of experiments , obviates some doubts , which had occurred to Mr. Necker , in relation to the validity of this hypothesis .
The second letter is addressed , as the former was , to M. Necker of Geneva .
In this letter , the hypothesis of M. Jallabert of Geneva , a very worthy member of this Society , in relation to the electrical phenomenon , is examined ; and such part of it , as does not coincide with the ideas of our author , he endeavours to confute by an ingenious series of deductions .
The third , fourth , and fifth Letters are addressed to M. Du Tour , of Riom in Auvergne , who has been a diligent enquirer into the nature and properties of electricity .
In the first of these , is a careful examination of the validity of the doctrine of plus and minus in bodies electrified .
So early as in February 1745 , I communicated to the Royal Society an experiment , and some deductions therefrom , which laid the foundation of this doctrine .
This experiment , and the deductions in consequence of it , were afterwards printed in the Philosophical Transactions * .
These I explained more at large , both by experiments and observations , in another paper , read to the Society in February 1745-6 ~ , and were the experiments , which so early caused me to conceive , that there was * Vide Vol. XLIV .
p. 739 .
~ See Phil. Trans. Vol. XLV .
p. 93-101 .
something something in the phenomenon of electricity , not to be resolved , but upon statical principles ; and enabled me first to assert , that the phenomenon in bodies electrised , however similar they might appear , did really arise from their electricity being either greater or less than their natural quantity .
This doctrine has , since that time , been the cause of a vast variety of experiments , both here and abroad , by which great light has been thrown upon this part of natural philosophy .
How far our author has been able to overturn this doctrine , must be left to other judges to determine .
In the fourth letter , the doctrine of resinous and vitreous electricity is examined .
In this letter , as well as in the fifth , a great number both of experiments and deductions are produced , not only to weaken the doctrine of plus and minus , but to establish the principle of simultaneous affluence and effluence of electric matter ; as , if this principle is allowed , the doctrine of resinous and vitreous electricity may be reduced to it : as our author is of opinion , that there is only one and the same kind of electricity , whether it is natural or artificial ; and that , however appearances may make it seem to vary , the electricity is one and the same .
The sixth letter is an answer to one of Father Beccaria , professor of experimental philosophy in the university of Turin , published in Italian , in the year 1753 , and addressed to the Abbe Nollet .
This letter of Pere Beccaria was translated into French , and published at Paris in 1754 , by M. Delor , with many additions and annotations .
It contains a very great number of curious experiments and observations , both upon artificial and natural electricity ; many of which are brought to prove the validity of the doctrine of our worthy member Dr. Franklin , in opposition to that of the Abbe Nollet .
More particularly , he endeavours to confute the abbe 's opinion , in relation to the affluence of the electric matter , which the abbe has , by experiments and observations , ingeniously endeavoured to confirm .
Pere Beccaria 's observations upon natural electricity , and upon meteors , on which he has made a prodigious number of experiments , many of them of a delicate nature , do him a great deal of honour .
The seventh letter , the ingenious author does me the honour to address to me .
In this letter , he , with justice , laments the calamities of war ; more particularly , as it , in a great degree , prevents that correspondence between men of letters , which contributes so much to their mutual satisfaction , and upon which the improvement of science so much depends .
The more particular purport of this letter , is to answer some objections , which Mr. David Colden , of North America , published against the former letters of our author .
These relate more particularly to the impermeability of glass to the electric fluid , and to the explanation of the phenomenon of the experiment of Leyden .
Besides these , he gives us his idea of nonelectrised bodies electrised plus , as he does not approve of the idea generally received of the accumulation of electricity .
He mentions , that he has read Mr. Canton 's memoir relating to electricity , with his observations upon stormy clouds .
He finds many curious facts in that work ; but thinks them not sufficient to make the deductions Mr. Canton has done , in favour of the doctrine of plus and minus .
M. Du Tour of Riom , has sent the Abbe Nollet a memoir , which he has likewise been so kind as to send me , containing a review of these experiments , from which he thinks it very easy to resolve all these phenomenon , upon the doctrine of simultaneous affluence and effluence of the electric matter .
The eighth letter is addressed to M. De Romas , assessor to the presidial of Nerac , and contains remarks upon electrical kites ; upon Father Ammersin 's manner of preparing and using wood to insulate bodies , in making electrical experiments ; and likewise some observations concerning the doctrine of simultaneous affluence and effluence of the electric matter .
M. De Romas , in flying his electrical kite , was the first who used a cord composed of hemp and wire .
This compounded cord conducted the electricity of the clouds far more perfectly than a hempen cord would do , even though it was wetted ; and this cord being terminated by one of dry silk , enabled the observer , by a proper management of the apparatus , to make what experiments he thought proper , without danger to himself .
The Abbe Nollet , however , desires M. De Romas to be very cautious in making these experiments , and not too much to confide in his silk lines ; as the vastness of the electrical matter in thunder-storms may overcome the property of the silk , and even make it a conductor of electricity , and hazard the life of the observer .
The quantity of electricity brought by M. De Romas 's kite from the clouds has been so great , that , on the 26th of August 1756 , ` ` the streams of fire were an inch thick , and ten feet long , which were conducted by the cord of the kite to the non-electric bodies near it , and the report of which was equal to that of a pistol .
' ' If a stroke of this kind had gone through the body of M. De Romas , probably the late unfortunate Professor Richmann had no longer been the only martyr to electricity .
Father Ammersin 's method of preparing wood , so as to make it serve the purpose of glass , wax , &amp;c. in electrical experiments , was published at Lucerne in the year 1754 , and our author has given us an extract of it at the end of his work .
This father found , that the frying of wood , after its being well dried in an oven , or otherwise , in either the oil of walnuts or that of linseed , made it fit to insulate those bodies , which you chose to electrise , by preventing the difsipation of the electricity : not only so , but what makes it still more valuable to those , who are engaged in these pursuits , you may excite electricity with it , as the Abbe Nollet says he has done , to his great convenience .
He says further , that the end of a board mounted upon four pegs , a pair of wooden shoes , some truncheons of beech , walnut , or lime , &amp;c. fried in oil , cost him but little , and answered his purpose better than cakes of wax , pitch , rosin , and all the supports of glass or silk , which he had employed before : and , in case of necessity , a cylinder of this prepared wood , or a globe turned out of it , will excite an electricity so strong , that you need not be at the trouble of exciting it with other bodies .
Father Ammersin himself employs common wooden measures , such as are usually found in granaries , first boiled in oil , and afterwards mounted so as to be turned by his wheel .
The Abbe Nollet , being desirous of supporting the validity of some opinions of his , in relation to the nature and properties of electricity , desired of the Royal Academy , that a committee should be appointed , to examine the truth of some experiments , which the abbe considered as proofs of what he had established .
A committee was accordingly appointed , which consisted of Messieurs Deparcieux , Fougeroux , Bezout , Tillet , and Brisson , who all attested to the academy , that the results of these experiments , at the making of which they were present , were such as the abbe had foretold , in memoir , which had been read to the academy ; an attestation of which is given in this work , signed by M. De Fouchy , secretary to the academy , and is dated 10th April 1760 .
These experiments are sixty in number , some of which are subdivided to more subordinate ones , and are most of them exceedingly well chosen .
They tend to prove the simultaneous affluence and effluence of the electric matter , a doctrine long since espoused , and very well supported by our author ; but vehemently , and with much asperity , controverted by some gentlemen at Paris .
For a detail of these experiments , I must refer you to the work itself ; and as they without doubt are very fairly stated , every person conversant in these enquiries will carefully consider them , and , at the same time , reflect how far the hypothesis is deducible from the phenomenon .
I am , with the most profound respect , Gentlemen , Your most obedient humble servant , May 24 , 1761 .

