XXXV .
Some Observations of the Planet Venus , on the Disk of~ the Sun , June 6th , 1761 ; with a preceding Account of the Method taken for verifying the Time of that Phenomenon ; and certain Reasons for an Atmosphere about Venus : By Samuel Dunn .
AS soon as I heard , that several mathematicians were to go abroad , and observe the transit of Venus over the disk of the sun , from foreign parts , I purposed to observe the same at Chelsea , and to compare my observation with the more accurate ones , which I expected would be made at the Royal Observatory at Greenwich .
Supposing , that if my observation at Chelsea was made with equal care , and as good instruments for ascertaining time , as the instruments to be used by the observers abroad , it might be useful , as a kind of proof , how exact the observations had been made abroad , where the observers had less conveniences for ascertaining time , than at the Royal Observatory .
Read Nov. 5 , 1761 .
Mr. Dollond ( a member of the Society ) had , some time before , newly ground , and fitted up for me , a Newtonian reflecting telescope , six feet in length ; which so far exceeded expectation , that by it the Reverend Mr. Maskelyne ( who is now at St. Helena ) and myself , had several times observed how long Jupiter 's satellites dwell on the limb of Jupiter , entering on the body .
And I was provided with an eight-day clock , having a second-hand , an iron pendulum , and an adjusting screw at its bob .
Altitude instruments of wood and brass , adjusted by spirit levels , had engaged my attention ; but having found several of these defective , by comparing their results with meridian altitudes , and the time by the clock ; and having many times examined the clock by double altitudes of the sun , taken with a Hadley 's quadrant , having a nonius to minutes , and an artificial horizon of sweet oil in a tea-saucer , I determined to depend on such an instrument and horizon , for ascertaining the error of the clock , and correctness of my meridian .
An artificial horizon of water , and even of quicksilver , I had found to be too easily disturbed , and therefore had , some time before , introduced oil , and found it vastly preferable .
And in taking altitudes , I always observe , when the sun , or other celestial body , is as near the prime vertical , or east and west azimuth , as possible ; and generally take either five double altitudes , half a minute of time asunder each , or three double altitudes , a minute of time asunder , dividing the sum by either ten or six , as the case is , for a mean single altitude , corresponding to the mean time of those observations by the clock .
And in taking the sun 's transit across the meridian , I take a mean of the times of appulse to several parallel and equidistant lines on each side of the meridian , and it generally gives the transit to less than a second of time .
The daily tables of the sun 's declination , equation of time , &amp;c. which I use , are those in the ephemerides of the Abbe de la Caille ; and the latitude of my place is 51~ 29~ 5~ N. and 41~ of time west of the observatory at Greenwich , between the physicgarden and Chelsea hospital .
Several observations * for verifying the quadrant , meridian , clock , &amp;c. made at different times of the year , were as follow ; viz. 22d December 1760 .
Altitude sun 's upper limb on the meridian 15~ 6~ 30~ .
Error by calculation 2~ of a degree .
26th December 1760 .
Altitude sun 's upper limb on the meridian 15~ 12~ 15~ .
Error by calculation 8~ of a degree .
2d January 1761 .
Altitude sun 's upper limb on the meridian 15~ 20~ 42~ .
Error by calculation 3~ of a degree .
18th February 1761 .
Altitude sun 's upper limb on the meridian 27~ 22~ 45~ .
Error by calculation 4~ of a degree .
6th February 1761 .
Sun on the meridian , by the clock , at 12h 14~ 35~ .
Error by equation table 0~ of time .
11th February 1761 .
morning , at 10h 20 , per clock .
Altitude sun 's upper limb 20~ 23~ .
Error of clock 0~ of time .
11th February 1761 , noon , sun on meridian , per clock , at 12h 14~ 44~ .
Error by equation table 0~ of time .
11th February 1761 , afternoon , at 6h 37~ 30~ per clock .
Altitude sun 's upper limb 6~ 37~ 30~ .
Error of clock 0~ of time .
*A great number of others were made , although not inserted in this paper .
From 18th February to 11th March , the clock had gained of equal time 37~ , which is near 2~ of time per day .
11th March to 10th April , the clock had gained of equal time 15~ , which is near 3~ of time per day .
4th June , afternoon , at 4h 52~ per clock .
Altitude sun 's centre 27~ 40~ 14~ , which is near 3~ of time per day .
6th June , afternoon , at 5h 40~ per clock .
Altitude sun 's centre 24~ 29~ 5~ , which is near 3~ of time per day .
8th June , afternoon , at 5h 20~ per clock .
Altitude sun 's centre 23~ 45~ 53~ , which is near 3~ of time per day .
9th June , noon , sun on the meridian , per clock , at 12h 59~ 32~ , which is near 3~ of time per day .
These latter observations , showing the gain of the clock 3~ of time per day , surprised me , as being contrary to my expectation ; for the clock had lost two or three seconds per day in winter , and therefore , I concluded it would lose more in the spring and summer , by the lengthening of the pendulum ; but it happened quite the contrary , and the cause thereof I could not determine .
For ascertaining the diameter of Venus , and also the position and distance of the solar maculae from Venus , I had caused to be constructed an instrument * , much like one which has been already described to the So* Angular micrometer .
ciety , with this addition , which was originally designed for that instrument ; namely , OF EAG and G H , two silver wires parallel to the diameter A B , and ImL distant therefrom 30~ =AE= CD nAG=BF=B H , the three K parallel wires E F , A B , and G H , being fixed , whilst the FBH moveable wires CD and IK opened to any angle , as ILC for intercepting the diameter mn of Venus , whilst CD was perpendicular to A B , and the planet was divided into two equal parts by the wire E F. This micrometer was placed in the eye-piece of a two feet Gregorian telescope , which magnified 55 times , and through the field of view , of which the sun passed in 118 seconds of time .
I had two eye-glasses to the six feet Newtonian * reflector ; one of which , being six tenths of an inch focus , magnified 110 times ; and the other , being three tenths of an inch focus , magnified 220 times , or four times that of the Gregorian reflector .
The greater of these two glasses I purposed to trust to , having often experienced its superiority in viewing the occultations of Jupiter 's satellites and the solar maculae .
The idea I had formed of the internal contact was , that the planet would touch the edge of the sun in an instant , like two drops of quicksilver meeting on a plane , and that in an instant the black contact would appear ; but in this I was deceived , the particulars of the phenomenon being as follows ; viz. * The diameter of the great speculum of this telescope was six inches .
June 6th , a cloudy morning , till about six o'clock , when the clouds began to dissipate , but not enough to afford a plain sight of Venus on the sun , till more than half past seven , and the planet got nearer the limb of the sun , than I had desired to see it first on the disk .
By repeated trials , the time in which the planet was passing from the internal to the external contact , with the wire of the micrometer was 33/ 4 seconds of time , and the angle ICL of the angular micrometer was 8~ .
With the six feet Newtonian reflector , and its magnifying power of 110 , and also of 220 times , I carefully examined * the sun 's disk , to discover a satellite of Venus , but saw none ; for I had a very clear dark glass next my eye , and the sun 's limb appeared most perfectly defined ; but a very narrow waterish penumbra ~ appeared round Venus , by which its limb was not perfectly defined , and at the distance of about a sixth part of Venus 's diameter from its edge , was the darkest part of Venus 's phasis , from which to the centre , an imperfect ~ light increased , and illuminated about the centre .
At 8h 16~ per clock , I was prepared to observe the internal contact ; and as Venus drew nearer to the limb of the sun , the penumbra near the limb of Venus * After the transit , till two o'clock afternoon the same day , I continued observing the disk with this telescope , but saw no satellite pass over the sun .
~ This penumbra could not by any means be made to disappear , although I tried to make it vanish , by altering the focus of the telescope a great number of times .
~ This could not arise from any imperfection of the telescope , as the solar maculae appeared sharply defined , as through a refractor .
became darker , and threatened to obscure the point of contact at the instant it would happen ; the circumstances of which , for each of the moments of time , are imperfectly delineated , on account of the nearness of the lines , but more truly described as follows ; ( a right line representing that part of the sun 's limb near where the contact happened , and an arch the approaching limb of Venus , for each three seconds of time , from the loss of the thread of light .
) A diagram , representing the approach of Venus to the sun 's limb , for each three seconds of time .
[ Vide Tab. VII .
] In this diagram , the black segments represent Venus , and the right lines drawn nearly at contact to them , represent a small part of the sun 's limb , as seen through a dark glass ; the intermediate spaces white , represent the sky .
In words , ( for each second of time by the clock ) thus : h~~ No diminution of light between the At 8 16 41 limb of Venus and that of the sun .
Slight penumbra , or diminution of 8 16 42 light , near where the contact was to be .
Penumbra of a grey colour , near the 8 16 43 same place .
Penumbra almost brown , and the 8 16 44 thread of light very narrow , and almost lost .
Penumbra brown , and the thread of 8 16 45 light in the contact point indistinct , or lost .
Penumbra more brown , and the touch 8 16 46 the smallest possible .
V ENUS with an ~ Atmosphere , as seen on the face of the SUN 6th June 1761 , thro a Telescope magnifying 220 times in Diameter .
Also the Approaches of the planet toward the Sun 's simb , &amp; the Circumstances referred to other Telescopes &amp; to the Royal Observatory at Greenwich .
By Samuel Dunn .
A Table deduced Approaches Approaches Approaches of the Planet Time pr .
Clock Apparent Time Apparent Time for Apparent Time for from this Observn .
deduced for a deduced for a toward the Sun 's simb , ~ with a Tel. of with a Tel. of Greenwich , by a TeParis , by a Telescope showing the appaTel .
of 80 times Tel. of 80 times at the Internal Contact .
220 ( Power 220 Chelsea .
lescope of 220 by ~ of 220 Power by rent Time of the for Paris .
for Greenwich .
at Chelsea .
this Observation .
this Observation .
Contact by different Tel. at Greenwich &amp; at Paris .
p. S. D. Power Greenwich Paris Paris h~~h~~h~~h~~ Observatory Observatory Observatory .
Greenwich .
16 .
58 8 .
18 .
14 8.18.55 8.28.20 h~~h~~h~~h~~ 150 8.18.21 8.28.16 8.28.35 8.19.10 Broader black Contact .
8.16.55 8.18 11 8.18.52 8.28.17 100 8.18.53 8.28.18 8.28.27 8.19 .
2 Broader black Contact .
8.16.52 8.18.8 8.18.49 8.28.14 75 8.18.55 8.28.20 8.28.19 8.18.54 Black Contact .
8.16.49 8.18 .
5 8.18.46 8.28.11 60 8.18.57 8.28.22 8.28.11 8.18.46 Brown Contact .
8.16.46 8.18 .
2 8.18.43 8.28.8 55 8.18.58 8.28.23 8.28.3 8.18.38 Grey Contact .
8.16.43 8.17.59 8.18.40 8.28.5 50 8.18.59 8.28.24 8.27.55 8.18.30 Atmosphere untouched .
8.16.40 8.17.56 8.18.37 8.28.2 45 8.19 .
0 8.28.25 8.27.47 8.18.22 No ~ of Sight now .
8.16.37 8.17.53 8.18.34 8.27.59 40 8.19.2 8.28.27 8.27.39 8.18.14 No ~ of Sight now .
8.16.34 8.17.50 8.18.31 8.27.56 35 8.19.5 8.28.30 8.27.31 8.18 .
6 8.16.31 8.17.47 8.18.28 8.27.53 30 8.19.8 8.28.33 8.27.23 8.17.58 8.16.28 8.17.44 8.18.25 8.27.50 25 8.19.12 8.28.57 The above numbers de8.16.25 8.17.41 8.18.22 8.27.47 note the correspondent 20 8.19.19 8.28.44 Approaches apparently , 8.16.22 8.17.38 8.18.19 8.27.44 and therefore in different 10 8.19.52 8.29.17 Telescopes the Atmos8.16.19 8.17.35 8.18.16 8.27.41 phere ~ less .
~ of the Planet Venus , with the Atmosphere as observed on the Disc of the SUN thro a Telescope magnifying 220 Times in diameter The apparent Magnitude ~ ~ 6th June 1761 .
Philos Trans. Vol. LII .
TAB. VII.p.190 .
h~~ Penumbra almost black , and the touch At 8 16 47 a little broader .
Slight black in the point of contact , 8 16 48 and the edges a little broader .
True black in the point of contact , 8 16 49 and the edges a little broader .
Here I concluded with myself , that observers would differ in their judgments 8 16 50 More so .
about the moment of con8 16 51 More so .
tact , some seconds of time , 8 16 52 More so .
or that some would estimate the contact sooner than others .
From these observations , I concluded , that the thread of light in the point of contact was so obscured , as to be undiscernible at 8h 16~ 46~ , and that true black did not succeed in the same point , till 3~ after , namely , 8h 16~ 49~ ; and from * both of these properties , * As the six feet Newtonian telescope magnified four times as much as that of the two feet Gregorian telescope , and the vanishing of the thread of light , from its least degree of duskishness to a true black , was about 3 seconds of time by the six feet telescope , the time in which the thread of light was vanishing from the least degree of duskishness to a true black , by a two feet Gregorian reflector , may be supposed to have been 4 times 3 = 12 seconds of time ; and hence an error , or rather difference , of pronunciation , but not of judgment , may have arisen among good observers , if some estimated the contact by the invisibility of the thread of light , and others by an apparent blackness in the point of contact , or , which is the same thing , the time when the planet had made the least apparent dent in the sun 's limb , of perties , I concluded , that the real internal contact was at 8h 16~ 47~ by the clock ; which makes 8h 16~ 11~ equal time , and 8h 18~ 2~ apparent time , at Chelsea ; and 8h 18~ 43~ apparent time , at Greenwich .
Whilst Venus was on the sun 's limb , no other penumbra appeared between the limb of Venus and the sun , than had appeared before on the sun 's disk ; and therefore , I concluded there must be an atmosphere about Venus , which , receiving weak impressions of light between the limbs of Venus and the sun , occasioned the uncertainty of ascertaining the exact instant of the internal contact , as above described ; and because my Newtonian reflector showed objects clearer than the generality of Gregorian reflectors , I concluded , that the aforegoing property was what no two feet reflector was capable of examining , the atmosphere being so narrow .
At 8h 35~ per clock , the external contact was near , and not encumbered with such a penumbra , or partial light , as the internal contact had been .
At 8h 35~ 4~ , the least dent possible , quite black , appeared in the sun 's limb .
And at 8h 35~ 6~ , the limb was restored to its perfect form , there having been a small trembling light , between the narrow watery border of Venus and the vanishing point of contact in the sun 's limb for these two seconds of time .
From which the of the same colour , through a dark glass , as the sky .
This was verified by a two feet Gregorian reflector , in the contact abovementioned , and possibly may have occasioned greater differences in estimating the contact , with lesser telescopes , to no less than half a minute of time .
external contact at Chelsea was 8h 34~ 30~ equal time , and 8h 36~ 21~ apparent time ; which makes 8h 37~ 2~ apparent time at Greenwich .
From the aforegoing circumstances , it appeared to me , that the external contact was more easily to be determined than the internal one , which was contrary to what I had before expected ; and because the point of contact must have appeared through such a telescope as I observed with , in its proper colour , dark or black , sooner than through a smaller magnifying power of equal light , I concluded , that , through my telescope , the internal contact was visible , sooner than through a two foot reflector , ten or twelve seconds of time .
And , considering the aforesaid penumbra , or border of partial light , surrounding Venus , as an atmosphere of that planet , with the time of its vanishing , 21/ 2 seconds of time ; and reducing this to the diameter of Venus , with due allowance for the oblique direction over the sun 's limb , the atmosphere of Venus comes out 81/ 2 thirds of a degree , which is nearly about 1/ 4 00 th part of Venus 's diameter ; which diameter being nearly equal to the earth 's diameter , the atmosphere of Venus comes out nearly 50 geographical miles .
As these observations were made with care and attention , I have lain them before the Society only ; and the more readily , as they reconcile a seeming contradiction in Mr. Short 's * numbers of the internal contact ; * It having been 3 seconds of time from the instant when the thread of light between Venus and the sun became so indistinct , as not to be properly termed light , to the instant when the black contact ; and , whilst I am very certain with respect to the particulars of the external contact , cannot determine why they differ from that ingenious observer 's numbers , or any other 's .
Samuel Dunn .
** When the limb of Venus was almost clear * of the sun 's disk , I perceived a difficulty would occur at the last contact , as the limb of the sun , and also that of Venus , which was to make the contact appeared through a telescope magnifying 220 times , the limits of time in which it continued in a like apparent state , by 140 2 telescope magnifying times , may be supposed to have 55 5 Savile-House is 30~ been seconds of time ; and as west 12 Chelsea is 41~ of Greenwich , the black contact , by the above observation , with Mr. Short 's telescope at Savile-House 8h 18~ 18~ was at the the telescope at Greenwich observatory 8 18 58 8h 18~ 21 1/ 2~ observations at those places being And , for other 8 19 0 telescopes , the limits above-mentioned may be supposed to have been nearly as in the following table .
Magnifying power .
Limits .
200 times .
3~ of time .
100 7 80 8 60 11 50 13 40 16 35 19 30 22 25 26 20 33 20 66 last dent , approached so near to a right line .
This led me to consider , that the spherical external angle of contact , by the six feet telescope , would be but an * eighth part of the same angle by the two feet telescope , the eye judging of the same relative distance in one telescope as in the other ; and that , therefore , as the versed sine of the dent in the sun 's limb was but a fourth part as large in one telescope as the other , and the last contact vanished in about 21/ 2 seconds of time , the last contact might possibly be estimated , by a two feet Gregorian telescope , about twice 21/ 2 , or 5~ or 6~ , seconds of time later than with a six feet Newtonian telescope ; which allowance being made , the apparent time of the two contacts , as reduced to a Gregorian reflector , magnifying 55 times : by such a telescope , the contacts at Greenwich observatory were , viz. internal contact 8h 18~ 55~ , external contact 8h 37~ 7~ .
The accounts which have been published of the observations made at Greenwich being , internal contact 8h 19~ 0~ , external contact 8h 37~ 9~ ; and the difference in each within five seconds of time , an error answering to about a 500th part of the sun 's distance from the earth .
* As the spherical angle of contact in the limb of Venus , and also of the sun , was four times as great in one telescope as in the other , the sum of both is eight times ; which , being diminished by four times the apparent magnitude of the versed sine of the least visible dent in the one telescope , what it was in the other telescope , leaves the one double to that of the other .

