XXIII .
Additional Observations upon some Plates of white Glass found at Herculaneum : In a Letter to Charles Morton , M. D. R. S. S. By J. Nixon , A. M. and F. R. S. Dear Sir , INa paper , which I had the honour to present to this learned Society about * two years ago , I offered my thoughts upon some plates of white glass found in the ruins of Herculaneum .
I now beg leave to add some more observations , with a view partly to explain and support what I then delivered , and partly to communicate such new informations , as I have since received , relating to the same subject .
Read April 9 , 1761 .
I observed ~ , upon the authorities produced by Mons. Renaudot ~ , that glass plates were not applied * Phil. Trans. Vol. L. Part II .
~ Ibid. p. 602 .
~ Mem. de l'Acad~ des Inscript .
Vol. I. for magnifying objects in optical experiments , till the beginning of the thirteenth century : but , upon reviewing his dissertation , I find he sinks the antiquity of that usage a century lower than this .
That learned writer adds further , ` ` That with regard to this question , whether the ancients made their astronomical observations without telescopes , the affirmative is looked upon as certain ; because , if this invention had ever been known before , there is all imaginable reason to believe , that the utility , which would result from it , not only in astronomy , but for several other purposes , would have prevented its being afterwards lost .
' ' Mons. Renaudot declines entering into this controversy ; but observes , that Mabillon mentions a manuscript he saw in an abbey in the diocese of Freisingen , wherein Ptolemy was represented observing the stars with a * tube , like our modern perspective-glasses .
This manuscript is said to have been written in the beginning of the thirteenth century ; which date ( says Mons. Renaudot ) is the more remarkable , because plain spectacles , which should seem likely , in the nature of things , to have been invented first , do not appear to have been known till a hundred years after .
Then , having produced the evidences , which prove , that this latter discovery was made about the time above-mentioned , he concludes with saying , ` ` that * Mabillon does not mention , that the tube had glasses ; neither indeed was that circumstance easily discoverable .
Perhaps such tubes were then used only to preserve and direct the sight , or to render it more distinct , by singling out the particular object looked at , and shutting out all the rays reflected from others , whose proximity might have rendered the image less precise .
we have nothing of this nature with regard to telescopes .
' ' The reason of my enlarging upon this article is a passage I have lately met in that learned antiquary , Mr. Rowland , which may seem to contradict the observation produced above .
This * author alleges the authority of Hecataeus ( apud Diod .
Sic .
tom .
i. p. 159 .
Ed. Wessel .
) for saying , that the Hyperborei , who inhabited an island in the Northern ocean , opposite to the Celtae , ` ` could ( as if they had the use of telescopes ) show the moon very near them , and discover therein mountains , and heaps of rocks , which that instrument only can discover .
' ' That we may distinguish how far Hecataeus is concerned in this passage , it will be proper to give a literal translation of it from the original ; viz. ` ` They say further , that the moon , viewed from this island , appears to be but at a very little distance from the earth , and to have certain protuberances , like land , visible on her surface ~ .
' ' Now , it may be observed , in the first place , that this phenomenon , if real , may perhaps be explained by the refraction of the moon 's rays in passing through the atmosphere of the earth , which , in an island situated very far north , might be continually charged with an extraordinary quantity of vapours .
Or further , as Hecataeus mentions it upon hearsay only , and subjoins some other circumstances in the same chapter relating to this island , which are entirely of a fabulous cast , * Mona Antiqua , p. 76 .
~~ ~ .
we may justly question the * truth of the fact ; and , consequently , shall not be obliged to maintain the necessary existence of telescopes in those times , in order to account for it .
As it appears ~ , that neither the lapis specularis , nor glass , was used for windows before Seneca 's time ; and it cannot be supposed , that the Romans , a people of so refined a taste in other instances , would suffer their apartments to be exposed to the free entrance of winds , &amp;c. it may be reasonably asked , What supplied the place of those materials before ?
To satisfy this enquiry , it is to be observed , that several other materials are mentioned by ancient writers , as serving the purpose before us ; such as thin hides , or ~ skins , like our parchment , mentioned by Philoponus .
Pliny likewise informs us , that the horns of the urus being cut into thin laminae were ~ transparent , and supplied , in some measure , the use of our lanthorns ; and we may probably conclude , from the analogy of things , that they served for windowlights also ; especially , as we meet with windows made of horn ( corneum specular ) in Tertullian , who wrote within less than two hundred years after Pliny .
To these , we may add the vela , made of ~ haircloth , or pieces of hides ~ ~ , which Pitiscus ( upon the * Vide Wesselium , not .
in loc. ~ Phil. Trans. Vol. L. Part II .
p. 605 .
~ Apud Salm .
Exerc .
Plin .
T. ii .
p. 1095 .
Ed. Par. ~ Plin .
Not .
Hist. L. xi .
c. 37 .
In laminas secta translucent atque etiam lumen inclusum latius fundunt .
Apud Salmas .
Plin .
Ex. T. i. p. 260 .
~ Vela cilicia .
Ulpian apud Le Antichita di Ercolano esposte , p. 268 .
~~ Fabretti .
Ibid. p. 256 .
The makers of these vela , ~ .
Act .
18 .
3 .
ibid. authority of Ulpian ) says , were in use before the invention of windows of the lapis specularis , or * glass .
Ulpian indeed , in the passage Pitiscus refers to , only mentions them as subsisting together with the ~ latter : but it seems obvious to conclude , that the vela , being an invention less perfect and commodious , were prior in time to the specularia , which are to be regarded as a subsequent improvement of the former .
Notwithstanding this , the vela still continued in question , even after the introduction of window-fences of stone or glass , and served as canopies , or ~ umbrellas , to keep the sun from places exposed to the open air ; as the others secured the inner parts of the house from cold , &amp;c. I took notice ~ of the natural connection there seemed to subsist between the using of plates of glass for adorning the inside of apartments in ancient times , and the employing them for introducing light into those apartments .
This observation has been supported by a letter I received from my learned correspondent , Abbate Venuti , at Rome , dated December 30 , 1759 , wherein he informs me , that he had lately read , in some anecdotes of Cardinal Maximi , That as they were digging among the ruins on mount Caelius , in the last century , they found a room belonging to an antique dwelling-house , that * Pitiscus , Tit .
Specular .
~ Specularia et vela , quae frigoris causa et imbrium in domo sunt .
Ibid. ~ Specularia-vela , quae frigoris , vel umbrae causa , in domo sunt .
Ulpian apud Le Antich .
See these vela exhibited , Tavol .
vi .
&amp; 49 .
ibid. ~ Phil. Trans. Vol. L. Part II .
p. 606 .
had all its sides within ornamented with plates of glass , some of them tinged with various colours , others of their own natural hue , which was dusky , occasioned by the thickness of the mass , of which they consisted * .
There were likewise in the same apartment , window-frames composed of marble , and glazed with laminae of glass .
' ' But as the Abbate did not take upon himself to ascertain the real age of this building , I shall not pretend to lay any greater stress upon this discovery , than I did upon the observation , for the sake of which I produced it , for proving the point I had then in view , viz. that the usage of glass for windows was ( probably ) nearly of the same antiquity with that of adorning houses with it .
I informed the Society ~ , that I had not been able to trace up the constructing of windows with plates of glass , such as these found at Herculaneum , higher than two hundred years short of the overthrow of that city : but , some time after , a passage in Baronius was suggested to me , which seemed to carry the antiquity of this practice much higher , even to the 42d year of the Christian aera .
It was a quotation ~ from Philo Judaeus , wherein he gives an account of C. Ca* Nam cum laminae crassioris essent molis , colorem opacum nigrantemque reddebant .
Venuti .
This would be the effect of the ancient glass , if it was of a coarser composition than ours : and that it was so in fact , a very eminent critic , both in sacred and profane literature , thinks , may be collected from St. Paul 's words , 1 Cor. xiii .
12 .
` ` Now we see , but through a glass darkly .
' ' ~ Philos. Trans. Vol. L. Part II .
p. 608 .
~ Baron .
Annal .
Eccles .
T. i. A. C. 42 .
p. 335 .
Col. Agrip .
1621 .
ligula 's reception of the Jewish deputies .
` ` When ( says he ) we had entered upon our harangue , the Emperor perceiving , that some things of no small weight were urged , and that others no less strong were likely to be alleged , he broke off the audience , and hurried away , with great precipitation , into a spacious hall : there walking * about , he commanded the windows to be shut on every side , consisting of white glass , resembling plates of the lapis specularis , which admit the light , but exclude the wind and the sun .
' ' This authority indeed , if genuine , would have fully answered my purpose ; but , upon consulting the text of Philo , I was fully convinced , that the Cardinal 's translation of the latter part of this passage , which alone affects the present inquiry , was directly contrary to the original ; which imports , that the windows in the imperial apartment consisted of laminae of stone , almost as transparent as glass ~ .
I cannot leave this passage , without taking notice of that conclusion of it , viz. ` ` That the windows of the lapis specularis admitted the light , but excluded the violent heat of the sun .
' ' This seems to prove , * Obambulansque jussit claudi fenestras vitro candido simili lapidibus specularibus , quibus lux admittitur , ventus et sol excluditur .
This version of Baronius is the same verbatim with that in the editions of Geneva 1613 , Lut .
Par. 1640 , and Francf .
1691 .
~ ~ ~ ~ , ~~~~ ~ .
Ed. Lut .
1640 .
&amp; Franc .
1691 .
Since the writing of this , Dr. Birch has informed me , that Dr. Mangy has translated this passage agreeably to my idea , viz. Lapidibus haud minus pellucidis quam vitro candido .
that the specularia in Martial were made of the same materials , if this reading adopted by Salmasius , &amp;c. is to be followed ; viz. Specularia puras Admittunt luces , et sine sole diem .
L. viii .
Epig .
14 .
But other copies have it Specularia puros Admittunt soles , et sine faece diem * .
This reading is espoused by Collessus , the Dauphin editor , who further explains ( puros ) by ( nitidos ) ; and yet , in his notes , tells us , that these specularia were of stone or talc ; which they could not have been , consistently with Philo 's account , but must have been of glass ; and consequently , we should have an evidence in Martial for the usage of glass in windows , as early as the first century : for that poet lived in Rome from A. C. 71 to 100 .
But perhaps these ( seemingly ) contradictory readings of this passage may be reconciled , as to their sense , by interpreting ( puras luces ) in the one , and ( puros soles ) in the other , to mean the mild light and warmth of the sun , which remained after the greater part of its rays had been either reflected by the exterior surface , or absorbed within the interior pores of the stone ; or , as Milton expresses it , The sun shorn of his beams .
* Ed. Ingolst .
1602 .
Pitiscus Specular .
&amp;c. Upon this hypothesis , sine faece will signify the exclusion , not of the rain , dust , &amp;c. as it is explained by the commentators , who follow this reading ; but that of the gross body of the sun 's rays ; and so will coincide with sine sole diem , in the other copies .
As I quoted * Lactantius ( De Officio Dei , c. viii .
) to prove the use of glass in windows in his time , viz. the third century , I hold myself obliged to take notice of the censure , which Cortius and Longolius pass upon this father , and which is as far from being candid , as the authorities they appeal to are from proving it true .
These gentlemen , in their notes on Pliny ( L. ii .
Ep. 17 .
) , boldly pronounce the father mistaken ( peccavit Lactantius ) with regard to the passage I produced from him : and they support this charge , by referring to Lipsius on Seneca de Prov .
C. iv .
&amp; Epist .
90 .
and to Pliny Hist. Not .
L. xxxvi .
c. 26 .
Now , whoever consults Lipsius on the places here referred to by these editors , will find nothing therein , but observations relating to the lapis specularis , viz. the reason of its name ; the countries where it was found ; its use in window-fences , for dining-rooms , bed-chambers , baths , porticos , and even in orchards and gardens .
This is what nobody ever denied , and what even Lactantius himself intimates , in the ~ passage before us .
How , therefore , this can affect that father 's testimony , relating to the use of glass in windows , exceeds my imagination to conceive .
And * Phil. Trans. Vol. L. Part II .
p. 608 .
~ Manifestius est , mentem esse , quae ea , quae sunt opposita , transpiciat , quasi per fenestras lucente vitro , aut lapide speculari obductas .
as for Pliny , I suppose it will readily be allowed me , that no writer , how respectable soever his authority may be , can possibly prove another , who lived two hundred years after him , mistaken , when he alludes to the practice of his own times .
As I hope the evidence is now undeniable , which I produced in my dissertation , to prove the use of glass in windows to have been as early as the third century ( not to mention the probable reasons there offered to show , that it might have subsisted some ages before ) , it may not be unacceptable to the curious in antiquity , to observe the slow progress this very commodious invention made in travelling towards the west ; since it appears , by our historians * , that it did not reach our island till the seventh century ; when it was brought hither from France , either by Benedict abbot of Winal , or Wilfrid archbishop of York ; as ~ lanthorns of horn were introduced by King Alfred , about the same time , viz. 680 .
Having now proposed all I had to offer , relating to the several uses of plates of glass , already mentioned in my essay , I beg the Society 's indulgence to permit me to subjoin two others , which I have met with since that communication .
The first of these was suggested to me by my ( late ) worthy friend Smart Lethieullier , Esq ; who , last winter at Bath , informed me , that he had in his collection an urn , of a quadrangular figure , which * Simon Dunelm .
Hist. Ang .
Script .
p. 92 .
Stubs Act .
Pont .
Ebor .
Hist. Ang .
Script .
~ Stavesly 's Hist. of Churches , p. 103 .
had been divided into two equal parts by a plate of glass , the vestiges of which were still remaining .
He was of opinion , that the cells made by this partition contained the remains of some pair , eminent either for their conjugal affection , or some of the other connections of social life .
This conjecture , highly probable in itself , is farther confirmed by similar examples in antiquity .
Thus we find in Montfaucon * the figure of a square urn , wherein were contained the ashes of a man and his wife , as appears by the inscription upon it .
Another urn is represented ( Plate LVII .
) , which held the ashes of a mother and her daughter .
To which we may add a third ( Plate LV .
) , covered with a square flat tablet of stone , on which were three inscriptions , signifying , that the remains of three persons , whose relation to each other is not specified , were enclosed therein .
The other instance was transmitted to me by the Abbate Venuti , in a letter from Rome , dated September 27 , 1759 .
viz. ` ` That , in digging up some ruins in that city a few years ago , there was found an ancient picture painted on marble , and covered with a plate of white glass , like those used in our times for that purpose , only somewhat thicker .
The picture expressed a lady 's head , and was of a very elegant composition .
' ' From this last circumstance , the Abbate infers , ` ` that it could not be the production of any later age ; ' ' meaning ( I presume ) any period between the decay of good painting among the ancients , and the revival of it among * Antiq .
Expliq .
Vol. V. p. 1 .
Pl .
34 .
Ed. Par. the moderns .
He further assures me , that he saw this picture , which ( together with its cover ) was deposited in the cabinet of the Marquis Capponi at Rome .
The circumstance of this piece being painted on marble , naturally leads our thoughts up to the age of the fragments of glass , which occasioned my dissertation , viz. to the overthrow of Herculaneum , out of whose ruins four pictures ( among many others ) have been found painted on the same materials .
There is a passage in Pliny * , which has been thought to carry up this manner of painting as high as to the times of Claudius , who began to reign A. C. 41 .
But I am humbly of opinion , that lapidem pingere , in this place , does not mean painting on stone or marble , but only the staining them with artificial colours ; as the remaining part of the sentence relates to the inlaying of pieces of marble of various tints , where the original veins were defective , either in variety or beauty : not that I think it at all improbable , at the same time , that this species of painting might be as ancient as the epoch mentioned above , viz. the reign of Claudius ; because it actually subsisted in the time of Pliny , which must reach up to that aera ; for the four paintings referred to in the beginning of this paragraph , as done in the same manner , were found in the ruins of a city ( viz. * Caepimus et lapidem pingere .
Hoc Claudii principatu inventum .
Neronis vero maculas , quae non essent , in crustis inserendo unitatem variare , ut ovatus esset Numidicus , ut purpura distingueretur Sinnadicus , qualiter illos , nasci optarent deliciae .
Hist. Not .
Lib. xxxv .
c. 1 .
Herculaneum ) , in whose catastrophe that writer lost his life .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient , humble servant , J. Nixon .
London , Feb. 3 , 1761 .

