XV .
An Account of the Cicuta , recommended by Dr. Stork ; by William Watson , M. D. F. R. S. To the Royal Society .
Gentlemen , INa paper I lately laid before you , I endeavoured to demonstrate , that the Cicuta major , which , since the publication of Dr. Stroke 's work at Vienna , had been used medicinally in England , was the plant intended by that gentleman ; and not the Cicuta aquatica , as had been suggested by some practitioners here .
And Dr. Stroke has removed every doubt , which could remain , by transmitting hither to Mr. Hudson , a very ingenious apothecary and botanist , some leaves of the Cicuta major , or common hemlock , which grew at Vienna , and is of the same species with the plant so denominated here .
Read Feb. 17 , 1761 .
As Dr. Stroke informs us , that , since the publication of his treatise , he has received letters from almost every part of Europe , confirming his good opinion of the virtues of the Cicuta , and as he is about to publish a second treatise upon the same subject , containing still more extraordinary relations of cures brought about , by administring that plant ; there is no doubt therefore , but that endeavours will be made here , to confirm the truth of the doctor 's assertions ; more especially , as some of the diseases , in which Dr. Stork found the Cicuta attended with great success , are such as are of all others the most shocking to human nature , and have , by too long experience , been found to give way to no other means .
Hence it is highly important to every one , more particularly to physicians , that the very plant , directed by Dr. Stork , be administred , and no other in the place of it , either through inattention or want of knowlege ; as judgment in the physician is of no real service , unless his prescriptions are faithfully prepared .
For these reasons , it may not be improper to inform those medical practitioners , who are not conversant in botany , and who may nevertheless be desirous of trying the effects of the Cicuta , that at this time of the year there is another plant , growing in the same places , and often mixed with it , so much resembling it in appearance , as not , without some attention , to be distinguished from it ; which , however , greatly differs from it in sensible qualities .
Great care therefore ought to be taken , that the one of these should be selected from the other .
The plant so much resembling hemlock , is the Cicutaria vulgaris of the botanists , which in some parts of England is called cow-weed , in others wild cicely .
Its greatest resemblance to hemlock is in the spring , before the stalks of the leaves of the hemlock are interspersed with purple spots ; and therefore , at that season , more easily mistaken for it ; though , even then , the leaves of the hemlock smell much stronger , are more minutely divided , and are of a deeper green colour , than those of the cow-weed .
Afterwards , indeed , they are more easily distinguished , as the Cicutaria flowers at the end of April and beginning of May , and the Cicuta not till June , when the other is past : to say nothing of the flowering stalk of the cow-weed being furrowed , and somewhat downey ; and that of the hemlock , smooth , even , and always spotted .
These plants differ likewise very essentially in their seeds , which in the cow-weed are long , smooth , and black , when ripe ; whereas those of the hemlock are small , channelled , and swelling towards their middle .
Besides the cow-weed , there is another plant in appearance very like the hemlock , although evidently differing from it in other respects ; and , unless I am very greatly misinformed , quantities of this have been collected , and sold in London for the hemlock .
This is more likely to be taken for the hemlock in summer or autumn , as it is an annual plant , and is produced and flowers late in the season .
The plant here meant is the Cicuta minor of Parkinson , or Cicutaria tenuifolia of Ray .
This , however , is easily distinguished from hemlock , by its leaves being of the colour and shape of parsley , its flowering stalks having no purple or other spots , and not having the strong smell peculiar to hemlock .
To the two plants before-mentioned , may be added a third , which very frequently , more especially about London , grows along , and is mixed , with the hemlock .
This plant is called , by the late excellent Mr. Ray , Small hemlock-chervil with rough seeds ; and is denominated by Caspar Bauhin , in his Pinax , Myrrhis sylvestris seminibus asperis .
This , like the cow-weed before-mentioned , can only be mistaken for hemlock in the spring .
It may be distinguished then from it , by the leaves of the myrrhis being more finely cut , of a paler green colour , and , though they have somewhat of the hemlock smell , are far less strong , and have no spots .
This plant flowers in April , and the seeds are ripe before the hemlock begins to flower ; and these seeds are cylindrical , rough , and terminate in an oblong point .
The leaves of hemlock are most fit for medicinal purposes , as being in their greatest perfection , when collected in dry weather , from the middle of May to the time that their flowering stems begin to shoot ; as by that time the plants will have felt the effects of the warm sun , have acquired an highly virose smell , and the stems of the leaves are covered with purple spots , an argument of the exaltation of their juices : and we should be attentive here to give them all these advantages , as three degrees of latitude , and other circumstances of soil and situation , may occasion a very sensible difference in the qualities of the same plant ; an instance of which occurs in the plant under consideration , and may be one of the causes , why the effects of the hemlock have not been such here , as we are assured they are at Vienna ; viz. Dr. Stork says , that the root of hemlock , when cut into slices , pours forth a milky juice , which I have never seen it to do here in England .
There are several vegetables , which , though they thrive apparently well , their productions are , nevertheless , not the same as in other parts of the world , where the heat is more intense , and the summers are of longer continuance .
It would be extremely difficult here , though the plants thrive very well , to produce from the white poppy , or Cistus ladanifera , either the opium or the labdanum , the known production of these vegetables in other parts of the world .
No art can make here the tragacantha pour forth its gum , the lentiscus its mastic , or the candleberry myrtle of North America its sebaceous concrete .
To these might be added many others , too tedious to mention .
In such mild winters as the last , the leaves of hemlock may be procured in any part of them ; but they are not to be depended upon , as their specific smell is then comparatively weak , their juices poor and watery , and they are wholly without spots .
I am , With all possible regard , Gentlemen , Your most obedient humble servant , W. Watson .

