IV .
A Letter from the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , A. M. Fellow of Trinity College , in the University of Cambridge , and F. R. S. to the Rev. Dr. Birch , Secretary to the Royal Society ; containing a Theorem of the Aberration of the Rays of Light refracted through a Lens , on account of the Imperfection of the spherical Figure .
Reverend Sir , ABOUT two years ago , becoming acquainted with Mr. Dollond 's curious discovery in optics , of correcting the aberration of the rays of light arising from the different refrangibility of the different sorts of rays , by a combination of two different kinds of glass ; and learning from him , in conversation , that he had invented a theorem , showing the quantity of the aberration of the rays refracted through a lens , on account of the imperfection of the spherical figure ; by the application of which , he was able to make the aberrations of the combined concave and convex object lenses perfectly equal to , and consequently to correct one another ; I was desirous of being more minutely acquainted with this farther great improvement in optics ; and Mr. Dollond accordingly readily offered to gratify my curiosity .
But in the mean while that he was looking over his papers , in order to lay them before me , having leisure , I set about the investigation of a similar theorem myself ; which having VO L. LII .
D completed , Read Jan. 22 , completed , I interchanged with Mr. Dollond for his theorem , he taking mine , and I taking his .
Our theorems , though similar , were not exactly the same ; but , by reduction to the same form , I inferred his theorem from mine ; which gave me a farther confidence of the exactness of both .
I have here sent you my theorem , and desire , that you will lay it before the Royal Society .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient humble servant , Nevil Maskelyne .
Prince Henry , St. Helen 's Road , Jan. 16 , 1761 .
LET the form of the lens assumed , in the investigation of the theorem , be a meniscus , the radius of whose convex surface is greater than that of its concave surface ; and the center of whose two surfaces lie on the same side of the lens , as the radiant point , from which the rays diverge , that fall thereon .
The ray falling on the extreme part of the lens will , after refraction , diverge from a point before the lens , nearer thereto than the geometrical focus of rays diverging from the same radiant point , and passing indefinitely near the vertex .
Let Q express the distance of the radiant point , before the lens , from its vertex ; R , the radius of concavity of the surface , on which the rays first fall ; and r , the radius of convexity of the second surface ; F , the principal focus , or the focus of parallel rays ; which will be on the same side of the lens , as the incident rays ; because R , the radius of the concave surface , is supposed less than r , the radius of the convex surface .
Let the ratio of m to n be the same with that of the sine of incidence to the sine of refraction of rays passing out of air into glass , and let Y express the semidiameter of the aperture of the lens ; the angular aberration of the ray falling on the extremity of the lens , or the angle made between this ray , after being refracted through the extremity of the lens , and another ray or line , supposed to be drawn from the same extremity of the lens , to the geometrical focus of rays diverging from the same radiant point , and passing indefinitely near the vertex of the lens , expressed in measures of the arc of a circle to the radius unity , will be m3 2 m2 n+2 n3 ~ Y3 / mn2~2m~ F3 +mn+4 n2 2 m2 ~ Y3 / mn~2m~ F2 r +m+2n~Y3/ 2m~F r2 4n2+3mn3m2~Y3/ mn~2m~Q F2 2m+2n~Y 3/ m ~QFr+3m+2n~Y 3/ 2 m~ Q2 F. Where R , the radius of the first surface , is exterminated ; and r , the radius of the second surface , is retained : Or , exterminating r , the radius of the second surface , and retaining R , the radius of the first surface , the angular aberration is also expressed by m2 ~Y3/ 2~mn2~ F3 2m+n~Y3/ 2~mn~ F2 R+m+2n~Y3/ 2m~FR2 +3m+n~Y3/ 2~mn~Q F2 2m+2n~Y3/ m~QFR+3m+2n~Y3/ 2m~ Q2 F. It may be proper to remark , that , as in these theorems , the principal focus is supposed to lie before the glass , as well as the radiant point , to adapt the theorem to other cases , if the lens be of such a form , as that its principal focus lies behind the glass , F must be taken negative : likewise , if the rays fall converging on the lens , or the point , to which they converge , lie behind the glass , Q must be taken negative : lastly , if the first surface be convex , R must be taken negative ; and if the second surface be concave , r must be taken negative ; and if , after all these circumstances are allowed for , the value of the theorem comes out positive , the aberration is of such a nature , as to make the focus of the extreme rays fall nearer the lens before it , than the geometrical focus , or farther from the lens behind it : but if the value of the theorem comes out negative , the aberration is of such a kind , as to make the focus of the extreme rays fall farther from the lens before it , than the geometrical focus .
With respect to the application of this theorem to Mr. Dollond 's combined object glasses , it is evident , that if the aberrations of the convex and concave lenses added together ( paying due regard to the signs of the theorem ) , are made equal to nothing , the two lenses will perfectly correct one another : but as there are two unknown quantities unlimited in the equation , namely , the radius of one surface of each glass ( for F and Q are given , as well as m and n ) , there is room for an arbitrary assumption of one of them , at the discretion of the theorist , or artist ; which being done , there will remain a quadratic equation , whence there will result two values of the radius , which remains unknown , either of which will produce an aberration equal to that of the other lens .

