V. An Attempt to Account for the Origin and the Formation of the Extraneous Fossil commonly called the Belemnite .
[ Vide TA B. III .
IV .
V. ] By Mr. Joshua Platt .
To the Right Honourable George Earl of Macclesfield President , and to the Council and Fellows , of the Royal Society , the following Attempt to account for the Origin and true Formation of the Extraneous Fossil commonly called the Belemnite , is humbly addressed , by Their much obliged and obedient humble Servant , Joshua Platt .
o n m Fig. 10 .
l Fig. 6 .
Fig. 11 .
Fi k i a~b b c d e f g Philos. Trans. Vol. LIV .
TAB. III.p.38 .
Fig.1 .
Fig.5 .
b c a Fig. 13 .
Fig.12 Fig.14 .
Fig. Philos. Trans. Vol. LIV .
TAB. IV.p.38 .
Fig.3 .
gg Fig.4 .
Fig.2 .
f bba e y hh cdc Fig.17 .
Fig.15 .
Fig.~ Fig.8 .
Found at Headington Stone pit near Oxon Philos. Trans. Vol. LIV .
TAB. V. p. 38 .
Fig. 16 .
Fig. 9 .
THE public hath of late been agreeably entertained with descriptions of many curious Fossils discovered in different parts of this kingdom : but very little hath been offered with a view to ascertain their origin and formation ; a point of much greater importance to a curious mind , than the most accurate descriptions , or the neatest delineations .
It may indeed be thought unnecessary at this time , to say any thing of the origin of extraneous Fossils in general ; all our modern naturalists being fully convinced , that they are the exuviae or remains of animals and vegetables , and the greater part of them of marine production .
Read Jan. 26 , 1764 .
But as to their particular origin and formation ; in what manner they were produced in the recent , and how and with what matter they afterwards became impregnated in their fossil state ; all this is a field of natural inquiry , that has been very much neglected , notwithstanding it is the most fertile and productive of useful and entertaining knowledge .
Besides , were we to consider it in this view , the recent and fossil remains would be found to throw a mutual light upon each other , and the naturalist would not be so often at a loss to class every new fossil acquisition , of which the recent specimen is not to be found , especially whenever the fossil has~ any thing seemingly aequivocal in its formation , so as on a superficial imspection to render the matter doubtful , whether the body belongs to the animal or vegetable kingdoms , or indeed to either of them .
One of the first note is the Belemnite , which has not until very lately been even ranked amongst the marine productions ; but whose origin and formation have never yet been fully explained .
I shall not enter into a minute detail of the several species of the Belemnite .
The history of this extraneous fossil , or an attempt to account for the origin and formation of the Belemnite , so far as they can be discovered and confirmed by reasonings drawn from facts and experience , is the object of the present enquiry .
I shall therefore confine my self to two species of the Belemnite ; the one common in most counties of this kingdom , and vulgarly known by the name of Thunder-bolt [ a ] : the other that of the fusiform or Spindlekind [ b ] , found in slate-stone at Stons-field , but in far greater plenty in the clay near Piddington [ c ] Oxfordshire ; and in the chalk-pits of Kent and Surrey [ d ] .
Those in chalk have been often mistaken for spines of the sea-hedgehog , or Echinus Ovarius ; but the characteristics of these two bodies are widely different .
The Belemnite breaks in a direction perpendicular to its axis [ e]~ the spine obliquely [ f ] .
The Belemnite , when broken , exhibits central rays ; the Spine a smooth resplendent surface .
This distinction is invariable , if the trial be repeated a thousand times .
These different appearances are probably the effects of different formations : and therefore the Belemnite seems to be formed by apposition , and the Aculeus or Spine by protrusion , or , as Mr. Reaumur calls it , by intus-susception .
The radii in the Belemnite are owing to the fine laminae , of which it is composed ; they are so very thin , and break so nearly alike , that they have ever an horizontal surface when broken , [ a ] TA B. III .
Fig. 1 .
[ b ] Fig. 2 .
[ c ] Fig. 3 .
[ d ] Fig. 4 .
[ e ] Fig. 5 .
[ f ] Fig. 6 .
which is common to all the shells of the trichite kind [ g ] .
The spine being formed by protrusion , its component parts are adjusted on a different manner , and the pores like the cancelli in bones ( though not so distinct ) are irregular , which is the reason of its breaking obliquely in any direction , but it is generally smooth by being saturated with a plated kind of spar [ h ] .
My ingenious and very worthy friend Mr. Brander , in a dissertation on the Belemnite , presented to the Royal Society [ i ] , justly observes ; ` ` that the Belemnite belongs to the testaceous part of the animal kingdom , and to the family of the nautili .
' ' And I would beg leave farther to add , that this gentleman 's sentiments are greatly strengthened by the surprising analogy , which the Belemnite bears to the little pearly concamerated shell , or cornu Ammonis ; and the orthoceratites , to the large nautilus ; the former having its siphunculus upon the verge , as the latter has it in the center of the diaphragm , or partition , of each cell or chamber .
` ` It has indeed been truly matter of speculation ( continues Mr. Brander ) how this huge solid substance called the Belemnite , exclusive of the nucleus , could be formed ; and how it happens , that some Belemnites should have the nucleus within them , others not ; the cavity to [ g ] Fig. 7 .
A piece of the Penna Marina , perforated by the Pholades .
[ h ] Spar seems to be nothing but crystal debased by a calcareous earth : the more debased sort breaks in a hairy trichite manner , the more pellucid kind with a smooth surface ; and always in an oblique rhomboidal direction ; which perhaps may in some measure enable us to account for its double refraction .
[ i ] Philosophical Transactions , Vol. xlviii .
for 1754 , page 803 .
contain the same in some very small , in others scarce or not at all visible ' ' .
But I flatter myself , that it will be found upon enquiry , that these are only circumstances , which are common to other testaceous bodies , that have been accidentally broken or decayed by time , when forsaken by their inhabitants .
For no testaceous body can be formed without an inhabitant ; nor does it appear to me , that any Belemnite was ever formed without an alveolus , or concamerated shell .
The conical cavity and its nucleus are always proportioned to the bulk of the Belemnite , but not to its length : some are four times longer in proportion to the alveolus than others .
The apex of the conical cavity , where the alveolus is first formed , in some runs up about half the length of the whole Belemnite ; in others not a sixth part of the whole [ k ] : but the aperture , or upper chamber [ l ] is equally proportionable to the bulk , or circumference of the Belemnite , of whatsover size or shape ; and is the seat [ m ] or dwelling-place of the animal , that forms the Belemnite .
In whatmanner this work is executed , I shall now endeavour to explain .
A considerable part of marine bodies , especially those of the testaceous tribe , are generally buried in mud or sand , except some few , which stick to rocks , &amp;c. as the limpets and periwincles ; by which means we are prevented from making those remarks upon the several stages of their growth , which an accurate enquirer would desire .
We must therefore have re[k ] Fig. 8 .
[ l ] Fig. xiii .
b. c. [ m ] We never find a Belemnite with part of the alveolus , but the vestigia or marks of the remainder appear in the cavity , and are continued to the verge of it .
course to the different steps or periods of their life and growth , as they are marked out by the indented lips or foldings of the shell ; until they arrive at their full size ; when they begin to fortify themselves , by bulwarks and strong holds , against the injuries and incidents , which attend old age .
This is most conspicuous in the cowree , or concha Veneris of Lister , book iv .
sect. 9 .
Mr. Reaumur [ n ] found , by repeated experiments , that land snails form their shells by juxtaposition : as the animal grows in bulk , the shell is increased by a mucous matter emitted from the body of the animal , which hhardens by degrees into a testaceous substance : and from the experiments upon land shells that great naturalist concludes by analogy , that all testaceous bodies are formed in the like manner , particularly those of the turbinated kind .
To this general rule an objection is made by Mr. Poupart , from the formation of the cowree , or concha Veneris before mentioned : but this learned gentleman was not aware , that this shell is first a buccinum , forming many convolutions before it draws in the verge to form the indented lip .
It was this very objection of Mr. Poupart , which led me to examine into the growth of the cowree ; and by sawing one of them through the middle , I found a turbinated shell within the outer wall , consisting of six or seven convolutions , but no stages , or periods , of the indented lip appeared in any of the convolutions , as we find in the helmet shell , and several of the buccinae .
I then began to consider how this animal enlarged its dwelling ; and was fully convinced , that [ n ] See his book of insects .
no more convolutions could be carried on ; the indented lips being a full stop to its inward dimensions ; and that here was the period of its growth .
My sentiments were just as to its inward dimension ; but observing that the lips of some were much larger than others , and that the curved part of the outer lip appeared thicker , when sawed open , than the other parts of the shell ; I began to think , that the animal , instead of enlarging the inner dimensions , was employed in thickening the outer wall , to guard against injuries and accidents , so common to the inhabitants of that turbulent element the sea .
I was the more confirmed in these sentiments by seeing the beautiful spots , with which this animal decorates its house , covered by other spots of different colour and size , as new laminae were added to strengthen the last-formed convolution .
It is really matter of admiration to see how these shells are adorned and variegated ; the exquisite polish , which covers the whole infinitely surpassing the skill even of the most accomplished human artist .
These new coverings or laminae , which are carried from the lips , terminate in the middle of the back part of the shell ; and there form a list , or seam , of a quite different colour from that of the other part of the shell , and of an unequal surface .
This very circumstance gave birth to my sentiments concerning the formation of the Belemnite : for whoever considers the seam or sulcus in the Belemnite , will , I think , conclude with me , that the outward lamina is formed latest , as in the cowree , and that the seam or sulcus is caused by the several additional coverings or laminae terminating there .
But as the anatomist makes fresh discoveries by dissecting the subject , so ( if I may be allowed the comparison ) I received farther information by luckily meeting with a Belemnite , whose laminae were in a manner dissected and laid open by the vague acid , or some other corroding menstruum , which every where pervades the earth , destroying some bodies [ o ] , and forming others [ p ] .
The laminae of this truly wonderful body are here exposed to view [ q ] , and plainly show us , that nature , in this , as in all her works , pursues the most simple , easy , and shortest methods , though they appear ever so intricate and interwoven .
This specimen will , I hope , serve to explain a matter , which hath so long puzzled the curious in natural history ; and convince us , that there is nothing more wonderful in the formation of the Belemnite , than in that of a cockle , oyster , or any other testaceous substance ; with this difference only , the oyster strengthens its shell , and excludes its first habitation , by additional laminae formed within ; the Belemnite encloses its dwelling by adding new laminae without .
Figure X. represents the Belemnite split up the middle , with the siphunculus in the front : a , b exhibit the first formed cell , or seat of the animal ab ovo .
As the animal grows larger , it forms a second cell or chamber b to c , at the same time covers the first cell , by forming the appendage or guard c , i , which is the first stage of the Belemnite .
In forming the third cell c , d , fresh laminae or coverings are carried on from d , to k ; and so of the rest , e , f , g , h ; or l , m , n , o. When we have duly considered the manner , in which the shell is [ o ] All calcareous substances .
[ p ] Such as selenites , pyrites , marcasites , talk , gypsum , &amp;c. [ q ] Fig. 9 .
thus formed ; it will be no difficult task to account for the different sections and broken parts of the Belemnite ; and in what manner they were reduced to the several forms or appearances , in which we commonly find them .
The better to illustrate my conjecture , I shall first exhibit some drawings , which show the several specimens broken and imperfect ; and then propose my sentiments concerning them before they were deserted by their inhabitants .
Figure 6 .
shows the spine of the echinus ovarius broken obliquely , as is common to all of them .
Figure 5 .
exhibits the inward structure of the Belemnite , when broken horizontally , with the central rays .
Figure xi .
is the same Belemnite split through its axis .
Figure xii , and xiii , are broken in the same direction as Fig. 5 .
and xi , and show how the several laminae [ r ] are placed one over another in the manner , in which it is formed .
Fig. xiv .
shows the Belemnite in the most perfect state we ever find it .
Fig. 4 .
is the fusiform Belemnite found in chalk , which has been often taken for a spine .
a , which is the termination of the conical cavity , has been thought to be the socket of the spine , which receives the papilla , when growing to the echinus ; but , when compared with the socket of the true spine [ s ] , we find it widely different .
The pricked lines b , c. b , c. show what the fusiform Belemnite was , when perfect , with the alveolus d , e. Many of [ r ] These distinctions of the laminae I presume to be owing to the mineral steams insinuating themselves into the Belemnite , when the spar pervaded the pores , and destroyed the texture , but retained the true form by substituting its self , and filling the Plasm or mould of the Belemnite .
[ s ] Fig. 6 .
b. those found in chalk seem to be somewhat injured at the end a , where they are deficient , and are rounded , but have an uneven surface , as if they had been gnawed or eaten by the pholas .
Those found in clay near Piddington [ t ] , Oxfordshire , approach nearer to the fusiform kind , and have a different appearance at the smaller end f , where the laminae are reduced to a white impalpable powder , by corrosive juices in the earth , so as to stain the fingers when first taken out ; and they afterwards retain a white chalky appearance : but , amongst a great number , I never found one that was three inches long .
These have suffered in the same manner as Fig. iv .
Fig. 3 .
f , shows where the alveolus terminates : g , h. g , h. how much has been destroyed by vitriolic acids [ u ] .
At Stons-field they are found much longer than at Piddington , and are enclosed in stone , which is split by the workmen to make slates .
Here we often find [ t ] Fig. 3 .
[ u ] It may be asked , why one part suffers more than another , as all parts are homogeneous , and free from extraneous mixtures ?
My answer is ; because those parts , where the concamerated shell is lodged , are much thinner than the other parts of the Belemnite ; and consequently the walls are more easily broken down , and the alveolus , being still less solid , is sooner destroyed , and reduced to an impalpable powder , by vitrolic and other acids , which the water takes up as it passes through different strata , abounding more or less with pyritical matter .
Where no spar follows the acid , the parts are carried away and lost in the interstices of the earth , and a mould or plasm is left , which Steno calls an aerial shell .
See his Prodomus , page .
84 .
But where the spar abounds , it pervades the whole substance , fills up the cavity , and assumes the true form of the shell ; and sometimes , by bursting the pores , is so far substituted in the place of the original particles , that the several diaphragms , with the siphunculus of the alveolus , are acurately and nicely preserved .
them in a much more perfect state [ w ] than the former , with the alveolus in many of them ; but that part is commonly crushed [ x ] by the incumbent matter .
The siphunculus of the Belemnite is always upon the verge of the chamber , or cell ; and in the siphunculus is a little gut or ductus , proceeding from the body of the animal , by dilating or contracting of which the animal , it should seem , may go out or into its cell at pleasure .
This is the only stay , which the animal has to secure its retreat : but I cannot agree with the learned doctor Hooke [ z ] , that the gut or ductus passes through all the cells to the end of the spiral cone , either in this shell or the nautilus .
His discovering of a spiramentum in the center of the latter was merely conjectural ; for the ends of the spiral cone of concamerated shells [ a ] are shut up in the same manner with those of the turbinated kind : and it is common for all turbinated shell-fish , as they increase in bulk , and enlarge their shells , to leave their bottom or first-formed convolutions .
Therefore I make no doubt but the same is done by the concamerated tribe ; for if the gut go through only one or two valves , it will be a sufficient stay to the animal , and , being contracted or dilated , will serve all the purposes above mentioned .
How far this is practicable by our little inhabitant , cannot absolutely be determined ; but if it be constantly fixed by the gut to the siphunculus , it has a surprising power of contracting and dilating its body , to extend so far as the bottom or point of the Belemnite , [ w ] Fig. 2 .
[ x ] Ibid. at y. [ z ] Hooke 's posthumous works published by Derham 8~ .
p. 306 .
[ a ] See the little pearly cornu-ammonis shell .
which in some is more than thirty times the length of the cell , into which it returns [ b ] .
I am apt to think , that this gut or ductus , as well as the body of the creature , is capable of being extended very considerably , to serve all the uses of forming the Belemnite , without leaving the siphunculus ; and that the gut serves for the same purposes with the tendons of the oyster ; the latter to open and shut the shell ; the former to allow the animal to go out and in at pleasure .
And as the oister feeds altogether in the shell , by opening the verge , the Belemnite ( whose residence is in the great deep , which is seldom disturbed ) very likely goes out in quest of food , but travels only upon the guard or rampart , leaving a trail behind , as all land snails do ; which hardening into a testaceous substance , increases the dimensions of the outer walls , both in length and thickness , from the cell or chamber , to the bottom or point of the whole Belemnite .
The animal in its progress and return clasps the whole guard , as a snail does a small branch of a tree in the gardens ; and where the two sides meet , there the sulcus is formed , as is evident from the laminae in Fig. 9 .
The Belemnites , like all other testaceous bodies , have the vermicular tribe attached to them , and are perforated by the pholades .
Other marine bodies also affix themselves to the Belemnites , oisters in particular : but this never happens whilst the animal inhabits the shell , because the new additional laminae would so cover the affixed body , and also the cells of the pholades and vermiculi , that they could have no communication with the water , and must consequently [ b ] Fig. 8 .
perish .
These bodies , thus attached , are the strongest proof we can desire , that the Belemnite is of marine production .
Indeed it may be objected , that the bones of quadrupeds , wood , and stone have these bodies adhering to them , and therefore may be said to be marine , as well as the Belemnite .
But when we bring them to chemical trial , the objection vanishes ; for the bones either come out of the furnace with a black core , or they are reduced to ashes ; whereas the Belemnite is changed into a fine calx , after the manner of all testaceous bodies , and is converted into a species of phosphorus [ c ] .
The oisters , having no loco-motion , frequently affix themselves to other bodies , that they may be better able to stem the tides , and currents , which might otherwise carry them from their proper beds , and places of feeding .
This attachment to other bodies no way incommodes them , because they increase the dimensions of their shells by adding fresh laminae inwardly : the first formed laminae , being , as it were , excluded , lie in the manner of tiles upon the roof of a house , and exhibit the several steps or stages of their growth .
I believe a Belemnite is very rarely found perfect in the fossil state : those in gravel-beds [ d ] have suffered very much by being rubbed against stones , &amp;c. by the fluctuating waters : those , which we find in rubble at Garsington-pitts [ e ] , have many adventitious bodies adhering to them , and consequently were deserted by [ c ] The Belemnite aster calcination , has all the properties of the Bolognian stone .
If it be exposed a few minutes to the Sun , and immed ately taken into a dark room , it will shine like Phosphorus for some time ; and when the light diminishes , if again exposed to the Sun , its splendor will be renewed .
[ d ] Fig xv .
[ e ] Fig. xvi .
their inhabitants before they rested there .
In the clay at Shotover [ f ] near Oxford , they have a curious smooth surface , but are otherwise imperfect : at Stonsfield , in the slate-stone , they are generally crushed [ g ] : those approaching nearest to perfection , which I have seen , came out of the sand [ h ] , under the bed of stone at Garsington-pitts near Oxford : the outer part is quite perfect , and the verge of the conical cavity is as thin as paper , but the alveolus is destroyed , except the apex or point .
At Thame , in digging for stone , several small ones were found in a stratum of blue clay of a more cylindrical form [ i ] ; some of which have the pearly substance still remaining ; an incontestable proof of their being marine productions .
How much of the cavity is occupied by the alveolus , cannot be truly ascertained , until a perfect one can be found , which it will be hard to do in the fossil-state ; but if we may judge from the nautilus , the walls are carried to a distance from the last formed valve , much greater than that , at which the valves are placed from each other ; as in fig. xiii .
from a , to b , which gives the animal all the convenience of forming a new valve or diaphragm , c. This circumstance has been very ingeniously cleared up by a learned physician in one of our monthly papers [ k ] .
The recent nautili are very common in the eastern seas ; and in the fossil state are frequently found with the Belemnites at Garsington near Oxford .
Why may we not therefore expect to find a recent Belemnite , [ f ] Fig. i. [ g ] Fig. 2 .
y. [ h ] Fig. xiii .
[ i ] Fig. xvii .
[ k ] Gent .
Magazine for Jan. 1752 .
page .
8 .
as well as a recent nautilus , if a diligent person were strictly to examine the coasts , where the nautili are found ?
Persons commissioned to collect shells , and other curiosities , generally grasp at such things as feast the eye ; not regarding those of less beauty and lustre , which would help us in our researches , and greatly illustrate the more useful parts of this study .
A premium , offered by a Society of Vertuosi , might encourage our sea-faring gentlemen to search the several coasts , upon which they touch in their long voyages , and to use drag-nets as they do in drudging for oisters : from such assistance , variety of new subjects would be produced ; and great improvements might be expected , if their inquiries should be successful .

