IV .
Of the Moon 's Distance and Parallax : A Letter to Andrew Reid , Esq ; from P. Murdoch , D. D. and F. R. S. 12 Nov. 1763 .
SIR , I Have at your desire wrote out what I was mentioning to you in our last conversation ; of an easy rule for determining the Moon 's distance , from the received theory of central forces : which I wish may merit your approbation : it will at least serve as a testimony of the esteem and regard with which I am , &amp;c. Read Jan. 26 , 1764 .
I. Sir Isaac Newton investigated the law of gravitation , in the duplicate ratio of the distance of the central body inversely , from the following data .
1 .
The length of a simple pendulum which vibrates in one second of time , gave him , by Huygens ' theorem , a determinate measure of the force of gravity , at the place of observation .
And , by his own theory , he could thence infer the like measure for any other place , of a given latitude * .
2 .
The Earth 's semidiameter was computed from the Abbe Picard 's measure of a degree of the terrestrial meridian .
* See one of the Essays prefixed to Busching 's Geography .
3 .
The Moon 's parallax , as determined by the most skilful astronomers , gave him the Moon 's distance in semidiameters of the Earth .
4 .
The time of a periodical month gave him the ratio of the versed sine of the arc of the Moon 's orbit which she describes in one second , to the radius .
And from these his conclusion was ; that the gravitation at the Earth 's surface , being diminished as the square of the distance from the Earth 's centre increases , would , at the distance of the Moon , produce a fall from rest , in one second , precisely equal to that versed sine .
Or , that the gravitation of the Moon toward the Earth , being increased as the square of that distance is diminished , would , at the Earth 's surface , be of the same quantity as that of falling bodies is ( by the experiment of the pendulum ) actually found to be .
II .
But the law of gravitation , thus deduced , being found to hold universally , and reciprocally , amongst all the great bodies of our system , so that even the minute anomalies of their motions are explained from it ; we may now assume it as given , and make the Moon 's distance the quantity sought .
Thus , writing F for the number of feet which a body falling from rest , describes , in vacuo , at the equator , in one second , V for the versed sine of the arc of the moon 's orbit described in the same time , to the radius unity , D for the semidiameter of the equator in feet , and the ratio of the distance of the centers of the earth and Moon , to the semidiameter of the earth , that of X to 1 : We shall have , by the general law , the Moon 's fall in 1~ , equal to F/ X2 ; but the same fall is equal to V~D~ X ; whence X3 = F/ V ~ D ' and X= 3~ F/ V ~D is the distance sought , in semidiameters of the equator .
Now a simple pendulum which beats seconds , measuring , at London , 39.126 inches ; if the usual allowance is made for the weight of the air , and for the Newtonian figure of the Earth * , the weight ( 1/ 2 8 9 ) taken off by the centrifugal force being likewise restored , a second-pendulum at the equator would be 39.154 inches long .
And , by Huygens ' rule , half this length is to the initial fall in one second , in the duplicate ratio of the diameter of a circle to it 's circumference : that fall therefore , at the equator , and in vacuo , is 16.10185 feet ; the logarithm of which number is 1.2068645 = log .
F. The toises in a degree of the equator , or , which is the same , in a degree of the meridian at lat. 543/ 4 , being nearly 57200 , the logarithm of the number of feet English in the semidiameter of the equator , that is log .
D will be nearly 7.3211900 , And the log.versed sine of the Moon 's 12.5492882 , arc in 1~ , being Their Sum 5.8704782 taken from log .
F , leaves + 5.3363863 , a third of which is 1.7787954 , the logarithm of X= 60.08906 semidiameters of the equator .
* See the Essay quoted above .
And the arithmetical complement of this last logarithm , which is 2~2212046 , is the log~ tangent of the Moon 's mean horizontal parallax at the equator ; which therefore , is 57~ 12~ , 34 .
III .
Such would be the distance of the Earth 's and Moon 's centers , were the Earth immovable : but it is somewhat increased by their revolution round their common centre of gravity .
Writing x+1 for that distance , divided by the centre of gravity in the ratio of x to 1 ; imagine a sphere of the same dimensions as our earth , placed at that centre , to exert the same attractive force on the Moon as our Earth actually does , the periodic time remaining unaltered : then must the density of this sphere be diminished in the ratio of x2 to x+ 1~2 , that its nearer distance from the Moon may be compensated by the defect of density and attractive force .
If now an inhabitant of the fictitious earth were supposed to compute its distance from the Moon , in the manner just now shown ; the quantities V and D would be the same as in the former calculation ; but his f would be to our F , as x2 to x+ 12 , and thence , his x would be to our X as x2/ 3 to x+ 1~ , that is , x= x/ x +1 2/ 3 ~ X. This is the distance from the fictitious Earth , or from the common centre of gravity ; but ( T ) the distance from our Earth , is x+ 1/ x ~ x/ x + 1~2/ 3 ~ X , greater , as was supposed , in the ratio of x+1 to x ; that is , T= x/ x + 1~-1 ~ x/ x + 1~-2/ 3 ~X= x/ x + 1~-1/ 3 ~X= 3~ x+ 1/ x ~ X. Sir Isaac Newton , from the phenomenon of the tides , estimated the ratio of x+1 to x to be that of 40.788 to 39.788 .
In that case , the cubic root of x+ 1/ x will have for its logarithm 0.0035934 ; which added to 1.7787954 , the logarithm of X computed for an immovable earth , gives 1.7823888 , the logarithm of 60.5883 semidiameters of the equator .
And the Moon 's horizontal parallax , for this distance , is 56~ 44~,07 .
IV .
On the other hand , if we had observations of the Moon 's parallax ( and distance ) which could be reckoned exact enough for the purpose , we might thence determine the ratio of x to 1 , that is , the ratio of the quantities of matter in the Earth and Moon .
For having T/ X = 3~ x+ 1/ x , and T 3/ X 3=x+ 1/ x ; likewise T being given from observation , and X computed as above ; it is manifest that the ratio of x+1 to x , and , by division , that of x to 1 , or of the mass of the earth to that of the Moon , is given .
For example , if it should be concluded from good observations , that T , the Moon 's mean distance , is 601/ 2 semidiameters of the equator ; for the logarithm of this distance , which is 1.7817554 , take the logarithm of X , or 1.7787954 , thrice the remainder will be 0.00888 , the logarithm of x+ 1/ x = 1.02066 ; and the masses of the Earth and Moon would , on this supposition , be as 48.4027 to 1 .
In all this , a small variation from the law of attraction , arising from the spheroid-figure of the earth , is neglected as inconsiderable ; which it will be found to be by whoever takes the trouble to compute its quantity and effects .
REMARK S. 1 .
If F and D were taken of their just quantities , the Moon 's horizontal parallax for an immovable Earth being , at the equator , 57~ 121/ 3~ , is a limit which the true mean parallax cannot exceed : and the correspondent distance 60.08906 is a limit which the distance cannot fall short of : both being computed upon the supposition that x+1= x , or that the matter of the Moon is as nothing in comparison of the Earth .
Nor can the parallax and distance be supposed to lye very near these limits , without leaving too little attractive force in the Moon to raise the tides .
2 .
If the Moon 's mean apparent semidiameter is 15~ 381/ 4~ , and the distance of the centers 60.5883 semidiameters of the equator , according to Sir Isaac 's estimate of the masses ; the semidiameter of the Moon will be 0.275601 parts of the semidiameter of the equator , or.2763 of a mean semidiameter of the Earth .
And the magnitudes of the Moon and Earth being as the cubes of their semidiameters , if the inverse ratio of their magnitudes is joined to the direct ratio of their masses ( 1 to 39.788 ) the sum will be the ratio of their densities , that of 1.19143 to 1 , a little less than 6 to 5 .
3 .
Supposing still the same semidiameter of the orbit as before , the force of gravity will be to the Earth 's attractive force on the Moon as 3670.94 to 1 , and to the Moon 's force on the Earth as 40.788 times that number , or 149730.4 , to 1 .
Again , the sorce of the Moon upon that surface of the ocean to which she is vertical , being to her force on the Earth 's centre , as the square of 60.5883 to that of 59.5883 ; and the difference of these squares being to the latter as 1 to 29.54623 , this difference of the forces will support the weight of one 4423968th part of the water at the vertex .
And , because the Earth 's semidiameter is small in comparison to the Moon 's distance , the like differences of force will decrease from the surface to the centre , nearly in an arithmetical progression , as the weight of the water does ; making the case analogous to the diminution of gravity by centrifugal force .
But it is likewise easily shown , that half this quantity of lunar force exerts itself to depress the waters all around at the distance of 90 degrees from the vertex ; 3/ 2 therefore of the former fraction , that is one 2949312 part of the force of gravity , will be the total cause of the difference in heigth of the flood and ebb , in an open and boundless ocean .
Say therefore , if ( in determining the figure of the earth ) 1/ 2 89 of gravity , suspended by the centrifugal force , gave , for the difference of diameters 1/ ~ 3 1 , what will one 2949312 part give ?
and the answer , in feet , will be 8.887 .
I NDE X. Wilson , B. F. R. S. his letter on the effects of lightning , p. 247 .
Winthrop , John , Esquire , his account of several fiery meteors seen in North America , p. 185 .
His letter concerning the longitude , 277 .
His thoughts on the equation of the time of noon , 278 .
His account of the transit of Venus , 6 June 1761 , 279 .
Wires parallactic , their uses in observing the horary parallaxes of the moon , 371 .
THEENDOFVO L. LIV .
4 .
In like manner , if we take 8~/ 3/ 4 for the Sun 's parallax , and , thence , his distance from the Earth 23468,6 semidiameters of the equator , we shall find that his whole force to produce a difference of Flood and Ebb , is to his force at the Earth 's centre , as 1 to 78232/ 3 .
But the Sun 's distance being to the radius of the Moon 's orbit as 387.34535 to unity , this last force will be to that of the Earth on the Moon , as 387,34535 to 178.7234 ( by cor .
2 .
prop. princip .
1 .
) And the Earth 's force on the Moon is to gravity as 1 to the square of 60 5883 ; whence , adding these ratios , the Sun 's force to move the sea will be to the force of gravity as the fraction whose logarithm is 8.1778026 to 1 ; or gravity is to that force as 13249445 to unity .
And therefore , by the same analogy as above , we find the difference of Flow and Ebb , from the Sun alone , to be 1.97824 ; one foot 113/ 4 inches .
The solar force therefore , in raising the tides , is to the lunar , as 1 to 4.4924 , in a ratio somewhat less than that computed by Sir Isaac .
The ratio likewise of the sum of the forces to their difference is but 7.869 to 5 , instead of 9 to 5 , which he assumes from comparing the spring and neap-tides at Bristol .
And it is indeed surprising , how he could , from that datum , arrive at conclusions so near the truth , as his very probably are .
He tells us he used the ratio of 9 to 5 , only till a more certain could be procured , And therefore the foreign mathematicians , who have censured him on that head , and on some other articles of this doctrine , might have spared their reflexions ; at least till they could show that their own deductions were more agreeable to nature and observation .
6 .
Unity representing the force of gravity , d the Sun 's distance , the Earth 's force on the Sun will be 1/ d2 , or the fraction whose logarithm is 9.259021.8 .
And the solar force on the Earth is ( from the numbers in remark 4 ) to the force of gravity as 1 to 1673.1 : whence the attractive forces ( and masses ) of the Sun and Earth will be as 325172,3 to 1 .
Add to this the inverse ratio of their magnitudes , collected from the Sun 's mean apparent semidiameter 16~.6~ , and the parallax 8~4/ 5 ; and the density of the Sun will be to that of the Earth , as 1 to 4.068 .
All this upon the supposition that the masses of the Earth and Moon are as 39.788 and 1 .
Hereafter , when the Moon 's distance shall be more certainly known , that element may be corrected , and the operations repeated .
As to the Sun 's parallax 8~ 4/ 5 , it cannot be much affected by any future determination of the Moon 's distance .
Nor is it here assumed of that quantity , at random ; but from a theorem deduced from the established principles .
I am , however , too diffident of myself to communicate it at present : because , altho ' it agrees very well with Mr. Short 's conclusion from the Transit of Venus , it differs considerably from that which a very learned and justly celebrated author hath lately published .
Note , The periods , as assumed in this paper , are ; a sidereal year of 365.2563923 days ; the periodical month 27.32165835 days .

