XXXI .
A Letter from the Prince de Croy to the Earl of Morton , President of the R. S. containing the Observations of the Eclipses of the Sun of the 16th of August 1765 , and of the 5th of August 1766 , made at Calais , together with some Remarks on the first of these Eclipses : Translated from the French , by Matthew Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. Calais , August 9 , 1766 .
My Lord , I Have the honour to send your lordship , according to your desire , the curious observation , which I made of the eclipse of last year ; and likewise enclose with it the observation we just now have been making , and which , though less curious , ( because this part of the moon has neither pits nor mountains ) , confirms the former with regard to the height of the cusps , or that small elevation which is seen against the sun 's cusps .
I do not send the figure of the latter , because it is nearly the same thing , excepting that it was , as you know , towards the lower part of the sun .
I think I have seen enough to conclude , that the atmosphere of the moon extends to at least double the height of the highest mountains 4 in Read Nov. 27 , in it , and that it has some dry cavities , which sink below the disk .
These two remarks , having been thought curious by Mr. Le Monier , and Mr. Cassiny , I have taken the liberty to communicate them to you ; and have the honour to be , My Lord , Your Lordship 's most obedient humble Servant , Le Prince de Croy .
Observation of the ~ of the Sun , of the 16th of August 1765 , at Calais , near the Steeple , in the same Place , where the central and annular Eclipse was observed .
Beginning 3h 50~ 46~ * End 58 171/ 2 The duration , of which Iam very certain 1 17 311/ 2 The greatest magnitude was of 2dig .
50min .
The points of ingress and egress are marked as they appeared to us in the three refracting telescopes , two of which had very nice micrometers , and in the large * This might have happened 1~ sooner , viz. at 45~ , on account of the uncertainty of the ingress .
I , however , think the former determination just , because I , at that instant , was pointing with the great refractor towards the spot , where the moon entered , and I was struck with the suddenness of the ingress of the penumbra .
refractor .
These , as well as the size of the cusps and the number of digits , were verified by Mr. de Fourcroy , chief engineer , who was so good as to assist us , and by Mr. Mouron , who assisted Mr. Blondeau in the observation of the annular eclipse .
There appeared hardly any sign of an atmosphere , except against the cusps of the sun , which seemed something bigger at the two sides , which touched the moon .
There is no indication of one any where else , unless that the disk seems not so well defined at the ingress and egress .
These two remarks would induce me to believe there is a small atmosphere ; and this is the subject of a separate memoir .
I saw very distinctly with the reflector of 4 feet 3 inches ( which answers a common telescope of 70 or 80 feet ) and with the acromatic telescope , several mountains , and particularly five , which I have delineated ( see TAB. XII ) , besides some inequalities .
I always saw them in their fixed places , whatever motion was given to the telescope .
No 1 .
Emerged from the sun 's left limb or cusp at 4h 32~ 6~ 2 .
4 35 18 3 .
4 38 6 These seemed to have their summits at about an equal distance from one another .
The mountain No. 4 .
which was the highest and well defined , made its exit at 4h 45~ 0~ ; it was accompanied with a smaller but well defined one a little on the left .
On the right hand several inequalities remained ; but the right limb of the moon had none , and was smooth and perfectly well defined .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LVI : TAB XII.* p. 264 .
We all four very well saw these mountains , and we certify their existence .
The three first seemed to have hollows between them , which penetrate a little into the moon ; all the rest projected out of the disc .
The clock was verified by the meridian the six following days .
The whole is referred to the meridian and point of Calais ; and it appears that the time marked for the new moon of that day requires a rectification .
Signed , Prince de Croy , De Fourcroy , chief Engineer , Granier , Engineer : Mouron~ Remarks on the Eclipse of the 16th of August 1765 at Calais , with regard to the Atmosphere , and the Mountains seen in profile .
The Atmosphere .
Upon mature consideration , I think the moon 's atmosphere perceptible , see Fig. 1 .
1 .
Because the two small elevations , which I constantly saw of the sun 's limb , towards the cusps , is easily distinguished in the large telescope , through which the other parts appeared very exactly defined .
It is true that the sun appears equally bright at the place of this small elevation , but the atmosphere cannot affect its brightness , and can only somewhat raise the rays , which pervade or slide over a denser medium .
2 .
Because this elevation is gradual , rising higher towards the moon , according to the degree of the density of its atmosphere .
3 .
Because this elevation of the sun against the cusps seemed to me a little higher than the mountain No. 4 .
which jetted out the most on a side view .
4 .
Because the penumbra , which I observed at the ingress and egress , and which certainly is much less defined than towards the middle , is very probably occasioned by the mixture of the rays , which are refracted in passing through the lunar atmosphere .
This appears to me more likely than that it should be caused by the inflexion of the light , from the globe of the moon ; because such inflected light sliding upon the globe ought rather to lessen its dark limb ; whereas , on the contrary , the penumbra , which was sufficiently thick , served , as we all observed , to enlarge that limb .
That the telescope was clear , appeared from the spots of the sun appearing exactly defined .
A parcel of these was seen somewhat below the middle on the right , and above it on the left .
The Mountains .
The most surprising circumstance to me , as I observed to the gentlemen present , and made a sketch of , after half an hour 's continual attention , was that of the mountains seen in profile , and perfectly well defined ; No. 4 .
in particular with the small elevation on the left , had several inequalities and protuberances , which I have drawn exactly enough , though with a pencil not sufficiently sharp ; I could have been more correct as to particulars , had I had a drawing pen * .
* Mr. Short told me in the month of July 1766 , in London , that he had had a side view of these mountains with his telescopes of 8 and 12 feet .
The three summits of No. 1 , 2 , and 3 , were very distinct , and especially the hollows between them , surprising on account of their depth , for they made cavities within the circle of the disc .
I am no longer astonished at the luminous points , which are seen starting from the crescent ; but I wonder that no notice should hitherto have been taken of these mountains seen sideways in the eclipses of the sun : a four feet telescope well fixed is necessary to observe them distinctly .
Large refracting telescopes cannot serve for that purpose , as it is difficult to prevent entirely their shaking .
Happily we had none of them ; the air was clear , the wind to the north , and I often made the eclipse move from the top to the bottom of the field of the telescope , in order to see whether any spots in the glass did occasion this phenomenon .
But the indentings were still the same , and equally well defined ; and when their place was known , they were likewise seen through the other telescopes .
It is only by sight that I have marked the place and distances of these mountains , as the great telescope had no wires ; but , to remedy this inconveniency , I exactly observed the instant of the egress of the four chief eminences , whence their position might be ascertained : it may be , this side of the moon is one of the least mountainous parts .
In delineating the mountain , No. 4 , whose figure was so exactly desined , I thought of the atmosphere ; but no trace of that is seen in that case .
This , however , in my opinion , does not afford a sufficient reason for den~ ing it , because the atmosphere , in that position , must be , on all sides , pervaded by the solar rays , which must render it invisible to our sight .
It is therefore only against the cusps , and that at the ingress and egress , that this atmosphere is to be searched for , with very large instruments , and sufficiently well fixed .
Prince de Croy .
N. B. I am inclined to believe , that there is no water in the moon , for the two cavities , which penetrated within the disk continued concave to the bottom , whereas if there had been there any water , the bottom ought to have been convex .
The mountains in the moon must be very high and hollow ; and that is the reason of their white circle .
If ever Tycho could be seen edge ways , it would make a beautiful appearance .

