Received January 3 , 1766 .
VIII .
A Letter from Edward Wortley Montagu , Esquire , F. R. S. to William Watson , M. D. F. R. S. containing an Account of his Journey from Cairo , in Egypt , to the Written Mountains , in the Desert of Sinai .
SIR , IT is with a good deal of difficulty that I have prevailed upon myself to write to you , for , as coming now to Italy was quite unforeseen , and I am immediately going back to the East , I have not my journal with me , but luckily have the famous inscriptions .
I am sensible every paper I send to the Royal Society exposes more and more my incapacity .
However , as these inscriptions are much wanted , I cannot avoid sending them .
I shall only speak to some of the points the bishop of Clogher mentions ; but cannot avoid being now and then a little prolix .
Read March 13 , 1766 .
I set out from Cairo , by the road known by the name of Tauriche Beni Israel , Road of the Children of Israel .
After twenty hours travelling , at about three miles an hour , we passed , by an opening in the mountains on our right hand , the mountains Maxattee .
There are two more roads , one to the northward of this , which the Mecca pilgrims go , and one to the south , between the mountains , but never travelled ( as it does not lead to Suez , to which it is thirty hours march from Cairo ) .
Through this breach the children of Israel are said to have entered the mountains , and not to have taken the most southern road , which I think most probable : for those valleys , to judge by what one now sees , could not be passable for Pharaoh 's chariots .
This breach , the inhabitants told me , leads directly to a plain called Badeah , which in Arabic signifies something new and extraordinary , and also the beginning , as the beginning of every thing is new , i. e. was not before known .
At Suez I found an opportunity of going to Tor by sea , which I gladly embraced , that , by going nearer the place , at which the Israelites are supposed to have entered the golf , and having a view from the sea , as well of that as of the opposite shore , I might be a little better able to form a judgement about it .
Besides , I was willing to have the views , bearings , and soundings , which I took , and they will appear some time or other ; but this paper would scarce be their place , if I had them with me .
When we were opposite to Badeah , it seemed to me ( for I was not on shore ) a plain , capable of containing the Israelites , with a small elevation in the middle of it .
I saw something too like ruins .
The captain and pilots told me , that this was the place , where the Israelites entered the sea , and the ruins were those of a convent ( I suppose built on the spot in commemoration of the fact ) ; they added that there was good water there .
There is here a strong current , which sets to the opposite shore , about south east ; it forms by its strength a whirlpool , where sailors said ships were lost , if forced into it , for want of wind , by the current .
This pool is about six miles northward of Cape Karondel ; and just below this pool there is a sand , a flat island at low water , which runs east and west about three miles .
This sand , I suppose , is thrown up by the force of the current ; and the same current , by the resistance it meets with from this bank , being forced back into the cavity made by this excavation , forms the whirlpool .
This pool is called Birque Pharaone , the well , or pool of Pharaoh ; and here they affirm his host was destroyed .
I shall say more of this as I travel back by land .
We came to an anchor in fifteen fathom water , within a mile and a half of the shore , to the southward of this sand , and in the Birque Karondel , to the northward of the cape ; here the eastern shore is already mountainous , which , near this place , was a sandy beach : the Egyptian shore , from Suez to Badeah , is likewise rocky and steep ; so no entering upon the golf from that shore , but at Badeah or Suez .
It is high water always , when the moon is at her meridian height , and it ebbssix hours .
At Suez , it flows six foot ; the spring tides are nine , and in the variable months , from the beginning of November , to the end of April , sometimes twelve .
From the beginning of May to the beginning of October , a northerly wind generally rises , and goes down with the sun ; it is often very strong .
This wind never fails in these months , unless there be some violent storm ; the rest of the year the winds are variable , and when they blow hard at S. and S. S. E. these winds set up the sea through the narrow straight of Babel Mandel , and up this golf through its mouth , between Gebel El Zait , on the west side of this sea , and the southermost point of the bay of Tor , on the east side of this western branch of this sea , where it is not above twelve or fourteen miles over .
I suppose such a wind , hindering the water from going out , causes this extraordinary increase in the spring tides .
We see the same thing happen with the same winds at Venice , both golfs running nearly in the same direction .
The Egyptian , western , or Thebaic shore , from Badeah southward to opposite Tor , on the eastern shore , is all mountainous , and steep ; and at Elim , the northermost point of the bay of Tor , ends the ridge of mountains , which begin on the eastern shore of this western branch at Karondel .
I say nothing of Elim , or Tor , or the marine productions of this golf , as this paper is intended to give an account of Sharme , Meenah El Dzahab , Kadesh Barnea , the stone which Moses struck twice , and the inscriptions .
I , however , mustsay , that , from this place , mount Sinai , properly called , cannot be seen ; but only the ridge or group of mountains , in which it is , and which altogether form that part of this tongue of land called in general Mount Sinai .
The garden of the Monks of MountSinai at Elim renders in dates , &amp;c. 20.000 piastres per ann .
or ~ 2.500 .
We from thence crossed the plain , in about eight hours , and entered the mountains of Sinai .
They are of granite of different colours .
At the entrance of the narrow breach , through which we passed , I saw , on a large loose granite stone , an inscription in unknown characters , given , I think , by Dr. Pocock , bishop of Ossory ; however , as the Israelites had no writing , that we know of , when they passed here , I did not think it of consequence enough to stop for ; the Arabs told me , it was relative to a battle fought here between Arabs , and indeed I do not see what point of history it can illustrate ; besides , there are not above five or six words .
We arrived at the convent of Mount Sinai , after the usual difficulties mentioned by other travellers , were received as usual , and saw the usual places , of which , however , I shall give the plans as well as elevations , which I took .
I must say , that the Monks were far from owning to me , that they had ever meddled with the print of the foot of Mahomet 's camel .
I examined it narrowly , and no chisel has absolutely ever touched it , for the coat of the granite is entire and unbroke in every part ; and every body knows , that if the coat of less hard stones than granite is once destroyed , it never returns .
It is a most curious Lusus Naturae , and the Mahometans turn it to their use .
Meribah is indeed surprisingly striking .
I examined the lips of its mouths , and found that no chisel had ever worked there ; the channel is plainly worn by only the course of water , and the bare inspection of it is sufficient to convince any one it is not the work of man .
Amongst the innumerable cracks in rocks , which I have seen in this , as well as other parts of the world , I never met with any like this , except that at Jerusalem , and the two , which are in the rock Moses struck twice , of which hereafter .
I had enquired of the captain and the two pilots of our ship , about Sharme and Dzahab , on the western shore of the eastern branch of the Red-sea ; they told me that they were often forced up the Elanitic golf , the eastern branch of the Red-sea , and generally went to Sharme , and sometimes as high as Dzahab ; that they generally ran from Cape Mahomet , the southermost part of the peninsula between those two golfs , to Sharme , in six hours , because they always made as much more way , as they commonly do , they very seldom going there but in a storm : they generally run four knots , so this makes forty eight miles , which brings it to the northward of Tor .
Tor is in lat. 27 .
55 .
Cape Mahomet thirty miles southward , lat. 27 .
25 .
Sharme forty eight miles nearly N. lat. 28 .
13 .
consequently about E. N. E. of Sinai .
The port is pretty large , surrounded with high mountains , the entrance very narrow , and the water deep quite to the rocks , which are so very steep , that a stone dropped from the summit falls into the bason .
No wind can be felt here ; they do n't cast anchor , but fasten their cables to the rocks .
There is good water ; some habitations are found on the sides of the mountains , and a pretty large village at top : this seems to answer the idea of Nest-Ken .
Dzahab lies as high again up the golf , so forty eight miles more , or in lat. 29 .
This port is considerably larger than the former , and very good , but not so closely surrounded with mountains ; it is however , very safe .
There is a well of great antiquity with very good water ; very considerable ruins are found , and they say , there was a great city formerly ; but no habitations now , except an Arabian camp of 2000 men .
There is a road from it to Jerusalem , formerly much frequented .
Thus far the captain and pilots .
I enquired from the Monks , as well as Arabs , about these places , as well as about the ruins , supposed by my learned friend , the bishop of Ossory , to be Kadesh Barnea : the former could only tell me , they had not received any fish from thence in many years , that it was two easy days journey off , but the road was mountainous ; so one may suppose the distance less than forty miles .
The Arabs agreed as to the road ; but they said , it was once a large place , where their prince lived , whose daughter Moses married , that Moses was afterwards their prince , and the greatest of all prophets .
These Arabs place Moses the first , Salomon the second , Mahomet the third , Christ the fourth , and then the prophets of the Bible .
As to Dzahab , the Monks only knew the distance to be four days journey , and that there was a road from it to Jerusalem : the Arabs told me the same , so the distance is about eighty miles .
I enquired of them all about the ruins ; they told me there were very considerable ones about half way to Dzahab , about forty miles from Sinai ; but I should think Kadesh must have been much nearer to Jerusalem .
I would willingly have gone to these places ; but as the four clans of Arabs , which inhabit this promontory , were then at war one with the other , I could get no conductor .
In another journey I hope to be more lucky , for this is all hearsay ; however , combining the whole together , and comparing it with what we collect from Scripture , I think we may well conclude , Sharme to be Midian , and Meenah El Dzahab to be Eziongeber : what the interjacent ruins are I cannot conjecture ; but I believe I have found Kadesh Barnea to be elsewhere .
I think it cannot be here , for the Israelites were on the borders of the Holy Land , or Land of Promise , when they were ordered back ; and when they were stopped by the Moabites , they are said to have been brought up from Kadesh Barnea ; and I meet with no place in sacred sacred writing , or any ancient geographer , neither Strabo nor any other , that draw the line of division between this promontory and the Land of Promise so low down ; nor could they do it , as these ruins are within almost seventy miles of the extremity of it .
There are two roads from Mount Sinai to Jerusalem , the one through Pharan , the other by the way of Dzahab : that through Pharan is eleven days journey ; two to Pharan , three to a station of the Mecca Pilgrims called Scheich Ali , one and an half to some considerable ruins ; all this to the northward : from thence four and something more to Jerusalem , by way of Hebron , leaving the Asphaltic Lake on the right hand to the southeastward .
The other way is longer , on account of the road being more mountainous ; that too passes the same ruins , and also Scheich Ali .
I enquired about this , when I was at Jerusalem , and received the very same account , with this addition , that such Mahometans , as went from Jerusalem to Mecca , went that way , to join the Cairo caravan at Scheich Ali .
This seems to be a situation opposite to Kadesh Barnea ; at the line drawn by all the geographers ; it is without Mount Sinai ( taken for this whole tract ) ; and just before the Moabites , as the children of Israel passed by Mount Hor , now Acaba , leaving the Asphaltic Lake on their left hand , to the northwest .
The tradition too of the Arabs is , that they passed this way ; therefore , I think , Kadesh Barnea must be near this spot .
There are here considerable ruins ; and I know of no city that ever was here , for Petra lay more to the east , between the Asphaltic lake and the Elanitic golf .
To leave no enquiry wanting , I asked the Rabbins of Jerusalem , where they placed Kadesh Barnea ; and they said , these ruins .
We set out from Mount Sinai by the way of Scheich Salem ; and , after we had passed Mahomet 's stone , came to the beautiful valley , mentioned in the Journal .
I lay there ( and hope I have discovered the manna , but that will be the subject of another paper ) and did not set out before day-light , that I might not pass the rock which Moses struck twice .
I searched , and enquired of my Arabs , but could neither hear nor see any thing of it .
I saw several short inscriptions stained on some parts of the mountains , the characters being the same with those on mount Sinai , Meribah , &amp;c. given by the bishop of Ossory .
About four miles before we arrived at Pharan , we passed through a remarkable breach in a rock ; each side of it is perpendicular as a wall , about eighty feet high , and the breach is about forty broad .
It is at this breach , I imagine , the Horites were smote , four miles beyond the present ruins of Pharan ; for having passed this breach they could make a stand , nor could they well be pursued .
Here , on the tops of the mountains to our right hand , were ruins of buildings , and one seemed a castle .
From Meribah to near this place , we had always rather descended ; in most places there is the bed of a stream and after rain the water runs ; but a little before we came to this breach , it winded off towards the west , for the waters fall into that part of the desert we crossed from Tor .
Between this breach and Pharan , there are several springs , and one at Pharan where we encamped ; there is the bed of the river mentioned by the Journal , the traditional account of which agrees with what is said by St. Paul .
Waters seem to have run from Meribah to within about six miles of this place ; the bed of a stream is here again very plain and a spring at the upper upper end of it , which does not yield water enough to make a stream , the bed then is dry ; four valleys terminate here , and form a large area .
I enquired about the road to Jerusalem ; the people agreed in the distance and ruins .
We travelled in the bed of the river through the valley to the north ; and in about half an hour , the sight and appearance of a large stone , not unlike Meribah , which lay at some distance from the mountain on our right hand , struck me ; and I also observed , it had many small stones upon it .
The Arabs , when they have any stone or spot in veneration , as Mahomet 's stone , and the like , after their devotion , lay some smooth stone upon it .
I asked what it was , they told me Hagar Mousa , the stone of Moses .
I told them that could not be , for that lay in Rephidim ; they said that was true , but this was Hagar il Chotatain , the stone of the two strokes ; that he struck it twice , and more water came from it than from Meribah ; witness the river .
The bed of the river winds to the eastward , about E. S. E. I asked how far it went ; they said this bed ran by Sheich Ali to those ruins , and quite away to the sea ; so the river must have begun here , and not at Pharan , and the bed from Pharan here is only formed ( I suppose ) by winter torrents .
If this is the bed of the river mentioned by St. Paul , as I dare say it is , we have the second rock : if it runs to the ruins , as is said , and there is no reason to doubt it , they will be pretty plainly those of Kadesh Barnea ; and if this bed continues in the same course to the sea , as it probably does , this probably is the river at Rinocolura , supposed , by Eratosthenes , to be formed by the Arabian lakes ; because he did not know its miraculous head .
This river is doubted of by Strabo , because dried up to the source , from the time the Israelites entered the Land of Promise , and the tradition was then lost .
You may see Strabo 's Assyria , edit .
Casaubon , p. 5 .
10 .
towards the bottom .
Pardon this bold conjecture ; but it coincides and conciliates sacred history with ancient geography .
This too seems a proof , that this is really the second struck rock .
As to the springs between the breach and Pharan , they certainly did not exist in the time of Moses ; or , if they did , they would have been as nothing to so many people .
We went down a large valley to the west , towards the sea , and passed the head of a valley , a part of the desert of Sin , which separates the mountains of Pharan from those which run along the coast , and the same plain , which we had passed from Tor .
We had scarce entered these mountains , and travelled an hour , when after passing a mountain , where there were visible marks of an extinguished subterraneous fire , we saw , on our left hand , a small rock , with some unknown characters cut on it , not stained upon it , as those hitherto met with ; and , in ten minutes , we entered a valley six miles broad , running nearly North and South , with all the rocks , which enclose it on the West side , covered with characters .
These are what are called Gebel El Macaatab , the written mountins .
On examining these characters , I was greatly disappointed , in finding them every where interspersed with figures of men and beasts , which convinced me they were not written by the Israelites ; for if they had been after the publication of the law , Moses would not have permitted them to engrave images , so immediately after he had received the second commandment : if they went this way , and not along the coast , they had then no characters , that we know of , unless some of them were skilled in hieroglyphics , and these have no connection with them .
It will be difficult to guess what these inscriptions are ; and , I fear , if ever it is discovered , they will be found scarce worth the pains .
If conjecture be permitted , I will give my very weak thoughts .
They cannot have been written by Israelites , or Mahometans , for the above reason ; and if by Mahometans , they would have some resemblance to some sorts of Cuphic characters , which were the characters used in the Arabic language , before the introduction of the present Arabic letters .
The first MSS .
of the Alcoran were in Cuphic : there is a very fine one at Cairo , which I could not purchase , for it is in the principal Mosque ; and the Iman would not steal it for me , under four hundred sequins , ~ 200 .
These have not the least resemblance to them : Saracen characters are very unlike ; besides , I should place them higher than the Hegira .
I think it then not unprobable , that they were written in the first ages of Christianity , and perhaps the very first ; when , I suppose , pilgrimages from Jerusalem to Mount Sinai were fashionable , consequently frequent and numerous , by the new Christian Jews , who believed in Christ ; therefore , I should believe them Hebrew characters , used vulgarly by the Jews about the time of Christ .
I showed them when at Jerusalem to the Rabins ; they were of the same opinion , and thought ~ , which is frequent , was ~ ; and to that ~ , which is just before with a small cross ~~ ~ , by changing the shin into sin , and adding je , it would be an Arabic word ~ a cross , and might be explained , the cross borne or carried by Jesus .
The Hebrew would be Jesus brought safety , or salvation .
But , Sir , more able than me will judge better .
These are all conjectures ; and it seems much easier to say what these inscriptions are not , than what they are .
They can scarce be of St. Helen 's time ; for they would have some analogy with Greek characters , and they have none .
Perhaps some gentlemen will think them ancient Egyptian , written , by the colony , which they suppose went to inhabit China .
That is a matter I wo n't meddle with ; but , amongst many others , it will be liable to one great objection , which is , that such colony , if there ever was one , probably went the straight road , from the head of one golf to the head of the other , from Hierapolis to Eloth , the way the Mecca pilgrims now go .
This place would have been far out of their way , being at least sixty miles to the southward of the pilgrims road , unless they were supposed to have had transports at Dzahab , or Sharme .
I , for the first reason given , did not think them written by the Israelites , and could not conceive that they were of any great consequence .
I only took these few as a specimen .
Here are on other parts of this rock , some Greek , and Arabic , as well as some Saracen inscriptions , and an Hebrew one , which is ~ .
The Saracens and Arabic only say , such an one was here at such a time ' ' ; the same say the Greek ones , except one , which says , as I remember , for I have it not with me , ` ` The evil genius of the army wrote this , ' ' which can only prove , that some body of Greeks was worsted here , after the charactere were written , and that they attributed their defeat to some magic power in these characters : as we are now fruitful in conjecture , perhaps some gentlemen will bring Xenophon here .
The characters seem to be of the very same kind with those stained on different parts of Mount Sinai , Meribah , &amp;c. which my learned and accurate friend the Bishop of Ossory has given .
The third day from this place , travelling westward , we encamped at Sarondou , as the Journal calls it ; but it is Korondel , where are the bitter waters , Marah .
I tried if the branches of any of the trees had any effect on the waters ; but found none : so the effect mentioned in Scripture must have been miraculous .
These waters at the spring are somewhat bitter and brackish , but as every foot they run over the sand is covered with bituminous salts , grown up by the excessive heat of the sun , they acquire much saltness , and bitterness , and very soon become not potable .
This place , off which the ships casts anchor , is below the sand , which I mentioned before , near the Birque Korondel .
After nine hours and a half march we arrived , and encamped at the Desert of Shur , or Sour .
The constant tradition is , that the Israelites ascended from the sea here ; this is opposite to the plain Badeah , to which the abovementioned pass in the mountains lead .
From this place the openings in the mountains appear a great crack , and may be called a Mouth , taking Hiroth for an appellative .
However , I should rather adopt the signification of Liberty .
It would hardly have been necessary for the Israelites to pass the sea , if they were within two or three miles of the northern extremity of the golf ; the space of at most two miles , the breadth of of the golf at Suez , and at most three foot deep at low water , for it is then constantly waded over , could not have contained so many people , or drowned Pharaoh 's army .
There would have been little necessity for his cavalry and chariots to precipitate themselves after a number of people on foot , encumbered with their wives , children , and baggage ; when they could soon have overtaken them with going so little about .
These reasons , added to the significant names of the places , Tauriche Beni Israel , road of the children of Israel ; Attacah , Deliverance , Pihahiroth , whether an appellative or significative ; Badeah , new thing , or miracle ; Bachorel Polsum , sea of destruction ; convince me , that the Israelites entered the sea at Badeah , and no where else .
Besides , all the rest of the coast from Suez , and below Badeah , is steep rocks , so there must have been another miracle for them to descend : the current too sets from this place where we encamped , toward the opposite shore , into the pool Birque Pharaone , Pool of Pharaoh , where , the tradition is , his host was drowned : a current , formed , I suppose , by the falling and rushing of one watery wall on the other , and driving it down : a current , perhaps , by God permitted to remain ever since , in memoriam rei ; the distance to the bitter waters is about thirty miles .
I omitted to mention in its place , that , between this and Korondel , we were not so lucky as the author of the Journal , who met with a charming rivulet of sweet water ; we met with none , good or bad .
The Ain Mousa , which the Israelites would have met with , if they had passed at Suez , and the coast from hence southward , about a mile to Tor , being all rock and steep too , induce me to believe , that they entered ed the sea at Badeah , and ascended from it here , and not at any other place .
But I am too sensible of my own inability to decide , and leave that to better judges than I am .
I only throw out what occurs to me , from the inspection of the country , an inspection as accurate as I am capable of .
If any thing I have said can in the least support that revelation , to which I dare declare myself a friend , even in this enlightened age , I shall be very happy ; or if this trip of mine can be of any use whatever , as I had great pleasure in it , I may truly say with Horace-Omne tulit punctum , &amp;c. The denomination of ~ , I believe , only regards the Hierapolitic branch , as the marine productions , Madrepores , &amp;c. which form admirable forests in the bottom of it , are not in the Elanitic branch , or the golf ; I mean the broad part below Cape Mahomet .
No more than that western branch was known to the Israelites at the time of their passage , if it was to the Egyptians ; but the name descended to the whole , as their knowledge of it .
The Red Sea seems to regard the broad part alone ; for tho ' there are not the abovementioned sea productions , yet there is so great a quantity of tube coral ( not found in the western branch of the Hierapolitic golf ) and such rocks , as one may say of them , that the Gedda ships fasten themselves to them instead of casting anchor .
It is of a deep red , so that possibly , the first navigators entering at the straight of Babel Mandel , from the red they saw , called it the Red Sea , and that name descended to the whole with their navigation .
This sea is tempestuous and full of shoals ; there is no harbour on the Arabian coast after Tor , except one , I mean between Suez and Gidda or Mecca , which is a day and a half from Gidda .
Gidda is its port ; and there is only one on the other coast , Cossire ; but it is a very bad one ; however , ships sometimes go thither , and caravans cross the country to Morshout .
The ships are , as the bishop of Ossory has described them ; the helm is on the outside , as I suppose , with his lordship , that of St. Paul was .
They make use of but four sails , and no compass , nor do they ever cast the lead .
They sail only by day light , from anchoring place to anchoring place and are not , above two days out of sight of land , from Cape Mahomet to the Arabian main : if a gale happen , they are often lost ; about one in ten every year .
I shall be glad to be honoured with the Society 's command , and in communicating this , you will oblige , Sir , Your most humble servant , Ed. Wortley Mountagu .
Pisa , Dec. 2 , 1765 .
P. S. I am a very bad draughtsman ; but I assure you , the sketches contained in Plate III .
are rather better than the originals .
They are about six inches long , the marble is whitish , in some places reddish , of a flesh color ; they are engraved with a pointed instrument , for one sees , in the bottom of them , round marks of the point of the instrument .
I have met with much basalto , but not one piece of that soft stone of which is the bust at Turin , nor any of the characters upon it , except some are found amongst these , I have neither seen any head , bust , or statue , in the character of that .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LVI .
TAB. III .
p. 56 .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ The second rock struck by Moses is , I think , 43 feet long , 16 broad , 13 high ; it has two cracks , oblique ones ; in them are some mouths , like those of Meribah : it is of a hard stone , not granite or marble .
I have the exact dimensions and elevation of the second stone , as well as of Meribah .

