Received February 20 , 1766 .
VII .
Extract from Two Letters , dated December 7th and 12th , 1765 , from the Rev. Mr. William Borlase , of Ludgvan , in Cornwall , F. R. S. to Emanuel Mends da Costa , Librarian , &amp;c. to the Royal Society .
Dear Sir ; ON board the Spackman tin ship , I have sent a contribution to the fossil collection of the Royal Society , which I beg you will present with my duty and respects to that illustrious body ; it is Read March 5 , 1766 .
NATIVETI N , a rarity indeed !
and I shall not be easy till I hear it is safely lodged in your Museum , as it is the fairest specimen I have seen .
As the existence of Native Tin is absolutely denied by all mineralists both ancient and modern ; and at the time I wrote my Natural History of Cornwall , having no evidences before me to evince the contrary , I contented myself with suggesting , page 185 , that its existence was far from being improbable , and in that manner I left the dispute undecided .
But a late fortunate discovery , which has furnished me with three specimens of this metal native , or pure , will now exclude all further doubt .
The account of it is as follows .
In the month of May last was found near St. Austle , by some streamers , a large cake , or nodule , of tin ore , weighing about six pounds , irregular in shape , cracked or jagged at the edges , lying about five feet under the surface , and in the middle of that stratum of tin ore , so remarkably spread in the moor adjoining to the forementioned town ( vide Natural History of Cornwall , page 163 ) .
When the lump was broke , it appeared to consist of two coats , or incrustations , surrounding the whole , and of a nucleus or central substance of a quartz intermixed with the purest malleable tin .
The first specimen is now lodged in my desk of Cornish fossils at the Museum in Oxford .
The outmost crust was about 1/ 8 of an inch thick at a medium , and of a brownish straw color ; the second or inner coat was blacker , closer grained , with some faint appearances of whitish specks interspersed , and about 1/ 3 of an inch thick ; these two coats enclosed a third substance , consisting of laminated crystals , rising side by side out of an edging , which shines like melted tin , and lies as it were at their roots coherent to the second coat .
These crystalline laminae are thin almost as the flakes or scales of talc , and being shot in a great variety of directions intersect each other , and leave a vast number of cells , within which are plainly seen , and may be cut freely with a knife , many specks and granules of pure native tin .
The second specimen , which I have the honor to present to the Museum of the Royal Society , is of the same structure , and part of the above-described lump , but is much richer in quality .
It was sent me on the 12th of August last by Mr. Henry Rosewarne , of Truro , a gentleman well versed in the knowledge and fusion of metals .
Besides all the appearances of native tin taken notice of , in the former specimen , here , in this No 2 .
we see the malleable tin , in color equal to the finest tin of the furnace , more liberally and distinctly dispersed .
The metal is not only found in granules , but in a foliaceous manner issuing out of the quartz , and formed like a thick , jagged , or scolloped lace or edging , of which the specimen itself only can give the justest idea .
The lump , or nodule , of which these two specimens are fragments , was so richly impregnated with tin , that though the best tin ore , in general , will not melt without flux , nor do twenty pounds of black tin usually produce more than fourteen pounds of white , this melted without flux , and twenty ounces produced eighteen ounces of the purest tin .
The third specimen is as follows .
On the 17th of July last was found in a stream work near the borough of Granpont , and two days after brought to the abovementioned Mr. Henry Rosewarne , by Jonathan Crowle , tinner , another lump of the same kind of tin ore as the former ; it 's weight between eleven and twelve pounds ; the native tin was enclosed so securely , that , but for the extraordinary weight , it had passed unnoticed .
Within the crust , the metal was not in granules , as in the first specimen , nor thin as a leaf , as in the second ; but much more abundant , and in some places more than one inch thick ; but unfortunately the person employed to discover the contents , injudiciously broke the outward crust all to pieces , by which means he got all the pure metal indeed , but prevented that absolute conviction , which this noble specimen would otherwise have conveyed to the doubtful .
However , the like structure of the crust , and that of the before-mentioned specimens , and its connexion , to some fragments still in the keeping of Mr. Rosewarne , with the granulated surface , and shotten edge , of the metal , pronounce it , upon comparison , to be native tin .
The crust , enclosing this third specimen , was certain stone of the quartz kind , very hard to break , and exactly the same , to all appearance , with that of the first mass .
I employed a tinner dextrous in vanning ( a way of breaking and trying ores , by washing them on a shovel gently with water ) to try it in his usual way ; he bruised it in my sight , and observed to his surprise , that it suffered no diminution , or decrease , as all other ores do ; that it was very rich in its kind ; that he had never seen any such before ; and that he could not say what metal it contained .
Thus far is the relation Mr. Borlase gives ; but as the existence of native tin is so universally doubted , I thought it necessary , that other proofs than a mere historical account , and the exhibition of only two specimens , and both from the same hand , should be produced to prove it .
Mineralists might then doubt whether what Mr. Borlase calls tin , was really that metal , or rather an arsenical marcasite , or other mi2 neral , neral , which might appear like , or be mistaken for , tin .
I thought it very necessary to remove all doubts , by making proper experiments to try if it was tin , before I presumed to communicate it to this learned body ; it being so extraordinary a discovery .
The experiments I made , and which , I hope , will prove satisfactory , to convince every one that it is really tin , are as follow , 1 .
It is perfectly ductile and malleable ; and , bent between the teeth , gives the same crackling noise as tin always does .
2 .
In an open fire it melts easily , calcines on the surface , and smokes somewhat ; forced in a stronger fire , with borax , it detonates with small phosphorescent sparks , which is a property of pure tin .
3 .
It is only corroded to a white calx in spirit of nitre , and oil of tartar per deliquium being added to the solution , not any thing was precipitated .
It is , therefore , pure Tin .
I am , with great respect and obedience , Gentlemen , Your ever devoted , and most obliged humble servant , Emanuel Mends da Costa .
Feb. 20 , 1766 .

