Received January 31 , 1765 .
XXXIII .
A Memoir , containing the History of the Return of the famous Comet of 1682 , with Observations of the same , made at Paris , at the Marine Observatory , in January , February , March , April , May , and the Beginning of June , 1759 .
By Mr. Messier , Astronomer , Keeper of the Journals , Plans , and Maps belonging to the Marine of France , Fellow of the Royal Society in London , and Member of the Society of Sciences in Holland ; translated from the French by Matthew Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. IN the predictions of the heavenly phenomenon , which depend on the motion of the stars , two things are to be considered , viz. the time and place .
As to the time , when the velocity and direction of the stars in their motions both apparent and real are known , the time of their different appulses and aspects may always be foretold , and the accuracy of the calculations depends on the exactness with which their velocity and their several inequalities are ascertained .
Now it is well known that all the former uncertainty , as to the exact time of the return of the comet foretold by Dr. Halley , was owing to the variations it must have undergone from its several situations and approximations to the planets in its progress thro ' the solar system .
Read Jan. 9 .
1766 .
Dr. Halley , who was first aware of the unequal returns of this comet in its former appearances , which he found to have been alternately of 75 and 76 years , was likewise the first who assigned their true cause .
He ascribed it , as I said above , to the nearer or more distant approaches of the planets of our system ; and having observed that the comet we are speaking of came very near Jupiter in the summer of 1681 , above a year before its last appearance , and remained several months in the neighbourhood of that planet , he judged that circumstance alone sufficient to have considerably retarded its motion , and prolonged the duration of its revolution .
Hence he concluded that its return was not to be expected till the latter end of 1758 , or the beginning of the next year .
Dr. Halley observes , in confirmation of this opinion , that the action of Jupiter upon Saturn is alone sufficient to alter the duration of Saturn 's period one whole month ; and he adds , how much greater irregularities must not a comet be liable to , which at its remotest distance gets near four times farther from the sun than Saturn , and whose velocity in drawing near the sun needs but a very small increase to change its elliptic into a parabolic curve .
Dr. Halley does not determine more exactly the time of the return of the comet of 1682 ; neither could he do it but by determining exactly the effect of the neighbourhood of Jupiter , which must very sensibly affect the velocity with which the comet was moving towards the sun .
Besides , regard must be had , not only to this approach to Jupiter in 1681 , but likewise to the other approaches to this and all the other planets , which act more or less upon the comet , as they do upon each other .
In short , it was necessary to consider all the different situations and distances of all the planets with regard to the comet , during the whole of its last revolution , and even during the former ones , when the returns had been found to be unequal .
What immense labour !
and what geometrical knowledge did this task not require ?
Mr. Clairaut , of the Royal Academy of Sciences , undertook it ; and his results differed but one month from the observation .
No small degree of exactness this , considering the immensity of the object .
In November 1758 , he published his conclusion , which allowed about 618 days more for the period that was to end in 1759 than for the former , whence he inferred that the comet must be in its perihelion towards the middle of April .
He added , however , ( Journal des Scavans , Jan. 1759 ) ` ` Any one may think with what caution I venture upon this publication , since so many small quantities unavoidably neglected by the methods of approximation may very possibly make a month 's difference , as in the calculation of former periods .
' ' It accordingly proved so , the comet having reached its perihelion on the 13th of March in the morning .
Mr. Clairaut has since published the methods and calculations , by which he has arrived at this conclusion .
The impatience of astronomers , and their desire to prepare for verifying this prediction of Dr. Halley , had put them upon enquiring for several years in what part of the heavens this comet was likely to appear ; but , being ignorant of the exact time of its return , they could not determine the spot where it might be expected to be seen , but by making various suppositions as to the time of its perihelium .
This Mr. Dirck of Klinkenberg , a famous astronomer , Member of the Society of Sciences in Holland , and a correspondent of the academy of Paris , had attempted seven or eight years before , having taken the pains to calculate the principal points of fourteen different tracts , which the said comet was to take , upon as many different suppositions relating to its passage thro ' its perihelium , almost from month to month , from the 19th of June 1757 to the 15th of May 1758 .
Messrs. Pingre and De la Land proceeded much in the same manner in the calculations they published in the Memoirs of Trevoux for April 1759 , first and second parts , with this difference , that the latter in their suppositions had taken narrower limits , and nearer to Mr. Clairaut 's determination , who , as I said before , had fixed the return of this comet to the middle of April .
Mr. De L'Isle , being curious of seeing the comet on its first return , as soon as it could be discovered by means of refracting or reflecting telescopes , before it was visible to the naked eye , thought he must proceed in a different manner from what other astronomers had done , to find out in what part of the heavens it must be looked for .
He considered that it was not necessary to know its place throughout its whole course , but only at the first moment of its appearance , because , having once found it out , it would be an easy matter afterwards to trace it thro ' its whole progress by observation and calculation .
A full description of this method is to be found in an ample memoir concerning this comet , which I have laid before the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , and which no doubt will be printed in their collection , together with a northern hemisphere , by means of which I have been enabled to look for this comet in the very place of the sky , where it ought to appear ; and it was by the help of this planisphere that I actually discovered the comet from the marine Observatory at Paris on the 21st of January in the evening , after searching for it two years successively whenever the sky would permit .
The weather was extremely clear the 21st of January the whole day and evening .
I seized this opportunity , and as soon as the stars were visible after sun-set , I examined , thro ' a Newtonian telescope of four feet and a half , those places of the sky , where my planisphere showed that the comet was to be expected .
After much pains , I perceived about seven o'clock a light resembling that of the comet I had observed the year before in August , September , October , and the beginning of November * .
I immediately made a configuration of this new light with respect to the neighbouring stars , in order to examine the next night whether it had had any motion among the fixed stars .
This light appeared pretty large ; and in the middle I observed a nucleus , or bright spot , which was no proof as yet that it was a comet , as there are some nebulous stars , with a bright spot in the middle .
By the drawing I took of this new light with respect to two neighbouring stars , one of which was the 18th of Pisces , according to Flamstead 's Catalogue , * See Mem. de l'Acad .
Roy .
des Scienc .
An. 1759 .
2d edition , of the 5th magnitude , marked with the Greek letter ~ , the other a new star of the 8th magnitude , which I ascertained by observation , by comparing it with the above-mentioned star ~ of Pisces , its right ascension for the present time being 352d .
13 .
5~ .
and its declination 1~ .
6~ .
40~ N. and is the 28th in the catalogue of the stars which have served to find out the position of the comet , which is to be seen at the end of this memoir ; at 6h .
56~ true time , the position of the comet in right ascension was estimated at 352~ .
15~ 47~ .
and its declination 1~ .
32~ .
6~ .
North .
Jan. 22 , at the same hour as the day before , the sky being equally clear , I again saw the same light with the 41/ 2 foot telescope , and found it had sensibly changed its place , but its appearances were the same .
From this second observation I no longer doubted of its being a comet ; and from this very night I began to take notice of the situation of the nucleus , by comparing it with a small new star which is not to be found in the catalogues , nor in the celestial maps of Flamstead , but is that whose position I have just now mentioned , and which stands No 28 in the catalogue annexed to this memoir .
It was not without some difficulty that I could take the position of the comet with regard to this little star , because I was obliged to throw light upon the threads of a silk micrometer , which was adapted to the Newtonian telescope , four feet and a half long , and the least degree of light from a wax candle I made use of , presently made both the comet and the star disappear .
The position of the comet may be seen in the second table hereunto annexed , and likewise all the other positions of it , which have been determined to the time of its final disappearing .
The 23d , the sky being very clear , I again saw the comet ; its appearanceswere the same as the two preceding days .
I compared the nucleus with a very small star , only of the 10th magnitude , which I have settled by comparing it with the 46th star of Pisces of the 6th magnitude , according to Flamstead 's catalogue .
See the position of this star in the first table , No 27 .
The position of the comet is set down in the second table .
The 24th in the evening , the fog , thin clouds , and vapours about the horizon suffered me to take but an imperfect view of the comet ; all I could do to get at its situation was to observe the differences of azimuths and heights of the comet , and the two stars of Pegasus called Algenib and Markab .
These differences did not appear to me to be so exact as to depend upon the determination of the comet from them , so I shall give no account of them .
The 25th in the evening , the sky being clear at times , I again saw the comet ; its light was increased , and the nucleus looked brighter than before , but without any appearance of a tail .
I compared it directly with a star which is the 16th of Pisces , in the order of Flamstead 's catalogue .
It was likewise compared with No 26 of my table .
The comet was sufficiently visible this night to be seen thro ' a common two feet telescope , and even thro ' one of a single foot .
At four minutes past seven , the comet was still to be seen thro ' the telescope at the height of 13~ above the horizon .
The 26th , the cloudy weather prevented my seeing the comet ; but the 27th , the sky being tolerably clear , tho ' the air was not altogether free from vapours , I again saw the comet , but could form no judgment of its appearances .
I compared the nucleus with a new star which is the 25th of my table , which I knew by comparing it with some stars in Flamstead 's catalogue .
I also directly compared the nucleus of the comet with the 16th star of Pisces .
See the second table .
The 28th , the sky being pretty clear in the evening , I began to see the comet at 261/ 2 above the horizon ; but the air was so much darkened by some fire-works which had just been played off at the Prince of Conde 's , that I could neither judge of its shape or brightness .
All I could do was to compare it three times with the new star mentioned above , No 25 of my table , and once with the 16th of Pisces .
The 29th and 30th it was too cloudy to see the comet , but the 31st it cleared up a little ; the comet appeared between the clouds , though not plain enough to judge of its increase , but only to compare it with two stars , which are not in Flamstead 's maps , nor mentioned in his catalogue , but are not far from the star k of Pisces of the 5th magnitude , with which I compared them .
They are both set down in the first table , No 23 and 24 .
February 1 , the sky being perfectly clear in the evening , the comet appeared , notwithstanding a strong twilight and the neighbourhood of the moon .
I compared the nucleus with the same two new stars , No 23 and 24 .
The clearness of the air this night induced me to measure the diameter of the coma of the comet with the micrometer adapted to the Newtonian telescope , and I found it 2 min. and 1/ 4 .
I likewise determined the magnitude of the nucleus , which I found to be 20~ , having compared it with the thickness of one of the threads of the micrometer , which I afterwards reduced into parts of the micrometer .
The twilight was then such as to favour this measuring and the other observations .
The 2d the clouds prevented my seeing the comet , but the 3d , about seven o'clock , the sky being tolerably clear , the comet appeared , though but faintly , by reason of its nearness to the horizon and of the light of the moon ; however , I compared it with a star of Pisces that is to be found in Flamstead 's catalogue .
It is the 8th of that constellation , marked with the Greek letter x~ .
The position of this star for the present time is shown in the first table .
The 4th I was as much hindered as the night before by the comet 's nearness to the horizon , and by the too great light of the moon , which made it impossible to judge of its increase .
I compared the nucleus with the same star x~ of Pisces .
From the 4th to the 11th it was utterly impossible to make any observations , or even to see the comet , by reason of the clouds which darkened that part of the sky at the time it should have appeared .
The 11th the sky was clear in the evening .
I saw the comet , which was but 10~ high , so that I could not judge of its appearances , from its nearness to the horizon , and the strong light of the moon , which was then at the full .
I was likewise much obstructed by the height of the chimneys which stand between the horizon and the marine Observatory to the West .
This prevented my comparing the comet with the neighbouring stars for a quarter of an hour that it continued visible .
All I could do was to draw the configuration of these stars with the comet , both with the four feet and half telescope and with a little two feet refracting telescope , which was fastened over the reflector in a parallel situation .
From this configuration , I have estimated the position of the comet , as is seen in the second table .
The 12th , the sky , which had been cloudy all day , cleared up a little in the evening .
The comet appeared near the horizon for a few minutes , but was soon hid behind the chimneys .
All I could do was to estimate its position relative to the neighbouring stars .
The 13th , the sky was quite overcast ; but the 14th having cleared up in the evening , I could see the comet , but close to the horizon , at the height of 6~ for a few minutes ; and it soon disappeared , being intercepted by terrestrial objects too high above the horizon , and which I could not keep clear of .
All I was able to do in the short interval it was visible , was to take a hasty estimate of its position with respect to the star A of Pisces .
The brightness of the twilight prevented my seeing the comet earlier .
The 15th and the 17th , the sky was pretty clear in the evening ; but I could not see the comet at all , because of the bright twilight , which continued till the setting of the comet .
The comet being no longer visible at night , on account of its getting into the sun 's rays , Mr. De L'Isle and I examined the exactest observations I had made , which helped us to determine the time and the place of the sky , where it was to re-appear in the morning , when it should get clear of the rays of the sun .
This was to happen towards the end of March ; but the cloudy weather , which prevailed at Paris during that month , prevented our seeing it again .
Besides this inconveniency , the marine Observatory did not stand high enough to see it at its first rising in the morning .
We were obliged to look out for a more convenient place in the neighbourhood , and met with one at the house belonging to the College of Lewis the Great , where there is a turret which overlooks all the horizon , and where Father Merville , Professor of Mathematics , makes his observations .
The 31st of March I removed thither my 41/ 2 feet Newtonian telescope , and likewise a pendulum clock .
I spent the night from the 31st to the 1st of April in this turret with Mr. De L'Isle .
At three in the morning , I began to trace a meridian upon the floor by means of a sea-compass ; and I likewise drew a line , which made an angle of about 74~ with the meridian , from the South towards the East , in the direction of which the comet was first to appear .
I directed the Newtonian telescope according to this line ; and at 52 minutes past three I saw the comet , about two degrees above the horizon .
It appeared much larger and brighter than in the middle of February ; and indeed it was but 18 days past its perihelion .
Now it is well known that comets are much brighter after the perihelion than at the same distance before it .
Besides , the comet after passing the perihelion was as near again to the earth as on the 14th of February , when I lost sight of it at night .
When I saw this comet again on the 1st of April , I could very plainly discern its tail , but could not ascertain its length , because of the morning twilight which was then beginning , and soon increased much ; it filled the field of the telescope , and must have extended far beyond .
According to what I have observed , the tail of the comet must have spread to more than 25 degrees .
The nucleus was considerable , but not well terminated , and it apparently exceeded the size of stars of the first magnitude .
It was of a pale whitish colour , not unlike that of Venus .
The nebulosity which surrounded the nucleus , and went on lessening , showed reddish colours , and these colours grew more vivid towards the brightest parts of the tail .
The morning twilight , which increased apace , soon put an end to these appearances , and afterwards made the comet itself disappear ; however , I had been able to perceive it with the naked eye when it was somewhat disengaged from the vapours of the horizon .
In this short interval , I had but just time to observe the shape of the comet with the telescope , and to compare the nucleus with a star which I have since found to be the 30th of Aquarius , according to Flamstead 's catalogue , where it is set down as of the 6th magnitude .
The difference of declination between the comet and this star was only estimated .
The true time of this observation , which will be found in the second table , has been concluded only by means of a minute watch , which had been set to the true time in the evening by the clock of the marine Observatory .
This was likewise the case with respect to the observations made during the month of April , in the turret of the College of Lewis the Great , where there was a pendulum clock , as I said before , set by a watch which was regulated every day of observation .
I saw the comet the 2d of April in the morning , a little before four o'clock , about 4~ above the horizon .
The tail did not then appear so plain as the day before .
Whether the twilight was stronger , or the horizon more encumbered with vapours , I could see none of those colours in the tail which I had observed the day before .
I compared the nucleus in the twilight with a fixed star which was nearly in the same parallel with the comet ; it is the 22d of the first table , and I judged it to be of the 7th magnitude .
The 3d , 4th , and 5th , I saw nothing of the comet ; but on the 6th in the morning I looked for it through the telescope , as it was no longer visible to the naked eye , from the great strength of the twilight at its first rising .
I began to see it at above a quarter after four , about 6~ above the horizon .
I compared the nucleus with a new star , which I have judged to be of the 7th magnitude .
Its position at that time is set down in my first table , N~ 21 .
April 7 , in the morning , the sky not being perfectly clear , I saw the comet a little before four ; the appearances were not so plain as for some days past .
I compared the nucleus with a new star which I judge to be of the 7th magnitude .
The determination of this star may be seen in the first table , N~ 20 , and that of the comet in the second .
The 8th in the morning , the sky being almost totally overcast , I saw the comet for a few minutes through some little intervals of the clouds , at near 41/ 2~ above the horizon .
All I could do towards ascertaining its position , was to estimate it with respect to the new star of the day before , No 20 .
The 9th , at 4h 23~ in the morning , I again saw the comet through some thin clouds ; but the shortness of the time it was visible did not permit me to take its position .
The 10th , 11th , 12th , and 13th , in the morning , the clouds prevented my seeing the comet ; but having on the 13th removed my instruments to a place still better situated than the turret of the college , though in the neighbourhood , I carried on my observations there till the 2d of May .
April 14 , in the morning , I saw the comet again , the sky being very clear , without a cloud , and I was only obstructed by the great light of the moon , which had past the full on the 12th at one in the afternoon .
The brightness of this and the twilight prevented my seeing the comet at its first rising .
I could see nothing of it till three quarters past three , when it was got about 4d above the horizon .
It was hardly to be seen , and the nucleus could not be distinguished from the coma , so that the comet looked but like a faint round speck of light .
It was then near the stars of the 3d and 4th magnitude , called by Bayer ~ and ~ of the tail of Capricorn , pretty close to the westermost of these two stars .
I had not time to take the distance by the micrometer , the twilight having quickly made the comet disappear .
All I was able to do , whilst it was visible , was to determine its situation with tolerable exactness , by means of the differences , azimuths , and heighths of the comet , and the two stars of Aquarius 's shoulR r2 ders , ders , and to estimate the position of the comet with respect to the star ~ of Capricorn .
I have set down this estimate in the second table .
It is more to be depended on than the determination by the azimuths and heighths .
In the night between the 14th and 15th , it being cloudy most part of the night , I saw the comet between the clouds ; but the twilight and the moon prevented my observing its appearances .
The nucleus was but imperfectly terminated , and surrounded with a whitish nebula of small extent .
I compared the comet in right ascension with the star ~ of Capricorn .
The difference of declination was only estimated .
At 19 min. past 4 , the comet disappeared in the twilight , being then but 8~ above the horizon .
The weather was overcast in the morning of the 16th ; but the 17th , the sky being perfectly clear , the comet began to appear soon after three quarters past three in the morning , being but about 21/ 2d above the horizon .
It was hardly discernible , on account of the twilight and the height of the moon , and appeared fainter still than the 15th .
I compared the nucleus with two stars that were near it .
These stars are new ones .
I determined their position for the present time , which will be found in the first table , No 18 and 19 .
The first was estimated of the 7th , and the other of the 8th magnitude .
The 18th and 19th in the morning , the sky being very clear , I looked for the comet , but could not discover it .
The great latitude it was advancing to every day left no room to hope it would be seen any more above our horizon in the morning ; but we knew the tract it was to follow in the heavens .
It was was to rise again above our horizon , after having run through several southern constellations with prodigious velocity , and approached the South Pole within 15 degrees .
The southern constellations , through which the comet was to pass after coming out of Capricorn , were the Indian , the Peacock , the Bird of Paradise , the Cross and the Centaur , from whence it was to traverse the Hydra with a motion almost perpendicular to the horizon , and finally be lost in the Sextant which lies under Leo .
It was only in this last constellation that it was to disappear from our horizon ; and I was preparing for seeing it again , taking the same precautions I had used to descry last year 's comet , when it was distant from the sun above twice and a half as far as the sun is from the earth .
Hence appears the utility which will arise from these last observations compared with the former made five months before , for ascertaining the true elements of the theory of this comet in this new apparition , and chiefly to find out the alterations which have happened in these elements since the apparition of 1682 .
They will help us to discover more certainly and demonstratively the effect of the action of the planets upon comets .
Having thus ceased seeing this comet on the 17th of April in the morning , as I before observed , I was eager to seek for it again towards the end of this very month of April , in that place of the sky where I had calculated it must then appear in the evening ; but the bad weather prevented my seeing it till the 29th , when I perceived it near the horizon , through thin clouds , but I was not able to take its position .
The 30th the sky was quite cloudy ; but on the first of May I saw the comet with the naked eye about nine o'clock at night , coming out of the clouds which overcast the horizon , but which dispersed soon after .
It appeared to the naked eye larger than the stars of the first magnitude , the nucleus surrounded with a great coma .
Its light was but saint , like that of the planets seen through the thick vapours of the horizon .
It would have appeared brighter but for the light of the moon , which probably prevented my taking an exact estimate of the size of the comet .
The nucleus appeared pretty distinct in the middle of the great nebulosity which surrounded it , and spread more to the East by one degree and a half .
The same night , May 1st , I compared the nucleus of the comet with two new stars that were just by , which I found to be of the 7th and 8th magnitude .
I determined the position of one of these stars by observing it at the meridian with known stars .
Its position may be seen in the table , N~ 17 .
All the observations since the 14th of April in the morning were taken from the place I mentioned , near the College of Lewis the Great .
The clock I made use of for these observations had been set to the true time only by a minute watch , which I had taken care to set by the clock at the Observatory , so that there may be an error of some minutes in the true times of the observations .
As I found by this day 's observation that I could observe the comet the following days from the marine Observatory , I caused the Newtonian telescope to be removed thither , as likewise the clock , which however was of no further use for these observations , having from this time made use of that of the Observatory , that is set by the motion of the fixed stars , and goes extremely regular .
So that all the remaining observations , down to the total disappearing of the comet , were taken at the marine Observatory .
May 2d was quite cloudy ; but the 3d , the weather clearing up at night , I saw the comet between two new stars of the 8th and 9th magnitude .
I determined their position for the present time by comparing them with the star ~3 of the Hydra in Flamstead 's Catalogue .
The nucleus of the comet I compared with these two new stars , which may be seen in my first table , N~ 14 and 15 .
That night the comet was distinctly seen with the naked eye ; it looked like a little cloud of light , in the center of which was a luminous point , which was the nucleus , and appeared tolerably well terminated when seen through the Newtonian telescope .
The moon , which was now in her first quarter , considerably obstructed the appearances of the comet ; notwithstanding which , we could distinguish a tail about one degree and a half in length , tending to the East .
The 4th was overcast ; but the 5th being perfectly clear in the evening , I saw the comet , but could form no judgment as to its appearances , because of the moon-light .
I compared the comet with two stars of Flamstead 's Catalogue , which are the 1st and 2d of the Hydra , both marked with the Greek letter ~2 and ~3 , the first of the 6th magnitude , the other of the 5th .
The positions of both these stars for the present time may be seen in the first table .
The 6th I again saw the comet .
The moon-light still prevented ascertaining its real size .
I compared the nucleus with a new star , which I judged to be of the 7th magnitude .
I determined its position by observing it several times on the meridian .
It is to be found in the first Table N~ 12 .
The 7th I compared the nucleus of the comet , with a new star , which I estimated of the 7th magnitude .
I determined its position for the present time by comparing it with the star ~2 of Hydra of the 5th magnitude .
The position of this new star may be seen in my first Table N~ 10 .
The 8th I did not see the comet till it was 24~ above the horizon .
I compared its nucleus with a new star , which I estimated of the 9th magnitude .
I found its position by comparing it with some stars .
It stands in the first Table N~ 11 .
The 9th quite clear at night .
The comet was upon the parallel of a new star , which I estimated of the 7th magnitude .
I determined its position for the present time , by observing it several times on the meridian .
It is set down in the first Table N~ 13 .
The 10th and 11th were cloudy evenings , but the 12th quite clear till 11 at night .
I saw the comet , but the full moon greatly lessened its appearances .
I compared the nucleus with a new star , which I estimated of the 6th magnitude .
I found its position for the present time , by comparing it with some known stars .
It is set down in the first Table No 16 .
The 13th the sky was cloudy almost all day , and at night ; however , I saw the comet in the vacancies between the clouds .
The moon was not yet up .
The appearances of the comet were plainer than the night before .
It was but just discernible by the naked eye .
I compared the nucleus with some very small stars , one of which I found by comparing it with some stars of the sextant .
The position for the present time stands in the first Table N~ 8 .
The 14th clear at night .
I saw the comet with the naked eye before the moon was up ; it was still equal to the stars of the 4th magnitude .
I determined the apparent diameter of the nucleus , which I found to be 27 seconds , by comparing it with the thickness of one of the threads of the micrometer , which was adapted to the Newtonian telescope .
I then compared the comet with several stars , namely with two new ones , which may be seen in my first Table N~ 6 and 7 , and with the 22d of the sextant in Flamstead 's catalogue .
The 15th the sky was quite clear at night .
I saw the comet very plain by the naked eye , but could perceive no tail ; but I observed one in looking through a refracting telescope one foot long , made of convex glasses , which is very clear , and discovers a great compass of the sky .
I made use of it to find out the stars which corresponded with the extremity of the tail , and then I determined the position of these stars with the comet , by means of the micrometer adapted to the telescope , which gave me the length and direction of the tail .
I found it to be 3d 1/ 4 long .
This tail was not visible with the reflecting telescope , no doubt by reason of its too great magnifying power ; it only showed a round and indeterminate light surrounding the nucleus of the comet .
I compared the nucleus with the 22d star of the sextant ; the position of this star may be seen in the first Table .
The 16th , the sky being as clear as the night before , I saw the comet till its setting .
The tail still appeared to me of the same length .
The nucleus was again compared to the abovementioned 22d star of the sextant .
The 17th , the sky being clear , I began to see the comet as soon as it was dark .
I again saw the tail through the one foot glass , and found it 4~ long .
I compared the nucleus with the same star as before , and with two new ones N~ 1 and 2 of the first Table , one of the 6th , and the other of the 7th magnitude .
I determined their positions for the present time .
The 18th , the sky being perfectly clear in the evening , I saw the comet through the one foot glass .
The tail appeared a little increased , but its light was very faint , and it was with difficulty I could perceive it at all .
I compared the nucleus with the two new stars N~ 1 and 2 .
The positions for the present time may be seen in the first Table .
The 19th still a clear sky .
I saw the comet as soon as it was night ; its appearances were the same as the evening before .
I took the position of the nucleus , by comparing it with the above stars N~ 1 and 2 .
The 20th the sky was clear in the evening , though with some thin vapours in the atmosphere .
The tail of the comet was not so plain to be seen as the night before .
The nucleus was lessened and indeterminate ; I compared it with the new star N~ 2 of the preceding nights , and with two other new ones N~ 3 and 5 of the first Table , which I ascertained by comparing them with some stars of the sextant .
The 21st , the sky being clear and cloudless , I saw the comet , and compared its nucleus with one of the three new stars of the night before , viz. N~ 3 in the first Table , of the 8th magnitude .
The 22d I observed that the comet visibly grew dim , and indeed it was now constantly drawing farther from the sun and earth ; its nucleus was likewise much contracted , and not terminated .
The tail was hardly distinguishable with the one foot glass , and terminated at the 41st star of the sextant according to Flamstead 's catalogue .
It was found to be a little more than 4~ long .
The nucleus was compared with the new star N~ 3 of the first Table .
The 23d clear sky at night .
I began to see the comet as soon as it was dark .
Its appearances were the same as the night before .
I compared the nucleus with the said new star N~ 3 .
The 24th the sky perfectly clear .
I compared the nucleus with the same new star N~ 3 , and with another very small new star N~ 4 of the first Table .
The 25th a fine clear sky .
I saw the comet as soon as it was dark , and compared it with the new star N~ 4 .
The 26th , the sky was as clear .
I again saw the comet .
It has now lost much of its light , especially for a week past ; the nucleus is no longer distinct , and it is to be perceived through the telescope , only by a stronger light than the nebulosity which surrounds it .
I compared the nucleus of the comet with the same star N~ 4 .
The 27th , a fine sky .
I saw the comet as soon as the stars appeared after sun-set .
I could scarce distinguish the tail with the one foot glass ; I judged it to be about 4~ long .
I compared the nucleus with the same star N~ 4 .
The 28th I could not see the comet before 10 o'clock by reason of thin clouds ; its appearances were greatly diminished ; it is no longer possible to see it with the naked eye ( nor indeed has it been so for these several days * ) .
I compared the nucleus with the same star N~ 4 .
The 29th a cloudy night ; the 30th I again saw the comet , but with great difficulty .
Its light was considerably abated , and might be farther eclipsed by that of the moon , which was now near her first quarter ; and it is to be presumed we shall not see this comet much longer .
The increasing light of the moon must in a few days prevent its being visible .
I have yet been able to compare the nucleus to a new star N~ 9 of the first Table .
The position of this new star has been found by comparing it with some new stars of Flamstead 's catalogue .
The 31st was cloudy , as was likewise the 1st of June .
The 2d I saw the comet in the interstices of the clouds , but could not take its position ; but the 3d I saw it again between the clouds , where the sky was perfectly clear .
Its light was very dim , and none but such eyes as had been accustomed to see it could have perceived it at all .
This was partly occasioned by the neighbourhood of the moon which was past her first quarter , so that this day may be * It is to be observed here that the comet , on the 28th of May , appeared much of the same size , as when I first discovered it on the 21st of January at night , though somewhat brighter .
supposed to be the period of its being visible , at least through the Newtonian telescope of 4 1/ 2 foot , which I have made use of , and which magnifies the diameter of objects about 66 times .
I have once more been able to compare the nucleus with a star of the 6th magnitude , which is the 27th of the sextant according to Flamstead 's catalogue .
Its position for the present time is set down in the first Table .
I looked again for the comet the following days , but in vain ; so that the 3d of June put a period to my observations of this comet .
The duration of its appearance has been 134 days , reckoning from the 21st of January , when I first saw it from the marine Observatory .
All the observations of the comet have been taken with the Newtonian telescope , to which was adapted a micrometer with silken threads , which could be inclined every way , so that it was an easy matter to bring one of the threads to the parallel of the comet ; another parallel thread served to take the differences of declination between the comet and the star to which it was compared .
At another thread , perpendicular to these , I observed the differences of the passages in right ascension of the stars and the comet .
The field of the telescope was about 53 minutes of a great circle .
By this account it appears , that the comet has had three several appearances above our horizon , which M. De l'Isle and I had calculated as soon as I had made my first observations , that is , as early as the month of February .
The first appearance of the comet was in the evening from the 21st of January , to the 14th of February , when I ceased seeing it by reason of its entrance into the rays of the sun .
The second appearance was at the comet 's getting clear of the rays of the sun in the morning , after the conjunction with that luminary , which was to take place a few days before its passage through the perihelion .
I observed it in the morning from the 1st of April to the 17th , when it entered the rays of the sun a second time .
The 3d appearance of the comet was expected to begin a few days after the end of the 2d , when the comet , after being hid below the horizon , might make its appearance above it ; I began to see it again on the 29th of April in the evening , but could not take its position because of the clouds .
I went on observing it till the 3d of June at night , when I saw it no more .
It was then in the sextant .
In this last appearance of the comet above the horizon , it was observed by most of the astronomers in Europe .
More minute accounts of this comet will be seen in a memoirwhich I have presented to the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , together with two celestial maps showing the tract of the comet through the fixed stars during its appearance , which I have traced exactly by my observations .
There is likewise annexed to this memoir a collection of all the observations which have been made of this comet , by my own and Mr. De L'Isle 's correspondents .
These observations have been taken , at the Hague by Mr. Dirck de Klinkenberg , at Leyden by Mr. Lulof , at Montpelpellier by Mr. de Ratte , at Avignon by Father Morand , at Vienna by the Rev. Father Hell , at Leipsick , at Rome , at Cadiz by Mr. Godin , at Lisbon by Father Chevalier , and at Pondicherry in the East Indies by Father Coeurdoux .
Explanation of the two Tables annexed to this Memoir .
The first table contains the right ascensions and declinations of the stars , both of the new ones and of those in Flamstead 's catalogue , for the time of the observations .
It appears from this table , that the comet has furnished me with an opportunity of determining the position of 29 new stars , which were not yet known , and which have served for the determination of the comet .
The second table contains all the places of the comet , as well in right ascension and declination , as in longitude and latitude , concluded from its situation observed relatively to the stars , whether new ones or already known .
These are the titles of each column : The 1st points out the days of the month ; the 2d , the true time of each observation ; the 3d , the right ascensions of the comet observed ; the 4th , the declinations ; the 5th , the longitudes observed ; the 6th , the latitudes ; the 7th , the differences of passage in right ascension of the comet and the stars , marked with the sign when the comet preceded the star or was to the West of it , and with + when it followed the star or was to the East .
This difference , according to the sign , being either added to or subtracted from the right ascension of the star set down in the first table , with which the comet was compared , will give its right ascension .
The 8th column shows the differences of declination between the comet and the stars , marked likewise with + , and - , and which , being accordingly either added to or taken from the declination of the star with which the comet was compared , will give its declination .
The 9th column contains the magnitude of the stars ; and the 10th , which is the last , has Bayer 's letters , and the numbers of the stars , either new or taken from Bayer 's catalogue , according to their order in each constellation .
The following are the elements of the comet , as computed by Messrs. de la Caille , Maraldi , and De la Land .
Mr. de la Caille .
Mr. Maraldi , Mr. de la Land .
S. D. M. S. S. D. M. S. S. D. M. S. Place of the ascending node 1 23 49 01 23 49 41 1 23 45 35 Inclination of the orbit 17 39 0 17 35 20 17 40 14 Place of the perihelion 10 3 16 0 10 3 16 20 10 38 10 Logarithm of the distance at the perihelion 9,766039 9,766115 9,7670848 March h~h~~h~~ Time of the perihelion 12 .
at 13 41 at 12 57 36 at 13 59 24 Mean time , at the meridian of Paris , the motion of the comet was retrograde .
TABLE I. Containing the right Ascensions and Declinations of the Stars for the Time of the Observations of the Comet of 1759 , both of the new ones and of those of Flamstead 's Catalogue , which have been made use of to find out the Positions of the Comet as set down in the next Table .
No of the Right Mag. of Stars .
ascension .
Declination .
the Stars .
~~~~~~ 1 149 48 55 67 45 S6A new Star , the Comet compared May 18 and 19 at night 22 151 25 27 6 52 25 6A Star of the Sextant , Comet compared May 14 , 15 , 16 , and 17 2 153 25 25 5 50 36 7A new Star , Comet compared May 17 , 18 , 19 , and 20 3 153 33 85 12 52 8A new Star , Comet compared May 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , and 24 27 153 35 49 3 10 36A Star of the Sextant , Comet compared June 3 4 153 42 34 4 28 35 10 A new Star , Comet compared May 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , and 28 5 153 42 34 5 21 5 10 A new Star , Comet compared May 20 6 153 46 21 7 58 55 8A new Star , Comet compared May 14 7 153 47 22 7 12 32 10 A new Star , Comet compared May 14 8 153 57 40 8 19 29 10 A new Star , Comet compared May 13 9 154 7 39 4 13 20 10 A new Star , Comet compared May 30 10 154 47 30 12 21 11 7A new Star , Comet compared May 7 11 154 52 21 11 52 46 9A new Star , Comet compared May 8 12 154 57 2 13 39 67A new Star , Comet compared May 6 1 156 8 56 15 5 53 6A Star of the Hydra ~2 .
Comet compared May 5 13 156 8 15 11 1 37 7A new Star , Comet compared May 9 2 156 43 56 15 37 38 5 ~3 of the Hydra , Comet compared May 5 14 156 58 8 19 36 31 9A new Star , Comet compared May 13 15 157 40 41 19 21 39 8A new Star , Comet compared May 3 16 159 25 32 8 34 41 6A new Star , Comet compared May 12 17 159 26 5 25 31 55 7A new Star , Comet compared May 1 171 .
160 0 28 25 36 24 9A new Star 18 322 3 15 20 52 19 8A new Star , Comet compared April 17 in the Morning 19 322 25 3 20 41 56 7A new Star , Comet compared April 17 in the Morning Continuation of the Table of right Ascensions and Declinations .
No of the Stars .
Right Ascension .
Declination .
Mag. of the Stars .
o ' ' ' o ' ' ' 49 323 25 38 17 12 53~ of Capricorn , Comet estimated April 14 and 15 in the Morning 20 325 10 5 11 26 37A new Star , Comet compared April 7 and 8 in the Moruing 21 326 12 50 9 42 07A new Star , Comet compared April 6 in the Morning 30 327 41 29 7 40 52 6A Star of Aquarius , Comet compared April 1 in the Morning 22 329 11 24 8 41 31 7A new Star , Comet compared April 2 in the Morning 5 344 4 32 0 48 0N6A of Pisces , Comet compared and estimated February 14 23 348 33 20 17 28 8A new Star , Comet compared January 31 and February 1 8 348 38 36 03 40 S5 ~ .
of Pisces , Comet compared February 3 and 4 24 348 49 10 0 32 29 N8A new Star , Comet compared February 1 25 349 40 54 11 14 8A new Star , Comet compared January 27 and 28 26 350 44 16 0 50 56 10 A new Star , Comet compared January 25 27 350 52 16 158 10 A new Star , Comet compared January 23 16 351 010 44 48 6A Star of Pisces , Comet compared January 25 , 27 , and 28 28 352 13 516 40 8A new Star , Comet compared January 21 and 22 18 352 26 60 25 53 5~ of Pisces , Comet estimated January 21 TABLE II .
Containing the Places of the Return of the famous Comet of 1682 , discovered at the Marine Observatory at Paris , January 21 , 1759 , in the Evening , in the Constellation of Pisces : concluded from its Situation observed with respect to the Stars of the former Table .
Tr. Tim .
r. ascension Declinat .
Longitude Latitude Diff. in r. Differ .
in M. of * .
No of * .
observed .
observed observed .
observed ascension Decline .
Northern Northern from the * .
from the * .
h''o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' 1759 .
Jan. 21 6 40 0 352 15 58 1 32 58 ~ 23 30 48 4 29 44 02 53 +0 26 18 +8 28 New * .
Com. estim .
6 56 0 352 15 47 1 32 6 23 30 37 4 31 26 0 10 19 15 13 +5 18 ~ of ~ .
Com.estim .
22 6 51 20 351 51 51 29 33 23 6 32 4 36 26 0 22 00 22 53 +8 28 Star above 23 75 37 351 26 31 1 25 28 22 42 16 4 42 23 0 34 15 +0 20 20 + 10 27 A new Star 7 10 9 351 26 10 33 45 + 10 27 the same 25 6 58 54 350 38 91 13 57 21 53 10 4 50 53 0 21 52 0 29 9+6 16 of Pisces 769 350 39 10 21 06 16 the same 769 350 39 11 14 30 21 54 84 51 005 15 0 23 34 + 10 26 New 27 6 22 31 349 54 47 14 48 21 9 31 4 59 34 0 13 53 +03 34 +8 25 New 6 38 0 349 53 114 36 21 7 51 5051700 19 48 +6 16 of Pisces 761 349 52 014 52 21 6 59 50 43 1810 20 4+6 16 the same 28 60 56 349 33 107 53 8 25 New 60 56 349 32 54 0 59 54 20 47 23 53 40 08001 20 8 25 the same 6 21 50 349 32 10 59 44 20 46 38 53 47 08 53 01 30 8 25 the same 6 21 50 349 31 46 0 59 38 20 46 25 53 51 1 28 15 0 14 50 +6 16 of Pisces 31 6 57 28 0 45 10 22 27 8 23 New 7 15 31 348 25 40 0 44 25 19 39 12 5 15 49 0 23 30 0 11 56 +8 24 New Feb. 15 48 12 348 5 35 0 40 25 19 19 45 20 00 27 45 0 27 38 23 New above 5 50 20 348 5 42 0 27 38 8 23 the same 5 52 26 348 5 50 0 27 30 8 23 the same 6 52 40 348 5 30 0 39 57 19 18 46 5 19 33 0 43 40 07 28 +8 24 New above 376 46 347 25 60 31 20 18 38 55 27 28 1 13 30 0 35 051 ~ .
of Pisces 46 39 56 347 560 26 58 18 17 52 5 31 15 1 33 30 0 30 38 58 the same 11 6 31 30 344 42 20 02 20 15 56 2640 Comet estimated Southern .
12 6 20 0 344 18 50 060 15 30 59 65 22 Estimated again 14 6 30 0 343 41 20 0 15 47 14 52 22 6 10 47 65A of Pisces Mar.~ 16 17 0 328 0 33 8 25 36 ~ 27 16 40 4 15 40 0 19 4+0 44 44 +6 30 of Aquarius Continuation of the Table of the Positions of the Comet .
Tr. Time .
r. ascension Declinat .
Longitude Latitude Differ .
in Differ .
in observed .
observed observed .
observed r. ascension Decline .
Southern .
Northern .
from the * .
from the * .
M. of * .
No of * .
h ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' 1759 .
April 1 16 34 0 327 44 39 8 44 7 26 55 33 43 33 1 26 45 02 36 +7 22 New 5 16 35 0 326 41 43 10 25 30 25 22 56 2 48 52 0 28 53 +0 43 30 +7 21 New 6 16 19 0 326 26 35 10 59 23 24 57 36 2 21 52 1 16 30 +0 26 40 7 20 New 16 28 0 326 26 5 10 59 23 24 57 92 22 21 16 0+0 26 40 7 20 the same 7 16 20 0 326 10 5 11 35 10 24 30 28 1 53 28 100+097+7 20 the same Com. est .
Southern .
13 16 10 0 323 58 53 16 35 35 ~ 20 51 54 29 33 0 33 15 +0 36 30 3 49 ~ of ~ .
Com. estim .
16 14 0 323 57 40 16 35 0 20 50 58 294 Comet by ~ 14 16 10 323 24 38 17 49 16 19 57 29 38 11 0100 37 11 +3 49 ~ .
of ~ .
decl .
estim .
16 16 60 322 2 30 21 13 0 17 38 44 5 56 45 00 45 0 20 41 +8 18 A new Star 16 12 0 322 2001 15 8 18 the same 16 14 0 322 1 45 01 30 8 18 the same 16 15 0 322 1 29 21 15 3 17 37 85 58 23 0 23 34 0 33 7+7 19 New May 19 27 43 159 51 20 25 43 6~ 22 28 20 31 26 27 0 25 15 +0 11 11 +7 17 New 9 36 10 159 50 42 25 41 43 22 27 3 31 25 28 0 24 37 +09 48 +7 17 the same .
9 43 51 159 50 16 25 40 52 22 26 10 31 24 52 0 24 11 +08 57 +7 17 the same 10 0 11 159 48 58 25 38 26 22 23 28 31 23 70 22 53 +06 31 +7 17 the same 10 43 2 159 46 12 25 31 55 22 17 43 31 18 25 0 20 7+0007 17 the same 38 58 7 157 25 31 19 35 41 17 9 59 26 51 00 15 10 0 14 2+8 15 New 98 49 157 25 28 19 34 33 17 9 31 26 49 51 0 27 20 +01 58 9 14 New 58 44 11 156 23 15 34 9 14 1 28 23 42 22 06 53 0 28 16 +61 ~2 of Hydra 8 53 30 156 1 33 15 33 42 14 0 33 23 42 20 42 23 03 56 52 ~3 of Hydra 910 156 1 18 15 33 3 14 0 33 23 41 34 0 42 38 04 35 52 the same 9 38 17 156 0 18 15 30 43 13 58 14 23 39 51 0 43 38 06 55 52 the same 9 50 20 156 0 10 15 29 19 13 57 58 23 38 39 0 43 46 08 19 52 the same 9 56 19 156 0 43 15 29 8 13 59 0 23 38 28 0 43 13 08 30 52 the same 10 2 51 155 59 55 15 29 0 13 57 7 23 38 21 0 44 108 38 52 the same 69 31 7 155 30 2 14 09 12 50 9 22 28 12 0 33 0+0 21 3+7 12 New 9 39 53 155 29 47 14 00 12 49 46 22 28 60 32 45 +0 20 54 +7 12 the same 9 47 0 155 29 30 13 59 23 12 49 19 22 27 41 0 32 28 +0 20 17 +7 12 the same 7 10 4 13 155 5 56 12 42 28 11 54 12 21 25 48 0 18 26 +0 21 17 +7 10 New 10 14 20 155 5 38 12 42 10 11 53 49 21 25 40 0 18 8+0 20 59 +7 10 the same 10 21 16 155 5 23 12 42 2 11 53 29 21 25 37 0 17 53 +0 20 51 +7 10 the same 8 10 43 12 154 46 4 11 40 37 11 9 24 20 36 16 06 17 0 12 97 11 New 9 10 35 50 154 30 25 10 45 52 10 31 55 19 51 34 1 37 50 0 15 45 7 13 New 12 10 50 30 153 59 55 8 34 699 39 18 155 25 37 00 35 6 16 New Continuation of the Table of the Positions of the Comet .
Tr. Tim .
r. ascension Declinat .
Longitude Latitude Differ .
in Differ .
in M. of * .
No of * .
observed .
observed observed .
observed r. ascension Declinat .
Southern Southern from the * .
from the * .
1759 .
h~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ May 13 9 24 10 153 53 32 83 26 8 51 25 17 35 204 80 16 310 8 New 14 8 57 34 153 47 28 7 32 19 8 33 22 17 8 25 01 7+ 0 26 368 6 New 9 45 12 153 47 27 30 15 8 32 24 17 6 45 2 21 35+ 0 37 50+ 6 22 of the Sextant 10 16 27 153 46 52 7 30 23 8 32 2 17 6 51 00 300 17 51+ 07 New 15 9 15 17 153 44 25 75 40 8 20 1 16 44 50 2 18 58+ 0 13 15+ 6 22 of the Sextant 11 34 23 153 44 10 73 17 8 18 56 16 42 42 2 18 43+ 0 10 52+ 6 22 the same 16 9 54 54 153 41 10 6 41 23 87 28 16 23 30 2 15 43+ 0 11 26 22 the same 17 9 20 47 153 39 18 6 22 10 ~7 58 14 16 6 21 2 13 51+ 0 30 156 22 of the Sextant 10 37 34 153 38 55 6 20 35 7 56 45 16 4 58 3 50 0+ 0 12 50+ 6~ 1A new Star 11 30 26 153 38 40 6 17 22 7 55 46 16 200 13 15+ 0 26 46+ 72 New 18 9 25 51 153 38 25 6107 49 13 15 47 20 13 0+ 0 10 24+ 72 the same 9 48 52 153 38 15 60 21 7 48 51 15 46 30 3 49 20+ 07 246 1 New above 10 57 38 153 38 56007 48 30 15 46 13 0 12 40+ 09 24+ 72 New above 19 9 19 30 153 37 55 5 44 27 7 42 22 15 31 50 3 49 0+ 0 23 186 1 New above 10 28 31 153 37 55 5 43 14 7 41 53 15 30 43 0 12 30+ 07 227 2 New above 20 8 56 19 153 38 10 5 28 57 7 36 39 15 17 21 0 12 45+ 0 21 397 2 the same 95 41 153 38 38 5 28 13 7 36 47 15 16 30 05 30+ 0 15 21+ 83 New 9 33 14 153 38 46 5 27 58 7 36 50 15 16 13 03 480 6 53+ 10 5 New 21 9 17 30 153 39 18 5 14 27 32 12 15 3 18 06 10+ 01 10+ 83 New above 22 9 34 28 153 40 56 5127 28 37 14 50 23 07 48+ 0 11 508 3 New 23 9 42 0 153 42 49 4 49 12 7 25 53 14 38 42 09 41+ 0 23 408 3 the same 24 9 12 25 153 45 74 38 22 7 23 59 14 27 47 0 11 59+ 0 34 308 3 the same 10 42 41 153 45 40 4 37 31 7 24 10 14 26 47 03 6+ 08 56+ 04 New 25 9 26 57 153 48 24 28 23 7 22 57 14 17 26 05 28+ 00 1210 4 the same 26 9 33 58 153 51 21 4 19 33 7 22 46 14 8008 47+ 09 210 4 the same 27 9 29 15 153 55 26 4 11 12 7 23 29 13 58 44 0 12 52+ 0 17 2310 4 the same 28 9 20 0 153 59 443 11 7 23 54 13 49 58 0 16 30+ 0 25 2410 4 the same 30 10 12 49 154 993 48 15 7 27 52 13 32 22 01 30+ 0 25 510 9 New June 3 10 1~ 154 26 50 3 26 11 7 36 22 13 5 21 0 51 1+ 0 16 8+ 6 27 of the Sextant

