Received December 5 , 1765 .
XXXI .
On the Nature and Formation of Sponges : In a Letter from John Ellis , Esquire , F. R. S. to Dr. Solander , F. R. S. SIR , YO U , who study nature in an eminent degree , view her in all her works proceeding by regular gradations from the lowest to the most perfect of all created beings ; among those animals commonly called Zoophytes , you may plainly discover an evident approximation , from the rudest irregularly-formed sponge ( which is the lowest being that I have yet observed to have the appearance of animal life ) to the most beautiful and elegant red coral .
Read Dec. 19 , 1765 .
The nature and formation of sponges having never yet been thoroughly investigated , every attempt to explain this dark part of nature must give satisfaction to the curious .
The intent , then , of this letter is to convey to the Royal Society , through your hands , what we have seen in the experiments we made on them at the sea side ; the substance of what has been said on the subject by moderns as well as ancients ; and lastly , to show how nearly they approach to the Alcyoniums , a class of beings next above them in the scale of nature , as being one step nearer to the appearance of animals .
If we consult the ancients , we shall find , that , in the days of Aristotle , the persons , who made it their business to collect these substances , perceived a particular sensation , like shrinking , when they tore them off the rocks ; and , in the time of Pliny , the same opinion continued of their having a kind of feeling or animal life in them ; but after his time no attention was paid to this kind of knowledge , and it still remained a doubt , till the illustrious Count Marsigli pronounced them vegetable , as he did all the corals , keratophytons , and alcyoniums , &amp;c. After him , it fell to the lot of the ingenious Dr. Peysonell , in his Enquiries , to discover them to be animals , or rather , as he calls it , the fabric of animals , formed by a species of urtica marina ( see his manuscript which he sent to the Royal Society in the year 1752 ) ; but finding upon re-examining these intricate bodies in sea water at Guadaloupe , he favours the Royal Society with a letter dated from thence , March 1 , 1757 .
Vid. Phil. Transact. vol. L. p. 592 .
wherein he has given a particular account of the animal , which he assures us forms the sponges .
There is something so remarkable in his description of the animal , and its manner of fabricating the sponge , that I am obliged to quote the most striking parts , in order to submit the probability of it to you and the rest of the Royal Society .
He takes notice , ` ` that the same kind of animal forms the four principal species of sponges described by Father Plumier , as the tube sponge , the cordlike sponge , the digitated sponge , and the honeycomb sponge .
These sponges , ' ' he says , ` ` consist of hard firm fibres , twisted about in doubles , and the interstices filled with a mucilaginous gluey matter , having large hollows , with cylindrical tubes , dispersed through their substance , forming a kind of labyrinth filled with these worms .
He says , he has observed , ` ` that the sponges begin to be formed on a nodule of petrified sand or other like matter , round which the worms begin to work , and round which they retire as to their last seat or refuge .
He then proceeds to give a description of them , which is , ` ` that they are 1/ 3 of a line thick , two or three lines long , of a conic figure , with a small black head furnished with two pincers ; the other extremity is square , and much larger than the head ; their motion begins at the tail , and ends at the head ; they are so transparent , that the circulation of the blood may be perceived ; and where the viscera should be , there is a kind of circular motion of a blackish matter moving to and fro in the animal .
He says , he has kept them alive more than an hour out of the sponge , and ( which is very singular ) when he put them near a piece of fresh sponge , where the nests were moist , and from which he had before pulled them , he saw them enter and disappear .
He goes on to tell us , that these worms have no particular lodge ; that they walk indifferently into the tubular labyrinth ; so that , he says , without offence to Pliny and other naturalists , he does not see that it is in their power to dilate and contract the bodies of sponges , which always remain in the same state of magnitude , without being sensible to the touch , being an inanimate body ; all the sensitive life belonging to the worms .
He then tells us , that with the slaver or juice they deposit , they make the sponge increase or grow , as bees and wasps , and especially the woodlice of America , increase their nests and cells .
' ' This account appearing so contrary to the proceeding of nature in the formation of the other kindred marine bodies , called Zoophytes , such as corals , keratophytons , and alcyoniums , particularly the last ; I was determined to find out the truth of this extraordinary ~discovery , which I found had been thought worthy of a place in our Transactions .
Accordingly , in the year 1762 , when we were together at the sea side at Brighthelmstone , we dissected carefully the spongia medullam panis referens , or crumb of bread sponge , in hopes of discovering the small animals that were supposed to fabricate them ; and were suprized to find a great number of small worms in them , particularly a very small kind of nereis , or sea-scolopendra : but these worms appeared evidently , instead of being the fabricators of it , to have pierced their way into its soft substance , and made it only their place of retreat and security .
After this , we proceeded along the sea coast to Little Hampton , near Arundel , on the coast of Sussex , where we took up out of the sea several specimens of the same sort of sponge full of an orange-coloured gelatinous matter ; and , while they were just fresh from the sea , we examined them ( after they had rested for some time ) in glasses of sea water ; and to our great surprise , instead of seeing any of the polype-like suckers , or any minute animal figure , come out of the papillae , or small holes with which they are surrounded , we only observed these holes to contract and dilate themselves .
And as a further confirmation of this motion , being at Hastings in Sussex , in August 1764 , in company with Dr. Gowin Knight , F. R. S. we collected from the rocks at ebb-tide , just under water , a variety of the same kind of sponge , but of a pale yellow colour , and in the form of several cocks combs united together , the tops of which were full of tubular cavities or papillae : when we examined these in glasses of sea-water , we could plainly observe these little tubes to receive and pass the water to and fro ; so that the sponge is an animal sui generis , whose mouths are so many holes or ends of branched tubes opening on its surface ; with these it receives its nourishment , and by these it discharges , like the polypes , its excrements .
But , to give a further proof of sponges sucking in and throwing out the sea-water , I shall quote a passage from that fair investigator of nature , the celebrated Count Marsigli , in his Histoire Physique de la Mer , p. 53 .
who , notwithstanding he took them for plants , as well as he did corals , &amp;c. has in his chapter on Sponges this curious observation , which proves quite the contrary .
J'ai un fond suffisant de ces plants pour en fair un botanique entiere , &amp; plusieurs reflexions curieuses sir la systole &amp; diastole , que j'ai observees , dans certains petits trous ronds de ces plants , lors qu'elles sortent de la mer , mouvement qui dure jusqu'a ce que l'eau soit entierement consumee .
' ' In English thus : ` ` I have a sufficient stock of these plants ( sponges ) to make a complete botanical collection , with many curious remarks , which I have made on the systole and diastole , which I have observed in certain small round holes , when they are first taken out of the sea ; this motion continues in them till the water they contain is entirely wasted away .
' ' Nothing can more clearly describe what I have seen in our sponges ; so that , making an allowance for the then prevailing opinion that they were vegetables , I think , he comes nearer the truth than Dr. Peysonell 's account of the formation of sponges by little animals , that walk to and fro in the labyrinth of the tubes to construct his extraordinary animal fabric .
I come now to show you how near they approach to the alcyoniums in their internal form and manner of growth .
In order to explain this , I have given you the perpendicular and horizontal sections of the common officinal sponge * ; because this is in the power of most gentlemen to examine .
And , in vol. LIII .
of the Philos. Trans. Tab. 20 .
Fig. 10 .
c. b. 11 and 13 .
I have given the perpendicular and horizontal sections of the alcyonium manus marina , both magnified and in the natural size ; because specimens of this kind are likewise easily obtained , being found in plenty on rocks and shells near the Isle of Sheppey , at the entrance of the river Thames .
You 'll observe , the connected tubes of both arise from the part to which they adhere to the rocks , &amp;c. From hence both kinds branch out and swell into irregular lobes , with this difference , that the surface * See Tab. X. fig. E and D. of the sponge is covered with holes guarded with minute points like little spines ; the surface of the alcyonium with starry openings of eight rays , from whence the polype-like suckers are protruded , in order to find out proper nourishment : and these starry openings in one , and the holes in the other , so far correspond , that in both kinds they are found of different sizes ; but this is in proportion to the age of the branching tubes that come to the surface .
In the sections of the alcyonium you may plainly distinguish the reticulated elastic fibres , that enclose the transparent stiff gelatinous part , as in the sponges : but , as this gluey substance is of a firmer texture than what is found in sponges , it requires more pains to separate it from the elastic fibres ; however , with a little trouble it may be done sufficiently to evince what I have endeavoured to prove , I mean , the great proximity there is between the animal life of sponges and alcyoniums , and consequently that both are animals .
Before I conclude , I must endeavour to remove some doubts , which seem to have distressed the generality of curious persons to account for ; the one is , what occasions those very large holes that appear here and there irregularly on the surface of most sponges ?
the other is , how came those extraneous bodies , such as small shells , stones , and even parts of fucuses , in the middle of these animal bodies ?
In answer to the first , upon cutting open and examining these bodies while recent in sea-water , as I have shown before , we frequently find a variety of different worms , who bore their way into them , and make their nests and retreats there , or perhaps to live on on the gelatinous part of the sponge .
This the celebrated Donati confirms , in his History of the Adriatic Sea ; who endeavouring to find out , like Peysonell , the animal fabricator of the alcyonium primum Dioscoridis , which approaches very near to the sponges : he met with many irregular cavities in it , and also different kinds of inhabitants ; one of them he has particularly described and figured .
Vide Donat .
Hist. M. Adriat .
p. 58 .
t. 8 .
fig. G. But he very judiciously says , these are not the fabricators , but the inhabitants ; and allows the alcyonium to be of animal origin , in which he says he has discovered evident marks of sensation .
As to the second doubt , it may be observed by the curious enquirer into nature , that the same property of enclosing extraneous substances is common to the whole class of Zoophytes , as they grow up , from the sponge to the red coral .
In order to prove this , I have various specimens as well of sponges as keratophytons and corals , with different bodies enclosed in them , both animal and vegetable .
I have specimens where even the red coral encloses the white coral , and the white the red ; with many keratophytons , that have enclosed small roundish shells of the barnacle tribe , thought by some superficial enquirers into nature ( who would have them to be vegetables ) to be the fruit of the keratophytons .
Vid. Phil. Trans. vol. L. p. 853 .
Tab. 34 .
Fig. 19 .
a. I am , SIR , Your most obedient servant , John Ellis .
Gray's-Inn , Dec. 5 , 1765 .
An Explanation of the PLATES .
PLATE X. A is an irregular piece of the crumb of bread sponge , found at Pagham on the sea-coast of Sussex ; aa represent the papillae , through which the sponge receives and discharges the water ; this , when recent , is of a fine orange colour .
FIG. B is the branched English sponge ; at b b , along the edges , and on the surface of the branches , are rows of small papillary holes , through which the animal receives its nourishment .
FIG. C represents the downy branched English sponge found on the Sussex coast ; this is covered over with a fine down so close , that it hides the many small holes that are on its surface .
FIG. D and E , the perpendicular and horizontal sections of the common officinal sponge .
PLATE XI .
G is the cocks-comb sponge , taken off the rocks at Hastings in Suffex , and viewed while alive in sea-water .
The other sponges , represented here , are introduced to show the variety of forms these animals appear under in different parts of the world .
FIG. F is a branched tuberculated sponge from Cape Coast Castle in Africa .
Fig. f represents the appearance of the tubercles in their dried state , Philos. Trans. Vol. LV.TAB .
X. P. 288 .
C a b A b a B Philos. Trans. Vol. LV .
TAB. XI.p.288 .
~ F G I when magnified .
This sponge approaches very near to the figure of the Corallium album porosum maximum of Sir Hans Sloane , see the Hist. of Jam. Vol. I. Tab. 18 .
fig. 3 .
and of the Porus albus erectior ramosus tuberculis crebris sursum spectantibus of Morison .
See Hist. Ox. p. 3 .
Sect. 15 .
Tab. 10 .
fig. 3 .
FIG. H is a sponge from Stavanger on the coast of Norway ; this may be called the Sea-fan sponge , from its great likeness to the keratophyton of that name ; all its pores are surrounded with small spiculae , which , from their minuteness , could not be well represented in the drawing .
The dichotomous branched sponge at FIG. I is of a firm but elastic texture , very full of small holes , guarded by minute spines ; this was found on the coast of Norway , and presented to me by my worthy friend Peter Collinson , Esquire , F. R. S.

