LXXIX .
Farther Experiments in Electricity ; by Mr. Benjamin Wilson , F. R. S. To the Right Honourable the Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society .
My Lord , IN my letter upon the Tourmalin , which I had the honour of communicating to the Royal Society in December last , there are some experiments to show , that glass is permeable by electricity .
I have since made others of the like kind , which seem to favour the same opinion .
Read Nov. 13 , 1760 .
The high regard your Lordship has always shown for experimental philosophy , encourages me to lay before you these experiments , with a few others , of a very curious nature .
But I beg leave , first , to take notice , that our electrical apparatus is much improved , by the discovery of Father Windelinus Ammersin , of Switzerland , who , in a Latin treatise published in 1754 , has shown us , that wood , properly dried , till it becomes very brown , is a non-conductor of electricity * ; and recommends boiling the wood in linseed oil , or covering it all over with varnish , after being dried , to prevent any return of moisture into its pores .
He * It appears , from the Philosophical Transactions , so early as the year 1747 , that Dr. Watson having occasion to support a long wire , in the experiment made near Shooter 's Hill , with a view to determine the velocity of the electric fluid , used stakes of dry wood , ( which , he tells me , were baked ) to prevent the electric fluid from escaping into the ground .
adds , that wood so treated seems to afford stronger appearances than even glass * .
The following experiments were made , with the assistance of wood thus prepared .
Being provided with a large square of glass , polished on both sides , and fixed upright upon one edge , I placed , for a conductor , a slender piece of ivory , about one foot long , having one end within two tenths of an inch from the center of the glass : at the other end were suspended two small balls of pith , by threads four inches long .
The ivory was supported horizontally by a stand made of the prepared wood .
When the glass was made a little warmer than the external air , my finger rubbed that side thereof which was farthest from , and opposite to , the ivory .
Upon doing this , the two sides of the glass were electrified plus , as were likewise the balls ; which continued plus , even after they were removed from the glass into any part of the room .
From the appearance of a plus electricity in the ivory , as well as on the two sides of the glass , the fluid must have flowed from the finger into the glass , and part of it into the ivory : otherwise , permit me to ask how the ivory should be electrified plus ?
That the fluid really flowed from the finger into the glass , may be inferred from the following experiment .
A piece of silver , being fixed upon a slender rod of prepared wood , I rubbed the same glass with it , as I had done before with the finger ; upon which the * See the Abbe Nollet 's Letters upon Electricity , published at Paris in 1760 .
silver was electrified minus , and both sides of the glass , with the conductor and balls , plus .
There are , therefore , certain circumstances under which the electric fluid passes through glass ; I repeat in certain circumstances , my Lord , because in others , for instance , the Leyden bottle , the fluid does not pass through the glass , but electrifies one side plus , and the other side minus , as my friend Dr. Franklin hath shown , in his letters upon electricity .
This difference , which is caused by the vitreous electricity in both cases , may perhaps be explained from the surrounding medium * , and the different degrees of the power with which the electric fluid endeavours to enter a body .
For the resistance owing to the surrounding medium in a polished plane , without covering , is not overcome , but by bringing the power near the glass , whereby the glass is electrified plus on both sides ; whereas , when the glass is properly covered , and the power brought upon it , the covering conducts the fluid equally to all the parts on that side , where it accumulates , that is , electrifies it plus ; whilst the opposite covering carries off to the communicating earth an equal quantity of the fluid naturally belonging to the glass , that is , electrifies it minus .
The same glass , without any covering , will be rendered minus on both sides , by removing the power to a greater distance , by which it is diminished , and the quantity of intermediate air , and consequently of resistance , increased .
* See the former paper upon the Tourmalin , p. 329 .
of this Volume , Part I. The power therefore which causes the minus effect , is less than the power which causes the plus effect : and that this minus effect arises entirely from the repulsive power of the fluid , appears from this , that part of the fluid naturally belonging to the glass , is driven off , and electrifies plus other bodies placed beyond it .
From hence I collect , that the three different effects , viz. the electrifying glass plus on both sides ; or plus on one side , and minus on the other ; or , lastly , minus on both sides ; are occasioned by the different degrees of the same power and resistance in the respective experiments with the same glass .
If , on the other hand , the three last experiments are made with the minus , instead of the plus electricity , the appearances , and consequently the reasoning upon them , are inverted : for the plus appearance , in that case , must be owing to the tendency of the fluid from the earth , air , and other neighbouring bodies , towards the opposite side of the glass , where the power acts , which causes the minus appearance .
This regular conversion serves to confirm the truth of the principles assigned .
And here , with your Lordship 's leave , I shall set down some farther experiments , most of which have been made with a view to show , that a plus electricity may be produced by means of a minus electricity .
Having electrified the inside of a large Leyden bottle plus , by means of a conducting-wire from an excited glass globe , I set it upon a stand of prepared wood , and took away the conducting-wire ; after which , the mouth of the bottle was closed with a stople of glass .
Then the pointed end of the ivory conductor was brought opposite to the middle of the bottle , and about two inches from it .
Upon doing this , the balls were electrified minus ; and more so , as the ivory was moved nearer the bottle in an horizontal direction .
But , on removing the ivory to a greater distance , the minus electricity decreased ; and , at a certain distance , there was not any sign thereof remaining : and when the distance was increased to about eighteen inches from the bottle , a plus electricity appeared , which continued , even after the ivory was removed entirely away .
After unelectrifying the bottle , it was set again upon the stand of wood ; and upon another of the same kind , was laid a large iron poker , so that the pointed end was about two inches from the outside coating , and much nearer the bottom than the top of the bottle .
I chose the lower part thereof , for no other reason , than to have the poker out of the reach of any effect that might happen from the conducting-wire , which communicated with the machine , and the inside coating of the bottle .
The other end of the poker , being a large round knob , was about one inch from a rod of iron , which communicated with the earth .
Under these circumstances , when the inside of the bottle was electrified plus , the outer coating became minus , as usual .
It is to be observed here , that the plus appearance in the poker was caused by that portion of the fluid , which was driven off from the outside of the bottle , by the repulsive force of the fluid conveyed into the bottle .
And this confirms the reasoning upon the remarkable markable experiments related in the treatise published by Dr. Hoadly and myself .
See p. 27 to 34 , and 46,47 .
Instead of electrifying the inside of the bottle , in the last experiment , plus , I electrified it minus , with the prepared wood , without any other change of circumstances .
In this case , the outside of the bottle was plus , as usual , and the poker minus .
The fluid , therefore , which caused the plus electricity on the outside of the bottle , must , in part at least , have flowed from the poker ; because there was no other open communication with the outside of the bottle and the earth to supply it .
With a cylinder of baked wood , which showed stronger signs of electricity , than I have yet been able to produce from glass , the balls hanging to the ivory were electrified minus , at the distance of four feet , or more , by holding the cylinder over the middle of the ivory , and continuing it there : and on moving it nearer , they were more strongly electrified minus ; but the same cylinder , on removing it back again to the distance of two or three feet , or more , electrified the balls plus .
When another conductor , for instance metal , without edges or points , was used instead of the ivory , and without any thing hanging from it , the same cylinder held over the metal , as was done in the last experiment over the ivory , at the distance of two feet , produced a plus electricity : and this was rendered weaker , as the cylinder was moved nearer ; but by lessening the distance to about one foot , the minus electricity took place .
In these cases , the plus appearance arose from the earth , air , or other neighbouring bodies .
When the preceding experiments were first made , I was a little embarrassed with the uncertain appearances of a plus electricity at one time , and a minus at another , in the same experiment : but , by repeated trials and observations , I have found that a plus or minus electricity may be produced at pleasure , by carefully attending to the following circumstances , viz. the form of the bodies , their sudden or gradual removal , and the degrees of electrifying .
I shall now proceed to acquaint your Lordship with some other circumstances of as nice a nature , where the slightest , and almost imperceptible differences in the position , or in the force of the friction , of two bodies , produce in either of them , the plus electricity at one time , and the minus at another .
Such are the effects of this subtle and active fluid , when the experiments are carefully made ; and therefore , they require the most scrupulous attention , to trace out the causes which occasion them .
Sealing wax and silver were the bodies used in the first two experiments ; but many other substances seem to perform as well .
The sealing wax was clean , and undisturbed by any friction whatever , but that of the air surrounding it ; and had been so for some hours .
The silver was fixed to a piece of the prepared wood , which was also preserved from friction for the same length of time .
Then taking one of these substances in each hand , the silver being at that end of the wood the farthest from the hand , I laid the smoothest part of the silver upon the sealing wax , and moved it along the surface gently , once only , and with a very slight pressure ; after which , the silver was electrified plus , and the wax minus .
On repeating the experiment , with equal care , and in the same manner , except that the smooth side of the silver was a little inclined , so that the edge thereof pressed against the wax ; the silver , after moving it as before , was electrified minus , and the wax plus ; which is contrary to what was observed in the last experiment .
These opposite effects , occasioned by the different applications of the flat , or edge of the silver , seem to arise from an alteration made in the surface of the wax , by destroying the polish in one case , and not in the other : and , in this respect , resembles the polished and rough glass mentioned in the letter upon the Tourmalin .
See p. 328 .
of this Volume , Part I. Experiment 24 .
Upon making use of prepared wood , instead of wax , and employing different degrees of pressure in the friction , with the same edge of the silver , I produced the like appearances ; the least pressure causing a plus , and the greatest pressure a minus appearance in the silver .
A flat piece of steel , well polished , and the edges rounded off , afforded the same appearances , by only applying the flat surface to the wood ; but it required more pressing to produce the minus effect in this case , than it did in the former , where the edge was concerned .
Whether the reason offered above for explaining these last curious appearances be true or not , I do not venture to affirm , for want of farther experiments ; but thus much may be safely advanced , that we have learned to produce at pleasure the plus or minus electricity from the same bodies , by attending to the manner of their application and friction .
Mr. Dufay , and the Abbe Nollet , have indeed observed an inconstancy in the effects , when they rubbed sealing wax ; but for want of the cautions above-described , in the choice and treatment of the bodies , they were not able to answer for the event of any experiment .
The Abbe , in particular , who has taken remarkable pains to find out from whence this uncertainty arises , acquaints us , in the thirteenth letter , with his difficulties , and how much it perplexed him to see , within an hour , in the same place , and with the same instruments , the effects changed , and become altogether contrary to those he had before observed .
In another part of the same letter , he says : Je me suis flat plus d'une fois d'avoir saisi les circonstances qui faisoient tourner a coup sir le resultat de l'experience d'un cote ou de l'autre ; mais la suite m'a fait connoitre que je m'etois trompe , ou qu'il manquoit encore quelque chose a ma decoverte .
' ' I might add other quotations of the same kind , but , as it would take up too much of your Lordship 's time , I shall beg leave to refer to the letter itself .
From the experience now obtained , it may not be improper to observe farther , that sealing wax of different hardness , will occasion a difference in the effects , the hardest being always plus , and the softest minus ; which agrees very well with the rule laid down in the letter upon the Tourmalin , p. 331 , that where electric appearances are produced by the rubbing of any two polished bodies together , that body , whose substance is hardest , and electric power strongest , will be always plus , and the softest and weakest always minus .
' ' Now we find that the Dutch wax is softer than the English , and the Irish harder : and it is not improbable that the French wax , which I suppose the Abbe Nollet used , may likewise be different .
Whoever , therefore , may be desirous of trying the preceding experiments , with a view to make them succeed , as they are here set down , must use the best English sealing wax .
I shall conclude with an experiment made by my friend Mr. Hamilton , professor of philosophy in the university of Dublin , as it seems to illustrate the doctrine of resistances , at least , so far as respects the air .
Let a slender brass , or iron wire , five or fix inches long , and finely pointed at each end , be fitted in the middle , with a brass cap , void of angles ; then let half an inch at each extremity be bent in opposite directions , till they are perpendicular to the rest of the wire , and in such a manner , that when the wire is suspended , by means of its cap , on a point of metal , it may lie in a plane parallel to the horizon .
The pointed metal , which supports this wire , must be two or three inches long , and have its other end fixed into a small block of wood .
Now , if this block , with a wire suspended , be set upon an electrified body , the wire will turn round with a very great velocity , moving always in a direction contrary to that in which the electric fluid issues from its points , without having any conducting substance near it , save that of the air : and if the wire be made to turn round by any other force , in the opposite direction , so that its points go foremost , it will , when electrified , soon be deprived of that motion , and made to turn round the contrary way .
This experiment , he says , was contrived , in order to try whether the electric fluid , which issues so freely from pointed bodies , would have any effect to move these bodies by its reaction ; and that it has such an effect , seems sufficiently manifest from the event .
Mr. Hamilton apprehends , that the electric particles , by their elastic force , issue directly forwards from the points , and endeavour to expand themselves ; but meeting with some resistance from the air , force the wire to move backward in a contrary direction , much in the same manner that a Catherine-wheel is made to turn round in a direction , contrary to that in which the small rockets affixed to its periphery discharge themselves .
And therefore , he is inclined to think , that it might be made use of as an electrometer , by having it to turn round in a plane perpendicular to the horizon , and loading the wire with small weights near one of its extremities , which will be raised to a greater distance from the perpendicular line , as the electric fluid is stronger .
I am , my Lord , Your Lordship 's most obliged and obedient servant , Great Queen-Street , Nov. 5 , 1760 .
Benj .
Wilson .

