LXXVIII .
A Proposal for discovering the Annual Parallax of Sirius ; by the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , A. M. Fellow of Trinity College , Cambridge , and F. R. S. THE Royal Society having come to a resolution to send persons of ability to proper places , in order to observe the approaching passage of Venus over the Sun , the 6th of June next year ; ( which phenomenon was first proposed to this Society , by the late excellent Dr. Halley , forty-four years ago , as a proper means of determining the Sun 's parallax , to a great degree of exactness ) I take this opportunity of recommending to the consideration of this learned body another very important object in astronomy , which , I apprehend , may be cleared up at the same time , by the astronomers sent to one of those places , which will probably be judged convenient for the observation of Venus 's transit ; I mean the island of St. Helena .
Read June 26 , 1760 .
The astronomical object , in favour of which I desire to engage your attention , is no less than the determination of the annual parallax of the Orbis Magnus ; the finding out of which , from observation , would be the fullest and directest proof of the Copernican system , as the want of this proof , hitherto , has been the strongest argument made use of by those , who have with-held their assent to an hypothesis , which so fully , and yet simply , satisfies all the other phenomenon .
No one , indeed , at this time of day , will venture to assert , that , even if no annual parallax could be found , after the greatest exertion of human art and industry , the Copernican system was not , therefore , true ; since the quantity of this parallax may be so small , as to escape the reach of our sight , though assisted to the utmost .
But though the defect of it would be no just argument against the Copernican system , yet the actual demonstration of it , from observation , would be a direct and convincing proof of the truth of that system .
It remains then to be considered , what hope there is now left , after astronomy has been brought to such a great degree of perfection , of being able to find out an annual parallax in any of the fixed stars .
I am sensible I may here seem to be presumptuous , in venturing to treat upon this subject , after the many accurate observations made by the learned Dr. Bradley , with an instrument constructed for this very purpose .
No one can have a higher veneration than I have for the discernment and exactness of this illustrious astronomer , whose merit I have the greater opportunity of being acquainted with , by having the honour of calling him my friend .
I would just beg leave to take notice , that the stars , which this astronomer observed , were such only as lay within a few degrees of his zenith : and though his observations do not seem to show a sensible parallax in any of them , yet we cannot thence absolutely conclude , that , amongst the great number of visible stars , there are none in which it may be perceptible , till they have all of them , especially those of the greatest lustre , been observed in proper places , near the zenith , with the like care and accuracy , which he has used : for , as Dr. Bradley has himself remarked , where any stars are remote from the zenith , the uncertainties of refraction , and the irregular motions of the air , become so great , as to take away from us all hopes of observing them to an equal degree of exactness .
The particular star , which , I propose , should be carefully observed , with a view of discovering its annual parallax , if sensible , is Sirius , the brightest of all the stars in the firmament , and which is therefore , probably , the nearest to us of them all .
With us , this star passes the meridian , at the altitude of 22~ , where the refractions are too irregular to admit of our discovering a very minute quantity , by observation : but , at the island of St. Helena , Sirius passes only half a degree south of the zenith ; and , on this account , I have , for some time , looked upon that as the most proper place to make observations at , for this purpose .
I shall now beg leave , with great deference , to lay before you a particular argument , which has , for these two years , induced me to think it probable , that the annual parallax of Sirius is not so small , as to elude the nice discernment of our modern astronomers ; and shall be glad to be determined by your opinion , whether it affords a sufficient presumption to us , to undertake a careful and assiduous series of observations of the distances of Sirius , from the zenith of the island of St. Helena .
This argument is drawn from an examination , which I have made , of the observations of the zenith distances of Sirius , taken at the cape of Good Hope , in the years 1751 and 1752 , by that excellent astronomer , and diligent observer , the Abbe de la Caille , recited in his Fundamenta Astronomiae , printed about two years since , wherein also are contained all the observations , which he has taken of the principal fixed stars ; a work truly worthy of its name !
Every particular observation of the same star is reduced to one epoch , that of the beginning of the year 1750 , by applying the equations of aberration , precession , and deviation , to the observed places ; so that the places corrected ought all to agree together , if the observations were perfectly exact , and the star was affected with no sensible motion , that was unaccounted for .
Being satisfied with the excellence of the observations , I was tempted to examine those of some of the principal fixed stars , in hopes of discovering some sensible differences in the observations made at different times of the year , when a parallax , if there had been any , would have had the greatest effect .
But I found very few stars , the observations of which were sufficient in number , or taken at proper seasons of the year , to give room for any inference at all .
Fortunately , however , the observations of the zenith distances of Sirius were more in number , and , what is still of more consequence , in this case , made in various , and some in opposite seasons of the year : and , upon looking them over , I was agreeably surprised to find a very sensible difference in the observations made at different times , agreeing in direction with what a parallax ought to produce , the zenith distance of Sirius in July coming out no less than 8~ greater than in the opposite season of the year , namely in December and January : the zenith distance also in March and April being of an intermediate quantity , as it ought to be : for , Sirius being in conjunction with the Sun in June and July , it is evident he must be then farther from the Earth than in December and January , when he is in opposition to the Sun , and , consequently , his latitude and declination , which are both south , must be less in the former case , than in the latter ; and therefore , as he passes north of the zenith at the cape of Good Hope , his zenith distance must be greater in the former season , than in the latter , as the observations indicate : but , in March and April , when Sirius is in quadrature with the Sun , and equally distant from the Sun and Earth , his apparent latitude and zenith distance must be the same as the true , or that which would obtain , if the Earth was translated to the Sun , and consequently , a mean between the zenith distances in July and December , agreeably to the observations .
I shall now lay before you the observations themselves , together with the calculations , which I have made of the values of the parallax for each , the maximum being assumed 9~ , which I find will best reconcile the observations with one another .
Zenith distance Annual Zenith distance Difference between of Sirius at Cape , parallaX corrected for aneach observation corobserved and reto reduce nual parallax .
rected , and the mean duced .
observat , of the distances corto mean .
rected .
~~~~ 1751 .
July 12 .
17 31 19.1 4.3 17 31 14.8 1.1 July 13 .
17 31 19.3 4.3 17 31 15.0 0.9 July 14 .
21.7 4.3 17.4 + 1.5 July 15 .
19.7 4.3 15.4 0.5 July 16 .
19.0 4.3 14.7 1.2 1752 .
April 5 .
16.7 1.0 15.7 0.2 April 3 .
15.7 0.8 14.9 1.0 March 28 .
14.0 0.4 13.6 2.3 March 14 .
13.1 + 0.7 13.8 2.1 March 8 .
15.2 + 1.2 16.4 + 0.5 March 5 .
18.8 + 1.4 20.2 + 4.3 March 4 .
17.3 + 1.5 18.8 + 2.9 March 1 .
15.9 + 1.6 17.5 + 1.6 Feb. 17 .
12.8 + 2.6 15.4 0.5 Jan. 21 .
11.1 + 4.0 15.1 0.8 1751 .
Dec. 31 .
11.6 + 4.5 16.1 + 0.2 Mean of zenith distances corrected for parallax 17 31 15.9 The first column shows the year and day of the observations ; the second the zenith distances of Sirius at the cape of Good Hope , as delivered in Abbe de la Caille 's recital ; the third contains the computed values of the parallax at different times , taking that of the maximum 9~ ; the fourth column gives observations reduced to the mean , by applying the parallax computed in the third column to the observations in the second ; which quantities ought all to agree together , if the observations were liable to no error , and the parallax was rightly assumed : but , taking a mean of them all , the last column shows how much each of them differs from that mean , which , in general , is very small , and scarce exceeds 2~ , except in two observations , in one of which it amounts to 3~ , and the other to 4~ : but these differ as much from the mean of the six other observations made at the same season of the year .
Thus , assuming a parallax , the observations will be found to agree as well with that supposition , as they do with one another .
But if the observations are considered in themselves , without any allowance for parallax , they will differ sensibly from one another : nor is this difference to be found only in two observations , in which case , it may easily be attributed to the account of the unavoidable errors ; but five observations in July opposed to two in December and January , make the zenith distances vary 8~ in the direction , which a parallax ought to produce .
I am aware , that it may be objected , that two observations made in the winter season in December and January , at one of the maxima of the parallax , are too few to determine a point of such consequence , and readily agree , that the argument is weakened in proportion to the paucity of the observations : but then , it should also be considered , that the observations made in March and April concur with the rest in supporting the supposition of a parallax ; and , upon the whole , the observations will , perhaps , be judged to afford a sufficient presumption of the existence of a parallax , to encourage the undertaking a careful trial .
It is upon the strength of this presumption , principally , that I have ventured to lay these thoughts before the Royal Society , whose members may justly claim the honour of having made the greatest attempts towards , demonstrating this important , but yet undetermined point in astronomy .

