LXXVI .
Some Observations upon a SamniteEtruscan Coin , never before fully explained .
In a Letter from the Rev. John Swinton , B. D. of Christ-Church , Oxon .
F. R. S. to the Rev. Thomas Birch , D. D. Secretary to the Royal Society .
Reverend Sir , I Have in my small collection a silver Etruscan coin , of the size of the consular denarii , similar to one published by ( 1 ) Fulvius Ursinus , ( 2 ) Patin , ( 3 ) Vaillant , ( 4 ) Havercamp , Read June 19 , 1760 .
( 1 ) Fulv .
Ursin .
in Famil .
Romanar .
num .
incert .
( 2 ) Car .
Pat .
ibid. ( 3 ) J. Vaill .
in Famil .
Romanar .
num .
incert .
( 4 ) Sig. Haverc .
apud Andr .
Morel .
in Thesaur .
Numismat .
p. 459 .
and Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri ( 5 ) , a gentleman of Pesaro , who has written two learned dissertations upon three or four medals of the same kind ; all which , with the greatest appearance of truth , he takes to have been struck on occasion of the Social war .
Fulvius Ursinus , Patin , Vaillant , Morel , and Havercamp assign the medal resembling mine a place amongst the uncertain , or unknown , consular coins ; though Havercamp ( 6 ) , without any manner of foundation , affirms it to be a medal of Faleria .
But this is not to be wondered at , as he seems to have been almost an entire stranger to the Etruscan character .
Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri has , with the highest degree of probability , determined it to be ( 7 ) a Samnite coin ; and clearly evinced it to have first appeared in ( 8 ) , or about , the year of Rome 663 .
But notwithstanding this most learned and ingenious gentleman has so perfectly well explained three very rare silver Etruscan medals of C. Papius Mutilus , who commanded the Samnite troops in the Social war , that not the least doubt can be entertained of the truth of his explication ; notwithstanding he has sufficiently proved the coin I am considering to have been adorned with the name of the pretor of the ( 5 ) Saggi di Dissertazioni Accademiche pubblicamente let nella Nobile Accademia Etrusca dell ' antichissima Citta di Cortona .
Tom. II .
p. 49-72 .
&amp; Tom. IV .
p. 133-148 .
( 6 ) Sig. Haverc .
apud Andr .
Morel .
in Thesaur .
Numismat .
sive Sig. Haverc .
Comment .
in Famil .
Roman .
num .
omn .
&amp;c. p. 459 .
( 7 ) Annib .
degli Abati Olivier .
in Saggi &amp;c. ubi sup. ( 8 ) Id. ibid. Marsi , who likewise distinguished himself against the Romans , in the same ruinous and destructive war ; yet I cannot prevail upon myself absolutely to congratulate him , upon his discovery of all the Etruscan characters forming that name .
His dissertation here does not come quite up to the point .
Of this he seems himself to have been aware , when he informed the learned world , that , ` ` after having viewed the Etruscan inscription with a very good glass , and well considered it , he thought he could make out the following letters , P. ITEEIV ; and that if such another medal should hereafter be found , with the elements better preserved , it might perhaps confirm his ( 9 ) conjecture .
' ' Having therefore a similar coin now in my possession , I hope I shall be indulged the liberty of transmitting to the Royal Society a few brief and concise observations upon it ; especially , as these may perhaps throw some new light upon Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri 's discoveries , and serve as a short supplement to his two most learned and elaborate dissertations .
The laureated head on my Etruscan denarius is adorned with an ear-ring , not visible either on Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri 's medal , or any of those published by Fulvius Ursinus , Dr. Patin , Dr. Vaillant , and Mr. Havercamp .
There is a minute difference between the lower part of the lance , held in the right hand of the galeated figure on the reverse of the piece before me , and the same part of the lance , exhibited by the other coins .
The drapery likewise of the galeated figure on the first of these is ( 9 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz , Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 65 , 66 .
something different from that of the same figure on the rest .
The foot of the ox or bull seems hairy on my denarius , but not so on the others .
All which singularities , together with the additional Etruscan element at the end of the inscription , representing R , and the Etruscan M on the reverse , will perhaps entitle the medal I am considering to the denomination of an inedited coin .
The workmanship is good , but somewhat different from that of the consular denarii , particularly those of the same age .
Mr. Havercamp justly remarks , that the legend , or inscription , here is Etruscan ( 10 ) ; but by no means ascertains the forms and powers of the letters , of which it is composed .
He even took the Etruscan A in the exergue of his own medal , which does not appear in that of mine , for an ( 11 ) inverted R. Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri calls these small silver pieces ( 12 ) Etruscan medals , because they have scarce any thing in common with those of Rome , and are adorned with Etruscan characters , or such as were in the earlier ages the letters of all Italy , then subject to the Etruscans ; but at the same time he observes , that they might with greater propriety , notwithstanding the authority of the Marquis Scipio Maffei , be termed Italian coins .
As I remember not to have seen an alphabet of the Samnite-Etruscan characters , exhibited to the public ; I have taken the liberty to transmit one to the Royal Society , deduced from some very valuable Samnite(10 ) Sig. Haverc .
ubi sup. p. 459 .
( 11 ) Id. ibid. ( 12 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 49 .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LI .
TAB. XX.p .
857 .
I. II .
~ Penes Joannem Swinton , S.T.B. Oxoniens .
R.S.S. Penes Joannem Swinton , S.T.B. Oxoniens .
R.S.S. III .
~ In Gaz .
Pemb .
The ~-Etruscan alphabet , deduced from the Coins of C. Papins Mutilus , Veturius , Capua , ~ , &amp;c. and used in several parts of Italy so late as the Year of Rome 663 .
~A ~B ~C ~E ~H ~TH ~I ~L ~M ~N ~P ~R ~S ~T ~V ~PH or F ~EI Etruscan coins .
The ducts of the letters are drawn with so much accuracy , that they may be entirely depended upon .
[ Vide Tab. XX .
] The inscription here mentioned , standing behind the laureated head on this denarius , is drawn from the right hand to the left , after the Etruscan manner , and consists of eight letters .
The first of these is the Digamma , equivalent to V or F , as it appears on the celebrated tables of Gubbio , and several Etruscan coins .
The second is apparently I , and the sixth will undoubtedly be taken for the same element .
The third is manifestly T , both on my medal and every similar one hitherto published .
The fourth and fifth must be E , though the latter of these has not been perfectly well preserved on my coin .
The seventh will be universally considered as V , though only part of it is visible on the piece before me .
The eighth is the Etruscan R , as presented to our view by one of the medals of C. Papius Mutilus , by the tables of Gubbio , and by other Etruscan remains of antiquity .
It is very perfect and entire , and not exhibited by any such piece that has hitherto appeared ( 13 ) .
Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri seems inclined to take the first element of the inscription ( 14 ) for P. But this is probably done in order to accommodate the name to the corrupted text of Velleius .
The form he himself has given us of this letter bears scarce any resemblance to that of the Etruscan P , on the medals of C. Papius Mutilus ; but approaches near enough to that of the ( 13 ) Tab. Eugubin .
pass .
Vid. etiam Gor .
Mus. Etrusc .
Vol. II .
&amp; Dempst .
De Etrur .
Regal .
Tom. I. ( 14 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 65 .
Digamma , or Etruscan V , above-mentioned .
( 15 ) Mr. Havercamp 's denarius , as well as mine , and that described by M. Morel , sets the point here insisted upon beyond dispute .
From the foregoing observations we may collect , that our inscription , in Roman , or modern Latin , letters , will be FITEEIVR , or VITEEIVR ; which , in the cacography of the Etruscans , as their rude and uncouth manner of writing is termed by Sig. Passeri ( 16 ) , seems to answer to the VETVRI , or rather VETVRIVS , of the Romans .
If this be admitted , it will be allowed extremely probable , that the name of the general , who commanded the Marsi in the Italian war , was FITEEIVR , VITEEIVR , or VETVRIVS , and neither VETTIVS nor INSTEIVS , as Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri seems inclinable ( 17 ) to believe .
This general is called Vettius , or C. Vettius , by ( 18 ) Claudius Quadrigarius ; Insteius , or Insteius Cato , by ( 19 ) Velleius ; ~ ~ , Vetius Cato , by ( 20 ) Appian ; P. Vettius , or P. Vettius Scato , by ( 21 ) Cicero ; Vellius , or Vellius Cato , by ( 22 ) Florus ; and T. Vettius , T. Vetius , T. Vetitius , and T. Vietius , in different manuscripts ( 15 ) Sig. Haverc .
ubi sup. p. 459 .
( 16 ) Jo. Bapt .
Passer .
Pisaurens .
De Num. Etrusc .
Paestanor .
Dissertat .
p. 18 .
in Symbol .
Literar .
opusc .
var .
&amp;c. Vol. II .
Florentiae , 1748 .
( 17 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 65 , 66 .
( 18 ) Claud .
Quadrigar , apud Senec .
De Benef .
Lib. iii .
c. 23 .
( 19 ) Vell .
Paterc .
Lib. ii .
c. 16 .
( 20 ) Appian .
Alexandrin .
p. 375 .
( 21 ) Cic .
Philip .
xii .
11 .
( 22 ) Flor. apud Sig. Havercamp .
in not .
ad Eutrop , p. 206 .
Lugd. Batavor .
1729 .
and printed editions of ( 23 ) Eutropius .
From whence we may infer , that the name of this general has been corrupted in most , if not all , of the texts of those authors ; even upon the supposition , that our coin bears not any relation to him .
But as ( 24 ) Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri has clearly evinced the truth of the contrary supposition , the variety of corruptions here produced will add no small weight to what is more than suggested by the denarius I am considering ; so that the inscription exhibited by this small medal is even supported by those corruptions , and will undoubtedly , in the opinion of the most learned men , ascertain the name of the general , who commanded the Marsi in the Italian war .
In farther eviction of what is here advanced , it may be observed , that the proper name VETVRIVS itself has also been indisputably corrupted in other passages of ancient writers .
In one of Cicero ( 25 ) it has been transformed into Betucius , and in one of Plutarch ( 26 ) into ~ , or Butetius .
Which being maturely weighed , it will not appear strange , that this general 's family name should have met with so hard a fate .
For that the piece I am endeavouring to explain is one of his coins , will be acknowledged more than probable , if we consider with proper attention what has been urged by Sig. Annibale degli Abati ( 27 ) Olivieri in favour of ( 23 ) Eutrop .
Hist. Rom .
Lib. v. c. 3 .
p. 205 , 206 .
Ed. Havercamp .
Lugd. Bat .
1729 .
( 24 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 65 , 66 .
( 25 ) Cic .
in Bruto .
( 26 ) Plutarch .
in Quaest .
Roman .
( 27 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
Tom. II .
p. 65 , 66 .
such a notion .
He has demonstrated this denarius and one of C. Papius Mutilus to be of nearly the same size and workmanship , to be adorned with inscriptions consisting of the same sort of characters , and to have the very same type on the reverse .
He has also incontestably proved , from the best authorities that can be produced , that C. Papius Mutilus , mentioned by the coins he has so learnedly explained , was cotemporary with our Veturius , or , as he denominates him , P. Iteeius , and the general under whose conduct the Samnites so greatly distinguished themselves , in the aforesaid ruinous war , against the Romans .
But this will still receive a farther accession of strength from another consideration , relative to the point I am now upon , which ought by no menas to be omitted here .
Two ( 28 ) medals of the Veturian family and one of ( 29 ) C. Papius Mutilus exhibit almost exactly the same type on the reverse , though the inscriptions they bear consist of different characters .
This amounts at least to a pretty strong presumption , that Ti .
Veturius , whose name occurs on one of the Roman denarii , was either the pretor of the Marsi himself or related to some commander of the allies of the same name ; as ( 30 ) Mr. Havercamp takes the piece to have been struck not long after the Italians had the right of suffrage conferred upon them by the Romans , in order to perpetuate the memory of that remarkable event .
I say , ` ` or related to some commander of the allies of the same ( 28 ) J. Vaill .
in Num. Fam .
Vetur .
p. 533 .
( 29 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. ubi sup. ( 30 ) Sig. Haverc .
Comment .
in Famil .
Roman .
num .
omn .
&amp;c. p. 438 , 439 , 440 .
name ; ' ' because it cannot perhaps be so easily proved , that he was our Veturius himself .
For we are told by Claudius ( 31 ) Quadrigarius , in a fragment of his preserved to us by Seneca , that one of this general 's slaves killed him , in order to prevent his falling into the hands of the Romans ; which seems to intimate , that he was dead before the conclusion of the Social war , or at least before the Italians were put upon an equal foot with the Romans .
However , his name might have been impressed upon this denarius , after his death .
Whether or no the Veturian family itself deduced its origin from the Marsi , notwithstanding the silence of Fulvius Ursinus , Dr. Vaillant , and Mr. Havercamp , on that head , I shall not take upon me to determine .
Be this , however , as it will , from the family name ~ , FITEEIVR , or VITEEIVR , on the silver Etruscan , or Samnite , medal , which at present is the principal object of my attention , we may infer , that the Etruscan orthography was very rough and unpolished , at least in some of the Italian provinces , so late as the 662d , or 663d , year of Rome ; when that of the Romans , now called the Latin , was arrived at almost the last degree of perfection .
It must nevertheless be owned , that the later Latin , or Roman , letters ( so denominated in contradistinction to the ancient Latin characters , undoubtedly the same with the Etruscan , and used by the Romans themselves in the earliest times ) as well as the Etruscan , were in vogue amongst several of the Italian states , when the medals of C. Papius Mutilus and Veturius were struck .
This most evidently appears , from the silver ( 31 ) Claud , Quadrigar .
apud Senec .
ubi sup. pieces , with the word ITALIA upon them , explained by Sig. ( 32 ) Annibale degli Abati Olivieri , in his first dissertation ; and from a similar one in my little cabinet , hitherto unpublished , which I lately acquired .
Hence some learned men may perhaps be inclined to believe , that both the denarius of the Veturian family and the coin by me here referred to our Veturius did in reality exhibit the name of the general of the Marsi , and first appeared about the 663d year of Rome .
With regard to the word ~ , or VETVRIVS , mentioned in the beginning of this paragraph , I shall beg leave to remark , that it might as easily have been transformed into VETTIVS , or VETIVS , in the manuscripts and printed editions of some ancient writers , as PAPIVS into APONIVS in those of others ; and that the ( 33 ) word APONIVS , for PAPIVS , stands in the text of Diodorus Siculus , as cited by Photius .
With which observations I shall conclude what I have here to say , in defence of my lection of this Etruscan inscription .
As I only intend this paper to be a short supplement to Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri 's two most excellent dissertations upon his Samnite coins , it would be entirely superfluous to attempt an explication of the types exhibited by those coins ; especially , as this has already been done in so ample a manner , with so much sagacity and erudition , by that very ingenious gentleman himself , the learned Sig. Bianconi , and the most acute Sig. Passeri , that scarce any thing new or material on that head can be added to their observations .
However , it may not be improper ( 32 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 57 .
( 33 ) Diod .
Sic .
apud Photium , in Myriobibl .
p. 1185 , 1186 .
Ed. Schot .
Rothomagi , 1653 .
just to remark , that both the denarii of C. Papius Mutilus and the piece by me attributed to our Veturius ( 34 ) were coined , in commemoration of the alliance entered into by the Italian states against the Romans , about the time of the commencement of the Social war ; whereas the Roman medal of Ti .
Veturius ( 35 ) , according to Mr. Havercamp , was probably struck after the conclusion of that war , and even after the admission of the Italian allies into the city , the memory of which it was perhaps intended to perpetuate , by the Romans .
That the Etruscan pieces here considered were struck on occasion of the Italian war , or war of the allies , is likewise abundantly clear , from a most rare Etruscan medal in Lord ( 36 ) Pembroke 's noble collection , never hitherto explained .
It is adorned with such a laureated head as occurs on Veturius 's coin , and on the reverse a bull goring with one of his horns a furious wild beast , resembling a monstrous dog , he had got under him , together with the Etruscan inscription , ~~~ ~ , C. PAAPI MVTIL EMBRATVR , though very indifferently copied .
This is a fourth Etruscan , or Samnite , coin of C. Papius Mutilus , the Samnite general ; which Sig. Annibale degli Abati Olivieri had neither seen nor heard of , when he published those two learned dissertations , which this paper is intended to render a little more complete .
The bull on Lord Pembroke 's medal undoubtedly denoted the states of Italy , or rather ( 34 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 65-72 .
&amp; Tom. IV .
p. 140-148 .
( 35 ) Sig. Havercamp .
Comment .
in Famil .
Roman .
num .
omn .
&amp; 'c .
p. 438 , 439 , 440 .
( 36 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp; 'c .
Thom .
Pembroch .
et Mont .
Gomeric .
Com. P. 2 .
T. 87 .
num .
10 .
the union of those states , combined against the Romans , as the fierce animal under him did the senate and people of Rome ; the whole type pointing out to us the hoped for superiority of the former over the latter , or rather being intended as a prognostication of such superiority .
That the bull was the symbol of several Italian cities , or states ( 37 ) , appears from the coins of Posidonia , Thurium , Arpi , &amp;c. and that the ( 38 ) word ~ , Italus , or Italian , in the old Etruscan tongue , the primitive language of all Italy , signified a bull , whence probably that animal might become the symbol of at least a very considerable part of this country , is a point so exceeding clear , that it will not admit of a dispute .
To what has been said we may add , that the Italians looked upon the Roman republic , about the time of the Social war , as a receptacle of wolves , always ready , if not determined , to ravish their liberty from them .
This we may collect from the following words of Pontius Telesinus , in Velleius : ( 39 ) adjiciens , nunquam defuturos raptores Italicae libertatis lupos , nisi silva , in quam refugere solerent , esset excisa .
This observation may possibly throw some new light upon Lord Pembroke 's medal , as well as upon the type of my Etruscan denarius , and the similar one of C. Papius Mutilus 's coin , which seems to have a little embarrassed the learned ( 40 ) author I have all along here had principally in view .
( 37 ) Hubertus Goltzius , in Magn. Graec .
Numism .
pass .
( 38 ) Apollodor .
Lib. ii .
Isacius ad Lycophronem , &amp; Tzetzes in Chiliadibus .
( 39 ) Vell .
Paterc .
Lib. ii .
c. 27 .
( 40 ) Sag .
di Dissertaz .
Accademich .
&amp;c. Tom. II .
p. 66 , 67 .
&amp; Tom. IV .
p. 141 .
As the foregoing Etruscan coins are proved to have been struck about the 662d or 663d ( 41 ) year of Rome , the Etruscan alphabet then undoubtedly prevailed over a very considerable part of Italy ; though the forms of some of the characters , particularly those of A , P , and I , were not precisely the same with those of the equipollent letters used in Umbria and the ( 42 ) Proper Etruria .
I shall only at present beg leave farther to remark , that the reverse of my Etruscan denarius has handed down to us a new form of the Etruscan M , placed in the exergue , which has never been before observed on any of the Etruscan remains of antiquity ; and that I am , with sentiments of the highest respect and esteem , SIR , Your most obliged , and most obedient , humble servant , Christ-Church , Oxon .
May 19 , 1760 .
J. Swinton .

