LXXV .
An Account of a Case of a luxated Thigh Bone reduced ; by Mr. Charles Young , Surgeon , at Plymouth : Communicated by John Huxham , M. D. F. R. S. AS John Down , a middle sized man , aged about forty , was , on the 21st August 1759 , harnessing his master 's horses , they suddenly took fright , and ran away with the chaise .
He had his back towards the chaise , the wheel of which , as it rolled very swiftly along , struck him on the upper and hinder part of the right thigh .
He fell to the ground , and was unable to rise again , and complained immediately of a violent pain in his right hip .
I came to him soon after the accident , and caused him to be put to bed ; when , on examination , I found his only complaint was the violent pain about the articulation of the femur with the ischium , which was increased by any even the least motion of the limb .
Read June 12 , limb .
The toe was turned in toward the heel of the left foot , and the heel of course outward ; and the whole limb , from the head of the femur to the toes end , distorted in proportion .
I thought it was very evident , at first sight , that there must be either a fracture of the femur , or a dislocation of its articulation with the ischium .
The former , I think , would have been easily discoverable .
But as by laying my hand on the great trochanter , while an assistant turned the foot inward and outward alternately , I could perceive , that the motion of the great trochanter corresponded exactly to the motion of the lowest end of the femur , I concluded , that , had there been a fracture , it must have been between the great trochanter and the head of the bone .
And , had this been the case , I expected to have been able to discover it , by the grating , that is always to be felt , when the two broken ends of a bone are moved against one another .
But no such thing being perceivable , and yet the limb so much distorted , and the pain so violent , and confined to the parts about the joint , I took it for granted , and pronounced the case to be a dislocation of the femur ; and consequently endeavoured to reduce it , by the usual method of extension .
To this end , two men extended the limb , by pulling on napkins tied round the ancle , while others counteracted them , by pulling on a sheet passed between his legs , and secured at the bed 's head , turning the foot outward as they made the extension .
This gave him great pain ; but the limb soon became , in every respect , parallel to the other .
It appeared as long , and , on laying it down on the bed , the great toes and heels of both feet lay exactly in the same position ; and the only difference , which I could perceive in the two limbs , was , that there was a little flatness about the hip of the right side .
In short , the difference between the two limbs was so little , that I began to think I had been mistaken in my opinion of a dislocation ( for it was evident there was no reduction made by the extension , for that could not but have been perceived , both by the patient and myself ) , and that the distortion of the limb was owing to nothing else than an involuntary contraction of the muscles , occasioned by the violence of the blow .
I therefore bled him , confined him to lie on his back , and charged him to move as little as possible ; imagining , that rest would be his most effectual remedy .
He continued in much pain for some days ; but by degrees grew tolerably easy , except when the limb was moved ; and at about twelve days after the accident , he could suffer the limb to be lifted to and fro gently , with little or no pain at all .
Notwithstanding which , he could no more lift it of himself than at first , when it was much more painful .
This embarrassed me a good deal .
I was convinced there was no fracture of the limb , in any part ; and I thought , from the circumstances above related , there could hardly be a dislocation .
I therefore desired the opinion of two other surgeons , who , on seeing the position of the limb , and inquiring into all the circumstances , which did and had attended it , agreed with me in opinion , that it was no fracture , and that it was equally unlikely , under these circumstances , there should be any dislocation .
For the right leg , when placed by the side of the other leg , as I have said already , was exactly parallel to it , and continued so , unless the patient~ either when asleep or at any other time , moved his body , so as to drag his leg : in that case , the toe was always found inclining inwards , and the heel outward ; but never so , but that it might be replaced , without the least difficulty or pain to him , but just so as one might have done by a limb that was paralytic .
We therefore recommended rest , hoping that farther rest and time would recover the perfect ease and strength of the limb .
But some days passing without any alteration , I gave him a strong purgative , and repeated it every other or every third day , for several times , in order to reduce the muscles , that I might the more plainly feel any thing through them .
For though he was , in point of height , but middle sized , he was pretty fleshy , and the glutaei muscles consequently too thick to suffer any thing to be felt with any degree of distinctness through them .
This answered my expectation fully ; for , by repeating the purgative often , and at short intervals , his living sparingly , and being confined to his bed , he became much emaciated , insomuch , that the head of the femur was plainly felt through the muscles , dislocated backward , and lying in the space between the os ischium and os sacrum .
Of this I acquainted the gentlemen , who had examined it before , and desired them to examine it a second time ; which they did , on the 15th September , and were immediately convinced , that the os femoris was dislocated , and that it was the head of the bone we felt through the glutaei muscles , in the space between the ischium and sacrum .
To the head of the bone 's lying in this space , it was probably owing that we were at first deceived ; since its being there allowed a greater latitude of motion , than could possibly have been the case any where else ; which may serve to account for the parallelism of the limb to that of the other , notwithstanding a luxation .
But , on turning the foot inward and outward by turns , while an assistant laid his hand on the head of the bone , a grating was perceived , both by the patient and us all .
This somewhat surprised us at first ; but , as this grating was never to be perceived , without pressing pretty hardly on the head of the bone , at the time the limb was turned round , and as the head of the bone was plainly felt to turn round , whenever the thigh had that motion given to it , we concluded it could be nothing but the side of the head of the femur against the edge of the ischium .
Convinced of this , we determined to make an extension ; and , to that end , brought him to the foot of the bed , and placed him on his back , with the bed 's post between his thighs , which was wrapped round with cloths , to prevent its galling him .
A napkin was tied round his leg , at the ancle , which two assistants pulled on , while a third turned the knee outward , and I had my hand on the head of the bone , pressing it downward .
As soon as the extension began , I perceived plainly the bone sink under my hand , which I had hardly time to say , before it gave a snap , which was felt by the patient , and heard by us all , and the bone was reduced .
When he was laid on his back in the bed , the right leg appeared somewhat longer than the other ; but that might possibly be owing to the muscles not immediately overcoming the effect of the extension sufficiently , to draw the head of the femur to the bottom of the acetabulum .
In about six or seven days he was easy , and able to walk over the room with crutches , and bear a considerable weight of his body on the right leg ; and , from this time , he recovered strength very fast , and is now , and has long been , as strong in that leg and thigh , as in the other , without any even the least difference in length , or any other respect .
To Dr. Huxham .
SIR , Plymouth , May 1760 .
I Have sent you the above case of John Down ; because I know it is asserted by some surgeons , and among those of the greatest character too , that a luxation of the head of the femur is little less than impossible ; and that what is generally taken for a luxation of this joint , is a fracture of the bone at its neck .
A fracture of the neck of the bone probably happens more often than a dislocation .
But the above case has convinced me , that it may happen , and that without any extraordinary violence , provided the force is aptly applied .
Indeed any force applied in the direction of the thigh downward can hardly have any tendency to dislocate it at all ; and any force from below upward will be sustained by the head of the femur bearing against the upper part of the acetabulum , till the neck , the weakest part , gives way .
But though it may not be possible , that the femur should be luxated by any force applied in a direction parallel to that of the thigh , in an erect posture of the body , it is not equally impossible it should be dislocated by a force applied in a contrary direction .
For , in the above case , the blow was received on the upper and hinder part of the thigh , in a direction forward , from the wheel of the chaise , which must necessarily have a tendency to drive it round forward , and consequently cant the head of the femur out of the acetabulum , backwards , where it is less deep than it is either above or below .
On the fore part of the acetabulum , it is yet more shallow , and therefore less force is required to dislocate it that way , and more especially , as there is on that side less strength of muscles to resist .
It was probably a fortunate circumstance for this man , that I thought myself mistaken in my first opinion of its being a dislocation ; for , had that been clearly the case , I should , no doubt , have used every method , and every assistance to be had , in order to have reduced it immediately ; and most likely , while the muscles remained in their full strength , and contracting involuntarily , and that violently too , as they will sometimes do , upon attempting an extension of them , and under which circumstance , the muscular fibres oftentimes rather break than give way , should have failed of being able to reduce it ; and , in that case , the man must have remained a cripple as long as he lived : whereas now , though five-and-twenty days from the time of the accident , the muscles were so much weakened , by his being confined to his bed , and wasted by his frequently repeated purges , that they very easily gave way , and the reduction was effected with as little difficulty , as ever I saw in a dislocation of the humerus .
Might not the giving strong purgatives , and frequently repeating them , so as to render the muscles of strong muscular subjects more lax and weak , be a means of reducing luxations of the humerus , which are not reducible by any method of extension , which is often found the case ?
I am , SIR , Your very humble servant ,

