LXIX .
An Enquiry into the Measure of the Roman Foot ; by Matthew Raper , Esq ; F. R. S. THE methods that have hitherto been taken to discover the measure of the Roman foot , will , upon examination , be found so unsatisfactory , that it is no wonder the learned are not yet agreed in that point .
Read May 15 , 22 , and June 5 , 1760 .
The ancient foot-rules now remaining ; the representations of the foot in sculpture ; and the measure of it , derived from the congius , differ so much among themselves , and from each other , as to be insufficient evidences separately : and the great disagreement of the foot from the congius , with the rest , has not hitherto been satisfactorily accounted for .
The foot-rules found in old ruins at Rome , are of various lengths ; and the age of none of them being certainly known , no precise measure can be determined from them , otherwise than by taking a mean from such as appear to be most perfect .
But though this may have been the foot in use at some time or other , yet as these rules are probably of different ages , both the greatest and the least of them may have answered to the standards of their times .
For though we have no account of any alteration ever made in the standard of the Roman foot , yet the wear of a standard measure by use , and the making new to replace the old ones , must , in all probability , create a difference ; especially , as the Romans had not those inducements to so precise an accuracy in these matters , as the later discoveries in natural philosophy ( particularly the invention of the pendulum ) have introduced among the moderns .
Add to this , that the different state of Europe , which has , for some ages , been divided into many considerable kingdoms and sovereign states , independent on each other , equally civilized , and carrying on a more constant and regular mercantile commerce with each other , than was known to the Romans , must necessarily introduce more frequent enquiries into the weights and measures of the different states , and a more careful examination of the respective standards of each , than the Romans could have any occasion for : and use in these matters , is the parent of accuracy .
We can arrive at no greater certainty from the marbles , than from the foot-rules .
These , indeed , do not differ so widely from each other , as the rules ; which seems to be the reason why most of the writers on this subject have given them the preference : but of the four that are extant , no two agree in the same measure ; nor is the age of any one of them known : and as they were intended for representations only , and not for use , their accuracy may reasonably be doubted .
Festus , Frontinus , and Rhemnius Fannius , say , the side of the quadrantal ( which contained 8 congii ) was a Roman foot ( 1 ) .
A standard congius of Vespasian ( 1 ) Quadrantal vocabant antiqui quam ex Graeco ~ dicunt , quod vas pedis quadrati octo et quadraginta capit sextarios .
Festus in v. Quadrantal .
Pes quadratus concavus capit amphora Vespasian is still in being , and has been measured by several learned men ; but the foot derived from it exceeds those on the marbles , and the greatest number of the foot-rules , so much , that Mr. Greaves could find no better way of accounting for so great a difference , than by supposing what Festus and Fannius say ( for he does not quote Frontinus ) , to be a vulgar error ( 2 ) : whereas the name of this standard shows its figure to have been a cube ( 3 ) ; which adds probability to their testimony , that its side was intended for the measure of the foot .
The measures of public roads in the itineraries , can be of little use in this enquiry ; for they omit fractions , and we do not know whether the distances of the towns are reckoned from the market-places or from the gates ; but a difference of half a mile in sixty , is equivalent to the tenth part of an inch in the foot : therefore , no exact measure is to be expected from thence , even though the modern mensurations of Cassini , Riccioli , and others , were more unexceptionable than they really are .
trimodia [ read , amphoram trimodiam ] .
Frontinus , in Expositione Formarum .
Though the passage is corrupt , there can be no doubt of the meaning .
Pes longo spatio latoque notetur in anglo , Angulus ut par sit quem claudit linea triplex ; Quattuor ex quadris medium cingatur inane , Amphora fit cubus : quem no violare liceret , Sacravere Jovi , Tarpeio in monte , Quirites .
Rh .
Fannius , de Pond .
et Mens .
( 2 ) See Dr. Birch 's edition of Greaves 's Works , p. 228 .
( 3 ) Quae illi ~ , nos quadrantalia dicimus .
A. Gellius , l. i. ~ .
20 .
The distances between the ancient mile-stones are not liable to these objections ; and if a sufficient number of such as stand nearest to Rome were carefully measured , their authority would be considerable .
But I do not find that any are now standing within thirty miles of that city , nor that any of these have been measured , or even any in Italy ; and provincial measures are not of equal authority .
There is still another method , whereby we may discover the measure of the Roman foot ; which is , from the remains of the ancient buildings now standing at Rome : and though many have made use of some single parts of them for this purpose , yet no one hath hitherto compared the measures of the principal parts of any one of them with each other , which is the only way to discover the measure whereby a building was constructed .
With this view , therefore , I shall carefully examine the measures of the buildings contained in that inestimable treasury of ancient Roman architecture , entitled , Les Edifices antiques de Rome , and published at Paris , by Mons. Desgodetz , in the year 1682 .
In order to this , it will first be necessary to ascertain the proportion of the Paris foot ( the measure used by this author ) to some known English standard .
The Paris foot is one sixth part of the toise in the Chatelet ; which was renewed in the year 1668 ( 4 ) , and the new standard has continued in use ever since .
( 4 ) See De la Hire 's Dissertation on the Roman Foot , in the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences for the year 1714 , where he gives an account of this renewal of the standard in the Chatelet .
In the year 1742 ( 5 ) , the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , at the request of the Royal Society of London , sent over a measure of half the toise of the Chatelet ; from which Mr. Graham determined the proportion of the Paris foot to that of London , to be as 1065,412/ 3 to 1000 .
Mons. Le Monnier , of the Royal Academy of Sciences , from the same originals , found their proportion as 864 to 811 , or as 1065,351 to 1000 .
The difference is inconsiderable , and we may , without injustice to Mr. Graham 's known skill and accuracy in these matters , suppose their true proportion to be as 1065,4 to 1000 .
Mr. Graham 's measure of the London yard , together with that of half the toise of the Chatelet , are deposited in the archives of the Royal Society at London , and of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris ; and whenever I shall mention the London foot , without specifying any particular standard of it , I would be understood to mean this measure .
In this enquiry , we are to seek a common measure to the several parts of each building , that shall not differ very widely from some assumed magnitude of the Roman foot : and though we might take this assumption from any of the ancient foot-rules now remaining , yet the nearer it is taken to the truth , the better guide it will be to us , and the more it will facilitate our enquiry .
Now , as a mean measure , derived from these rules , will , probably , be nearer the truth , than either the greatest or the least of them , so one that shall include such other remains of antiquity , as have hitherto been made of to discover ( 5 ) See Philos. Trans. No 465 .
the measure of the Roman foot , will be still more unexceptionable , as the writers on this subject are not agreed , which of the different authorities is to be preferred .
The representations of this foot in sculpture , are four in number ; one on the sepulchral monument of Cossutius , formerly in the Colotian gardens at Rome ; another on that of Statilius , in the Belvedere ; a third on that of M. Ebutius , in the Villa Mattei ( 6 ) ; and the fourth on a marble , without inscription , dug up of late years in the Via Aurelia , which , being in the possession of the Marquis Capponi , is called , by P. Revillas , the Capponian foot .
Most of the early writers on this subject have expressed their measure of the Roman foot by a diagram ; and Snellius ( 7 ) observing , that the paper contracted in drying , after the impression was taken off , endeavoured to make a proper allowance for it .
But Greaves , finding the measures of these figures to differ in different copies of the same impression , took another method ; and seems to have been the first that compared the original figures on the monuments of Cossutius and Statilius with a modern standard .
This he did with such care and diligence , that his measures deserve a particular examination .
The London foot , which he used upon this occasion , was taken from the iron standard of 3 feet in ( 6 ) Picard and Auzout ( in a paper called De Mensuris , hereafter quoted ) have given the measure of the foot on this monument of Ebutius for the Colotian foot .
( 7 ) See his Dissertation on the Roman Foot , in the 3d vol. of Saggi di Dissertazioni Academiche di Cortona .
the Guild-hall , London ( 8 ) ; which having been long since lost , or destroyed , we have nothing left whereby to discover its true magnitude , but the measures others have taken of it , and those which have since been taken of such magnitudes as Greaves had compared with his copy of it .
Snellius , from a measure sent him of this iron standard ( 9 ) , determined the proportion of the Rhynland to the London foot , as 1000 to 968 .
The Rhynland foot , according to Picard ( 1 ) , contains 696 such parts as the Paris foot contains 720 : whence the proportion of the latter to this measure from the iron standard , is as 1065,4 to 997 nearly .
Eisenschmid found the Rhynland foot to contain 1391,3 such parts as the Paris foot contains 1440 ( 2 ) ; which gives 1065,4 to less than 9961/ 2 , for the proportion of the Paris foot to that of the iron standard .
Huyghens makes the Paris to the Rhynland foot as 144 to 139 ( 3 ) ; whence the proportion of the former to Snellius 's London foot , will be nearly as 1065,4 to 9951/ 2 .
But there is reason to believe , that Huyghens 's measure of the Rhynland foot was too small ( 4 ) .
By ( 8 ) Graves , p. 223 .
( 9 ) Eratosthenes Batavus , p. 125 .
141 .
( 1 ) See a paper entitled De Mensuris , in Divers Ouvrages de Mathematique et de Physique , par Messrs. de l'Academie Royale des Sciences , Paris 1693 , in folio , and afterwards printed in the 4th vol. of Ouvrages adoptez .
( 2 ) Eifenschmid de Pond .
et Mens .
vett .
p. 94 .
( 3 ) Horolog .
Oscill .
part iv .
prop. 25 .
( 4 ) Picard , in his Voyage d'Uranibourg , p. 64 .
edit .
Amst. says , ` ` Passant par Holland je pris l'occasion de verfier la proportion By these comparisons it appears , that Snellius 's measure of the London foot , from this iron standard , was at least 3 parts in 1000 shorter than Graham 's London foot .
Our countryman Norwood , in the year 1635 , measured the distance between London and York , in order to determine the length of a degree on the meridian ; which he found to contain 367196 London feet of this iron standard ( 5 ) .
The French found the measure of a degree , in the latitude 66~ 20~ , to be 57438 toises , and at the equator 56783 .
Hence the measure of a degree in 52~ 44~ ( the middle latitude between London and York ) will be found to be 57276 toises , or 343656 Paris feet .
These numbers give the proportion of the Paris foot to that of the iron standard , as 1065,4 to 997,1 - , wanting somewhat less than 3 parts in 1000 of Graham 's London foot .
Picard 's paper De Mensuris , quoted above , and another on the same subject by Auzout , printed with it , contain some measures , which Greaves had before compared with his London foot .
Both these papers were written after the renewal of the standard of the Chatelet , in 1668 .
The former is so full of inaccuracies and mistakes , that little use can be made of it ; but Auzout 's measures appear to be accurate ; and as he seems to have taken his Paris foot from the portion du pied de Paris a celui du Rhin , dont l'original est a Leyde ; laquelle proportion me parut estre exactement comme 720 a 696 , au lieu de 720 a 695 , que j'avois supposee dans la mesure de la terre .
' ' This latter is Huyghens 's proportion .
( 5 ) See Norwood 's Seaman 's Practice .
toise in the Chatelet for this purpose , it was probably a correct measure of that standard .
Such of his measures as answer to Greaves 's , are here reduced to thousandth parts of the London foot , reckoning his Paris foot to contain 1065,4 such parts .
Greaves .
Auzout .
Diff. Diff. per foot .
The Statilian foot 972 .
969,96 -2,04 2,1 The braccio of Florence 1913 .
1908,84 -4,16 2,18 The braccio of Siena 1974 .
1973,21 -0,79 0,4 Paetus 's palm 732 .
731,35 -0,65 0,89 All these differences fall the same way , and show , that Greaves 's London foot bore a less proportion to Auzout 's Paris foot , than that of 1000 to 1065,4 .
The Statilian foot , and the braccio of Florence , give the greatest differences ; one is carved in relievo , and the other is a rod ; so that both are subject to diminution , by time and use .
The palm is engraved ; and Auzout , from the deviation of Paetus 's Greek and Roman foot , from the common received proportion of 25 to 24 , suspected , that the latter was lengthened by wear ; if so , the like must have happened to the palm .
How their measures of the braccio of Siena come to differ so little , I cannot account for .
But we can draw no certain conclusion from this comparison , till we know whether any , and what , allowance is to be made for the diminution or increase of these magnitudes , in the interval between Greaves 's and Auzout 's measuring them .
For this purpose , I shall compare Auzout 's measures , with those taken by P. Revillas , with a correct rect London foot ( 6 ) , between fifty and sixty years after .
These he has converted into Paris measure , by the proportion of 864 to 811 ; and I have reduced them back again , according to the same proportion .
Auzout .
Revillas .
Diff. Diff. per foot .
The Statilian foot 969,96 969,79 -0,17 0,18 The Ebutian foot 972,91 972,22 -0,69 0,71 Paetus 's palm 731,35 732,65 + 1,3 1,78 Paetus 's foot 966,26 968,74 + 2,48 2,57 or 967 or 1,75 1,81 Hence the carvings appear to have suffered very little diminution in this interval ; but Paetus 's measures , which are engraved , and in constant use as public standards , have been considerably lengthened .
Therefore , allowing for both these circumstances , we may conclude , that Greaves 's London foot wanted 2 parts in 1000 , to be to Auzout 's Paris foot , in the proportion of 1000 to 1065,4 .
Greaves 's measure of the door-case of the Pantheon , 9 inches within the jambs , is 19,602 of his London feet and decimal parts ( 7 ) .
Desgodetz found the measure of the same on the inside 18 feet 47/ 8 inches Paris measure , and on the outside 18 feet 41/ 3 inches , their difference is 1/ 23/ 4 of a Paris inch ; the depth of the jambs is 4 feet 103/ 4 inches Paris measure ; and ( 6 ) Esattissimo piede Inglese .
See Saggi di Dissertazioni Academiche di Cortona , vol. iii .
p. 113 .
I have been credibly informed , that this London foot was given him by the late Martin Folks , Esq ; and that it was made by Sisson , according to Graham 's measure .
( 7 ) Greaves , p. 348 .
9 London inches are equal to 8,447 Paris inches and decimals .
Hence the measure of this door-case 9 London inches within the jambs , should , according to Desgodetz , be 18,3676 Paris feet and decimals .
But 19,602 is to this number , as 1065,4 to 998,3 ; and Greaves 's London foot wanted 17/ 10 to be to Desgodetz 's Paris foot , in the proportion of 1000 to 1065,4 .
Greaves says , most of the white marble stones on the pavement of the Pantheon contained exactly 3 of those Roman feet on Cossutius 's monument ( 8 ) .
Their Paris measure , according to Desgodetz , is 2 feet 81/ 2 inches , which is equal to 2885,46 London parts .
This number divided by 3 , gives but 961,82 such parts ; whereas Greaves 's measure of the Cossutian foot was 967 parts of his London foot ; which must therefore have wanted above 5 parts in 1000 of the proportion before-mentioned .
But it is probable they measured different ranges of these stones .
The measure of the Paris foot , which Greaves received from Mons. Hardy , was taken from the old standard in the Chatelet ( 9 ) , and contained 1068 such parts as his London foot contained 1000 .
These numbers are in the proportion of 1065,4 to 997,57 ; therefore , if the new standard did not differ from this old one ( and no such difference appears to have been intended ) , Greaves 's London foot must have been 2,43 parts in 1000 shorter than Graham 's .
( 8 ) Greaves , p. 211 .
( 9 ) See Mons. Hardy 's Letter , in Greaves 's Works , p. 447 .
The measure he sent was only half the Paris foot ; but he tells Greaves , it was taken from the standard , under his own inspection , with great care .
All these comparisons show Greaves 's measure of the London foot to have been shorter than Graham 's .
But they are not all of equal authority .
The measures of Snellius depend upon the correctness of three several seet ; that is to say , his copy of the iron standard , the Rhynland , and the Paris foot ; whereas the rest ( except Norwood 's ) depend only on the Paris foot , applied to the same magnitudes that Greaves himself had measured .
Norwood 's measure is rather to be wondered at , that , notwithstanding all the difficulties he had to encounter , it should come so near to the true magnitude of a degree , than to be depended on for the exact measure of the iron standard ; and is an instance of what the diligence and sagacity of a private and obscure man , unassisted by the public purse , or the contributions of friends , could accomplish ; whose labours may , perhaps , be forgotten , when the measures of the French , taken under a royal commission , shall be known to the latest posterity .
The three more immediate comparisons of Greaves 's measure with the Paris foot , are by the measures of Auzout , Desgodetz , and Hardy , which afford as clear a proof as can well be expected in this matter , that his measure of the iron standard was about 2 parts in 1000 deficient of Graham 's London foot .
Mr. Greaves found the foot on the monument of Statilius to contain 972 such parts as his London foot contained 1000 ; and that on the monument of Cossutius 967 ( 1 ) .
These measures reduced to Graham 's foot , are 970 , and 965 .
( 1 ) Greaves , p. 208 , 209 .
Auzout 's measure of the foot on the monument of M. Ebutius , is nearly equal to 973 London parts .
Revillas makes this 9721/ 4 , and the Capponian foot 9683/ 4 .
The mean of these measures of the Roman foot on the marbles , is nearly 969 thousandth parts of the London foot .
Philander , in his notes on Vitruvius ( 2 ) , says , the foot from a porphyry column , inscribed ~ .
~ .
exceeded the Cossutian foot by the ninth part of an inch ; therefore it contained nearly 974 London parts .
This column seems to have been a more authentic measure of the Roman foot , than the figures on the monuments ; since the inscription shows it was intended for such , whereas they were only representations of it .
And notwithstanding the inscription was Greek , the foot must have been Roman ; for Philander 's measure of it exceeds the mean measure of those on the marbles , by less than the sixteenth part of a London inch , and is less than some of the ancient foot-rules , hereafter mentioned ; whereas it wants above the third part of an inch to be equal to the Greek foot .
It might , perhaps , be used by some Greek mason at Rome , to adjust his workmens rules by ; for when the Romans began to be expensive in their buildings , they had most of their masons from Greece .
And though this column is not now to be found , and the accuracy of Philander 's measure of it may be doubted , it is still a proof , that , at one time or other , the measure of the Roman foot was sensibly greater than that on the monument of Cossutius .
( 2 ) P. 117 .
of the Lyons edit .
1552 .
Lucas Paetus compared five ancient foot-rules with the marbles ; he seems not to have been a person of great accuracy ; for though in one place he allows there was some small difference between the Statilian foot and that on the monument of Cossutius ( 3 ) , yet he every-where else speaks of them as equal , and has given but one figure for the measure of both .
His comparisons seem to have been made only with the latter , the measure of which he had before set up in the Capitol , as the true Roman foot ( 4 ) .
Three of these rules , which , he says , were exactly equal to each other , were shorter than the Cossutian foot by one seventh part of a Cossutian inch ; they must then have been nearly 9531/ 2 London parts .
Of the other two , one appears to have been 958 , and the other 974 , equal to that from Philander 's column .
He decides in favour of the three shortest , to which perhaps he was induced , partly by their agreement with each other , and partly by his opinion , that the Roman foot had been continually increasing ; whence it must follow , that the shortest measure of it was the most ancient .
( 3 ) Cum quo sane convenit modico discrimine hic Statilianus .
Paetus de Mens .
et Pond .
lib. i. ( 4 ) Greaves , p. 209 .
says , the Roman foot engraved by Paetus in the Capitol , agreed exactly with that on the monument of Cossutius .
Paetus therefore seems at that time to have acquiesced in the opinion of Portius , which , he says , was generally received .
( Leonardus Portius Vicentinus , vir sane doctus , primus omnium nostrae aetatis qui de hac re scripserit , mensuram Colotiani pedis pro vera tradidit.-Quem juniores quoque secuti sunt .
) But he changed his opinion when he wrote his book , which was after he had set up the measures in the Capitol .
Greaves says , the Cossutian foot exactly agreed with some very ancient and perfect Roman feet in brass ; and from his comparison of two that differed from it ( which seem to be the greatest and least he had met with ) , one of them appears to contain nearly 9723/ 4 London parts , and the other 9623/ 5 ( 5 ) .
P. Revillas has given the measures of three footrules of an uncommon length ; one of which contains 972 London parts , another 976 , and the third 983 ( 6 ) .
There are many more of these rules in being , that we have no account of ; for most of the writers on this subject , preferring the authority of the marbles , have been negligent in their accounts of the footrules ; therefore I think a mean measure from these above-mentioned of no great authority , especially as some of them have been produced only on account of their difference from the more common measure of the rest .
If a cubic Roman foot contained a quadrantal of wine , the cube of half a foot must have contained a congius , which was the eighth part of the quadrantal .
Paetus , Villalpandus , and Auzout measured the standard congius of Vespasian with water ; and have ( 5 ) Greaves , p. 222 .
But , p. 227 .
he says , there is not one of ten measures of the Roman foot ( besides those on the monuments ) , that arrive to the proportion of that deduced by Villalpandus from the congius , by 27 parts in 2000 ; whereas the greater of the two here mentioned contained 9743/ 4 parts of his London foot , and he makes the foot from the congius of Villalpandus , but 986 such parts ; their difference is but 23 two thousandth parts of the latter .
( 6 ) Saggi di Diss .
Academ .
di Cortona , vol. iii .
given the weight of its contents .
The two first differ from each other by almost 51/ 2 modern Roman ounces , which is nearly the one-and-twentieth part of the whole weight , though they both measured up to the same part of the neck .
The weight of water given by Paetus , is deficient of the mean weight of Auzout 's measures by 3 Troy ounces ; and that given by Villalpandus exceeds the same by 2 ; therefore they must both have used bad balances .
Auzout measured this vessel twice , with the water of Trevi .
His greater weight of the water is 63024 Paris grains , his lesser 62760 ( 7 ) .
Picard found a cubic Paris foot of spring water to weigh 641326 Paris grains ( 8 ) ; and that foot containing 2089,69 cubic London inches , Auzout 's greater weight will give 205,36 such inches for the solid content of the congius , his lesser 2041/ 2 .
According to Picard 's experiment , a cubic London inch of spring water should weigh but 2513/ 4 Troy grains ; whereas , according to Snellius , it should weigh above 254 ( 9 ) .
Our countryman Wybard made many experiments to discover the weight of water ( 1 ) , from which the weight of a cubic inch of rain water should be 253 Troy grains .
His experiments seem to have been made with great attention , and his inch must have been that of the iron standard , which I have already ( 7 ) See the paper De Mensuris , above quoted , p. 366 .
371 .
of the folio edit .
where Picard gives these weights as Auzout 's , without any farther account of them .
( 8 ) Ibidem .
( 9 ) Snellius , in Eratosthene Batavo , p. 155 .
( 1 ) See Wybard 's Tactometria , from p. 269 to p. 287 .
shown to be less than Graham 's ; therefore , I think a cubic inch of Graham 's measure of the water of Trevi , cannot weigh less than 253 Troy grains .
This will reduce Auzout 's two measures of the congius to 204,35 and 203,49 cubic London inches ; which give 981,7 and 980,3 for the measure of the Roman foot .
Greaves measured the congius with millet seed ( 2 ) , and comparing it with our measures of capacity , found it to contain 71/ 8 pints wine measure , and 61/ 6 pints corn measure .
When he wrote , the wine gallon was universally allowed to contain 231 cubic inches ( 3 ) ; and the dimensions of the bushel were published yearly , by the Lord Mayor of London , to be 19 inches in diameter , and 71/ 2 in depth ( 4 ) .
But Greaves 's inches were according to the iron standard in the Guildhall , and were 2 parts in 1000 shorter than Graham 's .
Therefore reducing these measures in that proportion , the wine gallon will be found to contain 229,62 cubic London inches , and the corn gallon 264,22 .
Hence by the wine measure , the congius contained 204,5 cubic London inches , and by the corn measure 203,7 ; which give 981,9 and 980,6 for the measure of the Roman foot .
These measures agree so well with those of Auzout , that I think a mean between them must be very near the truth , and that we may reckon the ( 2 ) Greaves , note f. p. 303 .
( 3 ) See Wybard 's Tactometria , p. 264 .
Oughtred 's Circles of Proportion , p. 57 .
who quotes Gunter and Briggs for the same opinion .
( 4 ) Wybard 's Tactometria , p. 282 .
foot from the congius to contain about 981 London parts .
Greaves took likewise another measure of this congius , by the cube of his Cossutian foot , which he found to contain 7 congii , and about an half , of millet ( 5 ) .
Now , the quadrantal should contain 8 ; hence the side of the quadrantal to this congius will contain 988 parts of the iron standard : for 988 is to 967 ( Greaves 's measure of the Cossutian foot ) in the subtriplicate proportion of 8 to 71/ 2 .
But this is a greater measure than even that of Villalpandus , and was probably owing to an erroneous cube of the Cossutian foot ; for the joiners at Rome might be as bad workmen as the scalemakers ; and Greaves says , he could not get a balance there , fit to examine the congius by weight ( 6 ) .
Mons. Astruc , in his Natural History of Languedoc , says , he had caused the distance between the ninth and tenth mile-stones on the road from Nismes to Beaucaire to be measured , and that it was found to be 754 Paris toises .
They were both set up by Tiberius , and the road lies in a strait line between them .
This measure gives a Roman foot of 964 London parts .
He does not say he took this measure himself ( 7 ) , nor has he given any account how it was taken .
Perhaps by a provincial measure , and ( 5 ) Greaves , p. 225 .
( 6 ) Ibid. note f. ( 7 ) Memoires pour l'Histoire Naturelle de Languedoc , p. 225 .
His expression is , ` ` J'ai fait mesurer la distance de l'un a l'autre , et elle s'est trouvee de 754 toises de Paris .
' ' Where he speaks of the Marquis Massaei , he says , ` ` Il a mesure ; ' ' but , in the same paragraph , speaking of himself , he again says , ` ` J'ai fait mesurer .
' ' afterwards reduced to Paris toises ; or by a wheel , which is liable to great errors : therefore we cannot allow much authority to it , unless we were better assured of its accuracy .
He quotes the Marquis Maffei for a measure of 756 toises between two other mile-stones on the same road ; but observes , that they were set up by different emperors , Augustus and Tiberius , and that the road formerly made an elbow between them , whose position is now not certainly known .
Therefore this measure , which gives a foot of 9661/ 2 London parts , is likewise of small authority .
All that can be determined from such uncertain and discordant data , as I have here collected , is a measure that shall probably be neither the greatest nor the least magnitude of the Roman foot .
And for this , I shall take a mean from all the measures above recited , which is nearly 968 thousandth parts of the London foot .
Before I enter upon the examination of the ancient buildings , it may be proper to say something concerning the nature of the evidence to be expected from them .
All buildings are planned and executed by some measure of the country where they are built .
At Rome this measure was the foot , which was divided by the workmen into 4 palms , and each palm into 4 digits ( 8 ) .
If ( 8 ) Vitruvius , lib. iii .
c. 1 .
Frontinus de Agrorum Qualit .
Both these authors are technical writers , and give this as the division used by workmen ; and the ancient foot-rules are so divided .
They If the Roman buildings were correctly executed , and we had the true dimensions of their several parts in any known measure , some divisors consisting of Roman feet , and parts of those feet , applied to these measures , must , in the same building , give the same quotient to all ; and this quotient will be the measure of the foot , by which that building was constructed , in parts of the known measure .
Therefore , where a range of simple divisors , applied to the principal parts of any building , give as nearly the same quotient as can be expected from the common inaccuracies of workmanship , we may reasonably conclude , that these divisors were the architects numbers ; and the foot derived from them , that by which the building was constructed .
As an architect cannot be supposed to be limited to a few digits in the extent of the front , or of the depth of large buildings , it is probable such measures consisted of whole feet .
These , and the diameters of circular buildings , I call prime measures .
In all large prime measures , the preference is to be given to a round number for the divisor ; as it is more probable a building should be designed for 100 feet in front , than for 99 or 101 : and because the passus was 5 feet , I reckon any multiple of 5a round number .
The diameters of columns are of less authority than any other horizontal measures ; not only on account of the difficulty of measuring them correctly , They both mention the duodecimal division , which seems to have been used by the vulgar ; for the Romans divided every integer into 12 unciae .
but because errors of workmanship , to which they are more liable than square members , more sensibly affect the magnitude of the foot in small measures , than in large ones .
Uprights , of any considerable height , are of less authority than horizontal measures , from the difficulty of taking them correctly ; and being designed by modules , few of them answer well to the foot measure .
But here we must except such shafts of columns as are of one block of marble ; which seem to be as good authority as any part of a building : for the necessity of making them all exactly of the same length , must produce accuracy ; and the doing this was no difficult piece of workmanship .
Being likewise commonly ( if not always ) wrought at the quarry , to save expense in the carriage , they were probably bespoke to some simple measure ; and we shall find all such shafts answer to some number of whole palms .
In the following enquiry , I suppose that Desgodetz 's Paris foot contained 1065,4 such parts , as our London foot contains 1000 : since it appears , from the comparison of his measure of the door-case of the Pantheon with Greaves 's , that if Greaves 's London foot was not above 2 parts in 1000 shorter than Graham 's , Desgodetz 's Paris foot was but 3/ 10000 of the London foot shorter than that in the archives of the Royal Society .
This difference ( if such there was ) does not amount to the 277th part of an inch ; which is much nearer than we can expect to find the measure of the Roman foot , from all the remains of antiquity now in being .
The temple of Fortuna virilis .
When this temple was built , is not known ; but it is commonly thought , from the poorness of the materials , and the style of the architecture , to be one of the most ancient buildings now remaining in Rome .
The great simplicity of its parts , and their near agreement with each other , afford so clear an evidence of the measure by which it was constructed , that I have chosen to begin with it , as an introduction to the rest .
It has four Ionic columns in front , and seven in depth .
The depth , taken between the centers of the angular columns , is 54 feet 81/ 4 inches Paris measure , equal to 58264,06 thousandth parts of the London foot ; which contain just 60 Roman feet of 971 + such parts each .
The distance between the centers of the columns in this range , is 9 feet 13/ 8 inches , equal to 9710,6 London parts ; containing 10 Roman feet of the same measure with the former .
The extent of the front , taken between the centers of the angular columns , is 28 feet 81/ 6 inches , = 30556,25 ; which contain 311/ 2 Roman feet of 970 + London parts each .
The distance between the centers of the angular columns , and those on each side the entrance , is exactly equal to the distance between the centers of the columns on the sides ; being 10 Roman feet of 971 + parts each .
There remain therefore 111/ 2 Roman feet , for the distance between the centers of the columns on each side the entrance .
This measures 10 feet 55/ 12 inches ( 9 ) , equal to 11134,9 ; which , divided by 111/ 2 , gives 9681/ 4 for the Roman foot .
This disagreement between the measures in the front , cannot be reconciled by any probable divisors ; therefore it must be owing to an error in workmanship .
And if the distance between the centers of the middle columns were but a little more than 3/ 8 of a London inch greater , both that , and the whole extent of the front , would answer to the same measure of the foot with the sides .
Now , as the middle intercolumniation was intended to be greater than the rest , the workman might be less exact in laying out the front , than the sides , where they were all to be equal ; for the front intercolumniations next the angles being kept equal to those on the sides , the symmetry of the building would be preserved , and the whole error fall on the middle intercolumniation , where it could not be discovered .
Or if , on the other hand , we suppose the measure of the extent in front to have been correct , and the error to have lain in the sides , the workman must still have made the intercolumniations on the sides equal to each other , and those in the front next the angles , equal to them : and , in this case , 970 would be the true measure of the foot , instead of 971 .
Therefore , I think , it cannot be doubted , that one or the other of them was the measure by which this building was constructed .
( 9 ) Desgodetz has figured this 10 feet 51/ 12 inches ; which will be found to be a mistake , by comparing the correspondent numbers , and by his measure of this interval in modules .
The temple of Vesta , at Rome .
This building is remarkable for the style of its architecture , and the elegance of its workmanship .
The pointed abacus shows the architecture to be Greek ; which is a strong presumption in favour of its antiquity , as it is the only example of the kind now remaining at Rome ( 1 ) .
None of the diameters will answer to the same measure of the foot with the other parts , by probable divisors .
This was likely enough to be the case , if the circles of the plan were described by a cord , whose stretching might increase their diameters beyond the intended measures .
But the rest of the measures agree pretty nearly with each other , by as simple divisors as can be expected in so small a building .
At the door-case , the arch of the wall is discontinued , and the groundsil is strait .
The width between the jambs is 9 feet 12/ 3 inches , equal to 9736,6 ; which , divided by 10 , gives a foot of 973,7 London parts .
From the wall to the centers of the columns , is 8 feet 81/ 8 inches , = 9244,6 ; which , divided by 91/ 2 , gives a foot of 973,1 parts .
From the wall to the extremity of the basement , is 10 feet 6 inches , = 11186,7 ; which , divided by 111/ 2 , gives 972,7 .
( 1 ) That is to say , it is probably older than the Pantheon ; for , according to Pliny , in his thirty-sixth book , there seems to have been no marble temple in Rome above sixty years older than that building .
And his history of marble is confirmed by the saying of Augustus , ` ` That he found Rome brick , and left it marble .
' ' Sueton .
in Aug. c. 28 .
From the top of the surbase within , to the pavement of the cell , is 7 feet 91/ 6 inches , = 8271,65 ; which , divided by 81/ 2 , gives 973,1 .
From the top of the surbase without , to the outer pavement , is 9 feet 15/ 6 inches , = 9751,4 ; which , divided by 10 , gives 975,1 .
The shafts of the columns are 27 feet 5 inches , = 29209,8 ; which , divided by 30 , gives 973,7 .
The columns , with their bases and capitals , are 32 feet 0 inch , = 34092,8 ; which , divided by 35 , gives a foot of 974 London parts .
The mean measure of the foot from this building , is 973,6 ; which agrees nearly with the foot of Philander 's porphyry column above-mentioned , and with one derived from Greaves 's measure of the monument of Cestius , whose side within the city ( as he says in p. 151 of his works ) is completely 78 feet English ; which , reduced to Graham 's measure , is 77,84 , and contains 80 Roman feet of 973 London parts each .
The temple of Vesta , at Tivoli .
The measures of the parts of this building disagree~ so much with each other , by any probable divisors , that I shall only mention the width of the door-way between the jambs , which is 7 feet 33/ 4 inches , = 7790,7 , and answers to 8 Roman feet of 973,8 parts each .
The Pantheon .
This is a circular building , with a portico before the entrance ; which , having been added after the body of the work was finished ( 2 ) , has induced many ( 2 ) See Desgodetz , p. 3 .
&amp; p. 14 .
to think the temple was more ancient , and that Agrippa only adorned it with marble , and added the portico .
But the inscription on the freze , ` ` M. Agrippa L. F. Cos. tertium fecit , ' ' seems to refer to the whole .
And Pliny , enumerating the most magnificent buildings in Rome , says , ` ` Pantheon Jovi ultori ab Agrippa factum ; cum Theatrum ante texerit Romae Valerius Ostiensis architectus , ludis Libonis ( 3 ) .
' ' If the latter part of this passage alludes to the dome of the Pantheon ( as it seems to do ) , it will imply , that Agrippa built it .
In another place ( 4 ) , Pliny calls this building Agrippa 's Pantheum .
Now , temples of this form were usually peripteres ; that is to say , encompassed with columns ( 5 ) , as the two temples of Vesta ; but such a colonnade to this building ( supposing the entablature to reach up to the top of the wall ) could not consist of fewer than twenty-six columns of 9 London feet in diameter ; which , with their entablature , must have cost much more than the whole building , as it now stands .
Therefore , it seems as if no columns were at first intended on the outside , and that the portico was an after-thought .
This temple is said to have been burnt in that great conflagration , which happened in the reign of Titus ( 6 ) ; and again by lightning , in the thirteenth year of Trajan ( 7 ) , and to have been restored by ( 3 ) Pliny , lib. xxxvi .
c. 15 .
( 4 ) Ibid. c. 5 .
( 5 ) Vitruvius , lib. iv .
c. 7 .
( 6 ) Xiphilin .
in Tito .
Suetonius likewise mentions this fire ; but does not say what buildings were burnt by it .
Titus , c. 8 .
( 7 ) Eusebius in Chronico .
Adrian ( 8 ) .
But it does not seem to have been totally destroyed either time ; for the inscription of Severus says , it was ` ` vetustate corruptum ; ' ' which could hardly be true , if it was entirely rebuilt by Adrian , who began his reign but seventy-six years before Severus ; but is very applicable to a building that had stood above 200 years , and been twice damaged by fire .
Neither does it seem possible , that a building of this size and solidity , without any timber in it , except the roofing of the portico , should be totally consumed by the fire of the neighbouring buildings .
Therefore , we may suppose the measures of the principal parts of it to be according to the foot of the Augustan age .
If the execution of this noble building had been answerable to the beauty of the design ; the multiplicity of its parts , and the accuracy with which Desgodetz has measured them , would have afforded ample materials for the discovery of the foot by which it was constructed : but the dimensions of such parts of it as should be equal to each other , differ so widely , that scarce any but the prime measures are to be depended on .
These were , probably , the diameter of the circle passing through the centers of the columns within ; for on this , the diameter of the cupola depended ; and the diameter of the whole building , from out to out .
Desgodetz has given twelve measures of the diameter within the shafts of the columns .
The mean from them all , is 133 feet ~ inches Paris measure : ( 8 ) Spartianus in Adriano .
to this , add the mean diameter of the columns , 3 feet 44/ 5 inches , their sum , 136 feet 71/ 5 inches , equal to 145533,6 London parts , is the diameter of the circle passing through the centers of the columns ; which , divided by 150 ( as round a number as can be desired ) , gives 970,2 such parts for the measure of the Roman foot .
The mean depth of the four long chapels , between the shafts of the columns and the wall , is 9 feet 147/ 48 inch , = 9764,3 ; which , divided by 10 , gives a foot of 976,4 London parts ; but by 101/ 4 , one of 952,6 ; which is certainly too small .
And if this was an arbitrary measure , we cannot admit the fraction of a palm in it .
Therefore , we may suppose these chapels were intended to be 10 Roman feet deep in the clear between the columns and the wall .
The mean diameter of the columns , 3 feet 44/ 5 inches , = 3622,36 London parts , divided by 33/ 4 , gives a foot of 966 parts .
The shafts of these columns measure 27 feet 11/ 3 inches , whose eighth part ( reckoning the shaft at 16 modules ) is 3 feet 42/ 3 inches ; which is somewhat less than the mean of their diameters .
Yet even this measure ( which is equal to 3610,5 London parts ) does not want half a Roman digit of 33/ 4 feet of 970,2 parts each ; which the architect might safely neglect , and allow 33/ 4 feet for these diameters , in his general plan .
Now , if to twice the depth of these chapels , or 20 Roman feet , we add twice the semidiameter of the columns , or 33/ 4 such feet ; and to their sum , the diameter of the circle passing through the centers of the columns , 150 feet ; we shall have 1733/ 4 Roman feet feet for the diameter from wall to wall of the opposite chapels .
Desgodetz has given four measures of this diameter , whose mean , 158 feet 22/ 3 inches , is equal to 168570 London parts , which , divided by 1733/ 4 , give 970,2 - , for the measure of the Roman foot ; agreeing with that found from the diameter of the circle passing through the centers of the columns .
Or if , instead of taking a mean of the four diameters from wall to wall , we add twice the mean depth of these chapels , and twice the mean semidiameter of the columns , to the mean diameter of the circle passing through their centers , we shall have 158 feet 4 inches for the diameter from wall to wall , equal to 168688 London parts ; which , divided by 1733/ 4 , give 970,9 , for the measure of the foot .
But if this diameter from wall to wall was a prime measure , as well as that of the circle passing through the centers of the columns , the depth of these chapels must have been a residuary measure , and might be more or less than 10 Roman feet .
And if we divide the diameter last mentioned by 174 ( which being composed of 150 , and twice 12 , may here be reckoned a round number ) , it will give a foot of 9691/ 2 London parts .
But if , instead of twice the mean depth of these chapels , we take twice the greatest depth , 18 feet 6 inches , for part of this diameter , the same divisor will give a foot of 9701/ 2 such parts .
The measure of the diameter from out to out cannot be so well determined as either of the former ; for Desgodetz has given but one measure of the outer wall , which is 5 feet 41/ 2 inches ; to this we must add 1 foot 101/ 3 inches , for the mean depth of the niches in the long chapels ; and twice their sum , 14 feet 52/ 3 inches , added to 158 feet 22/ 3 inches , the inside diameter between the walls of these chapels , will give 172 feet 81/ 3 inches for the diameter from out to out .
This is equal to 183988,6 London parts ; which answer to 190 Roman feet , of 968,4 such parts each .
But this diameter being got by the addition of many small parts , one of which is a single measure , is of small authority .
Though if the outer wall is 5 feet 41/ 2 inches thick in brick-work , and the backs of the niches in the long chapels are encrusted with marble ( as I suppose they are ) , a proper allowance for the incrustation will make this diameter answer to a foot of 970 London parts .
The principal parts of the circular range within , are too unequal to answer to any regular division into compartments ; and the two largest measures in it sufficiently evince , how little use is to be made of the rest : for the width of the grand chapel opposite the entrance , and the width of the entrance between the pilasters in the range , will not answer to the same measure of the foot , by any probable divisors .
But the inequality of the faces of the pilasters , that terminate the solids in this range , affords the clearest proof , that no certain measure of the foot is to be obtained from the lesser parts of this building : for two of them , at the extremities of the same solid , differ in breadth by a Paris inch and three quarters .
One of the two on each side the grand chapel exceeds the other in breadth , by a Paris inch and a quarter ; and it exceeds the least in the circular range , by no less than 41/ 4 such inches , though the diameter of the column before it is less than that of some in the range .
The diameter of the circular light at top is 27 feet 5 inches , equal to 29209,7 ; which , divided by 30 , gives 9732/ 3 for the Roman foot .
Whether Desgodetz took more measures than one of this diameter , does not appear , nor how he took it .
It is probable , that 30 Roman feet was the measure here intended , being a round number , and one fifth of the diameter between the centers of the columns : but the making this light a true circle , precisely answering to a given measure , was a difficult piece of workmanship .
Therefore , this measure is of small authority .
The square compartments on the pavement measure 9 feet 02/ 3 inch , or 9647,79 London parts ; which , divided by 10 , give a foot of 964,8 parts .
But Desgodetz observes ( 9 ) , that this is not the original pavement : and this measure of the foot answers to the age of S. Severus , as I shall show hereafter .
This pavement being considerably raised above the old one , no measures of uprights taken from it are of any authority .
The height of the attic , above the cornice it stands upon , is 27 feet 23/ 4 inches , equal to 29010 ; which , divided by 30 , gives a foot of 967 parts .
But the walls of this building being brick , this measure may have been diminished by their settling , as the whole error occasioned by it might be made to fall on this part , rather than on the order below .
The length of the shafts of the columns in the circular range , is 27 feet 11/ 3 inches , = 28884,18 ; which answers to 293/ 4 feet , of 970,9 parts each .
( 9 ) Desgodetz , p. 41 .
The width of the door-case , between the jambs , has been supposed , by Picard , De la Hire , Eisenschmid , and others , to have been a measure of whole feet ; for this reason , because they thought it an arbitrary one , and therefore not likely to contain a fraction ( 1 ) .
But in this , I think , they were mistaken ; for it appears to have been determined by the width of the passage within , of which it takes up just three fourths .
The proportion is too simple , and too exactly executed , to be accidental ; and it is highly improbable , that the width of this passage , which is a principal part of the plan of the inside , should be determined by that of the door-case .
The width of the passage , is 24 feet 523/ 24 inches , = 26098,6 ; that of the door-way , next the passage , is 18 feet 47/ 8 inches , = 19610 ; next the portico , 18 feet 41/ 3 inches , = 19561,9 ; none of which will give a measure of the foot , answering to the rest of the building , by whole divisors .
The width of the doorway next the portico ( which has been supposed to be just 20 Roman feet ) , divided by 20 , gives 978 .
But the diameters of the temple ( taking either the greatest or the least , instead of a mean ) , will not answer to a foot of this measure , by probable divisors .
The principal measures in the portico are , its extent in front and depth , and the shafts of the columns .
( 1 ) Mr. Greaves says , this door-case is one entire marble stone .
See p. 348 .
and p. 494 .
And Ficoroni ( a late writer ) , in his Vestigia di Roma antica , p. 132 .
speaking of this door-case , says , Essendo amendue i lati , col di sopra , e il di sotto di un solo pezzo di marmo .
' ' But Desgodetz , p. 18 .
says , that each side of the architrave consists of two stones , and the top , of one ; and corrects Serlio , for saying the whole was of one piece .
The extent in front , taken between the centers of the angular columns , is 98 feet 43/ 8 inches , equal to 104797,6 ; which contain 108 Roman feet of 970,3 parts each .
Its depth on the right-hand side of the entrance ( 2 ) , from the center of the angular column to the center of the pilaster , is 41 feet 51/ 8 inches , = 44136,4 , and contains 451/ 2 feet of 970 + parts .
The shafts of the columns , which are each of one single stone , measure 36 feet 77/ 8 inches ( 3 ) , equal to 39053,6 ; which answer to 401/ 4 Roman feet of 970,3 London parts .
I can find no measures in this building of equal authority with the diameters , the shafts of the columns in the circular range , and these measures in the portico .
All of which give the measure of the Roman foot greater than 970 such parts as the London foot contains 1000 .
In the rest of the buildings , where the measures do not require a particular explanation , I shall first give Desgodetz 's measures , with their reductions to thousandth parts of the London foot , and then set down the divisors and quotients with two hooks between them ; the divisor on the left-hand , expressing ( 2 ) By some expressions of Desgodetz , his plans seem to be inverted , as gravings commonly are .
I speak according to the plan , supposing the reader to view it in front .
( 3 ) Desgodetz , p. 19 .
has figured the shafts of the pilasters in the portico 36 feet 71/ 3 inches , and in modules 16 mod .
81/ 4 parts ; which is somewhat too great for his foot measure , his module being 27 Paris inches .
But p. 16 .
he has figured the shafts of these columns 16 mod .
83/ 4 parts , which is 36 feet 77/ 8 inches .
And that this is no mistake , appears from his measures of the capitals of each .
a number of Roman feet ; and the quotient on the right , their magnitude in parts of the London foot .
The temple of Peace .
The length on one side within the walls , including the pronaus or porch , is 269 feet 81/ 2 inches , = 287347,26 296 ) ... ( 970,8 The width of the nave 77 feet 51/ 2 inches , = 82524,1 ( twice ) 85 ) ... ( 970,9 The width of the side-building 48 feet 0 inch , = 51139,2 ( thrice ) 523/ 4 ) ... ( 969,5 The length of the first division of the side 71 feet 5 inches , = 76087,3 781/ 2 ) ... ( 969,3 The length of the second division 71 feet 8 inches , = 76353,87 783/ 4 ) ... ( 969,6 The length of the third 70 feet 31/ 2 inches , = 74888,75 771/ 4 ) ... ( 969,4 The width of two of the passages in the cross walls , is 22 feet 4 inches , = 23793,9 241/ 2 ) ... ( 971,2 The width of the exedra in the middle division of the side 53 feet 11 inches , = 57442,82 591/ 4 ) ... ( 969,5 Its depth is equal to the width of the passages in the cross walls .
The two middle entrances through the porch , 15 feet 3 inches , = 16247,35 163/ 4 ) ... ( 970 The side entrances 14 feet 41/ 2 inches , = 15315,13 153/ 4 ) ... ( 972,4 5 The The entrance into the porch on the right-hand 14 feet 4 inches , = 15270,74 153/ 4 ) ... ( 969,5 The shaft of the column ( of one stone ) 49 feet 3 inches , = 52470,9 54 ) ... ( 971,7 The diameter of the column 5 feet 8 1/ 4 inches , = 6058,47 61/ 4 ) ... ( 969,4 The height of the order 71 feet 01/ 2 inch , = 75687,79 78 ) ... ( 970,4 A mean from these twenty-one measures gives a Roman foot of 970,3 parts .
But the measures in this building seem to be very incorrectly executed .
The temples of Bacchus , and of Faunus .
I shall not particularly recite the measures of these buildings , because they seem to be the works of a much later age than any of the rest .
By the different workmanship of the shafts of the columns in the temple of Bacchus ( 4 ) , it seems to have been compiled out of the ruins of other buildings .
In the temple of Faunus , most of the columns are of granite , but some of them of white marble ; the cross wall was evidently designed to support a flat roof , the outer wall being too weak to bear a cupola ( 5 ) ; and the windows ( which I take to be as old as the rest of the building ) are in the Gothic style : all which are marks of a late age .
Therefore both these temples seem to be more modern than they are commonly thought to be .
The temple of Bacchus ( 4 ) See Desgodetz , p. 68 .
( 5 ) Ibid. p. 79 .
answers to a foot of 968 parts , that of Faunus to one less than 967 .
The amphitheatre of Vespasian .
The plan of this building is elliptical ; and the area in the middle being allotted to the exhibition of the shows , seems to be the part on which the magnitude of the whole depended .
Therefore one of its axes must be the prime measure .
The greater axis measures 263 feet 11 inches , = 281176,8 London parts ; the lesser 165 feet 1 inch , = 175879,7 .
These numbers are so nearly in the proportion of 8 to 5 , that there is little reason to doubt their being intended for it .
The only two whole numbers in this proportion that will answer our purpose are 288 and 180 , by which the greater axis will give 976,3 London parts for the measure of the foot ; the lesser , 977,1 .
Either the distance from the inner to the outer wall , or that from the inner wall to the extremity of the upper step , was probably a prime measure too .
The former is 155 feet 51/ 3 inches , = 165610,5 ; which , divided by 170 , gives 974,2 .
The latter is 158 feet 01/ 12 inch , = 168340,6 ; which , divided by 172 , gives 978,7 .
But the axes will admit of other divisors , which are in my opinion as probable at least , as those abovementioned .
For if we suppose the greater axis to have been the prime measure from which the lesser was determined in the proportion of 5 to 8 , and assume 290 Roman feet for it ( which is a more probable measure than 288 ) , the lesser axis must then be 1811/ 4 such feet .
And the measure of the foot by the greater axis will be 969,6 parts ; by the lesser 970,3 .
The distance from the inner to the outer wall will not answer to this measure of the foot by any whole divisor .
And that from the inner wall to the extremity of the upper step , divided by 174 , gives but 9671/ 2 .
But this disagreement will not appear extraordinary , when we consider that these distances are not single measures , but the sums of nine or ten smaller ones ( 6 ) , and may therefore be liable to an error of some inches .
The lesser parts are so incorrectly executed , that no use can be made of them .
And the heights of the four orders , and of their parts , are so irregular as not easily to be accounted for .
The amphitheatre at Verona .
The principal measures in this building answer to the Greek foot ; which is not the subject of the present inquiry .
The arch of Titus .
This edifice is so ruined , that we have not the measure of the extent of its front .
The depth of the solid is 14 feet 7 inches , = 15537,1 16 ) ... ( 971,1 The width of the entrance , 16 feet 4 inches , = 17401,5 18 ) ... ( 966,7 The shafts of the columns , 16 feet 2 inches , = 17223,97 173/ 4 ) ... ( 970,9 ( 6 ) See the section , ~ .
3 .
The arch of Constantine .
The measures of this elegant design are so incorrectly executed , that I can make no use of them .
The fronts of the two outermost solids differ by a Paris inch and one third ; the side entrances by 12/ 3 ; the distances of the columns from the pilasters ( a measure of little more than 18 inches ) differ an inch and 1/ 12 ; and the depth of the solid at one end , exceeds that at the other end by no less than 71/ 4 Paris inches .
The temple of Antonine and Faustina .
Desgodetz has given the measure of no part of this building in feet and inches , but the diameters of the columns ; which he says do not differ from each other , as in many of the rest .
The diameter of the columns is 4 feet 67/ 1 2 inches , = 4846,09 5 ) ... ( 969,2 The extent of the portico taken between the centers of the angular columns , 25 mod .
165/ 6 parts , = 61935,7 64 ) ... ( 967,7 The shafts of the columns , 15 mod .
28 parts , = 38607,2 40 ) ... ( 965,2 These shafts were probably intended for 16 modules , and their measure is more to be relied on than that of the diameters , both on account of its size , and because the correct execution of it was not only more easy , but more necessary .
Therefore , though these measures are too few , and too unequal to determine the exact magnitude of the foot used in the conV O L. LI .
5M struction struction of this building , yet it seems to have been less than any we have hitherto met with .
The arch of Septimius Severus .
This building deserves our particular attention , both on account of the correctness of the workmanship , and because it exhibits a different measure of the Roman foot from any of the preceding .
It is all of white marble .
The stones are laid without mortar , and fastened together with cramps .
And the shafts of the columns are each of one stone .
The whole extent in front , is 71 feet 55/ 6 inches , = 76161,3 79 ) ... ( 964,1 The depth at one end , is 21 feet 83/ 4 inches , = 23150,3 24 ) ... ( 964,6 The depth at the other end , 21 feet 85/ 6 inches , = 23157,6 24 ) ... ( 964,9 The width of the middle entrance , 20 feet 10 inches , = 22195,8 23 ) ... ( 965 The width of the side entrances , 9 feet 2 inches , = 9766,17 101/ 8 ) ... ( 964,5 From the middle entrance to the extremity of the outer solid , on one side , is 25 feet 33/ 4 inches , = 26967,9 28 ) ... ( 963,1 The like on the other side , 25 feet 41/ 12 inches , = 26997,5 28 ) ... ( 964,2 The distance between the shafts of the outermost columns , is 60 feet 75/ 6 inches , = 64619,5 ( 7 ) 67 ) ... ( 964,5 The ( 7 ) This and the two following measures are inserted only to show the probability , that the diameters of the columns were designed The distance between their centers , 63 feet 41/ 3 inches , = 67504,9 70 ) ... ( 964,4 The distance including their shafts , 66 feet 05/ 6 inch , = 70390,4 73 ) ... ( 964,3 The diameter of the columns , 2 feet 81/ 2 inches , = 2885,46 3 ) ... ( 961,8 The uprights will not answer to any one measure of the foot by whole divisors ; nor will they agree with each other by broken ones , so nearly as the horizontal measures do , which may partly be owing to the difficulty of taking them correctly .
The shafts of the columns measure 21 feet 81/ 4 inches , = 23105,9 24 ) ... ( 962,7 The pedestals , 12 feet 35/ 12 inches , = 13088,14 131/ 2 ) ... ( 969,5 The whole order , 33 feet 41/ 4 inches , = 35535,53 37 ) ... ( 960,4 The attic , 15 feet 51/ 3 inches , = 16454,51 17 ) ... ( 967,9 The blocking , 1 foot 92/ 3 inches , = 1923,64 2 ) ... ( 961,8 The whole height , 62 feet 102/ 3 inches , = 67001,8 691/ 2 ) ... ( 964,1 I have produced these uprights , rather as an instance how little such measures are to be depended on , even in buildings correctly executed , than as of any authority for the measure of the foot .
For they cannot be reconciled to a common measure without signed to be three Roman feet , and not as of any authority in the determination of the measure of the foot .
fractions of the digit in the divisors , by which means any measure of the foot might be derived from any building .
A mean from the seven first horizontal measures gives a Roman foot of 964,3 parts .
A mean from the uprights one of 964,4 .
But the depth of the solid , and the widths of the entrances are most to be depended on , and these give a foot of 9643/ 4 London parts ; which will be found to be the greatest measure this building will answer to by probable divisors .
For though the extent of the front , or the width of the middle entrance , must probably have been the prime measure in a building of this kind ; yet no part seems more likely to consist of some number of whole feet ( or at least whole palms ) than the depth of the solid ; since there appears no reason why the architect should use odd digits in the measure of it .
Now if we suppose the extent of the front to have been 781/ 2 Roman feet , they will contain 970 parts each ; but to make the depth agree with this measure , it must have been 237/ 8 such feet , which does not seem probable , for the reason above-mentioned .
The middle entrance must then have been 227/ 8 , instead of 23 whole feet , and the extent on each side 2713/ 16 , instead of 28 .
And there will not be one whole measure in the plan of this building ; which is improbable .
Neither do these broken measures serve for the subdivision of the sides better , or even so well as the whole ones .
The shafts of the columns are so nearly 16 modules , that they seem to have been designed for that proportion ; and 1/ 32 of a Paris inch added to the diameters meters would make them so .
But this is not sufficient to make those diameters answer to 3 feet of 9643/ 4 parts , of which they want almost 1/ 10 of a Paris inch .
This may be partly an error in the workmanship , and partly in Desgodetz 's measure ; but if this quantity were added to them , they would not only answer to the same foot with the rest of the building , but all the parts in which their measure is included , would agree better with the depth of the solid , and the widths of the entrances .
The height of the blocking was probably intended for 2 Roman feet , though it answers to no greater measure of that foot than the diameters of the columns do .
But measures of 2 , 3 , and 4 feet , seldom agree with the larger ones in any of the buildings ; for a small error , either in the workmanship , or in the measuring , makes a very sensible difference in the length of the foot derived from such intervals .
And this blocking does not want the 1/ 13 part of a London inch , of 2 feet of 965 parts each .
The bankers arch , and the portico of Severus , are contemporary buildings with this , and seem to agree with it in the measure of the foot .
The former is a very small building , and its parts will not answer to any one common measure by divisors of whole digits .
However , the depth of the solid ( which , as I have before observed , is most likely to be a whole measure ) taken at three different parts , is 6 feet 4 inches , which answer to 7 Roman feet of 963,93 London parts .
There are but few measures in the portico of Severus .
Those most to be depended on are , the whole extent in front , and the shafts of the columns , which are each of one block .
The former measures 56 feet 1178/ 100 inches , = 60708,3 - , which contain 63 Roman feet of 963,6 parts each .
The latter measures 26 feet 111/ 4 inches , = 28699,22 , which contain 293/ 4 such feet of 964,7 parts .
The whole column , with the base and capital , measures 32 feet 61/ 2 inches , = 34669,9 London parts , which contain 36 Roman feet of 963 parts each .
It appears by the inscription on the architrave of the portico of the Pantheon ( 8 ) , that Severus repaired that temple ; and Desgodetz observes , that the pavement is not so old as the building .
That it was laid by Severus is probable , from the correctness of its measures , which is a remarkable characteristic of the workmanship of that age .
The square compartments on this pavement answer to 10 Roman feet , of 964,78 parts , agreeing with a mean from the depth of the solid of this arch , and the widths of the entrances , which are the most unexceptionable measures in it .
The breadth of the strait bands between these compartments , is equal to the measure Desgodetz has given of the diameters of the columns of this arch , and answers to 3 feeet of 961,8 parts .
But these bands might be purposely made somewhat short of the full measure , to leave room for one of the same breadth with the rest between the outermost compartments and the circular range ; for notwithstanding this , the workmen found themselves obliged to diminish both the outermost compartment , and the band beyond it .
( 8 ) Imp .
Caes .
Septimius Severus-et Imp .
Caes .
M. Aurelius Antoninus Pantheum vetustate corruptum cum omni cultu restituerunt .
The The concurring testimonies of these contemporary works , though not of sufficient authority to establish any measure of the foot by themselves , are yet very strong evidence in favour of the measure above derived from this arch .
And we shall find a farther confirmation of it in Diocletian 's baths .
The baths of Diocletian .
The whole length of this building is 439 feet 3 inches , = 467977 485 ) ... ( 964,8 The length of the great hall , 180 feet 81/ 6 inches , = 192497 + 200 ) ... ( 962,5 The breadth at one end , 74 feet 35/ 6 inches , = 79179,9 82 ) ... ( 965,6 Its breadth at the other end , 74 feet 51/ 2 inches , = 79327,9 82 ) ... ( 967 The distance between the middle solids on the side , 49 feet 81/ 4 inches , = 52937 + 55 ) ... ( 962,5 The depth of the recess out of the great hall between these solids , is 33 feet 61/ 6 inches , = 35705,7 37 ) ... ( 965 The distance between one of these solids and the nearest angular solid , 32 feet 115/ 8 inches , = 35124,9 361/ 2 ) ... ( 962,3 The distance between the other of them and the other angular solid , 33 feet 11/ 3 inch , = 35276,57 361/ 2 ) ... ( 966,4 Entrance at one end of the hall , 36 feet 21/ 6 inches , = 38546,8 40 ) ... ( 963,7 Entrance at the other end , 36 feet 11/ 4 inch , = 38465,4 ( twice ) 40 ) ... ( 961,6 Passage from the circular vestibule , 30 feet 91/ 4 inches , = 32783,2 ( twice ) 34 ) ... ( 964 Side entrance into the vestibule , 20 feet 92/ 3 inches , = 22166,2 23 ) ... ( 963,7 A measure from 4 feet 6 inches to 4 feet 61/ 2 inches , repeated 12 times , the mean from all of them is 4 feet 677/ 288 inches , = 4818,03 5 ) ... ( 963,6 A measure from 5 feet 5 inches to 5 feet 51/ 4 inches , repeated 11 times , the mean from all is 5 feet 52/ 11 inches , = 5787,05 6 ) ... ( 964,5 A measure from 2 feet 81/ 2 inches to 2 feet 85/ 6 inches , repeated 4 times , the mean from all is 2 feet 87/ 12 inches , = 2892,86 3 ) ... ( 964,3 A multiple of 6 feet on the wall , where this measure of 3 feet is thrice repeated , is 43 feet 51/ 8 inches , = 46267,2 48 ) ... ( 963,9 The diameter of the circular vestibule is too principal a part to be neglected .
It answers to 65 Roman feet of 969,1 parts , which the other measures in this building will not come up to by probable divisors .
It answers likewise to 651/ 4 feet of 965,4 parts ; but an odd palm in so large a measure is not probable .
Therefore it seems to have been incorrectly executed , and perhaps this circle was described by a cord .
The shafts of the columns , each of one block , measure 35 feet 115/ 12 inches , = 38302,6 393/ 4 ) ... ( 963,6 The whole column is 43 feet 61/ 6 inches , = 46359,7 48 ) ... ( 965,8 These are the principal measures in this building , and a mean taken from all of them , except the diameter of the vestibule , gives a foot of 964 , 1 London parts .
But the three small measures , of 5 , 6 , and 3 Roman feet ( the first of which is the passus ) are alone sufficient to discover the measure of the foot by which this building was constructed .
For , being so often repeated with so little variation , they must afford a mean very near the truth , if their divisors be rightly assumed ; and that these are so , can hardly be doubted .
For , were the two largest to be increased but by a single digit , they would give different measures of the foot from each other ; and that from the passus so increased , would fall short of 952 London parts ; which is less than the least of the ancient foot-rules .
On the other hand , were they diminished by the same quantity , they would not agree together so nearly in the measure of the foot as they now do , nor give such a measure of it as the rest of the building will answer to by probable divisors .
Besides , I have here reckoned only such of these measures as Desgodetz has figured on his plan ; whereas they are much oftener repeated , and that not in the diameters of columns , or the members of an order , but in breaks , projections , and thicknesses of walls , where a digit or two more or less could make no visible difference , provided the correspondent parts were made to answer to each other : and it is highly improbable that such odd measures as the passus wanting a digit , 6 feet wanting the same , and 3 feet wanting half a digit , should be so often repeated in so large a building , and in places that do not seem to require any such precise exactness .
Therefore these measures must have been whole feet , and the divisors are rightly assumed .
Their mean is 964 , 1 London parts , which exactly agrees with that found above from all the measures taken together .
The other remains of antiquity contained in this work are such fragments as can be be of little use in the present enquiry .
CONCLUSIO N. It appears from the measures of these buildings , that the Roman foot before the reign of Titus exceeded 970 parts in 1000 of the London foot , and in the reigns of Severus and Diocletian fell short of 965 .
Whether this difference proceeded from any alteration in the standard , or from a false measure of it being got into common use , either before the reign of Titus or after , is uncertain .
We have no account of any alteration made by law in the Roman standards after the Plebiscitum Silianum , quoted by Festus ( 9 ) ; but as great a difference as this might arise from their having been lost or destroyed .
( 9 ) Under the words Publica pondera .
They were kept in the Capitol ( 1 ) , and Rigaltius , from a passage in Hyginus , observes that the standard of the foot was deposited in the temple of Juno Moneta ( 2 ) .
Now the Capitol was burnt no less than three times ; first in the civil war of Sylla ( 3 ) ; then again when Sabinus was besieged in it by the troops of Vitellius ( 4 ) ; and the third time in that dreadful conflagration which happened in the reign of Titus ( 5 ) .
Whether the standards were destroyed in the first of these fires is uncertain ; but they could hardly escape the fury and confusion of the second , when , according to Pliny , the temple of Juno Moneta seems to have been burnt to the ground ( 6 ) .
And , if we may credit Xiphilin ( whose account of the third is in some measure confirmed by Spartian ) , not only the temple of Jupiter Capitolinus , but those adjoining to it , were burnt down in the last ( 7 ) .
Vespasian ( 1 ) This appears from the inscription on Vespasian 's congius , and from R. Fannius .
And Jul. Capitolinus in Maximinis , mentions the amphora Capitolina .
( 2 ) Hyginus de Limit .
constituend .
near the end , distinguishes the Roman foot by the name of Pes Monetalis .
That this temple was in the Capitol , appears from Livy , lib. vii .
c. 28 .
Cicero de Divin , lib. i. and Pliny , lib. xxxiv .
cap. 7 .
Suidas ( v. ~ ) tells us the mint was kept here .
( 3 ) Taciti Hist. lib. iii .
This fire is likewise mentioned by Plutarch and Appian .
( 4 ) Tacitus , ibid. ( 5 ) Xiphilin in Tito .
Sueton .
in Domit .
c. 5 .
( 6 ) Pliny , lib. xxxiv .
c. 7 .
says , ` ` AEtas nostra vidit in Capitolio , priusquam id novissime conflagravit , a Vitellianis incensum , in cella Junonis canem ex aere , &amp;c. ' ' And if the donatives were destroyed , it is not likely the standards should be saved in a scene of such confusion .
( 7 ) ~ ~ .
Xiphilin in Tito .
Spartian , enumerating the public Vespasian rebuilt the Capitol after the second conflagration , and restored the ancient records from copies of them that were got abroad ( 8 ) , and probably the standards at the same time .
The congius was restored by weight , according to the Plebiscitum Silianum , as the inscription on it testifies .
The quadrantal was too cumbersome a vessel for common use , to which the congius ( like our gallon ) was well adapted ; so that I do not see what other purpose it could serve , but to adjust the congius to its capacity , and the foot to its side : but here we see the congius adjusted by weight , and it is not very likely that a new quadrantal should be made for no other end but to adjust the foot by , when so many copies of the old standard were extant .
Therefore it is not improbable , that the standard of the foot was at this time restored , without any regard to its relation to the quadrantal .
But as to the difference between the foot derived from the congius , and that found from other authorities , I must farther observe , that the correct adjustment of weights to measures , is a very difficult matter , even in this age , and in this kingdom , where workmanship is arrived at a high pitch of accuracy .
And what errors rude workmanship is liable to , sufficiently appears from the weights Paetus and Villalpandus have given of the congius .
Therefore I see no reason to reject the testimonies of those authors , buildings restored by Adrian , mentions most of those that Xiphilin says were burnt in this fire .
Domitian rebuilt the Capitol .
Suet .
in Domit .
c. 5 .
( 8 ) Sueton .
in Vespas .
c. 8 .
who say that the cubic foot contained a quadrantal of wine ; and as little to believe that these two standards were ever truly adjusted to each other .
But had the original standard of the Roman foot been truly adjusted to the quadrantal , and continued invariable from the time of its first establishment , yet a false measure of it might at one time or other have got into common use at Rome , as well as a false measure of the French foot did at Paris ; where in the year 1668 , the mason 's foot was found to exceed the foot of the Chatelet by 5/ 72 of a Paris inch ( 9 ) , which is above 1/ 14 of a London inch : and the unaccountable negligence which appears in the Roman coinage , gives sufficient ground to suspect they were not more accurate in their measures .

