An Explanation of the Modes or Tones in the ancient Graecian Music ; by Sir Francis Haskins Eyles Stiles , Bart. F. R. S. NOtwithstanding the valuable editions of the ancient musical and harmonic writers , given by Meibomius and Wallis , and the great pains those two learned editors have bestowed on the correcting the tables , and throwing light on the difficult passages of those works , there are some of the doctrines delivered in them , that seem still to require a more perfect explanation .
Those , that respect the tones or modes , in particular , seem to have been ill understood : and as it was on these , that the effects of the ancient music were supposed principally to depend , I have thought , that the subject might well merit a reexamination .
Read December 1759 , and January , &amp;c. 1760 .
Concerning these modes , we find two distinct , and seemingly contradictory doctrines delivered by the ancients ; and this it is , which has perplexed the subject ; ject ; for some , not aware of the distinction , have charged the ancients with contradictions ; and others , who perceived the two doctrines , not being able to reconcile them , have either adopted one , and rejected the other , or given up the subject as hopeless : but , as they were both admitted by the ancients , they must both have been true , in some sense .
What , therefore , I have principally in view in these sheets , is to show , that the difference between the doctrines arose only from the different way of considering one and the same object ; and that therefore there was such an agreement betwixt them , as that , under certain restrictions , they may be embraced under one common interpretation .
For distinction sake , I shall call one of these doctrines the harmonic , and the other the musical doctrine ; the reason of which will sufficiently appear , when I come to treat of the distinction between the science of harmonic and that of melopaeia or musical composition .
According to the harmonic doctrine , the number of the modes had been augmented to fifteen ; but as Ptolemey , who appears to have favoured the musical , reduces them to seven , and as it is on the principles of that writer , that I propose to show an agreement between the doctrines , it will be necessary for me , in treating of the harmonic modes , to distinguish the seven he admits from the eight he has excluded .
This being premised , I shall be understood in making the distribution of what I have to offer upon this subject , which I propose to treat under the following six heads .
First , To explain the harmonic doctrine , as far as concerns the seven modes admitted by Ptolemey .
Secondly , To explain the musical doctrine of the same modes , and show its agreement with the harmonic .
Thirdly , To explain the eight harmonic modes rejected by Ptolemey , and give at large his reasons for excluding them .
Fourthly , To point out something of the origin of the two doctrines .
Fifthly , To show how far the preceding explanations may be supported by arguments , or warranted by the testimony of ancient writers .
Lastly , To consider how this subject has been understood by Meibomius , Wallis , and some few others that have wrote since , and in what respect their explanations differ from my own .
I now proceed to the first head ; viz. First , To explain the harmonic doctrine , as far as concerns the seven modes admitted by Ptolemey .
The harmonic doctrine of the tones we find expressly delivered in the harmonic treatises ; which , probably , is the reason , why , among the moderns , the later writers at least have , for the most part , determined themselves in its favour : how justly it is entitled to the preference , I shall have sufficient occasion to examine .
The treatises on harmonic , that are come down to us , are mostly Aristoxenian , which school seems to have treated the science , if not better , at least more methodically than any other , of which we can now form a judgment ; and hence we find their divisions often adopted by ancient writers , who might not , perhaps , be ready to admit all their principles .
In considering the physical properties of sound , and the ratios of intervals , the Aristoxenians appear to have been less exact than the Pythagoreans , the doctrines of the former being more adapted to the gross and familiar notions of the practical musician , than to the accurate speculations of the philosopher .
But , however exceptionable their treatises may have been in this respect , they are the more valuable to us , on this very account , as they give more light into the ancient practice of music ; which is what is chiefly desired , the philosophic principles of the science being better understood .
By this school harmonic was divided into these seven parts ; 1 .
of sounds , 2 .
of intervals , 3 .
of genera , 4 .
of systems , 5 .
of tones , 6 .
of mutations , 7 .
of melopaeia .
The propriety of their adding this last division I shall have occasion to consider .
Of these divisions , it was the fifth , which contained the doctrine in question ; but , to complete it , the sixth must also be taken in ; for , amongst other mutations , that of the tones was there treated of , and was indeed the most considerable object of that division .
This doctrine taught , that the difference between one tone and another lay in the tension or pitch of the system .
The system ( by which I mean the greater perfect one , exclusive of the less , of which I shall have little occasion to speak ) consisted of fifteen sounds , extending to a disdiapason , or double octave .
How these sounds were denominated , and at what intervals they succeeded each other , in the diatonic genus , to which I shall confine this explanation , is so well known , that I need say no more concerning the structure of the system , than that it answered to that of our natural scale , beginning with Are , and ending with Alamire .
This system was held immutable , as to the relation of its parts one to another ; that is , the order of sounds and intervals , by which it proceeded , was in the same genus to be always the same ; but the tension or pitch of the whole was variable , a different one being assigned for each mode .
The explanation , therefore , usually given of the system , by comparing it , as I have done , to a double octave , from A in our natural scale , is not to be understood as fixing its pitch , but as showing its succession only ; which might as well be done by a double octave from B , taking C# and F# into the scale , or from any other note , taking in the flats and sharps necessary to make the tones and semitones follow in the same order .
The relation of the parts to each other in the system being immutable , the fixing the pitch of any one sound in it , for any mode , was sufficient to determine that of all the rest .
For this purpose , the sound mes was commonly used ; which , by its situation , was well adapted to it , being the middle sound of the system .
If , therefore , we settle the position of the mes for each mode , we shall do all , that is requisite for the clearing up and establishing the harmonic doctrine , which considered the modes as differing only in the pitch of the system .
The modes admitted by the Aristoxenians were thirteen in number ; to which two more were added by later harmonicians ; and to the mes of each of these fifteen a distinct pitch was assigned ; but , as Ptolemey has rejected eight of them , I shall , as I have proposed first , separately consider the positions of the mes for the seven modes he admits .
Concerning the relative pitch of the respective meses for these seven modes , I find no disagreement amongst the harmonic writers .
There are not wanting , indeed , who charge the ancients with giving , in respect thereto , contradictory accounts .
Amongst others , the learned Dr. Gregory asserts , that Aristides Quintilianus inverts the order of the modes ( 1 ) : but what led the doctor into this mistake , was his not distinguishing the double doctrine .
Aristides , in the passage cited , is not speaking of the pitch of the system for the seven modes in question , but of the seven species of diapason , as they lay in the system ; which was , indeed , in the inverted order of the meses of the seven modes , as will appear , when we come to consider the other doctrine .
This , then , is no contradiction in the Greek writer , nor , if it were , would it be chargeable singly on him ; since , if the doctor had but cast his eye on his own Euclid ( 2 ) , he would have met with the very same doctrine he found in Aristides .
But his remark is , indeed , entirely without foundation ; and I make no scruple to assert , that the ancients agree in their accounts of the relative pitch of the meses , for these seven modes ; ( 1 ) Atque Aristides Quintilianus ( page .
18 .
editionis Meibomianae ) tonum Hypodorium acutiorem facit quam Dorium , et Hypophrygium quam Phrygium , et Hypolydium quam Lydium .
Vide Praefat .
ad Opera Euclid .
( 2 ) Page .
540 .
verse .
6 .
et seq. seu page .
15 .
verse .
15 .
edit Meibom .
for though many of the harmonic writers treat of the thirteen or fifteen modes all together , without distinguishing the seven in question , yet they have given them in such order , and at such distances , that the seven stand at the same intervals from each other , as are assigned for them by those , who have treated of them separately ; so that all the accounts agree in this particular .
The direction we may conveniently take from Bacchius ( 3 ) , where it is clearly and concisely delivered ; and where it appears , that the Mixolydian was the most acute ; the Lydian , graver by a semitone ; the Phrygian , graver than the Lydian by a tone ; the Dorian , graver than the Phrygian by a tone ; the Hypolydian , graver than the Dorian by a semitone ; the Hypophrygian , graver than the Hypolydian by a tone ; and the Hypodorian , graver than the Hypophrygian by a tone .
Now , as the Guidonian scale , in use amongst the moderns , when stripped of Guido 's additions , answers to the system of the ancients , in its natural situation , which was in the Dorian mode , and our Alamire consequently answers to the pitch of the Dorian mes , we have a plain direction for finding the absolute pitch of the meses , for all the seven in our modern notes , and they will be found to stand thus : Mixolydian mes in d Hypolydian in g# Lydian in c# Hypophrygian in f# Phrygian in b Hypodorian in e Dorian in a But to understand this doctrine , as it is delivered by the ancients , it will be necessary also to examine , how ( 3 ) Page .
12 .
edit .
Meibom .
the meses of the seven modes were stationed upon the lyre ; and , in order to this , we must consider the structure of that instrument .
The lyre , after its last enlargement , consisted of fifteen strings , which took in the compass of a disdiapason , or double octave .
These strings were called by the same names as the fifteen sounds of the system , and when tuned for the Dorian mode , corresponded exactly with them .
Indeed there can be no doubt , but that the theory of the system had been originally drawn from the practice of the lyre in this mode , which was the favourite one of the Greeks , as the lyre was also their favourite instrument .
In this mode , then , the mes of the system was placed in the mes of the lyre ; but in every one of the rest , it was applied to a different string , and every sound of the system transposed accordingly .
Hence arose the distinction between a sound in power and a sound in position ; for when the system was transposed from the Dorian to any other mode , ( suppose , for instance , to the Phrygian ) the mes of the lyre , though still mes in position , acquired , in this case , the power of the lichanos meson ; and the paramese of the lyre , though still paramese in position~ acquired the power of the mes .
In these transpositions , one or more of the strings always required new tunings , to preserve the relations of the system ; but , notwithstanding this alteration of their pitch , they retained their old names , when spoken of , in respect to their positions only ; for the name implied not any particular pitch of the string , but only its place upon the lyre , in the numerical order , reckoning the proslambanomenos for the first .
I thought this remark the more necessary , as I suspect it was the not attending to this circumstance , that led Dr. Wallis to assign c and g natural , for the places of the mes in the Lydian and Hypolydian modes , instead of c# and g # , where I have placed them ( 4 ) .
But , to return , We are now to give the places of the mes for these seven modes upon the lyre , which are thus settled by Ptolemey ( 5 ) .
String Mixolydian Paranetediezeugmenon 11 Lydian Tritediezeugmenon 10 Phrygian Paramese 9 Dorian Mes in Mes 8 Hypolydian Lichanos meson 7 Hypophrygian Parhypate meson 6 Hypodorian Hypate meson 5 The positions assigned for the meses of these seven modes , by the harmonic doctrine , being thus settled , both in our modern scale , and upon the lyre , I come now , Secondly , To explain the musical doctrine of the same modes , and show its agreement with the harmonic .
The musical doctrine taught , that the difference between one mode and another consisted in the manner of dividing an octave , or , as the ancients express it , in the different species of diapason .
The elementary principles of these species we find delivered ( 4 ) See his edition of Ptolemey , p. 137 .
( 5 ) Ibidem .
in the harmonic writers ; but as in the Aristoxenian treatises , they are not found under the fifth division , of tones ; nor under the sixth , of mutations , where it was natural to expect them ; but under the fourth , of systems ; and it not being there expressly affirmed , that the species had a relation to the tones , though , from their denominations , and other circumstances , it might well be inferred , this has created a difficulty in admitting their connection with the subject .
The obviating of this objection I shall reserve for my fifth head ; where I shall take occasion , particularly , to justify this doctrine , and the use I shall have made of it ; and I shall therefore proceed to explain it , as I find it in the harmonic writers .
To understand how this doctrine of the species of diapason came to be treated under the head of systems , it will be necessary to consider the definition given of the term system by the Aristoxenians , and their subdivision of this branch of harmonic .
With this school , whatever consisted of more than one interval , was a system .
So comprehensive a definition could not but make this branch a very large one ; and so we accordingly find it .
It was subdivided in the manner following : systems were there considered as differing in respect , first , to magnitude ; secondly , to genus ; thirdly , to the being consonant or dissonant ; fourthly , to the being rational or irrational ; fifthly , to the being sequent or transgressive ; sixthly , to the being conjunct or disjunct ; seventhly , to the being mutable or immutable .
Now , of these seven differences , it was under the third that the doctrine of the species of diapason came to be treated , the consonant systems being there enumerated , and explained .
By a consonant system was understood a system , whose extreme or comprehending sounds were consonant : of these , there were six within the compass of the immutable system , viz. the diatessaron , diapente , diapason , diapason and diatessaron , diapason and diapente , and disdiapason .
These consonant systems were considered as admitting each of a variety in the order of the intervals , of which it was composed .
A system of a determined magnitude , composed of the same intervals , and of the same number of them , might , if the component intervals were not equal , differ in respect to their order or succession .
These variations of each system they called ~ , its species , or ~ , its figure , for these terms were synonymous ( 6 ) .
The species of diatessaron were three ; those of the diapente four , and those of the diapason seven , being the sum of the species of the other two consonances , of which the diapason itself was composed : and here the doctrine of the species stopped ; for , in the three larger consonant systems , they seem not to have considered the species of the whole magnitude , but only those of the three smaller systems , of which they were composed , and which are called , by Ptolemey , the first consonances ( 7 ) .
As the species of diatessaron and diapente do not immediately concern this doctrine , the explaining them will be unnecessary ; and I shall therefore proceed to those of the diapason .
( 6 ) ~ ~ ~ .
Aristox .
p. 74 .
v. 9 .
( 7 ) ~ ~ ~ .
~ .
lib. ii .
c. 3 .
Concerning Concerning these , I find no disagreement amongst the writers of antiquity : they all agree , that they were seven in number , and had the denominations of Mixolydian , Lydian , Phrygian , Dorian , Hypolydian , Hypophrygian , and Hypodorian ; circumstances , which leave no doubt of their connection with the modes .
The succession of intervals , or manner of dividing the diapason for each species , has been variously explained by the ancient writers ; but the result of these explanations is the same , excepting the generic differences .
It will be sufficient here to give what respects the diatonic genus only , as the question concerning the tones does not turn upon the distinction of the genera .
In the diatonic genus , the diapason consisting of five tonic and two semitonic intervals , the Aristoxenians fixed the succession for each species , by the position of the two semitones ; showing , at the same time , between which of the sounds of the immutable system the species in question was comprehended : for this system consisting of fifteen sounds , contained eight octaves , two of which , viz. that from proslambanomenos to mes , and that from mes again to netehyperboleon , were divided after the same manner , and therefore constituted the same species : but the six others were all differently divided ; so that the system contained within itself the seven species of diapason , and thence obtained the denomination of perfect ; the lesser perfect system , which reached only to a diapason and diatessaron , being improperly so called for want of this qualification , as Ptolemey has shown ( 8 ) .
According to this method of explaining the species of diapason , they stand as follows : From hypate hypaton to paramese .
Species .
1 .
Mixolydian Semitones , first interval in the grave , fourth in the acute .
From parhypate hypaton to trite diezeugmenon .
2 .
Lydian Semitones , third interval in the grave , first in the acute .
From lichanos meson to paranete diezeugmenon .
3 .
Phrygian Semitones , second interval in the grave , second in the acute .
From hypate meson to nete diezeugmenon .
4 .
Dorian Semitones , first interval in the grave , third in the acute .
From parhypate meson to trite hyperbolaeon .
5 .
Hypolydian Semitones , fourth interval in the grave , first in the acute .
From lichanos meson to paranete hyperbolaeon .
6 .
Hypophrygian Semitones , third interval in the grave , second in the acute .
( 8 ) ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Ptol .
Harm .
p. 106 .
v. 3 .
From mes to nete hyperbolaeon , or prosl .
to mes .
Species .
7 .
Hypodorian Semitones , second interval in the grave , third in the acute .
It must be here observed , that these species , as they stand in the system , are , with respect to acuteness and gravity , in the inverted order of the seven modes , as settled by the harmonic doctrine , which will account for the mistake , which Dr. Gregory ( as was shown above ) and others have fallen into , in imagining the ancients did not agree in their accounts of the modes ; since it is plain these writers did not observe , that , in the one case , the modes were spoken of with respect to the position of the system itself , and in the other , with respect to the position of the seven species within the system .
These species may also be more readily shown , by examples out of the Guidonian scale , where , keeping the natural notes , they will stand thus : Mixolydian B to b. Lydian C to c. Phrygian D to d. Dorian from E to e. Hypolydian F to f. Hypophrygian G to g. Hypodorian e to a a , or A to a. But as well this , as the former way of showing them , we are to understand only as exemplifications of the succession of the intervals , and not as an assignment of the pitch for each , which was to depend on that of the system , out of which they are exemplified ; and it may not be amiss therefore , in order to prevent any limited conception of these species , to state generally the order of the intervals , of which each is composed ; which will be as follows , proceeding in each from grave to acute .
Mixolydian .
Semitone , tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone , tone .
Lydian .
Tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone , tone , semitone .
Phrygian .
Tone , semitone , tone , tone , tone , semitone , tone .
Dorian .
Semitone , tone , tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone .
Hypolydian .
Tone , tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone , semitone .
Hypophrygian .
Tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone , semitone , tone .
Hypodorian .
Tone , semitone , tone , tone , semitone , tone , tone .
Besides the manner above-mentioned of explaining the species of diapason , the ancients have given us another , the result of which is the same ; and that is , by the position of the diazeuctic tone , or interval from mes to paramese .
In the Mixolydian species , the diazeuctic tone was the first interval , reckoning from acute to grave ; in the Lydian , it was the second ; in the Phrygian , the third ; in the Dorian , the fourth ; in the Hypolydian , the fifth ; in the Hypophrygian , the sixth ; and in the Hypodorian , the last .
Now , either of these methods fixes the succession of intervals peculiar to each species ; but as the examples are taken from a system , whose pitch was variable , we are still to seek , at what absolute pitch the several species were taken in the modes , to which we suppose them to have been respectively subservient ; and it is , perhaps , the seeming difficulty of settling this , that has induced so many to reject this doctrine entirely , and fall in with the harmonic writers , who considered the modes as differing only in the pitch of the system : but , by taking in the assistance of the harmonic doctrine , we shall not only gain the true pitch for each species in the musical , but be led to see the agreement between the two doctrines , which , I have already said , was my principal view in these sheets , and which , having gone through the explanation of each doctrine separately , as far as concerns the seven modes , we are now ripe for considering ; for the eight modes , whose explanation I have deferred , have no concern in this agreement , being rejected by Ptolemey , as will appear , for this very reason , in substance , that they would stand the trial of the harmonic doctrine only , whereas the rest had the support of both .
Let us then consider how the two doctrines , as I have explained them , may be made to agree .
By the harmonic doctrine , we are told the pitch of the system for each mode ; and by the musical , in what part of the system to take the species of diapason : now , by combining these two directions , we gain the following plain canon , for finding any mode required .
CANO N. First pitch the system for the mode , as directed by the harmonic doctrine ; then select from it the diapason , directed by the musical ; and we have the characteristic species of the mode in its true pitch .
To make this more plainly appear , and also to avoid the length of particular explanations , I have annexed a diagram of the seven species , which will show at what pitch of the Guidonian scale each sound D IAGRAM I. Of the Species of Diapason in the Seven Modes admitted Mixolydian .
Lydian .
Phrygian .
Dorian .
Hypolydian .
e Paramese .
e Trite diez .
e Paran .
diez .
e Nete diez .
e Trite hyperb .
Diaz .
tone .
d# Paramese .
d# Nete diez .
d Mes .
Diaz .
tone .
d Trite diez .
d Paran .
diez .
c# Mes .
c# Paramese .
c# Paran .
diez .
c Lich .
mes .
Diaz .
tone .
c Trite diez .
b Lich .
mes .
b Mes .
b Paramese .
b Trite diez .
bb Parhyp .
mes .
Diaz .
tone .
a# Paramese .
a Hyp. mes .
a Parhyp .
mes .
a Lich .
mes .
a Mes .
Diaz .
tone .
g# ~ .
mes .
g# Mes .
g Lich .
hyp .
g Parhyp .
mes .
g Lich .
mes .
f# Lich .
hyp .
f# Hyp. mes .
f# Lich .
mes .
f Parhyp .
hyp .
f Parhyp .
mes .
e Hyp. hyp .
e Parhyp .
hyp .
e Lich .
hyp .
e Hyp. mes .
e Parhyp .
mes .
mitted by PTOLEME Y. Hypophrygian .
Hypodorian .
~ .
e Paran .
hyperb .
e Nete hyperb .
~ .
d Trite hyperb .
d Paran .
hyperb .
diez .
c# Nete diez .
c Trite hyperb .
diez .
b Paran .
diez .
b Nete diez .
~ .
a Trite diez .
a Paran .
diez .
~ .
g# Paramese .
Diaz .
tone .
g Trite diez .
mes .
f# Mes .
f# Paramese .
Diaz .
tone .
~ .
mes .
e Lich .
mes .
e Mes .
of the diapason is brought out by the canon for each of the seven modes .
As in the construction of this diagram , the directions of the canon have been strictly pursued , so it will appear , that the result of it is , in all respects , conformable to the principles of both doctrines .
Thus in the Dorian , for instance , it will be seen , that the mes is placed in Alamire , and that the rest of the sounds exhibited in that diapason , are placed at the proper distances , for preserving the order of the system , as required by the harmonic doctrine .
It will be also seen , that the diapason selected lies between hypate meson and nete diezeugmenon ; that the semitones are the first interval in the grave , and third in the acute ; and that the diazeuctic tone is in the fourth interval , reckoning from the acute ; all which circumstances were also required by the musical doctrine for this mode ; and , in the rest of the modes , all the circumstances required by each doctrine will , in like manner , be found to obtain : so that no objection can well be raised to the principles , on which the diagram has been framed , by the favourers of either doctrine separately ; and the very coincidence of the two doctrines therein , might furnish a probable argument in justification of the manner , in which I have combined them in the canon .
But as I propose to consider this under the fifth head , where the proofs will be collected , I shall leave this argument for the present , and proceed to explain , Thirdly , The eight harmonic modes rejected by Ptolemey , and give at large his reasons for excluding them .
Six of these modes , with the seven Ptolemey allowed , made up the thirteen allowed by the Aristoxenians : the other two seem to have been added afterwards , more with a view to regularity in the names and positions of the modes , than to any particular use , as will appear in the course of the explanation .
For the settling these eight modes , I shall have no occasion to go farther than the fixing the position of the mes for each , according to the harmonic doctrine : the result of applying the musical doctrine to them will sufficiently appear , when I come to explain the reasons , which Ptolemey has assigned for rejecting t~em .
The old Dorian , Phrygian , and Lydian modes , having , as we have seen , their meses respectively in a , b , c # , at the distance of a tone from each other , these tonic spaces were afterwards divided , to make room for the Ionian mes in b flat , and the AEolian in c natural .
To these five modes , whose meses succeeded each other at the interval of a semitone , and which came , in time , to be called the middle modes , five others were made to correspond , that lay respectively graver by a fourth , and took their denominations from them , but compounded with the preposition hypo , to distinguish them .
Of these , we have already shown the Hypodorian mes to have been in e , the Hypophrygian in f # , and the Hypolydian in g # .
Now , the two tonic spaces between e , f # , and g # , being likewise divisible , the Hypoionian mes was inserted in f natural , and the Hypoaeolian in g natural , at a fourth respectively from the Ionian and AEolian .
To these ten modes , it was conceived that five more might properly be ranged towards the acute , at the distances of a fourth respectively from the five first mentioned , and taking their denominations from them also , but compounded with the preposition hyper , which would complete them to fifteen , divided into five grave , five middle , and five acute .
But the Aristoxenians limiting the positions of the mes to the compass of an octave , had established only three out of these last five , viz. the old Mixolydian , whose mes we have shown to be in d , at a fourth from the Dorian , and which was therefore afterwards called Hyperdorian ; the Hyperionian , whose mes was in e flat , at a fourth from the Ionian ; and the Hypermixolydian ( for so it had been originally named , the preposition being taken in a different sense ) , the mes of which was in e , at a fourth from the Phrygian , and which was therefore afterwards called the Hyperphrygian .
To make these acute modes therefore five in number , as well as the grave and middle ones , two new modes were added , viz. the Hyperaeolian , whose mes was in f , and the Hyperlydian , whose mes was in f # , at a fourth respectively from the AEolian and Lydian .
The modes being thus augmented to fifteen , upon the single principle of the harmonic doctrine , their meses will be found to stand all together in the following order .
Hyperlydian in f# Hyperaeolian f Acute Hyperphrygian , or Hypermixolydian e Hyperionian eb Hyperdorian , or Mixolydian d Middle Lydian in c# AEolean c Middle Phrygian b Ionian bb Dorian a Hypolydian in g# Hypoaeolian g Grave Hypophrygian f# Hypoionian f Hypodorian e Having now shown , how these fifteen modes were situated according to the harmonic doctrine , I come to the objections raised by Ptolemey against the eight last explained .
For the right understanding of which , it will be necessary to give an account of all that he has delivered on the subject of the modes , a task of some difficulty ; for though his reasoning appears to me most clear and methodical , it is rather too prolix to be given exactly in his own words , as this , with the necessary explanations of those passages , of which the sense is less obvious , would carry me to too great a length .
I must therefore endeavour to abridge his doctrines , though at the hazard of leaving out some of the substantial parts , and thereby doing injustice to his argument .
It will be expedient to premise something concerning his apparent intention , and method of reasoning in this part of his work , which will serve as a key to his argument : and this seems the more necessary , as he has been thought by some ( 9 ) to ( 9 ) So obscurely has the best of all the ancient writers ( Ptolemey ) delivered himself on this article ( the tones ) , that deserved to have been most clearly handled .
Malcolm 's Treatise on Music , p. 539 .
have written very obscurely upon the subject .
His chief view was to reduce the fifteen modes , admitted upon the principle of the harmonic doctrine , to those seven , which had the support also of the musical : but this reformation was to be attempted with great precaution , on account of the obstinate prejudices it was likely to meet with , from the harmonicians of his own time : And we shall therefore find him first artfully treating the modes upon the foot of the harmonic doctrine only , and arguing ad homines for the reduction of the modes , even upon their own principles ; but , before he drops the subject , his true reasons will appear ; and , indeed , it will easily be seen , that he had them constantly in view from the first , though he does not argue openly upon them .
This will account for that mixture of the two doctrines , which is found in his writings , and will , with the assistance of a few explanations , render intelligible what he has delivered upon the subject .
The tones he considers , after the harmonic doctrine , as mutations by whole constitutions , which , he tells us , are therefore properly called tones , as they are differences in respect to tension .
These differences he admits to be infinite in possibility , but argues , that in efficacy , and in respect to sense , they are finite , and liable to certain limitations .
These limitations he derives from the theory of the consonances , by which means , he lays a foundation for his future argument , for reducing the modes to the number of species of the consonance diapason .
The limitations of the tones , which he proposes to regulate by those of the consonances , are , as he tells us , threefold ; viz. 1 .
As to the distance , or ratio , as he expresses it , of the extreme tones ; for the Pythagoreans , whose method he adopts with some improvements of his own , measured intervals by the ratios of the comprehending sounds .
2 .
As to the number of tones to be admitted between these extremes .
And , 3 .
As to the intervals , at which they were to stand in succession , which he calls their excesses .
Thus in the diatessaron consonance , which he instances , these three circumstances are observable ; first , That the ratio of the extreme sounds is sesquitertian ; secondly , That the component intervals , or ratios , are three ; and thirdly , That such and such are the differences of those ratios , meaning the intervals in succession .
But here he observes , that , in the consonances , these limitations have each their distinct cause ; whereas in the tones , the first being determined , the other two necessarily followed , as being dependent on the same conditions .
This remark will hardly be intelligible , without some explanation .
The interval , or ratio of the extreme sounds in each consonance , though differently treated by the Aristoxenian and Pythagorean schools , were yet determined , both by the one and the other , upon principles , which concerned not their intermediate division : their intermediate division again was settled by a doctrine , that required , in the composition of intervals , either that every fourth sound should complete the diatessaron , or every fifth the diapente ; without one or other of which circumstances , the composition was held inconcinnous nous ( 10 ) ; and hence the diatessaron could not be divided into more than three ratios , nor the diapente into more than four ; and again , the excesses of the ratios , or intervals in succession , were assigned by the doctrine of the genera ; so that in the consonances , each of the three limitations had a separate cause ; but in applying the same limitations to the tones , there was a connection between them ; so that the determining the first , determined the rest .
Thus , for instance , if the interval diatessaron , or sequitertian ratio , should be assigned for the limitation of the extreme tones , the other limitations could only be such , as were assigned for that consonance ; that is , the component ratios must be three , and the excesses of those ratios such , as were established for the diatessaron by the doctrine of the genera .
But the not knowing the necessity of this consequence , he tells us , had occasioned a great disagreement amongst the harmonicians in determining these points , some making the interval of the extreme tones less than a diapason , others equal to it , and others again exceeding it ; the later harmonicians , in particular , being fond of adding something to what had been admitted by those , who went before them .
To bring these various opinions to some determination , he proposes the restitution of similitude in the hermosmenon , or harmonised melos , as the chief circumstance , by which to regulate the ( 10 ) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Aristox .
p. 54 .
edit .
Meibom .
first limitation ; and this , he says , is effected by the diapason , for , at that distance , there was always a return of similar harmony ; so that the tone , that was a diapason distant from that first taken , was a repetition of it ; and the tone still farther distant , as for instance , at a diapason and diatessaron , the same with the tone distant a diatessaron only , and so of the rest .
For a proof of this , he appeals to the practice of music ; where it was well known , that in such mutations , as were at the interval of a diapason , no one of the strings required new tuning , though in all other mutations some alterations were necessary .
And hence he concludes , that those , who make the distance of the extreme tones less than the diapason , do not restitute the hermosmenon , there being still other tones beyond the limit they assign , unlike to those before taken ; and that those , who exceed the diapason , admit redundancies , by repeating some of the harmonies before taken ; and further insists , that even they , who proceeded no farther than the diapason , were yet to blame , inasmuch as they took in the tone , that was a diapason distant from the first , since , in so doing , they admitted one redundancy , and thereby gave a handle to those , whom they charged with passing the proper limits for the modes , to accuse them , in turn , with being really the authors of this licence , since , if one useless tone be admitted , the same privilege may be fairly claimed for a greater number .
This last argument seems levelled at the Aristoxenians , who admitted no more than thirteen modes ; because they would not exceed the diapason ; but whose Hyperphrygian was , according to this argument , a repetition of the Hypodorian .
The author supports this argument still farther , by an appeal to the circumstance of the species of diapason , the sounds of which were eight , but the number of the species seven only , answering not to the number of terms in the division , but to that of the component ratios : for that the diapason taken from the gravest sound towards the grave , yielded the same species with the first diapason taken from the acutest sound towards the same parts , was out of dispute , it holding true universally , that whatever takes its beginning in the same manner from either of the extremes of the diapason , produces the same power .
And here he leaves the first limitation , without expressly assigning the interval for the extreme tones ; for the title of the chapter , which seems to fix it to a diapason , ought to be understood only in this sense , that it should not exceed it ; which agrees with the reasoning in the chapter itself .
As to the conclusion , which depended on the two other limitations , if I may venture to draw it for him , it will stand thus , that into what number soever of terms the diapason be divided , the distance for the extreme tones should be the interval between the first term and the last but one .
The first limitation being thus far considered , he proceeds to determine the next , upon which depended the number of the tones ; and here he again opposes the Aristoxenians , rejecting , by his theory of this limitation , sive of their thirteen modes , besides the Hyperphrygian , which stood condemned by the former one , and leaving only seven , according to the number of the species of diapason , which he proposes as the properest rule , by which to govern this limitation ; and assigns for this the following reasons .
The number of the species of diapason was equal to that of the species of the two first consonances taken together , and the species of these last were taken according to the condition of the ratios in each , the number of which the very nature of them would not permit to be either increased or diminished .
Now the tones contained within the diapason following the nature of the consonances , and being indeed established on their account , viz. that the whole systems might have consonant differences , he argues , that those , who were either for admitting more than seven , which was the number both of the species and of the ratios in the diapason , or for making all the excesses of the tones equal , were not to be assented to , since they could not assign any satisfactory reason , either for the equality of the increments in general , which , in the harmonic genus , was particularly inconvenient , or for fixing either on the tone , hemitone , or diesis , in particular , for the common excess , ( from the supposition of one or other of which , they determined the number of tones , according to the number of such intervals contained within the diapason ) .
For what was there to determine such a preference , when the consonance ( meaning the diapason ) was , as they themselves allowed , susceptible not only of all these excesses , but of many others , in the orders both of the genera and of the distances ?
Nor could they say , that such a magnitude divides the diapason exactly , and such another not exactly , or one , perhaps , into an even number of parts , and another into an uneven : for though the diapason was divided into six by the tone , into twelve by the hemitone , into eighteen by the third of the tone , and into twenty-four by the quarter ; yet , in all these divisions , there was a variation from the exact truth , even perceptible to the ear .
All this reasoning is again manifestly levelled at the Aristoxenians , who , falsely esteeming the diapason to consist exactly of six tones , or twelve hemitones , had admitted thirteen modes , at the distance of a semitone from each other : and here we see the author still combats them fairly on the principles of the harmonic doctrine .
But , to go on with his arguments ; having thus fixed the number of the modes to seven only , he proceeds to consider the third limitation .
It will be asked , says he , what are to be the excesses chosen for these seven modes , since the diapason cannot be divided into seven equal parts ; and , if unequal intervals be admitted , there is still room for variety in the choice ?
In answer to this , he proposes , that the intervals in question shall be taken by means of the first consonances , diatessaron and diapente , and their differences or excesses , whatsoever they may be : for he argues , that the mutations , by consonant intervals , ought to be first established ; and next to these , the mutations , by concinnous intervals .
Those , who admitted eight tones , he tells us , had found their positions after the following manner .
The Dorian , Phrygian , and Lydian , the three most ancient , being first set at the distance of a tone from each other , they made the next mutation consonant , at a diatessaron from the Dorian , towards the acute , and at a limma from the Lydian , calling it Mixolydian ; because it lay not at the distance of a tone from the Lydian , but only at the distance of a limma , or difference between ditonus and diatessaron ; then this new mode having the Dorian graver than it by a diatessaron , that the rest of the four might be attended with the like circumstance , they established the Hypolydian , Hypophrygian , and Hypodorian , a diatessaron graver respectively than the Lydian , Phrygian , and Dorian ; and lastly , they placed the Hypermixolydian at a diapason from the Hypodorian , towards the acute , giving it that denomination from its position above the Mixolydian , misusing , as he tells us , the preposition hypo to signify the grave , and hyper to express the acute .
But though the result of this method is the same with that of his own , excepting as to the Hypermixolydian , ( which he excludes for the reason assigned in treating of the first limitation ) yet he objects to it ; because the concinnous intervals are first assumed , which ought to be taken by the consonances ; and gives his own , which is by the continual addition of the consonance diatessaron , but , however , within the compass of the diapason .
Wherefore , when such addition would exceed it , he directs taking the diapente in its stead , the contrary way ; whereby the division will be kept within the limits assigned .
This method , and its result , will perhaps be better understood , and will also be more succinctly couched in our modern expressions , in which I shall therefore give it , applying to it the corresponding characters of the Guidonian scale .
Having first taken the Mixolydian tone , which was the acutest of the seven , suppose in D , fall a fourth to A , for the Dorian ; another fourth to E , for the Hypodorian ; then , to avoid passing the bounds of the diapason , rise a fifth to B , for the Phrygian ; fall a fourth again to f~ , for the Hypophrygian ; phrygian ; rise a fifth to c ~ , for the Lydian ; and fall a fourth to G~ , for the Hypolydian .
By this method , the positions of the seven modes come out exactly , as I fixed them from Bacchius , in explaining the harmonic doctrine ; and we see , that , for settling them , Ptolemey has really recourse to no other theory of the modes , than that admitted by those he contends with , though he makes the species of the consonances , and those of the diapason more particularly , the governing rule for fixing their positions , as the only means , by which the two doctrines could be made to coincide .
But it remained , after thus settling the seven modes , to show more fully the consequence of following the method of the Aristoxenians , and others , who divided the tonic spaces found by his method , and placed the modes in a semitonic succession , by which their number had been raised to thirteen , even within the compass of the diapason ; and , in doing this , we shall find he ventures to assign the true reason for his reduction , which was grounded on the musical doctrine .
This argument , which is contained in the eleventh chapter of his second book , being very remarkable , and seeming strongly to support the combination of the two doctrines in the diagram I have given of the seven modes , I shall give a translation of the whole chapter , left I should be thought to strain his arguments in favour of the musical doctrine , which has been thought by many to have little or no relation to the modes , and which , if we except what this author has delivered , seems indeed , upon a slight examination , and comparison of the evidence , to have the weaker support .
Now , these being the tones we have established , it is plain , that a certain sound of the diapason is appropriated to the mes , in power of each , by reason of their being equal in number to the species .
For a diapason being selected out of the middle parts of the perfect system ; that is , the parts from hypate meson in position to nete diezeugmenon , ( because the voice is most pleased to be exercised about the middle melodies , seldom running to the extremes , because of the difficulty and constraint in immoderate intentions and remissions ) , the mes in power of the Mixolydian will be fitted to the place of paranete diezeugmenon , that the tone may , in this diapason , make the first species ; that of the Lydian , to the place of trite diezeugmenon , according to the second species ; that of the Phrygian , to the place of paramese , according to the third species ; that of the Dorian , to the place of the mes , making the fourth and middle spaces of the diapason ; that of the Hypolydian , to the place of lichanos meson , according to the fifth species ; that of the Hypophrygian , to the place of parhypate meson , according to the sixth species ; that of the Hypodorian , to the place of hypate meson , according to the seventh species ; that so it may be possible , in the alterations required for the tones , to keep some of the sounds of the system unmoved , for preserving the magnitude of the voice ( meaning the pitch of the diapason ) , it being impossible for the same powers , in different tones , to fall upon the places of the same sounds .
But , should we admit more tones than these , as they do , who augment their excesses by hemitones , the meses of two tones must , of necessity , be applied to the place of one sound ; so that , in interchanging the tunings of those two tones , the whole system in each must be removed , not preserving any one of the preceding tensions in common , by which to regulate the proper [ pitch ] of the voice .
For the mes in power of the Hypodorian , for instance , being fixed to hypate meson by position , and that of the Hypophrygian to parhypate meson , the tone taken between these two , and called by them the graver Hypophrygian , to distinguish it from the other acuter one , must have its mes either in hypate , as the Hypodorian , or in parhypate , as the acuter Hypophrygian ; which being the case , when we interchange the tuning of two such tones , which use one common sound , this sound is indeed altered a hemitone in pitch , by intention or remission ; but having the same power in each of the tones , viz. that of the mes , all the rest of the sounds are intended or remitted in like manner , for the sake of preserving the ratios to the mes , the same with those taken before the mutation , according to the genus common to both tones ; so that this tone is not to be held different in species from the former , but the Hypodorian again , or the same Hypophrygian , only somewhat acuter or graver in its pitch .
That these seven tones , therefore , are sufficient , and such as the ratios require , be it thus far declared ( 11 ) .
With ( 11 ) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ With this chapter he ends his doctrine of the modes , and of their reduction ; and we see he here makes the musical doctrine of the species the basis of his theory , as far as concerns the rejecting the eight redundant modes ; though , out of caution , and to obviate objections , he had established the seven upon the harmonic doctrine of the pitch of the ~ ~ ~ .
` H ~ , ~ ~ ` H ~~ .
` H ~ ` H ~ ~ ` H ~ , ~ ` H ~~ ` H ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ , ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ ~ .
~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~ To ~ ~ .
Ptol .
lib. ii .
c. 11 .
system .
That the force of his arguments in this chapter , and the result of admitting the eight modes , may be more plainly seen , I have annexed a second diagram of the species , as they lay in the spurious modes ; by which it will appear , to which species in the genuine ones they severally answered ; and the objection , raised against each of them by Ptolemey will become intelligible .
There is , however , an objection , to which this second diagram seems liable .
It may be asked , if the Hypoionian mode , instanced by Ptolemey , could give either Hypodorian or Hypophrygian harmony , according as either the eighth or the ninth string was employed for its mes ?
and if the rest of the spurious modes were liable to a like alternative , what was it determined me in my choice of the two species , in the construction of the diagram ?
To which I answer , that the ancients have decided for me as to five of them ; for we find ( 12 ) , that the Hypoionian was called the graver Hypophrygian ; the Hypoaeolian , the graver Hypolydian ; the Ionian , the graver Phrygian ; the AEolian , the graver Lydian ; and the Hyperionian , the acuter Mixolydian .
And this , by the way , furnishes us with an unanswerable argument of the antiquity of the doctrine enforced by Ptolemey , that the number of the modes ought not to exceed that of the species of the diapason ; for these appellations , which were given to the modes long enough before Ptolemey flourished , can be accounted for on no other principle , but the supposing the species of ( 12 ) Vide Euclid .
Introduct .
Harm .
p. 19 .
v. 29 .
&amp; seq. Arist .
Quint .
p. 23 .
v. 7 .
&amp; seq. diapason to have been considered as the essential characters of the modes ; and that these five modes therefore , though they had a difference in pitch , were thought to be the same , as to their effects , with those , after which they were thus named .
As to the other three , the Hyperphrygian , Hyperaeolian , and Hyperlydian , their meses being respectively at the distance of an octave from the Hypodorian , Hypoionian , and Hypophrygian , it was necessary to give them the same species with those three modes ; for a transposition of an octave was always understood to give a return of the same harmony , as has been already shown .
This second diagram , and that of the seven genuine modes , may be thought sufficient to render the subject intelligible : however , as the fifteen modes are parted in the two diagrams , and confined also to the compass of a diapason , for showing the species , I have added a table , showing the tuning of the fifteen strings of the lyre for all the modes .
The letters of Guido 's scale , placed within the squares , show , in their horizontal orders , the tunings of all the strings for each mode ; the two broader lines include the species of diapason ; and the meses are distinguished by capital letters , by which means , the cases , where the same string is employed for the meses of two modes , appear at the first view ; and the reasoning , upon which Ptolemey rejects the eight modes , is illustrated , so as to need no farther explanation .
Having now gone through with what I proposed to explain under the three first heads , I come , A TABL E , showing the Tuning of the STRINGS of the LYRE for every Mode .
Hyperlydian .
Hyperaeolian .
Hyperphrygian .
Hyperionian .
Hypodorian , or Mixolydian .
Lydian .
AEolian .
Phrygian .
Ionian .
Dorian .
Hypolydian .
Hypoaeolian .
Hypophrygian .
Hypoionian .
Hypodorian .
STRING~ of the LYRE 15 Nete hyperbolaeon .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab a a# aa ab a 14 Paranete hyperbolaeon .
g# gg ab g g# gg gb g g# g g# gg 13 Trite hyperbolaeon .
F# F f# gb f f# f f# ff f# f f# f f# 12 Nete diezeugmenon .
e eb Efee eb e eb ee eb e eb e 11 Paranete diezeugmenon .
d db d Eb D d# dd db d d# dd db d 10 Trite diezeugmenon .
c# cc db c C# C c# cc c# c c# cc 9 Paramese .
b bb b cb bb b bb B Bb bb bb b bb b 8 Mes .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab A a# aa ab a 7 Lichanos meson .
g# gg ab g g# gg gb g G# G g# gg 6 Parhypate meson .
f# f f# gb f f# f f# ff f# f F# F f# 5 Hypate meson .
e eb efee eb e eb ee eb e eb F 4 Lichanos hypaton .
d db d eb d d# dd db d d# dd db d 3 Parhypate hypaton .
c# cc db c c# c c# cc c# c c# cc 2 Hypate hypaton .
b bb b cb bb b bb b bb bb bb b bb b 1 Proslambanomenos .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab a a# aa ab a A TABL E , showing the Tuning of the STRINGS of the LYRE for every Mode .
Hyperlydian .
Hyperaeolian .
Hyperphrygian .
Hyperionian .
Hypodorian , or Mixolydian .
Lydian .
AEolian .
Phrygian .
Ionian .
Dorian .
Hypolydian .
Hypoaeolian .
Hypophrygian .
Hypoionian .
Hypodorian .
15 Nete hyperbolaeon .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab a a# aa ab a 14 Paranete hyperbolaeon .
g# gg ab g g# gg gb g g# g g# gg 13 Trite hyperbolaeon .
F# F f# gb f f# f f# ff f# f f# f f# 12 Nete diezeugmenon .
e eb Efee eb e eb ee eb e eb e 11 Paranete diezeugmenon .
d db d Eb D d# dd db d d# dd db d 10 Trite diezeugmenon .
c# cc db c C# C c# cc c# c c# cc 9 Paramese .
b bb b cb bb b bb B Bb bb bb b bb b STRINGS of the LYRE 8 Mes .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab A a# aa ab a 7 Lichanos meson .
g# gg ab g g# gg gb g G# G g# gg 6 Parhypate meson .
f# f f# gb f f# f f# ff f# f F# F f# 5 Hypate meson .
e eb efee eb e eb ee eb e eb E 4 Lichanos hypaton .
d db d eb d d# dd db d d# dd db d 3 Parhypate hypaton .
c# cc db c c# c c# cc c# c c# cc 2 Hypate hypaton .
b bb b cb bb b bb b bb bb bb b bb b 1 Proslambanomenos .
a ab a bb aa ab a ab a a# aa ab a Fourthly , To point out something of the origin of the two doctrines .
The harmonic doctrine was , as I have shown , expressly taught in harmonic ; and therefore , to account for its reception , it will be necessary to consider the scope of that science .
The musical doctrine I have also shown to have been explained in harmonic , as far as concerned the elementary principles of the species of diapason ; but the application of those principles to the doctrine of the modes was not taught therein , being reserved for melopaeia , a science , that looked higher than harmonic , and considered the use of the elements , when in the hands of the poet or musician .
It is to this science , therefore , that we must look for the origin of the musical doctrine .
But , before I consider the scope of either of these sciences , it will be necessary to show my reasons for separating them , since they were blended by the Aristoxenians , as has been shown above .
For this purpose , we must have recourse to the division of music , the mother science ; which , as treated by the ancients , comprehended all , that the moderns now understand by music and poetry .
Its first general division , according to Aristides Quintilianus ( 13 ) , was into theoretic and practic .
The theoretic was subdivided into natural and artificial ; the latter of which was again subdivided into harmonic , rhythmic , and metric ; ( 13 ) De Musica , p. 7 .
See also Meibomius on the passage , who has embraced the division of Aristides , in the following table .
metric ; which three sciences more particularly contained the poets elements , as teaching the grounds of tune , time , and verse .
But nothing less than a competent knowlege of every branch of the mother science could carry with it the respected title of ~ ~ , the musician .
To harmonic , rhythmic , and metric , in the theoretic , respectively answered melopaeia , rhythmopaeia , and poetic , in the practic .
In this author 's division therefore , we see , that harmonic and melopaeia are distinguished , even by the first general division .
Of the propriety of this even the Aristoxenians seem to have been sensible ; since , in order to justify their blending them , they have defined harmonic as a science , both theoretic and practic ( 14 ) .
And Aristoxenus himself , in the fragments we have under the false title of his three books of harmonic elements , seems to assign such bounds to harmonic , as might well be understood to exclude Physica , Arithmeticam , alia est pars quae dividitur in Physicam generi cognominem .
Theoretica , cujus rursus Harmonicam , parts duae Artificialis , quae dividitur in Rhythmicam , Metricam .
MUSIC AE Melopaeia .
Usualis , Rhythmopaeia , alia cujus parts Practica , Poesis .
cujus item parts duae ~ , Enarrativa , cujus parts ~ Hypocritica ( 14 ) ~ ~ .
Euclid .
Introd .
Harmon .
initio .
melopaeia ( 15 ) .
We have Plutarch also on our side , who , in a passage of his dialogue on music , which I shall have occasion to cite , amongst other proofs , enumerates only the first six parts of harmoniac , leaving melopaeia out of his division .
For this Meibomius blames him ( 16 ) , but too hastily ; for had the learned critic considered the whole passage , he must have seen , that the omission was not through ignorance , but design , the author being there expressly arguing for the confining of harmonic within its proper bounds .
However , whether the Aristoxenians were right or wrong , in including melopaeia in harmonic , my argument seems not materially affected by it ; for they gave it only as a last division , to be taught after all the rest had been inculcated ; and they agreed in defining it to be the use of the harmonic elements , according to the propriety of each subject ( 17 ) : which is distinction enough for the use I propose to make of it .
Having thus far justified my dividing these sciences , I shall now consider the scope of each ; which ( 15 ) ~ ~ , ~~ ~ ~~ .
Aristox .
p. 1 .
init .
( 16 ) Plutarchus dialogo de Musica sex tantum priores turbato etiam ordine recenset , cum tamen crebram ~ mentionem injiciat , adeoque , non una ratione excusari illud potest .
Not .
in Gaudientium , p. 30 .
( 17 ) ~~ .
Euclid .
~ .
Harmon .
p. 2 .
v. 5 .
&amp; p. 22 .
v. 18 .
will lead us to the origin of the doctrines they contained .
The object of melopaeia was propriety in the use of the harmonic elements , as appears from the definition just cited .
In what this propriety consisted , it is difficult to know , as no collection of the rules of this science is come down to us : it is not to be learnt from the harmonic writers , who treat very slightly of this branch ; and those of them , who are the fullest upon it , as Aristides Quintilianus and Manuel Briennius , wrote in later times , when the fashion of music was changed , and a new kind of melopaeia prevailed , with the rules of which the earlier musicians could hardly have been acquainted ; as , on the other hand , many of the earlier rules must have been forgot , or , in a great measure , disused .
There is more light to be procured from the dialogue of Plutarch , and some others , who speak occasionally of the practice of music .
I do not propose to collect any thing here upon this subject , as , indeed , there does not seem to be sufficient materials left us for a thorough explanation of it , which would require no less than a complete history of the science of its music , and its improvements : it is sufficient for my purpose to say , that , in the earlier times , when the best music is supposed to have prevailed , the genera , modes , rhythmi , metres , &amp;c. were not employed indiscriminately , nor even left to the discretion of the musician , but were under particular restrictions , which confined them to the arguments , to which they were held respectively the best adapted ; and that it was from the mixture of these ingredients , that arose the ethic character of the composition .
Hence the several nomi took their rise ; of which there is , in the dialogue of Plutarch , an ample account .
As what I am now advancing cannot but be well known , I need look no farther for the proof of it , than to a passage of Plato 's third book of laws , where he complains of a licence beginning even in his time to the prejudice of the science .
Speaking of times past , Our music ( says he ) was then divided according to certain species , and figures thereof .
Prayers to the gods were one species of song , to which they gave the name of hymns : opposed to this was another species , which , in particular , might be called threni ; another , paeones ; and another , the birth of Dionysius , which I hold to be the dithyrambus : there were also citharaedic nomi , so called , as being still another song .
These , and some others , being prescribed , it was not allowable to use one species of melos for another .
But afterwards , in process of time , the poets first introduced an unlearned licence , being poetic by nature , but unskilled in the rules of the science , trampling upon its laws , over attentive to please , mixing the threni with the hymns , and the paeones with the dithyrambi , imitating the music of the flute upon the cithara , and confounding all things with all , &amp;c. ( 18 ) .
This ( 18 ) ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ .
This passage , with what has been said , being sufficient to give a general idea of the scope of melopaeia , I shall pass to that of harmonic .
We have already seen , that the theoretic division of music was by the author , whose distribution I have followed , subdivided into natural and artificial , and that harmonic came under the latter .
The ancients , indeed , seem not all to have treated the science under such narrow limits , the physical properties of sound , the ratios of intervals , &amp;c. appearing to have been considered therein , by the Pythagorean and other schools , as well as the structure of the systems in use .
But not to stop at this objection , which is not very material , thus far must be allowed , that harmonic , as to the greatest part of its scope , was an artificial science , its most considerable object being to explain and teach the denominations , positions , powers , &amp;c. of the sounds of the system , and all other inventions in use , for facilitating the study of music , or bringing it to greater perfection .
Now , in this short view of the science , which is sufficient for our purpose , we may already begin to account for the difference between its doctrines and those of melopaeia , artificial sciences being but too prone to admit doctrines for convenience , that are repugnant to the truth .
This was indeed the case with harmonic , as the two doctrines of the tones sufficiently testify ; the origin of which I shall now consider .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Plat .
de Legibus , lib. iii .
The musical doctrine I look upon as the most ancient , and that which exhibited the modes in their proper character ; for which reason , it could not avoid making a part , and probably the most essential one , of the doctrines of melopaeia .
The precise time when it first came into use , I pretend not , in the midst of uncertainties , to be able to determine ; but we may , perhaps , be near the truth , if we refer its origin to the age of Pythagoras , if the eighth string of the lyre was really , as we are told , the addition of that philosopher .
The story of his discovering , at a forge , the ratios of hypate , mes , paramese , and nete , is well known .
These ratios , which gave rise to the harmonic proportion , and the numbers of which were so vainly applied afterwards , by philosophers , to all the parts of the universe , were drawn from the Dorian species of diapason , which we cannot suppose to have been well understood , till its form existed upon the instrument .
What doctrine of the modes prevailed , before the addition of the eighth string , we can only guess at ; for it was a question , even with Aristotle ( 19 ) , how the heptachord lyre had been adjusted ; and Nichomachus speaks of that instrument so ( 19 ) ~ , ~~~ ~ Aristot .
Probl .
sect. 19 .
qu .
7 .
~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Probl .
sect. 19 .
qu .
48 .
confusedly , confusedly , as to have given room for a supposition ( 20 ) , that it had received two forms , the seven strings answering , in the oldest from , to our notes e , f , g , a , b b , c , d , and in the new one , to e , f , g , a , b , d , e. However this may have been , neither the musical nor the harmonic doctrines could be then in use , exactly as they were taught in after times ; and the probability seems to be , that the modes were in those days characterized by the species of the lesser consonances , diatessaron and diapente ; but the theory of the Dorian species of diapason , we may be sure , took place about the time , when the lyre was brought to that compass ; and the other species , though they might have existed before , in the melody of particular instruments ; as for instance , the barbarous Phrygian , upon its flute , could hardly have been taken into the Greek theories of the science , till the extensioon of their own favourite instrument had brought the diapason under consideration : so that the origin of the musical doctrine of the modes , is , with great probability , to be referred to this improvement of the lyre .
I come now to the harmonic doctrine , for the origin of which we must look to the invention of the system .
The greater perfect system , upon whose pitch the modes depended , by the harmonic doctrine , consisted , as I have already shown , of fifteen sounds , answerable to those of the lyre ; and it is reasonable ( 20 ) Ut ex his difficultatibus nos expediamus , duas , non opiniones , sed aetates statuere debemus , quibus aliter obtinuerint intervalla in septem chordis .
Meibomius in Nichomachum , p. 52 .
See also Nichomachus , p. 9 .
v. 14 .
&amp; seq. &amp; p. 17 .
v. 24 .
&amp; seq. to think , that the structure of it was not settled , till the instrument had been again extended to the compass of a disdiapason , by the additions of the tetrachords hyperbolaeon and hypaton , and of the sound proslambanomenos : for this change the age of Alexander the Great may , perhaps , be a probable aera ; for , in the musical problems of Aristotle , I observe no mention of the new tetrachords , though many of the questions concern the strings of the lyre ; and yet there is no doubt of their being in use in the time of Aristoxenus , his disciple .
Should I be near the truth in this , the musical doctrine will then appear to have been earlier than the harmonic , by the whole period from Pythagoras to Alexander .
But , without being sollicitous about the precise time when the harmonic doctrine was introduced , I shall , with more certainty , endeavour to point out what must have given occasion to it .
The study of the music of the ancients , though they seem not to have much used composition in parts , must yet have been very perplexing , from the variety only of the tones and genera ; and some help might well be thought necessary , even in the time of the octachord lyre .
But when seven new strings were given to the instrument , and these placed not all at one end , but three at the acute , and four at the grave , the eight old strings , upon which the characteristic species of melody for each mode had been always exhibited , became confounded by these additions ; and possessing now the center of the lyre , it was difficult to distinguish them , and to preserve for each mode its proper character as before .
This difficulty must also have been increased , by the change introduced in the practice of the science ; for both the players and composers , having now a greater latitude , would not fail to take advantage of the enlargement ; and though the skilful among them might , in their excursions upon the new strings , preserve a due attention to the proper characters of the several modes , yet the melody peculiar to each could not be so easily comprehended , when carried beyond its usual limits .
An artificial help , therefore , to the learner , was now become indispensably necessary ; and with this view , I make no doubt , but that the system was invented .
It was , indeed , admirably well contrived for the purpose ; for its succession being the same with that of the lyre , in its Dorian tuning , with which the Greeks must have been the best acquainted , as being the proper mode of their favourite instrument , it was the most easy to be learnt and retained , and the knowlege of this succession was all now required ; for , by imagining only the system removed to some other pitch , and tuning all the strings in the same relations to a new mes , the melody of the old eight strings was thereby changed , and a new species of diapason gained thereon , without the trouble of studying the the musical doctrine , which was now left to the musician , or melopaeius , who was answerable for the choice of the successions he selected for his various subjects , whilst the harmonician followed him through the intricacies of his compositions , by the easier method of the transposition of the system .
And this I apprehend to have been the origin , both of the system itself , and of the harmonic doctrine of the tones .
But now , as it often happens , what was designed for the improvement of the science , became , in time , the ruin of it ; for , after the reception of the disdiapason system , the elementary treatises , as we see by what is left to us of them , became filled with this new doctrine of the parts and relations of the system , of its transpositions , of the positions of the mes , of sounds in power , and sound by position , and many other doctrines flowing from the same source , till , in time , the system itself came to be considered as the true type of a mode ; and a number of new modes were introduced , that were grounded on no other principle than this , which I scruple not to call a false doctrine of them , though the ancients admitted it for convenience , as I have shown , and thereby almost lost their impressions of the new one .
Having thus pointed out the origin of these two doctrines , as far as was possible , from a general view of them , and without entering into a critical examination of the many passages of the ancients , that might help us to greater certainty , I shall now proceed , Fifthly , To show how far the preceding explanations may be supported by arguments , or warranted by the testimony of ancient writers .
Here I must repeat , that the harmonic doctrine of the tones , as I have explained it , is found , expressly delivered under its proper head , in almost every writer on the subject ; and that the doctrine of the species of diapason is found also in the harmonic treatises , though not under the head of tones , nor expressly applied to them .
Now , this being the case , I shall have no occasion to waste time in bringing particular proofs , to support the explanations I have given of these two doctrines separately .
What immediately lies upon me is , to prove , that the doctrine of the species of diapason had a connection with the modes ; and to justify the manner , in which I have combined the two doctrines in the canon , and in the diagrams framed from it .
With this view , therefore , I shall direct my arguments to the proving of the five following points .
1 .
That the doctrine of the species of diapason was a doctrine of the modes .
2 .
That this doctrine was not distinct from , nor independent of , the harmonic , but so connected with it , that a mutation , according to the one , produced the alteration required by the other .
3 .
That the species of diapason , as taken practically on the lyre , lay all at the same pitch .
4 .
That this pitch was the diapason , between the strings hypate meson and nete diezeugmenon , as they stand in the diagram .
5 .
I shall endeavour to show , that it was the musical doctrine , and not the harmonic , that exhibited the true character of the modes , as considered in respect to their effects .
To begin with the first point .
That the doctrine of the species of diapason was a doctrine of the modes , might , perhaps , be inferred from some of the definitions given of a mode ; but as these definitions are mostly intermixed with , if not drawn solely from , the harmonic doctrine , and hence have given room for disputes , I shall rest this point upon three arguments , in which the definitions are not concerned .
First , Because the species are denominated after seven of the modes , which could hardly have arisen from any other cause , than their connection with them .
2dly , Because the whole reasoning of Ptolemey , in the sixth , seventh , eighth , ninth , tenth , and eleventh chapters , of his second book , tends to reduce the modes to the number of the species of the diapason ; which , as far as his opinion goes , is an express confirmation , that the musical doctrine was a doctrine of the modes .
3dly , Because Ptolemey is not single in this opinion , as some may have thought , but is supported in it by the Aristoxenian writers , who , though they admitted thirteen modes , upon the false principle of the harmonic doctrine , did , in fact , reduce them to eight , on the very principle of Ptolemey , calling the Hyperionian mode , which gave the same species with the Mixolydian , the acuter Mixolydian ; and calling also the AEolian , the graver Lydian ; the Ionian , the graver Phrygian ; the Hypoaeolian , the graver Hypolydian ; and the Hypoionian , the graver Hypophrygian ; the former of all which modes gave , respectively , the same species with the latter .
So that , to make their doctrine answer to that of Ptolemey , there wanted but the reduction of one mode more , which was their Hyperphrygian .
And it is not to be conceived , but that they saw this mode also to be a repetition of the Hypodorian ; but as this repetition was at the distance of an octave , and the other five were repeated at the difference only of a semitone in pitch , they could not have called this the acuter Hypodorian , without using the same expression in too great a lati5 C2 tude tude of sense .
And this might be the reason why they omitted taking notice of that circumstance attending this mode ; though we might perhaps , with safety to the argument , go a step farther , and suppose , that the Aristoxenians might think a difference of an octave in pitch worthy of a distinct denomination , though they would not allow it to that of a semitone .
And this is the more probable , as we find they did not absolutely reject these modes , as Ptolemey did , but admitted them upon the principles of the harmonic doctrine , though , by their denominating five of them from the genuine modes , it is plain they acknowleged them to be superfluous , in respect to the musical .
I cannot say more to this point , without defrauding the subsequent ones ; and I shall therefore leave it , with this remark , that whatever is proved of the subsequent points , and especially of the fifth , must hold true of this , a fortiori ; so that it may really be said to have the support of the whole testimony .
2 .
To the second point , the first diagram speaks very strongly ; for had the two doctrines no relation to each other , no such coincidence , as is there found , could have been expected , in the result of their combination ; and this proof , from the coincidence of the doctrines in the diagram , becomes much stronger , if we attend to these two circumstances .
First , That in the canon , upon which the diagram has been constructed , there is no strain of either doctrine , but a plain and natural combination of them , as they are stated separately by the ancient writers .
And secondly , That the species of diapason , as brought out by this combination , all fall upon the strings of the old octachord lyre , where it was natural to expect them ; for when the lyre had but eight strings , the species could be taken no where else ; and it cannot be thought , but that , after the extension of the instrument , they were taken at the same pitch as before , unless we should suppose , that the new strings brought with them an immediate change , both of the theory and practice of the science , which is most improbable .
We see our modern harpsichords have more keys given to them than those of the last century ; and yet neither the positions of the cliffs , nor any other circumstances attending our theories of the science , have been altered by them .
But that this point may not rest wholly on the circumstances of the diagram , I shall produce four passages , that plainly show the relation between the two doctrines .
The first from Aristoxenus .
Now , as some of those [ systems ] which we employ in music , are simple , and others mutable , we must treat of mutation ; and first of this , what mutation is , and how it is accomplished ; now , I say , there happens , as it were , a pathos in the melody ; afterwards , how many mutations there are in all , and according to what intervals ( 21 ) .
' ' In this passage , the author is speaking of the sixth division of harmonic , which was mutation ; and more particularly of mutation with respect to tone , which , in this division , was always treated upon the ( 21 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ [ corrige , ~ ] ~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~ ~ .
Aristox .
p. 38 .
v. 7 .
principle principle of the harmonic doctrine , and is so here ; but he tells us , there was a pathos in the melody , which can only relate to the musical doctrine , and therefore shows their connection .
In the next passage , from Aristides Quintilianus , it is more plainly hinted at .
For if a certain type of the voice follows each system , it is manifest , that the species of the melos will be altered with the harmonics ( 22 ) .
' ' But the two following passages from Ptolemey will put the matter out of dispute .
For we are not to imagine this constitution of the mutation , according to the tone , established for sake of graver or acuter voices , ( since the intension , or again the remission of whole instruments , suffices for such a difference , no alteration being produced in respect of the melos , the whole being executed by performers of graver or acuter voices ) ; but with this view , that the same melos , begun by the same voice , now from acuter places , and now from graver , may produce a certain change of ethos ; because that in the permutations of the tones , the extremities of the voice do not answer to both the extremities of the melos ; but in one , the extremity of the voice always falls short of that of the melos ; and in the other , the extremity of the melos of that of the voice : so as that the same melos , which at first ( meaning in the Dorian ) answered to the compass of the voice , now falling short ( 22 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~ .
Aristid .
Quintil .
p. 24 .
v. ult .
of it , and now again exceeding it , may give to the ear the impression of another mode ( 23 ) .
' ' For of the mutations in respect to tone , so called , there are two principal differences , the one by which we run through the whole melos in an acuter tension , or again in a graver , preserving always the succession of the species .
The other , by which there is an alteration , not of the whole melos in its tension , but only of a part thereof , from the succession it set out with .
Wherefore , this last might be called rather a mutation of the melos , than of the tone ; for , according to the former , the melos is not altered , but the tone ( tension ) of the whole ; whereas , according to the latter , the melos varies from its proper order , and the tension varies not as tension , but as on account of the melos .
Hence the former does not strike the sense with an idea of that alteration , according to power , by which the ethos is changed , but only of an alteration in respect to the being acuter or graver ; whereas the latter causes the sense to drop from the usual and expected melos , the succession being preserved some time , and then making a tran(23 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ .
Ptol .
Harm .
lib. ii .
c. 7 .
sition to another species , whether according to genus or tension ( 24 ) .
' ' 3 .
The third point will receive much support from these two considerations ; first , That diapasons , variously divided and variously bounded , also seem to form a more complicated theory , than can well be supposed to have prevailed in early times , when music had not yet lost its natural simplicity ; and secondly , That the compass of the instrument , in its octachord state , would not admit of any variation , in respect to the bounding sounds .
But there is testimony to this point also : I shall cite one pretty remarkable passage , from Aristides Quintilianus , which will be sufficient , as the proof of the next point necessarily carries this along with it .
Aristides , who , in his explanations of the harmonic doctrines , follows the method of the Aristoxenians , coming under the head of systems , to treat of the species of diapason , after explaining their situation in the immutable system , and assigning their denominations , immediately subjoins : Hence it is plain , that if we make our first sign the same , though denominated in different cases from ( 24 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~ ~ .
Ptol .
Harm .
lib. ii .
cap. 6 .
a different power of sound , the quality of the harmony will become manifest , from the succession of the sounds in order ( 25 ) .
In this passage , it is to be observed , that the term ~ , a sign , signifies a musical character , such as the ancients used to write over the words of a song , to express the air , or tune ; and that each of these characters represented not a sound of the system , subject to transposition , but , like the notes of our gamut , a sound of a certain pitch , or at least liable to very small variations only , from the generic differences .
The term , therefore , is properly used here by Aristides , in opposition to ~ , a sound of the system , whose pitch depended on the mode in which it was employed .
As to the expression , quality of the harmony , it evidently respects the species of diapason ; so that the author plainly means to tell us , that if we begin a diapason always with the same note , the succession of its sounds , that is , the manner in which it is divided , will determine the species : and so far he speaks to our purpose .
But this point will receive farther proof , from what we shall say upon the next .
4 .
The fourth point being the natural result of the combination of the two doctrines , carries a sort of conviction with it ; and the stronger , as not only the seven modes , but the whole fifteen , assist the proof , as will appear , on examining the table I have given of them : for there the sounds lying between the ( 25 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~ ~ .
Arist .
Quint .
p. 18 .
v. 7 .
strings hypate meson and nete diezeugmenon fall out so , as to give the proper species for every mode ; which circumstance will not attend any other boundaries , common or varying , without altering the positions of the mes , and thereby disturbing the harmonic doctrine .
But we have from Ptolemey sufficient testimony to this point .
In the eleventh chapter of his second book , of which I have given a translation above , we see , that the diapason in question is chosen by him , to exhibit the divisions , that belong to the several species .
It is true , he seems to insinuate , that any other diapason might have been chosen , were it not for the difficulty the voice finds in running to the extremes : and in this , as a theorist , he is right ; for musical relations and proportions , considered as objects of mere speculation , may be conceived at any pitch ; but in the case before us , it was the practice of the instrument , that governed the theory .
The pitch of the lyre had been made to answer to the double octave of the human voice ; the pitch of the system , in the Dorian mode , answered to that of the lyre ; and , in every other mode , the difference in pitch from that of the Dorian was determined .
Now , under such limitations , that took their rise from practical music , it is evident , that no other diapason , but that instanced by Ptolemey , could have served his purpose .
But that the boundary of the species is rightly adjusted in the diagram , there is yet another strong testimony , from the tables of Ptolemey , annexed to the fifteenth chapter of book second .
To make this proof evident , it will be necessary to give some account of this part of his work .
In the twelfth chapter of book second , he begins to treat of the sections of the harmonic canon , for proving , by experiment , the truth of the ratios he had delivered for the genera , and proposes to exhibit these sections for each genus , in all the seven tones .
Then , after showing the defects of the monochord canon in use , and ( chapter thirteenth ) the insufficiency of the improvements made thereon by Didymus , he proposes , and explains , his own method of applying the canon to eight strings tuned in unison .
But , before he proceeds to give the sections upon all the tones , he thinks it necessary to show , by experiment , the advantage of his own numbers , above those of preceding harmonicians ; for which purpose , the exposition of them in one tone , that is , in the immutable system , was sufficient .
Accordingly , in chapter fourteenth , ( the greatest part of which has been lost , and is supplied from conjecture by Wallis ) and in the tables annexed , he gives the sections of the Dorian species of diapason ; where the diazeuctic tone , lying in the middle , left a complete tetrachord on each side , for the exposition of the generic numbers ; and compares his own ratios with those of Archytas , Eratosthenes , Aristoxenus , and Didymus .
Then , in the fifteenth chapter , he proceeds , as he proposed , to give the sections according to his own ratios , for the genera most in use in all the seven tones : these sections he has included in two sets of tables , each set containing seven , viz. one for each mode ; and each table being again subdivided into five , for the generic differences .
Now , of these two sets of tables , the first justifies the diagram ; for here he has given his numbers upon the eight strings , from nete diezeug5 D2 menon menon to hypate meson ; so that the diagram and the tables agree in every respect , except the generic differences , which I had no occasion to consider .
In the second set , indeed , the numbers are applied to the diapason , from mes to proslambanomenos ; and there being no explanation in this chapter of the distinct use of this second set , nor any reason assigned for giving it , but the convenience of having the option , to begin the tuning from nete or mes ( 26 ) , this may seem to furnish an objection to the proof proposed to be gained from these tables : but if we look forward to the second chapter of his third book , we shall there see his meaning ; which I shall proceed to explain .
Having , in the sixteenth chapter , shown how the numbers , given in the two sets of tables , are to be applied to an octachord canon , he proposes , in the first chapter of the third book , to show , how the divisions for the fifteen sounds of the whole disdiapason system might , if required , be found , according to the same ratios he had already assigned for the extent of a diapason .
Now , for the doing this , two inconveniences were to be obviated .
First , If the instrument , on which this experiment was to be tried , was to receive an addition of seven strings , to complete the disdiapason , and these additional strings were all to be in unison with the eight before applied , it would happen , that , in shifting the moveable magas , or bridge , to the sections required , those strings , which were to exhibit the acute sections of the tetra(26 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ ~ .
Ptol .
Harm .
p. 174 .
v. ult .
chord hyperbolaeon , would have so little space left between the magas and the extremity of the string , that it would be difficult for them to yield a distinct sound .
And secondly , The canon must be crowded with these additional divisions , which would also have its inconvenience .
To remedy this , he proposes several methods ; the first of which is , to fit the instrument with fifteen strings , of which the eight , that were to receive the divisions from mes to nete hyperbolaeon , should be in unison , at the pitch of mes , and the other seven in unison , at the pitch of proslambanomenos .
Now , as the succession from the string proslambanomenos to the string mes , though it varied with the modes , was yet , in the same mode , always the same with that from mes to nete hyperbolaeon , the difference of a diapason in pitch excepted , it is plain , that , under this adjustment , a canon divided for the one diapason would serve equally for the other , the difference in pitch being established before in the open strings .
By this method , therefore , the divisions for the acuter diapason would be as large as those for the graver , and the canon needed not to be crowded with a greater number of divisions , than had been used for the single diapason , by reason of its double application .
The other methods , which he proposed , I need not go through the explanation of , farther than to remark , that , for those , as well as for this , a fresh set of numbers was necessary , those contrived for the succession of the diapason , from hypate meson to nete diezeugmenon , being no-ways applicable to a succession , which began from proslambanomenos or mes .
And this , it seems , was his reason for giving the second set of tables in his fifteenth chapter , as appears from his own words , in the second chapter of the third book .
In general , for such uses , as comprehend a diapason only , it behoves us to employ , out of the numbers exhibited , those which contain the section from nete diezeugmenon , that the melos may be taken in the middle tensions ; but for such as comprehend the disdiapason , those exhibited from nete hyperbolaeon , or mes , that the tuning may be adjusted at both extremities alike ( 27 ) .
Here we see he fully explains his former meaning ; and , in recommending his first set of tables for the uses of a diapason , gives the same reason for the choice of that diapason in particular , as he assigns for it in the eleventh chapter of the second book , viz. that the melos may possess the middle of the instrument .
But it must be observed , that when the whole disdiapason has been adjusted by the second set of tables , the tunings of the eight strings , from nete diezeugmenon to hypate meson , will come out , for every mode and genus , the very same , as if they had been tuned by the first set : so that no inference can possibly be drawn from thence , either that the author has varied as to his own meaning , or that the diagram , which I have given , does not correspond with it .
( 27 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Ptol .
Harm .
p. 228 .
v. 15 .
5 .
I come now to the fifth point , which has been the subject of much dispute , and which might well afford an endless controversy , whilst the union of the two doctrines was not understood ; for whatever reasons , from probability or testimony , might be urged in favour of the musical , the harmonic doctrine appearing to be still better supported , and seeming to contradict the other , was sure to suspend the decision , at least , if not gain one in its own favour .
But the agreement between the two doctrines being shown , and their views distinguished , the testimony borne to the harmonic doctrine will no longer be in the way of the musical , and we may safely allow whatever appears favourable to the latter , its full weight .
I shall therefore offer , in support of this point , the six following arguments .
First , No one accustomed to hear and judge of the effects of music , can conceive , that a mere alteration in pitch of the same melody , though in the hands of the most artful master , can have so powerful an effect , to change the mode or style of composition , as an alteration of the melodious succession : or , if this should be asserted , it might be disproved , by an appeal to the works of all the composers of eminence among the moderns ; who having , in all the variety of their modulations , but one change , that truly answers to the musical doctrine of the modes , viz. the change of the succession of the same key , from the major third to the minor , have all reserved this change for their pathetic passages .
I shall give but one instance of it , from our countryman Purcell , who , in his Mad Bess , has so happily introduced this change , upon the words , ` ` Cold and hungry am I grown , ' ' that if the performer does justice to the composition , the hearer can scarce help fancying himself affected with the very sensations , with which the starts of frenzy are there pictured .
2dly , If I have been right in assigning a greater antiquity to the musical doctrine , than to the harmonic , the effects of the modes must , in earlier times at least , be referred to the former .
And this carries with it an argument for later times also ; for the old principle of the modes could not be suddenly changed .
And though it may be urged , from the introduction of the eight spurious modes , that the harmonic doctrine came , in time , to be considered as a principle independent of the other , this will only prove a corruption of the better doctrine , which may safely be admitted ; though that the musical doctrine was ever quite disused , unless in very late times indeed , I much doubt , as some traces of it are found in almost all the writers come down to us .
3dly , Ptolemey 's rejecting the eight modes , that wanted the support of the musical doctrine , is another proof .
For , if the harmonic doctrine had been the more essential of the two , those modes ought to have been preserved .
Nor does the admission of six of them , by the Aristoxenians in earlier times , weaken the force of this argument : for though the rejecting them is conclusive , against the harmonic doctrine , as far as any weight is allowed to the opinion of the rejecter , the argument from their admission will not conclude in its favour , till it be proved , that in the use the species of diapason afforded by these modes was not attended to , but only the order from the proslambanomenos , in power of each , as the favourers of the harmonic doctrine seem to suppose : and this proof it would not be easy to obtain , since each of these modes had its species belonging to it , and was only exceptionable , because it repeated the melody of one or other of the seven .
4thly , The denominations given by the Aristoxenians to five of the spurious modes , after the genuine ones , whose species they afforded , furnish another strong proof ; for this could scarce have happened , if the pitch of the system had been the principal distinction .
5thly , We find in Plutarch , Pliny , and other authors , the invention of particular modes ascribed to particular musicians ; which may be accounted for , on the supposition , that the modes were so many different species of diapason ; since it requires great art and skill to introduce agreeably melodies , to which the ear has not been accustomed : but the taking the same melody at a different pitch is a variety , for which the inventor would hardly have had his name so carefully delivered to posterity .
But 6thly , there are passages , that strongly confirm the preceding arguments .
Aristoxenus speaks of modes of the melopaei ( 28 ) , by which I understand him to mean the species of diapason , in contradistinction to the modes of the harmonicians ; for I suspect the modes of melopaeia , mentioned by Aristides Quintilianus ( 29 ) , and divided by him into three kinds , viz. nomic , which was netoides ; dithyrambic , which was mesoides ; and tragic , which ( 28 ) Page .
40 .
v. 21 .
( 29 ) Page .
29 .
v. ult .
was hypatodies ; and which are also mentioned by other writers , of a low age ( 30 ) ; these modes , I say , I suspect to be founded on distinctions not in use so early .
The use of the species of diapason in melopaeia is confirmed also by Bacchius , who , immediately after explaining them , expresses himself thus : So many , therefore , in the art of music , are the species of the consonances , by which every melopaeia is formed ( 31 ) .
' ' And also by Aristides Quintilianus , who concludes his doctrine of the species , with these words : And thus much suffices concerning systems , which the ancients also styled the ethic principles ( 32 ) .
' ' For , by systems , we are here to understand systems in the general sense , as defined and treated by the Aristoxenians , whom Aristides follows in this part of his work , and more particularly the three consonant systems , whose species he had just been describing .
The passage I have already cited from Plato , serves also strongly to support this point ; for the terms , species , and figure , are there used in the strict technic sense , and not merely to express variety , as appears from his speaking , in the same passage , afterwards of the species of melos , the sense of which cannot be mistaken ; and that he is speaking of music , in ( 30 ) Martianus Capella , p. 189 .
v. 21 .
Manuel Bryennius in Oper .
~ , p. 503 .
v. 14 .
( 31 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~ ~ .
Bacch .
Sen. Introd .
Art .
Music .
p. 19 .
v. 18 .
( 32 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ .
Aristid .
Quintil .
p. 18 .
v. 12 .
respect to its effects , is manifest , from the whole passage : so that , though the modes are not directly mentioned , they are necessarily to be implied .
But Ptolemey is still more express ; for , in the passage cited above , from book second , chapter seventh , he directly affirms , that the ethos , or character of the mode , depended on the musical doctrine , and not on the harmonic ; and is still more explicit , to the same purpose , in the passage cited also from the sixth chapter of the same book .
These two passages are so clear , that there is no evading their testimony , but by supposing the author to be singular in his opinion ; which there is , indeed , room to think was his case , with respect to many of the musicians , his contemporaries ; for the pains he has taken to clear up and distinguish the two doctrines , is a sufficient proof , that mistakes had prevailed concerning them ; but that what he has advanced is not repugnant to the doctrines held in earlier antiquity , has , I think , been amply shown .
I shall now close these proofs with three remarkable passages from Plutarch 's dialogue on music , which will all become intelligible from the explanation given of this subject , at the same time , that they will serve to confirm it .
The first respects the invention of the Mixolydian mode , which we shall see he treats as a species of diapason , telling us between what sounds of the system it lay , and in what part of the diapason the diazeuctic tone was situated ; in both which circumstances , the passage agrees with the preceding explanation , and with the first diagram .
Lysis informs us , that Lamprocles the Athenian , seeing , that it ( the Mixolydian harmony ) had not the disjunction ( diazeuctic tone ) , where almost every one imagined ( meaning in the middle of the diapason , for so it was in the Dorian , which was most familiar to the Greeks ) , but at the acute , made the figure of it such as that from paramese to hypate meson ( 33 ) .
' ' The next passage informs us of a very remarkable circumstance , viz. that , after the addition made to the lyre of the tetrachord hypaton , no use was made of those strings in the Dorian mode , though they were employed in the rest .
Speaking of the earlier times , and arguing , that the ancients had omitted many things , rather from choice than ignorance ; It is manifest ( says he ) , that , in respect to the [ tetrachord ] hypaton , it was not through ignorance , that they abstained , in their Dorian [ compositions ] , from this tetrachord ; for they employed it in the rest of the tones , as plainly knowing it ; but , for the sake of preserving the ethos , they left it out in the Dorian tone , as respecting the beauty thereof ( 34 ) .
' ' From this passage it is evident , that the Dorian melody , which , in its proper character , according to the musical doctrine , was terminated by hypate meson , was in such esteem with the Greeks , from a long habit of hearing their best pieces composed in that succession , and within that compass , ( 33 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ .
Plutarch .
Dial .
de Musica .
( 34 ) ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ .
Ibidem .
that the additional strings could not be ventured upon in that mode , though in the rest they were admitted .
The last passage is that , which I have mentioned above to have been censured by Meibomius : we shall see here , that the author is expressly arguing for confining harmonic within its proper sphere , and not suffering it to encroach on melopaeia , by engaging with the rules of ~ , in the use of the elements ; so that it both justifies and explains the distinction I have made above , between the two sciences , and turns the censure of Meibomius upon himself , who seems , indeed , without excuse , unless we suppose him to mean only , that Plutarch , in giving the Aristoxenian division , ought not to have sunk any part of it : which remark would have been just , if Plutarch had given the division as such ; but he does not name the school , though he adopts their distribution of the science as far as the six divisions he approved ; so that no inconsistence can be charged upon him .
The latter part of this passage also confirms the distinction I have made between the two doctrines , and their use in the two sciences ; so that it assists most of the preceding arguments and proofs : and here I shall therefore rest this point , which will scarce be thought to need farther support .
For it is evident , that the immediate objects of harmonic are genera , viz. those of the hermosmenon , intervals , systems , sounds , tones , and systematic mutations ; and farther than this it cannot go : so that we ought not to expect it should determine how far the poet , in his music , has properly assumed the Hypodorian tone , for instance , for the outset ; or the Mixolydian and Dorian , for the conclusion ; or the Hypophrygian and Phrygian , for the middle ; since the harmonic treatise does not extend so far , but has need of many others .
For of the force of propriety it cannot judge , since neither the chromatic nor the enharmonic genus will ever contain a perfect force of propriety , such as to discover the ethos of the composition , that being the business of the artist .
And again , it is plain , that the voice [ pitch ] of the system is to be distinguished from the melopaeia wrought in the system , the consideration whereof does not belong to the harmonic treatise ( 35 ) .
Having now finished my head of proofs , I come , Lastly , To consider how far this subject has been understood by Meibomius , Wallis , and some few others that have wrote since ; and in what respect their explanations differ from my own .
In respect to the opinion of Meibomius , Malcolm tells us , that that writer , in his notes on Aristides Quintilianus , affirms the differences of the modes , ( 35 ) ~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~ .
Plutarch .
Dial .
de Musica .
upon which all the different effects depended , to have been only in the tension , or acuteness and gravity of the whole system ( 36 ) .
And indeed , in the note on page 13 .
verse 4 .
of that author ( 37 ) , which , I presume , Malcolm had under his eye , Meibomius clearly decides for the harmonic doctrine , as he does also in his note on page 2 .
verse 1 .
of Euclid 's Harmonic Introduction ( 38 ) .
But in this last note , he had just before told us , that tone was by the ancients also called harmonia , and species of diapason ( 39 ) .
And , in the conclusion of his note on page 1 .
verse 10 .
of the same author , he delivers himself more fully to the same purpose .
The ancients ( says he ) having considered several species of diapason in the bisdiapason , called these also harmonics .
Whence we read Dorian , Phrygian harmony , in the best writers .
The same were again called tones and tropes , or modes ( 40 ) .
' ' IN ( 36 ) Malcolm 's Treatise on Music , p. 540 .
( 37 ) Hic autem locus oppido notandus est contra recentiorum de tonorum effectibus opiniones , illorum enim varietates , so , la , acuminis atque gravitatis differentia veteres unanimi consensu definiunt-Acumen autem ac gravitatem nihil varietatis cantilenae adferre contra omnem cruditam vetustatem , imo communem sensum existimant .
Meibom .
in Arist .
Quint .
p. 219 .
( 38 ) Tonus seu modus est totius systematis harmonici , hoc est bisdiapason aut simpliciter diapason differentia ; ut Phrygius tonus a Dorio nulla alia re differt , quam quod totum Phrygii systema acutius sit toto Dorii systemate , tono , qui est in ratione superoctava .
Meibom .
in Euclid .
Introd .
Harm .
p. 46 .
( 39 ) Toni vocabulum quatuor modis accipitur ; -hic idem est quod modus ; cum dicimus tonus , five modus Dorius , Lydius , Mixolydius ; veteribus quoque harmonia adpellatur , et species diapason .
Ibidem .
( 40 ) Cum autem plures diapason species in bisdiapason antiqui fpectarent , illas quoque adpellarunt harmonias .
Unde Doria , Phrygia In his note also on the passage I have cited above , from Aristides , page 18 .
verse II .
he explains the expression , quality of the harmony , to signify the species of diapason , or tone ( 41 ) , which is the sense I have put upon it .
We see therefore , that though he hastily ascribes to the harmonic doctrine alone the effects , which I have supposed to arise only from the musical , yet he clearly admits both the doctrines to be warranted from antiquity ; and I am glad to have so far the support of this learned critic 's opinion : but of the connection between the two doctrines , as I have explained it , I see no trace in his notes ; nor is it to be imagined , but that , if he had seen it , he would have enlarged upon it .
In respect to Dr. Wallis , though he had the advantage of the notes of Meibomius , who had cleared up so many difficulties , and had also taken under his own management the text of Ptolemey , the author , of all others , the most likely to have given him a thorough insight into this subject , yet we find him not only defective in his explanations of it , but , contrary to his usual accuracy , even in misleading his readers by false doctrines .
With respect to the musical doctrine , if we may judge by his silence , he appears to have seen less of it than Meibomius ; for , in the appendix to his edition of Ptolemey , wherein he gia harmonia , apud optimos autores legimus .
Deinde eaedem toni et tropi , seu modi sunt adpellati .
Meibom .
in Euclid .
Introduct .
Harm .
p. 42 .
( 41 ) Id est quae sit species octachordi , seu quis tonus ; nam duobus modis usurpatur vox ~ , uno pro genere enarmonio , altero pro tono , seu tropo , seu modo ; quae significatio est huic loco propria .
Meibom .
in Arist .
Quint .
p. 230 .
undertakes to explain the harmonic elements , after treating of the species of diapason , he gives not the least hint , that they had any relation to the modes , except by giving their denominations ; and in doing this , he expresses himself ( 42 ) as if he thought these denominations rather assigned for some separate reason , than on account of their connection with the modes ; though , as he was going immediately to the doctrine of the tones , this was the place , where he might have been expected to have taken notice of the connection between the two doctrines , if he had observed it .
In treating of the modes , indeed , though he explains them on the foot of the harmonic doctrine only ( 43 ) , he assigns some of his author 's reasons for reducing them to seven ( 44 ) .
And his note also on the beginning ( 42 ) Atque hae quidem diapason species septem sua singulae sortiebantur nomina ; prima dicta est Mixolydia ; secunda , Lydia ; tertia , Phrygia ; quarta , Doria ; quinta , Hypolydia ; sexta , Hypophrygia ; septima , tum Locrensis tum Hypodoria .
Tandem de modis , seu tonis dicendum restat .
App. ad Ptol .
p. 311 .
( 43 ) Modus itaque , seu tonus , prout hic sumitur , denotat vocis locum , non quo una vox , sed quo tota vocum series , seu systema canitur ; acutiorem puta , gravioremve .
Utpote prout apud nos mi canitur , nunc in bfb mi , nunc in elami , nunc in alamire , &amp; c : Sic apud illos verbi gratia , paramese potestate ( quod tantumdem est atque nostrum mi ) , posita erat nunc in paramese positione , nunc in positione nete diezeugmenon , nunc in mes , &amp;c. Ibid. p. 312 .
( 44 ) Contra hos , qui tonos , seu modos , sic augent per hemitonia disputat Ptolemaeus , cap. 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 .
lib. ii .
docetque modorum variorum usum non in hunc solum finem introductum , ut acutior graviorve sit totius cantus tenor ; quippe huic sufficeret cantoris vox acutior graviorve ; aut musici organi ad hosce tenores accommodatio.-Sed eo potissimum fine fuisle introductum , ut in ipsius cantus curriculo transitus fiat de modo in modum , quam voV O L. LI .
5F cant ginning of chapter eleventh , book second ( 45 ) , rightly explains the species of diapason , as they lay between hypate meson and nete diezeugmenon : but this interpretation is formally introduced with a nempe hoc vult , as if he thought his author singular in this doctrine , and looked upon the doctrine itself , as stated in that passage , rather as explanatory of an incidental circumstance attending the harmonic doctrine , than meant to assign the true doctrine of the modes .
This is manifest , from his drawing the same inference , both in this note and elsewhere ( 46 ) , from this musical doctrine of the species , as he had drawn before from the harmonic one , viz. that the tones thus cant ( ~ ) mutationem secundum tonum : quod a nostris fit mutata clavis signatura adhibitis mollis et duri notis , &amp;c. -Et propterea tonos distinctos ponendos esse docet omnino septem , Mixolydium , Lydium , Phrygium , Dorium , Hypolydium , Hypophrygium , et Hypodorium .
Totidemque admittit hodiema musica pro varia clavis signatura .
Ibid. p. 313 .
( 45 ) Nempe hoc vult : diapason illud expositum ab hypate meson ad neten diezeugmenon ; hoc est ( in musica hodierna ) , ab elami ad elami , his vocibus post primam cani in tono Mixolydio , fa , sol , la , fa , sol , la , mi ; quae est prima species diapason , habens mi , seu tonum diazeucticum in loco praecedente , seu acutissimo : his in Lydio , sol , la , fa , sol , la , mi , fa ; quae est species secunda diapason , habens mi , in loco secundo ab acutissimo : in Phrygio , la , fa , sol , la , mi , fa , sol : in Dorio , fa , sol , la , mi , fa , sol , la : in Hypolydio , sol , la , mi , fa , sol , la , fa : in Hypophrygio , la , mi , fa , sol , la , fa , sol : in Hypodorio , mi , fa , sol , la , fa , sol , la ; quae sunt tertia , quarta , quinta , sexta , et septima species diapason ; habentes mi , in loco tertio , quarto , quinto , sexto , et septimo , ab acutissimo : quae omnia in musica nostra mollis et duri notis vary positis indicantur , ut mox dicemus .
Not .
ad Ptol .
p. 136 .
( 46 ) Ut soli supersint Ptolemaei septem , Hypodorius , Hypophrygius , &amp;c. totidemque agnoscit hodierna musica posito mi in F , G , A , b , c , d , e. Ibid. p. 154 , ad finem .
settled by Ptolemey are acknowledged by the moderns , in their seven positions of the mi .
For nothing savours less of the musical doctrine , than what the moderns hold in this respect .
And it is manifest also , from his neglecting to assist the explanation of this doctrine of Ptolemey , by any citations from other authors , that speak to the same purpose ; which he would not have failed to do , if it had struck him as an ancient and genuine theory of the modes .
But it is plain to me , that , however he may have penetrated the sense of these particular passages , he did not grasp their consequences .
This the mistakes he has fallen into sufficiently show ; which I shall now proceed to point out , and which a thorough comprehension of the subject could not but have prevented .
In speaking of the mes of the Hypophrygian mode , he explains it by c~ , instead of f~ ( 47 ) , a mistake , which , I think , must be imputed to his haste .
In the table of the modes , which he has given from Meibomius ( 48 ) , he has placed the letters in use with the moderns , against the Hypodorian , as well as the Dorian , making A answer to the proslambanomenos of the former , as well as the latter ; by which , it is to be presumed , he means them to express the absolute pitch of the sounds in the Dorian , and in the Hypodorian , to denote only the general relations of the system ; but this should have been farther explained .
( 47 ) Not .
ad Ptol .
p. 154 .
lin. 41 .
( 48 ) P. 155 .
But his greatest mistake , and which I know not how to reconcile to his usual cation , is in the method he gives for finding the places of the meses for the seven modes .
Not only is this method erroneous , but he gives it expressly as the method of Ptolemey ( 49 ) , though no such direction is to be found in his work .
As I have already given Ptolemey 's method , in our modern terms , for the sake of brevity , from his tenth chapter , where it is delivered , I shall here give that of Wallis , in the same terms , that the difference between the two may more easily be seen .
First pitch the Dorian , which is the middle tone , suppose in A ; rise a fourth to D , for the Mixolydian ; fall a fifth to G , for the Hypolydian ; rise a fourth to C , for the Lydian .
Then begin from the Dorian again , and fall a fourth to E , for the Hypodorian ; rise a fifth to B , for the Phrygian ; and fall a fourth to F ~ , for the Hypophrygian ( 50 ) .
' ' By this method , we see the meses of the Lydian and Hypolydian are brought out at c and f natural ; whereas , by Ptolemey 's , they come out at c ~ , and f ~ , where I have placed them .
This mistake , I apprehend , the doctor was led into by the eleventh chapter of Ptolemey 's second book , where the meses of the Lydian and Hypolydian are settled in trite diezeugmenon and lichanos meson ; which strings , in their natural situation , in the Dorian mode , were tuned to c and g natural ; ( 49 ) Hanc autem methodum adhibet Ptolemaeus in tonis suis septem designandis , &amp;c. primum omnium facit , &amp;c. secundo tonum sumit , &amp;c. App. ad Ptol .
p. 313 &amp; 314 .
( 50 ) Ibid. p. 313 .
lin. ult .
usque ad p. 315 .
lin. 20 .
but , in this chapter , the author means only to fix the numerical string allotted for each mes , without regard to its pitch , which was to be regulated by the distances assigned for the tones in the tenth chapter .
And by these distances , and all other concurring circumstances , it is manifest , that the two strings in question were , in these modes , to be made a semitone , more acute than their natural situation , as I have already observed , in explaining the harmonic doctrine .
How , therefore , the doctor could so far wander from the true theory , which lay before him in the text of his author 's tenth chapter , as to substitute a different method , and deliver it , with great prolixity of explanation , as the method of his author , is what I know not how to account for , much less reconcile to his accustomed care and fidelity .
What is still more extraordinary , is , that , after finishing the directions and explanations of his own method , he , in the very next paragraph , cites the very tenth chapter of Ptolemey , where the method is given ( 51 ) , in order to infer with his author , that the Mixolydian tone was distant from the Lydian a hemitone ; the Lydian from the Phrygian , a tone , &amp;c. though this inference , which is true only from Ptolemey 's method , directly contradicts all he had been delivering .
Could he overlook the falseness of this inference , whilst he was taking so much pains ( 51 ) His positis , inde colligitur ( ut cap. 10 .
) toni Mixolydii a Lydio distantiam limma , seu crassius loquendo hemitonium ; hujus a Phrygio , tonum ; hujus a Dorio , tonum ; Dorii ab Hypolydio limma ; Hypolydii ab Hypophrygio , tonum ; hujusque ab Hypodorio , itidem tonum .
App. p. 315 .
lin. 21 .
with the subject ?
But not to insist farther on the slips of a writer , to whom the learned world stands so highly indebted , I shall take leave of him , with this remark only , that whatever he may have seen of the truth of these doctrines himself , his explanations have not succeeded in making the subject clear to succeeding writers ; those I have seen having either adopted the harmonic doctrine only , or been so confounded between the two , as to give a right account of neither .
This has , in particular , been the case with Malcolm , who , in his Treatise on Music , explains that of the ancients , and has taken some pains to reconcile the two doctrines of the modes .
The greatest part of what this writer delivers is not only false , in respect to the order , positions , and , indeed , almost every other circumstance attending the modes , but , at the same time , scarce intelligible ; or , if any meaning can be put upon it , it is too foreign to the truth of either of the doctrines , to be worth considering .
I shall content myself with citing a passage from him , where his reasoning is the clearest , and where we may see , that , after all the pains he has taken to reconcile the two doctrines , he owns himself unable to make any sure decision upon the subject .
He ( Ptolemey ) says , in the beginning of that chapter ( cap. 7 .
lib. ii .
) , the mutations , which are made by whole systems ( which we properly call tones , because these differences consist in tension ) , are infinite , with respect to possibility , as sounds are ; but actually , and with respect to sense , they are finite .
All this seems plainly to put the difference of the tones only in the acuteness or gravity of the whole ; else , how do their differences consist in tension , which signifies a certain tenor or degree of tune ?
and how can they be called infinite , if they depend on the constitution of the octave ?
Yet , elsewhere , he argues , that they are no other than the species of octaves , and as such , makes their number seven ; and accordingly , in all his schemes , sets down their different modulations .
But , in chapter sixth , he seems more plainly to take in both these differences ; for he says , there are two principal differences with respect to the change of the tone , one , whereby the whole song is sung higher or lower , the other wherein there is a change of the melody to another species than it was begun in ; but this , he thinks , is rather a change of the song , or melos , than of the tone ; as if again he would have us think , this depended only on the acuteness and gravity of the whole .
So obscurely has the best of all the ancient writers delivered himself on this article , that deserved to have been most clearly handled .
But , that I may have done with it , I shall only say , it must be taken in one or other of the senses mentioned , if not in both ; for another , I think , cannot be found ( 52 ) .
' ' Notwithstanding the confusion in this author 's explanations , and his leaving the question thus undecided , it is his account of the modes , that seems chiefly to have been adopted by compilers since .
And hence we find nothing better in the Cyclopaedia of Chambers , or the Musical Dictionary of Grassineau , than a repetition of these doubts and perplexities .
Amongst the French writers , Brossard , in his Dictionaire de Musique , throws no light upon this sub(52 ) Malcolm 's Treatise on Music , p. 538 .
lin. ult .
ject , his account of the modes respecting chiefly those of much later times , which were distinguished into plagal and authentic , and with which the present question has very little concern .
Nor have I met with any thing satisfactory from their academicians , though some of them appear to have taken great pains with the subject .
The writer amongst these , who seems the most conversant with the music of the anantients , is Monsieur Burette , who , in the Memoirs of literature , has furnished many pieces on the various branches of the science .
Amongst others , there is a dissertation of his on the melopaeia of the ancient music , which the learned academician should rather have entitled a dissertation on harmonic ; for it contains an explanation of the elements of that science .
This author seems little apprised of the musical doctrine ; nor has he given a right account even of the harmonic one , having followed Wallis in his mistake , in respect to the method , by which Ptolemey fixed the positions of his seven modes ( 53 ) , and even drawn the same contradictory conclusion ( 54 ) : ( 53 ) Qu'ainsi on devoit renfermer dans l'espace d'une octave tous les modes , dont le Dorien devoit occuper , comme le centre , les six autres etant disposez de facon , que le Mixolydien fut d'une quart plus haut que le Dorien ; l'Hypolydien d'une quinte plus bas que le Mixolydien ; le Lydien d'une quart plus haut que l'Hypolidien ; l'Hypodorien d'une quart plus bas que le Dorien ; le Phrygien d'une quinte plus haut que l'Hypodorien ; et l'Hypophrygien d'une quart plus bas que le Phrygien .
Dissertation sir le Melopee , &amp;c. ( 54 ) D'ou il paroit , qu'a compter de l'Hypodorien , qui est le mode le plus bas , il ya de celui ci a l'Hypophrygien l'intervalle d'un ton ; de l'Hypophrygien a l'Hypolydien un autre ton ; de l'Hypolydien au Dorien , un demiton ; de ce dernier au Phrygien , un ton ; du Phrygien au Lydien encore un ton ; et du Lydien au Mixolydien , un demiton .
Ibidem .
whence it appears , that he relied on the doctor 's appendix for this part at least of his explanations .
In his notes on the dialogue of Plutarch , printed also in the same memoirs , the not understanding the musical doctrine has led him into a very false explanation of the passage cited above , concerning the invention of the Mixolydian mode .
He sets out ( 55 ) with excluding the only supposition , that could lead him to the sense of his author , by denying , that the octachord system could have any thing to do with this invention ; and then flies ( 56 ) to two other suppositions , viz. that either the hendecachord or disdiapason was here meant , both which are equally wide of the truth .
The public is much indebted to this writer , for the laborious collections he has made in these notes , concerning the ancient musicians ; but his harmonic explanations are not always to be relied on .
( 55 ) Lamprocle n'est point ici donne comme l'auteur de l'harmonie Mixolydienne , il en est regard seulement comme le reformateur .
Mais en quoi pouvoit consister cette reform ?
C'etoit , comme le dit Plutarque , a determiner le veritable systeme de cette harmony , ou de ce mode , quant a sa disjonction , ou a l'arrangement des divers tetrachordes , ~ composoient ce systeme .
En le reduisant a l'etendue de l'octave , ~ de l'octachorde , c'est a dire du double tetrachorde disjoint ; le lieu de cette disjonction est unique , et par consequent n'est point equivoque , comme on le peut voir par la progression de ce systeme , que voici , mi , fa , sol , la , si , ut , re , mi ; il no s'agit donc point ici du double tetrachorde disjoint .
Note 114 .
( 56 ) Mais l'hendecachorde , ou le triple tetrachorde disjoint , pouvoit etre le systeme , dont parle icy Plutarque-suppose qu'il soit icy question du systeme complete de l'ancienne musique , &amp;c. Ibidem .
The last writer , that I have seen , who has treated this subject , and with whose opinion I shall conclude these sheets , is the anonymous author of a letter to Mr. Avison , concerning the music of the ancients , published with the essay of the latter on mufical expression , in 1753 .
This author , who professes but a slender knowlege of the theory , either of modern or ancient music , has , in a few pages , discovered himself to be possessed of more than his modesty will permit him to lay claim to .
In the matter of the tones , however , ( such is the fatality , that seems to have constantly attended this doctrine ) he does not appear to have succeeded better than the writers that have gone before him .
He blames Sanadon and Cerceau , for affirming , in their observations on Horace , carm .
5 .
9 .
that the Dorian mode answered exactly to our A-mi-la with a minor third , and the Phrygian to our A-mi-la with a major third .
Now , that these French critics , though right , inasmuch as they seem to consider the modes as different species of diapason , are , nevertheless , mistaken in their application of them , does , indeed , appear from my first diagram , where it may be immediately seen , that what they assert of the Dorian and Phrygian modes , is true only of the Hypodorian and Lydian ; and had the anonymous writer gone no farther in his censure of them , I should readily have joined with him : but he rejects the musical doctrine entirely , and admits only of the harmonic .
` ` Surely ( says he ( 57 ) , speaking of what these critics advance ) this is a musical error , and a dream from the ivory gate .
Two modes ( 57 ) Page 6 .
with the same tonic note , the one neither acuter nor graver than the other , make no part of the old system of modes .
' ' And , agreeably to this opinion , he had before ( 58 ) described the seven modes , as reducible to one mode , taken higher or lower ; which , he says , may be be called the mode of A , and must have had a minor third , as c natural is a minor third to A-mi-la .
Whether this be a just account of the nature of the modes , I must now submit , having said already what has occurred to me , in support of the contrary opinion .
To conclude , if what has been said should be thought to establish any certainty concerning this matter , I should hope it might tend to revive an inquiry into the music of the ancients , which seems to have suffered an interruption from the difficulty of arriving at a right understanding of this material branch of it .
Such an inquiry may , perhaps , be judged well worth pursuing , not only from the advantages , which modern music might derive from it , but also for the sake of improving the art of poetry , and of better understanding and tasting the noble remains we have of the ancient poets ; the greatest beauties of whose works , especially the lyric and dramatic , are probably lost to us , for want of seeing their connection with this science .
( 58 ) Page 5 .

