An Account of a complete Luxation of the Thigh Bone , in an adult Person , by external Violence ; by Mr. Charles White , Surgeon , at Manchester .
Communicated by George Lloyd , Esq ; F. R. S. AS Robert Hog , ( a farmer in Clyfton , about four miles from Manchester ) a strong , robust , middle-aged man , was taking a load of wheat from off a horse , on the 20th of March 1759 , his foot slipping , he fell backwards ; his breech upon the pavement , and the load of wheat upon his belly and thighs .
The servants carried him into the house , and laid him upon a bed , where he remained in the most racking torture , when I came to him , which was about two hours after the accident happened .
I found his right buttock as large again as the other ; the knee and foot of the same side turned inwards ; and the thigh much shortened .
Upon endeavouring to make the thigh perform its rotatory motion , there was not the least crackling to be heard .
This convinced me , that the head of the bone was thrown out of the acetabulum ; and , upon examination , I could distinctly feel it under the glutaei muscles : to which situation of it , and not to any bruise , Read May 1 , bruise , I was now satisfied that the size of the buttock was owing .
I soon reduced it , by the following easy , and very simple method .
Some napkins being first lapped round one of the posts at the foot of the bed , to prevent its galling him , I ordered the patient to be laid upon his back , with one leg on each side the post , and then directed three or four assistants to pull at the dislocated limb , the post now placed to his groin being a fixed point to pull against .
Whilst they were making this extension , I clapped my left hand upon the head of the bone , to help it into its place ; and , at the same instant , with my right hand , turning the knee outwards , threw the bone into the socket , with the greatest facility imaginable , but with such an uncommonly loud noise , as greatly astonished all who were present .
He was perfectly easy from that moment ; the enlargement of the buttock entirely subsided .
In a fortnight , he was able to move about , without assistance ; and in two months afterwards walked as far as Manchester , being then quite sound ; and the limb , that had been dislocated , of the same length with the other .
REMARK S. Both ancients and moderns have fallen into great errors , in regard to the treatment of accidents , that have happened to the hip joint .
The ancients , who , for want of frequent opportunities of dissecting bodies , were ignorant , that the neck of the femur was often broken , always imagined it to be luxated .
Their patients were , therefore , sometimes tormented , ( in hopes of a reduction ) without any advantage ; and this want of success made the surgeons , at other times , abandon their patients , when they might have been relieved .
The moderns have fallen into a contrary extreme , but attended with as bad consequences .
Boerhaave , in particular , was of opinion , that there never was a dislocation of the thigh bone by any external violence , but that the head of it was commonly broken off at its neck , near the great trochanter .
The opinion of so learned a man has had such weight with the generality of the profession , that it has been taken for granted , that , in these cases , the neck of the bone was always broken : consequently , the reduction was seldom attempted , and the unfortunate patients remained cripples during the rest of their lives .
But the point is now , I think , cleared up , beyond the possibility of a doubt .
In the second volume of the memoirs of the royal academy of surgery at Paris , there are two cases related , to show the resources of nature , where luxations of the thigh bone have not been reduced .
Here it appears , ( from examination after death ) that , in the first case , the bone was thrown out upwards and outwards , the cotyloid cavity greatly diminished in size , and its figure changed from round to oval .
The head of the femur was received into another cavity formed upon the os ileum , under the glutaeus minimus , which served it as a capsula , to secure it within this preternatural cavity .
This accident was occasioned by a fall , when the patient was a child .
She was afterwards able to walk about , though she continued a cripple to the time of her death , which happened at the age of sixty-eight .
In the other case , the bone was luxated downwards and inwards , and the head fixed upon the foramen ovale .
There is a case too related , and very well attested , in the Edinburgh essays , philosophical and literary , vol. 2d , of a man at Worcester , who had the head of the bone thrown out of the acetabulum , and lodged in the groin .
It was with some difficulty reduced , and the man suffered no other inconvenience , than that of the leg 's being about a quarter of an inch longer than the other .
To these , let me add , that , about thirty years ago , my father was sent for to a man , who had luxated his thigh bone three or four days before .
The head of it lay in the groin , which the surgeon , who was first employed , did not discover .
However , it was immediately replaced , and the patient recovered the use of his limb , in a very short time .
From what I have said , I would by no means have it concluded , that the neck of the bone is not sometimes broken , or that it is not even oftener broken than luxated : but , from the case , which has fallen directly under my notice , joined to those , which I have above recited , I think it must appear very clear , that it has been frequently luxated , and that two different ways .
C. White .

