Remarks on the Bovey Coal : In a Letter to the Right Honourable George Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society .
By Jeremiah Milles , D. D. F. R. S. My Lord , THE description , which the learned professor Hollman has given the Society * , of two remarkable strata of fossil wood in Germany , one in the neighbourhood of Munden , in the duchy of Grubenhagen , and the other near Allendorf in Hesse , corresponds , in so many particulars , with some strata , discovered about fifteen years ago , in Devonshire , that it suggested to me a doubt , whether those German strata were really ( what the learned professor supposes them ) fossil wood , and formerly a vegetable substance , or ( what he says the miners call them ) fossil coal .
The reasons , on which this doubt is founded , are submitted to the judgment of your Lordship , and the Society , in the following * See the above , No xlix .
p. 506 .
4 account Read Feb. 28 , account of the Devonshire fossil , which is commonly known by the name of the Bovey coal .
It is found on a common surrounded with hills , called Bovey Heathfield , in the parish of South-Bovey , 13 miles south-west of Exeter , and 3 miles west of Chudleigh .
The uppermost of these strata rises within a foot of the surface , under a sharp white sand , intermixed with an ash coloured clay , and underlies to the south about 20 inches in a fathom .
The perpendicular thickness of these strata , including the beds of clay , with which they are intermixed , is about 70 feet .
There are about six of each , and they are found to continue eastward , in an uninterrupted course , to the village of Little-Bovey , a mile distant , and probably extend much further .
The strata of coal near the surface are from 18 inches to 4 feet thick , and are separated by beds of a brownish clay , nearly of the same dimensions , but diminishing in thickness downwards , in proportion as the strata of coal grew larger ; and both are observed to be of a more compact and solid substance in the lower beds .
The lowermost stratum of coal is 16 feet thick ; it lies on a bed of clay , under which is a sharp green sand , not unlike sea sand , 17 feet thick , and under that , a bed of hard close clay , into which they bored , but found no coal .
From the sand arises a spring of clear blue water , which the miners call mundic water , and a moisture of the same kind trickling through the crevices of the coal tinges the outside of it with a blue cast .
Some small and narrow veins of coal are found intermixed with , and shooting through , the beds of clay , forming impressions like reeds and grass , and very similar to those , which are generally found on the top of coal mines .
The clay also ( at least that part of it , which lies nearest to the coal ) seems to partake of its nature , having somewhat of a laminous texture , and being in a small degree inflammable ; and amongst this clay , but adhering to the veins of coal , are found lumps of a bright yellow loam , extremely light , and so saturated with petroleum , that they burn like sealing wax , emitting a very agreeable and aromatic scent .
Though the substance and quality of this coal , in its several strata , are much alike , and it is all indiscriminately used for the same purposes ; yet there is some difference in the colour , form , and texture , of the several veins .
The exterior parts , which lie nearest to the clay , have a greater mixture of earth , and are generally of a dark brown , or chocolate colour ; some of them appear like a mass of coal and earth mixed ; others have a laminous texture , but the laminae run in such oblique , waving , and undulating forms , that they bear a strong resemblance to the roots of trees , of which kind I have seen some specimens from Lough Neagh in Ireland , which seem to be the same sort of fossil .
There are other veins of this coal , which lie more in the center of the strata , and abound most in the lowest and thickest bed , the substance of which is more compact and solid ; these are as black , and almost as heavy , as pit coal ; they do not so easily divide into laminae , and seem to be more strongly impregnated with bitumen : these are distinguished by the name of stone coals , and the fire of them is more strong and lasting than that of other veins .
But the most remarkable and curious vein in these strata is that , which they call the wood coal , or board coal , from the resemblance which the pieces have to the grain of deal boards .
It is sometimes of a chocolate colour , and sometimes of a shining black .
The former sort seems to be less impregnated with bitumen , is not so solid and heavy as the latter , and has more the appearance of wood .
It lies in strait and even veins , and is frequently dug in pieces of three or four feet long , and , with proper care , might be taken out of a much greater length .
Other pieces of the same kind are found lying upon them , in all directions , but without the least intermixture of earth , or any other interstices , except some small crevices , by which the pieces are divided from each other , in all directions .
When it is first dug , and moist , the thin pieces of it will bend like horn , but when dry , it loses its elasticity , and becomes short and crisp .
At all times , it is easily to be separated into very thin laminae , or splinters , especially if it lie any time exposed to the heat of the sun , which , like the fire , makes it crackle , separate , and fall to pieces .
The texture of this fossil consists of a number of laminae , or very thin plates , lying upon each other horizontally , in which small protuberancies sometimes appear , like the knots of trees ; but , upon examination , they are only mineral nuclei , which occasion this interruption in the course of the laminae ; and pieces of spar have been sometimes found in the middle of this wood coal .
Though the texture of this coal is laminated , yet it does not appear to have any of those fibrous intersections , which are observed in the grain of all wood .
This coal easily breaks transversely , and the separated parts , instead of being rugged and uneven , are generally smooth and shining , in which even the course of the laminae is hardly discernable .
They dig this coal in an open pit , together with the clay that is mixed with it ; and though it lies very close and compact in its original bed , yet it is so easily separated , that they can afford to sell it for half a crown a ton at the pit .
The smaller coal is separated from the clay by a screen , or grated shovel ; the larger , which rises sometimes in pieces of above an hundred weight , is piled up by hand .
There is hardly any other use made of it at present , but to bake the earthen ware of a manufacture erected at SouthBovey , and for burning of limestone , which rising in great quantities at the neighbouring town of Chudleigh , the coal is carried thither , and they return with limestone to the pit ; which they burn there , for the use of the northern parishes , to whom it lies more convenient than the kilns of Chudleigh .
The fire made by this coal is more or less strong and lasting , according to its different veins : those which lie nearest to the clay , having a greater mixture of earth , burn heavily , leaving a large quantity of brownish ashes ; that , which they call the wood coal , is said to make as strong a fire as oaken billets , especially if it be set on edge , so that the fire , as it ascends , may insinuate itself between , and separate the laminae .
But that of the stone coal is accounted most strong and durable , being apparently more solid and heavy , and probably also more strongly impregnated with bitumen .
One of the proprietors of this coal made an experiment of burning it in the fire-engines of Cornwall , wall , to which it might have been transported , without much trouble or expense , being only four miles distant from the navigable river Teign ; but the heat of the coal was not sufficiently intense , and the consumption of it too great , to answer the purpose .
When this coal is put into the fire , it crackles , and separates into laminae , as the cannel coal does into irregular pieces , burns for some time with a heavy flame , becomes red-hot , and gradually consumes to light white ashes .
Though the transverse crevices made in it by the fire give it the external appearance of a wooden brand , yet , if quenched when red-hot , the unconsumed part does not look like charcoal , but seems to be almost as smooth and solid , as when first put into the fire .
The thick heavy smoke , which arises from this coal when burnt , is very faetid and disagreeable ; entirely different from that aromatic scent of the bituminous loam , which is found adhering to it , but much resembling that of the asphaltum , or bitumen of the Dead Sea .
The whole neighbourhood is infected with the stench , which is wafted by the wind to the distance of three or four miles .
When burnt in a chimney ( as it is sometimes in the neighbourhood ) , the offensiveness is lessened by the draught : however , it is found , by those , who live continually in the smoke of it , not to be unwholesome ; nor is it in the least prejudicial to the eyes , like the smoke of wood .
The most shining and solid pieces of this coal have not the least degree of electrical attraction .
Notwithstanding the resemblance , which this fossil bears to wood , especially when viewed in detached pieces , yet the following observations on its situation , its form and properties , will prove it to be not of a vegetable , but of a mineral origin .
In the first place , there does not seem to be any imaginable cause in nature , which could bring together such a mass of fossil wod , as is found in this , and other strata of the like kind in different parts of Europe .
It extends here to the depth of 70 feet : in that near Munden they have sunk 50 feet , without coming to the bottom .
Fossil trees , though frequently found single , or in small numbers , are generally discovered in morasses and soft ground , where they have either buried themselves by their own weight , or been overwhelmed by some accidental cause : but the Bovey strata are found in a dry soil , intermixed with clay and sand , and , by their regular course and continuance , carry the most undoubted marks of never having been disturbed since their original formation .
Fossil trees likewise preserve their form and size , their length and roundness , their branches and roots , their fibrous texture and strength , and are either found entire , or in such large pieces , that there is no room to doubt of their nature , since the very species of wood is frequently distinguishable in them ; whereas the Bovey coal comes out only in flat pieces , of a few feet long , like the splinters of large masts ; and on them we discover no signs of roots , branches , or bark , no round pieces , or concentric circles , which distinguish the annual growth of trees ; the laminae , which have the appearance of wood , being always horizontal , according to the situation of the pieces in the strata : or could we suppose a number of fossil trees to be brought together , and ranged in this regular manner in the several strata , yet , by the form and roundness of their trunks , they must be , in a great measure , encompassed by the soil , in which they are buried ; whereas there is not the least mixture of earth , or any other aperture , in the Bovey strata of coal , except a few crevices , common to this sort of fossil , which divide the pieces from each other in all directions , and seem to be inconsistent with the nature and fibrous texture of wood .
If the basis or matrix of this fossil were wood , it would acquire , by being impregnated with bitumen , a greater degree of inflammability ; whereas it neither kindles nor consumes so fast as wood .
The inflammability and laminated texture of this fossil , which have been the only reasons for supposing it of vegetable origin , may be accounted for from the nature of its principles , and their disposition , when united , to assume certain forms .
The bituminous matter uniting with various kinds of earth , in certain proportions , will form an inflammable substance ; and a similar mixture of these will generally assume a similar texture and form , as will appear from the accounts given us of this fossil both by the ancients and moderns , most of whom speak of it as a mineral substance .
Theophrastus * mentions ` ` a stone on the promontory of Erineas in Peloponesus , and another in the mines of Binae in Thrace , which being burnt , emitted a bituminous odour ; and another stone in the mines of Scaptisulae , not unlike to rotten * De Lapidibus , p. 4 .
wood , which would burn , if oil was poured on it , but would cease burning as soon as the oil was consumed .
' ' Dioscorides * observes of the lapis gagates , which is certainly a species of this fossil , ` ` that the sort , which kindles quickly , and gives a bituminous odour , is the best .
' ' He describes it as generally of a black colour , and uneven substance , broad and flat , and very light .
He mentions ~ also a black earth , found at Seleucia in Syria , called terra Ampelitis , which resembled long pieces of fossil coal , splitting easily , of an uniform glossy superficies , which being pounded , and immersed in oil , immediately liquified .
Pliny ~ describes the gagates as black , porous , and flat , not much unlike wood , brittle , of a disagreeable smell when rubbed , and emitting a sulphureous odour when burnt .
Galen ~ calls it ` ` a black stone , which , when put in the fire , sends forth a bituminous odour .
' ' And he speaks of some other black stones , brought by him out of Caelosyria , ` ` which were broad like a board , and , being put into the fire , burnt with a slender flame : they were generated in the hills on the east side of the Dead Sea , where the bitumen is produced , and the smell of the stone was like bitumen .
' ' I cannot but observe on this passage , that the smell of the Bovey coal , when burnt , is the * Lib. v. cap. 103 .
~ Lib. v. cap. 138 .
~ Hist. Not .
lib. xxxvi .
cap. 19 .
~ De Simplicium Medicamentorum Facultat .
lib. ix .
de Gagate .
same with that of the asphaltum , and of a stone impregnated with it , which is found at a small distance from the Dead Sea .
Agricola * mentions these , and several other kinds of bituminous fossils , taken notice of by the ancients , and points out several places in Europe where they are now found .
Later writers describe it under the name of metallophyton , or lignum fossile ; and most of them suppose it to be a mineral substance .
Francisco Stelluti , in a treatise printed at Rome 1637 , has accurately described some very curious strata of this kind , near Todi and Aqua Sparta in Umbria : he says , they consist of large oval and compressed pieces , lying horizontally , resembling the trunks of trees , but larger : he mentions one above 3 feet broad : they have neither roots , branches , nor fibres , but something like bark ; and the heart of the tree , which in some is as hard as a bone , in others as black as a coal .
The extremity of these pieces is as smooth , as if they had been divided by a saw .
It is full of veins of a dark brown colour , which , instead of running strait like the fibres of wood , are undulated and irregular , taking a variety of forms , and are only superficial ; for , upon taking off one of the thin laminae , of which this fossil is composed , the veins underneath appear in a different direction .
This fossil , when first taken out of the earth , bends like a bow ; and when put into the fire consumes slowly , with a great smoke , and disagreeable smell ; but , if burnt when dry , the smell is more pleasing .
The heat is more intense than * De Natura Fossilium , lib. iv .
p. 596 .
wood , and it does not consume so fast .
Many of these pieces are sprinkled with marcasite , and there exsudes from it a white bituminous substance , like rosin .
It is full of crevices , in all directions , and the pieces appear in a variety of forms , ' ' which the author has exhibited , together with a representation of the veins of the fossil , in several copper-plates accompanying his work .
He is clearly of opinion , ` ` that this substance is not generated from the seed or roots of any plant , but from a cretaceous earth transforming itself into wood , by the assistance of sulphureous water minerals , and subterraneous heat , which appears there in a thick smoke , and sometimes in flames , particularly in rainy weather .
' ' He forms his supposition on the different appearances of this fossil , ` ` some pieces of it being like chalk , others like wood , and again others like coal ; some are either totally or partially petrified , being stone without and wood within , or vice versa .
' ' But these various appearances may be easily accounted for , from the different kinds and proportions of earthy matter , with which the bitumen is mixed .
Of the same kind are the fossil strata in Iceland , mentioned in the Musaeum Wormianum , and by Horrebow , in his natural history of that island .
The former of these authors * describes it as ` ` a laminated substance , generally of a black , but sometimes only of a dark colour , heavy , and , when dry , brittle ; though the merchant , who gave the specimen , assured him , that when it was first dug out of the * Lib. ii .
cap. 16 .
p. 169 .
earth it would bend like a twig .
It consists of oblique fibres , and here and there some knots like the roots of a great tree .
A carpenter , who was a judge of wood , thought it to be the root of a walnut-tree grown black with age .
It was not easily to be polished , too brittle to be used in cabinet work , and was full of crevices .
This stratum is found some yards under the earth , in a mountain so high and perpendicular , that those only who have been accustomed to climb such precipices can venture to dig for it .
There is not the least appearance , that trees ever grew where this fossil is found , notwithstanding this author supposes them to be roots of trees turned black , by a subterraneous vitriolic juice .
The dust of this stratum is accounted , by the Icelanders , an excellent preservative of cloaths from moths and worms .
' ' Horrebow * says , ` ` it is an extraordinary sort of wood , which they call sortebrand , or black brand , very hard , heavy , and black like ebony .
It is found deep in the ground , in broad , thin , and pretty large panels , or leaves , fit for a moderate sized table .
It is generally wavy , undulated ; and is always found between the rocks , or great stones , wedged , as it were , close in .
' ' He was doubtful , whether it were wood , or a petrification ; but inclined to the former opinion , because it could be planed and managed like wood .
The same sort of fossil , according to Wormius ~ , is found in the islands of Faro .
It does not easily * Page 33 .
~ Musaeum Wormianum , p. 31 .
cap. 13 .
de Bitumine .
take fire , but has a splendor like gagates .
It is found in the joints of the rock , and is taken out in laminae , or splinters , of 3 or 4 inches thick .
' ' Of the like kind is the stratum of fossil wood near Thun in Swisserland , mentioned by Schentzer , in his Itinera Alpina * ; which he describes as lying under several strata of flints , clay , and ash coloured marle .
Being exposed to the air , parts of it grew hard , and others broke to pieces .
` ` It is ( he says ) observable of this fossil wood , that the trunks and branches are not round , but compressed ; yet , in some places , cloathed with their bark , and here and there adorned with their leaves .
The wood is inflammable , making a strong fire , and serves instead of fossil coals .
' ' The author supposes the compression of this stratum to be owing to the great superincumbent weight ; but others , he says , imagine it to be so formed by nature , from clay , in the bowels of the earth .
I would observe here , that the crustaceous appearance , so common to these bituminous fossils , might easily be mistaken by this author for the bark of the tree , the same appearance being observed by Stelluti , in that of Umbria ; but it is not so easy to account for the leaves , which certainly have no connection with a mineral substance .
John George Liebnecht , in his Hassia subterranea , quotes Pillingius 's treatise on bitumen and lignum fossile , for the following description of a stratum of this latter kind .
He says , that at Meislibitz , in the duchy of Altenburg in Saxony , there is a mountain , with a gradual ascent and fertile summit , the * Quarto , 1724 .
p. 604 .
outward stratum of which is vegetable earth , three feet deep ; and under it a stratum of clay , two fathom thick ; then a stratum of sand , made blackish by bituminous fumes : subtus lignum putridum , flammam concipiens , pectines annuos referens , ita a natura natum , ut nec aqua aquae , nec lac lacti similius , quam ligno huic minerali lignum vegetabile putridum .
Our English naturalists have likewise described this fossil , as found in several parts of the kingdom , and always , in or near strata of clay .
Dr. Plot , in his natural history of Oxfordshire * , observes , ` ` that the scarcity of firing in some parts of that county has induced people to burn a sort of black substance , of a grain somewhat like rotten wood half burnt , partaking also of a mineral nature , and therefore by authors called metallophyton , or lignum fossile .
Put into water , it will not swim ; and into fire , it consumes but slowly , and sends forth very unpleasant fumes .
A vein of it at Duchlington looked like wood ; yet broken , showed a smooth and shining superficies , not unlike to stone pitch ; and put into the fire , has not near so ill a smell .
As to the substance of lignum fossile , it is thought to be a cretaceous earth , turned to what it is by subterraneous heats ; for that it was never formerly wood , notwithstanding its specious and outward likeness , is plain from its never being found with roots or boughs , or any other signs of wood .
' ' And , in his history of Staffordshire , he quotes Scoochius 's opinion , ` ` that many of the stumps and trunks of trees found in Holland , Zea* Page 65 .
land , and Friezland , are of this mineral wood , chiefly because most of them are found without knots or roots .
' ' Dr. Morton , in his natural history of Northamptonshire * , mentions two or three varieties of this metallophyton ; one of which he describes , as ` ` of a dark colour , and having a grain ; for in one direction ( which is usually according to the length of the pieces ) , it cleaves or parts pretty readily into plates and splinters , the other way it snaps into shorter pieces , and will not cleave at all .
There is another sort , which does not so readily part into flakes .
None of these are found in any large masses .
They are all , more or less , of a glossy black , and have a density or smoothness within like that of bitumen , or jet .
In that also , they resemble the true bitumen , or pissaphalton .
They are not so firm and hard as the common coal , and are much brittler than canal or jet .
They likewise all of them agree pretty nearly in the same properties .
In water they sink .
They are all inflammable , but consume slowly in the fire , and emit a somewhat unpleasant fume , not unlike that of bitumen , only fainter .
' ' Of the same kind is the inflammable slate , or coal , of Dorsetshire , found in the cliffs at the north-west corner of the ifle of Portland , near the castle , of which I have received the following account from a gentleman of that county .
The upper stratum is the natural black earth 14 feet deep ; the next is a greyish , soft , paving stone , 6 inches thick ; then follows the vein * Page ~ .
of coal , of 10 inches ; under which is a black earth , and at the bottom of the clift , clay .
It rises in laminae , and is discovered in the outermost part of the clift , whence it is taken , by digging horizontally : some is black , and some of a redish colour ; which latter is reputed the worst , and does not burn so well .
The ashes of both are reckoned very good manure for clay ground .
It is made use of to heat ovens ; and when piled up as turff , gives a clear light , and yields a strong bituminous smell .
It is found more to the west , at Chickerel and Fleet , in the sands , the shore being open .
The Kimendge coal , which , in all respects , resembles that before-mentioned , and is so called from the place where it is dug , appears in most of the cliffs of the isle of Purbeck , from St. Aldhelm 's chapel to East-Lulworth , and at Osmington , opposite to that part of Portland where the coal is dug .
It is found 16 feet below the top of the rock , in great lumps ; but the stratum does not exceed 2 feet in thickness , nor extend far from the shore .
It emits , when burnt , a strong sulphureous smell , and has a great many yellow strokes and spots on it , which seem to be marcasite .
It is almost wholly used by the poor , in their ovens and chimneys , and is sold for nine pence per hogshead , or six shillings per ton .
Under water , and in the cliffs , it is very hard ; but when exposed to the air it shivers into pieces like slate .
At Kimendge are found small round pieces of this coal , from one to three inches in diameter , one side of which is flat , the other tapering , like the lower part of a cone .
In some there is a square hole in the center on the flat side ; in most of them two , or sometimes four holes , near the edge , but they do not penetrate quite through the piece .
They are sometimes found at the top of the cliffs , between two stones set on edge , and covered with a third , mingled with human bones .
Sometimes they are found by themselves , but always in made ground .
The common people call them coal money .
I think it can scarce be doubted , that they are British antiquities .
To these , I shall add Dr. Hoffman 's * account of a stratum of the same kind in Prussia , in the neighbourhood of Fischausen , &amp;c. where they dig for amber .
` ` The upper stratum is sand , under it a bed of clay , and then a woody stratum , consisting of a substance like old wood , but inflammable ; under this was a vitriolic mineral ; and , lastly , a bed of sand , in which a great quantity of amber was found .
' ' There is a remarkable resemblance between the order of these strata , and those at Bovey ; and though no amber has been discovered at the latter place , yet it would seem , as if there were some connection between that and these bituminous strata ; for it is remarkable , that Theophrastus ~ , speaking of an earthy inflammable substance in Liguria of this kind , adds , that amber is found there .
The resemblance likewise , which the strata of Munden and Allendorf bear to those of Bovey , is remarkable , the soil in which they lie consisting of clays , boles , and sand .
This is so much the case at Bovey , that they have large beds of a very fine pipe * Observationes Physico-chemicales , lib. ii .
obs .
23 .
p. 199 .
~ De Lapidibus , p. 4 .
clay in the neighbourhood , which has for many years been exported to Liverpool , and manufactured there into earthen ware ; but there is one now erected at Bovey .
The depth of the strata is likewise much the same ; for at Munden they have sunk 50 feet , without coming to the bottom .
The pieces , that form these strata , seem to lie much in the same manner ; they are compressed , without any intermixture of earth , full of cracks and fissures , and lying so close upon each other , that the professor says , ` ` it could not be discovered , whether they were entire trees , or only parts of them , ' ' and when taken out , they easily fell to pieces .
The German strata resemble those of Bovey in colour .
That of Allendorf , which Dr. Hollman calls bitumen , and which he distinguishes from the fossil wood lying under it , is said to be little inferior in blackness , splendor , and hardness , to jet ; and he adds , that the fossil wood approaches very nearly to the same colour .
He observes , indeed , that the stratum of Allendorf is not so strongly impregnated with bitumen , and therefore left by the workmen for future ages ; and , no doubt , some species of this fossil have so much earth , and so little bitumen , that they are not at all , or only in a small degree , inflammable .
I shall only observe further , that the layer of stone , which divides the two strata in the quarry of Munden , is a strong objection to the notion of their being fossil wood , properly so called ; and that the vein of the stratum at Allendorf , being taken in the adit of a mine , could not give an opportunity of examining the nature and disposition of its parts , with the same advantage , that we can view the strata at Bovey .
I shall conclude this paper with observing the several particulars , in which all the species of the bituminous fossils before-mentioned resemble each other .
They seem to be generally found between beds of clay , or stone ; are of a dark brown , or black colour , of a laminated texture : pliable when moist , and fresh dug , but crisp and brittle when dry ; full of cracks , and easily breaking transversely ; they all sink in water , and emit the same nauseous and bituminous smell ; they differ in being more or less solid , heavy , and inflammable , according to the proportions and principles of which they consist ; and if any doubt could remain of their being a mineral substance , it must be removed by the following analysis .
One pound of Bovey coal , of the woody kind , powdered , put into a glass retort , and distilled in sand , yielded four ounces and a half of phlegm , which had the appearance of common water , but somewhat of a bituminous smell and taste ; near four ounces of a turbid whitish bituminous liquor , of an intolerable faetid smell , and extremely pungent to the tongue ; about two drachms of a heavy bituminous matter , which would not mix with the liquor above-mentioned , but sunk entirely to the bottom , and ( which is very remarkable ) there was not the least appearance of any light oil floating on the bituminous liquor .
There remained in the retort about seven ounces of a very black powder , which had the same bituminous smell , not very heavy ; some of which being put on a red-hot iron , emitted a little smoke , but no flame .
The The ashes of this fossil , when burnt , being boiled in water , and the water evaporated , there remained no salt behind .
I am , my Lord , &amp;c. Grosvenot-Street , Feb. 28 , 1760 .

