XLVII .
Remarks on the Mutations of the Stars ; by Tho. Barker , Esq ; of Lyndon , in Rutland : Communicated by the Rev. W. Stukeley , M. D. F. R. S. IT is well known there have been several alterations among the fixed stars : for instance , Ptolemy 's ultima fluvii , a first magnitude star , is in Dr. Halley 's catalogue of the southern constellations only a third magnitude : and in much less time , the ~ of the Great Bear , which Bayer seems to have judged just of the same size with the other six , is grown far duller than any of them .
Some stars also have quite disappeared , while again new ones , not seen before , have been discovered : and there are others periodically larger and smaller .
Two very remarkably bright , yet short-lived , stars , have been also seen , one in Cassiopeia , the other in Serpentarius ; which breaking out , at once , with greater lustre than any other fixed star , gradually faded , and changing to different colours , in about a year and half were no longer visible .
But , I think , no one has yet remarked , that any lasting star was of a different colour in different ages : Greaves , on the contrary , takes notice , that the colours of the stars and planets are the same now as the ancients observed ; which is , I believe , very true in general : for Ptolemy , in his catalogue of stars , says , Arcturus , Aldebaran , Pollux , Cor Scorpii , and Orion 's Shoulder ( with another to be mentioned presently ) , are ~~ , reddish : and the five here mentioned are still of Read Jan. 31 , of that colour , and , I think , the only considerable stars which are so .
But , to this rule there seems to be one exception , and that in a remarkable star : for old authors mention the Dog star , which is now white , and not at all inclined to redness , as being then very much so ; as in the following places : ~ ~ ~~ ~ .
326 .
Which Cicero thus turns-See Gruter 's Cicero , IV .
359 Namque pedes subter rutilo cum lumine claret Fervidus ille Canis stellarum luce refulgens .
Seu rubra Canicula findet Infantes statuasHor .
Sat. II .
5 , 39 .
Acrior sit Caniculae rubor , Martis remissior Jovis nullus .
Seneca Quaest .
Not .
I. 1 .
~ ~ .
Ptolemy .
~ ~ .
~ , in the quotation from Aratus , does not expressly mean red ; but is always used of something showy , glittering as gold , various-coloured , &amp;c. ~ in the following places .
~~ ~ .
Homer 's Il .
v. 181 .
~ ~ ~ .
~ .
30 .
~~~ ~~ .
~ .
107 .
~~~~ ~ .
~ .
~ .
202 .
Aratus therefore , I think , shows at least , that the Dog star was not then of the same colour as other stars : and , as Cicero turns it rutilus , it appears he either understood the word to mean red , or knowing by his own view it was so , thought it the proper interpretation ; for rutilus is used of what is reddish , and often of the red glare of a fire , or the dawn , as below : rutilum vomit ille cruorem .
Ovid .
Met .
V. 33 .
Promissae et rutilatae comae .
Livy .
XXXVIII .
17 .
Arma inter nubem , caeli in regione serena .
Virg. AEneid .
VIII .
528 .
Per sudum rutilare vident , Sin maculae incipient rutilo immiscerier igni .
Georg .
I. 454 .
Auroram rutilare procul cerno .
Varro , de Ling .
Lat. VI .
5 .
Rubra , in Horace , will , I think , bear no other sense than red , or else it is the heat he there chiefly speaks of : and though , I think , Latin authors confound Canicula , some using the word for Sirius , others for Procyon ; yet it plainly appears , that Sirius is here meant , since Horace always calls it Canicula , and never uses the word Sirius : but Aratus and Ptolemy leave no room to doubt what star it was , being expressly speaking about the Dog star .
Seneca says , the redness was so strong as to exceed that of Mars , to which no star now approaches .
None of the notes on Seneca clear up this matter : Fromondus , indeed , observed the place , and declared his astonishment at it ; but does not attempt to solve the difficulty .
Ptolemy 's is , however , the most undeniable evidence , who , when directly describing the stars , and particularly mentioning the Dog star , says , expressly , it was of the same colour as Cor Scorpii , and the other stars , which are still red ; so that I do not see how his evidence can be disputed .
There is , however , one objection to what I have said , but I , think , not an unanswerable one ; which is , that , at first sight , Hyginus seems to call Sirius white : but since , if so , he contradicts the other authors I have above quoted to prove it red , and , because he there says something I do not well understand , I shall quote the whole .
Hygini Poetic Astron. II .
35 .
Canis habet in lingua stellam unam , quae ipsa Canis appellatur ; in capite autem alteram , quam Isis suo nomine statuisse existimatur , et Sirion appellasse propter flammae candorem ; quod ejusmodi sit , ut praeter caeteras lucere videatur , itaque quo magis eam cognoscerent , Sirion appellasse .
He again distinguishes these two stars , lib. III .
34 .
Canis habet in lingua stellam unam , quae Canis appellatur , in capite autem alteram , quam nonnulli Sirion appellant , de quo prius diximus .
Of two stars in the Dog 's head , Isis and Sirius , Eratosthenes also speaks : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Hyginus , in distinguishing Canis from Sirius as two different stars , seems , to me , to contradict all other writers , who speak of them as one , except , perhaps , two or three latter ones , who directly quote Hyginus 's words .
Sirius , or Canis , the brightest star in the heavens , is that , which Ptolemy calls in the mouth ; Eratosthenes and Hyginus , in the tongue : but whether Bayer ~ , which Flamstead calls a third magnitude star , Ptolemy only a fourth , was in more ancient times larger , I will not pretend to say ; since , Eratosthenes and Hyginus both speak of two stars in the Dog 's head , as thought worthy of particular names .
If , in Hyginus , flammae candorem means the whiteness of its light , as candor often does , he expressly contradicts what I have quoted above from others ; yet still I think Ptolemy 's authority is greater than that of Hyginus .
But that candor is also used for innocence , beauty , brightness , &amp;c. take the following examples .
Bis senis equis candore eximio trahentibus .
Suet .
Caes .
Octav .
94 .
Si tamen ille prior , quo me sine crimine gessi Candor Ovid .
Epist .
IV .
31 .
formae nisi candor .
Metam .
I. 743 .
Candore noto reddas judicium peto .
Phaedrus .
III .
Prol .
64 .
Pendebant ex auribus infignes candore et magnitudine Lapilli .
Quint .
Curt .
IX .
4 .
Ut cum videmus speciem primum , candoremque caeli .
Cic .
Tusc .
Quast .
I. 28 .
Solis candor illustrior quam ullus ignis .
De Not .
Deor .
II .
15 .
In the second or third last quotation , candor is used in the same sense as in Hyginus , for brightness , without regard to colour ; for so , I think , he must be understood , not only to avoid contradiction between him and Ptolemy , but from the name Sirius , which it could not be called from its whiteness , ~~ bearing no relation to that , but to brightness , heat , or dryness ; all which the ancients speak of , as properties of the Dog star .
Again , it is brightness , wherein it excells all other stars , and not in whiteness ; for Orion 's foot and others are as white , but there is none so bright as the Dog star .
All this is said , on supposition there was but one remarkable star in the Dog 's head , that in the mouth : for if there were two , as Hyginus says , we are not here concerned with either the brightness or colour of his Sirion , which was in the head , as it certainly faded before Ptolemy 's time , who mentions only one , that in the mouth , and which , he says , was then red , but is now white .
To conclude the whole ; however remarkable and without precedent it may be , that so noted and lasting a star as the Great Dog should have changed its colour , yet as at least five different writers affirm it , some so expressly , and where their subject required them to speak particularly about it , it appears to me to have been certainly the case .
If , however , any one , startled at the strangeness of the thing , thinks the evidence I have brought insufficient to prove it , he is desired to invalidate what I have here said , by a deduction of fresh evidence , and to account for these several expressions in old authors , which seem to prove , that such a change has really happened .

