XXXVI .
New Experiments and Observations concerning Electricity ; by Robert Symmer , Esq ; F. R. S. PAPER I. Of the Electricity of the human Body , and the Animal Substances , Silk and Wool .
I had for some time observed , that upon pulling off my stockings in an evening they frequently made a crackling or snapping noise ; and in the dark I could perceive them to emit sparks of fire .
I made no doubt but that this proceeded from a principle of electricity ; and I was confirmed in this opinion , by observing that , in weather favourable for electrical experiments , those appearances were more remarkable than at other times .
I mentioned this observation to several of my friends , and some of them told me , they likewise had often perceived the snapping , and the emission of fire from their stockings upon pulling them off , especially in the winter evenings : but I could not hear of any body that had taken this phenomenon into consideration in a philosophical way .
For my own part , I could not but think that so striking an appearance , one that seems to have an immediate connexion with the human body , or is at least as much about us as the cloaths we wear , and is obvious to the perception of our senses , merited not only a philosophical attention , but the strictest inquiry possible .
I was the more in4 duced Read Feb. 1 .
duced to such an inquiry , as it seemed to me to open a new path for proceeding in electrical researches , and might perhaps throw new light on the great and surprising discoveries already made in that branch of natural philosophy .
The simplicity of the apparatus , and the great facility in making the proper experiments , putting it in my power to begin and carry on my enquiry at pleasure , I entered upon somewhat of a regular course of observations about the beginning of November last ; and since that time have pursued it as closely as my leisure , and the weather , which has been far from favourable for electrical experiments , would permit .
It is the purpose of this , and of those papers that may follow , to lay before the Royal Society an account of the experiments and observations I have already made , or may hereafter be able to make , in the progress of this inquiry .
My first endeavour was to discover what sort of stockings was most proper to produce electricity .
In order to determine this , I tried single stockings of different kinds , viz. thread , cotton , silk , and worsted , putting them on , and wearing them some time .
On pulling them off , I could perceive nothing of electricity in the thread or cotton , and no remarkable degree of it in the silk and worsted .
When I say no remarkable degree of it , it may be proper to be a little more explicit .
I must therefore observe , that silk and worsted , being in themselves electric , are both of them , especially silk , extremely susceptible of electricity .
I have sometimes observed , particularly when the weather was favourable , that silk , when but barely handled , nay , when but simply touched , has become electrical where it had been handled or touched , as appeared by its attracting little light balls suspended by threads .
It cannot therefore be supposed that silk or worsted stockings can be put upon the leg , without being excited to a sensible degree of electricity .
And thence it is , that when taken off they are sometimes perceived to snap , though worn single .
But whatever electricity the single stocking acquires by friction or otherwise , it immediately loses upon being separated from the leg : if any electric virtue remains , it is no more than what belongs to it as an electric substance ceasing to be excited ; and it is in so small a degree , as in the present case not to merit attention .
In general , when I speak of the electricity in question , I mean such a power of electricity as is obvious , and perceptible to the senses ; so that the stocking , after being taken off , should appear more or less inflated ; throw out an electrical wind to be felt by the bare leg ; attract or repel another stocking visibly ; and , upon the touch , snap , and emit , or receive electrical fire .
After making the experiment above-mentioned with single stockings , I proceeded to try the effect of two stockings upon one leg .
This I did with two of thread , cotton , worsted , and silk successively ; but this produced no electrical appearance more than before .
I then combined them one with another , and , running through all the different changes , I found that none of those I then made use of exhibited visible proofs of electricity , but the silk and worsted together ; and there , indeed , the electric power appeared remarkably strong .
It seemed to be a matter of indifference whether the silk or the worsted was uppermost , the combination of the two was what I judged to be essential ; and happening at that time to wear silk stockings with thin worsted under them , I kept to the use of these , and found it a convenient circumstance in the course of my experiments .
As some may have the curiosity to examine the observations I present them with , by experiments of their own making ; before I proceed further , I shall furnish them with a few remarks , which may enable them to make their experiments with more ease and certainty , than if they set out unacquainted with some circumstances , which I have learnt from experience .
One of the first things to be attended to , is the weather , which has an influence on all electrical experiments , but upon none more than those which relate to this branch of electricity .
The most favourable weather is that which is dry and clear , and , if a little frosty , so much the better .
In general , when the quicksilver in the barometer rises , and the fire burns remarkably brisk and clear , we may expect a considerable appearance of electricity : at other times , it is better not to attempt the experiment .
When the weather is favourable , it is not necessary to wear the stockings all day : That , indeed , raises the electrical power to the highest degree ; yet , provided they be dry , and made warm by the fire , before they are put upon the leg , their continuance upon it for a very short time , prepares them sufficiently for exhibiting visible proofs of electricity .
If this should not answer upon the first trial , the operation may be repeated two or three times , to bring them into a proper disposition to receive the electrical virtue ; and this is no more than what is found to be sometimes necessary necessary with respect to glass globes and tubes , especially when new .
If the stockings have once acquired this disposition , they retain it for the day , or until a change of weather , and the experiment may be repeated with success as often as one pleases ; for no sooner are they discharged of their electricity , than they are ready to receive it anew ; nay , if speedily returned upon the leg , they catch it instantaneously , and may immediately be pulled off to exhibit a new explosion : what is still more surprising , they seem to gather force by the frequency of the repetition , and , to some certain degree , increase in electrical power , provided they be all along kept warm and dry , and that the leg continue warm .
Another circumstance to be carefully attended to , is the manner in which they are to be taken off ; for as to the putting of them on , it is a matter of indifference how that is performed .
In taking them off , care must be had not to separate them ; for if that happens in pulling them off , all the electricity escapes .
The best way , is to put the hand between the leg and the stockings , and push them off together .
Nothing more remains to be done , than to pull them asunder ; for upon that , they both of them exhibit a degree of electricity , which , when at the highest , is really surprising .
Before I conclude these occasional remarks , it may not be improper to observe , that it is not absolutely necessary that the stockings be applied to the bare leg ; if a fine thread stocking separate them from the leg , though left upon it when they are taken off , it does not much impair their electricity .
But it is more convenient to use the hand instead of the leg .
The insertion of the hand into the stockings , is alone sufficient , especially in favourable weather , to communicate such an electric power , as renders them capable of answering expectation , in such experiments as I have had occasion to make *.-I now return to my subject .
The opinion I had conceived , that the combination of silk and worsted was necessary for the production of electricity , seemed to meet with confirmation from all the experiments I made with the stockings I then wore .
I was at that time in mourning , so that my silk stockings were black , and under them I constantly wore thin white worsted .
About the latter end of November I went out of mourning , and of course changed the colour of my stockings .
On the second of December , having put on a pair of white silk above the worsted , after I had wore them some hours , I resolved to amuse myself with a few experiments .
The weather was remarkably favourable , and I had reason to expect a fine appearance of electricity : but upon taking off my stockings , and pulling them asunder , to my great astonishment , I found they discovered no signs of electrical power ; as I * An improvement may perhaps be made upon this , by getting a piece of silk or worsted knit , or wove in the stocking loom , so that without being cut , it may be formed into the shape of long mittens or sleeves , or rather into what we might call a silk or worsted tube .
The reason why it ought to be knit , or wove in the stocking loom , is , that it may better embrace the hand or arm ; and likewise , that it may be more retentive of electric virtue , which would escape more easily from a piece of silk or worsted wove in the common loom , and cut with a number of ends of threads exposed , than from any thing formed in the fashion of chain work , and consisting of one single thread of silk or worsted .
held them in my hands they hung down collapsed , and did not more attract one another , than before they were put upon my leg .
I repeated the experiment two or three times , but with no better success , An event I so little expected , disconcerted me much .
I saw I was no longer to ascribe electricity to the combination of silk and worsted ; but I remained at a loss to know to what I should ascribe it .
At last , upon considering the circumstances of this and other experiments , a conjecture occurred , that the electricity in question might depend upon the nature of different colours .
In order to determine this , I thought it fairest to make the trial in the same substances .
Accordingly I had recourse to the following experiment .
I took a pair of white silk stockings , and having warmed them at the fire put them both upon the same leg .
After I had worn them about ten minutes , I took them off , and pulled them asunder , but discovered no signs of electricity in either .
I did the same with a pair of black silk , but to no other effect .
I then proceeded to the decisive trial .
I put a black and a white stocking upon my leg , and wore them likewise ten minutes .
I waited with some impatience to see the success of my experiment , and in return had the satisfaction of observing , upon their being pulled asunder , that each of them had acquired a stronger degree of electricity than I had before seen : they were inflated so much , that each of them showed the entire shape of the leg , and at the distance of a foot and a half they rushed to meet each other .
I went through the same experiment with worsted stockings , and found that , as in silk , nothing but the combination of black and white produced electricity .
As I had often experienced the power of electricity in the combination of black silk with white worsted stockings , there remained to try but that of white silk with black worsted , which answered as I expected , and seemed to complete the demonstration .
A phenomenon so new , and of so curious a nature as this experiment presented , could not but for some time engage my attention .
I saw , that if this appearance did not arise from some accidental or collateral cause , correspondent effects would follow , upon the combinations of the intermediate degrees of light and shade , between the extremes of white and black .
I have had a particular attention to this in the experiments I have since had occasion to make , and so far as I have yet been able to go , it appears to answer my expectation .
Nevertheless , as this is a matter that merits a more minute examination , we may hereafter take it up as an immediate object of inquiry ; with a view to determine , if light and colours have , of their own nature , a relation with electricity , and in what that relation consists .
In the mean while I shall pursue my principal design , which is to investigate from experiments the nature of that electric virtue , with which the animal substances under consideration appear to be endued .
I have already made some progress , farther than what is contained in this paper ; and I shall continue to follow the views that seem naturally to open to my inquiry .
If I make any discoveries , or come at any conclusions that may merit the attention of the curious , they shall , together with the experiments on which they depend , be submitted to the judgment of this learned Society .
New Experiments and Observations concerning Electricity .
PAPER II .
Of the Electricity of black and white Silk .
IN my former paper , I gave the Society an account of some experiments , made with silk and worsted stockings ; by which it appeared , that the remarkable degree of electricity they had acquired , by being put upon the leg , depended on their being of different colours , namely , black and white .
I did not then , nor do I yet , take upon me to determine the cause of this phenomenon .
Whether it be owing to light , which is the origin of colours ; or only to the ingredients , which enter into the composition of the several dyes ; or to those conjunctly with the colours they produce : in any of these views the matter is curious , and equally merits a careful inquiry.-But I fear the solution of this , and of many other difficult questions concerning electricity , will depend upon the establishment of a more persect theory than we have yet attained to .
Till we shall be so fortunate as to discover the nature and properties of the powers employed in these operations , we must be satisfied to pursue the path of experiment and observation , in quest of those , as first principles .
This is the method I shall continue to follow ; and having already shown the manner of electrifying the black and the white stocking , it is now my purpose to give an account of the appearances and powers of that electricity so excited .
Read May 17 , 1759 .
Having made a great number of experiments since I had the honour of presenting my former paper to the Society , I have had an opportunity of observing , that the electricity produced between black and white silk , is stronger than that between silk and worsted of those different colours , and a great deal stronger than that between worsted and worsted : the last is so weak , except in time of frost , or when a sharp north-east wind blows , that tho ' the effects are always of the same nature , yet they are sometimes so languid as to be scarce perceptible .
I shall therefore , and for the sake of brevity , confine myself , in this paper , to what is observeable with regard to the electricity between black and white silk .
It is proper to mention another circumstance : having found it troublesome to electrify the stockings , by putting them as often on my leg as was requisite in making experiments , I have quitted that method entirely ; and satisfy myself with the degree of electricity which is excited in the stockings by drawing them upon the hand : and this is to be understood with regard to all the experiments and observations I may have occasion to mention , unless when otherwise expressed .
The electricity thus produced is not equally powerful with that which is excited by means of the leg ; but it is nevertheless sufficiently strong to answer all the purposes in view ; and it is attended with this advantage , that the stockings continue longer fit for these experiments : for , like other electrical aparatus 's , they must be kept clean , and free from all extraneous matter ; and are therefore most to be depended upon when new , or when newly washed .
To give a distinct account of the electricity of black and white silk , I shall trace it through its whole process , beginning before the stockings of the different colours are put together .
After being a little aired at the fire , when the black silk is drawn single upon the hand , a crackling noise is heard~ ; and in the dark , sparks of fire may be perceived as passing between the hand and the stocking : while it is drawn backwards and forwards the crackling continues , and is most considerable upon the separation of the stocking from the hand .
Thus it appears , that black silk is highly susceptible of electricity ; that it is produced almost instantaneously , or at least with very little friction ; that most of it escapes , while the stocking is yet upon the hand ; and that , upon the total separation , very little remains .
This is similar to what happens with the glass tube , when the hand , after passing along it in one direction , repasses it in the other .
But still the electricity that the stocking retains , after it is separated from the hand , is considerable enough to attract or repel little light bodies at the distance of one or two feet : some degree of inflation in the stocking is likewise perceiveable ; and when a non-electric is brought near it , a crackling is heard , and in the dark sparks may be seen .
If two black stockings be drawn upon the hand at a time , the appearances are much the same as before ; only that the stockings , when taken off and separated , give smaller proofs of electricity , than if each of them had been single upon the hand .
Having found it necessary , as I proceeded in my course of experiments , to fix upon some method of ascertaining the principal appearances of electricity , and marking the degree of it , I had recourse to the little pocket electrometer of Mr. Canton 's contrivance , which is described in Vol. XLVIII .
No. 93 .
of the Transactions of this Society .
When this instrument is supported by glass , it not only shows the attraction and repulsion , in general , of electrified bodies , which is one of the most essential properties of electricity , but it distinguishes between the positive and negative state of electricity , according to the reciprocal attraction or repulsion of the little balls .
By the terms positive and negative , I mean only to denote the opposition of the two different states .
The particular allotment of the one or the other term appears to me to be arbitrary ; but that I may not differ unnecessarily from others , I shall apply the word positive to that state , in which a body is found to be , when electrified by the clear glass tube , rubbed by the hand ; and the word negative , when electrified by the rough or opaque glass tube , of Mr. Canton 's invention ( described in the Transaction mentioned above ) , when rubbed in the same manner , or by sulphur or wax excited .
In other words , when the body is in a state of repulsion with the former of those tubes , we say it is positively electrified , and negatively when in a state of repulsion with the latter , or with sulphur or wax .
Nothing appears to be more wonderful than this double state : here electricity seems to counteract itself , the electrified body attracting in the one , what it would repel in the other case , and vice versa .
As this remarkable property may be traced , in its consequences , through almost all electrical appearances , I cannot but think it merits great attention , and , when it comes to be better understood , may throw much light upon the system of electricity .
However that may be , it was impossible for me not to observe , that it runs through the whole of that branch , which I have at present under examination , and to which I return .
White silk differs much in electricity from black silk .
When the white stocking is drawn separately upon the hand , no crackling is heard , nor sparks of fire seen in the dark , let it be pulled backward and forward ever so often : when another white stocking is drawn on above it , nothing more appears : and , when separated from the hand , neither of them discovers any sings of electricity , excepting that , when brought within a few inches of the electrometer , they attract and repel the balls a little .
If instead of two white or two black stockings , one white , and over that , a black stocking be drawn upon the hand , they discover not the least signs of electricity while they continue upon the hand , even tho ' they should be drawn backwards and forwards upon it several times ; nor , when taken together from the hand , and presented to the electrometer , do they appear to have acquired any more than a very small degree of electricity .
They must be brought within the distance of a foot , nay , sometimes of a few inches , before they have any effect upon the balls : but the moment they are separated , they are found to be both of them highly electrified , the white positively , and the black negatively .
The circumstances , that appear the most to merit observation , are as follow : 10.-When the electrometer is palced on a nonelectric , and the black stocking is presented to it at the distance of 3 , 4 , or 5 feet , according as it happens to be more or less powerfully electrified , the balls begin to be visibly attracted , and when it is brought nearer , they are seen to be agitated in a violent manner .
If , instead of the black , the white stocking be presented at the same distances , it is found to have precisely the same effects , attracting and agitating the balls in the very same manner : From whence it appears , that whatever difference there was between the electricity of the black and the white , under other circumstances , they each of them acquire an equal degree of electricity , by being electrified together .
20.-When the electrometer is supported by glass , and the white stocking is presented to it , it first attracts the balls , and afterwards repels them ; when taken away , it leaves them in a repulsive state with regard to each other ; when brought back , it repels them as before .
If , in place of the white , the black be now presented , the balls are immediately attracted , soon after again repelled , and left once more in a repulsive state with regard to each other .
If the white be again presented , the same train of effects takes place as before ; and so on , alternately , as in the case of the clear and opaque glass tubes , when excited ; the white stocking answering precisely to the clear , and the black to the opaque tube , and acting the one positively , the other negatively , at full as great a distance , and as forcibly , as the tubes .
30.-Both the stockings , when held at a distance from one another , appear inflated to such a degree , that , when highly electrified , they give the entire shape of the leg ; and when brought near the face , or any naked part of the body , there is a sensation felt , as if a cool wind was blowing upon that part .
When the two white , or the two black , are held together by the extremities , they repel one another , and form an angle , seemingly of 30 or 35 degrees .
40.-When a white and a black stocking are presented to each other , they mutually attract , with a force answerable to the degree of electricity they have acquired : when brought within the distance of three feet , they usually incline towards one another : within two and a half , or two feet , they catch hold of each other ; and when brought nearer , they rush together with surprising violence .
As they approach , their inflation gradually subsides ; and their attraction of foreign objects diminishes : when they meet , they flatten , and join as close together , as if they were so many folds of silk ; and then the balls of the electrometer are not affected at the distance of a foot , nor even of a few inches at certain times .
But what appears most extraordinary , is , that when they are separated , and removed at a sufficient distance from each other , their electricity does not appear to have been in the least impaired by the shock they had in meeting .
They are again inflated , again attract , and repel , and are as ready to rush together as before * .
When * The phenomena , here remarked , of the black stocking and the white when electrified ; namely , that , as they approach one another , their attractive and repulsive force decreases , with regard to foreign objects , but increases surprisingly , with regard to each other ; and that their electricity suffers no diminution from the When this experiment is performed with two black stockings in one hand , and two white in the other , it exhibits a very curious spectacle : The repulsion of those of the same colour , and the attraction.of those of different colours , throws them into an agitation that is not unentertaining , and makes them catch each at that of its opposite colour , at a greater distance than one would expect .
When allowed to come together , they all unite in one mass ; when separated , they resume their former appearance , and admit of the repetition of the experiment as often as you please ; till their electricity , gradually wasting , stands in need of being recruited .
50.-When they are separated from one another , they lose their power very soon , much as the excited tube does ; but when they are together , they will retain it for an hour or two , and longer , when the air is in a state favourable for electricity .
While they are asunder , and any non-electric is brought near them ; if that non-electric is of a broad surface , it is with difficulty they are discharged of their electricity ; but if the point of any , especially of a metallic , body , be presented , they are instantaneously deprived of their electrical virtue : but if they be in conjunction together , they retain their electricity with so much obstinacy , that even the sharpest point of metal cannot deprive them of it .
In this , and in some shock of their congress , appear to me to be observations new in electricity , and to merit attention .
They seem to point out a retentive power of electricity , which takes place between electrics and electrics only ; and which , I apprehend , may be found to be the cause of many curious and singular phenomena .
other respects , there appears to be such a resemblance between the Leyden phial , or the electrical pane of glass , and the black stocking in conjunction with the white , especially when the one is within the other , that I have been induced to consider them both in the same light .
In both cases , the positive electricity is on the one side , and the negative on the other ; and the stockings , as well as the phial , and the pane of glass , are at once electrified positively and negatively .
In both cases there is an accumulation of electricity , and a retention of it , far beyond what is to be met with in a simple body , electric or non-electric .
There is , however , a very remarkable difference between them in two respects .
In the phial , and in the pane of glass , an explosion is always obtained by carrying on a communication between the two sides by the interposition of a non-electric ; but , in the case of the black stocking and the white , I never yet have been able to procure an explosion , nor so much as a speedy discharge , by any means I could think of , while the one was within the other .
I have put one hand within the innermost , and with my other have clasped the outward stocking ; nay , I have thrust in my hand , and turned the stockings inside out , and , in that condition , have dashed them against the floor ; and all this without procuring the least perceptible discharge .
On the other hand , the phial and the pane of glass afford no opportunity of separating the positive from the negative electricity , so as to show them entire and distinct from each other ; whereas we need only pull the stockings asunder , and then in the white we find the positive , and in the black the negative electricity .
60.-When the stockings are separated , and in the dark , upon presenting to them the point of one 's finger , or any small metallic body , rounded at the end .
they exhibit the appearance of electrical fire or light , according to the negative or positive state of the stocking the object is presented to .
With the black , at the distance of two or three inches , there appears to dart from the end of one 's finger a sprig or pencil , as it were , of fiery sparks , which dilates in its progress , and strikes against the surface of the stocking : at the same time a crackling , or snapping noise , is heard .
When the first discharge is made , upon presenting the finger to a fresh part of the stocking , the same phenomenon is repeated , till you have traversed the whole length of the stocking , which , when the finger moves slowly , usually yields eight or ten distinct discharges , before it is divested of its electricity .
With regard to the white stocking , the same appearances hold ; but with this difference , that , instead of sparks of fire issuing from the finger , a little globule of white or blueish light is seen at the point of it ; and , when the electricity is strong , that little body of light seems to break in an explosion between the stocking and the finger ; and rather a hissing than a crackling noise is heard .
70.-The electrical phial may be charged by the stockings , either positively or negatively , according as the wire from the neck of the phial is presented to the white or the black ; and in the one , or the other case , the hissing , or the crackling noise , is louder than when any common wire , or non-electric body , is presented : but if the electricity of the white stocking be thrown into the phial , and upon that the electricity of the black , or vice versa ; in that case , the phial will not be electrified at all .
The charging of the phial was among the first of my experiments with electrified stockings .
By some trials I made in the month of December last , I found it would succeed .
One frosty evening in that month , having thrown into a small phial , filled with quicksilver , the electricity of one black stocking , I received from the explosion a smart blow upon my finger .
With the electricity of two stockings , the blow reached both my elbows ; and , by the means of four , I kindled spirits of wine in a tea-spoon , which I held in my hand , and , at the same time , I felt the blow from my elbows to my breast .
It may not , however , be improper to observe , that the electricity , in this case , was excited by means of the leg .
From what hath been said in the preceding pages , it is evident , that all the remarkable appearances of electricity , hitherto discovered , may be exhibited by a simple apparatus of black and white silk .
But this is not all : in the course of experiments above-mentioned , something curious has occurred to my observation , of which I do not find that any notice has been taken by others.-What I mean is , a strong cohesion produced by electricity .
But as this paper is already extended to a great length , I shall reserve the account of electrical cohesion for another , which I shall soon have the honour of presenting to the Society .
New Experiments and Observations concerning Electricity .
PAPER III .
Of Electrical Cohesion .
A Ccording to what I promised in the conclusion of my last paper , I come in this to give the Society an account of cohesion produced by electricity .
I had not made any great progress , in the series of experiments and observations I have already had the honour to communicate , before I perceived that the black and white stocking , when electrified , and allowed to come together , not only joined extremely close , but actually stuck to each other ; insomuch that unless when weak in electricity , or improperly applied , I could make the white bear the weight of the black , or the black that of the white , and that for a considerable time .
But as the weather , for some months in winter , was so seldom favourable for electrical experiments , that I had scarcely opportunities sufficient to satisfy myself with regard to other points , I did not enter upon an examination of this phenomenon experimentally , till about the latter end of March .
By that time , I had got ready the scale of a balance properly fitted with a hook to catch hold of the stocking , a set of Troyweights I could depend upon , and an exact pair of scales , to take the precise weight of the stockings as occasion should require .
Read June 21 , 1759 .
By experience I found that the same pair of stockings did not always do equally well , even independently of the weather ; and that , by being too frequently electrified at a time , their virtue appeared to diminish .
I therefore judged it proper to be provided with changes of pairs ; and that there might be the greater conformity between the experiments , I chose them as exactly as possible of the same size and substance .
The sort I fixed upon , is what is called half gauze ; the weight of the white stocking , at an average , 18 dwt .
and 10 gr. but when died black , 1 oz. and 1 dwt .
the weight being increased , by the dying of that colour , above 5 dwt .
in the pair .
When the white and the black stocking were warmed at the fire , so as to be prepared for electricity , they usually lost about a twentieth part of their weight ; so that in the course of my experiments I rate the white at 17 pwt .
and 1/ 2 , and the black at 1 oz. The scale , with the silk lines that belonged to it , and the hook , was adjusted precisely to the weight of 1 oz ; and as I commonly measured the strength of cohesion by fixing the hook to the black stocking , and taking hold of the white , I had but to make an allowance of 2 oz. more than the weights put into the scale , so as to take the precise weight the stockings could raise by the power of cohesion .
I measured this power two different ways ; the first whilst the one stocking was still within the other ; secondly , when separated , and the one afterwards applied externally to the other .
In the first of these cases , it may be thought that an allowance should be made for the friction in pulling the stockings asunder ; but that appeared to me to be very inconsiderable ; for when those of the same colour were put one within the other , and inverted , they dropped asunder of themselves ; or if there was any intanglement about the heel , a little shaking disengaged and separated them : however , if it should be thought proper , the allowance of an ounce may be made , by deducting so much from the weight respectively found .
I have but one circumstance more to mention , before I proceed to give the result of my experiments ; which is , that we must not be surprised , when we find the force of cohesion externally , to be in no regular proportion with that within ; for when the stockings are highly electrified , they rush together with such impetuosity , that it is extremely difficult to direct their motion , and make them meet in the manner most advantageous for cohesion .
In the experiments I have made , to measure the force of electrical cohesion , I have always found it answerable , so far as I could judge from appearances , to the degree of electricity at the time excited .
When the stockings have been but weakly electrified , I have found them unable to support the weight , the one of the other .
When in a more powerful state of electricity , I have known them to raise , respectively , from one to twelve ounces , and upwards ; nay , once I found the cohesion so strong as to move seventeen ounces , including the scale and the black stocking .
For the sake of accuracy , I shall give a particular account of the result of a few of my most remarkable experiments , as I find them in the notes , which I took at the time of making them .
The first I find is of the 30th of March ; the wind at north-east ; the weather clear , inclining to frost .
The white stocking within the black , raised the weight of 1 lb. 1 oz. 6 dwt .
1/ 2 , half a pennyweight more separated them .
I find no note here taken of the weight born by the stockings applied externally to each other .
April 6 .
A hazy and wet morning ; but the wind at north-east .
With new stockings ; the white , being within the black , raised 11 oz.-without , 6 oz. With another pair , that had been much used in experiments ; the white , within , raised 6 oz.-without , 3 oz. April 16 .
A clear dry morning ; the wind at north-east ; Fahremheit 's thermometer at 48 .
Of the new , the white stocking , within , raised 1 lb. 5 oz.-without , 6 oz. 15 dwt.-Of the old , the white stocking , within , raised 8 oz.-without , 5 oz. 15 dwt .
The last observation I find marked , is of the 19th of May ; the weather clear ; the wind at north-east ; the thermometer at 55 .
The white , within the black , raised 10 oz. and without , 6 oz. It is to be remarked , that by this time I had got the old stockings washed ; and now there appeared little or no difference between the power of them and of the newer pairs ; though the latter had still the advantage .
In making the experiments , it was necessary to lose as little time as possible , on account of the waste of electricity : I could therefore seldom proceed to the accuracy of fractions of a penny weight ; nor often indeed of those of an ounce ; and this is the reason that my notes run generally in round numbers , which , however , may be depended upon .
The greatest weight I have been able to raise by the force of electrical cohesion , as appears above , has been seventeen ounces .
Now the white stocking , which weighed but 17 dwt .
and an half , bore all this weight : in this case therefore it raised , by the strength of its cohesion with the black , 340 pennyweight ; that is , nearly twenty times its own weight * .
And if we consider that the force , applied to separate them , acted in a direction parallel to the surfaces , by which they cohered ; and that when the surfaces are smooth , a force acting in such direction , has much greater influence in separating bodies , by making them slide gently over one another , than if those bodies were rigid , and the force employed to separate them acted in a direction perpendicular to the cohering surfaces ; * As the experiments mentioned above were made in the space of six or seven weeks from about the latter end of March , when the temperature of the air begins to be less favourable for electricity , I did not doubt , but upon the approach , and during the progress of the ensuing winter , I should meet with instances of a stronger degree of cohesion , than I had before been able to ascertain .
Accordingly , since this paper was read in the Royal Society , and particularly in the months of November , December , and January last , at times , when the weather was clear and frosty , I found that the same stockings lifted considerably more , than I had been able to make them do in the preceding months of March , April , and May .
I likewise found , that when the stockings were perfectly new , or the black dipped afresh , and the white newly cleaned and sulphured , as also , that when they were of a more substantial make , such as those that are wove of spun silk , weighing commonly about the double of those that go by the name of half gauze , their power of cohesion , when favoured by the temperature of the air , increases to a very considerable degree .
Under those circumstances , at particular times , I have been able to make the black stocking , or the white , when the rough sides of each were put together , raise ( the half gauze ) from 20 to 40 , and ( of spun silk ) from 40 to 90 times its own weight .
Vide the subsequent letter from Dr. John Mitchell to the Rev. Dr. Birch .
when we consider this , I say , it will be hard to determine how great the strength of their cohesion may be .
The experiment may be tried with two plates of glass , the one electrified positively , the other negatively .
As in that case the principle , upon which the cohesion of the white with the black silk depends , would take place , I make no manner of doubt but the effect would be the same .
I have not had an opportunity of trying the experiment : but I should expect that the two plates would be found to cohere with greater force , than I have been able to ascertain in the stockings ; as a contrivance might be made to pull them asunder in a direction perpendicular to their cohering surfaces .
The force with which the black and the white stocking cohere , is not the only thing remarkable in their junction .
The solution of that cohesion , and the different degrees of tenacity , according to different circumstances , afford some curious observations .
When the black and the white stocking are in cohesion with each other , if another pair , more highly electrified , be separated , and presented to the former still in conjunction , the black to the white , and the white to the black ; in that case , the cohesion of the first pair will be dissolved , and each stocking of the second , will carry off that of its opposite colour adhering to it .
If the degree of electricity of both pairs be equal , the cohesion of the first pair will be weakened , but not dissolved ; and all the four will cohere , forming as it were one mass .
If the second pair be but weakly electrified , the cohesion of the first pair with one another will be but little impaired , ed , and that of the stockings of the second with those of the first , will be weak in proportion .
And lastly , if the second pair be not at all electrified , or if , in their place , any other body not electrified be presented , there will be no effect produced on either hand .
White silk and black , when electrified , not only cohere with each other in the manner shown above , but when in a high degree of electricity , are found , both one and the other , to adhere to bodies of broad and even , or polished surfaces , though those bodies be not electrified .
This adhesion I discovered accidentally .
While I was about some electrical experiments , having , without design , thrown a stocking , that was highly electrified , hastily out of my hand , I was surprised to find it some time after , sticking against the paper-hangings of my room .
This led me to make the following experiments .
I presented the white and the black silk , highly electrified , and in cohesion with each other , to the hangings ; but no effect was produced .
I then separated the black from the white , and presented them singly ; in that case each of them readily adhered to the hangings , which they likewise did when flung from a little distance , and continued there for near an hour before they dropped .
Having stuck up the black and the white , in the manner above-mentioned , I came with another pair of stockings highly electrified , and applying the white to the black , and the black to the white , I carried them off from the wall hanging on those that had been applied to them .
When the second pair were electrified , but to a moderate degree , on applying them , in the manner above described , the former immediately quitted their hold of the hangings , and dropped to the ground .
The same experiments held with the painted boards of the room ; and likewise with the looking-glass ; to the last of which , both the black and the white silk , appeared to adhere more tenaciously , than to either of the former .
I am afraid I have presumed too much on the patience of the Society , by giving so full a detail of my experiments and observations , on a branch of electricity , that takes its rise from so singular , and so mean a subject as that of black and white silk : But however particular the subject may be , the properties of electricity that are thence experimentally deduced are of a general nature , and must find a place in every true system of electricity .
If any apology be wanted , the best I can make , is to endeavour to draw such inferences from the experiments above recited , as may possibly throw new light upon the theory of electricity .
But lest I should swell this paper to too large a size ; and as the season is at hand when the Society usually adjourns for some months ; I think it best to defer any matter I may have to offer , concerning the theory of electricity , till a convenient time after our next meeting .
I shall only beg leave at present , to mention one or two things , which I have not hitherto had a proper opportunity of throwing out .
It hath been said , that the influence of colours in electricity is no new discovery ; that Mons. Du Fay had treated at large upon the subject ; and , after a variety of experiments , had concluded , that colours , as such , had no effect in electricity ; but that whatever was was remarkable in that way , was owing to the change , which the ingredients of the dye produced upon the coloured body .
I had not then seen what Mons. Du Fay wrote upon the subject ; but as I have since , I shall take the liberty to state this matter fairly .
The late Mons. Du Fay , an ingenious member of the Academy of Sciences at Paris , to whom we owe some valuable discoveries in electricity , gives an account of what is here alluded to , in a memoir , presented in the year 1733 .
Electricity was at that time in its infancy ; Mr. Hawksbee had , but a little before , published an account of his experiments ; which brought such surprising appearances of electricity to light , as could not but induce the curious to turn their eyes upon that subject .
In the course of those experiments , he had taken notice of something remarkable with regard to colours .
Mr. Gray succeeded , and having opened a new path , made still further discoveries in electricity : he likewise , in giving an account of what he had observed , hinted at something curious with regard to colours .
But neither of them appear to have come to any determined point in this matter .
Mons. Du Fay , who concurred with Mr. Gray , in carrying on electrical discoveries , with a candour and ingenuity that did honour to them both , having entered upon an enquiry ( the subject of the memoir above-mentioned ) to determine what sort of bodies were most susceptible of electricity , thought proper , in consequence of what had fallen from Mr. Hawksbee and Mr. Gray , to examine what effect the different colours had in augmenting or diminishing the electricity of different substances .
Accordingly he ranged a number of ribbands , of all the primitive colours , hanging them in the same vertical plane ; and to these he applied an excited glass tube , in an horizontal direction.-Upon this he observed , that the black was first attracted ; and , as he brought the tube nearer , the white next ; and the rest successively , though not always in the same order .
He made another experiment , in the same view , with gauzes of different colours , through which he tried the force of an excited tube , upon light bodies placed at a proper distance behind them : and from the result he was of opinion , there was something in the influence of colours .
But having afterwards tried some experiments with the coloured rays of the sun as refracted by a prism , with flowers of different colours , and with white ribbands rubbed over with differently coloured substances , he began to change his opinion .
He likewise had recourse to what he calls a decisive experiment : he dipped his different-coloured ribbands in water ; and when they were all equally wetted , he applied his tube , and found they were all equally ` attracted .
From this last-mentioned experiment , in particular , he concluded that colours , as colours , had no effect in electricity ; but that all was owing to the ingredients of the dye imbided by the coloured body .
It is not my purpose here to inquire , whether Mons. Du Fay 's conclusion is well or ill founded .
Whatever may be the decision of that point , I apprehend the whole of this affair hath very little concern with what hath been the subject of these papers , and could have been of little use to me , had I been acquainted with it before .
The series of my experiments , however inconsiderable they may prove in the result , have taken a turn I did not at first foresee .
I set out with inquiring into the nature of an electricity , that seemed to have some connexion with the human body : I had made but little progress when I was surprised with an appearance of electricity , arising from the contrast of two colours , or coloured bodies of the same substance : I met with it in my experiments , perpetually positive and negative ; and under that appearance have followed it through a variety of its operations .
The notions it hath led me to conceive , are different from those I had before entertained of electricity .
Such as they are , they shall , in due time , be freely submitted to the judgment of the Society .
Having been told by one or two of my friends , that they had tried some of the experiments mentioned in the preceding papers , but could not get them to succeed ; I beg leave to add a few words , before I conclude , by way of caution to any , who may have a curiosity to verify my experiments .
However easy it may seem to be , to follow the directions I have already given in electrifying the stocking , I am sensible from my own experience , that an attention to a number of little circumstances , besides some small degree of address , is requisite , in order to make it succeed readily .
This is known to have been the case with the electrical tube and globe : few people , at first , knew how to manage them successfully ; and yet glass is not so much exposed to many inconveniences , that affect electricity , as silk .
To give but one instance of this : we know that a very small quantity of dust , grease , or any other matter that sticks to the tube , will injure its electricity : Now this is what may easily be wiped off from glass ; but it may be very difficult to clear the silk of it , as silk is of a nature more apt to imbibe , and to retain extraneous matter than glass.-From these considerations , I should not be surprised at any persons being disappointed , as to the success of their experiments , in a few trials ; but I should think it not fair for them to conclude from thence , that those above-recited are not to be depended upon * .
Yet , if any member of the Society , who is curious in these matters , hath not been able to satisfy himself with regard to any particular experiment , I shall think it no trouble to show him , at any proper time , how it succeeds with me .
* The circumstances necessary to be attended to , in order to procure the most considerable appearance of electricity , are as follow .
10 .
That the wind be in the north , north east , or east ; the weather clear and frosty , or inclining to frost .
20 .
That the stockings be of silk ; one of a good black , the other of a clear white ; and both of the same size and substance .
30 .
That they be new ; or be kept carefully wrapped up in paper , and only used in electrical experiments .
40 And lastly , That they be dried before the fire , and warmed to about the degree of heat of the human body , before they be drawn upon the hand or leg .
And when taken off , care should be had in separating them , so as to keep them at a distance from one 's clothes , or any thing that may lessen their virtue .
The circumstances above-mentioned , might be gathered from what has been said in these papers ; but I thought it not amiss to bring them together in this note .
New Experiments and Observations concerning Electricity .
PAPER IV .
PART I. Of Two distinct Powers in Electricity .
I Observed , in the papers I have already had the honour of communicating to the Society , that the different state of electricity , as distinguished into positive and negative , was a leading circumstance in all electrical appearances ; and that , if followed out with due attention , it might bring us to a clearer view , than we yet have had , of the powers that nature employs in those wonderful operations .
Nothing could be more proper to serve this purpose , than the simple apparatus I had all along made use of .
It consisted of two electric bodies , of which , when they were excited , one never failed to assume the positive , the other the negative state of electricity .
The observations I had frequent opportunities of making , with regard to the manner in which they acted , in these different states , on other bodies , and on each other reciprocally , confirmed me in a notion , which , in the course of my expriments , I had very early conceived .
Read Dec. 20 , 1759 .
My notion is , that the operations of electricity do not depend upon one single positive power , according to the opinion generally received ; but upon two distinct , positive , and active powers , which , by contrasting , and , as it were , counteracting each other , produce the various phenomena of electricity ; and that , when a body is said to be positively electrified , it is not simply that it is possessed of a larger share of electric matter than in a natural state ; nor , when it is said to be negatively electrified , of a less ; but that , in the former case , it is possessed of a larger portion of one of those active powers , and in the latter , of a larger portion of the other ; while a body , in its natural state , remains unelectrified , from an equal balance of those two powers within it .
I do not here undertake to give a system of electricity .
It is the design of this paper to propose the grounds of my opinion , only so far as it rests upon observation and experiment .
If the proofs I have to offer shall be found conclusive , and it be allowed , that two distinct and counteracting powers prevail in electricity , one of them corresponding with the positive , and the other with the negative state ; in that case , the truth thus established , may afterwards be assumed as a principle in theory ; and we may try how far it will serve in accounting for the various appearances of electricity .
But even then , I should not think of troubling the Society with discussions of so great a length , and of so speculative.a nature , as those usually are that relate to theory .
I might bring arguments to prove the existence of two distinct powers in electricity , from a variety of observations and experiments , some of them taken from among those mentioned in the preceding papers : But as the bounds I prescribe to myself in this , do not permit me to enter upon so large a field , I shall confine myself to such observations only , as have fallen within my notice , in one particular branch of electricity , that which relates to the Leyden phial .
All who allow of positive and negative electricity , know , that the phial , when charged , exhibits electricity in those two states , the one within , the other on the outside ; and that when a communication is made between the two , by the means of a non-electric touching the coating , and at the same time approaching the wire , or vice versa , the explosion is produced , and the phial discharged .
This reduces the question to a narrow compass ; for if , upon the discharge of the phial , we meet with proofs not only of a power acting from within to the outside , but also of a power acting at the same instant from the outside to within , then , I think , we may fairly conclude , that what is called negative electricity is , in reality , a positive active power ; and that electricity , in general , consists not of one alone , but of two distinct , positive powers , acting in contrary directions , and towards each other .
The proof I shall offer first , is founded on the following experiment .
When the phial is electrified but a little , if we touch the coating of it with a finger of one hand , and at the same time approach a finger of the other hand to the wire , we shall receive a pretty smart blow upon the tip of each of the fingers , the sensation of which reaches no farther : If the phial be electrified a degree higher , we shall feel a stronger blow , reaching to the wrists , but no farther : When again it is electrified to a still higher degree , a severer blow will be received ; but will not be felt beyond the elbows : Lastly , when the phial is strongly charged , the stroke may be perceived in the wrists and elbows ; but the principal shock is felt in the breast , as if a blow from each side met there .
This plain and simple experiment seems obviously to suggest to observation , the existence of two distinct powers , acting in contrary directions : And I believe it would be held as a sufficient proof by any who should try the experiment , with a view to determine the question simply from their own perceptions .
But as I am sensible , that the proof of any important point in philosophy , ought not to depend upon the perceptions of this or that particular person , I judged it necessary to have recourse to experiments , the result of which might admit of no ambiguity .
The fortunate discovery of M. Muschenbroek and M. Allamand , with the improvements that have since been made upon it , puts it in our power to increase electricity to what degree we please .
I did not therefore despair of the means of bringing this matter to a fair decision .
I expected , that if an electrical stroke should be made to pass through a solid body , with so much force as to pierce and tear the substance of it , such marks would be left , as might enable us , with certainty , to trace the course of the electrical power in its passage through the body .
Having no apparatus of my own capable of producing such effects , I had recourse to a worthy member of this Society , doctor Franklin , who was possessed of a very good one .
I had communicated all my observations to this gentleman as they occurred , and , in return , met with an ingenuity and candour , that render him as estimable in private life , as the improvements he has introduced into electricity , and particularly his discovery in relation to thunder and lightning , will render his reputation lasting in the learned world .
We differed in opinion with regard to the point in question ; nevertheless I found him ready to give me all the assistance in his power , for bringing the matter to a fair decision .
I had seen him pierce a quire of paper with a stroke of electricity ; and as I perceived it had been struck several times before , I desired he would give it me , that I might at leisure examine the effects of the sundry strokes .
When I came to do so , I observed , that at every hole which had been made through the quire , the upper and the under leaf ( for the quire had been laid in an horizontal position when it was struck ) were ragged about the orifice , and those ragged edges pointed mostly outwards from the body of the quire .
But what was more material ; when I came to turn over the leaves , I found , that the edges of the holes were bent regularly two different ways ( and more remarkably so about the middle of the quire ) , one part of each hole upwards , and the other part downwards ; so that , tracing any particular hole as it traversed the quire , I found on one side the fibres pointed one way , and on the other side the other way ; much in such a manner , as if the hole had been made in the quire , by drawing two threads in contrary directions through it .
This was not all : A piece of paper , covered on one side with Dutch gilding , had been accidentally left between two leaves in the quire , and had been pierced by two different strokes .
This exhibited a very remarkable appearance : Where each of the strokes had been given , the gold leaf was stripped off , and had left the paper bare for a little space , in an oblong form , rounded at the ends ; in which , at the distance of about a quarter of an inch from each other , appeared two points , one of them a little round hole , the other only an indent or impression , such as might have been made by the point of a bodkin .
In the leaf , which fronted the gilding , two such points likewise appeared , corresponding to those above-mentioned ; so that the hole in the one was opposite to the impression in the other , but surrounded with little black or blueish circles .
When the hole , which had been struck in the quire , was traced from above down to the gilding ( for the gilt paper happened to lie with its gilded side uppermost ) , it was found to terminate on the point in the gilt paper where the impression appeared , and there the impression pointed downwards .
Again , when the hole in the lower part of the quire was traced from below upwards , it was found to terminate on the point in the leaf fronting the gilding , where the impression was , and there the impression pointed upwards .
The facts abovementioned seem to leave it without doubt , that the stroke had been given , at the same instant , upwards and downwards ; but that the electrical power from above , and from below , had seized upon the gilding , dissipated part of it in vapour , and by that means become so weak , that each of them could afterwards only make an impression upon the paper , marking the respective directions of their course .
I communicated these observations to Dr. Franklin ; but as no conclusion can , with certainty , be drawn but from facts , confirmed by repeated trials , I desired to have the satisfaction of making a few experiments riments with him in relation to this matter ; to which he readily consented .
For that purpose I waited upon him one morning about the middle of June last ; and the better to ascertain what was essential in the facts , I varied the circumstances a little from those above .
In the middle of a paper-book of the thickness of a quire , I put a slip of tin-foil ; and in another of the same thickness I put two slips of the same sort of foil , including the two middle leaves of the book between them .
Upon striking the two different books , the effects were answerable to what I expected .
In the first , the leaves on each side of the foil were pierced , while the foil itself remained unpierced ; but , at the same time , I could perceive an impression had been made on each of its surfaces , at a little distance one from another ; and such impressions were still more visible upon the paper , and might be traced as pointing different ways .
In the second , all the leaves of the book were pierced , excepting the two that were between the slips of foil ; and in these two , instead of holes , the two impressions , in contrary directions , were very visible .
I have lately got an electrical apparatus of my own , formed on the model of that of Dr. Franklin 's , and have had opportunity since , of making frequent repetitions of the experiments above-mentioned .
Notwithstanding some little variation in appearances , arising , as in other electrical experiments , from the particular state of the weather , the different degree of electricity , or other accidental circumstances , I have met with nothing but what confirms me in my opinion of two distinct counteracting powers .
All the remarks I have been able to make in the repetition of experiments , that need to be added to what I had before observed , may be reduced to the three following .
10 .
When a quire of paper , without any thing between the leaves , is pierced with a stroke of electricity , the two different powers keep in the same tract , and make but one hole in their passage through the paper : not but that the power from above , or that from below , sometimes darts into the paper at two or more sundry points , making so many holes , which , however , generally unite before they go through the paper .
What I mean is , that I never yet could observe the two powers to make different holes in the paper ; but that they always keep the same common channel , rushing along it with inconceivable impetuosity , and in contrary directions .
They seem to pass each other much about the middle of the quire ; for there the edges are most visibly bent different ways : whereas in the leaves near the outside of the quire , the holes very often carry more the appearance of the passage of a power issuing out , and exploding into the air , than of one darting into the paper .
20 .
When any thin metallic substance , such as gilt-leaf , or tin-foil , is put between the leaves of the quire , and the whole struck ; in that case , the counteracting powers deviate from the directest tract , and leaving the path they would in common have taken through the paper only , make their way in different lines to the metallic body , and strike it in two different points , distant from one another about a quarter of an inch , more or less ( the distance appearing to be least when the power is greatest ; ) and whether they pierce , pierce , or only make impressions upon it , in either case , they leave evident marks of motion from two different parts , and in two contrary directions .
It is this deviation from a common course , and the separation of the lines of direction consequent upon it , that affords us the strongest proof , of the exertion of two distinct and counteracting powers .
30 .
When two slips of tin-foil are put into the middle of the quire , including two or more leaves between them , if the electricity be moderately strong , the counteracting powers only strike against the slips , and leave their impressions there .
When it is stronger , we generally find one of the slips pierced ; but seldom both : and from what I have observed in such cases , it would seem as if the power , which issued from the outside of the phial , acts more strongly than that which proceeds from within ; for the lower slip is most commonly pierced : But that may be owing to the greater space , the power from within has to move through , before it strikes the paper .
I take the liberty to lay before the Society a paperbook , of the thickness of a quire , struck three times in the manner above described .
The first stroke ( A ) is given , when there is nothing between the leaves of the book .
The second ( B ) when a piece of paper , covered on one side with what is commonly called Dutch gilding , is laid in the middle .
The third ( C ) , when two slips of tin-foil are put into the book , including the two middle leaves between them .
The members , who are curious in these matters , may , at their leisure , examine the effects of the sundry strokes ; and if any gentlemen , in particular , desire the farther satisfaction of seeing the strokes given , I shall be very ready , at any proper time , to comply with their desire .
New Experiments and Observations concerning Electricity ; by Robert Symmer , Esq ; F. R. S. PAPER IV .
PART II .
Of Two distinct Powers in Electricity .
THE notion of two distinct electrical powers , acting in contrary directions , may appear to some to be the same with that of the effluence and affluence of electrical matter , which M. l'Abbe Nollet gives as the general cause of the phenomena of electricity * .
It may therefore be not improper to take a nearer view of these two opinions , to see how far they agree , and in what they differ .
Read Dec. 20 , 1759 .
This ingenious author , whose merit in the learned world is very considerable , particularly with regard to his labours in electricity , had observed , that , when a body is electrified , a current of electric fluid issues from it , and , in the form of diverging rays , spreads through the air , and enters into other bodies ; and that , at the same time , a current of electric fluid , * ` ` Plus de trois ans se sont ecoules depuis que j'ai propose comme la cause generale des phenomenes electriques , l'effluence et l'affluence simultanees d'une matiere fluide , present par tout , et capable de s'enflammer par le choc de ses propres rayons .
' ' Preface to Recherches sir l'electricite , at the beginning .
issuing from other bodies , passes through the air , and , in the form of converging rays , enters into the body electrified .
From thence he concludes , that a continued , and ( to use his own terms ) simultaneous * effluence and affluence of a fluid matter , extremely subtle , constitutes ~ electricity .
Upon this principle he endeavours to account for all the phenomena that attend the electrification of bodies .
What M. l'Abbe Nollet has observed with regard to two contrary currents in electricity , is by no means inconsistent with the principle of two distinct counteracting powers .
On the contrary , the existence of two such currents is , according to my opinion , a necessary consequence of the exertion of those powers from one body upon another .
It is a phenomenon of electricity only ; not the principle upon which all electrical appearances depend .
But a more essential difference takes place between this gentleman 's opinion and mine : he represents the two currents as consisting but of one and the same * ` ` Ces deux courans qui ont des mouvemens opposes , ont lieu tous deux ensemble , c'est ce que j'exprime par le mot simultanes .
' ' Lettres sir l'electricite , p. 30 .
~ ` ` L'electricite , comme je l'ai deja dit et prouve ailleurs , n'est pas seulment l'emanation d'une matiere qui s'elance du corps electrise ; c'est aussi un remplacement continuel qui se fait de cette matiere , par un autre tout-a-fait semblable , qui se port de toutes parts au corps electrise ; c'est pour ainsi dire , un commerce de la matiere qui j'ai nommee effluente , et de celle que j'ai appellee affluente .
Si celle-ci vient a manquer , ou que la premiere n'ait plus la liberte de sortir , cet etat ou ce double mouvement , que l'on nomme electricite , doit bien-tot cesser .
' ' Essai sir l'electricite , p. 202 .
fluid ~ ; admits but of one kind of electricity ~ ; and maintains , that two bodies cannot be said to be differently electrified , but as they are electrified in a higher or lower degree * .
On the other hand , it is my opinion , that there are two electrical fluids ( or emanations of two distinct electrical powers ) essentially different from each other ; that electricity does not consist in the efflux and afflux of those fluids , but in the accumulation of the one or the other in the body electrified ; or , in other words , it consists in the possession of a larger portion of the one or of the other power , than is requisite to maintain an even balance within the body ; and , lastly , that according as the one or the other power prevails , the body is electrified in one or in another manner .
In those respects we differ in opinion .
Who is in the right is another question .
The whole seems to turn on a single point , namely , whether there be but one , or if there are two distinct kinds of electricity .
The bounds of this paper do not permit me to enter upon a full discussion of the point .
I cannot , however , but observe , that the whole series of experiments mentioned in the preceding papers , tends to confirm the distinction , formerly made , of electricity into two kinds ; and to show , that there is an essential difference ( whatever it be that constitutes that difference ) between what is commonly called positive electricity , and negative .
A farther proof of that difference arises from the success of an experiment , of ~ Essai sir l'electricite , p. 160 , 161 .
~ Ibid. p. 118 , 119 .
* Lettres sir l'electricite , p. 101 .
105 .
which I threw out a hint in my third paper , and which I have since taken an opportunity of making , touching the electrical cohesion of glass .
The experiment is as follows : I took two panes of common window-glass , about nine inches square , the thinnest , the most even , and the smoothest in their surfaces I could get .
I covered one of the sides of each with tin-foil , leaving the space of near an inch from the edges uncovered .
I warmed them a little at the fire ; and , applying the two bare sides together , I laid them upon four wine-glasses , which supported them at the corners .
I then brought down a chain from the prime conductor , nearly to touch the coating of the upper plate , and applying a wire , which I held in my hand , to the coating of the under plate , the machine was put in motion , and the electrification performed , as in the case of the common electrical pane .
When the operation was completed , I removed the chain and the wire , and taking hold of two opposite corners of the upper glass ( those corresponding to them in the other having been purposely cut away , I lifted it , and found , that the under glass came up with it .
The cohesion appeared to me to be considerably strong ; but I had not any proper apparatus ready to measure the strength of it .
I laid them down again on the wine-glasses , and procured an explosion , as in the case of the common electrical pane .
I then took hold of the corners of the upper glass , and lifted it ; but found , that the cohesion was dissolved , the under glass remaining behind .
I could indeed perceive , that , after the discharge , there was still some small degree of cohesion between the plates , which felt as if some glutinous substance had got feeble hold of them : but this was no more than what I found took place between them , when , without being electrified , they were forced close together .
For that reason , two plates of glass , finely polished , and so even as to come into close contact through the whole extent of their opposed surfaces , would be very improper for this experiment ; for , when the power of electricity had forced them into contact , the pressure of the air , and a cohesion proceeding from another principle , would keep them together .
But to pursue the purpose of our experiment.-All who admit of the distinction of electricity into two kinds , agree , that as in the Leyden phial , so likewise in the electrical pane , the different sides are differently electrified : That side , which more immediately receives its electricity from the glass globe , is said to be positively , and the other negatively , electrified .
What may be said of the electrical pane , is applicable to the glass plates in this experiment ; for , when they are put together in the manner mentioned above , they form an electrical pane between them ; one of the plates corresponding with one of the sides , and the other with the other side of the pane .
When , therefore , the glass plates are electrified in the manner before described , the plate , which receives its electricity immediately from the chain , will , according to this distinction , be positively electrified , and that which receives its electricity from the wire , negatively .
Upon these considerations , we may expect , from the experiment in hand , the means of determining , whether the distinction of electricity into two different kinds is merely nominal , or if there is an essential difference between them : For after the glass plates have been electrified in one position , so as to be incapable of receiving any more electricity , if they be inverted , and in that new position presented to the chain and wire , and the globe again be put in motion , according as one or other of those opinions holds , correspondent effects will follow .
If the electricity , that comes by the chain , be of the same nature with that which comes by the wire , no change will be produced upon the plates ; for being before full of one and the same kind of electricity , they can do no more than keep what they had , or exchange it for just as much of the same kind .
But if , by the chain and the wire , two kinds of electricity , totally different in their nature , be conveyed into the respective plates , in that case it is to be expected , that the electricity that each of them had acquired in their former position , will be gradually destroyed , till no signs of electricity appear in either ; after which , they will begin again to be electrified , having their electricity reversed .
In order to see what would really happen , I repeated the experiment in the following manner : I electrified the two plates till they were fully charged , and in strong cohesion , the snapping from the chain and the wire having totally ceased .
I then turned them upon the glasses that supported them , applied the chain and the wire to the different sides , and began to electrify as before .
The glass globe was no sooner in motion , than the snapping from the chain and the wire returned with violence ; and the plates , which , in the former position , would receive no more electricity , appeared , in their new situation , to receive it both from above and below , more greedily than ever .
As this new electrification proceeded , I found , by several trials , that the cohesion became gradually weaker , till , at a certain period , it was totally dissolved ; from which , it began again to be restored , and at last , when the snapping ceased , I found it to be as strong as before .
I carried the experiment still farther : I took two complete electrical panes ( that is , two glass plates , covered each on both sides with tin-foil ) , and laying one upon the other , I applied the chain and the wire , and proceeded to electrify .
The electrification took place throughout ; and I could procure an explosion from either of them single , or from both together : but however highly they were electrified , I never could perceive the least appearance of cohesion between them .
This was agreeable to what I expected .
I judged , that , in consequence of two different kinds of electricity , each of the panes would be charged , on its different sides , with the different kinds ; which , by counteracting one another in the same pane , would reduce it to a neutral state of electricity , and by that means prevent the two panes from acting on each other .
It is not here my purpose to account for electrical cohesion ; yet I cannot but observe , that , in this case at least , it is obvious , that the cohesion cannot be owing to an effluence and affluence of one and the same electrical fluid : For the two plates being of the same substance , and in every respect alike , the effluent current must have just as great an effect in separating them , as the affluent can have in bringing or keeping them together .
The experiment above seems to make it evident , that there are two distinct kinds of electricity ; and the influence of those in making the plates cohere , seems naturally to denote , in concurrence with the experiments mentioned in the former part of this paper , two distinct and counteracting powers , corresponding with the two different kinds of electricity .
If , upon the whole , the arguments I have brought to prove the existence of two distinct powers in electricity , are found to be conclusive , it may , perhaps , be expected of me to say something of the nature of those powers .
Without entering into any particular theory , or indulging myself in loose conjecture , I shall take the liberty to offer a few considerations , such as occur to me on this occasion .
All we know of active powers , extends no farther than as we perceive them to be effects of a power still more general ; or as we find them producing effects according to certain laws .
I have not been able to trace the powers of electricity farther back , than the observations I have given above , have led me .
I do not therefore take upon me to determine , whether they consist of the finer parts of matter , constituting an active and elastic fluid , the elasticity of that fluid remaining still to be accounted for ; or if they are of a substance yet more subtle and active , of which , however , we have hitherto been able to form no distinct idea .
Whatever other power they may be the immediate effects of , or whatever be the secret and imperceptible manner in which they act , the more interesting object of our inquiry , is to know the laws according to which they act , and how far their operations extend in the material world .
The same observations that lead us to the discovery of any power , if followed out with due attention , may serve to instruct us in the laws of its action ; and if we can attain a sufficient knowlege of those laws , however ignorant we may be of the peculiar manner in which the power exerts itself , we may be , by that means , enabled to trace it through its various operations .
The laws of nature are few and simple .
It is only from the variety of circumstances , under which the respective powers are exerted , that the phenomena of nature are multiplied .
The powers of mechanic motion , those I mean by which bodies act upon one another in impulse or pressure , are found to be under the direction but of three general laws ; and from thence is deduced a most extensive branch of natural knowlege .
The laws that regulate the powers , by which bodies act at a distance upon one another , when we come to be better acquainted with them , may be found to be not more numerous or complex .
What appears wonderful to us , is , that bodies should at all be capable of acting upon one another at a distance : But are we not equally ignorant of the manner , in which the powers of motion are exerted , when the bodies are in actual congress ?
Daily experience convinces us of the fact in this case ; and in the other , repeated experiments , and frequent observations , leave us little room to doubt , that there are powers , which , when lodged in one body , are capable of being exerted upon another at a distance .
The powers of electricity are found to be of this nature .
When either of those powers prevails in a body , it exerts its influence , so long as it is lodged there , every way around , and , by pressure or otherwise , acts upon another body within the sphere of its influence .
If it meets with no resistance , it enters this other body , and from this begins to act , as it did from the former .
In the mean while , the counteracting power prevailing in this other body , the like effects will be produced : and thus these two bodies , by means of their corresponding powers , will continue to act upon each other , till their powers be reduced to an equal balance .
Did electricity consist but of one power , after an experimental inquiry into the laws according to which it acted , we might , upon that principle , be able to account for the phenomena of electricity .
But if two distinct and counteracting powers prevail , as appears to me to be evident from the preceding experiments and observations , in that case , it will be impossible to give a complete and consistent theory of electricity , but upon the principle of two such powers .
Nor will this principle be found , upon due consideration , to disagree with the general system of nature .
It is one of the fundamental laws of nature , that action and re-action are inseparable and equal .
And , when we look around , we find that every power , that is exerted in the material world , meets with a counteracting power , that controls and regulates its effects , so as to answer the wise purposes of Providence .
A Letter to the Reverend Dr. Birch , Secretary to the Royal Society , concerning the Force of electrical Cohesion .
SIR , I Happened to be at Mr. Symmer 's on Saturday the 15th instant , when he desired me to be witness to some electrical experiments , he was about to make , with silk stockings , of a particular kind , which he had received for that purpose .
Read Dec. 20 .
1759 .
The weather was then remarkably favourable for electricity , being clear and dry , with a sharp frost , which had continued five or six days .
The wind was easterly , and had been in that quarter for ten days .
It was about noon when we made our experiments ; the barometer at 30 , and Fahrenheit 's thermometer at 32 .
The stockings above-mentioned were wove of carded and spun silk , and were more substantial and weighty , than those with which he had made the experiments mentioned in his third paper .
One pair was of a deep black , having been twice dyed , in order to improve the colour .
Another pair was of the natural colour of the silk , of a dusky white ; and both new .
The pair of black weighed four ounces , eight pennyweight , and four grains ; and the white three ounces , eighteen pennyweight , and fifteen grains .
We began with making a few experiments with the thin stockings formerly made use of ; and found the result to be much the same with what is related by Mr. Symmer in his third paper : that is , we found , that when the white stocking was put within the black , or vice versa , and both highly electrified , taking hold of the one , while a scale with weights was put to the other , we could raise seventeen ounces before the stockings separated .
We then repeated one or two of those experiments with some little variation of circumstances .
We turned one of the stockings inside out , and put that within the other : the inner or rough sides of the stockings being thus together , by which means they took faster hold of each other , we now found , that it required the weight of twenty ounces to separate them .
When the stockings were separated , and applied externally to each other , they then raised the weight of ten ounces * .
We * Some time after this letter of Dr. Mitchell 's had been read in the Society , as I was of opinion , that the thin stockings , mentioned above , had lost much of their electrical power since the beginning of April last , when they first had been made use of in experiments , and that it was owing to the peculiar influence of the weather , that they raised as great a weight now as they had done then , I had the black new dyed , and the white washed , and afterwards whitened in the fumes of sulphur .
Upon this , I found their force very much increased .
On the 9th of January , the weather being much in the same state as it had been the 15th of the preceding month , the stockings , thus prepared , and put one within another , having their rough sides together , lifted no less than three pounds and three ounces before they separated .
Dr. Mitchell was likewise present at this experiment .
How far the circumstance of smoking the white stocking in the fumes of sulphur , might have contributed to increase the electrical power , is what I cannot take upon me to say .
I should think , however , that it does not much contribute to it ; for we find , by the experiments in the sequel of this letter , that the force of cohesion We next proceeded to try the force of electrical cohesion , with the stockings of a more substantial make ; viz. those I have above described ; and there we found it to be much more considerable , as appears by the following experiments .
10 When the white stocking was put within the black ( without either of them being turned inside out ) , so that the outside of the white was contiguous to the inside of the black , they lifted nine pounds , wanting a few pennyweight .
Now , taking the weight of the stocking to be one ounce , eighteen pennyweight , and fifteen grains ( viz. the half of the weight of the pair as mentioned above ) , it follows , that , by the force of its cohesion with the black , it raised fifty-five times its own weight .
20 .
When the white was turned inside out , and put within the black , their inner or rough sides being contiguous , they lifted no less than fifteen pounds , one pennyweight and a half , before they separated : So that , in this case , the single stocking raised ninetytwo times its own weight ~ .
sion is surprisingly great between the black and the white stocking of spun silk , when electrified : and yet I was assured by the hosier , that the white had never been put into the fumes of sulphur ; and that the colour it had was the natural colour of the silk , no other method having been taken to whiten it , than that of scouring and washing .
~ Since that time , I have not been able to raise above ten or eleven pounds with these stockings , even when the weather has been most favourable ; owing , perhaps , to my having cut off all the ends of threads , and tufts of silk , which had been left on the inside of the stockings ; which I did with a view of increasing the cohesion : whereas , when the inner sides of the stockings were put together , those ends of threads , and tufts of silk , by joining intimately with those of the different colour , probably contributed much to produce that powerful cohesion .
30 .
When the inner stocking was drawn out , and applied to the outside of the other , they lifted one pound and three quarters ; that is , between ten and eleven times the weight of the white stocking * .
It is not my design to draw any conclusions from these experiments , and much less to determine how far electrical cohesion may serve , as a principle , to to account for many remarkable appearances in nature .
I relate the experiments I have been witness to , by way of supplement to Mr. Symmer 's third paper ; and I consider the result of them , only , as a farther proof of the surprising degree , to which a power in electricity , which had not before been attended to , may be carried , in even the slightest substances , those of white and of black silk .
I am , Sir , Your most obedient , humble servant , John Mitchell .
Kew , December 18 , 1759 .
* In the third of these papers I observed , that stockings electrified , and applied to one another externally , cohered with a force greater or less , according to the manner in which they joined in contact with each other .
This appears to be the reason , why the stockings here made use of , being much less pliable than the thinner kind , do not , in external cohesion , raise a weight so great in proportion as those do .
From thence I fancied , that if the stockings of spun silk should be first allowed to come together , and afterwards be pressed close between one 's hands , their cohesion externally with one another would thereby be much improved : Accordingly , upon repeated trials , I found , that the white stocking , when thus pressed to the black in external contact , was capable of raising between three and four pounds ; that is , about twenty-two times its own weight .
I have taken the liberty to subjoin these few observations , by way of notes , to Dr. Mitchell 's letter , as they relate to the same subject , and contain matter , which has occurred since his letter was read in the Society .
R. Symmer .
February 1st , 1760 .

