Experiments on the Tourmalin : by Mr. Benjamin Wilson , F. R. S. In a letter to Dr. William Heberden , F. R. S. SIR , I Have the pleasure to communicate to you some experiments made upon the Tourmalin , or Ashstone , which you were so kind as to procure me , together with some others , respecting the vitreous and resinous electricities , as they are called , and the observations I have made thereupon .
The more I am acquainted with electricity , the more I admire a wonderful simplicity which seems to prevail in nature , at least in this part which abounds with phenomenon of a very curious kind ; whereof many that have passed under my examination of late are so extremely nice , that I avoid venturing to relate them , because I would not willingly subject myself to the censure of incautious observers .
4I canRead Dec. 6 .
I cannot enter into this particular subject , without first settling a dispute amongst electricians , which subsists at this day , concerning the two electricities ; because some consequences , drawn from the several experiments I have to produce , greatly depend upon it .
Polished glass , upon being rubbed properly , has been supposed to give an electricity to bodies , and those bodies that receive it from the glass , are said to be electrified plus .
Whereas wax , amber , &amp;c. upon being rubbed in the same manner , have on the contrary been supposed to receive an electricity from bodies , and those bodies which part with it are said to be electrified minus .
But no experiment , that I know of , has yet appeared to determine which of these electricities does really electrify plus , and which of them does really electrify minus ; though it happens that the fact turns out just as they have all along supposed .
In a second treatise upon the subject of electricity , that I published in the year 1748 , several experiments were produced , to show that all bodies are surrounded with a medium , which is of an exceeding elastic nature , and extends but to a very small distance from the body when it is not disturbed by heat , or other causes .
Since that , other experiments of the like kind have been published in a work , wherein my late worthy friend Dr. Hoadly was concerned with me .
Among the proofs therein given , is a curious one , which I observed in the Torricellian vacuum , where the appearance was remarkably sensible .
And what is more singular , that same appearance not only proves the existence of a medium , at or on the surface of bodies , but at the same time determines which of the electricities is truly plus , and which of them is minus .
You must remember , Lord Charles Cavendish first observed the luminous appearance in one continued stream throughout the whole vacuum of an exhausted tube .
It is a fine experiment , and affords more information than I at first imagined , therefore I shall beg leave to recite it from the Philosophical Transactions * , before I give you any farther particulars about it .
This apparatus consisted of a cylindrical glass tube of about three tenths of an inch in diameter , and of seven feet and half in length , bent somewhat like a parabola , in such a manner , that thirty inches of each of its extremities were nearly straight , and parallel to each other , from which an arch sprung , which was likewise of thirty inches .
This tube was carefully filled with mercury ; and each of its extremities being put into its bason of mercury , so much of the mercury ran out , until , as in common barometrical tubes , it was in equilibrio with the atmosphere .
Each of the basons containing the mercury was of wood , and was supported by a cylindrical glass of about four inches in diameter , and six inches in length ; and these glasses were fastened to the bottom of a square wooden frame , so contrived , as that to its top was suspended with silk lines the tube filled with mercury before mentioned ; so that the whole of this apparatus without inconvenience might be * Vol. xlvii .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LI .
TAB. IX .
p. 311 .
moved together .
The Torricellian vacuum then occupied a space of about thirty inches .
In makeing the experiment , when the room was darkened , a wire from the prime conductor of the common electrical machine communicated with one of the basons of mercury , and any non-electric touching the other bason , while the machine was in motion , the electricity pervaded the vacuum in a continued arch of lambent flame , and as far as the eye could follow it , without the least divergency .
' ' I imagine Dr. Watson , who has described this experiment , did not , when he made the experiment , attend to a singular appearance of light upon one of the surfaces of the quicksilver , because he has taken no notice of it .
However , I had a mind to make the experiment myself , and try whether I could not manage the quicksilver , so as to have more than two visible surfaces , in order that I might have that remarkable appearance repeated .
To do this , I let a very small quantity of air into the tube , by which means four columns of quicksilver were obtained , reckoning great and small together ; and six visible surfaces , three of which I called upper , and three under surfaces .
But the figure in the plate No. IX .
will give you a better idea of the instrument , than I am able to do by writing .
When the column of quicksilver on the left hand was electrified , and the other on the right communicated with the earth , the stream of light was visible in a darkened chamber , and the general appearance , all the way through the vacuum , was a light of a seeming uniform density , excepting at the upper surfaces , for above one tenth of an inch , reckoning from each surface ; and there the light was always considerably brighter ; insomuch that a gentleman , then present , who was unacquainted with experiments of this kind , desired to know the reason of the three knobs of light appearing on the tops of the quicksilver .
I mention this circumstance , because they were remarkably conspicuous ; whereas the three under surfaces exhibited no such appearance , the light being rather less bright than even in the general appearance of the whole illuminated vacuum .
An electric current , setting in from the glass of the electrifying machine , and passing along the tube through the quicksilver and vacuum , and so to the earth , must have caused those bright knobs by means of the resistance the fluid met with at the upper surface of the quicksilver in endeavouring to enter it ; because the appearances were alike on the three upper surfaces , and nothing of the same kind was seen at the under surfaces .
Glass therefore electrifies bodies plus , or , in other words , gives bodies a quantity of electric fluid more than they have naturally .
I am now to acquaint you with the appearances that the minus electricity occasioned .
Instead of the glass cylinder to electrify with , I put a resinous one , preserving the communication , and every thing else , as in the former experiment .
In these circumstances , the general appearance of the light in the vacuum was the same ; but in this experiment the knobs of light were on the under surfaces , and not upon the upper .
From the knobs of light being at the under surfaces , and not upon the upper , I concluded that the flow of the fluid was the contrary way to that caused by glass ; for in this case it appeared to come from the earth , then into the tube , and so on to the resinous cylinder .
Those bodies therefore which have no communication with the earth , and from which the resinous cylinder is supplied , must be electrified minus * .
These luminous knobs ( were there no other proofs ) are a strong confirmation of the existence of a medium at or on the surfaces of bodies , which , to a limited degree , resists or hinders the entrance and exit of the electric fluid .
But we have some other experiments to illustrate the same , and the Tourmalin does assist us not a little .
There is one thing more , which I am obliged to take notice of , concerning the impermeability of glass by electricity .
Our friend , Dr. Franklin , seems to found a great part of his system on this opinion .
Glass , says he , has within its substance always the same quantity of electrical fire , and that a very great quantity in proportion to the mass .
This quantity , proportioned to the glass , it strongly and obstinately retains , and will have neither more nor less , though it will suffer a change to be made in its parts and situation ; i. e. we may take away part of it from one of its sides , provided we throw an equal quantity into the other .
' ' This doctrine I could never agree to , so far as it relates to the impermeability of glass , as appears by my letters in answer to the Abbe Nollet and M. le Roy , on their requesting to know my sentiments about it , * The same cylinder made rough with emmery , and rubbed with flannel at one time , and with leather at another , will afford these different appearances , the first causing the minus , and the last the plus appearance .
in the year 1756 , the former of whom it is well known could never come into it * .
And I am still the less inclined to alter my opinion of this matter , from an acquaintance with the properties of the Tourmalin , which I think has furnished me with sufficient grounds for advancing that Dr. Franklin is mistaken .
I have wondered that AEpinus did not take notice of some of the experiments which electrify glass either plus or minus , because the Tourmalin affords leading experiments towards it ; and can ascribe it to no other cause than a favourable opinion he was willing to entertain of Dr. Franklin 's hypothesis .
To prove that glass is permeable by electricity , I took a very large pane thereof ( I chose it large , that no objection might be made to the experiment ) and then warmed it a little , so that it was free from moisture .
After that , I held it upright by one edge , whilst the opposite edge rested upon wax , and rubbed the middle part of the surface with my finger .
After this , I found that both sides were electrified plus .
Upon repeating the experiment many times , with different glass and different degrees of rubbing , still both sides were in every experiment electrified plus .
Now they could not both be electrified plus by this treatment , unless some part of the fluid had really passed through the glass ; because the virtue could not get round to the other side over so great a surface : besides , the extremities of the glass were not electrified at all .
As to electrifying glass minus , I find it may be done three different ways .
But these and other experiments relating to the permeability of glass , I shall * Vid. lettres sir l'ectricite par M. l'Abbe Nollet , let .
iv .
forbear mentioning , till I have brought you better acquainted with the Tourmalin .
The first account I met with of the Tourmalin , and the remarkable properties belonging to it , was from a memoir in the Berlin acts , printed in the year 1758 ; wherein it appears , that F. V. T. AEpinus , professor of natural philosophy , made several very curious and judicious experiments upon it ; the most material of which , prove a plus electricity on one side thereof , and , at the same time , a minus electricity on the other side ; provided the Tourmalin is moderately warmed , and even by hot water .
These appearances are the more extraordinary , as the like means employed in the same manner upon diamonds , glass , and all other electric bodies hitherto tried , produce no such appearances .
The Duke de Noya , who visited this kingdom in 1758 , wrote a small treatise on the subject , and published it at Paris on his way to Italy : in this work he mentions AEpinus 's experiments , but does not admit of a plus and minus electricity belonging to the Tourmalin when heated .
On the contrary , he says that the two sides are electrified plus , but one of them is more so than the other ; and that it is the difference between those degrees which has led AEpinus into the mistake .
I remember to have repeated most of the experiments mentioned in the Berlin memoir , soon after it appeared in England , with the Tourmalin belonging to our friend Dr. Sharp , which you fortunately recollected to have seen in his possession many years ago at Cambridge ; for it was the only one known of here at that time : and though but a small one , compared with AEpinus 's , yet it was large enough to satisfy me that his opinion was well founded .
Besides , the trials you made with the same stone before I had it , were a farther confirmation of the truth .
However , the following experiments , which I made to procure more data towards attaining some simple explanation of these curious phenomenon , will sufficiently prove , that one side of the stone is really electrified plus , and the other side minus .
And had the Duke de Noya made farther experiments , and pursued the same method I have done , I think he would have been of the same opinion .
The largest Tourmalin I had from you , and with which I made the following experiments , weighs above 120 grains .
It is of an oval form , and polished : the greatest diameter measures an inch and a quarter , and the least one inch .
One side is plain , the other is convex , but cut into several small planes or facettes , something like a rose diamond ; the thickest part of which is near one third of an inch .
This shape does not seem to me to be the most convenient for makeing experiments , but I would not alter it , lest the stone should break ; for there are several cracks in it ; and I sear it will be difficult to meet with another of the same size .
To make experiments with the Tourmalin requires the greatest attention , as the appearances sometimes are scarcely sensible , insomuch that I have been obliged to employ the tenderest kind of apparatus , and even interpose a sort of screen to prevent my breath , or other like motions of the air , from disturbing the experiment .
My apparatus for making many of these experiments , consists of two very small balls made of the pith of elder , and suspended by two linen threads of the finest kind : the ends of these threads I fasten to a slip of wood about three inches long , and half an inch broad : then upon a stick of sealing wax nine inches long , fixed upright on a table , or any other convenient place , I fasten the slip of wood , from one end of which the threads &amp;c. hang down five inches , so that the pith balls are about four inches from the table .
These balls are always supposed to be electrified plus , except where the contrary is mentioned : but with no greater power , than to make them recede from each other about one inch in every experiment .
I prefer the wax stand to a glass one , as the latter when cold acquires moisture very soon , and therefore becomes a conductor : whereas wax , when it is once in good order , will continue a non-conductor for a long time .
Before I set down my experiments , I must mention three truths that are commonly known , and which , for the present , I shall call GENERALLAW S. Two bodies equally electrified plus recede from each other , or are repelled .
Two bodies electrified minus recede also from each other , or are repelled .
One body electrified plus and another body electrified minus , to an equal degree , accede , or move towards each other , or , as it is generally expressed , are attracted .
EXPERIMENTS upon the TOURMALI N. Exp. 1 .
One edge of the Tourmalin being properly fastened to a long stick of sealing wax , I dipped the stone into boiling water , and continued it there near one minute .
On taking it out , and presenting the convex side thereof near the pith balls , they immediately receded from it , but not very strongly .
On turning the plain side towards the balls , it caused them to accede to it , but rather at a greater distance in this case , than they receded from it in the last .
When the stone was colder , these appearances were considerably stronger ; but , on cooling still more , they were less and less .
Exp. 2 .
I repeated this last experiment , with the difference only of having the balls electrified minus instead of plus * .
And in this case ( as might be expected ) the effects were reversed ; the balls acceding towards the convex side , and receding from the plain side .
These appearances in the two experiments agreeing with one another , sufficiently prove , that when the stone has been heated by water , one side is electrified minus , and the other side is electrified plus ; which is the first law laid down by AEpinus .
This state has not improperly been called its natural state ; because the heat , which disposed the Tourmalin to afford these appearances , was uniform in every part of its surface , and the water itself an uniform conductor .
Exp. 3 .
I presented the convex side to the flame of a candle , but not so near as to touch the flame , and held it there about one minute , during which time the stone acquired a plus electricity on both sides , for *I did the same thing in every experiment where there was occasion to use these balls , to be more certain of the conclusions .
the balls receded from them , but rather with a greater force from the convex side , than from the plain side .
This appearance proves an increase of the power in the stone ; because it continued to act for a time like other bodies electrified plus .
And in regard to the different forces of the two sides , that will be particularly considered hereafter .
Exp. 4 .
After a short time , the Tourmalin being colder , and the remaining heat more equally diffused , it changed its last state to a plus and minus one ; for the plain side made the balls accede , and the convex side made them recede .
This change seemed to arise from some alteration , on or near its surfaces , by having the heat equally diffused throughout the stone : if it was not so , I see no reason but that the Tourmalin should continue to be electrified plus on both sides , whilst any electrical signs remained .
Exp. 5 .
I now held the plain side as near the flame as I had done the convex one ; and instead of both sides being electrisied plus , they were electrified minus , for each side caused the balls to accede .
From this experiment , I had reason to believe that the stone was emptied ( if I may so say ) of its electricity ; because it continued to act for a time like other bodies electrified minus .
Exp. 6 .
After the same length of time as in the fourth experiment , the Tourmalin being colder , it changed its state also ; for the convex side made the balls recede , and the plain side continued to make them accede , as they had done before .
This change seemed likewise to arise from some alteration on the surfaces of the Tourmalin , by having the heat equally diffused throughout the stone : if it was not so , I see no reason but that the Tourmalin should continue to be electrified minus on both sides , whilst any electrical signs remained .
I was naturally led next to examine at which surface of the Tourmalin the fluid entered ( if any did ) , whilst it continued heating .
Exp. 7 .
Flame being improper for my purpose , because the electric fluid is readily dissipated by its presence , I made choice of an iron rod , at the end of which was a round knob .
This was heated , and afterwards brought to a certain distance from the balls , in order to see if they were moved by it : but not perceiving the least motion , I interposed the Tourmalin , with the convex side next the balls .
They acceded a little , and when I removed the heated iron , they returned to their place again .
I then brought the iron nearer to the Tourmalin than before : the balls in this case moved with vigour towards the stone , and continued in contact with it for a considerable time ; and , after that , they receded from it .
On examining the balls , I found they had lost all their plus electricity , and were electrified minus .
I also observed that the stone itself was minus on both sides .
I gathered from this experiment , that the electric fluid flowed from the balls towards the stone ; because they not only lost their own plus electricity , but were electrified minus : and , as the Tourmalin was minus also on both sides , a quantity of electric fluid must have flowed from it towards the iron .
That this was really the fact will appear presently .
Exp. 8 .
When I heated the convex side in the same manner as I did the plain one , the balls were not moved towards the Tourmalin , but from it , and continued in that state .
In this experiment they were electrified plus , and the stone also was plus on both sides .
I gathered from this experiment that the plus electricity in the stone did not flow from the balls , because they lost none of their virtue ; but it must be from the iron itself .
It was now necessary to examine the iron : but I found it very difficult to do this for many reasons , and such as might perhaps be thought too tedious if I mentioned them .
I therefore had recourse to another expedient~ where there was a probability of meeting with better success .
This was to make use of a tube of glass about two feet long , one end of which I heated red hot and tried the experiments again : observing at the same time the state of the glass after each experiment .
Exp. 9 .
When the plain side of the Tourmalin was exposed to the heated end of the glass , in like manner as it was to the knob of iron in the seventh experiment , I observed that about three inches of the heated part of the glass was electrified minus , and beyond that distance it was electrified plus , and continued so even when the glass was very near cold .
This plus and minus state in the glass , must be caused from the action of the fluid flowing from the balls and Tourmalin towards the glass : because I found that a current of the electric fluid acting against the natural quantity of the fluid in the glass will produce the same effect : for having rubbed a tube of glass , I applied it to the heated end of another tube , and the appearances were exactly alike ; that part which was heated being minus , and the part beyond it plus .
This seems a leading step , towards discovering the truth we are in search after : for the current of the fluid seems to be fairly traced in these circumstances , the heat having disposed the Tourmalin properly to let the fluid pass from the balls , through its substance , towards the glass .
Exp. 10 .
I was now eager to try what would be the event , when the heated part of the glass was next the convex side of the Tourmalin .
Upon making the experiment , I found that the tube was electrified minus above one foot in length , without the least appearance of a plus electricity beyond the minus one , as in the last experiment .
And this minus appearance continued also when the tube was nearly cold .
Now because the Tourmalin was plus , the balls plus also , and the heated glass minus , the electric fluid must have flowed from the glass to produce a plus electricity in the stone and balls .
Thus you see , Sir , I have discovered two currents of the electric fluid passing in contrary directions , the one of them electrifying both sides of the Tourmalin plus , and the other both sides minus .
MY next step was to put the Tourmalin into its natural state ( as AEpinus calls it , ) in order to make farther experiments .
Exp. 11 .
To answer this purpose best , I separated the Tourmalin from the wax , and placed it in boiling water for a short time , where it was surrounded on all sides with a conductor and an equal degree of heat : then , taking it out of the water .
I laid the convex side ( after it was dry ) upon the slip of wood , supported by wax , to which the pith balls were suspended ; but no appearance happened , for the balls continued at rest .
Exp. 12 .
But when the stone remained on the wood a little time longer , the balls separated to a considerable distance , sometimes near two inches ; and remained so for more than one minute .
In this state they were electrified plus , as appeared by their acceding towards amber when it was rubbed and brought near them .
From the balls being electrified plus , the flow of the fluid from the plus side of the Tourmalin must have caused some part of the wood itself to be minus , and the balls plus ; because the same effects happened in Exp. 9 .
Besides , electrified glass opposed to the same wood produced similar appearances .
Exp. 13 .
If , whilst the stone continued resting upon the wood , I brought my finger near the plain side of the Tourmalin , the balls receded farther from each other ; and when I repeated the approach , it every time affected the balls and made them recede a little more , unless the Tourmalin was become too cold ; in which case they approached nearer , but still continued to be electrified plus .
In this experiment , the finger did nothing more than supply the stone with the electric fluid , more readily than the air itself would have done .
Exp. 14 .
Upon removing the stone by degrees from off the wood , the balls approached nearer and nearer : but when it was taken away entirely they receded again , and in this case were electrified minus instead of plus .
This is a farther confirmation that the fluid flowing from the stone electrified the wood minus , by forcing part of the natural quantity in the wood into the balls , and so made them plus ; but because some part of the fluid was forced likewise out of the balls into the air whilst they continued plus , therefore when the stone was taken away , they were just as much electrified minus , as the force of the fluid flowing from the stone was able to drive out of the balls : and I have formerly shown * that the balls will recede from one another in this minus state as they do in a plus one , by the crouding in of the fluid from the air &amp;c. on all sides to restore the aequilibrium ; but being retarded in some degree in endeavouring to enter the balls by the medium on their surfaces , an accumulation is formed , and consequently atmospheres similar to the plus ones ; with this difference only , that one is tending from the body and the other to the body .
Exp. 15 .
After heating the stone again in boiling water , I laid the plain side upon the wood .
In this case the balls continued at rest as they did in the eleventh experiment , when the convex side laid upon the wood .
* See exp .
and obs .
by Hoadly and Wilson .
Exp. 16 .
But , after a little time , the balls separated an inch or more , and remained so for some time .
In this state they were electrified minus ; for they receded from the amber .
The Tourmalin , in these circumstances , was supplied with the electric fluid from the wood and balls , as appears from the preceding experiments , when the heated glass was applied ; so that the balls must have been in a minus state , and some part of the wood in a plus one : because of the like resistance at the surface to be overcome , where an accumulation of the fluid must have been caused before it could pass to the Tourmalin ; as appears by Lord Charles Cavendish 's experiment .
Glass electrified minus , and applied in the same manner , produced the like effect .
As to the method of electrifying glass minus , it will be shown presently .
Exp. 17 .
Upon bringing my finger near the convex side , the balls receded farther from each other , as they did in the thirteenth experiment : and , on repeating the approach , the balls receded a little more , unless the stone was become too cold .
The approach of the finger , therefore , conducted the fluid from the stone , more readily than the air surrounding it .
Exp. 18 .
On removing the Tourmalin the least from the wood , the balls approached nearer each other , and continued to do so as the stone was removed farther off ; nevertheless they were electrified minus , though in a less degree .
Exp. 19 .
I then removed it entirely , and the balls receded , but to a greater distance than at any time before in the preceding experiments ; and , instead of being minus , they were now plus ; for the amber caused them to accede .
By the balls receding to a greater distance in this last case than in any other experiment I have yet produced , and the flow of the fluid , during the natural state of the stone , being from the minus to the plus side , we have produced another proof , that the resistance is least at the minus side of the stone : and from this cause , the tendency of the fluid from the balls towards the stone must be greater , than when the fluid tended from the stone towards the balls .
But there is a resistance appertaining to the wood , that was observed before , and which must be taken into the account , though it is the same in each experiment .
Nevertheless , since the tendency of the fluid is different when different sides of the stone are exposed , different degrees of the electric fluid will be accumulated .
Hence we see the reason why , upon removing the stone from off the wood , as in this last experiment , more of the accumulated fluid must have flowed in , than flowed out , because the balls were electrified plus .
HAVING endeavoured to explain these three different states of the Tourmalin , caused by different applications of heat , I shall now offer some farther experiments in which friction is concerned , and compare them with other experiments of the vitreous and resinous kind , in order to observe how far they agree with one another , and whether the principles here advanced are constant and uniform .
Exp. 20 .
The Tourmalin being again fixed to the wax , I gave the convex side one slight rub with my finger , and observed , that both sides were electrified plus .
When the Tourmalin was put into its natural state , so as to electrify plus and minus , I gave the same side another slight rub ; and in this case both sides were electrified plus .
Upon repeating these two last experiments with the plain side instead of the other , the Tourmalin was electrified plus on both sides likewise ; but with this difference , that now they were considerably more electrified than before .
This is a farther argument , that the resistance is less on the plain side than on the convex side ; and that the fluid passed through the stone .
And because so slight a friction occasioned such a sensible alteration , we are sufficiently cautioned from touching the stone at any time , but when the experiment requires it .
The same caution is to be observed with glass , amber , silk , &amp;c. These experiments put me upon trying the experiment with the pane of glass , mentioned in the beginning of this letter ; and , upon finding that the electric fluid not only passed through the glass , but electrified it plus , I had a mind to try , whether I could not electrify it minus .
Exp. 21 .
For this purpose I made use of the same glass , and , when it was a little warmed , I held it within two feet of the prime conductor , which was electrified plus .
By this method , that part of the glass , which was opposed to the conductor , became electrified minus on both sides ; but beyond that , a considerable part all round the minus , was electrified plus on both sides .
This effect is of the same kind with that mentioned in the 9th experiment .
In a few minutes , the minus electricity disappeared , and the plus continuing , diffused itself into the place of the other ; so that now the whole was electrified plus .
Exp. 22 .
The experiment so far succeeding , induced me to make use of a less piece of glass , that I might have the whole electrified minus .
Upon making the experiment , it answered accordingly .
These advances led me to observe the power of electrifying this small piece of glass and the Tourmalin at different distances .
Exp. 23 .
I exposed the small piece of glass to the prime conductor , at the distance of two feet , which was the same as before in the 21st experiment , and observed a minus electricity at both surfaces .
Exp. 24 .
As I moved the glass nearer , to a certain distance , it was more sensibly electrified minus ; and after that , on moving it still nearer , the minus appearance was less and less sensible , till it came within the distance of about one inch , and then it was electrified plus on both sides .
These last experiments are farther confirmations of the permeability of glass .
Exp. 25 .
This plus electricity in the glass I found might be changed to a minus once again , by removing the glass , and holding it for a time at a greater distance : which is another proof of the repulsive power of this fluid .
Exp. 26 .
The Tourmalin afforded like appearances when in the same circumstances ; with this difference , that they were caused at greater distances than those of the glass ; and particularly the plus electricity was acquired at the distance of one foot , or more .
From this difference in the power at different distances , I inferred , that the Tourmalin resists the exit and entrance of the fluid considerably less than glass , or even amber ; for the distances requisite to cause changes in these , were less , than the distances which caused changes in the Tourmalin : and since , by exposing glass , and the Tourmalin , to an electrified body , at considerable distances , they are rendered minus , and at a nearer distance plus ; it is no inconsiderable argument that their general laws are the same ; and that the Tourmalin differs in nothing from other electric bodies , but in acquiring an electricity by heat .
And , in regard to this remarkable effect , the experiments I formerly made , which rendered electrics non-electric , as likewise Mr. Delaval 's curious experiments upon early substances , are other instances how particular bodies may be so altered , as to suffer the electric fluid to pass through them or not , according to the different degrees of heat employed in the experiment .
But to proceed with our observations on rubbed glass .
Exp. 27 .
Having by me a pane of glass , one side of which was rough , and the other smooth , I rubbed it slightly on the rough side ; upon doing which , both sides were electrified minus .
Exp. 28 .
I treated the other side in the same manner ; after which , the minus electricity was changed to a plus one , on both sides .
Now , because the same glass afforded different appearances when different sides thereof were rubbed , and there being no other difference in the circumstances of the two experiments , expect that in the surfaces themselves , the one being rough , and the other smooth ; it follows , that the power of electrifying plus or minus arises from one and the same fluid .
Exp. 29 .
I then had a curiosity to try , whether I could not , by rubbing , make one side of this glass plus , and the other minus , at the same time .
This I effected , after both sides were made plus ; for , by rubbing the rough side of the glass less , than I rubbed the smooth side , that became minus , and the smooth side continued plus .
I rubbed the rough side less , because I found from experience , that rough glass required a less power to electrify it minus , than smooth glass did to electrify it plus ; and therefore I concluded , that the medium on the different surfaces has different powers , the greatest belonging to the smooth , and the least to the rough surfaces ; as Sir Isaac Newton has shown concerning light falling upon polished and rough glass .
I remember an observation of the like kind , which Mr. Short made , upon having occasion to heat one of his metal speculums , behind which was fastened a wooden handle .
This speculum he placed near a strong fire , with the polished surface towards the same , where it continued above an hour , without receiving the least degree of warmth .
That power therefore , which reflected the heat , must certainly be of the same nature with that , which occasioned the knobs of light in vacuo , mentioned in the first experiment .
I have frequently endeavoured to cause alterations in that power , with a view to be better acquainted with its laws ; and , amongst other attempts , I rubbed electrics against electrics .
Exp. 30 .
The first trial was with the Tourmalin and amber , which produced a plus electricity on both sides of the stone , and a minus one in the amber .
Afterwards I electrified the amber , and held it near the Tourmalin ; still both sides were plus : and if I rubbed the Tourmalin whilst the amber was electrified , it continued plus .
Then I rubbed the stone with glass ; notwithstanding which , both sides of the Tourmalin were plus , and the glass minus .
Exp. 31 .
But when the glass was electrified plus , and held near the Tourmalin , as I had done before with the amber , in this case , both sides were electrified minus .
These experiments seem to show , that where electric appearances are produced , by the rubbing of any two polished bodies together , that body , whose substance is hardest , and electric power strongest , will be always plus , and the softest and weakest , always minus .
It was from this theory , with which I had the pleasure to acquaint you , that I was desirous of trying to electrify the Tourmalin minus by rubbing , not having at that time been able to do it .
I fixed upon a brilliant diamond for this purpose , as being the hardest body , and strongest electric , that I was acquainted with ; and , upon rubbing the Tourmalin with it , my expectations were answered ; for both sides of the Tourmalin were electrified minus , and the diamond plus .
Exp. 32 .
These experiments succeeding , I rubbed glass against glass , and found , that they electrified each other ; but one of them was plus , and the other minus .
Exp. 33 .
Two pieces of amber , treated in the same manner , were also electrified plus and minus .
Exp. 34 .
When I rubbed glass against amber , the former was plus , and the latter minus .
Exp. 35 .
Two Tourmalins being rubbed against each other , one became plus , and the other minus .
From all which it appears , that some alteration was made in the medium on their surfaces ; otherwise these opposite effects could not have been produced : and in regard to the same bodies producing different effects , it is not improbable but they may differ in degrees of hardness , polish , or of their electrifying power .
Now , as electrics , rubbed against electrics , occasioned electrical appearances , I was encouraged to try what would be the effect of air , if I rubbed , or rather forced , it against electrics ; for I supposed the particles of air to be surrounded with a medium of the same kind as grosser bodies , which is the cause of their being so elastic .
Exp. 36 .
To do this , I only made use of a common pair of bellows , and having brought the Tourmalin near to the end of the pipe , I found , after it had received about twenty blasts , it was electrified plus on both sides .
Air therefore seems to be less electric than the Tourmalin .
Exp. 37 .
Into the place of the Tourmalin I brought a pane of glass , and blew against it the same number of times as in the former experiment .
When I examined both sides , they were electrified plus also , but less than the Tourmalin .
Exp. 38 .
Amber , treated in the same manner , was electrified less than the glass .
Exp. 39 .
I had recourse next to a smith 's bellows .
The difference these occasioned was only a much stronger electricity in the Tourmalin .
Amber was still weaker than the glass , and the glass weaker than the Tourmalin .
Still having in view the medium on the surfaces of the particles of air , I considered , that heat would rarify it ; by which means , air , having its resistance lessened , would more readily part with the electric fluid , and of consequence electrify more powerfully .
Exp. 40 .
The pipe of the bellows being made redhot , I blew against the Tourmalin twelve times only , which was eight blasts less than in the former experiments with cold air .
In this experiment likewise the Tourmalin was electrified plus on both sides , but to a considerable degree more , than was done in the 36th and 39th experiments .
The hot air had the same effect upon glass ; but electrified it less than the Tourmalin : and amber , though , like the other bodies , it suffered an increase of power by the same treatment , was electrified the least of all .
From the air electrifying more powerfully when it is hot , than when cold ; and the Tourmalin being electrified more than glass , and glass more than amber , as appears by these last experiments , we seem to have obtained a proof , that the whole atmosphere is constantly promoting a flow of the electric fluid , by the alternate changes of heat and cold : and further , that air is not only less electric than the Tourmalin , but less than glass , and even amber .
Exp. 41 .
When the Tourmalin had received the same number of blasts against the plain side , whilst my finger touched the convex side , it afforded different appearances ; for the plain side was electrified plus , and the other minus .
After a short time , both sides were plus ; and some time after this the stone recovered its natural state , the plain side being minus , and the convex plus .
What appeared singular in this experiment , was , that the middle state of the stone should be plus on both sides .
But we no more wonder at this , when we consider , that there were two causes to produce these effects : the first was heat , which put the stone into an unnatural state ( as AEpinus had observed before ) ; for , upon cooling , it would recover its natural state , and consequently afford different appearances .
But the second cause , which electrified both sides plus when the stone was in an intermediate ( or , as AEpinus calls it , neutral ) state , between the two extremes , was , that then the effects of the air itself took place , and electrified both sides plus , as it had done before in the 35th experiment .
Exp. 42 .
The convex side was now presented to the bellows in the same manner , and received an equal number of blasts .
In this experiment both sides were plus , but weaker than in the last experiment ; and , after a time , the stone returned to its natural state , affording a plus and minus appearance .
This property in the air , of electrifying glass , amber , &amp;c. will , in all probability , account for an experiment I met with in France , made by M. Le Monnier * , who showed me , at St. Germains en Lays , two or three long wires , which he had suspended horizontally from the palace to his apartment , above * See the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences .
thirty feet from the ground ( the same experiment that was made by my friend the Abbe Mazeas , and communicated , with several others , to the Royal Society * ) , in order to observe the electric effects during thunder storms and cloudy weather .
These wires he frequently found electrified in a small degree , when the day was clear , and without the least appearance of a cloud .
Might not this effect therefore arise from the friction of the air against the wires ?
From considering all these things , and what these last experiments have taught us concerning the different effects produced by hot and cold air , it seems probable , that many of the curious operations in nature arise from a constant flux and reflux of the electric fluid .
And if the observation be true , that air , free from moisture , during tempests and hurricanes in the night , frequently affords a faint kind of light , resembling what is seen in an exhausted receiver , through which the electric fluid is caused to flow , as also it occasions a more general clearness in the heavens , than would appear were there no such violent agitations ; it is reasonable to imagine , that a flux of the electric fluid in the air , is the cause of such appearances ; for the same reason that our artificial blasts produced the electrical effects I have just now mentioned .
But it remains to be inquired into , whether the Tourmalin is so disposed by nature , as to suffer the electric fluid to pass through it only in one direction , like magnetism through the loadstone , or is indifferent which way it flows .
* See the Transactions of the Royal Society , Vol. XLVIII .
Exp. 43 .
Upon examining a Tourmalin which was flat on both sides , and polished , except upon its edges , part of the edge appeared plus , and another part opposite to it minus ; so that a line , drawn from the plus part through the centre of the stone to the other side , would pass through the minus part .
Exp. 44 .
Two smaller Tourmalins , that were flat also , and polished , like the other , exhibited the same appearances .
Exp. 45 .
Another Tourmalin , which was also flat , but unpolished , afforded a fourth instance of this kind .
Exp. 46 .
The first of these Tourmalins was afterwards polished , as well at the edges as the surface ; in order to see , whether that would make any alteration ; but I found it still retained its former electrical state .
Exp. 47 .
I experienced the same with another Tourmalin , which had been rough likewise .
Exp. 48 .
I then , with a little emery , made that edge , which was plus , rough again , preserving all the rest smooth ; but I could not perceive , that any alteration was made by it .
I did the like with the edge of the other polished Tourmalin , without being able to observe any difference .
Exp. 49 .
As to the small Tourmalin , that is plain on one side , and a little convex on the other , which you observed to be a very good one , it is plus on the plain side , and minus on the convex ; which is contrary to the large Tourmalin described in the beginning of this letter .
Exp. 50 .
I had an opportunity of trying another Tourmalin , now in the British Museum , which afforded another instance of the singular disposition of this stone .
The Tourmalin I now speak of , is plain on one side , and concave on the other ; with a small flat border round it .
It was square , but one of the corners had been broken off .
When I examined it , the broken part was plus , and the corner opposite to the broken part minus : so that here also the electric current ran through the stone in a diagonal line .
Exp. 51 .
Every one of these Tourmalins , except that in the British Museum , I greased all over , and , whilst they were warm enough to preserve the grease liquid , I tried each Tourmalin separately , but found , no alteration in the virtue of the stone , except weakening it a little ; though it is well known , that moisture , of any sort , readily conducts the electric fluid ; and therefore , if the Tourmalin had not a fixed kind of electricity , the plus and minus observeable on the two sides of the stone , must , by this treatment , have united , and destroyed each other : the plus side parting with as much of the fluid , as the minus , on the other side , wanted , to restore the equlibrium .
Upon the whole , all these experiments do most clearly prove , that the Tourmalin suffers the electrical fluid to pass through it only in one direction , and so far it bears some analogy to the loadstone .
And as the loadstone loses its virtue by being made red-hot , I was desirous to see what would be the event in the Tourmalin under the same treatment .
Exp. 52 .
I therefore put one of the flat Tourmalins into a strong fire , for half an hour ; but could not , afterwards , perceive the least alteration .
I made the same experiment upon another Tourmalin , with the same success .
Exp. 53 .
Lastly , I heated the stone again , and , whilst it was red-hot , I threw it into water ; by which treatment the virtue of the Tourmalin was entirely destroyed , and it had the appearance of being shivered in many parts , without breaking .
IN regard to the internal frame of the Tourmalin , we can say nothing ; yet so much I have learned , by these experiments , that there are three different methods of heating the Tourmalin , which produce different electric appearances ; that different degrees of heat , afford different appearances ; that friction has the same effect upon it , as upon glass ; and that the Tourmalin , when it is heated properly , suffers a current of the electric fluid to pass through it in one direction only : so that the Tourmalin hath , as it were , two electrical poles , which are not easy to be destroyed or altered ; and farther , that there is not any substance in nature , which we are acquainted with , that the electric fluid does not readily pass through ; that there seems to be a constant flux and reflux of it in all bodies , as well in the air as in vacuo , occasioned by the alternate changes of heat and cold in every part of this globe .
All which things do very much confirm the opinion I formerly entertained , and attempted to prove by experiment , that the electric fluid is diffused throughout the whole earth , as well as in the air surrounding it * .
How far this flowing of the electric fluid may be concerned in the ordinary operations of nature , by keeping up that motion , which seems so necessary in the several parts of the grand machine , I leave to others , who may be more successful in their researches .
* See a Treatise on Electricity , the 2d Edit .
by B. Wilson .
By these advances , we have likewise attained to a more certain knowledge of that medium , which seems to surround the surfaces of all bodies , and which , being of a greater or less density , or exercising ( if I may so say ) a greater or less resistance , produces different effects , as the electric fluid ( or aether , if you please ) passes in and out of bodies , whenever they are disturbed by any external violence ; and , were it not for this medium surrounding all bodies , the electric fluid , I apprehend , could neither be accumulated , nor detained , in any body whatsoever .
This principle is very simple , and seems to be of a very general nature .
Our great philosopher adopted it from many experiments : he supposed , that the wonderful phenomenon of nature , particularly those of light , were not to be explained without it ; and therefore did not scruple to propose it , as a principle , to be farther inquired into .
I shall think my time well employed , if , by these inquiries , I have at all contributed to show , how much we are indebted to this happy Interpreter of Nature , and have afforded fresh occasion , by the light of his labours , to admire , and adore , the first cause of all things .
But whatever may be the success of my endeavours , they have at least been attended with a satisfaction , which not a little increases that desire I have ever had for pursuits of this kind .
I am , SIR , Your most obliged humble servant , Benja .
Wilson .
Great Queen-street , London , Nov. 9th , 1759 .

