XXX .
An Account of some extraordinary Effects of Lightning , in a Letter to Dr. Gowin Knight : By Mr. William Mountain , F. R. S. Dear Sir , THE following account of the effects of lightning , in my neighbourhood , I have drawn up for your perusal ; and , if it meets with your approbation , be pleased to communicate the same to the Royal Society , or dispose of it in any other manner , as you shall think proper .
Read Nov. 22 , 1759 .
During the morning of July the 16th last , was much thunder and lightning : about eight o'clock was heard an extraordinary loud crack , which seemed to me very near , as the large flash and sound were almost coincident .
In a few minutes , there was an alarm , that an house was on fire in Goat-street .
I readily suspected the cause , and soon after went to the place , in order to inquire into particulars , and was informed , that three houses were damaged in that place .
The first house I entered into was inhabited by Mr. William Loft , a custom-house waterman , which was almost untiled on the west side , and being of timber , was very much split and shattered : some of the weather-boards were thrown outwards to the bottom of the garden , to the distance of about thirty feet from the house , and the windows were forced inwards ; but no damage was done to this house by fire .
It may not be amiss to mention , that several small pieces of glass , in the leaded windows , were impelled with such force , as to stick very fast in a door which was opposite , and in the hard plaistered partition ; some of which I drew out of both , which , together with some bits of melted window-lead , you will find in the box No 1 .
The second house , that I examined , was that of Mr. Arthur Tawke , a sail-maker , on the opposite side of the street , to the eastward .
This was the house said to have been on fire ; and here I found the following accidents and effects ; viz. the windowshutters of the back parlour , on the east side , were shattered , and most of the bell-wire in this room melted ; its track on the wainscot much scorched , but more so at the cranks : a hole was burnt in a copper-plate print , which hung under the wire ; and , along the same side of the room , several rush-bottomed chairs were burnt in specks and holes of different ferent forms and sizes : the floor had the like marks of burning , more especially under the course of the wire : on the projections of the wainscot , I found several granulations , and longer pieces of the wire , some of which were bedded in burnt cavities .
A few of these , taken out by hand , I examined ; but could not find , that they were impregnated with any magnetic quality .
I afterwards employed magnets in search of the iron particles , which were found in the crevices of the wainscot , seams of the floor , and in the bottoms of the chairs , &amp;c. which you will meet with in the box No 2 .
The servant maid was standing in the door-way , between this room and the fore-parlour , when the stroke happened , and gives this very simple description of what she saw ; viz. ` ` that the appearance in the room was like a shower of fire.''-The dispersion and fall of the red-hot particles of the melted wire would make such a representation very natural .
In the fore-chamber , up one pair of stairs , which lies to the west , Mrs. Tawke was in bed , having lately laid-in : the flash alarmed her much ; but , having recovered from the fright , she perceived a sulphureous suffocating smell.-By her direction , a dark closet near the bed-side was examined , and found full of smoke and flames , which were soon extinguished .
Hence arose the before-mentioned report of an house being on fire .
In this closet , I found the bell-wire , coming from the parlour below , to be entirely melted , or dispersed , but the effect ceased at the crank , which transmitted it to the chamber adjoining , where it remained entire .
A pair of striped cotton trousers , at the distance of 4 or 5 feet from any part of the wire , were burnt almost to tinder , a piece of which is here preserved in the box No 5 .
An old wig-box was burnt in part : a sheet was burnt through several folds , in large holes , and also a blanket ; but the holes were smaller , tho ' of different sizes : the velvet cape of a surtout coat , at a greater distance from the wire , was treated in like manner ; tho ' the burnt spots were in general smaller .
Hence it seems , as if the particles of the fused wire did not all drop perpendicular ; but that they were actuated by some impellent force , and that the smaller granulations were diffused to a greater distance ; and hence arose that appearance of the shower of fire before-mentioned : and in this I am somewhat the more confirmed by some of the facts hereafter described .
Even some of the larger pieces were thrown to a great distance ; for here I found a wire mark burnt in the floor not less than six feet from any part of the suspended wire , and , on comparing a piece , which the maid picked up in the said place , with the said mark , it appeared to be the same , which produced that effect.-You will find it , being the largest in the box No 3 .
A deal box , standing on a cloaths-chest under the the wire , was burnt in spots even more remarkably than the floor , according to the figures and forms of the several pieces , particles , or granulations .
In this closet I also employed the magnets , and collected from the crevices , corners , &amp;c. a quantity of iron particles , which are contained in the box No 3 .
The third house , inhabited by Mr. Robert Harris senior , corn-factor , lies at the north-east corner of the same street , at the distance of about 40 yards .
Here I found some damage done to the glasses and China ware in a closet contiguous to one of the bellwires in a ground room : most of the wire in this room was melted ; and a piece of the deal moulding , nine inches long , covering the wire , and adjoining to the brass thumb-piece , very near the said closet , was splintered off , and struck the servant maid in the face , as she was entering the room , at about 14 feet distance .
In some of the rooms in the second story , the wires were in part melted .
In one room of the third story the wire was entirely dissipated ; the wall scorched ; the whole plaistering over the door , adjoining to the bell , driven out in a body ; the floor burnt ; and the sheets and quilt of a bed , near the bell-wire , scorched and fire-pitted in like manner as at Mr. Tawke 's ; only the effects of the ignited particles were not so general through this house , nor was any thing here absolutely set on fire .
I was afterwards informed , that tho ' all the wires were not destroyed , yet they had been obliged to renew the whole ; for , when they came to be examined , they were found so unpliable and brittle , as to be rendered quite useless .
On the 28th of July I went again to Mr. Tawke 's , who , being then at home , conducted me to a garret , which lies partly over the before-mentioned dark closet , from whence a bell-wire was directed to this room , by me unobserved before ; nor did the family very soon discover , that this wire was entirely melted , and the partition greatly scorched .
This room contained a large heap of oats , and another of beans , a foot-path , as it were , being reserved next the partition , where the ascending wire ran , which was covered with much dust and straggling grains of the corn.-Here again I employed the magnets , Mr. Tawke assisting , and collected a considerable quantity of melted particles , not only from the floor , joints and projections of the skirting-board , but from the holes and chasms in the broken plaistering , where-ever we could introduce the magnets , and that at the distance of 4 or 5 feet from the wire-place .
These you have in the box No 4 .
Hence I suspected , that granulae might be found among the oats : we probed , but to no no purpose ; the heap was too large , and had been moved , by fetching away what was wanted from time to time .
However , we carried our inquiry to the bare floor , quite across the heap , at 10 feet distance , and , in the joints or seams , found of very fine particles a sufficient quantity to prove , that they were violently diffused to a great distance .
From these houses the lightning seems to have tended towards the N. E. for in that direction , at the distance of about 200 yards , and not so far from my own house , Captain William Provost was struck thereby , standing in his own entry , and rendered almost senseless and speechless for some hours , and , for several days , was much afflicted with a stupor , giddiness , and vomiting , and retained a constant and strong taste of sulphur in his mouth and throat .
His child had hold of his cloaths , and his wife was near him ; but the stroke appears to have been above the child , as it seems to have struck him about the head .
No other damage was done here .
Mrs. Provost says , that the flash or fire seemed to be as large as a small pewter plate , and passed clear through the entry ( the doors being open ) directed to the northward .
On the opposite side of the street , and somewhat oblique towards the north-east , at the distance of about 20 yards , Mr. Ambrose Lyon , sail-maker , had , at the same time , about six dozen of bottles of Port wine broken to pieces .
The front of Mr. Lyon 's house has nearly a southwest aspect : among other conveniences under-ground is a substantial arched brick vault , and capacious for a private house ; it is quite close , having no light or opening into it , but at the door , which faces the south , and is always kept locked.-On the western side of this vault were reposited several casks of wine , most of them iron-bound ; also several dozens of rum behind them upon the floor .
On the northern end was a circular tub or cooler , iron-bound with three hoops , containing Port wine in bottles .
About ten feet from hence , on the eastern side , nearer the door , and directly opposite thereto , stood by itself another large circular cooler , 32 inches diameter , and 12 inches deep , bound also with three iron hoops , containing about six dozen of Portugal wine , called Barabarha , the remainder of a larger quantity , which he had kept in cask for more than two years before it was bottled , in which last state it had been for more than three months , and all proper care taken of it ; for he is very curious in these things .
These bottles were inclined upon their sides , for their better preservation , as were all the others containing wine ; and this tub was fixed upon skids ( pieces of timber ) about six inches thick .
In half an hour , or less , after the great thunderclap , having occasion to go into the vault , upon his entrance , he immediately discovered the noise of a running drip , and liquor flowing about the floor , which , upon further inspection , he found proceeded from the last-mentioned cooler , the bottles therein contained being broken to pieces , as if done by a mallet , not so much as one remaining entire of the whole quantity ; and the cooler being not very tight , the wine was running out from thence ; but , by a quick application of such vessels as were at hand , the remainder was preserved , and , after clearing it from the glass , was put into a small cask to recover , adding thereto about a one-third part of Port wine to fill up the vessel , some of which I have tasted ; and a bottle , drawn from the said cask , I herewith send you .
Mr. Lyon did not observe , at the same time , any kind of alteration in the said wine made by fermentation , or otherwise ; only that it was vapid or flat : one bottle of the said wine was afterwards found among the bottles of Port in the first-mentioned cooler , which was not affected , but was fine , and in perfection ; nor was any other damage done in the vault , that he could discover upon the strictest inquiry .
Captain John Dickinson , a gentleman in the neighbourhood , shared half the cask of the said wine , which had a similar management , was bottled off at the same time , and had a less cool and friendly vault ; yet not one bottle of this has hitherto been in anywise damaged .
I have been more particular in the examination of some of the foregoing facts , as they seem to contradict an opinion generally received , that the solution of metals by lightning is effected by a kind of cold fusion ; for it appears very evident , that the melted iron-wire , in the several preceding cases , had all the marks of heat and ignition , that usually attend the fusion of that metal , when brought about by common fire .
I am , Dear Sir , Your most obedient servant , Gainsford-street , Southwark , Septem .
28th , 1759 .
Wm. Mountain .
Some Remarks on the preceding Letter , by Gowin Knight , M. B. F. R. S. and Principal Librarian of the British Museum .
THE facts , contained in Mr. Mountaine 's letter , are an evident proof , that the fusion of metals by lightning is , sometimes at least , attended with heat and ignition , as in the case of common fusion .
And , since the reading of those facts , I have been more and more induced to suspect , that the received opinion of a cold fusion is a vulgar error , tho ' too generally adopted , and of very long standing .
From some of the circumstances attending these facts , compared with what is to be found in authors relating to the same subject , I think it possible both to show , whence this opinion first took its rise , and how it became so general ; and at the 4 Read Nov. 22 , the same time to prove , that there is no clear evidence for the truth of it from any relations hitherto published .
The instances , that are most generally given of cold fusion , are two ; that of a sword being melted in its scabbard , and that of money being melted in a bag , both the scabbard and bag remaining unhurt .
A great number of authors have mentioned both the facts , without giving their own testimony , or that of any one else , for the truth of them , or describing any of the other concomitant circumstances .
However , it seems possible , that lightning might produce effects sufficiently similar to these , to give rise to such reports , without our being obliged to have recourse to a cold fusion to account for them .
If at any time the edge or external surface of a sword had been melted , whilst the main part of the blade remained entire , it would have afforded sufficient grounds to assert , in general terms , that the sword was melted , and yet the scabbard might have remained unhurt ; because either the edge or surface of a sword might be instantly melted by lightning , and cooled so suddenly , as to make no impression of burning on the scabbard .
Metals , as well as other bodies , will both heat and cool sooner , in proportion as they are thin and slender .
Very small wire will instantly become red-hot , and even melt , and run into a round globule , in the flame of a common candle ; and it is no sooner removed out of the flame , but it is as instantly cool .
The edge of a sword therefore , or even its surface , might be instantly melted by lightning , and being in contact , or rather still united to the rest of the blade , which might be still cool , it would part with its heat too suddenly to produce any appearance of burning .
I was confirmed in this reasoning , by examining the fragments and melted particles of wire sent me by Mr. Mountain .
Amongst them there appeared to be globules of various sizes , which had undergone very different degrees of fusion : the largest of these had not been fluid enough to put on a spherical figure ; but they approached nearer thereto , in proportion as they were smaller : so that in the smallest granulae the fusion was most perfect , the globules being very round and smooth .
Their sizes continued diminishing , till they became invisible to the naked eye ; and some of them , when viewed with a microscope , required a third or fourth magnifier to see them distinctly .
Some of the bits of wire were rough and scaly , like burnt iron , and were swelled in those places where they were beginning to melt : others continued strait , and of an equable thickness ; but their outward surface seemed to have undergone a perfect fusion , so that there were two or more pieces adhering together , as if joined by a thin solder .
In Mr. Pitfold 's account of the effects of lightning at Darking in Surry , published in the Philosophical Transactions * , mention is made of a similar fact .
He says , ` ` some small tacks were soldered together , six , seven , eight , or ten in a clump , as if they had had scalding metal run over them .
' ' It is easy to conceive , how the heat of this supersicial fusion might be so suddenly diffused throughout * Philos. Trans. Vol. XLIX .
p. 311 .
the metal it surrounded , which the lightning might not have heated , as instantly to have reduced the whole to too cool a state , for any other contiguous body to be burnt thereby .
In like manner , a stream of lightning passing thro ' a bag of money , might fuse the surfaces of such pieces as lay in its way , and solder a number of them together ; and yet the bag remain unhurt .
An accident or two of this kind may have come , by tradition , to the knowledge of some of the first collectors of marvellous facts , and from them be transcribed by others , perhaps with additions and improvements .
Thus , according to Pliny * , both gold , silver , and brass , have been melted in bags sealed up , which were not in the least burnt , nor was the wax of the seals melted : whereas Seneca ~ speaks only of silver being melted in the pocket or purse , which remained whole and unhurt .
Later writers seem to have copied from one of these for the most part , without mentioning their authority .
In the Philosophical Transactions are two or three relations , which seem , at first , to favour a cold fusion ; but , when duly considered , prove nothing conclusively .
The first is in a paper concerning the effects of lightning at Colchester , on July 16 , 1708 ; which concludes with observing , that , ` ` during the same storm , four persons were killed in a boat , that was going from Harwich to Ipswich ; and that , in one of their pockets , a watch and chain was melted all on a lump .
' ' In another account , given by Or* Plin .
Not .
Hist , lib. ii .
c. 51 .
~ Seneca , Not .
Quaest .
l. ii .
c. 32 .
lando Bridgman , Esq ; describing the same storm , it is said , that ` ` the chain of the watch was melted , and that no harm or burn could be perceived on his breeches or cloaths .
' ' Now , if both the watch and chain were melted all on a lump , and the pocket unburnt , as might be concluded from both these accounts laid together , it would be a strong argument in favour of cold fusion : but there is great reason to suspect the truth of the first-mentioned relation ; because the author of it writes only from hearsay , being himself at Colchester , at several miles distance from where the thing happened .
Whereas Mr. Bridgman was upon the spot , and examined one of the dead bodies himself very minutely ; and tho ' he does not say , that he saw the body of him , whose watchchain was melted , yet he gives a very circumstantial account of it ; and , if the watch had been melted , as well as the chain , he could not have omitted that particular .
It is therefore probable , that the chain only was melted , and that , hanging out of the pocket , it had left no marks of burning on the breeches .
We have , in our Transactions , another account of the effects of lightning by Dr. Cookson , of Wakefield ~ , who relates , ` ` That the lightning fell on a box of knives and forks , and melted a great many of them , the sheaths being untouched .
' ' But the doctor , in another account , which is fuller and more exact , says , ` ` the lighting dispersed a great many dozen of knives and forks , which were put up in a box , all over the room .
Upon gathering them * Philos. Trans. Abr .
Vol. V. p. 154 .
~ Ibid. Vol. VIII .
p. 504 .
up , some of them were melted ; others snapped in sunder ; others had their hafts burnt ; others their sheaths either singed or burnt ; others not .
' ' From all which circumstances , duly considered , I think nothing certain in favour of cold fusion can be fairly

