XXVIII .
Thoughts on the different Impregnation of Mineral Waters ; more particularly concerning the Existence of Sulphur in some of them , by John Rutty , Doctor of Physic .
INASMUCH as the existence of sulphur in waters hath been doubted , not only by Lister and Hoffman , but by another author , that has lately appeared , to whom the public has been , in some measure , indebted for exploding sulphur from some waters , on which it had been too liberally , and without the due evidence of experiment , attributed ; I have therefore thought it worth while to review , collect , and sum up , the evidences of sulphur in waters , in order to show , not only that antiquity hath not altogether rashly attributed sulphur to waters , but how far the existence of that mineral is demonstrable to sense in several , and more especially the cold , waters of that denomination .
Read Nov. 15 , 1759 .
1 .
That the fetor of these waters is not owing to mere stagnation ; and that they possess something more than what common water acquires by putrefaction , appears not only from Dr. Short 's observation of some of these having a full and brisk current , but because putrid rain-water , and many of our chalybeat waters , turned putrid by keeping , do not discolour metals , as these waters do .
2 .
The effects of these waters , and their vapours , in discolouring metals , and their peculiar smell and flavour , like that of boiled eggs , and in the stronger like that of rotten eggs , are perfectly similar to those of the artificial solution of sulphur , and its vapours .
3 .
Many of these waters , both foreign and domestic , are found to contain the native alcaline salt , which is the proper menstruum for , and has the same effect in , dissolving sulphur , as the artificial alcali ; viz. not only the hot waters of Aix la Chapelle and Borsel , but the cold of Geronsterre ; and , in England , those of Chadlington , Nottington , Bilton , Quincamel , Suttonbog , and Wigglesworth ; and the following in Ireland , viz. those of Swadlingbar , Derrylester , Lisblenk , Ashwood , Derryherce , Anaduff , Aghaloo , and one lately discovered at Lucan near Dublin .
4 .
Accordingly a milkiness , or incipient precipitation , analogous to lac sulphuris , is produced in several of these waters , by dropping acids into them ; particularly in those of Aix la Chapelle , even according to Dr. Lucas 's own testimony of the effects of distilled vinegar on it , and in that of Moffat in Scotland ; of Harrigate ; in our Swadlingbar water , and another of our springs of this sort in the C. Fermanagh : and to this add the white hairy mucus ordinarily precipitated on the sticks , or grass , in the passage of these waters , analogous to a magistery of sulphur .
5 .
The sulphur in waters is in a most highly attenuated , subtle , and fugitive , state ; insomuch that , as Dr. Lucas observes of those of Aix la Chapelle , there is a great alteration in the colour of the precipitate caused by solution of silver in that , which hath been immediately drawn from the source , and that which has lain by only twenty seconds , even in a bottle filled , and close stopped ; so soon is it lost or dissrpated : and moreover , it is also blended with other minerals ; so that it is no wonder it should be difficult to exhibit a palpable sulphur , and that the distinguishing appearances proper to that mineral should often fail , particularly the above-mentioned test by acids , and the burning blue .
6 .
That a real sulphur , or bituminoso-sulphureous substance , is dissolved in these waters , and subsists in some of their less volatile or more fixed parts , is evident from the following appearances in the mud and scum collected from several of them : for the mud of several of the cold waters I have called sulphureous , as well as that of several hot baths in Germany and Hungary , mentioned by Browne in his Travels , is variegated with the several colours of yellow , green , and red , as the real sulphur , and , in some experiments , burnt with a blue flame , and a sulphureous smell ; and the like evidences may be given of the sulphureous quality of the scum of divers of our cold waters , particularly in that of Mechan , in the north of Ireland , which , being dried , exhibited on the upper side a whitish yellow , or cream-colour ; but underneath a deep grass-green , a pale , beautiful gold-colour , and a light reddish pink-colour , interspersed in a substance of a leaden blackish colour ; every colour excellent in its kind , and as slippery as frogs spawn : varieties of colours , like these , being also found in the preparation of lac sulphuris variously exposed to the air .
But , to come to more direct proofs , we are assured , in Short 's first volume of his History of mineral waters , as to the cold waters of Harrigate , that both the mud and scum burnt with a blue flame , and smelt strong of sulphur ; and that great quantities of yellow sublimed flowers of sulphur have been found under the basons of that well .
And Dr. Peter Shaw affirms , that real brimstone , even found to be so by proper trials , hath been seen floating in the water like feathers , and separable by bare straining : and to all this agrees the observation I have frequently made on several of these cold waters , viz. certain light purple-coloured pellicles are frequently found floating in them , which , being dried , sparkle , flame , and stink , on the red-hot iron .
But , to conclude , the operation and effects of several of these our cold waters , altogether similar to those of sulphur , abundantly confirm their impregnation with that mineral .
Thus it appears , that sulphur is not confined to the hot baths of Aix la Chapelle , and a few more abroad , but is found also in the cold waters of both England and Ireland ; and as these have , of late years , been subjected to a minute examination , I shall subjoin a brief comparison between the one and the other from experiment and observation : thus , 1 .
Is the smell of the waters of Aix la Chapelle like that of the washings of a foul gun , or like that of the solution of sulphur in an alcaline lye ?
So is that of our cold waters called sulphureous .
2 .
Do Aix la Chapelle waters , taken from their source , turn silver of a gold-colour , and blackish ; and with its solution , and that of sugar of lead , exhibit a dark-coloured precipitation ?
So do our waters called sulphureous .
3 .
Does Aix la Chapelle water , on dropping distilled vinegar into it , exhibit a milkiness , analogous to lac sulphuris ?
So divers of the cold waters abovementioned do also exhibit a white cloud with other acids .
4 .
Do the waters of Aix la Chapelle and Borsel contain an alcaline salt ?
So do many of our cold waters above enumerated .
5 .
Is silver , borne in the pockets during a course of Aix la Chapelle waters , tarnished ?
The like effect hath been observed in several of our cold waters .
6 .
Do the waters of Aix la Chapelle yield flowers of sulphur ?
and do some of the springs of Borsel precipitate a magistery of sulphur ?
The like hath been observed in some of our cold waters above enumerated .
7 .
Are the baths of Aix la Chapelle of known efficacy in the cure of the itch , impetigo , vitiligo , and ulcers ?
So are the cold waters above enumerated , as appears from the signal successes , which have attended their use , even in some of the most inveterate and rebellious disorders of this kind .
Is there any rashness then in concluding , that these our cold waters do also contain sulphur substantially dissolved in them , and differ from the hot ones of Aix la Chapelle and Borsel in nothing but heat , and the different proportions of impregnating minerals of the same quality ?
Hence appears the great usefulness of examining mineral waters in concert ; for as various accidental circumstances give occasion to different appearances , the examination of a competent number and variety of them , helps to supply the defects in the histories of some of them .
And , if this were further prosecuted , I doubt not but sulphur in substance might be obtained from several of them , as well as from Aix ; which is therefore recommended to physicians and naturalists .
So much may suffice concerning such waters , wherein sulphur is the predominating ingredient ; but there are others , wherein there are strong indications of its presence in a smaller proportion , and mixed with other minerals ; and indeed , perhaps , few waters are without an admixture of it ; for , beside several plain waters , especially such as contain the native alcali , and the purging waters , sea-water , the brinesprings , and the chalybeate waters , all which manifest a fetor by putrefaction , and some of them thereupon the like discolourations of metals as the sulphureous waters , the chalybeate waters , in particular , manifest a sulphureous admixture , by the cream , which they throw up to the surface , the various colours whereof , and its discolouring metals , are marks of sulphur .
There are , moreover , several other waters , even some of those , which otherwise make the nearest approach to pure element , having very little salts or earth , which I have mentioned in the beginning of this work , which also give strong suspicions of some degree of a sulphureous impregnation , by the purple and black sediments precipitated from them by solution of silver ; which are eminently confirmed by a late examination of the celebrated Holy wells at Malvern , published in the 50th volume of the Transactions , and there extolled for many cures ; which , altho ' they do not yield quite a grain of solid contents from a pint upon evaporation , give three evidences of sulphur .
1 .
The purple powder precipitated from them by solution of silver .
2 .
In exhaling the water slowly in a silver vessel , the bottom of the vessel was tinged of a pale yellow colour , as if it had been gilded .
3 .
When exhaled almost to a dryness , it emitted vapours of the smell of burning brimstone .
And lastly , besides all these , I have frequently remarked of several other waters , here and there mentioned in this work , that their sediments , obtained by evaporation , did manifest some pittance of this mineral , by the fetor they acquired on being rubbed with salt of Tartar ; which , in the language of our author above-mentioned , being attracted by the acid , the phlogiston is let loose .
I have above recommended the farther investigation of sulphur as a desideratum in the history of mineral waters ; and shall now beg leave to conclude this paper with the mention of two or three more articles , which greatly want further elucidation .
The first is alum , which , although hitherto found but in extremely few waters , and chiefly in those of Nevil Holt , Ballycastle acid water , and perhaps in the Hartfell water in Scotland , above-mentioned , according to some late experiments ; yet the genuine crystals of alum have not as yet been satisfactorily demonstrated in any of these .
The second is the volatile mineral alcali , which the nitre of the ancients contained ; and some of our mineral waters here and there give strong suspicions of , by the experiments with a mixture of quick-lime , and of the solution of mercury sublimate corrosive : but this matter greatly merits farther inquiry , and several difficulties attending it remain necessary to be explained .
Thirdly , the hint lately given in the 49th Vol. Part .
II .
of the Transactions , of the efficacy of the Carolsbadt water , as superior to lime-water , in dissolving stones out of the body , if confirmed by correspondent events in the internal use , would be a discovery of the greatest moment , and highly deserves to be prosecuted .
I shall only observe here , that the principal minerals impregnating it are a native alcaline salt , and a calcarious earth ; and that the Aix la Chapelle waters are not without such a salt and earth also , and , which is of more moment , they are reported , by long taking , to render the urine alcaline , even as do the Carolsbadt waters ; and we are also told , that calculi , macerated twenty-four hours in the water of Aix la Chapelle , have been reduced to a sand , or soft consistence : but how far this last , the Selters , the Bourne waters , or our Tilbury water , or others alike impregnated , may participate of a like virtue , must be determined by further observation and experience .
Dublin , the 24th 3d mo .
1759 .

