XXVII .
Some Remarks upon the several Accounts of the fiery Meteor ( which appeared on Sunday the 26th of November , 1758 ) , and upon other such Bodies ; by John Pringle , M. D. F. R. S. IN my last paper , I laid before the Society all the accounts I had received of the meteor , of the 26th of November , 1758 ; which I could not reduce into a narrower compass , without the hazard of omitting such observations , as might be judged necessary for ascertaining some of the principal circumstances ; or without passing over those facts , which , however immaterial they may appear at present , might afterwards afford some light in explaining the nature of these phenomenon .
I have even inserted some particulars contradictory to others , that Iimagined more likely to be true , as I myself might be deceived , and as , by preserving the several relations entire , I thereby did most justice to the observers .
The deception of the senses , upon the appearance of unusual objects , the short continuance of the meteors , and Ll2 the Read Dec. 20 , the surprise occasioned by them , at a late hour , among people unaccustomed to think on these subjects , will sufficiently account , not only for the variety , but the contradictions , in the several observations .
I come next to the result of all the relations , with regard to the true path , the velocity , figure , magnitude , and other circumstances relating to this body ; which having deduced in the best manner I could from the preceding materials , I shall now submit to the judgment of the Society .
But as my last paper on this subject was of so great a length , I shall not farther insist on it now , than barely to mention the conclusions I have made , without losing time in recapitulating the several steps that led me to them * .
First then , as to the path .
This meteor seems to have been vertical at Cambridge , or nearly so , and to have taken fire about the zenith of that place ; or at least to have appeared first there in a state of ignition .
From thence it proceeded directly , almost N. W. by N. over several counties in England , over the Solway frith ( which it crossed between Carlisle and the town of Dumfries ) ; and in Scotland over the shires of Dumfries and Lanerk : but soon after its becoming vertical to the last , viz. a few miles to the southward of Douglas ( or perhaps nearer to the borders of Lanerk and the shire of Air , about 10 or 12 miles to the eastward of Auchenleck ) , part of the tail seemed to break off , and to disperse in bright sparks of fire ; whilst the head , into which the remainder of the tail was instantly collected , moved on in the same * Some of the most material are subjoined in notes to the former paper , since it was first presented to the Society .
direction , till coming over Fort William , in the shire of Inverness , after a course of about 400 miles , it there suddenly disappeared .
But , notwithstanding the extinction of the meteor at this place , it seems still to have proceeded northwards ; since it was seen again , in a luminous state , in a globular form , but without a tail , about the 58o of latitude , on the western coast of the shire of Ross , almost vertical to the observer ; moving then to the southward of the east ; that is , in a direction almost contrary to the first : and in this last course , of which we know not the end , it possibly might have gone a great way to the eastward .
During the first part of its progress , viz. from Cambridge to Fort William , it went obliquely downwards , in such a manner , that , by computation , it must have been from about 90 to 100 miles high at the first of these places , and between 26 and 32 miles at the last .
But at what height it was afterwards seen in the shire of Ross , is not to be determined , since one observation only was transmitted to me from that country .
As Dr. Mackenzie observed it nearly over his head , and yet of a smaller size than the full moon when some hours above the horizon , I should suspect , that , after its descent to Fort William , it had reascended at the time he saw it ; because he probably would have described it as a larger body , if then not higher than when it first disappeared .
This dipping and rising , in the course of a meteor , is not more extraordinary than its lateral deviation from a straight line , as I have elsewhere shown * .
Such * See the note subjoined to Obs. XXVII .
are the facts , tho ' , perhaps , it may be hard to account for them from the common principles of motion .
What seemed most likely to be the cause of the vertical change of its direction , was its rapid descent towards the earth , till it came so low as that the resistance of the air might act upon it ; in which case , the lower part of the body meeting with denser air than the upper , it would be so reflected from that medium as to ascend ; for tho ' , at the height of 20 or 30 miles , the air is extremely rarefied , yet , in this instance , the immense velocity of the impingent body will make a less resisting medium produce a greater effect .
The meteor , therefore , might be reflected by the air , in the same manner as a cannon ball by water , when it strikes it in a very oblique direction .
If this reasoning can be admitted , we may account for the lateral variation of its path , in the manner following .
Although it should seem , that , during the first part of the course , the wind was at S. E. yet , when the meteor advanced towards the north of Scotland , it there probably met with a westerly wind ; from this circumstance in Dr. Mackenzie 's letter , of the sea being that night remarkably louder than at any other time during a whole month he had been at Flowerdale : for that place lies on the western ocean , in the shire of Ross ; and there , I imagine , the sea could not produce that stormy noise , unless the wind had blown from some point between the west and the north .
If therefore the current of the air obliquely opposed the motion of the meteor , that body would be gradually reflected into a new direction ; from which , by another current , it might have been turned a second or a third time , until it fell at last into that path described by the doctor .
From this account it will follow , that the lower a meteor descends , the more irregular its course will be ; as it will then meet with the most resistance , both from the density and the currents of the air .
In regard to the velocity , it seems almost incredible ; as we have sufficient data for computing it at the rate of 30 miles in a second .
But if we allow , that it only moved through half the space in that time , we shall find the progression of this body to have been above 100 times swifter than the mean celerity of a cannon ball , and nearly equal to that of the earth in its orbit round the sun .
As to its real size , we cannot pretend to determine that point with any precision ; since its dazzling brightness would occasion some deception , and the apparent magnitude has been so differently represented by the observers .
If the meteor , when nearest to Dublin , appeared to Mr. Garret equal to the full moon , then we shall find , that its true diameter was about two miles ; and if the farmer at Ancram saw this body , whilst it was vertical at Cambridge , of a size equal to the crown of his cap , or to about half that of the full moon , we cannot allow less than a mile for the real axis .
Upon estimating from the observations made at St. Andrews and Dunfermline , the diameter was at least half a mile , and perhaps much greater .
However , as the imagination is so apt to enlarge such objects , we shall put the size of the globe at the smallest , and reckon it only about a mile and a half round .
The body must surely have been of a considerable bulk to have yielded such a light , as that , when in the zenith of Cambridge , the farmer at Ancram ( at the distance of above 260 miles ) should , upon entering his threshold , see the whole side of his house illuminated by it ; and , to use his own expression , with a brightness as of sun-shine .
And indeed the greatness of the light is every-where taken notice of , even at those places where the atmosphere was so thick as to hide the tail , nay , the whole meteor , as at Auchenleck , where it was nearly vertical .
As for the tail , it was a stream of light several miles in length ; for this was no deception , like what we suppose the train of a shooting star to be , but was either a real flame , or , what is more probable , it consisted partly of flame , but mostly of smaller masses of fire ( which the observers call sparks , when falling out of the lucid tract ) , and of vapours or fuliginous particles , not heated red-hot , but illuminated by the parts actually burning .
Perhaps these vapours were the chief part of the composition , and which will account for its light being so much fainter than that of the head ; since in some places where the air was less clear , or the distance greater , we find the whole meteor described either as a round ball , or a spheroid ( with the largest axis in the direction of its motion ) , but without a tail .
In this last case , viz. that of the oval form , it is probable that , besides the head , the beginning of the tail was also visible , as consisting of flame , and therefore brighter than the rest ; and that both together appeared oblong to those observers .
But such as were nearest , and had a clear atmosphere , saw the tail of a considerable length ; that is , the flame , the sparks and the illuminated vapour , in a train behind the head , as being lighter , and therefore meeting with more resistance from the air ; in the same manner as the flame , the sparks , and smoke , of a torch are seen to follow it .
All this is plain ; but , in regard to that separation of the third part of the tail from the rest , a circumstance clearly described by the farmer at Ancram , and seemingly confirmed by other observations , there may be some difficulty .
Perhaps at this period , upon a greater explosion in the ball , most of the combustible matter was thrown out at once , which falling behind , occasioned that appearance of the breaking off a part of the tail , whilst , for want of fuel , the remainder vanished , or , as the observer expresses it , was collected into the head .
This account is rendered more probable , by what is said of the emission of a greater light about this time , and by the loud report heard by the farmer five minutes after , and which , upon computing the distance , ought to have reached him much about that time , had it been occasioned by this extraordinary bursting and dispersion of the inflammable matter .
The hissing noise , taken notice of by some while the meteor passed them , was a deception of that kind , which frequently connects sound with motion ; and is the case of those who fancy they hear something , when they see the shootings of the aurora borealis ; I say a deception , because if the meteor , during its course , really made any noise , so great was the distance of that body , and so short its continuance , that this sound could not have been heard till some minutes after the return of darkness .
But the final report , so frequently mentioned , not only heard by those who saw the light , but by others who knew nothing of what had happened , was a real sound , and immensely greater than any we are acquainted with .
For , at the distance of 70 miles and upwards , it was compared to loud thunder , the report of heavy artillery , the fall of the gabel-end of the house the person was in , and to a musket fired off in the garret .
If this noise was produced when the body threw out those masses of burning matter ( by the observers called sparks of fire , the bursting of the tail , and delineated in Fig. 5 .
as balls of a smaller size in the train itself ) , we shall find , that at this time the meteor , by being more than 41 miles high , was in a region where the air is three thousand times rarer than on the surface of the earth ; that is , about six times rarer than in a common exhausted receiver , where sonorous bodies are not heard , and even where gunpowder and the pulvis fulminans take fire , and are exploded , but without noise .
Hence I would infer , that the separation of the elastic matter must have been performed with a velocity exceeding all imagination ; as the intensity of sound so much depends on the resistance of the air , and as this elastic matter could fly off with so much celerity , as to find so great an opposition from so thin a medium * .
I should also conclude from the great report , that the substance of the meteor was of a firmer texture than what could arise from mere exhalations , whether formed into a sphere , and then burning ; or dis* M. Saluce has lately shown , by some curious experiments , that such substances as gunpowder and the pulvis fulminans , have a detonation in proportion to the rapidity with which the internal air is separated , and to the resistance of the external air .
See Miscell .
Taurinens .
Tom. I. posed into a kind of train , and consumed by a running fire : for sounds , as far as we know , are either produced by the quick and violent percussions of hard bodies upon the air ; or by the sudden expansion of an elastic fluid , after being condensed within some solid substance .
The noise occasioned by the motion of electrical matter is , perhaps , the only exception ; but we have no reason to imagine , that this was at all concerned in the present case .
There seems to be the more ground for believing this body was solid , at least that its surface was so , from finding , that , after the violent explosion , it still retained its form ; a circumstance that could hardly take place , if the meteor had consisted of nothing but vapours .
We may therefore presume , that the burning matter found vent through a hard crust by certain apertures , which either might have been there invisible , or unobserved .
All I can say in support of this conjecture is , that , by the Memoires of the Academy of Bologna , we find a meteor appeared in Italy in the year 1719 , lower in the air than that we have now been treating of , and in which , it is pretended , four several chasms were distinguished , each emitting smoke * .
To these arguments for the solidity of this body , we may add its extreme velocity , and the intensity of the light ; which are likewise circumstances more conformable to a heavy and solid substance , than to one formed of exhalations only .
Upon the whole , I believe it will appear , that these relations are not favourable to the prevailing * Apparebant in eo hiatus seu voragines quatuor fumum exhalantes .
Instit .
&amp; Acad. Bonon .
Tom. I. p. 285 .
hypothesis about the formation of such bodies , which makes them to consist of certain sulphureous vapours arising from the earth : for , besides what has been urged above , Dr. Halley has shown , ` ` That , at the height of 41 miles , the air is so rarefied as to take up 3000 times the space it occupies on the surface of the earth ; and that , at 53 miles high , it would be expanded above 30000 times : but thinks it is probable , that the utmost power of its spring cannot exert itself to so great an extension ; and that no part of the atmosphere reaches above 45 miles * .
' ' This being the case , how can we suppose any such vapours to rise to the height of 90 or 100 miles , where the air must be so many millions of times rarer than what we breathe ?
Again , we find that all vapours , in their ascent , mutually repel one other ; so little do they seem disposed to run together into globes of such a size .
But Dr. Halley observes ( in treating of the great meteor of March 1719 ) , ` ` That tho ' the aqueous , and most of the other vapours , are soon condensed by cold ; and wanting a certain degree of specific gravity in the air to buoy them up , ascend but to a small height ; ' ' yet he adds , in favour of the opinion of these bodies being formed of exhalations , ` ` That the inflammable sulphureous vapours , by an innate levity , have a sort of vis centrifuga , and not only have no need of the air to support them , but , being agitated by heat , will ascend in vacuo Boileano .
' ' From hence he infers , That the sulphureous vapours , disengaged from all other particles , may rise far above the reputed * Phil. Trans. No 181 .
p. 104 .
Abridge .
Vol. II .
ch .
1 .
~ 9 .
limits of the atmosphere ; and contracting themselves into a narrower compass , by that principle of nature that congregates the homogenea , may lie like a train of gunpowder in the aether , till catching fire by some internal ferment , the flame may be communicated to its continued parts , and so run on like a train fired , ' ' &amp; c * .
But this hypothesis of that excellent naturalist seems liable to the following difficulties .
1 .
What are the experiments which show , that inflammable vapours have any sort of a vis centrifuga ; or will rise either in an absolute vacuum , or in a medium where the meteors are often found , and where , according to the doctor , the air must be five hundred times rarer than in a common exhausted receiver ~ ? ?
2 .
Altho ' sulphureous vapours may ascend from the earth , upon being agitated by heat , will not that volatility soon cease , by the coldness of the air , long before they can arrive at the upper regions ? ?
3 .
Does not all matter , capable of taking flame , suppose a proportion of an acid salt , adherent to the phlogistic principle , and consequently some gravitation ? ?
4 .
And will not the weight be increased by the large quantity of condensed air , or some other elastic fluid combined with the inflammable vapours , which is the cause of the explosion and report ? ?
5 .
Are we not led to this notion about the innate levity and vis centrifuga of igneous matter , from finding , that heat has a greater tendency upwards * Phil. Trans. No 360 .
p. 978 .
Abr .
Vol. IV .
Par. II .
Ch. 1 .
~ 28 .
~ His expression is , above three hundred thousand times rarer than what we breathe .
than downwards ?
but is not this owing to that portion of the air , which , receiving the heat , and being thereby dilated , becomes specifically lighter than the rest , and therefore rises in the colder and more condensed atmosphere ? ?
6 .
Suppose attraction to take place , should not those vapours , by that law , assume a globular form , and not , like a train , contract in breadth , and extend in length ? ?
7 .
What is to set this train on fire ; since a ferment , according to the chemists , implies a mixture of heterogeneous parts , contrary to the doctor 's hypothesis ? ?
8 .
How comes this train to be drawn out in so straight a line , and of so equal a breadth , insomuch that , in the path of the late meteor , for about 400 miles , there was no sensible deviation , nor any change in the magnitude of the luminous appearance , but what might be accounted for from its greater or less distance from the observer , or its being seen through a clearer or an obscurer atmosphere ?
Some have been of opinion , that these fiery meteors are only a kind of lightning , at greater heights than common ; forming their notion upon the velocity of those balls of fire , and upon the sound accompanying them , so much resembling that of thunder .
But this hypothesis having gained no credit , I need not employ time in refuting it ; and the less now , as the nature of lightning is so much better understood than when this theory was first published .
I shall only observe , that before the matter of lightning was discovered to be of the electrical kind , it was natural to suppose it to be formed of the sulphureous vapours arising from the earth ; and if the earth was found proper for producing such exhalations , of course it was judged capable of furnishing materials for all the lucid phenomenon in the ethereal regions .
Thus , not an hundred years ago , the comets themselves were accounted for on no better principle ; and therefore we are the less to wonder if these meteors have been hitherto almost constantly referred , even by the best naturalists , to the same origin .
Of all the hypotheses that have come to my knowlege on this subject , a hint of Dr. Halley 's ( in a paper presented to the Society several years before the above-mentioned ) , seems best to agree with the late meteor ; viz. that such bodies may be formed independent of any vapours from the earth * .
But , with regard to the rest of his conjecture , that the one he described , ` ` might be a collection of matter formed in the aether by some fortuitous concourse of atoms ; and that the earth had met with it newly formed , and before it had conceived any great impetus of descent towards the sun , ' ' I say , with regard to these circumstances , they are not at all supported by the present case : for , if we consider the immense velocity with which the late meteor moved northwards ( and in judging of which we could not be deceived by either the diurnal or annual motion of the earth ) , we must be convinced that the earth did not meet with it before it had conceived a considerable impetus of descent , either towards the sun , or some other attracting power .
And altho ' there was likewise a motion of this body towards the earth , as appeared by the dipping of its path , yet it did not come quite down , * Phil. Trans. No 341 .
p. 159 .
Abr .
Vol. IV .
Par. II .
Ch. 1 .
~ 25 .
as might have been expected , had gravitation to the earth been the only principle concerned ; but it descended no lower than to a certain depth in the atmosphere , after which it seems to have risen again , and made a considerable progress in the higher regions ; contrary to Dr. Halley 's opinion about such meteors , which , he believed , actually came to the ground * .
And here I will venture to affirm , that , after perusing all the accounts I could find of these phenomenon , I have met with no well-vouched instance of such an event : nor is it to be imagined but that , considering the frequency of such appearances , if these meteors had really fallen , there must have been long ago so strong evidence of the fact , as to leave no room to doubt of it at present .
Their descent , under the horizon , is sufficient to make the common observers believe they see them come to the ground , whilst an explosion , high up in the air , coming late to their ears , passes for the crashing noise of the fall .
Not that I call in question the possibility of their touching the earth ; which they are likely to do as often as they move perpendicularly towards it , and not in that oblique direction so often mentioned , and by which means , it should seem , they are constantly reflected by our atmosphere .
All that I would conclude is , that hitherto we have had no certain proof of their fall ; and it is to be hoped , that their motions , like those of the comets , have been so regulated at first by a governing Power , that we have nothing to apprehend from their aberration .
Unless we should imagine , that the perpendicular descent and bursting of * Vide loc. cit. one of these bodies has given rise to the story of Phaeton ; since no other event will , perhaps , so well account for not only the foundation of that fable , but for a prevailing opinion among the ancients , that~ besides a large tract of country , even the heavens themselves , in appearance , had once suffered by a conflagration .
If it is then probable , that these balls of fire come from regions far beyond the reach of our vapours ; if they approach often so near to the earth , and so seldom or never touch it ; if they are moved with so much celerity , as in that respect to have the character of celestial bodies ; if they are seen flying in all directions , and consequently have a motion of their own , independent of that of our globe ; if they part with such quantities of an elastic fluid , a phlogistic matter , and probably an acid , surely we are not to consider them as indifferent to us , much less as fortuitous masses , or trains of terrestrial exhalations in the ethereal regions ; but rather as bodies of a nobler origin , possibly revolving about some center , formed and regulated by the Creator for wise and beneficent purposes , even with regard to our atmosphere ; which , during their combustion , they may supply with some subtle and salutary matter , or remove from it such parts as begin to be superfluous , or noxious to the inhabitants of the earth .
Since these sheets were printed off , Dr. Pringle received another letter from Sir Robert Pringle , acquainting him , he had not found that part of his intelligence hold good , of the ship-master 's seeing the meteor ( of the 26th of November 1758 ) in the Baltic ; but , upon further inquiry , had learnt , that though this person had observed an appearance of the same kind in those seas , it was not on the same day .
Dr. Pringle thinks it likewise proper to inform the public , that , since his paper was printed , he has received two further accounts of the meteor , one from Mr. Pringle , sheriff-depute of the shire of Roxburgh , the other from Mr. Garret , of Island-Bridge , near Dublin .
Mr. Pringle says , ` ` that having , since his last letter , drawn a more accurate meridian , at the farmer 's house at Ancram , he now finds , that the shepherd 's house ( mentioned p. 236 ) bears nearly S. E. by S. from the farmer 's dwelling house ; that the hill with the trees , over which the meteor seemed to break ( laid down in Fig. IV .
as at 92~ 30~ W. of the meridian ) , really bore W. by N. from the observer ; and that the bearing of the luminous body , at the point of its extinction , was nearly W. N. W. and not due N. W. as the farmer at first imagined , who , upon this last survey , was convinced of his mistake .
' ' Upon this communication , Dr. Pringle drew~ on two different maps , a W. N. W. line from Ancram to the path of the meteor , and found , that in Elphinston 's map of Scotland , the intersection was a few miles to the eastward of Glasgow , but in Kitchin 's map a little to the westward of it .
In consequence of these last observations , the Doctor has fixed the point of extinction to the zenith of that city .
But as Glasgow lies about 76 miles to the southward of Fort William , over which the meteor , in the preceding paper , was supposed to disappear , the first course of that body is reduced to about 324 miles in thirteen seconds of time , and its velocity therefore to about 25 miles in one second .
Mr. Pringle has likewise acquainted the Doctor , ` ` that the farmer , on seeing the engraving of the 4th figure ( of which Mr. Pringle had received a copy ) , had found fault with the size of the head of the meteor , as being too large in proportion to the length of the whole ; since , to his imagination , the diameter of the head did not exceed 8 inches , and that the tail seemed to be about 3 or 4 yards long .
' ' Mr. Garret acquaints Dr. Pringle , ` ` that , since his first letter to the Doctor , Emanuel Miller and he , having communicated their observations to Mr. William Gibson , mathematician , at Dublin , that gentleman had come to Island-Bridge , and having made a survey with his instruments , found , that the greatest altitude of the meteor was no more than 12 degrees .
' '

