XXIV .
An Account of some Experiments relating to the Preservation of Seeds : In Two Letters to the Right Honourable the Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society .
From John Ellis , Esq ; F. R. S. My Lord , London , Jan. 18 .
1759 .
AS the supplying our colonies with the seeds of useful plants , in order to have their produce imported from thence into England , instead of the places of their natural growth in Europe , Asia , and Africa , as we do at present , is a matter of some importance , therefore I am persuaded , that experiments tending to promote so useful and beneficial a work , will meet with the approbation of this honourable Society .
Read Jan. 18 , 1759 .
Among many useful seeds , which I sent governor Ellis in the year 1757 , were some acorns of the corktree , which were put in a box in sand .
These , he mentions in his last letters , were entirely spoiled in the voyage ; and observes , that the confined air in the hold of ships , occasions such hot and penetrating steams , especially in warm climates , that it disposes all seeds , in common packages , to a sweating or putrefactive fermentation , by which the vegetative quality of many is entirely destroyed : and therefore advises , vises , that seeds should be sent in tight casks , and placed on or near the deck , so as to have the benefit of the fresh circulating air , at the same time the tightness of the cask would secure them from the salt water .
In order to send the governor a fresh supply of cork acorns , in a growing state , I tried the following experiments on them to preserve them sound ; the effect of which I expect to have the honour to lay before this Society next summer : but as I tried the very same experiments , at the very same time , on a parcel of fresh oak acorns , which I collected myself at Sydenham in Kent , the latter end of last October , and have since kept them by me in a box in a warm room , it may give us some insight into what may be the fate of those that are sent abroad .
The experiments were made between the 25th and 30th of October 1758 ; and the acorns cut open to see the effects , Jan. 17 , 1759 .
Experiment 1 .
Acorns of the English oak smeared over several times with a strong solution of gum arabic ; and also they had been dried in a window , folded in a piece of paper , and put into a deal box .
When these were cut open , they appeared hard , dry , and inclining to black , being quite perished .
When I first thought of making this experiment , I imagined , that the perspirable matter of the kernel of the acorns could not pass through the glassy , close substance of the gum arabic ; but experience has convinced me of the contrary .
Exp. 2 .
Some acorns , treated as in the first experiment , were wrapped up in papers , soaked in a strong solution of gum arabic , each in a separate paper : after they had been dried , they were put in the box with the rest .
These were somewhat softer than the first , but decayed .
Exp. 3 .
Some of them were smeared several times over with gum senega ; and when they were dried in the window , and well hardened , were put in a paper into the deal box .
These looked rather better than the two former parcels ; but unfit for vegetation .
Exp. 4 .
Some of the same acorns were put into the middle of a cake of plaisterers stiff loam , or such as the brewers use to stop their beer barrels , and covered over near an inch on every side .
This soon became dry , without any cracks : it was about 21/ 2 inches thick ; and was placed with the rest , wrapped up in a paper , in the box .
The kernels of these were shrivelled up , and grown quite dry and hard , like horn , the loam proving a strong absorbent .
Exp. 5 .
Some were rolled up separately in thin flakes of bees-wax , warmed , to make it pliable , and put in paper in the box .
These looked very well when they were cut asunder , and appeared likely to grow ; but were a little shrunk .
Exp. 6 .
Some were rolled separately in rosin , made pliable with warmth .
These cut quite fresh .
Exp. 7 .
Some of them were rolled , each in a thin covering of a mixture of pitch , rosin , and bees-wax , called mummy by the gardiners .
These cut as well , and looked as fresh , as if they , had just fallen from the tree .
The cork acorns , that were sent to Georgia , were enclosed in the same substances with the foregoing , and put into a box filled with dry sand , quite full , and well fastened : this was put into a tight cask , among papers and wearing apparel , and stowed in the upper part of the hold of the ship .
While I was making these experiments , I wrote to Dr. Linnaeus , of Upsal , for his opinion of them , and for his method of preserving seeds in long voyages .
I have lately received his answer ; in which he considers the great danger that attends seeds in warm voyages , in the same light with governor Ellis , and has communicated to me a very probable method of preserving seeds in long voyages , which , he says , has never failed .
The following is an extract of his letter to me , dated the 8th of Dec. 1758 , from Upsal .
Seeds may be brought from abroad in a growing state , if we attend to the following method : ' ' Put your seeds into a cylindrical glass bottle , and fill up the interstices with dry sand , to prevent their lying too close together , and that they may perspire freely through the sand ; then cork the bottle , or the a bladder over the mouth of it .
Prepare a glass vessel , so much larger than that which contains the seeds , that , when it is suspended in it , there may be a vacant space on all sides of about two inches distance between both glasses , for the following mixture ; four parts of nitre , and onefifth part , of equal parts , of common salt , and sal ammoniac : these must be well pounded , and mixed together , and the spaces all round between the outward and inward glasses well filled with it .
' ' This saline mass , which should be rather moist , will always be so cold , that the seeds in the inner glass will never suffer , during their voyage , from the heat of the air .
This experiment has been tried , and has not failed .
' ' I am , my Lord , Your Lordship 's Most obedient , humble servant , John Ellis .
My Lord , IN a letter , which I took the liberty to address to your Lordship , dated Jan. 18 , 1759 , relating to some experiments , which I had made to preserve the acorns of English oaks for a longer time than usual , in a perfect state of vegetation , I there took notice , that I had sent some acorns of the cork oak to the governor of Georgia , preserved in much the same manner : but as the substances I made use of for this purpose differed a little , I shall describe those experiments here more particularly .
Read Dec. 20 , 1759 .
On the 27th of Nov. 1758 , I prepared seven parcels of the acorns of the cork-bearing oak or ilex , in the following manner : No 1 .
15 acorns , each covered over singly with a stiff solution of gum arabic , and afterwards rolled up in gum 'd paper .
No 2 .
13 Do .
each rolled up in a thin cover of common yellow bees-wax , softened before the fire , and rolled up afterwards , separately , in white paper .
No 3 .
10 Do .
each rolled up , as before , in wax , and afterwards each covered with a coat of brewers loam moistened with a thick solution of gum arabic .
No 4 .
5 Do .
each coated with gum arabic , and afterwards with whiting moistened with a thick solution of gum arabic .
No 5 .
25 Do .
each coated with gum arabic , and afterwards with brewers loam moistened with a thick solution of gum arabic .
No 6 .
3 Do .
each covered with gardeners grafting mummy , consisting of a mixture of beeswax , rosin , and pitch .
No 7 .
10 Do .
each covered with fullers earth made into a paste with a stiff solution of gum arabic .
These seven parcels were all put into chip boxes , filled with dry house-sand , and afterwards put into a tight cask ; and arrived in Georgia in April following .
Governor Ellis , in his letter to me , dated from thence May 6 , 1759 .
says , of all these experiments , none succeeded but the parcel No 3 .
which had first been covered with bees-wax , and afterwards with a paste made of loam and dissolved gum arabic .
We even find , that those that were covered with a thin coat of bees-wax , and afterwards with paper , did not succeed ; as their covering was not thick enough to keep in their perspiration .
This was the case with some of the English oak acorns , which I had coated in the same manner in October 1758 , and cut open in November last 1759 ; their kernels being shrivell 'd and decayed : and those I had covered the same time with a mixture of rosin , bees-wax , and pitch , tho ' their kernels were plump and juicy , yet they , by this time , were turned brown and rancid , by imbibing the steams arising from the pitch and rosin , and were rendered unfit for vegetation .
It may possibly be remarked , that it is no uncommon thing to receive the acorns of oaks from most of the provinces of North America in a growing state in January , and even in February ; and therefore it may be asked , why it should require more care to send acorns of our growth thither ?
The reason of this appears to me , that as the summer heats of those provinces by much exceed ours ; so consequently their juices being higher maturated , are not so liable to shrivel and decay as ours are ; which , experience shows , are more watery , and less oily : tho ' , perhaps , if both kinds were packed up in a dry , soapy earth , and could be carried at a cool season of the year , I mean the winter months , they might equally succeed ; but , in this kind of weather , we have seldom an opportunity to send them , so as to expect their arrival before the weather , in the southern parts of North America , begins to grow too warm , as the ships seldom arrive there till April .
The chesnut , next to the acorn , being the most difficult to preserve sound during the course of one season , or a whole year , on the 23d of February last , 1759 , I procured a parcel of Spanish chesnuts , just as they were imported , many of which were sounder than they generally are so late in the season : these I divided into four parcels , and put each parcel into a small earthen jar , involving them in the following substances : Jar No 1 .
12 Chesnuts in mutton suet .
2 .
12 Do .
in bees-wax and mutton suet , equal quantities .
3 .
12 Do .
in bees-wax .
4 .
12 Do .
in bees-wax and yellow rosin , equal quantities .
These substances I melted ; but did not pour them among the chesnuts , till I could bear my finger in them without the least sensible uneasiness , which I considered as the proper test not to affect the kernels by their heat , and immediately immersed the jar to the brim in cold water .
As this experiment was made with a view to give those gentlemen some hints , who go to the East Indies , I placed these jars in a room , where they were exposed to the unusual heats of last summer ; heat being the great promoter of the putrefactive fermentation of vegetables , and which it is very hard for such gentlemen to guard against , especially as they are obliged twice in their voyage home to pass the equinoctial line .
In order to examine the effects of these experiments , and to lay before the Society a fair account of them , I broke all the jars on the 22d of November last , before some ingenious gentlemen of the Society , very intelligent in these matters , and found , that jar No 1 .
which contained the chesnuts immersed in mutton suet , proved all rotten , attended with a very disagreeable putrid smell .
Those in jar No 2 .
were most of them sound and fresh , and their kernels as white and sweet-tasted , as when fresh gathered .
These were enclosed in half bees-wax , and half mutton suet , melted together .
Those in jar No 3 .
were equally sound and well-tasted , and had been enclosed in bees-wax only .
Though part of the chesnuts in these jars were rotten ; yet it appeared plainly to be owing to some defect in them when they were first immersed into these substances ; most probably to the lateness of the season , when the experiments were made .
Those in jar No 4 .
which were enclosed in half bees-wax and half yellow rosin , were all turned soft and spongy , of a brown colour , and a most disagreeable taste and smell , from the resinous steams they had imbibed .
On the 24th of November last , I planted six of the chesnuts preserved in wax and suet ( No 2 .
) and six of those preserved in wax only ( No 3 .
) in two garden pots , and placed them in a very spacious conservatory , belonging to my worthy friend Philip Carteret Webb , Esq ; F. R. S. at his seat near Godalmin in Surry ; where I have the pleasure to inform your Lordship and this honourable Society , that many of them are already germinating ; which proves this method of preserving the larger seeds a very proper one to recommend to gentlemen that go to China , and other parts of the East Indies , to preserve many kinds of valuable seeds in a state of vegetation during a voyage of a whole year , till they arrive here ; and probably till they are carried to our settlements in the American colonies .
It remains then , for gentlemen who go to the East Indies , to place the seeds they preserve in bees-wax , or bees-wax and suet , in the coolest part of the ship , to prevent these substances being affected with the heat of those parts , which far exceeds ours .
Perhaps Dr. Linnaeus 's method of enclosing them in a larger vessel , and surrounding them with a mixture of salts , described in my former letter , will answer this end .
He speaks with so much certainty of its success , that I think it worth the trial , especially when he assures us it never fails .
I am , my Lord , Your Lordship 's most obedient humble servant , John Ellis .
London , Dec. 13 .
1759 .
P. S. Small seeds , in their pods , may be preserved by being placed thinly on pieces of paper , cotton or linen cloth , that have been dipped in wax , then rolled up tight , and well secured from air by a further covering of wax .

