XXII .
A remarkable Case of an Empyema .
By Mr. Joseph Warner , F. R. S. and Surgeon to Guy 's Hospital .
MORRIS EVANS , aged 30 years , on the 13th of March , 1759 , was admitted into Guy 's hospital , with a remarkable complaint in his chest , which attacked him in the month of August 1758 , with the symptoms of a pleurisy .
Upon Read June 28 , Upon inspection it appeared , that the left side of the thorax was greatly enlarged , and prodigiously distended : the pectoral muscle was somewhat raised up ; on pressure it felt soft , and readily gave way : upon a removal of the pressure , the integuments resumed their former appearance , no marks of impression remaining on this , or any other part of the thorax , so as to constitute the characteristic of an aedematous swelling .
The spaces betwixt the 9th and 10th , and betwixt the 10th and 11th ribs , counting from above , were visibly enlarged , and somewhat elevated : they felt soft , and yielded to the fingers ; but were not at all inflamed , or otherwise discoloured .
Upon examination , I discovered a fluctuation in both these parts .
The general symptoms that attended this case were similar to those arising from all considerable collections of fluids deposited in either cavities of the thorax : for instance , the patient had a continual flow fever ; a short cough , but without the least expectoration of matter ; a great difficulty in respiration , particularly in the acts of expiration .
He was incapable of lying down on the right side , without very great uneasiness ; he was much emaciated ; and his countenance was uniformly sallow : he did not complain of so much pain , or so great a difficulty in breathing , when in an erect posture , as I have sometimes observed in diseases of this kind even where the quantity of extravasated fluid has been much less ; but at the same time I must acknowledge , that no fair inference could be deduced from hence , because of the peculiar position the diseased side was put in when the poor man sat down , or stood up ; either of which he was incapable of doing without being supported .
The left side of the thorax inclined forwards , and protuberated in a peculiar manner , so as to give the head and trunk an horizontal posture ; in which position of the body , the weight of the contained fluid most certainly was , in part , prevented from pressing so forcibly upon the left portion of the diaphragm , the mediastinum , and the right portion of the lungs , as it must necessarily have done in a more erect position of the body .
He had one symptom , which I had never before observed in patients labouring under this complaint ; that is , he was incapable of lying on his back , without bringing on very alarming threats of suffocation ; but he did not remember ever to have heard any noise or rattling of the pus upon motion .
He could lie most conveniently on his left side ; but even that posture was of late become very painful to him .
In short , he could find no tolerable posture to put his body into , but that of inclining it considerably forwards , which ( I have already observed ) he was under a necessity of doing , to enable him to draw his breath ; and I dare venture to say , that , upon attending to the subsequent part of the history of this poor mortal 's case , the reason , why such effects should be produced from such a cause , will very readily occur to those , who have a moderate degree of knowledge of the formation and uses of these parts of the human body .
Upon making an incision upon the most prominent part of the space betwixt the 10th and 11th rib , in the cavity of the thorax of the left side , at least eight Winchester quarts of a thin yellow matter , not at all faetid , was discharged upon the spot in a full stream : the matter issued thro ' the wound by leaps , and was projected at the distance of two yards and upwards from the patient 's body : he did not faint during the operation , nor afterwards ; but from that moment he grew easy ; his symptoms abated ; he slept well at night ; and the next day he had no bad symptoms , except that his difficulty in breathing was not quite removed .
This , indeed , could not reasonably be expected , considering the long disuse and extension which the diaphragm , the intercostal muscles , and the rest of the muscles of respiration , had undergone from the pressure and weight of the confined matter , joined to the injury which the lungs themselves had sustained .
He continued with very little alteration till the fourth day , when his respiration became worse , accompanied with bad nights , a quick pulse , a great discharge of foetid matter from the wound , and a flushing in his face .
These symptoms remained till the 9th .
To-day his breathing was better , his pulse became more calm , the flushings in his face disappeared ; but the discharge was considerable in quantity , and he complained of a want of appetite , which , till now , had been tolerably good ever since the operation .
On the tenth day , his difficulty of breathing returned ; the discharge was very great , and offensive ; he had very little sleep last night : in short , he seems greatly upon the decline .
11th , 12th , and 13th , he continued much as on the 10th .
14th and 15th days he has had more sleep than usual ; his appetite very bad ; cough frequent , and troublesome ; discharge very thin , and considerable in quantity .
Upon exerting his powers in the act of expiration , to discharge the matter from the cavity , there appeared an eminence betwixt the 7th and 8th ribs ( counting from above ) on the anterior lateral part of the thorax , which was very tender ; but , upon his ceasing to exert himself , the swelling disappeared .
16th and 17th days , his cough very troublesome ; the discharge from the wound was great ; the matter very thin , and faetid ; he gets very little sleep ; his pulse quick , and low ; his tongue dry , and parched : in short , to all appearance , he seemed to have a very short time to live .
But , notwithstanding these threatening symptoms , he very unexpectedly survived till the 10th of June following ( exactly 12 weeks from the time of his undergoing the first operation ) .
In the middle of the month of April next preceding his death , he thought himself much better than he had been for many days before : his discharge at this time was much lessened ; but his pulse was very weak , and fluttering .
About three weeks before the patient 's death , a second opening was made by incision betwixt the 11th and 12th ribs by my colleague Mr. Way , under whose immediate care this poor man was from the day of his admission into the hospital , and who treated him with the greatest humanity and judgment .
Three days before the patient 's decease , the swelling betwixt the 7th and 8th ribs burst of itself , and discharged at least a pint of matter , that was exceedingly offensive .
Upon opening the body , the following particulars were discovered : the right portion of the lungs was greatly ulcerated on its superior part , where it adhered firmly to the pleura : on the inferior part of the cavity , the lungs adhered to the diaphragm ; the lobes of the lungs on this side were not so much wasted as I expected they would have been , from the great degree of pressure which they had so long sustained from the prodigious quantity of matter , that was confined in the opposite cavity of the thorax ; nor was there any extravasation in the right cavity of the thorax .
The lobes of the lungs on the left side were almost entirely destroyed : in this cavity there was near a quart of faetid matter ; the whole of its internal surface was ulcerated , and the two inferior ribs were carious in the neighbourhood of the second opening .
In every other part the ribs were sound ; so was the sternum .
The pericardium and heart appeared in their natural state .
The injury done to the internal surface of the left cavity of the thorax was so great , as to have destroyed almost the whole of the intercostal muscles on that side of the trunk .
N. B. It may be worth remarking , that this patient did not any time suffer the least inconvenience from the pressure of the external air , which entered into the cavity of the thorax thro ' the incisions , as has been said by authors to have happened in a great degree in the like cases ; but as that effect was not produced in this , or any other instances of the like kind , which has come under my inspection , I am inclined to conjecture , that the bad effects of the pressure of the external air , when admitted thro ' an opening made into the cavity of the thorax , is such an inconvenience as may rather be supposed to be likely to happen , than has been really known to happen often ; the act of breathing having never been in in the least suspended , altho ' the openings made into the cavity have been very large , and the time taken for dressing the patient ( sometimes once , sometimes twice a day ) has been very considerable ; but , on the contrary , at every dressing , I have observed , that the patient has breathed with greater freedom and ease than he could do before the performance of this operation , or even for some hours before the dressings were renewed .
As the matter in this disease lies loosely in the cavity of the thorax , there is no greater danger of wounding the lungs in this operation , than there is of wounding the intestines or omentum , in tapping the abdomen in the ascites ; and if the method be pursued , which I have recommended for making the incision thro ' the intercostal muscles , there will be no danger of wounding the intercostal artery , which is a circumstance much dreaded by some practitioners , but with no great reason .
However , was this to happen , it would probably not be attended with any bad consequences , as the bleeding might very readily be stopped by pressure , or otherwise .
Jos .
Warner .
Hatton Garden , June 28 , 1759 .

