Experiments concerning the Encaustic Painting of the Ancients .
In a Letter to the Right Honourable George Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society , from Mr. Josiah Colebrooke , F. R. S. My Lord , THE result of experiments ( whatever the success attending them may be ) , in philosophical or mechanical inquiries , is not below the attention of the Royal Society .
The Read Mar. 1 .
The art of painting with burnt wax , ( as it is called ) hath long been lost to the world ; the use of it to painters , in the infancy of the art of painting , was of the utmost consequence , drying oil being unknown , they had nothing to preserve their colours entire from the injury of damps , and the heat of the sun ; a varnish of some sort was therefore necessary ; but they being unacquainted with distilled spirits , could not , as we now do , dissolve gums to make a transparent coat for their pictures ; this invention therefore of burnt wax supplied that defect to them , and with this manner of painting , the chambers and other rooms in their houses were furnished ; this Pliny calls encaustum , and we encaustick painting .
The following experiments which I have the honour to lay before your Lordship and the Society , were occasioned by the extract of a letter from the Abbe Mazeas , translated by Dr. Parsons , and published in the second part of the 49th volume of the Philosophical Transactions , No 100 , concerning the ancient method of painting with burnt wax , revived by Count Caylus .
The Count 's method was , First , To rub the cloth or board designed for the picture simply over with bees-wax .
Secondly , To lay on the colours mixed with common water ; but as the colours will not adhere to the wax , the whole picture was first rubbed over with * Spanish chalk , and then the colours are used .
VO L. LI .
G Thirdly , * Spanish chalk is called by Dr. Parsons , in a note , Spanish white ; this is a better kind of whitening than the common , and was the Thirdly , When the picture is dry , it is put near the fire , whereby the wax melts , and absorbs all the colours .
EXPERIMENT I. A piece of oak board was rubbed over with beeswax , first against the grain of the wood , and then with the grain , to fill up all the pores that remained after it had been planed , and afterwards was rubbed over with as much dry Spanish white , as could be made to stick on it ; this , on being painted ( the colours mixed with water only ) , so clogged the pencil , and mixed so unequally with the ground , that it was impossible to make even an outline , but what was so much thicker in one part than another , that it would not bear so much as the name of painting ; neither had it any appearance of a picture : However , to pursue the experiment , this was put at a distance from the fire , on the hearth , and the wax melted by slow degrees ; but the Spanish white ( tho ' laid as smooth as so soft a body would admit , before the colour was laid on ) yet on melting the wax into it , was not sufficient to hide the grain of the wood , nor show the colours by a proper whiteness of the ground , the wax in rubbing on the board , was unavoidably only white that had the name of Spanish annexed to it , that I could procure , tho ' I enquired for it at most if not all the colour shops in town .
My friend Mr. Dacosta showed me a piece of Spanish chalk in his collection , which seemed more like a cimolia ( tobacco pipe clay ) , and was the reason of my using that in one of the experiments .
thicker thicker in some parts than other , and the Spanish white the same : on this I suspected there must be some mistake in the Spanish white and made the enquiry mentioned in the note * page .
41 .
To obviate the inequality of the ground in the first experiment ; EXPERIMENT II .
A piece of old wainscoat ( oak board ) 1/ 4 of an inch thick , which having been part of an old drawer , was not likely to shrink on being brought near the fire ; this was smoothed with a fish-skin , made quite warm before the fire , and then with a brush dipped in white wax , melted in an earthen pipkin smeared all over , and applied to the fire again , that the wax might be equally thick on all parts of the board , a ground was laid ( on the waxed board ) with levigated chalk mixed with gum water ( viz. Gum Arabic dissolved in water ) : When it was dry , I painted it with a kind of landskip , and pursuing the method laid down by Count Caylus , brought it gradually to the fire ; I fixed the picture on a fire screen which would preserve the heat , and communicate it to the back part of the board , this was placed first at the distance of three feet from the fire , and brought forward by slow degrees till it came within one foot of the fire , which made the wax swell and bloat up the picture ; but as the chalk did not absorb the wax , the picture fell from the board and left it quite bare .
EXPERIMENT III .
I mixed three parts white wax , and one part white resin , hoping the tenacity of the resin might preserve the picture .
This was laid on a board heated , with a brush , as in the former ; and the ground was chalk , prepared as before .
This was placed horizontally on an ironing box , charged with an hot heater , shifting it from time to time , that the wax and resin might penetrate the chalk ; and hoping from this position , that the ground , bloated by melting the wax , would subside into its proper place : but this , like the other , came from the board , and would not at all adhere .
EXPERIMENT IV .
Prepared chalk four drams , white wax , white resin , of each a dram , burnt alabaster half a dram , were all powdered together and sifted , mixed with spirit of molosses instead of water , and put for a ground on a board smeared with wax and resin , as in Exp. 3 .
This was also placed horizontally on a box-iron , as the former : the picture blistered , and was cracked all over ; and tho ' removed from the box-iron to an oven moderately heated ( in the same horizontal position ) , it would not subside , nor become smooth .
When it was cold , I took an iron spatula made warm , and moved it gently over the surface of the picture , as if I were to spread a plaister .
( This thought occurred , from the board being prepared with wax and resin , and the ground having the same materials in its composition , the force of the spatula might make them unite .
) This succeeded so well , as to reduce the surface to a tolerable degree of smoothness : but as the ground was broke off in many places , I repaired it with flake white , mixed up with the yolk of an egg and milk , and repainted it with molosses spirit ( instead of water ) ; and then put it into an oven with a moderate degree of heat .
In this I found the colours fixed , but darker than when it was first painted ; and it would bear being washed with water , not rubbed with a wet cloth .
EXPERIMENT V. A board ( that had been used in a former experiment ) was smeared with wax and resin , of each equal parts ; was wetted with molosses spirit , to make whitening ( or Spanish white ) mixed with gum-water adhere .
This , when dry , was scraped with a knife , to make it equally thick in all places .
It was put into a warm oven , to make the varnish incorporate partly with the whitening before it was painted ; and it had only a small degree of heat : water only was used to mix the colours .
This was again put into an oven with a greater degree of heat ; but it flaked off from the board : whether it might be owing to the board 's having had a second coat of varnish ( the first having been scraped and melted off ) , and that the unctuous parts of the wax had so entered its pores , that it would not retain a second varnish , I cannot tell .
EXPERIMENT VI .
Having miscarried in these trials , I took a new board , planed smooth , but not polished , either with a fish-skin or rushes : I warmed it , and smeared it with wax only ; then took cimolia ( tobacco-pipe clay ) divested of its sand , by being dissolved in water and poured off , leaving the coarse heavy parts behind .
After this was dried and powdered , I mixed it with a small quantity of the yolk of an egg and cow 's milk , and made a ground with this on the waxed board : this I was induced to try , by knowing that the yolk of an egg will dissolve almost all unctuous substances , and make them incorporate with water ; and I apprehended , that a ground , thus prepared , would adhere so much the more firmly to the board than the former had done , as to prevent its flaking off .
The milk , I thought , might answer two purposes ; first , uniting the ground with the wax ; and secondly , by answering the end of size , or gum-water , and prevent the colours sinking too deep into the ground , or running one into another .
When the ground was near dry , I smoothed it with a pallat-knife , and washed with milk and egg where I had occasion to make it smooth and even : when dry I painted it , mixing the colours with common water ; this , on being placed horizontally in an oven , only warm enough to melt the wax , flaked from the board ; but held so much better together than any of the former , that I pasted part of it on paper .
EXPERIMENT VII .
* Flake white mixed with egg and milk , crumbled all to pieces in the oven , put on the waxed board , as in the last experiment .
The bad success which had attended all the former experiments , led me to consider of what use the wax was in this kind of painting : and it occurred to me , that it was only as a varnish to preserve the colours from fading .
In order to try this , EXPERIMENT VIII .
I took what the bricklayers call fine stuff , or putty ~ ; to this I added a small quantity of burnt alabaster , to make it dry : this it soon did in the open air ; but before I put on any colours , I dried it gently by the fire , lest the colours should run .
When it was painted , I warmed it gradually by the fire ( to prevent the ground from cracking ) , till it was very hot .
I then took white wax three parts , white resin one part , melted them in an earthen pipkin , and with a brush spread them all over the painted board , and kept it close to the fire in a perpendicular situation , that what wax and resin the plaister would not absorb might drop off .
When it was cold , I found the colours were not altered , either from the * Flake white is the purest sort of white lead .
~ Putty is lime slacked , and , while warm , dissolved in water , and strained through a sieve .
heat of the fire , or passing the brush over them .
I then rubbed it with a soft linen cloth , and thereby procured a kind of gloss , which I afterwards increased by rubbing it with an hard brush ; which was so far from scratching or leaving any marks on the picture , that it became more smooth and polished by it .
After I had made all the foregoing experiments , in conversation with my honoured and learned friend Dr. Kidby , a fellow of this Society , I said I had been trying to find out what the encaustic painting of the ancients was .
Upon which , he told me , that there was a passage in Vitruvius de architectura relative to that kind of painting ; and was so good as to transcribe it for me from the 7th book , chap .
9 .
De minii temperatura .
Vitruvius 's words are ; At si quis subtilior fuerit , &amp; voluerit expolitionem miniaceam suum colorem retinere , cum paris expolitus &amp; aridus fuerit , tunc ceram punicam liquefactam igni , paulo oleo temperatam , seta inducat , deinde postea carbonibus in ferreo vase compositis , eam ceram apprime cum pariete , calefaciendo sudare cogat , fiatque ut peraequetur , deinde cum candela linteisque puris subigat , uti signa marmorea nuda curantur .
Haec autem ~ greece dicitur .
Ita obstans cerae punicae lorica non patitur , nec lunae splendorem , nec solis radios lambendo eripere ex his politionibus colorem .
Which I thus translate : ` ` But if any one is more wary , and would have the polishing [ painting ] with vermilion hold its colour , when the wall is painted and dry , let him take Carthaginian [ Barbary ] wax , melted with a little oil , and rub it on the wall with an hair pencil ; and afterwards let him put live coals into an iron vessel ( chasing-dish ) , and hold it close to the wax , when the wall , by being heated , begins to sweat ; then let it be made smooth : afterwards let him rub it with a* candle and ~ clean linen rags , in the same manner as they do the naked marble statues .
This the Greeks call ~ .
The coat of Carthaginian wax ( thus put on ) is so strong , that it neither suffers the moon by night , nor the sun-beams by day , to destroy the colour .
' ' Being satisfied , from this passage in Vitruvius , that the manner of using wax in Exp. 8 .
was right , I was now to find if the wax-varnish , thus burnt into the picture , would bear washing : but here I was a little disappointed ; for rubbing one corner with a wet linen cloth , some of the colour came off ; but washing with a soft hair pencil dipped in water , and letting it dry without wiping , the colours stood very well .
A board painted , as in Exp. 8 , was hung in the most smoaky part of a chimney for a day , and ex* This account of the method of polishing [ painting ] walls coloured with vermilion , gave me great satisfaction , as it proved the method I had taken in experiment 8 .
( which I had tried before I saw or knew of this passage in Vitruvius ) was right .
The use of the candle , as I apprehend , was to melt the wax on the walls , where by accident the brush had put on too much , or afford wax where the brush had not put on enough , or had left any part bare .
~ The rubbing the wall with a linen cloth , while warm , will do very well , where there is only one colour to be preserved ; but where there are many , as in a landschape , it will be apt to take off some , or render the colouring rather faint ; which I found by wiping the wax off from a painting while it was hot .
posed to the open air in a very foggy night .
In the morning the board was seemingly wet through , and the water ran off the picture .
This was suffered to dry without wiping ; and the picture had not suffered at all from the smoke or the dew , either in the ground or the colours : but when dry , by rubbing it , first with a soft cloth , and afterwards with a brush , it recovered its former gloss .
Suspecting that some tallow might have been mixed with the white wax I had used , which might cause the colours to come off on being rubbed with a wet cloth , I took yellow wax which had been melted from the honeycomb in a private family , and consequently not at all adulterated ; to three parts of this I added one part resin , and melted them together .
EXPERIMENT IX .
Spanish white , mixed with fish glew , was put for a ground on a board , and painted with water colours only .
The board was made warm ; and then the wax and resin were put on with a brush , and kept close to the fire till the picture had imbibed all the varnish , and looked dry .
When it was cold , I rubbed it first with a linen cloth , and then polished it with an hard brush .
In these experiments I found great difficulties with regard to colours ; many water colours being made from the juices of plants , have some degree of an acid in them ; and these , when painted on an alkaline ground , as chalk , whitening , cimolia , and plaister , are , totally changed their colours , and from green became brown ; which contributed much to make the experiments tedious .
I would therefore advise the use of mineral or metallic colours for this sort of painting , as most likely to preserve their colour : for although I neutralized Spanish white , by fermenting it with vinegar , and afterwards washed it very well with water , it did not succeed to my wish .
These experiments , and this passage from Vitruvius , will in some measure explain the obscurity of part of that passage in Pliny which Dr. Parsons , in his learned comment on the encaustic painting with wax , seems to despair of .
Ceris pingere was one species of encaustic painting .
~ , inustum , may be translated , forced in by the means of fire , burnt in : for whatever is forced in by the help of fire can be rendered into Latin by no other significant word , that I know of , but inustum .
If this is allowed me , and I think I have the authority of Vitruvius ( a writer in the Augustan age ) for it , who seems to have wrote from his own knowlege , and not like Pliny , who copied from others much more than he knew himself , the difficulty with regard to this kind of painting is solved , and the encaustic with burnt wax recovered to the public .
What he means by the next kind he mentions , in ebore cestro id est viriculo , I will not attempt to explain at present .
The ship painting is more easily accounted for : the practice being , in part , continued to this time ; and is what is corruptly called breaming , for brenning or burning .
This is done by reeds set on fire , and held under the side of a ship till it is quite hot ; then resin , tallow , tar , and brimstone , melted together , and put on with an hair brush while the planks remain hot , make such a kind of paint as Pliny describes ; which , he says , nec sole , nec sale , ventisque corrumpitur , as they were ignorant of the use of oil painting , they mixed that colour with the wax , &amp;c. which they intended for each particular part of the ship , and put it on in the manner above described .
In the pictures painted for these experiments , and now laid before your Lordship and the Society , I hope neither the design of the landschape , nor the execution of it , will be so much taken into consideration as the varnish ( which was the thing wanted in this inquiry ) : and I think that will evince , that the encaustic painting with burnt wax is fully restored by these experiments ; and though not a new invention , yet having been lost for so many ages , and now applied further , and to other purposes than it was by Vitruvius ( who consined it to vermilion only ) , may almost amount to a new discovery , the use of it may be a means of preserving many curious drawings to * posterity : for this kind of painting may be on paper , cloth , or any other substance that will admit a ground to be laid on it .
The process is very simple , and is not attended with the disagreeable smell unavoidable in oil painting , nor with some inconveniences inseparable from that art ; and as there is no substance we know , more durable than wax , it hath the greatest probability of being lasting .
*A bird painted by Mr. Edwards on paper , and the colours fixed by burned wax , was shown to the Society , April 5th .
I ask pardon of your Lordship and the Society for taking up so much time as this paper hath required : but if it meets with your Lordship 's and the Society 's approbation , I may , in some future paper ( when the necessary avocations of my profession will allow me leisure ) , lay before you some experiments , relating to colours which are not likely to change by being painted on any kind of ground .
As your Lordship 's recommendation contributed much to make me a member of this learned body , I must beg your patronage of this communication ; and am , with the greatest respect , Your Lordship 's and the Society 's Most obedient humble Servant , Budge-row , Josiah Colebrooke .

